Understanding Alphaville by Jean-Luc Godard

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 65

  • @Czechbound
    @Czechbound Рік тому +4

    Saw it on the big screen last night at the prague French Film Festival. Really great, sold out screening.

  • @eleventhrealm8374
    @eleventhrealm8374 3 роки тому +9

    this is one of my favourite films - it's timeless

  • @hundredcaws
    @hundredcaws 5 років тому +20

    blade runner and alphaville resemblence is true. you nailed it. good work.

  • @JhhhJbbdbd
    @JhhhJbbdbd 8 місяців тому

    Godard is a legend a great director and cultivate person he brought something new to the cinema rip

  • @gustavturefeldt3938
    @gustavturefeldt3938 9 років тому +23

    This is excellent, I love Godard, keep it up!

    • @killershark88
      @killershark88  9 років тому

      +Gustav Turefeldt Thanks! Should be making another video essay soon..

  • @kristianwhite2912
    @kristianwhite2912 3 роки тому +3

    Absolutely fantastic!
    What a joy to you discover and for me to unveil something truly amusing and quite enlightening.
    Thank you and keep it up!

  • @petecanthropus9947
    @petecanthropus9947 8 років тому +48

    Hi. There's a strong link between Alphaville and Jorge Luis Borges' ideas present in his essay-style books "History of Eternity" (1936) and "A New Refutation of Time" (1944-1946), the latter published a few years later, included in "Other Inquisitions" (1952). Indeed the Alpha 60's monologue "Time is the substance of which I am made. Time is a river which carries me along. But I am time. It's a tiger, tearing me apart; but I am the tiger" is a quotation from Borges.

    • @KHRAGF
      @KHRAGF 4 роки тому +2

      Thank you

    • @JSTNtheWZRD
      @JSTNtheWZRD Рік тому +1

      I must check it out, thanks - I just wish all my Borges books weren't in storage.

  • @Joe-ol5bq
    @Joe-ol5bq 5 років тому +3

    MORE OF THIS !! YES WE LOVE A WELL DONE VIDEO ESSAY subscribed

  • @sunlightpictures8367
    @sunlightpictures8367 4 роки тому +6

    Great commentary on this unique film. I've been a fan of Godard and inspired by him as a filmmaker for 25 years.

  • @michaelforthriller
    @michaelforthriller 4 роки тому +18

    it was hard to get used to the narrative style at first and also due to the fact that i had to watch it with English subtitles, but by the end it became very engaging and incredibly thought provoking.

  • @sirjaunty1
    @sirjaunty1 8 років тому +42

    Dammit. I was typing a comment outlining the very real allegory between Alphaville and Bladerunner. Then you go and do that right at the end. That will teach me patience to wait till the upload is over. Superb and articulate observation my friend. If this is part of a college course or diploma, then you are well on your way to merit status.

    • @mcopado
      @mcopado 6 років тому +4

      The Alphaville/Blade Runner connection has been well studied, I remember watching and discussing both in a college class on French New Wave Cinema in 87 or 88.
      Funny I stumbled onto this video because I actually felt like Blade Runner 2049 reminded me more of, and felt more like a sequel to this Alphaville than to Blade Runner.

    • @bramblebop1904
      @bramblebop1904 6 років тому

      Yes! Quite a good observation.

  • @fredceely
    @fredceely 8 років тому +3

    Very nice lesson, professor. Thanks!

  • @mauriceviel9
    @mauriceviel9 8 років тому +10

    Very interesting analysis, thanks ! Alphaville is somehow comparable with a Jules Verne spy novel of 1880, "Les 500 Millions de la Begum": A totalitarian dystopy, where the monster machine is not a Bull computer but a huge Prussian cannon.

  • @afrendeiro
    @afrendeiro 7 років тому +3

    Thank you

  • @Entonces
    @Entonces 7 місяців тому

    Nice job, thanks

  • @omarblanchfield6717
    @omarblanchfield6717 Рік тому

    A voice from the past spoke of the future, which is now the bleak present.

  • @theodorehebert6424
    @theodorehebert6424 8 років тому +2

    Great work, my friend!!!

  • @MonicaForrestall
    @MonicaForrestall 7 років тому +6

    Très intéressant!

  • @ZeeshanAhmad-ig6gn
    @ZeeshanAhmad-ig6gn 4 роки тому +2

    Amazing....

  • @timothysassoon1077
    @timothysassoon1077 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent commentary

  • @5hiv4Hulk
    @5hiv4Hulk 7 років тому +2

    Amazing commentary!!

  • @luzalvari
    @luzalvari 7 років тому +3

    This was so helpful, thank you!

  • @kulturindustrie5361
    @kulturindustrie5361 5 років тому +1

    I love his films!!!

  • @criticaltransfer425
    @criticaltransfer425 2 роки тому +3

    Thankyou for making this video :) I really love Alphaville; but, you've really added to my appreciation of it! I particularly enjoyed your commentary on the editing and directorial intent.

  • @jackr4507
    @jackr4507 2 роки тому

    Germany Year 90 Nine Zero builds really well on Alphaville as a sort of sequel, just in Godard’s much later and more mature style

  • @k.t.5405
    @k.t.5405 3 роки тому +4

    Alphaville = what Blade Runner 2049 should have been.

  • @Bazed.
    @Bazed. 2 роки тому

    Oh and forgot the blatant allegory of the cave and “The Republic” parallels (“enlightened” ai philosopher king ruling by the concept of the “universal good”, which in both Alpha60’s “mind” and Plato’s is technocracy/rule by absolute “logic”/quantification of life. e=mc2 symbolizes this idea in the film. Energy representing life in this case. More parallels abound but I’m not writing an essay lol. Thanks for the vid.

  • @louisaparker
    @louisaparker 11 місяців тому

    I tried to watch this movie, but had to fight sleep.

  • @blackbird5634
    @blackbird5634 3 роки тому

    It is better to travel hopefully than to arrive.

  • @paulmurphy42
    @paulmurphy42 7 років тому +7

    Does anyone know the name of the actress who played Beatrice, the seductress? She isn't even credited in the film!

  • @bramblebop1904
    @bramblebop1904 6 років тому +2

    Hey, what is the significance of the Éluard book Caution gets from dying Tamiroff?

    • @phillipphil1615
      @phillipphil1615 3 роки тому

      One of Paul Eluard's most famous poem is liberté, written while France was under Nazi rule. It's a very powerful ode to the yearning for freedom.
      Sur mes cahiers d’écolier
      Sur mon pupitre et les arbres
      Sur le sable sur la neige
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur toutes les pages lues
      Sur toutes les pages blanches
      Pierre sang papier ou cendre
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur les images dorées
      Sur les armes des guerriers
      Sur la couronne des rois
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur la jungle et le désert
      Sur les nids sur les genêts
      Sur l’écho de mon enfance
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur les merveilles des nuits
      Sur le pain blanc des journées
      Sur les saisons fiancées
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur tous mes chiffons d’azur
      Sur l’étang soleil moisi
      Sur le lac lune vivante
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur les champs sur l’horizon
      Sur les ailes des oiseaux
      Et sur le moulin des ombres
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur chaque bouffée d’aurore
      Sur la mer sur les bateaux
      Sur la montagne démente
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur la mousse des nuages
      Sur les sueurs de l’orage
      Sur la pluie épaisse et fade
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur les formes scintillantes
      Sur les cloches des couleurs
      Sur la vérité physique
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur les sentiers éveillés
      Sur les routes déployées
      Sur les places qui débordent
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur la lampe qui s’allume
      Sur la lampe qui s’éteint
      Sur mes maisons réunies
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur le fruit coupé en deux
      Du miroir et de ma chambre
      Sur mon lit coquille vide
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur mon chien gourmand et tendre
      Sur ses oreilles dressées
      Sur sa patte maladroite
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur le tremplin de ma porte
      Sur les objets familiers
      Sur le flot du feu béni
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur toute chair accordée
      Sur le front de mes amis
      Sur chaque main qui se tend
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur la vitre des surprises
      Sur les lèvres attentives
      Bien au-dessus du silence
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur mes refuges détruits
      Sur mes phares écroulés
      Sur les murs de mon ennui
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur l’absence sans désir
      Sur la solitude nue
      Sur les marches de la mort
      J’écris ton nom
      Sur la santé revenue
      Sur le risque disparu
      Sur l’espoir sans souvenir
      J’écris ton nom
      Et par le pouvoir d’un mot
      Je recommence ma vie
      Je suis né pour te connaître
      Pour te nommer
      Liberté.
      Paul Eluard
      Poésie et vérité 1942 (recueil clandestin)
      Au rendez-vous allemand (1945, Les Editions de Minuit)

    • @bramblebop1904
      @bramblebop1904 3 роки тому

      C'est tres bon - merci, mon ami.

  • @timkuijlen6733
    @timkuijlen6733 2 роки тому

    I hope you can help my memory. I am wondering about a film, I think it is from Godard, where a guy is talking in front of train tracks. Then a train passes by with a lot of noise, and his monologue becomes inaudible, as if it is the most normal thing in the world.
    Anyone knows what film I'm talking about?

    • @claudenyspinelli8047
      @claudenyspinelli8047 Рік тому

      in Pierrot le fou there´s a train scene with Belmondo, but i don´t know if that´s the one you´re talking about

  • @alexioukaterina675
    @alexioukaterina675 2 роки тому

    Are u a film student? This was so great I wonder

  • @IndieGuvenc
    @IndieGuvenc 5 років тому +6

    the first 30 minutes put me to sleep, maybe I have to give it more time? Subtitles didn't help

  • @Bazed.
    @Bazed. 2 роки тому +2

    Technocratic scientism as an ouroboros symbolized by the spinning of the computer fan and the spinning of the computer tapes is a clear theme missed. The whole way Caution beat Alpha60 was by exploiting the flaw in its foundational logic. It can’t explain Telos; or the why. Nor can it justify itself or the “universal good” (logic) it claims to serve. I’d wager Godard was influenced by Quine’s “Two Dogmas of Empiricism” (1951) paper.

  • @jondstewart
    @jondstewart 4 роки тому

    Isn’t this movie set in an alternate universe or another planet?

  • @JSTNtheWZRD
    @JSTNtheWZRD Рік тому

    By godard? You should of just let the man speak if your going to put his name to it

  • @tolkorm
    @tolkorm 3 роки тому

    #bezos #musk #xmen #cicades

  • @matthewcalkins4979
    @matthewcalkins4979 3 роки тому

    2:12

  • @Mangocomatose
    @Mangocomatose Рік тому

    Wait hang on this isn’t about steamed hams

  • @StratsRUs
    @StratsRUs 3 роки тому

    Just another movie inspired by 1984.

  • @thecivilianseries3267
    @thecivilianseries3267 2 роки тому

    Boy it would be nice if you gave your viewers the respect to announce the fact that you spoil the ending of Alphaville.

  • @AdAstra78
    @AdAstra78 2 місяці тому

    Like so much of Godard's work, this was a huge disappointment. It never felt 'otherworldly'. It just felt like...France at night.

  • @RobWatt
    @RobWatt 2 роки тому

    hate strobes

  • @laluna5548
    @laluna5548 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting and complicated chatacter? Haha…maybe for the 60ties, but still incredibly disappointing writing of a woman

  • @NuNugirl
    @NuNugirl 3 роки тому +1

    Dark City is a better movie in every way, and it is also entertaining. This movie was a pretentious bore. Shell Beach 👍

  • @cheekygeeks4130
    @cheekygeeks4130 Рік тому

    Nitpicking a little but your mispronunciation of 'Auteur' and 'Tyranny' lead me to doubt your knowledge and opinion.

  • @TheGreatWent1
    @TheGreatWent1 3 роки тому

    cheap french parody of 1984

  • @jackr4507
    @jackr4507 2 роки тому

    Germany Year 90 Nine Zero builds really well on Alphaville as a sort of sequel, just in Godard’s much later and more mature style