I discovered this back in 2010 and was my first fx video. I remember being shook by Sulli's visuals and loved her voice. She was my bias in fx and stopped paying attention to them when she left. She was a strong and brave woman - thanks for your contribution to the world.
This is like the wild side of the sweet innocent SNSD version. From sweet and innocent to dark and daring... Freaking cool for being just a phone promotion xD.
I really like the idea of white SNSD and black f(x) so much. They have the same song but has different concepts. F(x) actually has brilliant concept too bad the company focus more to SNSD back then.
lily yellow I love SNSD and f(x) equally but because SNSD was their most popular girl group (especially the clash between their Gee comeback and f(x)’s debut, they were popular but not as popular as SNSD). Although this was a business matter, it also meant that f(x) was being overshadowed:,)
f(x) was always left aside, the fandom just got named 7 years after debut, same for getting concerts. I dont even know why SM created them 'cause they never cared for them. Such a waste, f(x) was the most unique one and full of talent.
It is. SM has something to do with the schedule in China, or hasnt it? Tbh Im not sure. But Im just reminded when Victoria said that she would leave f(x) when she is 30, now shes 31.
In 2014 *before* Sulli left. So if Sulli was in the group it would be f(4) anyways. But dont worry, sjhe didnt leave. Shes 31 now and stayed because Sulli left and because f(x) still want to be a group. But I cant be happy about this because its still f(4) and no Sulli :(
Mr Boogie is also one of their sexiest songs, I wish Amber wasnt injured during the time they were promoting that song because I wanted to see her do the choreography.
People always complain about Amber never breaking out of her tomboy shell but let's never forget the skin tight pants and stomach bearing top she wore for Chocolate Love. It was probably very out of her comfort zone but damn she looks awesome
에스엠 아이돌은 완벽하다라는 이미지를 갖게 한 건 에프엑스 때문이었던 것 같음.. 사실은 통틀어서 봤을 때 에스엠은 외모와 자본력이지라는 생각 밖에 안 드는데, 에프엑스 활동 시기 동안만 에스엠에 대한 이미지는 완벽이었음. 그래서 에프엑스 말고는 늘 왜 좀 아쉽지..?라는 생각이 들었던 것 같음. 에프엑스가 노래도 좋았고 외모도 탑이었지만 안무와 춤태도 한몫 함.. 큰 동작이 있는 것도 아닌데 복잡하지만 절도 있는 안무를 멤버들이 트렌디하게 소화했다고 해야 하나.. 다들 몸 리듬감이나 춤선이 너무 좋아서 잘 소화했음.. 지금까지 나온 아이돌들 모두 춤을 전부 잘 추지만.. 에프엑스 느낌은 아님..
Luna is honestly so amazing she's got such an incredible voice but doesn't get the recognition she deserves she is so so talented she invented vocals ❤💕
Kayla I think it was originally from SNSD and you can see the differences clearly from the outfits, musics, sets,etc. Example fx version have a rap verse and SNSD have it as a dance break.
this was nearly a britney spears song apparently, the demo of this song (to my knowledge) is a continuation or a reworking of another demo for the song "sweet dreams my LA ex", originally called "phony lullaby". plus the song was also given to brooke valentine under the name "blah blah blah". girls generation also had a cover of the song, they're another korean pop group
can everyone stop comparing SNSD and f(x)?Both SNSD and f(x) are great groups and they each have their different types of styles so the music is most likelygoing to change to fit each group better. so please stop comparing. some of us are SNSD and f(x) fans
@@MorainStaria I see. I was referring to former member Sulli. She passed away back in October. I kind of understand where you are coming from, but I personally don't let toxic fans get in the way of anything that I like. Unfortunately there are toxic fans no matter the fandom so I just ignore them. I am curious as to how you found this video since you don't like K-Pop. YT recommendations?
still can't believe SM gave f(x) the sexy/dark version of Chocolate Love instead of giving it to SNSD when f(x) literally were all minors except for Victoria during this time, Sulli was literally 15 here, and Krystal was 14(Chocolate Love was released 3 days before her birthday, October 24)
Yes!!! It's so weird. All of them were minors except for Victoria; Amber was 17, Luna was 16, Sulli was 15 and Krystal was 14. It just comes off as so creepy and such a weird choice
@@jeshellecerbito6697 it's not about the music styles or concepts, it's about how sm sexualized freaking minors. Kpop companies in general should really stop sexualizing their groups male or female and make them do music that is appropriate for their age
@@zizi2251 sexy and sexualization are two different things, at least on my perspective. A person or group can do a sexy concept but the sexualization is the decision of the viewers/fans. To me, I see five women who are mature enough to handle this concept.
Fun fact, this song (along with SNSD's version) were both produced by Bloodshy and Avant. They produced Britney's Toxic, so I'm not surprised at how impeccable both version are.
If it was these days they shoud have been aespa type of group, but even with the comparison they were completeley different of all mainstream kpop because they were so innovative and experimental... so unique
I love both versions lol i always heard snsd version over years till now i found f(x)'s version where the heck was i ??? Both r amazing snsd cute concept F(x) hot concept and amber's rrap is a huuge bonus Asdfghjj
Rookie f(x) 😭😭😭😭 I'm crying.... this MV is turning 10 years old soon just like my babies. They were such babies back then, & now they are fine gorgeous ladies in the industry 💜💜💜😭
f(x) is one of the best kpop groups of SM, it hurts that they do not know how to value that, they have already passed several years and still do not return, they have abandoned them ... They give more attention to new groups like Red velvet, instead of f(x) that there really is talent in this group :(♥
It's not really SM's fault at this point.Not only that but MeUs in general aren't that strong. They support their own bias but not the group. While f(X) is respect, they're not domestically popular. That's what SM cares about, domestic popularity. MeUs let Luna flop even though she was the most talented because she didn't meet Korea's beauty standards. MeUs let Amber flop even though she's the most creative, her talking shit about SM isn't helping her. SM has to stop taking chances at some point. Krystal is more valuable as an actress and Victoria is more valuable releasing her music and acting in China. F(X) is just more valuable apart than together
This was the first mv i saw of f(x) and immediately fell in love with their visuals, styles and voices. I remember being mesmerized by the visuals of Victoria and Krystal especially. Since then I became a meu to this day. 💜 hope one day f(x) can reunite and make a group comeback, without the corruption of SM of course. 😅😂
I loved this concept. Both versions were amazing. And Luna better get that shit. I love when they are actually given good choreo. Let's hope that they do not lose momentum with the success of 4 Walls and their solo concert tour. Let's expand
Fact: The original song of this is Topbillin' Love the 2nd demo for Sweet Dreams My LA Ex but was rejected by Britney and Rachel so it was later given to Brooke Valentine's for her First Album the Title is "BLAH BLAH BLAH" and years later the korean group changed some Stuff and instrumental and the lyrics but not the way they sang it and it's now the masterpiece we have today
Amber Liu. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at this time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and Happy Birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can! We adore you so much and never give up on your once-in-a-lifetime artistry. Be safe, and praying for the happiness and health of you and your loved ones always.
I've been known Sulli since she was a little girl - standing among Kangta and Lee Soo Man in Smtown's party. Until she was a member of f(x) and this is their first music video I watched also. This is so touching...I wish in another world she could do everything she wants and receive more love from people because she deserves.
SNSD take feminine, gorgeous and elegant side while f(x) take energetic and quirky side. I just wonder how if Red Velvet join this project too kkk. Calm and mature if they use velvet concept, but it can be cheerfull if they take red side
Not every girl is uncomfortable about things like this at this age. At their age I know many girls that would have been totally comfortable. I really hate when people automatically think that they're "forced" and "uncomfortable" and "helpless" just because they are girls. Girls can be strong at that age and like this concept.
@@Raphael-2 but they were minors at that time, even if they feel comfortable it's not ok. this feels like those things some "adults" says to minors , the typical "you're so mature for your age, you dont look like 14"
@@Ana-ug6es Well I disagree and I want to reply with exactly what I previously said. We must stop underestimate and ovefprotect girls like that in my opinion.
Dear SM, why is f(x) the only artists currently under contract with you that don't have their channel listed on the SMTOWN youtube homepage? In the column on the right there is EXO, Red Velvet, NCT, NCT 127, NCT Dream, Super Junior, TVXQ, Girls Generation and BoA, but not f(x).
i love this version of chocolate love. i love the styling of fx in the video. please put amber back in outfits similar, she rocked it. fx would do well this visual dark sleek concept again.
이거 쥬니어네이버에서 소녀시대 버전 vs 에프엑스 버전 투표했었는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ추억이다ㅠㅠ
이ᄆ임 소시압승이엿죠 싸이언 초콜릿폰 ..ㅠㅠ
ㅁㅊㅠㅠㅠㅠ 10년만에 살아난 기억....
다들 소시를 외칠때 난 엪엑 버전을 외쳤다구.. 도입부 크리스탈부터 발려버렸고 빅토리아 존예..
와 이거 나만 기억하는게 아니였네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
@@Iqeudbehehbd8 어쩔수 없었죠ㅠㅠ 소시가 경력도 있었고 인기가 넘 많았음 ㅠㅠ
11 years passed and i still remember all the lyrics and adlibs 😌😭
Same haha! 😆
In both versions even haha
SAME
Same 😂
@@LaylaUnicornlover101-bd3qx hopefully your mother after birthing someone like you…
Lets be honest, you search this because miss them so much
The reason why I come here is because SM is going to debuting new GG and I kinda feel f(x) vibes in their intro 😂👍🏻
Kangen banget 😭
Jaman awal kuliah. Lebih suka yg versi fx daripada snsd
Fix orang indo
@@muhammadnawfalaqeel4849 LMAO don't compare F(x) to anyone else .. sorry i respect Asepa but F(x) is on another level
그때 당시에 똑같은 노래인데 편곡을 다르게 해서 다른 그룹이 곡을 낸다는게 너무 신기했음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 핸드폰 CF 노래지만.. 개인적으로 편곡이 에펙버전이 더 좋음
so so 마자요 완전 동감
마자요 진짜
그당시 뭐랄까 밀크초콜릿(소녀시대) 랑 다크초코(Fx)느낌이었음
@@user-KkOoRrEeAa 생각해보니 진짜 그런느낌ㅋㅋㅋ
천상지희 버전하고 레드벨벳 버전도 나왔으면 하는 전형적인 슴덕 추가요
“8 years ago” why does that break my heart a little?
why does 4 walls take my heart
why does sulli take my heart
why does this 3 years no comeback take my heart
I hate SM, pls give some love to f(x)
Why dose Sulli have to leave f(x)?
how about join fx again Sulli ? im so sad reading this
Blueberry Had a scandal Sulli is dating :((((
Both versions are awesome tbh
agreed
I have seen one. Ya I haven't. You have tbh
So true
f(x)'s one is better bc of that Amber's "yOU anD I"
I agree
소녀시대가 밀크초콜릿이였으면
에프엑스는 다크초콜릿이였음.
따봉 유투브 알고리즘아 고마워!
오랜만에 추억여행이였다.
ㅇㅈ
술 들어간 초콜렛이 딱맞음
@Youna Lee 레몬초콜릿 - 보아
봉봉오쇼콜라 - 천상지희
밀크초콜릿 - 소녀시대
다크초콜릿 - 에프엑스
레드벨벳초콜릿 - 레드벨벳
이게 맞는 듯
@@franz0812 에스파는 뭔 초콜릿이여
@@door_seokite 슈팅스타
I discovered this back in 2010 and was my first fx video. I remember being shook by Sulli's visuals and loved her voice. She was my bias in fx and stopped paying attention to them when she left. She was a strong and brave woman - thanks for your contribution to the world.
safslut01 same I’m heartbroken 😔
same, my first fx music video
Same. I really liked 4Walls though but it felt empty without her
This is like the wild side of the sweet innocent SNSD version. From sweet and innocent to dark and daring... Freaking cool for being just a phone promotion xD.
What's kind of creepy is that 4/5 of them (except Victoria) were 14-15-16 years old when they filmed this...
@@MorainStaria 17. Sorry.
It reminds me of twice and itzy :o
sandra sofia itzy is still cute, they just aren’t as direct about it
@@joe8551 yeah, but I can't help but feel that they're f(x) inspired
PLEASE, GIVE F(X) A COMEBACK!!!
It’s not happening unfortunately😢
Still one of my favorite songs for both groups.
A tip: you can watch series at Flixzone. Been using them for watching a lot of movies lately.
@Quinton Andre Yup, been watching on Flixzone} for years myself =)
@Quinton Andre Definitely, I have been watching on Flixzone} for years myself =)
@Quinton Andre Yup, been watching on flixzone} for since december myself :)
yeah one of the best songs from fx
좋은곳에서 편히쉬자 설리.. 잘지내
When Jessica see the behind door and look at her little sister...
*SHE SPEECHLESS*
GOLDENSONESxREVELUVxBUDDYxMeUxBLINK Fan I guess you were referring to Yoona. 😊 It wasn't Jessica
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
the thing is Yoona looks like Krystals and Jessica like SinB
I really like the idea of white SNSD and black f(x) so much. They have the same song but has different concepts.
F(x) actually has brilliant concept too bad the company focus more to SNSD back then.
Leoni Maretha How did you know? 🙃
Because they didn't sell much like Snsd, you know business?
lily yellow I love SNSD and f(x) equally but because SNSD was their most popular girl group (especially the clash between their Gee comeback and f(x)’s debut, they were popular but not as popular as SNSD). Although this was a business matter, it also meant that f(x) was being overshadowed:,)
@@neon09 true (〒﹏〒)
f(x) was always left aside, the fandom just got named 7 years after debut, same for getting concerts. I dont even know why SM created them 'cause they never cared for them. Such a waste, f(x) was the most unique one and full of talent.
에프엑스 보구싶다 .. 사실 케이팝 역사에 길이남을 그룹이라고!! 핑크테이프 레전드 앨범ㅇ..을 내가 왜 못 샀을까...
i don't need a phone, and i don't like old technology but i just bought 50 of these things because of this video. someone help me.
I don’t think they sell these phones anymore lol
How did you manage to buy 50? The LG Chocolate BL40 is discontinued??? stop lying lol..
흑sunny yes they don’t
I don't really like this era of cell phones, slide phones are nah, it's flip phones or go home. I love this song tho
@@lemons2300 This phone was a touchphone tho...
COMEBACK FOR F(X) !!!
Cowboy looks pretty recent. CORRECT ME IF IM WRONG, but Cowboy to me looks a couple weeks old.
COMEBACK FOR FX AND SULLI TO FX!!!!!
It is. SM has something to do with the schedule in China, or hasnt it? Tbh Im not sure. But Im just reminded when Victoria said that she would leave f(x) when she is 30, now shes 31.
wait when did Victoria said that? :(
In 2014 *before* Sulli left. So if Sulli was in the group it would be f(4) anyways. But dont worry, sjhe didnt leave. Shes 31 now and stayed because Sulli left and because f(x) still want to be a group. But I cant be happy about this because its still f(4) and no Sulli :(
This is the sexiest concept ive seen from f(x) and Amber now I can die in happiness
Mr Boogie is also one of their sexiest songs, I wish Amber wasnt injured during the time they were promoting that song because I wanted to see her do the choreography.
but now... we have *Other People*
Rip my beautiful Sulli. I can’t believe I’m actually writing this
SM은 fx진짜 돌려내ㅜㅜㅜ 이렇게 유니크한 걸그룹을 왜 가만히 썩혀
People always complain about Amber never breaking out of her tomboy shell but let's never forget the skin tight pants and stomach bearing top she wore for Chocolate Love. It was probably very out of her comfort zone but damn she looks awesome
Why UA-cam recommends this video now? Lol btw this song is still so good
Me too 😆
funny. me too. But i already knew this song. Sm trash here 😂
im confused too
That's what I'm saying I only got this recommended after sullis death
@@Kai-th5sf same here.. i have sulli and fx everywhere on my recommendation, i'm crying
오늘도 알 수 없는 유튜브 알고리즘이 날 여기로 데려왔다,,,
한수정 헐 저도 몇일전부터 계속 뜨길래 봐버렸서....
아니 이 알고리즘은.... 대단하다 혹시 우리집 보셨나요
에스엠 아이돌은 완벽하다라는 이미지를 갖게 한 건 에프엑스 때문이었던 것 같음.. 사실은 통틀어서 봤을 때 에스엠은 외모와 자본력이지라는 생각 밖에 안 드는데, 에프엑스 활동 시기 동안만 에스엠에 대한 이미지는 완벽이었음. 그래서 에프엑스 말고는 늘 왜 좀 아쉽지..?라는 생각이 들었던 것 같음. 에프엑스가 노래도 좋았고 외모도 탑이었지만 안무와 춤태도 한몫 함.. 큰 동작이 있는 것도 아닌데 복잡하지만 절도 있는 안무를 멤버들이 트렌디하게 소화했다고 해야 하나.. 다들 몸 리듬감이나 춤선이 너무 좋아서 잘 소화했음.. 지금까지 나온 아이돌들 모두 춤을 전부 잘 추지만.. 에프엑스 느낌은 아님..
ㅜㅜ진짜요 😢
*Sulli* You will be forever missed 1994-2019♡
I remember when the Chocolate was like the coolest phone ever. f(x) totally owned this rendition!
왜 이게 갑자기 추천 영상에 뜨는거여ㅋㄲㅋㅋㅋ
저만 그런게 아니군요....
@@untitle8408 ㅋㅋㅋ 귀여우심ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
추억이다....☆
추억팔이 하라고 그런가봐요 ㅋㅋㅋ
I'm sad how underrated this song is. I don't see many MeUs or Sones talking about this Bop
we have returned to 2009 thx SM
edit: this was a joke comment I forgot I even made but thanks for the likes lol and SM can choke for letting f(x) rot!
ew dont thank to this ugly entertainment SM doesnt deserve a thank you
look how they treat f(x) and Sulli
yap...that's true
I miss Sulli
I really miss Sulli!😭😭
Sorry for my girls because have a bad of bad of bad company like SM :((((((
Meu wants f(x) comeback.
We want f(5) comeback
난 에프엑스 버전이 더 좋았음.. 다시 들어야겠다 띵곡ㅠㅠ
갑자기 이게 왜 뜨지... 알고리즘 진짜 알수없다ㅠ 에프엑스는 솔직히 첫사랑니갑....
헐 에프엑스 버전 초콜릿 러브도 있었네...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이제 알음
hahaha. there is another version of this mv🤙🏻
I appreciate that random Amber solo dance at 2:59
진짜 대단하다 멤버중에 네명이 미자였는데 저런 느낌을 내다니 재능...
Luna is honestly so amazing she's got such an incredible voice but doesn't get the recognition she deserves she is so so talented she invented vocals ❤💕
WE MISS F(X) QUEENS 😭💔
F(5) :(((
this version of chocolate love is so good but the girls generation version is also good as well
HT H i agree, both are good in their own way
HT H what is the different? And whose song is this actually?
Kayla I think it was originally from SNSD and you can see the differences clearly from the outfits, musics, sets,etc. Example fx version have a rap verse and SNSD have it as a dance break.
Kayla this song is made for LG Chocolate phone series
but why they sing it the two of the bands
I can't believe sulli and krystal was only 15 here -.-
ok
they were so young though :(
Krystal was 14...
this was nearly a britney spears song apparently, the demo of this song (to my knowledge) is a continuation or a reworking of another demo for the song "sweet dreams my LA ex", originally called "phony lullaby". plus the song was also given to brooke valentine under the name "blah blah blah". girls generation also had a cover of the song, they're another korean pop group
woahh that's why this sounded very much like a Britney Spears song
can everyone stop comparing SNSD and f(x)?Both SNSD and f(x) are great groups and they each have their different types of styles so the music is most likelygoing to change to fit each group better. so please stop comparing. some of us are SNSD and f(x) fans
I’m in disbelief. I wish this was just a cruel nightmare...
s.coups d'etat 😢😢😢
Me too
@@MorainStaria Because of our beloved Peach
@@MorainStaria I see. I was referring to former member Sulli. She passed away back in October.
I kind of understand where you are coming from, but I personally don't let toxic fans get in the way of anything that I like. Unfortunately there are toxic fans no matter the fandom so I just ignore them. I am curious as to how you found this video since you don't like K-Pop. YT recommendations?
Gelynn Then don’t. Just enjoy the music.
still can't believe SM gave f(x) the sexy/dark version of Chocolate Love instead of giving it to SNSD when f(x) literally were all minors except for Victoria during this time, Sulli was literally 15 here, and Krystal was 14(Chocolate Love was released 3 days before her birthday, October 24)
Yes!!! It's so weird. All of them were minors except for Victoria; Amber was 17, Luna was 16, Sulli was 15 and Krystal was 14. It just comes off as so creepy and such a weird choice
It was their music style. Both were different colors of sexy, but still sexy. It's just that f(x) has the electro pop sound.
@@jeshellecerbito6697 it's not about the music styles or concepts, it's about how sm sexualized freaking minors. Kpop companies in general should really stop sexualizing their groups male or female and make them do music that is appropriate for their age
@@zizi2251 sexy and sexualization are two different things, at least on my perspective. A person or group can do a sexy concept but the sexualization is the decision of the viewers/fans. To me, I see five women who are mature enough to handle this concept.
@@jeshellecerbito6697 you shouldn’t be sexually attractive to anyone when you’re a literal child you weirdo
i'd love to see nmixx and itzy doing something like this, a contrast between two groups from the same company and generation.
Itzy would do the bright concept and Nmixx would do the dark
Fun fact, this song (along with SNSD's version) were both produced by Bloodshy and Avant. They produced Britney's Toxic, so I'm not surprised at how impeccable both version are.
I miss them. I miss fx. I miss them so much. They are the bestest.
All LG chocolate series cellphone commercial MV this is the best for me 🖤🖤🖤
이 노래 아직도 매일 듣는 사람은 나밖에 없겠지..
한 2주전부터 매일 떠서 듣는 중...
여기도 숨듣명 생존자
저두 플리에 아직도 있어요! 띵곡ㅠㅠㅠ
띵띵곡
여기 한명 추가요
i miss my girls. there is no one doing it like them in kpop
11 years later and i'm here again, this era was fireee
불과 10여년만에 진짜 세상이 어마어마하게 바뀌었다...
와 10년전 실화...? 얽ㅠㅠㅠ
소녀시대버전이랑 다른 느낌이어서 좋았음
특히 뭔가 엠버 랩부분이 최애엿음
I personally like this version better because I like f(x)'s voices when they sing all together
저 때 설리 크리스탈이 지금 장원영 나이네
와... 진짜,,? 근데 포스가 다르긴하다.. 컨셉때매그런가 같은나인댄데 원영인 귀여운느낌인데 클설은 성숙한느낌 ㅋㅋ
약간 시대가 추구하는게 바뀜 저때는 어린애들한테 어른?처럼 섹시컨셉으로 벗기거나 킬힐에 화장진한메이크업이었는데 테니스스커트 유행때쯤부터 학생컨셉 컬러풀한 색깔에 한뼘정되되는 옷입고 성인이 교복입고나옴
웍을 들어라 장위엔잉!
와 진짜 어릴때 데뷔했구나.....
A Reum Kim 둘다 약간 이상하넼키0
If it was these days they shoud have been aespa type of group, but even with the comparison they were completeley different of all mainstream kpop because they were so innovative and experimental... so unique
Ok but if sm doesnt do this again with rv and their New girl group then what its even the point 😂
This one supports a comment here that Sm should've gave f(x) some love instead of overshadowing them by comebacks of other ggs on almost same dates.
@@chemikaela9133 I dont understand you comment man
I doubt that will happen.
people would get SO pressed but i would love that because they could combine and have an odd number of people for the dance
now that we have aespa i would absolutley love this and hope for interactions!
PLEASE COMEBACK PLEASE!!!
I love both versions lol i always heard snsd version over years till now i found f(x)'s version where the heck was i ???
Both r amazing snsd cute concept
F(x) hot concept and amber's rrap is a huuge bonus
Asdfghjj
+souadhassani hassani me too. I didn't know fx has a version too
I only find out know
300万再生おめでとう❗
曲調もメンバーのビジュもセクシーで大好き♡
ビクトリアの重めの前髪もすごく好き
La nostalgia me invadió y ahora estoy con un maratón con canciones de F(x) 😭😭
Rookie f(x) 😭😭😭😭 I'm crying.... this MV is turning 10 years old soon just like my babies. They were such babies back then, & now they are fine gorgeous ladies in the industry 💜💜💜😭
f(x) is one of the best kpop groups of SM, it hurts that they do not know how to value that, they have already passed several years and still do not return, they have abandoned them ... They give more attention to new groups like Red velvet, instead of f(x) that there really is talent in this group :(♥
It's not really SM's fault at this point.Not only that but MeUs in general aren't that strong. They support their own bias but not the group. While f(X) is respect, they're not domestically popular. That's what SM cares about, domestic popularity. MeUs let Luna flop even though she was the most talented because she didn't meet Korea's beauty standards. MeUs let Amber flop even though she's the most creative, her talking shit about SM isn't helping her. SM has to stop taking chances at some point. Krystal is more valuable as an actress and Victoria is more valuable releasing her music and acting in China. F(X) is just more valuable apart than together
@Sulli
I know right. 😡
I feel like between the snsd version and this version, this one just seems more natural. f(x) owned this song.
난 에펙버전 더 좋아했음ㅋㅋㅋ
저도요! 뭔가 중독성 있어요.
저도 에프엑스 버전 더 좋아했어요!!오랜만에 들으니 반갑네요>_
엠버 랩파트 지림
저두
This was the first mv i saw of f(x) and immediately fell in love with their visuals, styles and voices. I remember being mesmerized by the visuals of Victoria and Krystal especially. Since then I became a meu to this day. 💜 hope one day f(x) can reunite and make a group comeback, without the corruption of SM of course. 😅😂
Amber's hair from this era was really quite something 💖💖💖
I love this version. F(x) has something especial for me. Love them so much. I miss this days.
Today, Krystal reportedly leaving SM and I'm here watching all f(x)'s MVs. Am I allowed to cry?
Don't feel so bad i miss them as f(5)
I loved this concept. Both versions were amazing. And Luna better get that shit. I love when they are actually given good choreo. Let's hope that they do not lose momentum with the success of 4 Walls and their solo concert tour. Let's expand
eyeliner is a important thing on korean makeup look at that time🤣
Hi, MeU! Luna's new song "After This Night Is Over" released. You can find by writting "LUNA&UL feat Danny Jung" on UA-cam's search button
sm forgot about this song but my soul can’t
Fact:
The original song of this is Topbillin' Love the 2nd demo for Sweet Dreams My LA Ex but was rejected by Britney and Rachel so it was later given to Brooke Valentine's for her First Album the Title is "BLAH BLAH BLAH" and years later the korean group changed some Stuff and instrumental and the lyrics but not the way they sang it and it's now the masterpiece we have today
Amber Liu. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at this time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and Happy Birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can! We adore you so much and never give up on your once-in-a-lifetime artistry. Be safe, and praying for the happiness and health of you and your loved ones always.
I will remember U forever...
F(x) version is a bop sorry not sorry 💅
I completely agree
They had such a unique sound I will forever listen to their music the members were great love forever fox and our angel Sulli
Sulli was one of my biases of fx, rest in peace beautiful. You didnt deserve it 😢
I've been known Sulli since she was a little girl - standing among Kangta and Lee Soo Man in Smtown's party. Until she was a member of f(x) and this is their first music video I watched also. This is so touching...I wish in another world she could do everything she wants and receive more love from people because she deserves.
*It's 2023 and this song remains legend🛐❤️🔥*
One of the most unique releases of pop music and it's for a phone, unreal.
11年前にf(x)にどハマりしてとくにこれ好きでずっと聴いてたのを急にふと思い出して聴きにきました………
SNSD take feminine, gorgeous and elegant side while f(x) take energetic and quirky side. I just wonder how if Red Velvet join this project too kkk. Calm and mature if they use velvet concept, but it can be cheerfull if they take red side
Wait I didn’t know this exist before, I have only listened to gg’s retro pop version😂
Me too 😂
I feel like this song/video basically epitomized f(x). They were edgier than their sister group SNSD and gave off a different feel
If f(x) doesn't make a comeback in 2018 (or at all) I'm quitting kpop 😭 They're my ult
Neulei same
How are you doing now?😅
@@yuikorj96 Haha! Still listen to kpop but not as active as I used to be. And I'm not really listening to newer groups.
They're so little and just babies. Can't believe this was 10 years ago.
Imagine how uncomfortable the girls felt.. 4/5 were minors 😐
Oh this is NOTHING compared to groups debuting in the 3rd & 4th gen.
@@fiat4930 really? could you give some examples?
Not every girl is uncomfortable about things like this at this age. At their age I know many girls that would have been totally comfortable. I really hate when people automatically think that they're "forced" and "uncomfortable" and "helpless" just because they are girls. Girls can be strong at that age and like this concept.
@@Raphael-2 but they were minors at that time, even if they feel comfortable it's not ok.
this feels like those things some "adults" says to minors , the typical "you're so mature for your age, you dont look like 14"
@@Ana-ug6es Well I disagree and I want to reply with exactly what I previously said. We must stop underestimate and ovefprotect girls like that in my opinion.
sm, what are you doing? You only care for your new groups F(X) IS STILL FAME
give them a comeback!! please!!!
i miss sulli my love
Dear SM, why is f(x) the only artists currently under contract with you that don't have their channel listed on the SMTOWN youtube homepage? In the column on the right there is EXO, Red Velvet, NCT, NCT 127, NCT Dream, Super Junior, TVXQ, Girls Generation and BoA, but not f(x).
When I saw the intro, I thought I watched the wrong group xD I didn't know SNSD has sung this earlier than f(x)
진짜 저시절에는 폰 디자인 다양해서 재밌었는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
SM might as well create a Chocolate Love Red Velvet version. Hmm ballad version perhaps? Thumbs up!
벌써 12년 전 노래라니.. 오랜만에 들어도 좋다ㅠㅠ
And I am back 🖤
14 years later, this is still an iconic bop. happy 14th anniversary, f(x) 💜💜💜
i love this version of chocolate love. i love the styling of fx in the video. please put amber back in outfits similar, she rocked it. fx would do well this visual dark sleek concept again.
rip sulli almost 6 month already i can't forget you😢
11 years later, I’m back here again to listen to this amazing song. I miss old KPOP.
이곡이 십년전이라는것이 놀랍다