OBS Studio Vs PolyPop Live Which is better?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- OBS Studio Vs PolyPop Live. Which is better?
OBS Studio is free, and its an awesome live streaming tool. It's the de facto streaming tool in fact. But can a new free software compete?
Today I compare OBS Studio and newcomer PolyPop Live. PolyPop is a really cool new 3D based live streaming tool that is free to use as well.
They stack up pretty well in some areas and not so well in others. I cover the pros and cons of each one and which is better right now.
Sponsor:
Own3d Pro ►► own3d.gg/michae...
Own3d TV ►► own3d.gg/michae...
OBS Studio: obsproject.com/
PolyPop Live ►► bit.ly/PolyPop...
#OBSStudio #Streaming #Tutoriel #LiveStreaming #UA-camForBusiness
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Channel Sponsors.
Envato Placeit ►► 1.envato.marke...
StreemTunes ►► bit.ly/StreemT...
Douwan ►► bit.ly/scDouWan
Own3d Pro ►► own3d.gg/michae...
Own3d TV ►► own3d.gg/michae...
PolyPop Live ►► bit.ly/PolyPop...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Support the channel.
NerdOrDie ►► nerdordie.com/...
Streamyard ►► streamyard.com...
Restream Studio ►► restream.grsm....
Envato PlaceIt ►► 1.envato.marke...
Envato Elements ►► 1.envato.marke...
Streamlabs Melon ►► talkstudio.str...
Patreon ►► / michaelfeyrerjr
TubeBuddy for free ►► www.tubebuddy....
Subscribe ►► / @michaelfeyrerjr
Website ►► michaelfeyrerj...
The Gear I use ►► michaelfeyrerj...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Live stream guests ►► • How To Live Stream Mul...
OBS and live streaming ►► • OBS Tutorials and live...
Live Streaming Tools ►► • Live streaming tools
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thanks For watching!
DISCLAIMER:
This description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links and buy a product, I receive a small commission.
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Your videos get better and better! In terms of editing, order, and pace, etc, it is obvious to me that you REALLY put attention and care into what you do here as you learn and apply what you show us over time and I for one appreciate it!
Questions about PolyPop (unless I missed them):
1. Is it open source?
2. If not, will it remain free?
3. Will it work on Linux distributions?
Great stuff. *SUBSCRIBED!*
I just want to know if it's as lightweight as OBS for the PC. That was the deciding factor between OBS and SLOBS for me since I have a lower end computer
I would like to know this too. Especially since their site says the alert interactions are created live & it has all those animations. I have very poor internet speeds so I need to keep my stream very simple from a bandwidth perspective.
I just ran a streaming test to compare. I set up 2 identical scenes (1 in OBS and 1 in polypop). Both had just a cam and a screen capture and stream output at 1080p. Here's the results:
OBS
===============
cpu: 2.2%
memory: 657 MB
GPU: 40%
Polypop
===============
cpu: 11%
memory: 313 MB
GPU: 35%
I've no doubt that if you add animate 3D elements to polypop it's going to use up more resources but I'll check that another time. Only just had my first coffee of the day ☕
@@ChrisWebDev Thanks for sharing these results. I'll stick with OBS for now. :)
And one more thing... It's easy to use. You can learn it fast and has a great support.
Also, this is for Windows ONLY. I run OBS / Streamelements on Mac. It'd be nice to have this as an alternative for MAC users too, but it's not the case.
Yet
@@MichaelFeyrerJr Do they have a Mac version coming?
Mac users get enough cool stuff.. WINDOWS ONLY 😅😅 J/K
I was expecting a harsher opinion of Polypop considering it is still beta and OBS has been in development for years. Kudos on being impartial and pointing out what is good about Polylpop. There is the capability to get the same functions as OBS move transitions by animating the camera object through the Action Sequence feature. Stinger Transitions just released 4/15 as well.
I was wondering how PolyPop stacked up. I am looking at this as an option now too! Thanks for sharing your insight as always!
Love your videos 😁 just found out you're a Ford CEO too. I guess you create some cool videos for Ford 😊
how taxing on your pc is polypop , when i get home from work think im gonna test it out
Here to learn waiting for a video on screen recording and editing on poly. That's the only thing with it being newer not much about it yet. Nothing about screenrecord yet
Damn shots fired on Netflix... Lol epic!
Thanks Michael! Another awesome product!
Thanks Dave.
Awesome review! Thanks for sharing! Have a great day!
Probably we can expect features in the Polypop will start to appear in OBS as plugins.
Maybe.
Seems like its only available for windows Is that correct? If so it would have been good to have mentioned this early on to save us Mac peeps some heartake 😉
Can you benchmark these two programs against each other to see which takes more resources?
No
@@MichaelFeyrerJr that’s okay, I already found my answer.
@@_B.C_ where did you find your answer? I'm wondering the same thing.
@@_B.C_ I tried Polypop briefly and if you have a few things going on, it soon gets a bit intensive.
That was a while back, so maybe they've worked on that in subsequent updates.
Both are great use them together!!!
I'm definitely going to have to check this out! What kind of camera would you typically use for when your streaming on Twitch?
Does it have the same massive fails? I hear streamers so often mentioning "OBS just crapped out on me," or "I got an unexpected, forced update right in the middle of trying to stream.."
I have never had that happen. But I actually test things to be sure they work before I use them live.
Oh no, subscription time again🏁
Ok, I've watched your videos and although you are thorough and clear, I am just unable to get OBS to work right for me, so is there something I can use to create live videos that also show screenshots which is easy and free?
Absolutly. OBS is probably the most difficult to learn of all the free ones. Prism live Studio would be what you should take a look at. I have a bunch of videos on it. Here is a playlist ua-cam.com/play/PLO4maup2s9t5q3JHRFYX6hTONDLjLeeD1.html
can you do screen capture with audio in it like you can with OBS although it is a bit of a faff from a DAW
Looks nice. No mac version yet :-(
thx.. why dont they mention this??
Does this use a lot of CPU power??
Not really.
excelent
Thanks
What are you using to build this video?
Obs to record, a camera, and an editor.
@@MichaelFeyrerJr What I suspected. TYVM
Does it have capabilities to stream to tiktok?
If they share the stream key anything can stream to it. I’m guessing they don’t.
We been waiting for this video , Thanks for the quick easy video and great review of the 2
YOU RULE!!!!
Glad to help.
thank you
Is there a list of your sponsors?
In the description. Under sponsors.
Transitions are actually available now and are pretty nice out of the box
Where can I download polypop please
Link in the description.
My only issue with polypop is; they dont support a capture card for 2 pc stream set up yet. Soon i hope
Does it support Zoom?
To do what?
@@MichaelFeyrerJr I have a hybrid class with people face to face and a few more online only, and I wanna put on a big Show for them
OBS is on Steam. Boom! Checkmate.
I checked it out, but way to dam complicated to use, OBS is bad enough 😕
It’s actually pretty easy.
Imma keep an eye on this, and once transitions are added, I may switch over. Although, considering how lazy I been in regards to switching from SLOBS to OBS, I also may not, lol.
I tried streamlabs and I didn’t like it 😊
Need a Mac version.
3 minutes later hmmm hi my yt friends
A quarter of this video is about sponsors 😂
Which one makes me look more like Brad Pitt
First comment ❤❤❤❤ {thank you}
12 fps
A alternative to obs you say? Intriguing, I enjoy your channel I've learned a lot thank you.
I just want to know if it's as lightweight as OBS for the PC. That was the deciding factor between OBS and SLOBS for me since I have a lower end computer
Importanter is CPU/GPU ussing
Streamlabs moroons 17% cpu/gpu inuse
StreamElements OBSlive Between 2% max 7% cpu/GPU use same PC lol.
Twitchstudio crap 20%
So far StreamElements the best option every.
Obs is the best option.
When using streamlabs my oc was using 50%+ CPU usage, OBS is using 7% what does this service use?
They are basically the same. The overlay and connections on streamlabs just have a lot of overhead. It is not well optimized.
Sorry but Polypop looks to streaming what FruityLoops is to music, compared to something like Cubase.
transitions are coming in the next update. im personally still using both systems cause it is a lot of work to rebuild everything in polypop
I use OBS everyday but don’t know how to do most of this stuff.
Glad to help
Which has less lag?
OBS
Thanks for this. It’s always great when there are alternatives. A set up video about Polypop would be really good .
Is the video quality better? Obs has been struggling lately with the video quality, I tried twitch studio and the picture quality is way better, but it doesn't have as many features as obs. I'd try this app if the picture quality is better than obs while streaming.
I'm pretty entrenched. Tons of OBS plugins and Streamer bot managing it.
my problem with obs is that it takes too much cpu and ram even though its on lowest settings, so glad i found a new alternative for obs.
You didn't mention the type of input signals that can take can it do NDI
Dreadful
Elaborate please.
Also I hope people use PolyPop over streamlabs just because of how shady Streamlabs is
Wtf is polypop live?
Also that name sucks 🤣
Is polypop easier on my GPU/CPU?
Probably not.
@@MichaelFeyrerJr thanks for the reply and all your helpful videos.
can you record with polypop
Yes
@@MichaelFeyrerJr cant downoad it thank you thou
Only for windows??? Bah....
there is something weird happening with your frame pacing tho its jarring maybe its just me?
What about Android phone
Which operating system do you use
On poly pop can I play my switch when I stream ?
Does it have studio mode like obs?
But polypop I love
I do have a question about this I've been using streamlabs and basically using remote as a stream deck to switch between scenes using my phone does Polly pop have anything like that
Not yet.
Sadly no Linux version :(
I am feeding PolyPop into OBS and use the Stream Deck. It is easy to set up. Just using some basic stock PolyPop effects for now but it does liven up the PodClass for sure. Easy to use and free.
Why 24fps? Do at least 30, it's really weird watching this framerate...
So you never watch movies?
@@MichaelFeyrerJr U got the point but for some reason the video is a bit to much choppy for 24fps, i felt very weird watching it. All in all great vid as always keep up the good work love seeing new ideas that u have i hope there will be much more interesting quirks to cover in obs bcs ur channel helped me a lot especially when i had my encoder overloading in windows 11 couple of videos gave me a few ideas why that could be happening... If u didn't u should make a video of possible outcomes why is overload happening :D It's a common thing to happen on rtx series cards especially 3xxx.
At first I was like "Meh, another windows-only program".
But the text part might be useful. Wonder if I can just make stuff with it, record and use the resulting videos as effects on OBS... IF I can run it through WINE. :1
Does polypop have window record function that will record a different window while i'm playing a game. OBS use to do this flawlessly but will no longer do it for some reason gives me blackscreens on all recordings as soon as I leave the window
thanks for the info Michael, I thing I would get it a trial run and see if it fits my need as a streamer. and is it alright if I relink this vid to my stream when I live test?
could you please give a tutorial on how to add closed captioning to a stream?
best youtuber
Amazing
Hello Michael, i have a question. PolyPop Live demands more Cpu/gpu use from the computer?, more than OBS?. I'ts Heavy-Use than OBs?
Of course, great video, have a nice day.
Depends entirely on how much 3D stuff you jam into a scene. If you have basic setup like shown in this video, PolyPop will run pretty close to the same requirements as OBS.
@@notthomasharrell Are you sure? thank you sir
Love your videos! Do you do your zooms in post, or do you have a special camera for that?
He doing it in software when editing it.
now if only we could add sound effects in polypop...
You can.
I watch all your videos and have learned a lot, but comparing a solid, finished software package like OBS to beta software Polypop is a bit unfair. Polypop is an amazing product but it's BETA, meaning it's not finished. This isn't even a 1.0 release of Polypop. Polypop doesn't use or have an open API for plugins yet. We all know Exceldro and others have made OBS a premier product. Polypop is an Up and Comer in this software catagory and in no way is on equal footing with OBS as of right now.
Polypop is amazing but is in no position to even match OBS functionality. Anyone who would trade OBS for Polypop are just fans of 3D, the swap does not make good business sense and will not provide even half of what OBS can do. I use Polypop in my stream, as a source into OBS.
Comparing an established software package to Beta software is unfair.