thanks for your commentary. I think this was originally 麥炳榮 冼劍麗 演唱 record, not for 折子戲? those days, there were many such examples.. there was market demand for these songs as long as they were well-known and popular singers. Audience did not look beyond what they hear lo. 不算受歡迎的作品 - as a record for 演唱, yes, one of the many fish in the sea those days/years. but i think as 折子戲,, 算受歡迎 in recent years..easy to perform, only 2 artists involved, as you said, 完全是容易掌握. but for me as 折子戲 or a song, not very appealing..
I don't think that is easy to perform, although only 2 actors participated in the show , singing is different from acting, that is more complicated. Attraction or not is your feeling.
兆明哥真係聲，色，藝俱佳❤❤🎉🎉
謝謝
❤❤❤❤❤👍
❤😂❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊
多謝上傳！
😢
兆明太出色了，潔清還需努力！
年資不同，當然有差別，而且清清當時有點病，也需要諒解。
Miss Wong is my favorite actress.
thanks
這支曲我聽過好多次，麥炳榮先生的口白好有感情。
逝者已矣, 總要接受新人演出。
前輩模範，總要多學習。
學習是必然的, 但必須消化以配合個人特點, 不能純粹倒模式學習。@@cutechick9463
現在問題是基本個人感情都缺少，比較生硬公式。好多年前曾聽過梁太麥文潔接受港台訪問，她說香港的粵劇演員說口白很生活化，很自然，很值得國內的演員學習。
文潔沒有說錯, 但如要以個人還是大個較大的準則去衡量。如兆明, 其實他的唱和白都帶有少量鄉音, 如單純以個人角度, 要地道的香港廣東話, 肯定不會接受。除了語音, 內地定居香港的粵劇演員, 其說話方式和方法, 用語用句都和香港本地有不同, 如藍天佑在紫釵記, 稱呼盧太尉為老師, 劇本寫恩師, 香港本地演員包括任劍輝都會說恩師, 但今天一般人又習慣稱老師, 我自己的學生, 或者我的後輩如梁心怡, 或者尊重我的, 都會稱我為老師。而這些用語都會影響對說話人的觀感。再者不同人的說話方式, 又各有不同。所以, 我強調消化和配合個人特點, 就是這個原因, 完全生搬硬砌不但未必是好事, 有時反而窒礙了正常演出。所以, 要從表演是否順暢, 感情表達是完整, 演出是否用心出法。學習前輩還有另一個問題, 就是每個人對事情的看法都一定不會完全相同, 這包含每個人的背景影響, 我做編劇, 就經常遇到這種情況, 演員導演和我的看法可以是完全不同。如我上傳的燕子箋荒山初會, 老尼姑對男女主角說, 如果兩人有意, 可以私結婚姻, 未必不是一件好事, 就有網人認為是歪理, 其實是基於他們對封建社會的既成觀點。我把唐朝故事搬到南宋初年, 有這種觀點不一定錯, 因為有宋理學發展, 確可以這樣看, 但我這一段情節, 大概是源自明清話本[豆棚閒話]其中一個故事的情節。我舉這些例子, 其實是想說明, 是想說明世事其實有很多可能情, 一個演員表達角色的感情, 一個接收者接收的方式, 都存在千差萬別, 基本有主觀的因素, 所以都是回到剛才那一句, 表演是否順暢, 有沒有用心演出, 感情表達是否完整, 才是考慮的準則, 不應是否如某一位前輩相同的表現方式來判斷。@@cutechick9463
多謝上載，有幸看到，真有福！
請支持粵劇
永不改變。❤🎉🥰😍🤩😘@@manfungau1948
嘩！隻老虎咁瘦嘅。❤🎉😂😅
謝謝@@longfu1431
?@@longfu1431
👍👍👍
此曲在上世紀的粵曲點唱節目，點唱率不弱的，是麥炳榮前輩除鳳閣外，熱門的曲目
多人唱唔代表好, 等如演得好未必有觀眾欣賞, 世事本就如此。啲靚仔最鍾意食垃圾食物。
哈哈，我不追星的，而且此曲多聽麥前輩及洗劍麗女士的，@@manfungau1948
好好聽👏🏻👏🏻
謝謝
👍👍❤❤
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
兆明哥真係冇得頂
謝謝, 請繼續支持他們和粵劇。
😢
thanks for your commentary. I think this was originally 麥炳榮 冼劍麗 演唱 record, not for 折子戲? those days, there were many such examples.. there was market demand for these songs as long as they were well-known and popular singers. Audience did not look beyond what they hear lo. 不算受歡迎的作品 - as a record for 演唱, yes, one of the many fish in the sea those days/years. but i think as 折子戲,, 算受歡迎 in recent years..easy to perform, only 2 artists involved, as you said, 完全是容易掌握. but for me as 折子戲 or a song, not very appealing..
I don't think that is easy to perform, although only 2 actors participated in the show , singing is different from acting, that is more complicated. Attraction or not is your feeling.
👍👍👏👏❤️❤️😀😀