As a Taiwanese who lives in Canada, my ID number cannot give away my gender, ethnic background, citizenship status (not to my knowledge). I agree with you that the Taiwanese government has to do more to make our friends feeling welcomed. But I also ask for your patience, since Taiwan was still a policing state really not that long ago. Please give her a bit more time. Cheers 🍻
I'm a Taiwanese in the Netherlands for 20 years, but still I hold only my Taiwanese passport. Even though applying for a Dutch citizenship doesn't really require me to give up my Taiwanese passport (because they officially do not see Taiwan as a country, so Taiwanese passport is only a "travel document," not a passport.) but I am happy with my Taiwanese passport.
My fiancé, as an Italian, and myself a Taiwanese, we’ve been living in Australia more than 6 years, my fiancé is trying to apply for the citizenship now, because of COVID, the process of all the documents seems going really fast than usual. As myself, I’m hesitating to do it or not, only because I feel even if I have OZ passport, the life, the environment will never be like in Taiwan, and if someday I’m gonna do it, that will be only for the future if we are having kids someday. Or maybe someday I need to go to Italy with my fiancé or anywhere in Europe, Australia passport might be stronger than Taiwanese passport, since many European countries don’t count taiwan as a country, cuz I had that experience when I was flying in and out from UK 😅 also the crew from Italy even need to double check if my Taiwan passport is under China or not. But then I told them the different, luckily I got let go. 🙄
@@28907008 Tawinese can take advantages of duel citizenship from other nation and foreigners can't with Taiwan. So the people who can take advantage of the duel nationality system is Taiwanese people and not foreigners
@@28907008 This doesn't make the countries to lax. It make the country more open! Having duel nationality hasn't been proving to be more a security risk then permanent residency. Western country have other laws in place for foreigner from stealing information. Taiwan can still denial duel citizenship from country's that treating Taiwan independence, and still be open to trusted countriess. But you know what Japan , South Korea , taiwan and china have all in common??? They are homogenous countries in the world. Western country have benefited from having different culture mix in
I’m a citizen of earth so I feel okay about it. It would be more of a novelty for me to have Taiwanese ID. I feel connected to Taiwan regardless. I’m treated so lovely by the locals I really can’t complain. Interesting episode.
I’m a Hong Kong PRC holder after living there for 7 years when I was growing up. While I’m a UK national, in my heart I have a much deeper connection with HK than I do to the UK. It’s certainly a conflicting feeling, my daughter was born in the UK but I was brought up in HK and even got married there. The concept of belonging when you’re technically a foreigner in one country but feel like a foreigner in your native country is a complex issue...
I understand your disappointment, however I don't think a person's sense of belonging should be reduced to or dependent on the ID numbers. It's not only about if you have done enough for or how much you love Taiwan, but the technical and highly politically sensitive reasons due to the complicated situation of Taiwan and its relations to China. Please don't let the numbers consume your passion for Taiwan.
FYI - All government affairs will now take 3x as long for you the first time since they all will be confused since their records now will identify you as a "Taiwanese" and everyone will be confused. They will also spend 15 min trying to re-enter your new APRC number without finding any records of you at all before they flip your card and see your old number on the back. #TrueStory
Banks ? That’s why I make two trips indoors every year.. no more than that or I’d lose it mentally.Not changing mine until I have to update my passport.
For Taiwanese household registration(registering a Taiwanese household then a Taiwanese ID card and a Household Certificate are issued), Taiwanese babies born overseas will get an ID with a second number 7, Mainland China people married to Taiwan will get an ID with a second number 9, and naturalized foreigners will get an ID with a second number using 0~6. Different ID number formats designed to distinguish different groups of people are very practical for many aspects instead of merely making feelings of isolation or separation. For example, the police officer could more easily investigate crimes according to concerned people's backgrounds, and administrative authorities could easily provide promotive or welfare measures for naturalized foreigners.
LOVE FROM INDIAN🇮🇳 IN TAIWAN🇹🇼 但我認為台灣正在緩解外國人的移民。 例如，政府正在考慮將工作簽證的永久居留權從5年延長至3年，而將高等專業的畢業生（碩士和博士學位）的永久居留權定為1-2年，這是非常受歡迎的。 好話題艾倫和一如既往的好工作。 but I think Taiwan is easing the immigration for foreigners. For example, the government is thinking to make the permanent residency from 5 years to 3 years for working visa and so on 1-2 years for the graduates of higher studies(Master and Ph.D) which is really welcoming. Good topic Allen and good job as always.
If you go to UK, Europe ,Japan and any any other countries will not give me a residency even I was there studies or work, so why Taiwan shall be easier to non residents? We don’t want anyone came to Taiwan for the national healthcare ,please think yourself what can you help or contribute to Taiwan first.
Taiwanese in Australia here. I have dual citizenship, hold both countries passports. I can use either when travelling (although I generally use the Aussie one when travelling with my partner so we get the same treatment at the airports and doesn't have to split up. ) I came here on skill migration grounds, the rule back then was first a 6mths bridging visa to transition from my student visa, then following a permanent resident visa on skilled worker grounds, living here for 2(?or maybe it was 3) years in 5 years before I can have citizenship. There is now a citizenship test, whist back then I just need to swore in and recite the rights and responsibilities of being a Australian citizen. During this process I was not required to denounce my Taiwanese citizenship... Probably because Australia doesn't mind duo nationals (unless you are a MP in the upper house I think).
I think the rule is actually that taiwanese can become dual nationals, but foreigners coming into Taiwan need to have an exceptional contribution or something to Taiwan before being allowed dual citizenship.
I am a Taiwanese living in Spain, all the tax or social health insurance paid are much higher than Spanish people. Now I live here at the fifth year, once I live 10 years, I can get a permanent residence card or apply for Spanish passport. For Spanish passport, I don't need to give up my Taiwan passport but need to pass Spanish history and culture tests in A2 degree which for me is a way to go because I mainly speak English in life to Spanish people who are passionate as Taiwanese.
I ended up using a random ID number generator on the internet so I could make a booking at the local karaoke place. So many things were made difficult as a result of the two letters in the ID number!! Glad they've done something about it though.
I’ve been living in the UK on and off (was away for 1.5 years) for about 11 years, have had switched visa categories a few times due to unforeseen circumstances. As a result I am STILL ‘doing my times’ to be eligible to apply for ILR and ultimately the passport which really bugs me as the government only recognises the amount of years under a single category not the total length of time one spends here 🤷♀️
Hey Allan. My girlfriend is taiwanese and we live in here in Belgium. In order for her to be eligible for the belgian nationality she needs to work and live for 5 years in the country without interruption. She also has to have a proof that she masters one of the two officials languages here in Belgium (Dutch and French). After all that, she can apply for citizenship and an unlimited stay. She can have both Taiwanese and Belgian nationalities. She doesn't have to abandon her taiwanese one.
8:20 My 2nd resulted in periods of mild drowsiness on the following two days. Nothing more. Was bracing for an ordeal as my 1st really kicked my butt for the 1st two days following and wasn't myself for the rest of the week. As with the 1st dose Hong Kong's vaccination process was highly efficient. Was in and out inside 45 minutes. Highly recommend people get the vaccine. The quicker we get to 70%+ vaccinated the sooner life can get back to some sort of normal. Interesting observation: at both of my jab sessions < 50% in attendance were locals.
I am a Taiwanese who was born in Taichung and lived, worked, married, and had children in the Philippines for ten years. In the Philippines, I cannot even get a general foreign spouse visa because of the Philippines’ one-China policy. Regarding these matters, I can only say that each country has its own reasons for enacting laws. Although I feel that I am also half Filipino, this country does not recognize my identity due to political factors, and there is nothing I can do.
Congratulations to get new ID number! I understand the sense of loss, it's a nice question to think. Thank you to introduce the information about the change of your ID number.
I was born and raised in Taiwan and also has a USA passport. Half of my life spent in Taiwan and half in USA. I don’t really care what number I was given on my USA passport and I feel I am completely a US citizen with my love of both Taiwan and US. I hope that helps make you feel better?! I think you will find a deeper root in Taiwan if you get married and have kids in Taiwan. Trust me that will work.. lol
When China is at war with Taiwan, a UK passport would definitely come in handy. It all boils down to a question: Would you stay in Taiwan with the rest of Taiwanese people who don’t have a foreign passport to run to another country, or would you be on the evacuation plane on your way back to the UK?
I'm not Taiwanese. I'm a Westerner. The term "foreigner," unless you relinquish your British citizenship, is objectively correct for identification purposes. Plus, single citizenship is the case in many, many countries. Taiwan particularly, given its unique diplomatic situation, would not benefit from dual loyalties. Not sure what the problem is. I know you're PC and consider yourself "a citizen of the world," but it's not about how you feel. It's about what is objectively true. This is an ID card, not a greeting card. It's to identify and register you... not give you the warm and fuzzies.
Tell me why i grabbed my ARC card to check out the numbers haha. I came September 2020 & have the 2 letter ID system. Maybe I should head to immigration ~
Totally agree. U like Taiwan so much, and even though you spent your entire life in Taiwan, probably still can not get citizenship. National ID No is very important when living in Taiwan, whether using any app or making an appointment, you would be inconvenient without it. Thanks so much, you make such great videos
About the immigration policy and law, Taiwan still has long way to go. Taiwan used to be a very conservative country about immigration until recently. Most important laws were changed just in the passed 10 years.
I am a Taiwanese living in USA and we are the working visa now, we've been here for nine years, studying, finding job, right now is applying for green card, ones you get the green card, you need to live here for five year and you can go citizen test, so....it can be faster if you marry an American, and depends where're you from, some countries are lot more easier to apply, some countries need to wait a long time...but for Taiwanese, we can have both citizenships at the same, that's the benefit for us! So...I know the feeling to be a alien, but will become lot more better, God bless you!! 平安喜樂喔！祝福你～～
Very informative video Allan.. and yes, I understand the difficulties faced by ARC and APRC holders here, especially the latter as although the name suggests "permanent", all holders of APRC's do not enjoy the same benefits given to Taiwanese ID holders. I held an APRC for more than 6 years before I decided to become a Citizen here, main reason was because I have settled down here and have a family and I love this country, which is my home away from home.
Tell your government to recognize Taiwan as a country first. After that, when Taiwanese people apply for the UK citizenship, your government will ask them to give up Taiwanese citizenship, too. Your government doesn’t recognize Taiwan as a country, so Taiwanese people don’t have a “citizenship” to give up. On the other hand, we think we are a country, so when you want to become a Taiwanese citizen, you should give up your original citizenship. Get your loyalty right.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Who has citizenship in a foreign country?
As a Taiwanese who lives in Canada, my ID number cannot give away my gender, ethnic background, citizenship status (not to my knowledge). I agree with you that the Taiwanese government has to do more to make our friends feeling welcomed. But I also ask for your patience, since Taiwan was still a policing state really not that long ago. Please give her a bit more time. Cheers 🍻
台灣如果要增加人口 減輕生育率的壓力 確實應該做到更讓移民有歸屬感
I'm a Taiwanese in the Netherlands for 20 years, but still I hold only my Taiwanese passport. Even though applying for a Dutch citizenship doesn't really require me to give up my Taiwanese passport (because they officially do not see Taiwan as a country, so Taiwanese passport is only a "travel document," not a passport.) but I am happy with my Taiwanese passport.
@@MrKurt76958 送錢生第二個. 加錢生第三個. 免奶粉生第四個
My fiancé, as an Italian, and myself a Taiwanese, we’ve been living in Australia more than 6 years, my fiancé is trying to apply for the citizenship now, because of COVID, the process of all the documents seems going really fast than usual. As myself, I’m hesitating to do it or not, only because I feel even if I have OZ passport, the life, the environment will never be like in Taiwan, and if someday I’m gonna do it, that will be only for the future if we are having kids someday. Or maybe someday I need to go to Italy with my fiancé or anywhere in Europe, Australia passport might be stronger than Taiwanese passport, since many European countries don’t count taiwan as a country, cuz I had that experience when I was flying in and out from UK 😅 also the crew from Italy even need to double check if my Taiwan passport is under China or not. But then I told them the different, luckily I got let go. 🙄
台灣超過半個世紀面臨中共強大的威脅，如果台灣的公民權(投票權)像很多國家一樣寬鬆，則中共可以透過其他國家的身分再取得台灣的公民權(投票權)，防止中共的滲透，就是取得台灣國籍比較嚴格的原因之一。
你選擇『貼近』台灣，但瑞莎選擇『成為』台灣人，所以你沒有公民權，瑞莎有公民權(台灣身分證)，有一位林明道先生，放棄美國籍，取得台灣身分證還在台灣當兵，差別就在這裡。
當台灣面臨戰爭，台灣的男生是要上戰場的，你連英國的國籍都不想放棄，我們怎麼相信到時你會放棄生命保衛台灣?
當然我也不想死，不過概念上就是這樣，連100元都不捐，你怎麼相信他會捐10萬元，100萬元?
大陆沦陷区灾胞这么想来台湾，哪怕是不能入籍只要有永久居留权也好啊，
@@philiptuam9963 但淪陷區會有帶著目的來居留的人，不可不防…..
@@ViVianChang-ip4tf 可以学韩国接待北朝鲜难民那样啊，先集中隔离起来，慢慢审查啊，
“
他學習到一部分台灣人的習慣，有哭有糖吃
艾倫, 您好!
您與台灣的連結, 並不是從法律及規範中的"8"所代表!
而是與台灣人民的心連結在一起, 那你就是真正的台灣人了!
因為這是兩種不同層面的事!
日本也是一樣的、要拿日本護照必須先放棄本國國籍、這與你愛不愛這個國家是兩回事分（當然也不是這個國家不愛你）
是根據很多方面來的結果吧！
對...有很多外國人總是抱怨為什麼要放棄原屬國籍才能拿台灣國籍...總拿自己國家那樣寬鬆的規定要求台灣比照辦理....說穿了就是想要擁有雙重國籍兩邊占便宜拿好處...但這樣的寬鬆規定對台灣來說是有害的
如果那樣台灣一定會被雜七雜八的外國人搞得烏煙瘴氣....因為人都有佔便宜的心理....所以千萬不可放寬外籍人士取得我國永久居留的門檻..否則此例一開...會有沒完沒了的外國人要求比照辦理...那是我們台灣無法承受的...所以萬不可陷入會吵的孩子有糖吃這樣的困境
其實很多外籍人士一旦給他方便之後..它們就會當隨便...這話大家是可以深記的
請在台灣的外國人理解並遵守我國的規定OK
@@28907008 Tawinese can take advantages of duel citizenship from other nation and foreigners can't with Taiwan. So the people who can take advantage of the duel nationality system is Taiwanese people and not foreigners
@@amvhate 台灣人要拿人家的國籍是要照對方國的規定....比如英國就沒要求外國人放棄原所屬國籍....但日本..韓國...等很多國家...就有要求外國人要放棄原所屬國籍....
所以你不要拿你們英國的規定...要求我們台灣跟要你們英國一樣好嗎...
我們台灣人不是到世界各國都可享有不放棄原所屬國籍才能拿對方國籍的特權好嗎?
這正好說明你們英國的規定太寬鬆...所以才會又那麼多雜七雜八的外國人去你們國家...把你們國家搞得烏煙瘴氣的....比如發動恐怖攻擊的那些人
@@28907008 This doesn't make the countries to lax. It make the country more open! Having duel nationality hasn't been proving to be more a security risk then permanent residency. Western country have other laws in place for foreigner from stealing information. Taiwan can still denial duel citizenship from country's that treating Taiwan independence, and still be open to trusted countriess. But you know what Japan , South Korea , taiwan and china have all in common??? They are homogenous countries in the world. Western country have benefited from having different culture mix in
日本永久居留證聽說是最難拿到的
因為台灣的政治局勢比較敏感，所以把歸化為國民的條件設定的比較嚴苛我覺得蠻合情合理的吧！
也不是說排斥外國人，只是持有投票權就能夠左右台海的情勢，這麼重大的決定權還是希望留給在這片土地上長期耕耘的人。
更何況連國家邦交都沒有
我覺得跟邦交比較沒關係，英國有沒有跟台灣邦交又不能作為判斷他適不適合作為台灣國民的依據。
根據國籍法，歸化為台灣國民的方法要嘛結婚要嘛有功勳，真的沒有辦法達到上面兩個條件就要通過自己努力達到審查條件（居住時間夠長、沒有犯罪紀錄、具有能養活自己的專業能力、具備我國語言基本能力及國民權利義務基本常識），但中文蠻難的，願意花心思學而且真的能在青、中年這個階段學起來的外國人好像不怎麼多。
台灣的法規允許雙國籍是除非你有特殊功勳者及高級專業人才。
另有特殊情形可以不用放棄原來國籍，例如：紐西蘭不允許國民放棄國籍，而紐西蘭政府會發一章「不允許放棄國籍」之正式文件。特殊情形適用於無法取得喪失原有國籍證明的人，但這一個例外只確保在法律下，不同人受不同對待，紐西蘭人因此能夠順利取地雙重國籍。
沒辦法..... 世界上有那麼多國家不承認我們又不給讓加入聯合國，外國人要改入籍中華民國實在沒什麼必要....
心裡有真的愛台灣就好了，在台灣安居樂業、互相幫助扶持，犯罪的事不要做就好了。
大家都是地球人.....國籍、法規..... 都是人弄出來的，做人要善良就好！
對部分國家外國人, 有中華民國國籍就能用台灣護照, 台灣護照排名算前面算相對好用的
中華民國國籍對於某些政治動盪、犯罪率高、性別不平、少免簽證及各種你不知原因(即使入了聯合國)的國家而言，只能說它有你無法理解的價值
那麼多外國人選擇入籍台灣，必然經過審慎評估，認為有必要，別人不會比較笨~~
身為台灣人不需要妄自菲薄~~有沒有加入聯合國，絕對不是評估你身分證有沒價值的依據!!這次的全球肺炎災難恰巧就是讓世界看清楚~~聯合國也沒比較有屁用!!!
還真沒聽說過紐西蘭政府可以出文件“不允許放棄國籍”，容易取得嗎？
@@JerryLiangtimes 我是在台灣國籍法簡介裡看到的，但沒有說是否容易取得：
twnationality.com/zh/an-overview-of-current-nationality-law-in-taiwan/
或許可以查查紐西蘭的國籍法規看看或請教相關外交辦事處的專業人員解答 🤔
畢竟，永久居留證的ID，與身分證的ID，還是有一點不一樣。可能這與投票系統有關吧，或只是分類而已，但絕對與歧視無關。
分類管理的差別！
畢竟他是持有他國國籍的外國人士！
為了好認而已，不要想太多
分類 is a type of 歧視 though!
最主要的原因還是在一些需要驗證身份證號的網站如銀行, 網購, 政府服務等等, 舊的居留證號無法驗證通過, 造成很大的困擾, 才會依照驗證規則改為跟身份證號相同的編碼方式(第一個數字不同), 這是最快的方法, 不然改網站和軟體會耗時太久! 加上原有的編碼原則存在於太多的系統之中, 如果將外國人的居留證號編碼改為跟本國人一樣(第一個數字相同), 問題會相當多也相當難以管理!
如果將來以居留身份拿到身份證, 現有新編碼的居留證號碼也是你未來的身份證號碼, 所以就...接受它吧! 這是要跟著你一輩子的.
政府無法承認雙重國籍的原因是怕有些人在國內為非作歹,但其憑藉另一國籍護照出境，而逍遙法外所致.但除非你有對台灣特別貢獻的人,且為知名人士,政府才會以專案特許.
臺灣出生才可以持雙國籍
@@Mifi-mv 國外出生 只要父或母其中一人是台灣公民 也可以持雙重國籍 自身經驗
因為臺灣的國籍不是「屬地」，也就是說，不會因為你在臺灣出生，你就是臺灣人。
個人跟其他人的想法類似，因為我們有“來自對岸的威脅”，所以必須要謹慎防範。
雖然覺得 對這麼愛臺灣的「帥倫」感到抱歉，但，這也是沒辦法的是
@@frnk57 是看血統
不是出生地
你爸媽是台灣人
你在美國出生 也會有中華民國國籍
像是林書豪跟他弟
都有國民身分
血統 你妹
這並不是特別去定義是外國人或是本國人，本身持有的就是永久居留證並不是身分證，所以在統一編碼上面有點區別也是很正常的事情。
I’m a citizen of earth so I feel okay about it. It would be more of a novelty for me to have Taiwanese ID. I feel connected to Taiwan regardless. I’m treated so lovely by the locals I really can’t complain. Interesting episode.
Hi earthian???
Does your Earth citizenship allow you to travel to every country visa free?
yes, considering oneself world citizen is a good idea :D
或許跟政治特殊有關係，一旦大開可能會影響公民投票而改變政權，澳洲華裔議員就有被涉入問題，雖然曾是香港籍，但香港已經很多大陸地區人民遷入。
更重要的是不少在地香港人已經被利益矇蔽良心，替中共辦事，宣揚極權主義，所以不得不防。台灣面對世界局勢也是如此
帥倫 Interesting video! I didn´t know it, actually I need to change it soon.
捕獲野生黑素斯😆
期待你的影片
It’s made my life a pain in the ass!! Hahaa..... my bank got locked up and I couldn’t file taxes! Hahaha
黑素斯你要申請台灣身份證的計畫進行的如何?
@@lifeintaiwan Well, the latter doesn't sound that bad actually. XD
怕(海外的中國人)用各種方法(大規模移民台灣)!!再用投票方式讓台灣回歸中共
台灣從古至今都不屬於中共 樓主怎麼能用回歸這一詞呢？應該用併吞這詞吧？
對，台灣有些法律背後的確是要保護台灣不被對岸侵略，而且在還有侵略意圖的局勢下，還願意讓對岸的人入籍已經算友善了！
@@argus-r1j 中共粉紅快回家，再整天繞著台灣轉，你也不會像我們這樣幸福快樂
@@argus-r1j 台灣人很大一部分出過國，見過世面，一個小島沒世界觀怎能活到現在！倒是中國深井之粉紅sb蛙，很大一部分人沒出過國卻在網路自嗨兼高潮出水🤔🤔🤔，言論被限制網頁被屏蔽，收到的資訊是政府丟給你的一言論，只要是「正常人」的邏輯判斷，就知道誰是井蛙，而且還是蛙中之王！
@@argus-r1j 是啊~都逃出國的!國外的自由氣氛真香!!不用被屏蔽不用翻牆，哈哈~笑死!!有了綠卡還什麼祖國~我呸!
歐洲很多國家申請當地國籍的其中一個條件，就是要學會該國的語言，台灣沒有這樣的規定，但是建議你可以先學點基礎的國語再說。
不少歐洲國家的法律規定，就算外國人在當地住很久，跟當地人結婚，這樣的情況也只「可能」取得永居，不一定能拿到國籍，台灣的規定並沒有比較嚴格，而且台灣還是一個資源有限的島國，還有戰爭風險
如果接受雙重國籍，很多大陸有心人會來申請台灣國籍，這會造成相當大的國安疑慮，這是我個人的想法
講到這個就傷感情了
目前中國來台，是變更「戶」籍，不是變更「國」籍
不論是我方還是對方，都不認為對方跟我們不同「國」
@@reptilemonk 可以請你說明清楚嗎？ 因為我媽是陸配，她是放棄中國身份證才有台灣身份證的，而且她回去中國也是拿台胞證。
沒錯。
真的要當間諜，用2個國籍不是更讓人疑心
@@PeiRong5 www.immigration.gov.tw/5385/12162/12194//CP_QA?alias=QAClass&type=%E5%A4%A7%E9%99%B8%E5%9C%B0%E5%8D%80%E4%BA%BA%E6%B0%91%E7%94%B3%E8%BE%A6%E7%9B%B8%E9%97%9C
大陸配偶申請定居、入籍、取得身分證之流程為何?
一、大陸地區人民為臺灣地區人民之配偶，經許可在臺灣地區長期居留且符合臺灣地區與大陸地區人民關係條例第17條第5項規定者（即每年在臺灣地區合法居留連續2年且每年居住逾183日、品行端正無犯罪紀錄、提出喪失原籍證明、符合國家利益），即得申請在臺灣地區定居，經審查會通過後，印定居證，發函通知申請人持長期居留證及大陸居民往來臺灣地區通行證至原申請之服務站換領定居證，持憑定居證至戶政事務所辦理設籍及領取身分證，並向原大陸居住地申請戶籍喪失，作成公證書後經海基會驗證，再送交本署。
不是完全認同這個問題跟想法，歸屬感跟國家認同不是用一張身分證來證明的，有很多人住台灣但心在祖國 ，如果你真的認同也想長期住在台灣，放棄你原有的國籍，努力拿台灣的身分證，歸屬感是在你心裡對這個國家高度認同。
Allen並不打算放棄原有的國籍，那是他出生的地方，父母也在那，所以也只能拿居留證了
我不認為台灣對於給予外籍人士國民身份證嚴格審視有什麼錯誤，畢竟我們有惡鄰居虎視眈眈，過於寬鬆只會讓台灣遭殃。如果Allen真如你所說愛台灣的話，你應該能體諒政府作法，另外建議把中文學好，讓人感受到你真的心口如一愛台灣，想更深入了解台灣文化，畢竟很多中文比你更流利的外籍人士都沒台灣身份證了。雖然學好中文不等於愛台灣，但如果生活在台灣，卻連我們的母語都不想用心學習的話，那口中說愛台灣也實在沒什麼說服力
我不完全認同您的看法，外國人愛臺灣用自己母語並無不妥，何況臺灣語言並非只有中文或普通話。客家話，原民語皆可。
@@張宏甫 我只是覺得到別的國家生活這麼久，卻連這個國家最常用的母語都沒認真學習，口口聲聲說愛台灣，還想有身份證字號，這真的愛台灣嗎？我有點懷疑
有同感，但也許再多給他一些時間吧！反正，有心人自分出優劣。最重要不是語言，而是認同臺灣，以及該納的稅務！時間會證明你的看法。
只是常常看他影片就知道艾倫聽得懂只是沒有自信說而已。我在國外的時候也是這樣，只因為我害羞說日文就被日本人指責不想了解日本我根本不夠愛日本，所以你這篇讓我有很大感觸，聽到的外國人會覺得，這就是歧視！
我在日本做的事情多過很多日本人，常常做志工、捐錢捐物，但只因為我日文說不好就要被打進不夠愛日本，這是不公平的，反面，艾倫對台灣做的事情也很多，用英文介紹台灣給外國人，宣揚台灣的理念和文化，難道你覺得這樣還不夠？一定要能說中文才能愛台灣？或是要他學所謂母語台語、原住民語、客家語才叫做真正的愛台灣？
@@張宏甫 在中華民國沒有把國語（ mandarin)像中共把普通話(mandarin)訂立為官方語言。中華民國只有國家語言，國語、臺語、閩南語、客語、原住民各族語言、各省方言、、、等都是平等的。現在只是政府在國內要與國際接軌，正在推廣普遍通用的語言國語及英語在2030年成為國家的雙語國家。但因為沒有官方語言法強制規定，是以柔性來讓中華民國成為中英語雙語國家。
這樣中華民國所有人民才不會失去他們在各省各地方家鄉的母語。各民族語言平等。
在1895年日本依據馬關條約接管臺灣，來到臺灣就要警察去學習在臺灣使用最多的臺灣閩南語（臺語）與在臺灣的人溝通。
居留證號的改變，主要應該是要解決外國人申辦金融服務上遇到的問題
I’m a Hong Kong PRC holder after living there for 7 years when I was growing up. While I’m a UK national, in my heart I have a much deeper connection with HK than I do to the UK. It’s certainly a conflicting feeling, my daughter was born in the UK but I was brought up in HK and even got married there. The concept of belonging when you’re technically a foreigner in one country but feel like a foreigner in your native country is a complex issue...
well said~~
熱愛台灣跟入籍台灣是兩回事，不能混為一談。英國自己的社福及退休制度，遠比台灣好太多，應該沒有人會輕易放棄。再者，除非原生國家動亂不堪、戰亂連連，經濟低落，或者是為了異國婚姻組織家庭，否則應該沒有外籍人士會輕易放棄自己的原生國籍。
不放棄就不要講這些啊XD
如果沒健保他們連夜逃跑，超現實！
台灣就是不承認雙重國籍，我100%贊成，就是不能承認雙重國籍，這是台灣的特殊歷史問題
台灣是人民可以有雙重國籍，但是不讓外國人擁有我們的雙重國籍。
@@chih662002 因為當初的黨國權貴雖然在台灣洗腦台灣人要做堂堂正正的中國人，但是會把小孩送去當美國人又不願意放棄在台灣撈資源的特權
其餘的老百姓只是沾了黨國權貴的光，可當外國人但不用放棄台灣國籍
@@kaichikc 洗腦台灣人？原住民嗎，真正台灣人有多少，國民黨大部分都從大陸來，當時時空背景當然是要做中國人，現在誰還會說要當中國人，一直說台灣藉，拜託，現在是中華民國藉好不好，還有，現在雙重國籍的大部分都是民進黨的人，就知道為什麼不改政策了吧，因為現在黨國權貴變民進黨了。
中國視為外國人，目前一視同仁的做法是為了防堵中國人走後門滲透台灣，這是不得不的做法，希望帥倫能理解哦！
真的
滿大街都是中共同路人充斥著台灣社會。只要出現關鍵時刻，這班人就會成為中共眼中的“英雄”。
@@wonderman7788 台灣還有30%共 可怕喔
我覺得原因很簡單，因為台灣在國際上不被承認是一個國家。
就算Allan你再怎麼愛台灣，在YT上說多少次台灣是個國家，你的母國英國也不會承認台灣是個國家。
2010年，英國商人林克潁在台灣撞死人後，潛逃回英國，結果就是蘇格蘭法院判不引渡，台灣政府，法律完全拿他沒辦法。
那麼，在這種情況下，台灣為什麼要輕易的給外國人台灣國籍？
外國人入台灣國籍要先放棄母國國籍，這樣台灣法律才能管到他。
如果今天英國商人是在美國撞死美國人，情況會一樣？
台灣本來就不是國家 因流亡中華民國變成流亡政府 不正常的政府 才會出現如此多的不正常事情發生 你願意為台灣的不正常努力嗎? 使台灣正常嗎?
@@中國流亡政府在台灣地
丟掉中華民國...改為台灣國 ...我們台灣就能正常...OK
因為 ...中華民國...是以蔣介石為首的國民黨政權強加給我們台灣人民的.....所以必須丟掉它...真實地做自己...當一個真真切切...堂堂正正的台灣人..OK
歸屬感不是由號碼給你
應該是由生活中感受到的🧧🧧
莫彩曦 就是最好的例子
不好意思我打中文，首先謝謝您想當個中華民國國民，身分證號碼是個問題。我以前也有過可以當外國人的機會，在中美洲CENTRO AMERICAN的某個國家，要當他國人民，首先你要”拋棄”本國國籍，在去接受他國的一些行政要求，例如用當地官方語唱國歌等等，中華民國的男人基本要素之一，兵役問題，四個月，夏令營，Allen如果你有去履行國民應盡之義務，我想政府跟其他觀點，會真正的認為你是R.O.C的人民，中華民國的國民有應盡的義務，也有應受之教育。這點是跟其他國家有所不同的。另外，華人到外國去生存，完完全全要具備足夠生活的外文能力，我在您的頻道只有學惜到英文，很少聽到中文，我想這真的是不可思議，我之前可以移民的國家要說的官方語言是西班牙文，在去之前我完完全全不知道，那是什麼語言。所以您提出來了你的觀點，我回答了我認為的答案，“拋棄本國籍跟服兵役“，或許能夠解答你的問題。
如果他的體檢沒問題的話
他也會中文吧(去換証時 用中文溝通 也聽的懂) 只是自己的頻道是英文配中英字 其實這樣子的英文頻道 很適合給對台灣有興趣的外國人看到.假如他的頻道只有中文配中字的話 受眾只有聽的懂中文的人 而英文配中英文發音 其受眾會更多吧.
@@羽文真 我的重點不是中文，而是國民應盡的福利與義務。
@@羽文真 真要像你說的 那他頻道標題會是英文或是會有英文
他是真的來台灣很久但不太會使用中文與人交流，他跟酷有拍過一篇
I understand your disappointment, however I don't think a person's sense of belonging should be reduced to or dependent on the ID numbers. It's not only about if you have done enough for or how much you love Taiwan, but the technical and highly politically sensitive reasons due to the complicated situation of Taiwan and its relations to China. Please don't let the numbers consume your passion for Taiwan.
FYI - All government affairs will now take 3x as long for you the first time since they all will be confused since their records now will identify you as a "Taiwanese" and everyone will be confused. They will also spend 15 min trying to re-enter your new APRC number without finding any records of you at all before they flip your card and see your old number on the back. #TrueStory
Yeah I can totally believe that!
Sounds terrible 🤦🏻♀️
Banks ? That’s why I make two trips indoors every year.. no more than that or I’d lose it mentally.Not changing mine until I have to update my passport.
Dang that sucks, but I guess it's a temporary thing right? It will get better once the agencies get used to the new ID system
最重要是你的心 有人有台灣身份證不認同台灣而有些外國人為台灣付出了他的一生就像這一百多年來從外國來台的宣教士們 Bless you.
永遠都沒辦法測試心。這就是共諜突破的點。
@@wonderman7788 對
愛台灣巳很棒了.這塊土地同住的人.不会去在乎你的身份証怎樣.快樂的生话才重要
這些是法律上必要之惡。 來台灣玩的人太多了。 自從我20年前還是學生以來，情況一直都是這樣，尤其是教英語的外國人。 就是劣幣驅逐了良幣，因此台灣有些法律必須存在！ 台灣給外國人的禮御夠多了，那是台灣本地人自己也沒有，那些外國人在獲得身份證後，不就玩的更誇張？ 玩到身體壞掉為止後，還有台灣便宜的健保！ 保障一生...
For Taiwanese household registration(registering a Taiwanese household then a Taiwanese ID card and a Household Certificate are issued), Taiwanese babies born overseas will get an ID with a second number 7, Mainland China people married to Taiwan will get an ID with a second number 9, and naturalized foreigners will get an ID with a second number using 0~6. Different ID number formats designed to distinguish different groups of people are very practical for many aspects instead of merely making feelings of isolation or separation. For example, the police officer could more easily investigate crimes according to concerned people's backgrounds, and administrative authorities could easily provide promotive or welfare measures for naturalized foreigners.
good details
Wrong! I'm a naturalized foreigner and my ID number has a 1 in the second digit, not a 6 as you claim.
Can you clarify them for us then perhaps?
@@davidli2k I mean, a Taiwanese's Vietnamese wife will get an ID like T26XXXXXXX. The 1 in your ID still represents your gender.
@@小黃-y4o Ah OK!! You meant the 3rd digit, not the 2nd digit...then in that case, you're right.. As my ID number has this format F16xxxxxxx.
In Japan, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, they don’t even allow dual citizenship in any circumstances.
and thats one of the reasons why foreigners rarely consider living in Japan long term...
艾倫住台灣十幾年，中文都不太會說，學習當地語言很重要，你想當台灣人的誠意說實在我看不太到
LOVE FROM INDIAN🇮🇳 IN TAIWAN🇹🇼
但我認為台灣正在緩解外國人的移民。 例如，政府正在考慮將工作簽證的永久居留權從5年延長至3年，而將高等專業的畢業生（碩士和博士學位）的永久居留權定為1-2年，這是非常受歡迎的。 好話題艾倫和一如既往的好工作。
but I think Taiwan is easing the immigration for foreigners. For example, the government is thinking to make the permanent residency from 5 years to 3 years for working visa and so on 1-2 years for the graduates of higher studies(Master and Ph.D) which is really welcoming. Good topic Allen and good job as always.
台灣應該歡迎更多印度人
If you go to UK, Europe ,Japan and any any other countries will not give me a residency even I was there studies or work, so why Taiwan shall be easier to non residents? We don’t want anyone came to Taiwan for the national healthcare ,please think yourself what can you help or contribute to Taiwan first.
身為系統工程師，我認為能夠只從一個ID號碼判斷出是否是外國人很便利，因為在做一些法規相關判斷時，我不需要拿到你的國籍資料就可以完成判斷，例如所得稅計算、勞健保勞退和離職儲金計算...等等。
Taiwanese in Australia here. I have dual citizenship, hold both countries passports. I can use either when travelling (although I generally use the Aussie one when travelling with my partner so we get the same treatment at the airports and doesn't have to split up. )
I came here on skill migration grounds, the rule back then was first a 6mths bridging visa to transition from my student visa, then following a permanent resident visa on skilled worker grounds, living here for 2(?or maybe it was 3) years in 5 years before I can have citizenship.
There is now a citizenship test, whist back then I just need to swore in and recite the rights and responsibilities of being a Australian citizen.
During this process I was not required to denounce my Taiwanese citizenship... Probably because Australia doesn't mind duo nationals (unless you are a MP in the upper house I think).
I think the rule is actually that taiwanese can become dual nationals, but foreigners coming into Taiwan need to have an exceptional contribution or something to Taiwan before being allowed dual citizenship.
@@djunior874 that's correct. 第 6 條
外國人或無國籍人，有殊勳於中華民國者，雖不具備第三條第一項各款要
件，亦得申請歸化。
第 9 條
外國人申請歸化，應於許可歸化之日起，或依原屬國法令須滿一定年齡始
得喪失原有國籍者自滿一定年齡之日起，一年內提出喪失原有國籍證明。
屆期未提出者，除經外交部查證因原屬國法律或行政程序限制屬實，致使
不能於期限內提出喪失國籍證明者，得申請展延時限外，應撤銷其歸化許
可。
未依前二項規定提出喪失原有國籍證明前，應不予許可其定居。
外國人符合下列情形之一者，免提出喪失原有國籍證明：
一、依第六條規定申請歸化。
二、由中央目的事業主管機關推薦科技、經濟、教育、文化、藝術、體育
及其他領域之高級專業人才，有助中華民國利益，並經內政部邀請社
會公正人士及相關機關共同審核通過。
三、因非可歸責於當事人之事由，致無法取得喪失原有國籍證明。
前項第二款所定高級專業人才之認定標準，由內政部定之。
I am extremely fortunate to have Taiwanese citizenship before obtaining my Aussie status.
@@djunior874 Exactly! Taiwanese policy IS the problem and has been for a long time!
帥倫謝謝你做了這支影片，雖然短時間內不會改變但是會留下機會。至少因為你的關注我們才知道現在的不一樣，而且你的感覺更好了點只是還有最後的瑕疵。在惡劣的大環境下你還願意和我們生活在一起，我感到很溫暖；我相信一切都會慢慢的變好，從另一方面來說我期待你心想事成的那一天，到時候希望能看到你拍個慶祝活動影片。
影片前面說道
外國人的兩位數英文不方便訂票，或從事其他需要用id的事務，
但你影片後面 6:27 又說，
如果政府不打算讓外國人和本國人用相同系統，何必改呢？
你不覺得自己自相矛盾嗎？
臺灣政府不就是為了讓外國人能夠更順利的在臺灣生活，而試著做出改變了嗎？
你不想放棄自己的原國籍，卻又想和國籍為臺灣的人用相同的id系統，不是很怪嗎？
不是歧視外國人，也不是覺得你對臺灣貢獻不夠，
而是每個國家都有自己的做法，
我想你應該能夠明白。
能不能很快拿到我們的身份證，也應該看其國家是否對等於我國民相同的態度（是否互惠原則）！就像是簽證問題，我們如果對其免簽他們是否也對我免簽一樣，如果他們的政府對我們的政府友善互惠，相對的我們也會是友善互惠的！
希望你也能多說點台灣的語言 讓人感受到你的努力 而不僅是要求
I am a Taiwanese living in Spain, all the tax or social health insurance paid are much higher than Spanish people. Now I live here at the fifth year, once I live 10 years, I can get a permanent residence card or apply for Spanish passport. For Spanish passport, I don't need to give up my Taiwan passport but need to pass Spanish history and culture tests in A2 degree which for me is a way to go because I mainly speak English in life to Spanish people who are passionate as Taiwanese.
呃真的有要當台灣人再來談歸屬感吧...
I ended up using a random ID number generator on the internet so I could make a booking at the local karaoke place. So many things were made difficult as a result of the two letters in the ID number!! Glad they've done something about it though.
不是不能討論，而是我覺得提出這個問題前，也想想為什麼台灣政府要這麼做？ 除了邦交國，有誰正式承認台灣是國家？這狀況下當然沒所謂的雙重國籍，雙重國籍是自己認定，你要以怎樣的方式出入國都是自己選擇的，政府從來沒有正式承認雙重國籍的事情，例如：你不能拿日本或美國護照直接進來台灣投票或當永居權，你還是得拿台灣發的護照或永居證進來台灣吧？
而另個角度想，身分本就是外國人，當然同樣的台灣人在別的國也是如此，不要誤解你外國人自己感到不方便和些許差異就是本國政府要歧視外國人的意思，然而要拿到台灣身分證的人民，本來就是在擁有台灣人民身分的父母生下你，才有資格直接成為台灣人，並且要遵循台灣憲法規定，需為國家義務性服務的，台灣華僑也是依我國憲法第20條及兵役法第1條規定，凡具有中華民國國籍之役齡男子皆有服兵役之義務，基於依法行政，具雙重國籍的役齡男子在臺灣均有服兵役之義務，應接受兵役相關法令之規範。再來，外國人士想要成為真正的台灣人也是同樣的，願意付出多少，才會收穫多少，林道明.瑞莎，他們也是願意冒這個兩頭空的風險，才得到今天所謂的歸屬感。而他們拿到台灣國籍後，他們要怎麼再拿其他國家的國籍，台灣政府不管，別國政府要他們回來放棄台灣國籍也是有可能的。台灣人也是不能拿著護照登入進去到國外永居和投票是吧？更不用說只有永居權的人卻想和台灣公民一樣享受額外擁有的投票權掌控台灣在國際上的發展方向吧？
標題寫下 為什麼台灣政府不給我身分證？
我倒覺得標題反思寫 自己為什麼不讓台灣政府給予你身分證？可能更貼切觀感更好一點吧？而且給別人看起來感到更友善些。
因為我們隔壁有敵國隨時想用人海戰術侵略我們，真的愛台灣，可以站在保護台灣的立場來理解這個問題。
I’ve been living in the UK on and off (was away for 1.5 years) for about 11 years, have had switched visa categories a few times due to unforeseen circumstances. As a result I am STILL ‘doing my times’ to be eligible to apply for ILR and ultimately the passport which really bugs me as the government only recognises the amount of years under a single category not the total length of time one spends here 🤷♀️
Thank you very much for sharing !
這樣投票跟健保才能分別。因為在台灣出生的才能有正常1-2身份證。
Hey Allan.
My girlfriend is taiwanese and we live in here in Belgium. In order for her to be eligible for the belgian nationality she needs to work and live for 5 years in the country without interruption. She also has to have a proof that she masters one of the two officials languages here in Belgium (Dutch and French). After all that, she can apply for citizenship and an unlimited stay.
She can have both Taiwanese and Belgian nationalities. She doesn't have to abandon her taiwanese one.
That’s awesome! Fingers crossed she gets it as soon as she can! Good luck!
這是一個很好的問題，外國人要拿取中華民國身分證必須放棄原國籍，但是原本就是中華民國的人卻可以去其他國家拿取身分證，我不知道其他國家是否承認雙重或多重國籍，但是如果那個國家本來就與中華民國無邦交，又不承認有這個國家，是否就不存在雙重國籍？無論如何，台灣目前的國籍劃分與投票權及及相關，為了不被惡意滲透投票，所以會嚴格也是不得已的，但也不代表沒有討論與改革的空間
吳鳳拿到台灣身份證但是不用放棄原來國籍，因為他是“特殊高級專業人才”
多跟dpp業配你就能拿到身份証不必放棄原國籍了
@@s885107 人家親台灣屁股也算是有貢獻啊
@@s885107 很愛崩潰喔？！😂😂
吳鳳可是拿到金鐘獎主持人,在台灣外國人好像只有兩三個拿到金鐘獎。
藍叫比雞腿
我應該是正常人吧！如果真的要當台灣人就移民入籍到台灣
當然也是要放棄原本國籍,但這是正常
台灣人想要當英國人不也是照著英國的標準入籍嗎?
這是因為yt計算看到這部影片,所以寫出自己看法
英國過去是大航海國家
管理移民方面比較寬鬆 ,
沒有台灣這麼嚴格~
台灣的法規很多都保留傳統 ,
沒有做修改!!
畢竟台灣修法速度真的不快......
英國那邊可以容易取得雙重國籍身分~
但台灣法規還是要....
放棄原有國籍!! 才能入籍台灣
@@asdfg5qwert920 你跟我開玩笑嗎?台灣真的比英國嚴格嗎?這搞錯了吧！是英國比台灣嚴格,而且台灣是可以接受雙重國籍,不然那麼多明星都不當兵,我就有聽過怎麼拿日本跟台灣的,如果是台灣人先放棄自己的國籍,申請日本,再回來申請一次
8:20 My 2nd resulted in periods of mild drowsiness on the following two days. Nothing more. Was bracing for an ordeal as my 1st really kicked my butt for the 1st two days following and wasn't myself for the rest of the week.
As with the 1st dose Hong Kong's vaccination process was highly efficient. Was in and out inside 45 minutes. Highly recommend people get the vaccine. The quicker we get to 70%+ vaccinated the sooner life can get back to some sort of normal.
Interesting observation: at both of my jab sessions < 50% in attendance were locals.
還好Rocco身體好多了，祝Rocco在台灣每天都開心，身體健康，希望帥倫能變成真正的台灣人💖💖💖😽😽😽
很多外國人只想享受台灣便利生活，並不想盡國民義務，沒有真正融入台灣社會，只在外國人同溫層內，不說中文、若不分條件的大量濫發國民身分證，一定有很多人反對。
移民政策太過放鬆會引發國安問題，尤其是完全民主的國家。例如澳洲的維多利亞州政府就明顯受到中國移民的選票影響，還有美國種族問題。在台灣，選票對國家未來的影響更是難以想像。
沒錯，受不了很多中國人移民到澳洲，拿到永居甚至入籍了，卻還是貶低澳洲稱讚祖國，心中只有祖國偉大然後一直嘲笑/瞧不起澳洲
那麼愛中國幹嘛不回去，生活在一個自己看不起的地方有比較快樂?
P.S我目前在維州，這個州長真的很......無語......
I am a Taiwanese who was born in Taichung and lived, worked, married, and had children in the Philippines for ten years.
In the Philippines, I cannot even get a general foreign spouse visa because of the Philippines’ one-China policy.
Regarding these matters, I can only say that each country has its own reasons for enacting laws. Although I feel that I am also half Filipino, this country does not recognize my identity due to political factors, and there is nothing I can do.
6:56 video「視頻」是大陸用語，台灣翻譯成「影片」
雖然現在很多人常看抖音或是很多對岸來的廣告都講視頻所以有些人已經習慣了
但是其實聽到還是感覺怪怪的，畢竟不是慣用語
所以還是建議可以把video翻譯成「影片」聽起來比較舒服喔
這些理性的「報怨」，是促使政府法令更健全的必要之惡，不過請不要只放在網路上，請填意見表或寫信，送給市政府的相關單位。 民主國家也是需要時間去成熟的，法令不全或失當之處，更需要人民去批評建議。 謝謝你表現了一個成熟公民的榜樣。
國家主權的權力 不會某網紅而改變
讓百萬外籍勞工拿台灣身分證，然後外籍勞工的家屬在依親拿台灣身分證，台灣人口破三千萬可喜可賀，到時候生活品質下降不要抱怨
@@lorenwei1 何來百萬外勞拿身分証？
很多外勞在台灣工作十多年還是拿一般居留證！
@@蘇贏-s2h 我是說如果開放讓外勞拿台灣身分證後果會很嚴重
有投資台灣很多錢嗎？
有創造台灣很多工作機會嗎？
有什麼台灣人沒有的特殊技能嗎？
願意放棄英國國籍嗎？
聰明的台灣人會容許双重國籍者說自己愛台灣嗎？
Congratulations to get new ID number! I understand the sense of loss, it's a nice question to think. Thank you to introduce the information about the change of your ID number.
I was born and raised in Taiwan and also has a USA passport. Half of my life spent in Taiwan and half in USA. I don’t really care what number I was given on my USA passport and I feel I am completely a US citizen with my love of both Taiwan and US. I hope that helps make you feel better?! I think you will find a deeper root in Taiwan if you get married and have kids in Taiwan. Trust me that will work.. lol
I live in Taichung as well, a Hongkonger started living in Taichung since August 2020. So nice you have APRC so that you can enjoy the time here.
When China is at war with Taiwan, a UK passport would definitely come in handy.
It all boils down to a question: Would you stay in Taiwan with the rest of Taiwanese people who don’t have a foreign passport to run to another country, or would you be on the evacuation plane on your way back to the UK?
*Allen是台灣人無誤 ! 希望一切順利 !* 🤗
為什麼新居留證號依然保持外國人特征？原因很簡單，因為事實就是您依然是外國人（國籍），由於您不是中華民國國民，所以我們當然只能給您非中華民國國民的識別。其他國家的做法應該也是如此。我們不能因為您很愛我的國家，就忽略您真實的身份。但是這也不是不能改變，您可以做到的是，改變您的國籍或是改變我國的法律（修改成承認雙重國籍），後者當然難度比較高，但是台灣是民主國家，如果有足夠多的人讚成您的想法，那麼就可以實現了！
Thanks Allen for pointing the issue for future improvements, but I believe for most of your Taiwanese fans, me included, you are us!
🙏
臺灣政府更改ID編號系統，是為了讓持有居留證的外國人能夠在填寫相關資料時，不會再被系統顯示ID不符合格式，並不是為了讓外國人更「像」本國人。如果想要再更貼近臺灣，那就請歸化成臺灣國籍。
而歸化成臺灣國籍，必須先放棄原有國籍，即所謂禁止雙重國籍原則，這對於臺灣這個情勢波譎雲詭的國家而言是有其必要性的。畢竟本國人跟外國人的權利義務有所差異，而這差異最明顯的就是是否有投票權，這是攸關台灣國家未來走向的事情，必須慎防敵國透過歸化取得投票權來影響臺灣。因此，嚴格規範外國人歸化要求對臺灣而言，不管是對國家存立安全抑或是國民利益保障而言都是正確的決定。
說難聽一點，若當臺灣面臨戰爭時，那些擁有雙重國籍的人還能逃回母國，而真正的臺灣人只能用生命跟臺灣共進退，這就是其中的差別。
親愛的 Allen 叔叔,很難過沒有讓你得到更好的歸屬感,但是您在我們心中已經是個道地的台灣郎~ :)
I'm not Taiwanese. I'm a Westerner.
The term "foreigner," unless you relinquish your British citizenship, is objectively correct for identification purposes.
Plus, single citizenship is the case in many, many countries. Taiwan particularly, given its unique diplomatic situation, would not benefit from dual loyalties.
Not sure what the problem is. I know you're PC and consider yourself "a citizen of the world," but it's not about how you feel. It's about what is objectively true. This is an ID card, not a greeting card. It's to identify and register you... not give you the warm and fuzzies.
Thanks for the information
I‘be heard there’s new ID for foreigners, but no idea for the details, my boss will need this… thanks,
畢竟永久居留證不是真正的台灣身分證，所以編碼規則肯定不一樣
帥倫別難過，凡事都要一步一步慢慢來，也許等到你拿到台灣身分證的那一天時，再回想過去等待的那段日子，相信一切都是值得的。
Tell me why i grabbed my ARC card to check out the numbers haha. I came September 2020 & have the 2 letter ID system. Maybe I should head to immigration ~
Make sure you take your camera if you do! Views are off the charts on this one for some reason!
@@lifeintaiwan 😂
“Wild” Jenn caught... 🤪
恭喜新的號碼編排有很大的調整。
永久居留證跟身分證是不同的，所以號碼也不同也很正常，這在其他國家也是一樣。
Just got my first ARC and I got one letter.
所以台灣人去英國住了一陣子...英國政府就應該自動發給這台灣人身份證了?
你這麼愛這個國家
可我卻很怕隔壁鄰居隨時砲打我們····
台湾不是国家
@@freedomjam6951 台灣是你爹
I want to point out a translate problem in 6:57. We don't use "視頻” as video in Taiwan. We use "影片" instead. 視頻 is word from China.
突然發覺你的頻道風格，讓我想起一個住在英國的布萊頓youtuber，叫“戴舒萱”的女生很類似，差別是艾倫住在台灣，推廣台灣生活文化，而她是住在英國，主要是用英文，有時候也會用流利的中文，在影片中教大家英文，並介紹英國生活文化。可以同時跟兩位英國人學英文，挺好的。😊😊
英國曾於1812年強行抓捕已經歸化美國的英國移民並強制入伍，此事亦成英美發生戰爭的原因之一。至於其他歐洲國家也曾干過相應的事情。原因在於此時認為公民對國家具有永久效忠的義務，雙重國籍很明顯使一人需要同時承擔兩個國家的權利義務，對兩個國家效忠。如果兩國開戰，那就有意思了。
摘自網路～
如果一個人可以"很容易"拿到兩個國家的護照，那是不是可以拿到三個國家的護照，甚至200個國家的護照，出國都不用辦簽證，全世界都是我的國家。
Totally agree. U like Taiwan so much, and even though you spent your entire life in Taiwan, probably still can not get citizenship. National ID No is very important when living in Taiwan, whether using any app or making an appointment, you would be inconvenient without it. Thanks so much, you make such great videos
你可以選擇歸化中華民國，但是你願意放棄英國國籍嗎？像那位烏克蘭的瑞莎！
他說過不會放棄原國籍
I have been living in the US for almost five years, and paying tax with delaying for almost 5 years. Still a non-citizen, not even green card yet.
我也想問丫爲什美國不給我公民身份
先去辦綠卡再說行不行？
同塊土地上家人和貴人分別於勿忘責任義務；謝謝分享！
i just got my Citizenship my Taiwan ID now i can say Im a Taiwanese!🇹🇼❤🇵🇭
how long you get id bro ?
Welcome to the family
what is your profession and contribution to Taiwan we wonder?
@@gwyn. Thank you brother.
@@cdnsilverdaddy im a taiwanese by blood. through my father.
About the immigration policy and law, Taiwan still has long way to go. Taiwan used to be a very conservative country about immigration until recently. Most important laws were changed just in the passed 10 years.
美國也對外移人口也有分別吧，很正常
I am a Taiwanese living in USA and we are the working visa now, we've been here for nine years, studying, finding job, right now is applying for green card, ones you get the green card, you need to live here for five year and you can go citizen test, so....it can be faster if you marry an American, and depends where're you from, some countries are lot more easier to apply, some countries need to wait a long time...but for Taiwanese, we can have both citizenships at the same, that's the benefit for us! So...I know the feeling to be a alien, but will become lot more better, God bless you!! 平安喜樂喔！祝福你～～
主要是卡雙國籍吧~除了特殊人才可以保留，如果真的要辦國民身分證就要先放棄現有國籍的相關證明資料，真的有移民這樣的打算嗎? 還是只是要工作長期居留? 這跟日本的條件也差不多吧
Very informative video Allan.. and yes, I understand the difficulties faced by ARC and APRC holders here, especially the latter as although the name suggests "permanent", all holders of APRC's do not enjoy the same benefits given to Taiwanese ID holders. I held an APRC for more than 6 years before I decided to become a Citizen here, main reason was because I have settled down here and have a family and I love this country, which is my home away from home.
艾倫 恭喜你拿到新的身份證
😊
相比之下～一般台灣人去美國要拿到綠卡，更難啊！
說起歸屬感，我不是想嗆你，只是提醒您回憶一下上次和酷拍的影片，剩下的我想交給蔡阿嘎來評論
同感+1 正想說類似的話
請問是什麼意思呢 我沒follow到之前的影片 想知道
@@蔣和宏 那幾部影片大意是酷帶帥倫去體驗各種台灣的美食和生活，並強迫帥倫用國語點餐。帥倫體驗後很後悔自己不敢說中文，因為在英國說不好英文會被白眼，但台灣人很熱情的包容他的爛中文，自己十幾年來心中的隔閡拒絕了這個友善的社會，最後還哭了。
雖然我無法解決你的問題，但還是謝謝你那麼愛台灣～
題外話，既然你要拿台灣身分證
影片何必都講英文呢
怎麼不講中文或是台語？？？
@@mri917 等你出國 碰到很多 本地人 要你來這邊 不要講 台灣語言
你就會瞭解我說的意思了
Tell your government to recognize Taiwan as a country first. After that, when Taiwanese people apply for the UK citizenship, your government will ask them to give up Taiwanese citizenship, too. Your government doesn’t recognize Taiwan as a country, so Taiwanese people don’t have a “citizenship” to give up. On the other hand, we think we are a country, so when you want to become a Taiwanese citizen, you should give up your original citizenship. Get your loyalty right.