Ramachandra Guha on BJP, Tipu, Savarkar and Karnataka| No Filter with Dhanya Rajendran
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Historian and author Ramachandra Guha speaks on how historical figures are being weaponised in Karnataka. He asks whether the elections should address the issues people face now rather than speak about rulers who lived centuries ago. He tells Dhanya Rajendran that while Narendra Modi is like Indira Gandhi on steroids, BS Yeddyurappa is almost a Congressman.
#RamachandraGuha #Karnataka
00: Promo
00:40: Intro
00:54: ‘The BJP System’
03:03: Modi is Indira on steroids
06:21: Regional media is better
08:15: Why India becoming Hindu nation
11:44: Tipu a complex character
15:39: Reasons why BJP chose Savarkar
20:37: Modi Shah agile at appropriation
23:30: Yeddiyurappa unhappy at communalism
-------------------------
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute Channel: / thenewsminute
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute Malayalam: / @thenewsminutemalayalam
▶ Subscribe to The News MinuteTamil: / @thenewsminutetamil
▶ Like us on Facebook: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow us on Instagram: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow us on Twitter: / thenewsminute
▶ Follow all latest stories by TNM here: www.thenewsmin...
▶ Subscribe to The News Minute’s daily newsletter: tinyurl.com/TN...
What about Mamta, Stalin, Vijayan, KCR , Gehlot ? Is democracy flourishing in those states? Is there no discrimination there?
He mentions..except that PPL hear what they want to hear
watch at 39min
Truth
Who introduced Tipu Jayanthi celebration?Is that not hatefilled politics and weaponising History?Not mentioning about this is suppression veri.
Perhaps, this Gentleman wrote Rahul Gandhi s speech at Cambridge. We all have personal or family physician.Mr.Guha is a family historian for Nehru family.
He is staunch critic of Gandhi Family. No one appreciate Whatsapp University knowledge these days. You can look lot smart by not showing ignorance in public.
@@thatslife1058 if I don’t look smart to your eyes, so be it. In return for your gesture, let me suggest that you go
And check in dictionary as to “ what is a naivity “ . You can differ from my views, but, learn to write politely your view point.
I will suggest you to read his book "India after Gandhi". He is critical of Nehru for 1962 war, highly critical of Indira Gandhi for emergency and blamed her for suppressing institutions and also blamed Rajiv Gandhi for minority appeasement. He has vehemently criticised Rahul Gandhi recently. So your point is stupid
Guha is a disputed person. He wants people to forget the past and present atrocities of Muslims. And do not have any Pride for real Indian culture. These people for money can dump the country, Congress has already done maximum damage.
tru
Where was this paanwala during 1984 Sikh riots. Thousands of my Sikh bretherens were burnt alive. Properties looted. I was there is Tilak Nagar Delhi. Fridges were sold for Rs.500.
According to this panwala historian only congress has the right to weaponize history 😅
Agnostic whose name is 'Ramchandra'...irony. Hey Bhagwan...
Your time up Mr guha...
This congress PR man's income and other grants must have taken a hit because of the present government. These corrupt people shouldnt be given spaces to spread lies and distorted opinion. He is not aware of this same situation that is happening in Kerala, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal etc.
Why BJP won in three Non Hindu States in Northeast? Will Guha explain ?
Congress has done enough damage
If both Hindus and muslims live a life of secularism, then the nation will be in peace. Reform religions according to the signs of the time. Our public appearance should not declare our religion. Religion l should not be a public performance.
BUT DO MUSLIMS BELIEVE IN SECULARISM 1st
Idiots will finally discredit their parentage also😢
There is no gainsaying that Tipu was an ideological destroyer of Hindus in Malabar. All the atrocities that he organised there had little to do with territorial occupation. What a tyrant he was to the Mangalore Catholics and the Mandyam Iyengars. But in Malabar he was very vocal in his ideological motivation. You cannot be selectively loyal to humaneness and to the national cause.
Mr. Guha is very selective in his views with Myopic vision.
What freedom struggle....? There was no such thing 😂😘
Really? Can you prove what you are saying?
Ramachandra Guha Should Speak Only On Cricket, Since He Has Been Certified As An Expert In The Game By Indian Supreme Court...
He Need Not Prove His Anti-Nationalist Credentials Here....
Why he forgets the partition ,the terror attacks and punjab agitation?
Guha is best ignored... He will not bring about any change
Another useless like Amartya sen
Mr. Ramachandra Guho,
You are requested to kindly go through the history of Pakistan which has been written after 1947
One more sorosjeevi, always false narratives, distortion of history. A buddhijeevi (in kannada he is called as a laddhijeevi - ಲದ್ಧಿಜೀವಿ)
West Bengal is a paradise of democracy?
Oh miah guh, when india was not hindu ? What r BD, SL, Pak states....r not all the states of the world are based on a particular religion? 🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️
Bring back ancient civilization which was surppresed by foreign invasion which diluted the truth.
Be bold.remove unnecessary provocation.
Our ancient past history must bring back. Revisit our great India civilization.
Go back to 10th century glorious times and pls bring the times back :-))
@@hema_raghu that's great my friend. Your history tell your how great you are. Only converts may not realise but the reality must resurfaced
@@rajkrishnan3651 If you love liberalism and secularism and humanism, they you don't tolerate Islam anywhere in your midst. Islam's official doctrine is to eliminate, wipe out, persecute non-monotheistic religions. Any Muslim in Karnataka who doesn't condemn the Qur'an which only allows protection of monotheistic faiths (Christianity and Judaism) should be thrown out of India. We are so stupid for putting up with them. It took centuries for Muslims in Persia to say, "Well..... okay maybe we can include Zoorastrianism as a religion of the book".. Why does it have to take them such a long time to realise that persecuting Jews is wrong and persecuting Zoroastrians is also equally wrong? When they realise this is, it's too late; Zoorastrianism has been nearly eliminated.
Only Muslims and Christians who condemn the genocidal doctrines imbedded in their religions and commit to identifying as Sanātanis should remain in India. (Of course, they can worship whichever Jesus or Allah they want to; but they must not condone their scriptures.)
@@paulthomas281 agree sir. You gave excellent explanation of today's faith and repercussion of anti elements of sanathana dharma.
As an Indian whatever you faith,we are the same ,we are the sons of this soil India.
We speak according to the states language, same language, eating same ancestors foods, having same cultural bonds but only difference is the religion. Abramic religion simply splitting the roots of the same family and becoming more arabic or European and also becoming a threat to same our own race.
If we start thinking, it will trigger our own downfall because our mind has been ransacked and creates disharmony among the same race. Imagine by whom, how ..........???????
Religion of our ancestors has profound wisdom and spiritual science, we must come back to our mother religion. Otherwise, this land will have enemy within.
Bring back bullock cart. WhatsApp university graduate
He is the man of virus not sorus
This guy is hypocrite
We know you are biased
Radical hindus.. wow.. He is the judge jury and god... and Dhanya is happy with his certification of her news agency
He has obviously not read about RSS or Hedgewar.
Joker from khangress
Guha, is jobless person.
I request public to see the UA-cam presentation of the personality of GUHA who has completely analysed and dissected him and his writing very nicely by Sri T.N.SUDARSHAN
Like many so-called intellectuals he is propped up by the West.He should be ashamed he was born in India as. Hindu! Very sad!
Guha is talking bullshit as he is with congress
History must narrate the past of India unvarnished.
You have distorted history
I saw his books stacked in Fiction genre in library. Librarian knew his job well.
Haven't seen any books written by you yet
bloody criminal
Anti national
8:28 he didn't answer the question. He didn't explain how bad it was under Indira.
Guha is a congress historian
I came here to read only comments.
Well he is psychology dis oriented person
Illogical arguments
Breathlessly making allegations against BJP
"election only democracy". True. Wow.
There is no serious attempt in the opposition to come out with a Visio for India’s inclusive development and a good India’s stability.
Joker from khangress
Mr guha be ready for a visit from ED or income tax department.
Metcalfe is speaking
Pls put dislike symbol so that that this man's video will not propogate
Nonsensical about VDS and British. Gandhi was a pro xasticism, thats why he further divided hindis as harijans. Whereas, Hindus were unified by VDS, and a social reformer.
Whatever may be the situation during Indira Gandhi period, but there wasn't hatred amongst majority and Minority.... There wasn't devision amongst citizens in India on religion. There wasn't a single example of religious intolerance!!!!
What records say ? Let us be purely neutral & finely knowledgeable while giving observation.
Nothing to say kilafat, Bengal partion, destruction of temples by tipu and partion in the name of religion? Sikhs annihilation, ethnic cleansing of pundits and wiping of tamils in elam? Whether tipu and savarkar are complex,we don't know but sure kuha is complex
I consider him fool and every hindu must oppose him...such people sare shame
Guha at his best again, babbling.
This Guha is achamcha of the Gandhi family . He thinks Bharat came into existence because of Nehru and Gandhi! Ha Ha
Why would muslim of Karnataka Potray Tipu as there hero who is Bigoted anti Hindu as per BJP
Mamta, Kejri, Mulayam, laloo, Salin , Owais are all peace spreading angels.
They aren't, but they are small players.
Wuhan Allah
Understand that sarcasm
Absolutely correct ramachandran ji
Then why if some Iyer or nambuduri has done 2century before modern day Iyer or FC community has to answer or suffer in this quota system and various laws which punish Fcommunity
Because they still uplift the practice n look down upon other sect of people. And act innocent n play victim when questioned. If no then please confirm if everyone will be allowed to perform pooja n archana in the Temple's of our country? And make it a qualification based service n not caste based?
@@Jeyakumar-hs9zr well ur statement itself doesn't make sense, u speaking of Church n Mosque. In both these anyone who wants to be a Father/ Brother Mother/sister in Christianity and being a Moulvi in Muslim can do so by taking up that responsibility without any caste discrimination they learn there practices n they perform their prayers. But in Hindus we see only one community who are allowed close to the deity for the prayers to be recited. Can a person from a lower caste be trained on mantras n enter the garbagudi (holy sanatorium) And even today many ppl from the lower sect of life are ill treated by the so called elite community. So in such case y are the elite's cribbing abt quota. They want to perform prayers n consider them closer to God n above others, and also if someone is getting benefits because the elite's are misbehaving n have rights to safe guard their lives that should also not be given because the elite want that part of their benefit too.
This distorian is smoking something really special
Puppet of moghaals.congress party
Ramguha is a fairytales story writer...?
Looser guha is not worth the weight of one of his raddi books
He should be proud to be indian so he is alive
Thanks for the interview❤
paytm professor
6:18 Modi - Indira Gandhi on steroids.
Tool kit man
Country's direction is best now
Congress also appropriated Gsndhi and made him Mahatma to promote that party's interests. Listen to what Dr.Ambedkar has said in an interview to BBC those days about this trick of Nehru .
He was first called Mahatma by tagore. U r obviously ignorant and from WhatsApp university
@@vindukur100 O Yours is WhataApp university is it?
@@ramachandraks1 get a good education first
'Mahaathma' title for Gandhiji it's not the trick Neharu,
Ravindranath Tagore called Gandhiji, as 'Mahaathma' Gandhiji.
Distorian
28:44 wow
The Great Alexander aur Expansionist worldwide Terrorism protector VETO ko hii Huck hai?
Tibet bhii hadapna chahiye,Nepal bhii, Pakistan bhii,Srilanka bhii?
BHARAT ko ek kamzor ministry aatte hii hadapne men kitna easy Worldwide Terrorism protector ko?
Worldwide COVID 19 Pandemic ke dauraan vishwa janata ko protect karne waalem sada Das bankar rahem?
Worldwide peace and security keliye worldwide deshom se milkar MODIJI ka Government jo uchit kadam udha raha hai uskeliye koti koti dhanyavaad Modiji ko aur unka Government ko.
Koi Godhra, Pulwama,Pathankot,udi,
Sansad attack,Mumbai Serial blast,Ahmedabad serial blasts etc. Se Bharat ne apna sahan shakti ka parichay sansaar ko dii hai.
Ab nahim hoga Worldwide atankvaadiyom se Bharat par koi internetional notoorious weapon lobbies ne hamla nahim karaayega.
Ab karaayega to usko sahi ilaaj Bharat ka Demonetised janata ka 300 paarwaale Democracy retaliates karnekeliye saksham ho.
SATYAMEVA JAYATE
SATYAMEVA JAYATE
SATYAMEVA JAYATE.
UNITED NATIONS kii jai
UNITED NATIONS kii jai.
UNITED NATIONS kii jai.
Where voted. All purchased like
Main thing is let elect and get selected
Mr Guha, if a person has avision for democratic India and works for the good like Lee K Yew, what is wrong. Why are you blindly against Rahul Gandhi? Though he is from a privileged family, he is not like Indira Gandhi.
Guha is at best a waste of time, at worst a cake of dung. In summary, absolutely irrelevant!
Please do not put such a man like him on your show...has not bothered to look into facts of Bharator its culture. .has been doing so for several years...
Delhi Durbar cannot rule nation at one stroke because regional aspirations are different ideology. We independence against common foreign rulers and now we have to fight for Regional aspirations. We must’ve to have a separate country and form like European Union system so that have more participation in the government and Delhi Durbar has no way. National political parties trying to kill the regional political parties
If I Gujarat go as an independent country Modi can rename it into Hindu nation without any delay. No rat and frog story sets in no state is satisfied
Ambedkar was always loggerheads with gandhi but only on the issue of untouchability and representing the downtrodden castes. Otherwise Ambedkar had great respect for Gandhis humanism and his efforts to involve the masses in the freedom movement which till Tilak had remained confined to the cabal of minuscule oppressing castes oligarchy who shamelessly and hypothetically continued to oppress the bahujan majority with casteism and in the same breath had the audacity to declare’freedom is my birthright’ …..
Is Ram c guh istorian....🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️🧜♂️
Savarkar is a Vandari, Tipu sulthan is a India origion of Dravidan.
He is a useless historian claiming great let him
Write Tiippu secular where our community was forced to convert our ancestors ran away from there and settle in present TN is congress democracy What Indira emergency’s and her rule
Who are your ancestors?
When you look at Karnataka, the formation of Karnataka is not similar to the other southern states. It was formed by amalgamation of different provinces, 'The Mumbai Presidency and the Madras Presidency', the Mysore State and the Nizam ruled Karnataka. With the influx of all cultures, it is pluralistic. It might be a reason why Karnataka politics is different from the other southern states. The cultural influences becomes an easy task for BJP to actually look at it as an experiment that works according to their plan.
29:50; Guha is absolutely on dot when he says ‘history should excite and shld be taught with reference to all dimensions’. All along we have been taught that the british used divide and rule policy to rule over india but it’s not ever told that due to the already existing caste structure and casteism the indian society remained fractured since thousands of years providing ideal ground for defeat and enslavement by all and sundry. History teaching also has regional bias with all focus on the north and ignoring the south and other regions….There’s just a passing reference made to the kingdoms of the south particularly. Instead of analysing the socio-economic dimensions of various conflicts history teaching revolves only around battles.
The British have a population of approx 65 million today. India has a population of 1.4 billion.
When the British ruled India, India's population was around 320 million - about 5 times that of Britain today. At no point of time were there more than 300,000 British in India (administrators and soldiers included).
How the fuck is it that 300,000 British ruled 320 million Indians for 200 years?? How much can one really 'divide and rule'? Any decently sized province should have been able to defeat the British with every possiible advantage of home-turf.
Shows that Indians were either bloody cowardly or bloody stupid, or both. Either way, you can''t 're-write' that history.
He supported d Gandhi empire from 1947 to 2014
Stir, will this situation continue.?
Thanks for effective information
I am expressing my deep sense of gratification to u for the wonderful conversation with Dr Ramchandra Guha who is eminent professor of history.I am sincerely requesting you to extend your channel in West Bengal.
26:31 genuine 360 degree view
Instead of understanding Mr Guha some people write absolute rubbish echoing the garbage of bigots.
He doesn't know history.he bcmes histerical
May be becos he knows and can't stand the violation of it!
He is not important any more because the lies and half truths he is spreading..😂
Very informative discussion congress fought freedom movement, gave democracy allowed all thoughts to grow giving chance of proper and timely election. Congress wants to make India a nation states.
Currant inc has nothing to do with freedom movement. They misusing the name for political gain. The real heroes are Bose and Bhagath sing who gave their life for the nation. Gandhi and Nehru are British stooges and manipulated the movement so that goras can leave India and gave them face saving exit. With out these two India would have been free much earlier.
The correct point it is due to Pakistan become Islamic due to this Modi need to make Hindu rastra
But what Pakistan earn by doing it today
The same India will earn very soon after making Hindu rastra
Truly all our institutions are functioning at the whims of the bjp.
No more good can be expected.
Mr Guha if u were in Indra Gandhi s time u would not be able to talk even so much.....
It's the most random hypothesis Indians love ..of course the other one is too much democracy
Sir,it's right reflection what u have shown.
Thanks for bringing this interview. Good analysis of political history
This man is a Gandhi loyalist his world view consist of d Gandhi backside
Unfortunately we have now last of the Historians who can be called impartial unbiased ones like Romila Thapar, Ramchandra Guha Irfan Habib. Henceforth we will have committed historians with distorted history.
Thapar, Guha, Irfan.... unbiased historians? LoL!
Truly unbiased in favour of Pakistan They have only spoken lies and it is a disgrace that we had such people and one day history will bring their true colours.
Guha is a congress man. He insulted saverkar. Gandhi helped british with his nonviolence . Wrong narration
Mr Guha calls a spade a spade. Anyone who speaks against BJP propaganda is dubbed as anti national or congressmen. Very sad.