Animator Ranks ALL Punishing: Gray Raven Ultimates
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
- See you on our streams where we review animations! / dillongoo
Professional 3D Anime Rig for Blender: dillongoostudi...
Get Goo Engine here: gooengine.org
Twitter:
/ dillongoo
/ dillongoostudio
Main Animation channel: / dillongoo
Edited by @AbnormalSloth
These animations were so much fun to rank with just how high quality each of them are. The animators on the PGR team did an absolutely AMAZING job on these. Please keep in mind that all of the comments made in this video are just nitpicks at this point for the sake of choosing a winner. Much love and respect to the animators and artists at Kuro Games!
You all literally manifested Punishing: Gray Raven after all the comments last time. Let me know what you guys want me review next!! See you in the streams! twitch.tv/dillongoo
you should do tower of fantasy, nikke or snowbreak containment zone ultimates!
there olso few latest character that you miss like alisa echo, lamia lullaby, black rock shooter, watanabe epitatph, qu shukra, teddy decryptor, luna oblivion, bridget ardeo, and hanying S rank frame( can't find what her new frame called).
great vid but you kinda miss some characters and their other frames too! please check it out when you can because you had miss some good animation from there. Also could you do Wuthering waves ults (it's another game from the same people who made PGR). They are really good too!
wuthering waves!!
@@bahychairyhakim8535 its solacetune thats what it called
"Hyperreal is the winner"
> Puts Entropy on screen
I'm wheezing
LOL WHOOPS
Yeah, that was mega fail 😂
@@professorGoo LMFAO
Nah it's fine it's just another version of Lee from a different timeline, he's here because Lee from the current timeline is on the mission and is not available at the moment lol
😂😂😂
Gen 2 really blew Gen 1 out of the water with animation
And gen 3 is coming
@@haffex4418in Terms of animation not much will change from Gen 2
@@haffex4418 Honestly, Gen 3 does not really have anything distinct to be called Gen 3.
@@khulmach9662 It does have Gameplay differences. Though It's not that eye catching
@@shihabsharar3539 Not Really, even each Gen 2's has their own distinct Mechanics, the Newer Characters are being called Gen 3 only because of their Damage and Buffs, Luna is the only one actually bringing something Completely New
Goo: focused on the scythe movement
Chat: "Yeah but boobs"
Goo: "But my scythe movement would have have put even MORE focus on the boobs!"
Always gotta have those “framing” animators on the squad 👍
Is so amazing to see Pgrs evolution, started with basic beeg slash now whole cinematics
Waiting for most of the first characters to get remade
Someone please send this to Kuro Games this is very valuable for them when they make future characters in PGR and WuWa.
Agree
yes,since kuro hears the players preferences
Omg thank you, i found it because Kuro post it on their FB!
I wouldn't be surprised if they see this regardless since they reached out to Dillon themselves originally so they probably have someone keeping an eye on him
Can't wait for Wuthering Waves to come out so we can peer pressure this man to rank their ults too.
Well the time has come
He just did!
he did Wuwa already, Jinhsi was his favorite
Should've replied to my comment before others did XD
@@kyotheman69 jinhsi is just crazy man the difference between 1.0 and 1.1 is so crazy
Some characters you missed
-Alisa echo
-Lamia
-Teddy
-Luna Oblivion
-Hanying S rank (idk ger frame name)
-bridget
-Qu Shukra
-Watanabe Epitaph
-Black Rock Shooter
The ultimates video was definitely made before Alisa
@@Zyleace yeah, just reminding
Ayla: Kaleido too
I think Ayla Kaleido is also missing from this list?
@@uwu-chan oh yeah!
I always find PGR's animation to be very cool, but to hear the technical behind why its cool from a professional is great!
26:02 It's kinda funny that you asked for more frames into that pose, since from gameplay perspective, her long ult animation is already time consuming since she doesn't have a timestop (the stage time plays a big role in this game).
Also about the sniping shot by Lee Hyperreal (the one where he jumps and do the shooting), it's actually just his core passive attack. The real ult was his powerful shot in the end. I kinda wished people also react to this core passive attacks, because some of them were really cool (another example is the mid air attack by Alpha in your animation video)
I am so happy that Hyperreal is the winner. I stayed up so late to get that bossfight to feel so good. I cant see him without hearing 3:25 Under Dimension by Vanguard Sound.
So happy that you think he's got the best ultimate. Its so freaking cool.
I’m so glad he got best ult 😍 bro is so sick
True Lee is just too cool☺
Yeah the fire god himself
lee solos
The thing that always gets me about Hyperreal is, in that shot you were fond of where he...sheathes his gun, three or four images of him draw together and overlap into him since he's the culmination of timelines. Just looks so neat, imo.
Fun fact: Lee Hyperreal entire movesets all pay homage to his previous frames ultimates.
- The 4th normal attack is a multi-body gun play like his Palefire Ult
- The gun slam in the 5th normal attack AND the Red 3-ping in the Hypermatrix form resembles Entropy "divine punishment" Ult
There is also the Blue 3-ping where he jumps over the enemies and quick aim the rifle WHILE BEING UPSIDE DOWN, from which you can seemlessly transition into his Hypermatrix opening shot (like the start-up for the ultimate that you see).
Also also, everytime you use 3-ping in the Hypermatrix mode, there is another "Lee" appears and coordinate the damage with you. What so sick from a conceptual stand point is that once this state ends, all the "Lee" converge into one as the Hypermatrix cracks open and revert to normal environment. Just makes Lee's animation even sexier than it ever should be.
Hyperreal has the sexiest moveset in existence thats why I never get bored playing him
Literally the same
I'm playing him since the release and still can't get enough of his gameplay, it's so good
Frame's overall design, animations, SFX, voicelines, my lord did Kuro cooked with this one
we really need someone to make a new video with all the ults, this video people use is nearly a year old with tons of characters missing 😭
Oh man if only the rest of gen 2 and the beginning of gen 3 was shown in the referenced vid, Really enjoy seeing an animators perspective and insights on these, makes me pay even closer attention to detail and appreciate the smaller things even more, Great vid Prof. ^o^
Wow, excellent analysis of all the animations! We can see how the ultimates improved over time.
Perhaps you can also analyze the Un Finishing moves too. A finisher is exclusive to the Uns, and it is executed by depleting an enemy's Orange bar by attacking them. Once it is empty, the next basic attack will have the character perform a special execution move that instantly kills the target. There's not a lot of Uns, but it would be a cool short video to see your thoughts on how they are animated.
this should go all the way up!
As Hyperreal lover and as someone who was going crazy when he was announced, this video is totally a win.
Hi I just wanted to say hey I just watched your genshin cyberpunk thing, I’m really excited for me because I genuinely think you’ve brought new life to genshin
Also the whole raiden thing in the zandicorp thing gave me mega goosebumps+happy tears 😂
Also again really like hearing your insights on the animation process
I'm so glad you like it!!!
@@professorGoo, can you do more of this pgr ultimate review. I enjoyed watching it, btw can you please review hanying: solacetune or any gen 2 like luna: oblivion or watanabe: epitaph. They got really good ultimate animations
This list is quite old and missing a lot of the newer animations! But awesome video, man!
I'm pretty sure he's playing on a North American server, we're a year and a half behind so that means we have less characters
@@skrrskrr5386no this is an old compilation video.
@@skrrskrr5386no. Cos he is also reviewing a few which aren't global like noctis and amp 21
@@user-uq9nl2fg3c oh that's true, he probably made this awhile ago then
@@skrrskrr5386 nah i've seen some other reaction channel have react to the exact video that is shown here
The CN ultimates are sick, if you plan to make a part 2, you should definitely react to them.
It's so wonderful seeing the insights of an animator in making these media for entertainment. You get a peak of how they mix physics with exaggeration provided by the freedom of their platform.
One thing about Vera Garnet (Spear)'s ultimate that I dont think you noticed is that you watch it fly through the air and start spinning in the distance as she pulls it back to herself using electricity... You can also follow it up with her passive by holding the attack button before the animation ends as it's flying into the distance and she jumps into the air as she calls it to her hand before slamming it down on the ground and it just looks soooooooooooooooooooo goooooooooooooood!
I like how you take time to explain what's being done and why, and also what could be done better by drawing on the screen! Really cool ranking, thanks for spreading the PGR greatness ❤
Now im curious what's your opinion about the newer characters because the video you watched is kinda old
Thank you for the advance birthday gift!😁
I'd love to see you check out the un counter and executes, thats where they really shine! Side note btw that picture at the end was lee Entropy not hyperreal, they can get really confusing haha
I was surprised Lee Hyperreal won this one. His moveset is just my favourite especially his yellow orb 5:00 in his core passive.
Bro was Speach-Less looking at Luna: Oblivion 😂
Cant wait to see u rate Gen3 character , this vid only include gen1 and gen2
bro, why did you skip multiple ones ? *sad noises*
Man I was waiting for S Bianca but she never came 😭
"No way, there gonna beat this guy"
Watanabe Epitaph, Alisa Echo and Luna Oblivion in the corner:
From the New Characters coming the only ones I see getting into S or Higher for Him are Alisa, Black Rock Shooter and Lamia, maybe Qu as well
Nah, most of them aren't that good. Alisa will be rated probably same as Bianca, maybe even lower as concept is similar. Luna Oblivion isn't animation wise anyhow crazy, some VFX are good but that is not what he is rating. Luna suffers from same syndrome in terms of ults as her previous frames, fine VFX but really poor animation itself.
Watanabe could be more interesting, but i think he might rate it lower due to how pointless some part of animation feels like. Like in case of Hyperreal you have build up for another build up and that build up pays off and everything has purpose. Even most of his kit is explained in lore.
pfft still no leemao
Watanabe's looks too flashy and you can't really see the animation itself as well as Luna's. Her ultimate is even more messy, no vfx can help it. Alisa's is good but it's not beating Hyperreal.
I personally think Luna is a bit... tooooooo flashy, other than the blackhole as the highlight, I can barely see her in the animations.
Epitaph is pretty good, S tier at least but not as impactful as Hyperreal (try to ignore the DPS, only the VFX please). Really like the phase 1 ult especially, building up the suspense that would be paid off in phase 2 ult. The phase 2 ult tho...... lotta fire (which I like), but not as impressive as PULLING OUT A FOLDABLE CANNON. It's probably just circumstance.... but yeah, a minus.
Alisa Echo is sorta like Bianca Abystigma, but with quite a bit more dynamic. S -> SS (I personally like it very much), but at the end of the day it's Excalibur...... not a minus ofc, but we have plenty of them already. Generic is not necessarily good, just...... uninspiring? So to speak.
Seriously, just like the video explained, Hyperreal ult is just Masterclass in terms of compositions, perspectives and building up anticipation, let alone all the space-time cracking stuff going on. It's really difficult to top.
i REALLY wanna see him act to newer ults like lamia, watanabe epitaph, or qu shukra, these breakdowns were great
I loved when you lost it at empyrea's and hyperreal ultimates! always loved your videos so nice you got to do one about pgr!
AAhgahshshshs, it was and IS so amazing to see pgr grow in the animation section of their game!!!!
Not sure how much this matters, but if I recall, there is arole implication as to why at 7:23 he is putting all the weight of the sword on his wrist.
Basically, he is extremely strong, so strong, that he can easily use a single hand to wield that sword, and has in the past requested a second sword, so he could dual-wield, but was denied.
Ooh, missed the livestream but this should be a good one
I really would love for you to react to the more latest characters ultimates too, like, you've missed a lot.
i really like that you can literally see the progress of the games animation thru the years
I was waiting for you to do reaction abt pgr finallyyyy😭😭😭
I think Vera's bent wrist makes sense as she's adding spin to her throw like it's a javelin.
Man keeps changin the thumbnail every so often to keep the algorithm on its feet
nice to see the improvements compared to the gen 1 constructs towards the newer ones
Its interesting to get your perspective on this.
Ive played PGR for a year, and its great to just throw on for 10 minutes to do a daily routine and then do some competitive PVE on a leaderboard to rack up points with some awesome characters, though admittedly, as flashy as the game is, the animations (not the effects, but the body animations) for characters while they fight, and their ultimates (save for the later introduced gen 2-3-4 characters) are actually not that great.
they cut a LOT of corners and use a lot of visual tricks to make certain things work, like with Crimson Weave during the strike from her second ultimate she straight up just vanishes into the ground and teleports to the opposite side of her strike, but because of the cut and the speed you dont really see it.
would love to see you react to the characters that the chinese version of the game has, they are a year ahead, and the characters are GORGEOUS, far more complex in combat design by comparison, Crimson Weave is just the start, we got Lamia, Watanabe Fire, Bridget, Teddy, Qu Shukra, Luna Annihilation, Black Rock Shooter Collaboration, and we recently had an upgrade for Hanying, they are all fantastic.
Dude, all the critics make perfect sense, I hope they take your advices and make the animations better lol
Lee Hyperreal not only has the best animation for his ultimate but also he moves around while he does it and avoids almost every attack, it's so OP.
Despite the technical flaws in the early character animations, I still have a lot of respect for Kuro for putting it out there. As a creator it's so easy to get caught up in perfection that it can prevent a project from moving forward. Plus, it's kinda cool to see how far they've come with the game!
I was in this video I'm so hyped!!!!
looking forward for you to react to the other characters too, the newer ones are insane
I can't unseen the broken wrist NOO
I can't wait for you to review Wuthering Waves soon (another game from Kurogames)
You should check out the new star rail animations, they are amazing!
About the hands wrapping around more I agree, cuz nilous spin camera angle and hand movements are perfect
YOU ANIMATED THAT FIGHT SEQUENCE? AAAWWHWIUSHGLISK;WA
WAIT YOU AMINATED THAT PGR FAN ANIMATION?!
Try looking at the resonance liberation wuthering waves animation, it looks good too.
can't wait for you to see it.
Wish you also did the skin animations, they're soo good.
Whos here because of Kuro shoutout congrats
I really hope when there’s more characters you can do this again, because I was really hoping to hear your thoughts and analysis on Black★Rock Shooter’s, her signature just blows me away!
Oh my god yes, finally
This is what makes PGR good. The exhilarating combat combined with fantastic visual effects makes you want to keep playing it. Not to mention the bosses that have equally as many movesets as your characters. This game is a masterpiece. It's a shame that it is a gacha game. The gacha playerbase is not into gameplay. They are more into collecting waifu and stuff. It doesn't matter if the gameplay is bad as long as they get to collect stuff easily. Since PGR is combat-focused and likely hinder their progression because of "skill issues", i can see why PGR is not so popular.
Literally fire god for the win frfr
Thanks for talking about the hand animation that's my biggest problem right now
Congrat! Official has been recognized your video
Wait I just realized Rosetta, Kamui Tenebrion, and Camu are missing
Ye and also some newer ones that global doesn't have yet. Would love a part 2!!!!!
Well neither camu nor kamui have ults Like that. And I actually noticed a frame with rosetta's ult when he says "I'm back"(I'm assuming in the stream he took a break)
@@SapphireYuna Yeah one of the latest ones on CN are extremely interesting. And I'm quite interested to what he has to say about Luna's because it was so close to perfection yet it "felt" so off somewhere at the same time I kept investigating into it. But alas, I couldn't find where the "problem" and was hoping he'd be able to provide some enlightenment. Shame he didn't get to see them though.
I kinda wish there were Core Passive from all these characters included too because they actually have really good animations too outside of just Ultimate. And some characters like Haicma, Noan, Pulao are Uns, which are different than the rest of the characters that are Omns. Uns have Finisher Moves and I think that's worth reviewing too next time.
I’m a veteran and this is way better then Honkai Impact
In terms gameplay only, I agree 👍
@@kenjigentarou3614 thank you are you one as well
Ummm music? @@kenjigentarou3614
Except for that one herscher of sentience ult
That girl is killing it
@@unlimitedquickworks7387 well yes…..”maybe”
The video you watched didn't have Gen 2 characters from CN for some reason, so with that you missed characters like Luna Oblivion, Qu Shukra, Watanabe Epithaph and the other future characters
Wish the hold-dodge and hold-basicattack animations were shown for CW before the ult too. Former has an auto-parry and the animation for the latter is awesome. Great ult analysis, by the way!
Him and His Team did an Official PGR animation for Kuro and from it(and even His comments before reviewing Her Ult's) you can see that He knows Alpha's complete Move Set, I'm betting thier research probably involved watching Blanc and Rexlant's Popular Alpha Videos on Top of actually playing Her a bit
i like how you can tell whats Super Old and whats relatively New.
I was waiting for Scire Karenina and Crimson Weave
should've done some of the fancier skins too, the vfx on some of them are chefs kiss
You should do a pr2 for honkai star rail their new character are crazyy
hope there will be a part 2, cause some ults are missing
also can't wait to see this man checking the wuthering waves ults
I was soo much waiting for pgr one.... Pls next to wuwa too 🕊️
Hope you do wuthering waves the game kuro games are also doing, not much characters tho since it's new. Or do Aether Gazer by yostar
I really want you to do Epic 7. I think their ultimates are very good!
Yeah the moment i know you did the animation short i knew you'd do a reaction on the game. But you're missing out on the characters in CN server. Animations goes wild
common Lee W thats why he is the goat
bro your model is so good
I'm fine with the placements but still I have to point out what I think is an inconsistency with the tier list.
while most characters are judged purely by their ultimate attack animations alone, I've noticed that some are judged by not only their ultimate attack animations, but also getting bonus points from their signal orb animations and core passive animations such as with hyperreal.
Nah He just said Lee's attacks looked Cool even though He also said He couldn't tell too much of what was happening with them, He didn't say anything else about them and He did go at length about why He liked Lee's Ult just like All the Other Characters
I would love if you did the Aether Gazer ultimate skill chains! That's basically longer ultimates where 2-3 characters team up to do a big attack. There is a video that goes up to 2.2, but in CN right now we have skill chains all the way to patch 3.0, so keep that in mind. There are tons of great ones you'd miss out on.
With all analysed, and playing the game, it's kinda better to understand their personalities and character development is often reflected (intentionally or not) on their animations.
Some began strong but grew confident.
Others where clumsy but confident and became more technic.
You'll definitely like the zenless zone zero ultimates. There's a lot of anticipation in every single ult
12:49 It's ironic that Noan and Iida have the same VA in the Japanese dub
The even ironic part is
Noctis is supposed to be DMC Nero, and they even got Nero's VA
Vera also has a good catch animation when she catches her spear it shows the weight of the spear being caught
So beautiful
15:19 I'm pretty sure this is referencing the Vegeta punch meme, the camera is angled above Noctis tho so it looks like the start to an uppercut
prof. goo going from luminance to empyrea was so funny 😭 for context empyrea was around the time pgr started seeing a lot of development with how they did the characters
Ngnl. Even with old gens. If you play them together in a full quick rotations. You can still appreciate their animations.
Next please ranks Wuthering Waves
Thanks for using JP Voices, also cool video
Really surprised not to see Qu Shukra here
Thanks for the video as always, I would love to see you break down aether gazer joint ultimates, a lot of them are quite fast but I would love to see your opinion on them
9S being in his own tier is so funny. WAIT NO 2B CANT BE IN 9S’ TIER-
6:38
At this moment you know he was as extended as that Ion Cannon
Did everyone forgot Selena: Tempest?
yeah, saw her pic on the tierlist but wasn't shown
enjoyed this a lot! hope you will watch the newer chars one day
Vera: Rozen is on the list but you didn't actually review her ultimate.
bro he need to see Stigmata's maid skin ultimate, the effect just AWESOME
goo being more focused on how the scythe balances out the animation instead of Alya's boobs has gotta be the biggest green flag ever
The fact that he choose the one with thousands copy of the character doing his ult is 🔥