As much as this may all of been a publicity stunt you cant help but love seeing how well they pulled it off and even more so how much inspiration they drew for lesbians, especially in a country where it was very looked down on, them kissing on stage like that so blatantly was a lot stronger a symbol for a lot of people back then than how a lot of people see them now.
@coolnamebro In their own country (Russia) in those day, yes it would have been difficult and to do it publically would be worse still. Plus it would be even more unlikely you find 2 that can sing as well Lena and Julia AND sing as well as they do together. Yeah it would have been nice to use actual lesbians but back the they were a perfect match and would not have been beaten.
You do not take into account the context of the time, this is not the authoritarian year 2023, but 2002, when Putin portrayed a liberal, that Putin said in an interview that he does not see anything wrong with homosexuality, this is a relatively liberal Russia. Everywhere, from television to the beginnings of the Internet, Tatu were glorified, they were called the new nesting dolls. The stem of Russia, the pride of Russia. And during Eurovision, this couple reproached Europe for “conservatism compared to Russia.” According to citizen surveys, the majority of the population, even 5-year-old children, even old people, do not see anything wrong with LGBT people. This is not modern Russia, this is another Russia, good Russia😢
They are actually playing the early version of Nas Ne Dogonyat because i was playing both and some of the lyrics are different especially this part 6:15 - 6:45, that part is completely different from what they released on thier album!
How cute! :3 I used to like these songs (English version) when I was a child, but I had no idea of their meaning [I only used to speak Spanish Lol]. It's funny 'cause I am a young lesbian adult and after my coming out I was looking for some "girl to girl" love songs and tATu was among the first results in Google. Lol
Best performance i've ever seen in my life !! What a talent ! There voices is higher than the Playback yulia's voice did not damaged only by screaming it's also by cracking it She need to learn how to sing clearly and without cracks
did someone see the expession of Lena when Yulia was near her? and the sweetness when she stroke Yulia´s hair? they look beautiful togheter! I miss that days... they were really in love eachother, and now Katina didnt talk to Volkova... :(
Jocelyn Bigras there’s a difference 💀 romantic love and platonic love. platonic love is the love you feel for your friends and family. Romantic love is when you’re in love with someone. Are in love with your parents? That’s concerning.
Oli Via it was their image. although it’s never been disclosed whether they dated at all or not because they’ve always evaded the question, in 2003 they were ‘exposed’ as not actually being lesbian and after that, yulia actually had a few boyfriends. Yulia has some very homophobic views and they’re even both married to men now.
Как быстро все изменилось..тогда была качественная музыка,интересные шоу и не было этой гомофобии.люди просто наслождались качественным музыкальным продуктом
не-а,гомофобия всегда была,а в то время когда тату выступали вообще была в России ужасная гомофобия,сейчас более менее получше,за это не убивают как раньше
а к их образу лесбиянок относились нормально потому что все время самих лесбиянок сексуализировали(особенно мужчины) а к геям ужасней относились на одном из их концертов вообще в геев кинули бутылкой когда они целовались,хотя по шоу так должно было быть
They were never a couple, though. It was an act all along made by their management. It's not like Russia had Pro-LGBT laws up until the last few years; they've had anti-LGBT laws for quite a while. They declassified Homosexuality as a mental illness in 1999. There is no exact answer to why they allowed this on Russian TV except for exploitation money.
***** Cus of the new laws and shit , now this is considered a gay propaganda and to promote homosexuality is illegal , you can be gay but you cant talk about it basically. Im not an expert but its something like that.
Kids Junk do you know what is propoganda? Alright, time for politic lessons for you.. Alright, look.. Propoganda is like gay parades, showing on TV "BECOME GAY AND BE HAPPY", yeah so.. that's the propoganda, you can be gay in Russia and that's very legal, u can kiss on street with other man etc. You just got bullshit into your ears by U.S, sorry for you :D Lesbians are sexy btw.
I wish to Know what was the lines they used at last part of the song is not like originals... and yes at 2004 at documentary of Tatu Julia knew she needed care of her voice or she would lose it poor Julia... And this performance totally memorable perfect energy how they look for eachother... Good times...
+Daniela Vrasinec its quite simple, these lines come from their first song/ demo called " 200 po vstrechnoi" who includes some lines used later in nas ne dogonyat too . I love this performance so much ! Khochetsya tak Chtoby prikolno Bez tormozov 200 po vstrechnoi Eto lyubov Eto ne bolno Eï chelovechki Eï chelovechki Khochetsya tak Chtoby ne mimo Vam ne ponyat Vam ne poverit Ne obyasnit Ne obyasnimo Vam ne dognat Krov iz arterii
+Daniela Vrasinec Blame Ivan and the producers. One of them got inspired by a German group for the screaming in songs and made Yulia scream in songs knowing full well they were destroying her voice. They more or less told her to keep screaming in songs as that was t.A.T.u's image or she would be replaced. The producers etc only saw these girls as $$$$ makers exploiting them for their talents.
Хочется так Чтобы прикольно Без тормозов Двести по встречнои это любов, это не болно Еи человечки, еи человечки Хочется так Чтобы не мимо Вам не понять Вам не поверять Не обьяснить не обьяснимо Вам не достать кровь из артареи ♫
Еще где-то в 53-м с приходом кукурузного казнокрада, краснобая и лицемера: пошло резкое загнивание бюрократии продолжающееся по сегодняшний день с соответствующими результатами.
I liked it very much. I liked the fact that they kissed. Maybe I shouldn't enjoy watch it, but I liked it. They acted as lesbians. It was crazy. I like this
FUCKING LEGENDARY QUEENS
Jimmy Medina BY THE WAY FROM RUSSIA😏
Fucking🎉🎉
Yulia had such a powerful voice. Amazing 💕
unfortunately she was nos singing in the last song... she was yelling... thats y she lost it
Thats playback🎉
As much as this may all of been a publicity stunt you cant help but love seeing how well they pulled it off and even more so how much inspiration they drew for lesbians, especially in a country where it was very looked down on, them kissing on stage like that so blatantly was a lot stronger a symbol for a lot of people back then than how a lot of people see them now.
@coolnamebro In their own country (Russia) in those day, yes it would have been difficult and to do it publically would be worse still. Plus it would be even more unlikely you find 2 that can sing as well Lena and Julia AND sing as well as they do together. Yeah it would have been nice to use actual lesbians but back the they were a perfect match and would not have been beaten.
You do not take into account the context of the time, this is not the authoritarian year 2023, but 2002, when Putin portrayed a liberal, that Putin said in an interview that he does not see anything wrong with homosexuality, this is a relatively liberal Russia. Everywhere, from television to the beginnings of the Internet, Tatu were glorified, they were called the new nesting dolls. The stem of Russia, the pride of Russia. And during Eurovision, this couple reproached Europe for “conservatism compared to Russia.” According to citizen surveys, the majority of the population, even 5-year-old children, even old people, do not see anything wrong with LGBT people. This is not modern Russia, this is another Russia, good Russia😢
Wow, I wish they would have stayed young forever.
why
sebastropas why not, is the question
these dresses. and kisses. i love them both :)
Right?? :'))
agreed!
Best live performance ever! The energy coming out is unbelievable, after 22 years is still stuck in my mind. ❤
They're too adorable. Like Anime characters
I want to live in these good times. o.o
Эхэхэх... Я тоже... Но мне было лет 7, когда группа была популярна)
same >
best live ever... the energy that they put in this live is amazing...
12 years later and still have shivers looking at this!!!
Продюссер талант! Проект 🔥! Такие простые ходы .. так эффективно! А в наше время такое возможно? Думаю нет!
Las considero las mejores artistas rusas de todos los tiempos con sus voces tenian el mundo a sus pies cuando eran Tatu.
I have no idea what they're saying or singing but my god, they are fucking adorable in this video!
KathVoldsby
It's how they want to be together even though they're the same sex. They like each other but unsure if the other knows
Even though they’re singing over the recording, they could hit every note. Even the “Shining upon you” part 😯 👏🏻
Капец до сих пор я эту песню слушаю не могу забыть супер песня Татушки
cuando Mtv pasaba musica :,) y de la buena.
si,que recuerdos :')
Песенка моего детства)) Помню, записывал эту программу на видеомагнитофон)) 0% пошлости в отличие от нынешних) Браво!
LEGENDARY QUEENS
They are actually playing the early version of Nas Ne Dogonyat because i was playing both and some of the lyrics are different especially this part 6:15 - 6:45, that part is completely different from what they released on thier album!
it seems to me that this is other text. However, this is more like it :)
It was a promo version then changed to what it is now
Search nas ne dagoniat premiere versión 🥰
the voice of julia...... =(
Who is still listening to the group in 2021?
me.
Me
me!
I’m here
I’m here :)
Que hermosas !!!! Viendolas en 2020 con tantos recuerdos... estas chicas marcaron mi adolescencia 😍
good old days this girl I love them...
Yulia era un encanto... Trataba a lena con mucha pasion y cariño.
Jajaja si, pusieron el playback pero ellas cantaban y no cantaban, para mi fue uno de los mejores conciertos que dieron :DD
Ajaja
That time when MTV was cool and had real, good music
Oh, they were so cute! Love them, t.A.T.u.forever!!
столько лет прошло, и даже сейчас уже мой сын их фан.
To ma takiego powera, że szok
How cute! :3
I used to like these songs (English version) when I was a child, but I had no idea of their meaning [I only used to speak Spanish Lol].
It's funny 'cause I am a young lesbian adult and after my coming out I was looking for some "girl to girl" love songs and tATu was among the first results in Google. Lol
What a beautiful history xD
Xóchitl
0😶
Xóchitl
-Raul Mora- that ended few years ago ;-;
wow!!! Después de 15 años me sigue gustando. :3
Amo tatu ...
OMGGG good times, i remember those times :'(
эххх было же время))
Siempre ad!kta & Aferrada a sus canciones... Son Geniales!!!
Best performance i've ever seen in my life !! What a talent !
There voices is higher than the Playback
yulia's voice did not damaged only by screaming it's also by cracking it
She need to learn how to sing clearly and without cracks
I wonder if the girls still remember this show.
I'm pretty sure they do, especially when feeling nostalgic.
did someone see the expession of Lena when Yulia was near her? and the sweetness when she stroke Yulia´s hair? they look beautiful togheter! I miss that days... they were really in love eachother, and now Katina didnt talk to Volkova... :(
And you do understand why, right?
They weren’t in love but they loved each other
@@gringa4914 They weren't in love but they loved ? HAHAHAH what's that? I'm not feeling cold but I feel cold 🤣
Jocelyn Bigras there’s a difference 💀
romantic love and platonic love. platonic love is the love you feel for your friends and family. Romantic love is when you’re in love with someone. Are in love with your parents? That’s concerning.
Oli Via it was their image. although it’s never been disclosed whether they dated at all or not because they’ve always evaded the question, in 2003 they were ‘exposed’ as not actually being lesbian and after that, yulia actually had a few boyfriends. Yulia has some very homophobic views and they’re even both married to men now.
kurde, kiedyś to było :D
2013 and I still listen to this song!
almost 2022 but im still listening this masterpiecee
I love this performance, I can not stop watching it and it was 11 years ago. hahah :D
Lindas verlas
Как же я завидую тем, у кого ностальгия по этим девчулям!! Я тоже так хочуууу ааааааа я сошел с ума))
Как быстро все изменилось..тогда была качественная музыка,интересные шоу и не было этой гомофобии.люди просто наслождались качественным музыкальным продуктом
не-а,гомофобия всегда была,а в то время когда тату выступали вообще была в России ужасная гомофобия,сейчас более менее получше,за это не убивают как раньше
а к их образу лесбиянок относились нормально потому что все время самих лесбиянок сексуализировали(особенно мужчины) а к геям ужасней относились
на одном из их концертов вообще в геев кинули бутылкой когда они целовались,хотя по шоу так должно было быть
eso ya se sabe, pero da gusto verlas, es una de las mejores actuaciones que hicieron :D
absolut love them, they fab and gorgeous!!!!!
en el año 2000 tenia 6anños ni siquierA sabia de este grupo hasta hace poco
Reminds me again that music in my childhood were the best... 🙂
wspaniały teledysk:-)
Tak, ale myślę, że były to lipsyncing
me 2!! I LOVE TATU!!!
Wait so this was allowed in Russia 12 years ago but now its considered illegal !?!
They were never a couple, though. It was an act all along made by their management. It's not like Russia had Pro-LGBT laws up until the last few years; they've had anti-LGBT laws for quite a while. They declassified Homosexuality as a mental illness in 1999. There is no exact answer to why they allowed this on Russian TV except for exploitation money.
What? How is it considered illegal?
***** Cus of the new laws and shit , now this is considered a gay propaganda and to promote homosexuality is illegal , you can be gay but you cant talk about it basically. Im not an expert but its something like that.
AmyTheJawsTerminator yes i know it was an act , been a fan of them since the first album , its just sad how the law has taken a step back
Kids Junk do you know what is propoganda? Alright, time for politic lessons for you.. Alright, look.. Propoganda is like gay parades, showing on TV "BECOME GAY AND BE HAPPY", yeah so.. that's the propoganda, you can be gay in Russia and that's very legal, u can kiss on street with other man etc. You just got bullshit into your ears by U.S, sorry for you :D
Lesbians are sexy btw.
I wish to Know what was the lines they used at last part of the song is not like originals... and yes at 2004 at documentary of Tatu Julia knew she needed care of her voice or she would lose it poor Julia... And this performance totally memorable perfect energy how they look for eachother... Good times...
+Daniela Vrasinec its quite simple, these lines come from their first song/ demo called " 200 po vstrechnoi" who includes some lines used later in nas ne dogonyat too . I love this performance so much !
Khochetsya tak
Chtoby prikolno
Bez tormozov
200 po vstrechnoi
Eto lyubov
Eto ne bolno
Eï chelovechki
Eï chelovechki
Khochetsya tak
Chtoby ne mimo
Vam ne ponyat
Vam ne poverit
Ne obyasnit
Ne obyasnimo
Vam ne dognat
Krov iz arterii
+Daniela Vrasinec Blame Ivan and the producers. One of them got inspired by a German group for the screaming in songs and made Yulia scream in songs knowing full well they were destroying her voice. They more or less told her to keep screaming in songs as that was t.A.T.u's image or she would be replaced. The producers etc only saw these girls as $$$$ makers exploiting them for their talents.
Хочется так
Чтобы прикольно
Без тормозов
Двести по встречнои
это любов, это не болно
Еи человечки, еи человечки
Хочется так
Чтобы не мимо
Вам не понять
Вам не поверять
Не обьяснить не обьяснимо
Вам не достать кровь из артареи ♫
Rosie Summer That is terribly sad.
2020, I'm still here :)
I wasn’t expecting for a kiss but, damn...
my and my girlfriend are going to be them for halloween hahaha, just for laughs , shes russian too and we both have the same hair, it will be fun!
sounds fun! i want to cosplay as Yulia but i have no friends to be Lena * *
Me and my friend this year aswell ! :D
@@duhweez4415 wow lucky!! that sounds fun
@@Іапаi can be your lena
@@duhweez4415 yayy!! :D xD
Te quiero tatu
Omg Julia's voice :c
Тату, вы вечны 💝💥💗
Мне вспоминается 2001 год ,армия Газ 66 и всего одна кассета Тату, которую я слушал 3 месяца.
I need that studio version of Nas Ne Dogonyat. Now.
2:35 awwww
Вот время то было, а теперь минзурина добилась того, что такое шоу приравнивается к пропаганде ЦП.
Россия, которую мы потеряли.
Ага ага. Привет из России 2020-го😒 Слушаю сейчас и кажется, будто это что-то почти из другой жизни.
me encanta
hermozaz
By the way, the perfomance is from 2001
-I Love t.A.T.u.- understood
Love T.A.T.U.
Ikona muzyki kocham TA TU Brawo Rassija
6:44 jejciu...awww urocze
5:29 "Begite Za Nami"
Jesus they were crazy here!! Hahaha
2:36 ♥♥♥
te amo
Мурашки по коже бегут, когда эти двое целуются, боже, как же это круто, к тому же, мне нравится, что они такие разные (я про волосы и цвет)
It sounds like they're just singing over the regular song
-Matthew Miller- playback you mean... yea they are... but they are singing at the same time so... that doesn't matter just enjoy the video
Octubre 2019 lml
¿¿cuando sera el dia en que otras hermosas jovenes sean la nueva generacion de t.AT.u?? :D
bluedrop kennedy Wesker ahora lo homosexual no sorprende
Coronapollas no creo que lo diga por el hecho de tener connotaciones homosexuales.
dancers are amazing!
А ведь 12 лет прошло
Е мое, сколько же этой песне лет, больше 20 ?
Блин какая настольгия я 😭
M fascina tatu
Lena ❤️❤️
ТВ: "Такую Россию будущего ты хочешь видеть?!?!?!?!!?" я: Лол, да!
Мои любимые солистки группы tatu Лена Катина
Юлия Волкова
so cute they r....
Мне вот просто интересно как мы от этого пришли к тому что происходит сейчас...где и когда наша многострадальная нация повернула не туда...
Еще где-то в 53-м с приходом кукурузного казнокрада, краснобая и лицемера: пошло резкое загнивание бюрократии продолжающееся по сегодняшний день с соответствующими результатами.
amesing memmory thx
2021-2022 i share Tatu all album 💿 au top 👌
wowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww lovely
I liked it very much. I liked the fact that they kissed. Maybe I shouldn't enjoy watch it, but I liked it. They acted as lesbians. It was crazy. I like this
i really don't understand what they are singing
but i like it
to jest nadal dobre
zawsze było ;3
jest nadal :D
2020
ууух, чо творят, интересно Милонов от них фанател
конечно, милонов это тот еще актер.
Nice song.....
ЭТО ШЕДЕВР!!!!
Love music
4:14 ОРУ ДО СМЕРТИ
Las amo
не догонят и это точно !!!!!!!!!!!!! вперед россия !!!!!!!!!
если вперед с замаскированными лесбиянками, то ты кто?
Игорь Фурсов наоборот, это натуралки, замаскированные под лесбиянок
My highschool years 🎈👍
zajebista piosenka daje kopa w życiowe problemy ma moc !!!!