Gibson Vs Epiphone One Has To Go! Which One Did I Keep?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 70

  • @brianmckenzie1318
    @brianmckenzie1318 2 роки тому +7

    The best and most insightful thing is you give us YOUR reasons for choosing what you keep! I like it!

  • @eddepreist9178
    @eddepreist9178 2 роки тому +3

    Hey Dylan. I've commissioned a build from Matt and Chris at TTG and it'll feature a set of your P90s. So looking forward to it.

  • @shanewalton8888
    @shanewalton8888 2 роки тому +1

    I'm a proud owner of a Schecter Sun Valley Super Shredder in Birch Green. Looking forward to what you have to say about it.

  • @erikpedersen7977
    @erikpedersen7977 2 роки тому +1

    I have one of the new SG Juniors. Also, for me, a bucket list guitar. I love mine, but I am interested in your P90s. My ES 330 may benefit from them.

  • @michaelmenkes8085
    @michaelmenkes8085 2 роки тому

    some people put bike racks or a car hitch behind their RV. You sir need to tow a man cave so you can keep a few axes. The Epiphone semi hollows are really practical guitars to have around.

  • @charleswallace5818
    @charleswallace5818 2 роки тому +2

    Have always wanted a 335 style guitar! Thanks for making a very very nice guitar.

  • @rayfabris2512
    @rayfabris2512 2 роки тому

    just got my first Gibson les paul standard in cherry burst bad ass and I got it at the Gibson garage in the beginning of August.

  • @SgtBFGunner
    @SgtBFGunner Рік тому

    The finish is not "superficial"... Epiphone is a poly finish, Gibson is a real nitrocellulose finish. Worlds of difference material-wise.

  • @stancoleshill8925
    @stancoleshill8925 Рік тому

    I kept both of them and bought more Epiphones, Gibsons and Gretsch's. What I do is KEEP THEM ALL

  • @ryanfulldark2775
    @ryanfulldark2775 2 роки тому +1

    That McPherson is pretty damn killer. I played one at Gruhn Guitars in Nashville and it honestly blew me away

  • @Rad_Pug
    @Rad_Pug 2 роки тому +3

    I thought the SG was a dream guitar of yours.

  • @garrybyng8173
    @garrybyng8173 2 роки тому +1

    You do not know what you are talking about. The Epiphone is a very collectible guitar. Gibson and Epiphone company goes we’ve back. Both companies have a history. Some Epiphones are very collectible. I have both Gibson Les Pauls, Fenders, And lots of Epiphones. I think maybe you need to get a house? Maybe, just a thought. Also I have been playing guitars for around 40 Years. Had hand surgery in 2019. Not bragging, I just think that for $ 500.00-800.00 I can get a good tool. Where about $ 1,000-up to the sky. I just think for the money you can get a really nice playing guitar. To be honest I was a little let down when I purchased my first Gibson. Don’t get me wrong it is a good guitar? Epiphone s are Great guitars for the money. Thank you very much. Garry B

  • @benallmark9671
    @benallmark9671 2 роки тому

    Had to come back and watch this video to see which ones going.

  • @DJPLAYNICE
    @DJPLAYNICE 2 роки тому

    Sometimes hard to practice that degree of economy, eh? Keep bangin'. 🤘🏼

  • @BrianBrazilHarmonica
    @BrianBrazilHarmonica 2 роки тому

    Hi Dylan, If you are concerned about having room for your guitars and you want a Gibson ES 335 style model why not get the ES 339? It's like a ES 335 with a smaller body. Everything is the same including the scale. It's just that the body is a little smaller. It's slight wider than a Les Paul, but about the same length. It's a little lighter too. I've waited for years for Gibson to make a smaller version of an ES 335 they finally did a few years ago. Epiphone has an ES 339 also. The ES 335 is my favorite guitar but it's a little too large for me to play comfortably. I use to own a 1968 Walnut finish ES 335 but traded it for an SG Standard.

  • @peterschmidt9942
    @peterschmidt9942 2 роки тому

    Only 3 guitars? Dylan shouting "Honey, I think we need a bigger motorhome"!

  • @lazvt8469
    @lazvt8469 2 роки тому

    Best 335 value? Eastman...hands down. As good....1/3 the price...ask around.

  • @ny7294
    @ny7294 2 роки тому

    I have both Gibson and Epiphone SG guitars .The Epis are their high end models from the past 15 years or so ,and are very nice instruments with Gibson USA pickups and specs/features that set them apart from typical Epis... that said , my Gibsons just have that "feel" that puts them over the top for me. If I was forced to choose between my Gibsons and my Epiphones, the Gibsons stay .

  • @vanshankguitars
    @vanshankguitars 2 роки тому +1

    We all kinda knew the Epiphone was sold as you had already hinted at that during the Thursday live show.

  • @chriscampbell9191
    @chriscampbell9191 2 роки тому

    Before you gave the reason I guessed the SG was the keeper because SGs with single P90s aren't as common as dual humbucker guitars, so that could be a factor. When I see an SG with P90s, I always think of Pete Townshend for some reason. Maybe because he got such great sound from his.

  • @hillbillygeorg
    @hillbillygeorg 2 роки тому

    An idea when you´re on the road,is that you limit the time for keeping the "extra guitar" by xxx numer of travelled miles with it.It would be intreresting if you made a video with the topic "what is a collectable and what is not? Is there low priced guitars out there today that could be a good keeper and might be considered a "collectable" in the future?" Thanks for what you are doing here!

  • @KresnaCahyaP
    @KresnaCahyaP 2 роки тому

    I owned a Epiphone LP 59, im not gonna lie if someone ask me to throw my Epiphone away and he/she would give me a Gibson LP Standard in exchange, pretty sure I would throw my Epiphone guitar away. And im sure Epiphone fanboy will do the same with me. I owned many epiphone guitars, its a very nice guitar, but Gibson has a better quality.

  • @Steinstra-vj7wl
    @Steinstra-vj7wl 2 роки тому +2

    Sell both and buy a PRS Fiore :)

  • @drewsollars2239
    @drewsollars2239 2 роки тому

    I've decided to keep my les studio and sell my sheraton for largely the same reasons. My dilemma is, do I swap the Duncans in the les for the 57 classics in the Sheraton before I do. If it didn't involve working on an archtop it would be an easier decision.

  • @UmVtCg
    @UmVtCg 2 роки тому +2

    I've got a 2010 Gibson Les Paul in Iced Tea burst. And I've bought 3 Epiphone models after they've changed the headstock shape. I had to return them all. I did not like the finish, the pickups and the quality control sucked. they all had terrible string buzz. Poly flamed finishes do not move. It's the nitro cellulose that does it for me.

  • @guitarxplorer2022
    @guitarxplorer2022 2 роки тому

    Great job!

  • @timothypotter2137
    @timothypotter2137 2 роки тому

    Good video, sound logic. I too want a 335 style guitar. One day...

  • @dreamakah
    @dreamakah 2 роки тому

    Recently got one of the SG Jr.'s and I would need years of very expensive therapy if I had to part with it.

  • @shanewalton8888
    @shanewalton8888 2 роки тому

    I wonder if there will be a Dylan-branded Sustaniac type pickup in the future? lol

  • @stanburtt
    @stanburtt 2 роки тому +1

    Great content thanks .

  • @theelectricsexmachine7502
    @theelectricsexmachine7502 2 роки тому

    Dylan, you Gibson fanboy you 😂😂
    I would be interested to get your take on the Squier Contemporary Strat specifically the single coil mod which either comes as hard tail or a trem . Pickip placement reminds me of Robbie Robertson’s positioning

  • @timothymallon
    @timothymallon 2 роки тому

    Ditch both and buy a Fender!

  • @platypuspracticus2
    @platypuspracticus2 2 роки тому +1

    "I have to be able to promote my products"
    So one P-90 slot vs two humbucker slots. Seems like a straight forward choice. Let's see if my math adds up?

    • @platypuspracticus2
      @platypuspracticus2 2 роки тому

      Nope, haha.

    • @DylanTalksTone
      @DylanTalksTone  2 роки тому +2

      the amount of pickups in a guitar doesn’t make it a better marketing tool…. Lol.

  • @kirkwilson6229
    @kirkwilson6229 2 роки тому

    "Collectibility" means absolutely nothing to me. Even less so in an instrument I like enough to keep. It would only have meaning if I meant to sell. Interesting that your reasoning is opposite. I would keep the two guitars that made me want to play the most, and to hell with collectibility and brand name.

  • @ramencurry6672
    @ramencurry6672 2 роки тому

    Both gorgeous. It’s like picking between Elizabeth Taylor or Marilyn Monroe.

  • @2dazetake
    @2dazetake 2 роки тому

    Hopefully neither, every guitar has It's own personality and use,these are two guitars every guitarist should have in their collection, along with a strat and a tele, and of course a 24 fret guitar,although you may be able to mimic the sound of each guitar, with just one,I found it more useful,to just get the guitar used to make your favorite tone,or favorite tune, two guitars that are exactly alike,can even sound different,so choose wisely,brand names mean nothing,if the guitar doesn't feel right in your hands,and is just going to collect dust sitting in a corner somewhere,budget guitars make it possible for those who might have wanted a guitar,but don't want to put out the money for a brand name, the quality of budget guitars has really improved these days, throw a set of Dylan's pickups in an Epiphone,and save yourself $1000 of dollars,and blow away the brand snobs.

  • @RockinfromtheGrave
    @RockinfromtheGrave 2 роки тому

    If you're not a Gibson fanboy, you should be! Jk.
    Personally, I think Gibson nailed it so well with the Les Paul that even Les Paul copies are amazing instruments that are extremely versatile. You can take them to just about any kind of jam session and sound great.

    • @RockinfromtheGrave
      @RockinfromtheGrave 2 роки тому

      Once you get a guitar that has that mojo (for you) then you just don't want to put it down when you play it. You just want to keep playing and playing.

  • @leroybrady4288
    @leroybrady4288 2 роки тому

    You're a Fender fan boy!

  • @ghostbanana271
    @ghostbanana271 2 роки тому

    10:53 Freudian slip! Dylan secretly wants Charvel guitar :)

  • @Dirge4july
    @Dirge4july 2 роки тому

    Keep the Gibson. Of course.

  • @shanewalton8888
    @shanewalton8888 2 роки тому +1

    Some one called you a Gibson fanboy. That's hilarious.

  • @davidkornblatt991
    @davidkornblatt991 2 роки тому +2

    I am of the opinion, ya keep both. This could be good because you made both guitars yours and you put your heart, soul, and sweaty MOJO into both. I even believe that dead pieces of wood have a frequency that only their owners can drag out of them. That's why guitars aren't made out of metal, plastic or ceramic because those materials don't have MOJO likewood

  • @jbourke33
    @jbourke33 2 роки тому +4

    Such a Fender fanboy…

  • @chrisparker5278
    @chrisparker5278 2 роки тому +1

    Get a jazzmaster and wind some pickups!

    • @DylanTalksTone
      @DylanTalksTone  2 роки тому +1

      We already make killer jazz master pickups.

  • @neverenoughguitars8276
    @neverenoughguitars8276 2 роки тому +2

    The Epiphone fanboys are seething right now lol.

  • @These_go_to_eleven_1959
    @These_go_to_eleven_1959 2 роки тому

    Yeah but do you Really,Really REALLY love it?
    You do say "Really" a lot! 😂

  • @Nugmania1
    @Nugmania1 2 роки тому

    Fender rules Gibson drools lol

  • @matthewpowell2527
    @matthewpowell2527 2 роки тому

    Ha Fender Fanboy!

  • @jeffalfred5785
    @jeffalfred5785 2 роки тому

    you need a left handed guitar, that will be one you keep forever lol It will showcase your left handed pickups lol

  • @jayhill5982
    @jayhill5982 2 роки тому +1

    Pretty sure the Chinese junk is down the road,LOL

    • @DylanTalksTone
      @DylanTalksTone  2 роки тому +1

      what Chinese junk? This epiphone is fantastic

  • @josearaujo8616
    @josearaujo8616 2 роки тому

    Man, you just shot yourself in the foot. You are a pickup manufacturer, you should never go for the single pickup guitar... 3 pickups at least... Best of luck and its perfectly understandable. The collection and gibson, not that much, because there are so many gibsons out there that their collectible value is questionable.

    • @davidburke2132
      @davidburke2132 2 роки тому +1

      And you think that Epiphones are comparatively rare?! 🤔😝🤣🤣🤣

    • @DylanTalksTone
      @DylanTalksTone  2 роки тому +1

      These comments amuse me.

    • @josearaujo8616
      @josearaujo8616 2 роки тому

      @@davidburke2132 My point wasn't to keep the epiphone, just saying I don't see a normal gibson has a collectible guitar, its something you want to own.
      Collectibles are usually things that are not made to be collectible, they just become desired things. There are many vintage collectible gibsons, but they were never made for that purpose.
      Will a regular gibson, or fender from this day and age ever be a collectible? In, my opinion, they are too expensive to be used by upcoming musicians and become iconic, and the established musicians will use custom shop stuff, so most probably not.
      Most probably some obscure "affordable" model, or a strange brand that appeals to a particular musician will become the next collectible guitars, not a 2021 SG... Maybe the Fender Clapton strat, which is the guitar he uses on tour. Or an 1995 epiphone Riviera..

    • @davidburke2132
      @davidburke2132 2 роки тому

      @@josearaujo8616 and the purpose of a collection is often not about rarity or increasing investment value. Often when it comes to guitars it’s about filling a specific recognised niche. In that sense, put bluntly, an Epiphone version of an ES-335 is not a “reference” guitar. A Gibson ES-335 absolutely is.

    • @josearaujo8616
      @josearaujo8616 2 роки тому

      @@davidburke2132 1995 Riviera is played by the Strokes guitarist. Just like the 72 Fender Bronco is now a very collectible guitar because its an iconic Artic Monkeys guitar.
      2021 SG, so far no one that I know plays them...
      I was talking about collectibles in that sense, not owning guitars you like. But maybe its also another sort of collection, but in this case its the guitars you love, does not have to be a specific brand or model.