Imagine scoring a seat here and bringing your laptop so that you can check emails or watch videos of cats. I appreciate that the speaker called out the audience member.
Maybe they are doing this for someone else as a job and don't have incentives to do better, Rms Of? Some professor, I think, called those "bullshit jobs."
I wonder if the best historians do that and write it at a grade 6 reading level, Hicham El-Ouali? That may be the best reading level for the masses. Grade 6 may be the mean. We get this, but wouldn't it be great if more people got it too?
This sounds politically incorrect and may be anecdotal, Hicha, El-Quali. It was probably a coincidence, but out of all those planners, five were essential. Three of them were Jews.
In this and other snyder lectures his insight on the dual meaning of what used to be dismissed disdainfully as elbow space redefined as a more complex fear/want of habitat and relative comfort to others is profoundly important nut to grasp towards greater understanding
I wish everybody would learn about the subject it's so important for us to know the history of the Holocaust I tried to share what I know which after hours of watching documentaries I realize I know very little I went to Decca when I lived in Germany and I was shocked and amazed but it tweaked my curiosity to where I made it my aim to learn as much as I could but Mr Snyder has opened up so many more doors of knowledge for me thank you to Mr Schneider for sharing his knowledge with the world Darlene g duck
1:16:00 question cricism is on point yet if one can understand that snyder has painted a start that needs to be pursued further i think that is an enormous contribution of the book... framing a context to understand why hitler resonated on a level or thinking more rational than the other or fear ... the premise that it might actually be cultural approaches to reason and behavior that set up an order of human cooperation not well suited for some must be pursued but so close the the flame of blaming the victim that critical sort of discourse to tease out truth by trial and error of peer review is all but banned
Prof. Snyder is always fascinating to listen to, but here I'm afraid that here he's smoothly leading us down the garden path. In fact, after reflecting about this for a while, I began to feel as if I'd been temporarily mesmerized by his eloquence. The young Hitler was a poorly educated and deeply frustrated man who cobbled together what he considered to be a scientific justification for his ultra-nationalist, ultra-militarist, revanchist views. The philosophical worldview that Snyder summarizes here is not just unpolitical (as Snyder acknowledges), but in many respects also glaringly absurd and unattractive even to other far-right German nationalists, who surely regarded Germany's mission in loftier terms than a biological struggle to get as fat as the Americans. Hitler's kooky personal philosophy obviously had something to do with the Holocaust, but it's crazy to offer it as a sufficient explanation of such a world-historical event. A ton of context has gone missing from Snyder's analysis.
Hi framing of Hitler remarks on the ottoman cleansing of Armenians around ww1 years being more about his plans to detroy the national identity of the non Jewish poles rang true although as he rues he would yearn to have more insight to Hitler's mindset related to that quote noted by only one of the generals at the meeting with Hitler when he said it
Apparently, in his philosophy, A.H. forgot that India, China, and Japan, among others (accounting for >60% of the world's population) independently developed complex flourishing societies with rules and politics and religions all of their own devising and independent of Mediterranean and European influence. Kind of pokes a little hole in the world domination theory of a small group of people who put their laws down in a scroll in the Levant region of Syria after the Romans destroyed their temple two thousand years ago. But... whatever.
Crazy this 2013 line of thinking got little political traction then but especially crazy only gradually coming to the fore a few years after soul searching of the 2016 brexit and trump and subsequent
Hello : interesting lecture , I recently finished reading ( Against our better judgement ) by (Alison Weir) Downloaded in to from Amazon to my Kindle If what she says is true . My country America lost 200,000 men in ww1, a war that Wilson had promised to keep us out of . Well read the book and we can discuss this. I want a civil discussion and let's keep it to the facts.
Imagine scoring a seat here and bringing your laptop so that you can check emails or watch videos of cats. I appreciate that the speaker called out the audience member.
Maybe they are doing this for someone else as a job and don't have incentives to do better, Rms Of? Some professor, I think, called those "bullshit jobs."
@@coreycox2345 David Graeber. Great, sadly late, thinker.
He taught us a course of Eastern Europe since 1914 in one week. It was a knowledge boom!!
I wonder if the best historians do that and write it at a grade 6 reading level, Hicham El-Ouali? That may be the best reading level for the masses. Grade 6 may be the mean. We get this, but wouldn't it be great if more people got it too?
I knew he was a geographer, Hicham El-Ouali!
This sounds politically incorrect and may be anecdotal, Hicha, El-Quali. It was probably a coincidence, but out of all those planners, five were essential. Three of them were Jews.
I just realized that even our thinking has a geography. :) Hitler was such a competent terrorist that he included a logic legal system. Yikes.
unlike most professors, thee man is genuinely learned.
BE SURE TO MIC AUDIENCE QUESTIONS
Great Speaker
In this and other snyder lectures his insight on the dual meaning of what used to be dismissed disdainfully as elbow space redefined as a more complex fear/want of habitat and relative comfort to others is profoundly important nut to grasp towards greater understanding
in times of inhumanity, we have no words
we have only each other
Talk starts 7:30
I wish everybody would learn about the subject it's so important for us to know the history of the Holocaust I tried to share what I know which after hours of watching documentaries I realize I know very little I went to Decca when I lived in Germany and I was shocked and amazed but it tweaked my curiosity to where I made it my aim to learn as much as I could but Mr Snyder has opened up so many more doors of knowledge for me thank you to Mr Schneider for sharing his knowledge with the world Darlene g duck
I misspelled dachau d. Duck.
I once learned a lot about the Holocaust to detract from my feelings, Darlene Duck.
This is fascinating!
Starts at 7:17.
41:16- I was listening to this and had twitter on and saw something funny there... what timing
the nerve of some students , huh?
1:16:00 question cricism is on point yet if one can understand that snyder has painted a start that needs to be pursued further i think that is an enormous contribution of the book... framing a context to understand why hitler resonated on a level or thinking more rational than the other or fear ... the premise that it might actually be cultural approaches to reason and behavior that set up an order of human cooperation not well suited for some must be pursued but so close the the flame of blaming the victim that critical sort of discourse to tease out truth by trial and error of peer review is all but banned
Wow, great lecture.
I've been listening to his courses, thanks for his knowledge.
41:14 - quite awkward!
There will be changes in how to remember history. It always was happening in history.
We must not let any thing like this happen again.
May Allah bless the victims soles in paradise.
47:11 bruh
obviously hitler's words, calm down
This is so excellent.
Thank you.
Prof. Snyder is always fascinating to listen to, but here I'm afraid that here he's smoothly leading us down the garden path. In fact, after reflecting about this for a while, I began to feel as if I'd been temporarily mesmerized by his eloquence. The young Hitler was a poorly educated and deeply frustrated man who cobbled together what he considered to be a scientific justification for his ultra-nationalist, ultra-militarist, revanchist views. The philosophical worldview that Snyder summarizes here is not just unpolitical (as Snyder acknowledges), but in many respects also glaringly absurd and unattractive even to other far-right German nationalists, who surely regarded Germany's mission in loftier terms than a biological struggle to get as fat as the Americans. Hitler's kooky personal philosophy obviously had something to do with the Holocaust, but it's crazy to offer it as a sufficient explanation of such a world-historical event. A ton of context has gone missing from Snyder's analysis.
Wonderful knowledge shared with passion
Thinking about nukes means you are destroying yourself and nothing.
Hi framing of Hitler remarks on the ottoman cleansing of Armenians around ww1 years being more about his plans to detroy the national identity of the non Jewish poles rang true although as he rues he would yearn to have more insight to Hitler's mindset related to that quote noted by only one of the generals at the meeting with Hitler when he said it
Apparently, in his philosophy, A.H. forgot that India, China, and Japan, among others (accounting for >60% of the world's population) independently developed complex flourishing societies with rules and politics and religions all of their own devising and independent of Mediterranean and European influence. Kind of pokes a little hole in the world domination theory of a small group of people who put their laws down in a scroll in the Levant region of Syria after the Romans destroyed their temple two thousand years ago. But... whatever.
This lecture helps answer the question, why a master race had so much to fear of the Jews that its leaders insisted on their genocide.
Crazy this 2013 line of thinking got little political traction then but especially crazy only gradually coming to the fore a few years after soul searching of the 2016 brexit and trump and subsequent
Hello : interesting lecture ,
I recently finished reading ( Against our better judgement ) by (Alison Weir)
Downloaded in to from Amazon to my Kindle
If what she says is true .
My country America lost 200,000 men in ww1, a war that Wilson had promised to keep us out of .
Well read the book and we can discuss this.
I want a civil discussion and let's keep it to the facts.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND ITS CITIZENS VS. nwo
USA is the nwo since 1942
Americans weren't obese a century ago.