@@MetroSportsYT I see where you’re coming from. Personally I can’t quite get there with such raw and untested potential in Richardson. At least compared to someone who is one of the greatest QBs to ever play, top 25 for sure. And Brady played well when he was 40. Fair point though.
Fair assessment on geno. I think a lot of people carry over “he’s a bench qb” mentality from years ago and don’t realize that the dude is a solid solid qb. And I agree with a lot of what you said. He’s a fringe top 10 player who has shown he can lead a team to the playoffs. does require a good team around him in order to win big games but isn’t going to make the team worse like some qbs
As a Bengals fan, I think it is fair to put Burrow where he is if you have questions about how he will come back from the wrist injury. If we assume he will be at least as good as 2021, he should be in the Best tier. He made it to the superbowl with a bad O-line, and did not get blown out. What other QB has played well enough to get to a SB with a bad O-line? When Mahomes had a bad O-line, he was getting chased even though the Bucs only rushed 3 and couldn't pick apart the defense.
Great list, I would change almost nothing with it, love the AR respect. Also as a ravens fan I think lamar allen and burrow are in the same tier, and mahomes is a slight tier above them bc of his superbowl rings. I get it if this is based off more recent performances but overall I'd say him making a sb lets him be in the same tier as allen and lamar
Idc Rodgers in the very good category. Above Dak, Jalen, and especially Richardson. Ik he’s 40 coming off an Achilles. That arm talent has gone no where tho. He still has it. Richardson should be behind all those guys very good and above all the way till I would say Tua. He can be in front of him. Then I’m moving Stroud and Goff back. Burrow, Herbert, Stafford, Love, Stroud, then Goff.
Im sorry but the richardson thing aint happening, he will be a fantasy star but no way will he actually win playoff games and stuff, im hoping to be wrong
any particular reasoning behind this opinion? I get that he very unproven, but i don’t see why he wouldn’t be able to take a big step next year and win a playoff game.
Aaron Rodgers is a 4X NFL's MVP all with the Packers but I'm sure he would love to join with Hall Of Famer Peyton Manning for the most NFL MVP in NFL's History 1:18
I would say C.J.Stroud I believe he'll become a legitimate BEST QB in the NFL but make no mistake about it just this sure the former Ohio State University Buckeyes Alumni was a 1st Round 2nd overall pick by the Texans won Rookie of the year from 2023 season but he's just getting started in H-Town cause I really can assure you this he will be willing as well as fully prepared to do all he can to bring the Houston Texans it's 1st ever Championship in the 22 years franchise history of existence it would really mean so much to not only the fan base the organization the front-office the entire ownership & managers all rolled into one few and far between it all
I don't mind throwing Tua Tagovailoa maybe Justin Herbert to the mix cause they both is young splendid special players who will be a NFL MVP too depends if they stay healthy and not get hurt they will be all right 1:00
Every rookie should be below average, they haven't proven themselves yet and a lot of rookie quarterbacks struggle, look no further than the 2021 NFL draft with Zach WIlson, Fields, etc. Baker who had like 300 yards and 2-3 TDs in a playoff game is not below average and Watson has also done nothing since he left Houston he is also below average. There are definitely mistake here on this list and also Burrow is easily part of the Best tier.
Solid list but stafford is too high mabey end of that tier Anthony Richardson is a guy I also think could be realy good but for now I would move him down a tier Rodgers purdy and Lawrence all need to move down a tier especially purdy and baker should be in mid
Stafford has set record breaking seasons with 3 different receivers. MEGATRON most yards, Kupp triple crown & Puka most yards by a rookie. Stafford top 3 and the guy above him on this list interviews saying he mimics his play style. Come on now 😂
@MetroSportsYT Oh Yes Indeed he's very Decent a 1st Round 1st overall pick in the 2009 NFL Draft he's the Golden Boy he's really the Chosen One but of all the 1st overall pick from a QB perspective no doubt it's Peyton Manning cause like Stafford Peyton in his Prime won a Super Bowl Championship in 2006 & Stafford in 2021 won the Super Bowl too with the Los Angeles Rams as well
Respectfully I disagree a bit here. I love Brock and I’ve defended Brock quite a bit recently: that being said the dude has 3/4 all pro players surrounding him and maybe the easiest system in the nfl to work within. Now Brock has been great but I look at many QBs in the league and see them playing at a better/ similar level with worse rosters and think they’re better. Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, Lamar, Stafford, Dak, Herbert, and CJ to me are definitively better. But I can make cases for guys like Goff, Tua, Hurts, Love, and probably someone else to be better than or on a similar level to Brock
Only QBs I’ll say that are better. 1.Mahomes 2.Joe Burrow 3. Josh Allen 4. Lamar (which I’m hesitant on because he ONLY shows up in the regular season) Tied 5. Maybe Stafford only because he’s not getting any younger, but he proved he can win when it matters.
@@MetroSportsYT You can’t discredit a guy because of the situation he was drafted into. Brock isn’t the only QB to have talent around him. Guys like Montana, Peyton Manning, and Kurt Warner, just to name a few, had elite talent to help them win, but we don’t discredit their legacies because of it.
Mahomes should be in Very Good. He wasnt top 5 in any stats this year, and he was carried by his defense. He is still top 10 no doubt, but ranking him top 3 after last season seems questionable.
Baker at below average is nasty work
I’m not super high on baker next year. I hope I’m wrong because I love baker but I’m just higher on other guys
@@MetroSportsYTyour really full of shit
@@MetroSportsYTyea but I don’t think he’s that low either way
@@MetroSportsYTI’d say he’s definitely mid or good enough
@@MetroSportsYTbut valid argument I guess he will just see
lost me immediately upon placing anthony richardson above aaron rodgers
Arod is 40 years old coming off a torn achilles. I trust the talent and potential of Anthony over the age and decline of ARod
@@MetroSportsYTbut you don’t keep the same logic with Purdy?
@@MetroSportsYT I see where you’re coming from. Personally I can’t quite get there with such raw and untested potential in Richardson. At least compared to someone who is one of the greatest QBs to ever play, top 25 for sure. And Brady played well when he was 40. Fair point though.
@@MetroSportsYT you are a fool.
@@ZxZNebula EXACTLY!!!
This dude on my tier list of youtubers trying to talk football ranks as “stick to that 9-5 buddy”
You want fries with your burger?
Fair assessment on geno. I think a lot of people carry over “he’s a bench qb” mentality from years ago and don’t realize that the dude is a solid solid qb.
And I agree with a lot of what you said. He’s a fringe top 10 player who has shown he can lead a team to the playoffs. does require a good team around him in order to win big games but isn’t going to make the team worse like some qbs
I agree! I think that Geno with an awesome team around him could easily win a championship. And I do believe that the Seahawks are nearing that level
@@MetroSportsYT LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
rodgers under anothony is crazy
this dude is a certified ballbag
This list sucks
As a Bengals fan, I think it is fair to put Burrow where he is if you have questions about how he will come back from the wrist injury. If we assume he will be at least as good as 2021, he should be in the Best tier.
He made it to the superbowl with a bad O-line, and did not get blown out.
What other QB has played well enough to get to a SB with a bad O-line?
When Mahomes had a bad O-line, he was getting chased even though the Bucs only rushed 3 and couldn't pick apart the defense.
I agree I’ve always thought that a healthy Burrow is a top 5 guy
Not good enough is where I place this list
Why? The only qb I see who i totally disagree with their ranking is baker. Everyone else I can at least understand even if I don’t agree
Fr this list is full of shit
For real this list is full of shit
@@trentwise3762umm AR with 2 games is a top 10 project qb?
@@thienhua9100 eh, I mean I don’t agree but he’s the 2nd most hyped player from that class.
Great list, I would change almost nothing with it, love the AR respect. Also as a ravens fan I think lamar allen and burrow are in the same tier, and mahomes is a slight tier above them bc of his superbowl rings. I get it if this is based off more recent performances but overall I'd say him making a sb lets him be in the same tier as allen and lamar
JAR - ED GOFF JAR - ED GOFF JAR - ED GOFF JAR - ED GOFF
you should've made a category where unproven players such as rookies go
Idc Rodgers in the very good category. Above Dak, Jalen, and especially Richardson. Ik he’s 40 coming off an Achilles. That arm talent has gone no where tho. He still has it. Richardson should be behind all those guys very good and above all the way till I would say Tua. He can be in front of him. Then I’m moving Stroud and Goff back. Burrow, Herbert, Stafford, Love, Stroud, then Goff.
Im sorry but the richardson thing aint happening, he will be a fantasy star but no way will he actually win playoff games and stuff, im hoping to be wrong
any particular reasoning behind this opinion? I get that he very unproven, but i don’t see why he wouldn’t be able to take a big step next year and win a playoff game.
I disagree big time. I truly do believe that Anthony is the perfect Qb for the colts. And I believe in his talents. I am very high on him
@@MetroSportsYTI believe your full list is full of shit
@@IsaiahGarcia-pl8og guy is a chizzode
Aaron Rodgers is a 4X NFL's MVP all with the Packers but I'm sure he would love to join with Hall Of Famer Peyton Manning for the most NFL MVP in NFL's History 1:18
How does Bo Nix suck if he hasn’t played a game yet? Thats just hating
dudes a big hater. if u see his other videos he bites "opinions" off other Ytbers... which is why i unsubbed. hes a follower and a bad one.
I would say C.J.Stroud I believe he'll become a legitimate BEST QB in the NFL but make no mistake about it just this sure the former Ohio State University Buckeyes Alumni was a 1st Round 2nd overall pick by the Texans won Rookie of the year from 2023 season but he's just getting started in H-Town cause I really can assure you this he will be willing as well as fully prepared to do all he can to bring the Houston Texans it's 1st ever Championship in the 22 years franchise history of existence it would really mean so much to not only the fan base the organization the front-office the entire ownership & managers all rolled into one few and far between it all
Agreed!
Stroud won’t win any Super Bowl
I don't mind throwing Tua Tagovailoa maybe Justin Herbert to the mix cause they both is young splendid special players who will be a NFL MVP too depends if they stay healthy and not get hurt they will be all right 1:00
Herbert will be mvp, tua throwaninterception will stay in the wahbulence
Every rookie should be below average, they haven't proven themselves yet and a lot of rookie quarterbacks struggle, look no further than the 2021 NFL draft with Zach WIlson, Fields, etc. Baker who had like 300 yards and 2-3 TDs in a playoff game is not below average and Watson has also done nothing since he left Houston he is also below average. There are definitely mistake here on this list and also Burrow is easily part of the Best tier.
Fair point, but I wanted this video to be more about projecting how players will perform. So in this instance I believe that Caleb will be average
Solid list but stafford is too high mabey end of that tier Anthony Richardson is a guy I also think could be realy good but for now I would move him down a tier Rodgers purdy and Lawrence all need to move down a tier especially purdy and baker should be in mid
Move geno smith down a tier as well and AR fits in after Kyler at the end of the good egnough
Stafford has set record breaking seasons with 3 different receivers. MEGATRON most yards, Kupp triple crown & Puka most yards by a rookie. Stafford top 3 and the guy above him on this list interviews saying he mimics his play style. Come on now 😂
Gardner isn’t the starter. It’s been said many times Aiden is QB1.
Bryce is not better than Baker
Yes he is
@@Will-wm7st No he's not he was ass last year
@@truzzprod.8191 you’re ass 💀
@@truzzprod.8191 His O-line was like this short about the giants
ua-cam.com/video/edk0QxVm6VE/v-deo.html
Non existent
I think Bryce will be better than Baler next year
How can you say JJ sucks when he hasn’t played one down? Lame video
I think like how you mentioned, the team around the qb affects if they will be good or not
we gottah knock trevor lawrence down to mid, so many weapons and still there wasn't anything crazy about him last year
I’m gonna give him one more year to prove himself. I trust him
@@MetroSportsYT quiet
Matthew Stafford at the very least deserve one NFL's MVP before he can ride off into the sunset to the Hall Of Fame soon very soon
Would be awesome if he could!
@MetroSportsYT Oh Yes Indeed he's very Decent a 1st Round 1st overall pick in the 2009 NFL Draft he's the Golden Boy he's really the Chosen One but of all the 1st overall pick from a QB perspective no doubt it's Peyton Manning cause like Stafford Peyton in his Prime won a Super Bowl Championship in 2006 & Stafford in 2021 won the Super Bowl too with the Los Angeles Rams as well
13 QBs aren't better than Brock. 5 at the most.
Respectfully I disagree a bit here. I love Brock and I’ve defended Brock quite a bit recently: that being said the dude has 3/4 all pro players surrounding him and maybe the easiest system in the nfl to work within. Now Brock has been great but I look at many QBs in the league and see them playing at a better/ similar level with worse rosters and think they’re better. Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, Lamar, Stafford, Dak, Herbert, and CJ to me are definitively better. But I can make cases for guys like Goff, Tua, Hurts, Love, and probably someone else to be better than or on a similar level to Brock
Only QBs I’ll say that are better.
1.Mahomes
2.Joe Burrow
3. Josh Allen
4. Lamar (which I’m hesitant on because he ONLY shows up in the regular season)
Tied 5. Maybe Stafford only because he’s not getting any younger, but he proved he can win when it matters.
@@MetroSportsYT You can’t discredit a guy because of the situation he was drafted into. Brock isn’t the only QB to have talent around him. Guys like Montana, Peyton Manning, and Kurt Warner, just to name a few, had elite talent to help them win, but we don’t discredit their legacies because of it.
Brock purdy definitely should to be higher
Mahomes should be in Very Good. He wasnt top 5 in any stats this year, and he was carried by his defense. He is still top 10 no doubt, but ranking him top 3 after last season seems questionable.
This is pretty bad
😫😫
REALLY BAD.