Can Roblox Studio compete with Top Tier Game Engines?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @k4sp
    @k4sp  4 місяці тому

    yoo if you have any suggestions/ideas for my games/vids or would just like to chat, you are more than welcome to join our community discord.com/invite/ZWgFtGPMvX :)

  • @FlawlessPixel
    @FlawlessPixel 4 місяці тому +9

    As a roblox dev i can confirm this vid is true

    • @mawesome4ever
      @mawesome4ever 4 місяці тому +1

      As a Roblox dev I can confirm this comment is true

    • @trankhanh945
      @trankhanh945 4 місяці тому

      Have you earned money from roblox yet? Is it feasible?

    • @mawesome4ever
      @mawesome4ever 4 місяці тому

      @@trankhanh945 yes I have. But not career changing money, more like “oh, I can buy bags of chips for a week”

  • @TheNuclearAtomizer
    @TheNuclearAtomizer 22 дні тому

    Something I notice about Roblox Studio to actaul Roblox is how for me the Studio never lags for me. But a game of the same quality in Roblox could slow down most of my devices.

  • @kynze5228
    @kynze5228 2 місяці тому

    I believe that Roblox Studio is the best engine for indie game devs since you have everything you need to make a game, there isn't anything that makes the engine too hard for nothing and with it, you can make your games very accessible. I've been a Roblox dev since 2014, i know pretty much everything there is to know about this engine and i can tell that you can do way better than what you see from others.
    There's some limitation suchs as the limits for cloud/toolbox assets data size but you can just split the asset in multiple pieces if it's too big. And i think games can only run if the memory usage is bellow 6GB, but using that much is excessive. Other than that, i don't really have any other issue, i guess transparent objects will look glitchy but you can make the effect less noticable.
    I hate the whole 'It's just a kids game' idea, i know that Roblox is filled with these cartoony kids game but Roblox is too good to be a 'kids game'. I think games should try to remove any content that will scream 'Roblox' such as the default materials, default character, default UI, Bloom and more.
    Not to sound like an old person but the Roblox community back then was better, it wasn't as childish and boring as it is today with these clicker gambling games or 'simulators' as they call it. I don't think there was any game that really shows the features Roblox studio has, like no game has physics as the main focus for example.
    I said i know pretty much everything about studio, well not everything, i don't know everything about lua, i haven't touched GUI enough to be a master at it and i think i will find something new about building and/or physics, they make updates once often so they might bring something new to this category sometime soon.
    Im not a scripter but what i whould like is the ability to use the camera, i think this will give some opportunity for specific games like that could be usefull for dancing games. I don't think Roblox supports VR trackers at all but i guess it whould be possible anyways by coding a 3rd party software that changes the data of the trackers to controller data tho can you use 2 or more controllers at once?

  • @rivvielet
    @rivvielet 4 місяці тому +3

    0:40 Who the fuck has the explorer on the left side (and toolbox on right)

  • @xx752xx
    @xx752xx 3 місяці тому +1

    The map you show is actually no more than 1 hour work for a normal developer at roblox. Roblox have got a ton of limitations but this just means that there are a ton of work arounds! I have developed on roblox for more than a year and the graphics are not bad it depends on the developer's skills! Roblox supports good graphics but since it's hard to make and it takes a ton of time most of the games prefer the easier way and in addition the games which chose hyper realisum it's hard for them to edit the map once they built it! I'm currently working on a game which is based of GTA but with different idea and currently it's going nice! It's named Lost Sanches!

    • @Jackinbox19001
      @Jackinbox19001 2 місяці тому

      limitations is just de graphis lol (Its only the devloper who decides how good the game is)

    • @xx752xx
      @xx752xx 2 місяці тому

      @@Jackinbox19001 true but even teh graphics most of the times is not a problem

    • @xx752xx
      @xx752xx 2 місяці тому

      @@Jackinbox19001 but still the studio is like kind of limited with some functions missing

    • @Jackinbox19001
      @Jackinbox19001 2 місяці тому

      @@xx752xx nah disagree

    • @xx752xx
      @xx752xx 2 місяці тому

      @Jackinbox19001 maybe yes maybe no I still got new things to learn in studio everyday! :D

  • @thestickmahn2446
    @thestickmahn2446 4 місяці тому +1

    try to run realtime voxel raytracing in studio /j
    no but seriously roblox studio can be a very good engine but it does have it's issues (for example, it only has Lua, which can become an issue when you need to do more intensive work)

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      true true id prefer even c++ over lua

  • @Divine20136
    @Divine20136 21 день тому

    3:13 is wrong

  • @savigro
    @savigro 4 місяці тому +3

    roblox uses luau not lua btw

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +2

      whats the difference?

    • @ImmortalSpelldagger
      @ImmortalSpelldagger 4 місяці тому +2

      ​@@k4spversion and some functions

    • @_lod
      @_lod 4 місяці тому +3

      @@k4sp type checking, performance improvements, sandboxing

  • @plumcakey
    @plumcakey 4 місяці тому +1

    just learn to use godot holy cow

  • @Duck_cheese
    @Duck_cheese 3 місяці тому

    I use roblox studio

  • @Cinarbayramic
    @Cinarbayramic 4 місяці тому +6

    "2" + "2" = 4 and hard to read syntax(i mean any syntax that is not c like) is bad enough for me to stick to unity or s&box

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      yeah i dont like lua either

    • @ImmortalSpelldagger
      @ImmortalSpelldagger 4 місяці тому +2

      "2" + "2" would error out in lua lol

    • @SuperMegaToto
      @SuperMegaToto 4 місяці тому

      @@ImmortalSpelldagger does that mean there is no string concatenation?

    • @ImmortalSpelldagger
      @ImmortalSpelldagger 4 місяці тому

      @@SuperMegaToto u connect anything with
      ..
      Like
      "2".."2"
      "2"..50
      "7"..true

    • @Cinarbayramic
      @Cinarbayramic 4 місяці тому

      @@ImmortalSpelldagger wdym print("2"+"2") output 4 in the online compiler i used also you cant make complex games with just lua

  • @6hundred9
    @6hundred9 4 місяці тому +12

    The only thing I hate about LUA is the fact that lists start with index 1 instead of 0

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      i hate that it doesnt have normal oop im so used to classes i just cant do shit w/o them

    • @6hundred9
      @6hundred9 4 місяці тому +1

      @@k4sp I've been using C# for 2 years now and started my journey with lua so I can code without classes but they feel essential to me

    • @fabimawn
      @fabimawn 4 місяці тому +1

      @@k4sp You can very easilly do that with metatables, OR tables themselves. There's two ways to make classes and objects with constructors, destructors, methods in them, you name it. The only thing missing is the class, public, and private keyword

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      @@fabimawn yeahhh ik but it still confuses me maybe bc of its simplicity

    • @fabimawn
      @fabimawn 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@k4sp Ah ok, and you know the local table in constructor method? that might be the easiest to wrap your head around.

  • @xadok
    @xadok 4 місяці тому +3

    people always talk about how easy lua is, i've never been able to understand any kind of programming language, what's the best way to learn?

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +2

      do projects on your own and when you dk something google it up, the knowledge will just stack up overtime

    • @xadok
      @xadok 4 місяці тому +2

      @@k4sp ok, thank you

    • @amara7734
      @amara7734 3 місяці тому +2

      Take a course in C at college if you can and listen and do well in it, after that picking up a programming language shouldnt be too hard. If that isn't feasible, watch tutorials and follow along with the teacher, i reccomend BrawlDev's beginner and advanced scripting series

    • @xadok
      @xadok 3 місяці тому +1

      @@amara7734 issue is I'm never going to college so that's not an option for me

  • @nuin9937
    @nuin9937 4 місяці тому +1

    So you can make filth!

  • @shinobi5237
    @shinobi5237 4 місяці тому +2

    Hey! I'm a Roblox dev since 1 year and half, and I was wondering if I needed to change my game development engine. I downloaded Unity, but my computer LAG on a template even if I have 8GB of ram. After watching this video, I'm not sure anymore: Roblox or Unity? My old Roblox projects did terrible results like 1.5k visits... I'm making a game since 5 months, I published a trailer on youtube and everything I got is 30 poor views. During holidays, I remember spending like 6 hours a day working on my game, but it just didn't work! I don't get any visits! Maybe my idead are bad... Do you have something to recommand to me?

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      an actual game engine would give you way more control over whats going on in your game but roblox is prolly easier to get players so it just depends on what you want to do. but you can try out both and see which one you like more. also to advertise your games dont do trailers because no one knows ab them in the first place, you should instead advertise them by making TikToks/yt shorts/interesting yt vids ab ur game cuz thats what most ppl watch nowadays, but you have to be very strategic with what you show/how to interest people to play your game

    • @shinobi5237
      @shinobi5237 4 місяці тому +1

      @@k4sp Thanks for your answer! I will try Unity deeper. For the "marketing side", you said that getting Roblox players was easier. How can you get players if you publish your game on plateforms such as Google Play Store? Do you need to pay ads?

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      you could pay for ads or do social media or pay other social media creators to play ur game and make videos ab it

    • @shinobi5237
      @shinobi5237 4 місяці тому +1

      @@k4sp Well, thanks!

  • @hs50
    @hs50 4 місяці тому +3

    kasp finally got his password back

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +5

      toook me about 4501873 guesses but we got it

  • @SHaris-wu2ne
    @SHaris-wu2ne 4 місяці тому +1

    If i want to learn c++ where should i start?

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +2

      youtube tutorials, online courses and just doing lots of projects and googling when u dk how to do something, the knowledge will just stack up overtime

  • @Nitbandier
    @Nitbandier 4 місяці тому +2

    2d games: am i a joke to you ?

  • @Dyzcroll
    @Dyzcroll 4 місяці тому +1

    well, acctually there is game really well made specially one that is made to copy cod, if you search up for roblox cod game you find videos of a game that does not look like 99% of the roblox games, its so well made.

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      true true i meant that most games just dont look good

  • @ifqiyeh
    @ifqiyeh 3 місяці тому

    It is easier to promote Roblox game via social media if your country has a large audience, I can confirm this as I live in a country with small population it was hard to get it out but one of my games got viral because of the audience from neighbouring countries: Indonesia & Malaysia. Also making unique games is not as worth making compared to simpler games on Roblox nowadays so don't spend too much time on it because the chances are slim that it will blow up unless the idea is really good and you see a potential from it

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  3 місяці тому

      true but you could also just promote the game in English to reach as many people as possible

    • @ifqiyeh
      @ifqiyeh 3 місяці тому

      @@k4sp Not true though based on mine and my other friend's experience (he also made a viral horror game)

  • @JaggyDev
    @JaggyDev 4 місяці тому

    btw u can change the grass color in roblxo

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому

      u cant put a gradient on it (thats when grass looks the best)

  • @SuperBro112Lol
    @SuperBro112Lol 4 місяці тому +1

    roblox has a huge problem: You cant use it on linux and you cant even use a virtual machine because its blocked there too (wine doesnt work)

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому +1

      oh damn

    • @SatokoHoujouOriginalRoleplayer
      @SatokoHoujouOriginalRoleplayer 4 місяці тому +1

      i mean, i expect that. roblox's anticheat doesn't really like virtual machines
      since they can be use for cheating.

    • @SuperBro112Lol
      @SuperBro112Lol 4 місяці тому +1

      @@SatokoHoujouOriginalRoleplayer yes and i think that they even mentioned this

    • @berendberend702
      @berendberend702 4 місяці тому

      that's not a problem for 99% of people and I can actually run roblox on windows sandbox

    • @SuperBro112Lol
      @SuperBro112Lol 4 місяці тому

      @@berendberend702 wdym what is sandbox

  • @Sealters
    @Sealters 4 місяці тому +1

    I would consider roblox more like 3d mario maker with code and ingame currency.

  • @Fossilsmudge
    @Fossilsmudge 4 місяці тому +1

    firstt

  • @ThatGuyfr1
    @ThatGuyfr1 4 місяці тому +1

    Real skibidi toilet tower defence is the best game🥵😨😈👆🤓

    • @k4sp
      @k4sp  4 місяці тому

      lideralrly me when i run from the roblox police