Grade 9 Analysis of Kamikaze by Beatrice Garland

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @Blaver
    @Blaver 6 років тому +94

    Hello sir,
    I need to say a huge thank you. English was always my weekest subject. I was getting 3s in language and 4s in lit. I was so stressed for my gcses. I studied with your videos for hours and hours a day. In the end i got an 8 in lit and a 6 in language. I would have never thought i could get such good results. I had only passed 1 language paper before the actual exam.
    Thank you for everything!!!!!!!

  • @Ettajuli
    @Ettajuli 6 років тому +50

    Hello, mr salles just wanted to say thank you so much ur videos helped me get a 9 in literature and an 8 in language which I never thought would happen

  • @ReformedChristianGirl
    @ReformedChristianGirl 3 роки тому +24

    I really love the point about the silver being linked to Judas and the Christian belief. I really appreciate how you don't just make videos based on the national curriculum and say the obvious points that they teach in school but you explore it much deeper on a more complex level. Thank you : )

  • @imaanislam8160
    @imaanislam8160 5 років тому +41

    please collab woth stacey reay that would be the ultimate grade 9 essay

  • @HighSchoolHacks1
    @HighSchoolHacks1 9 місяців тому +2

    Some extra notes here: (see more)
    water was used to clean the blade before the samurai committed seppuku (suicide), meaning that the plane he sat on was like a shrine/place to specifically commit seppuku
    The form's structure is also one large line of regular stanzas, similar to how there were 7 light carriers left in Japan's arsenal at the end of ww2, and us reading it gives a feeling as if the pilot was leaving his home behind, which were those 7 light carriers and into certain finality
    The light carriers would have probably been the home of the pilot for a long time as they were ships that were meant to launch aircraft and were useful for kamikaze because they can launch aircraft close to the enemy
    The banzai charges (land based suicide attacks), operation ten-go(water based suicide attack) and the kamikaze could be indicative to when Garland wrote the poem, like how it is in Ozymandias where the hinting of present events are presented through a lens of the last such as KGIII's tyranny represented by Ramses II in Ozymandias and in this poem, 9/11 indicated by another plane based suicide attack
    Bunting could also symbolise unwavering commitment to orders as ww2 fleets usually coordinated eachother by waving certain coloured flags to show orders such as no quarter or form a battle line
    The word "arcing" could also hint for the flash fires that Kamikaze pilots would result in if they crash into enemy ships. If a ship gets hit with a shell or a kamikaze plane, it usually doesn't split in half. But, if the shell or plane hits the ship's ammunition, it causes a flash fire that "arcs" since it's a geyser of flame that tears the ship apart, which could show a traumatic flashback from the pilot and a foreshadowing of his potential fate
    the asonance could be symbolic of a warcry of "tennou heika banzai" or "for the emperor" in which an "a" sound is stressed

  • @niralprajapati5928
    @niralprajapati5928 Рік тому +2

    never have i been this confident with a poem before. Thank you so much!

  • @dedbread1134
    @dedbread1134 2 роки тому +4

    Hi Mr Salles, I just wanted to thank you so much for helping me love English. I've always loved reading and writing stories, but when it came to high school and analysing literature I found it quite boring because I didn't understand the purpose of doing so or how to do it properly. Watching your videos has given me a much greater, in depth understanding of the purpose of literature which has helped me not only progress as a student but also as a person. I have realised that I have a much deeper knowledge of myself now, and that was a skill that I never thought I would learn from English. Thank you so much :)

  • @matthewlewiswilliams6160
    @matthewlewiswilliams6160 5 років тому +13

    sibilance could reflect the taunting idea of shame inside a samurai's mind, forcing him on

  • @macbeth455
    @macbeth455 5 років тому +12

    wow, you are the teacher i never had! thanks

  • @kyo5886
    @kyo5886 2 роки тому +1

    i love your energy during the video, its really nice to see how passionate you are :D

  • @sohaimakhan7871
    @sohaimakhan7871 2 роки тому +1

    the moment the video finished, the first thing I did was subscribe to ur channel. ur really helping, thank u so much

  • @isabel761
    @isabel761 4 роки тому +5

    could you link 'swivelled towards the sun' to the story of Icarus, perhaps suggesting that his attempt to escape his fate (as Icarus escapes from Crete) is ultimately futile as it results in his metaphorical death? or is this too far fetched?

    • @MrSallesTeachesEnglish
      @MrSallesTeachesEnglish  4 роки тому +6

      It is an interesting comparison. Icarus also defied orders - at least his father's instructions - which led to his death. The Kamikaze pilot does the same, and chooses life. This is, as you suggest, an ironic victory, as it leads to another kind of death. I think it is a great idea - which I shall steal happily!

  • @EggPotionFilms
    @EggPotionFilms 6 місяців тому

    Nice to add on that actually the pilots didn't have one way fuel. If the mission would seem to be an unlikely success, maybe there were too many battleships which would shoot the plane down if they got too close, or if they couldn't find any ships, they could always turn back, because obviously they needed to save men.

  • @greyillo2704
    @greyillo2704 5 років тому +3

    Thanks, Mr Salles!

  • @ridadari6298
    @ridadari6298 Рік тому

    this is such a beautiful poem

  • @saminaahmed3433
    @saminaahmed3433 5 років тому

    Thank you for the video!
    It has really prepared me for my practice exam for tomorrow.

  • @danielanastuta4972
    @danielanastuta4972 5 років тому +1

    This poem makes me cry 😭

  • @danielanastuta4972
    @danielanastuta4972 5 років тому +19

    Hey there , I just got this really interesting idea and I want to know if I would be able to use it or if it makes sense . Maybe he didn’t come back as there was not enough fuel for one way, therefore dying but he came back as a spirit , suggesting that he did not finish him journey in life, and the poet is implying that the mission of kamikaze is stopping young men/soldiers from finishing their journey in life by being brainwashed and sacrificing their life for a place in history. I know it says the children were taught “to be silent” and that’s why I am asking if it would be okay to use this idea 💡. Anyhow thank you so much for helping me and many more students in our long and hard journey in gcse 😂😭🤦🏼‍♀️.

    • @gracedavina8760
      @gracedavina8760 5 років тому +2

      Daniela Nastuta sounds amazing

    • @nateboness9801
      @nateboness9801 4 роки тому +2

      @Hardstuck Plat sounds like something i'd write to fill out an essay in the last 5 minutes of my English exam

  • @mannanhanda5564
    @mannanhanda5564 7 місяців тому

    Does this work?
    The use of assonance and sibilance in the beginning is confusing and overwhelms the reader. Perhaps, this is symbolic of the battle between the pilot's conscience and the world's expectations of him as a Kamikaze pilot???

  • @ufifoebjfkekehifleof6188
    @ufifoebjfkekehifleof6188 6 місяців тому

    help whats the form and structure in this poem

  • @calcpost3641
    @calcpost3641 3 роки тому

    Hi Sir
    i am a little confused by the analysis on the figure of 8, can you explain it please

  • @saminaahmed3433
    @saminaahmed3433 5 років тому +1

    Though I have one question, in what order is the poem being told (like first was the wife, and so on, and then it goes back to the wife's views)?

  • @leahrialas7365
    @leahrialas7365 5 років тому +1

    Helped me so much thank you ❤️

  • @janeylittle2787
    @janeylittle2787 6 років тому +2

    Thank you so much! Are you going to continue going through the poems?

  • @flix4809
    @flix4809 4 роки тому

    great video, helped alot- thankyou.

  • @mahimabegum3733
    @mahimabegum3733 6 років тому +9

    My target grade is a 9 but i really think i will get a 6 and i’m quite stressed. English is just so hard!! I’m taking my exams this year and i am really grateful for your videos. Hopefully i can make a large improvement! ps is anyone doing romeo and juliet and jeckyll and hyde for lit paper1?? can’t find many resources for romeo and juliet

    • @MrSallesTeachesEnglish
      @MrSallesTeachesEnglish  6 років тому +1

      I have lots on Jekyll and Hyde. I will do some Romeo and Juliet

    • @mahimabegum3733
      @mahimabegum3733 6 років тому

      Mr Salles Teaches English we’ve just started jeckyll and hyde can’t wait to use your videos. thank you so much you are so thoughtful i wish i could pay you

    • @MrSallesTeachesEnglish
      @MrSallesTeachesEnglish  6 років тому

      One day I'll get Patreon!

  • @itssarima5190
    @itssarima5190 6 років тому

    Hello Mr Salles, I just wanted to say thank you so much for helping me in English but do you have a grade 9 analysis of Blood Brothers and Christmas Carol?

  • @ISAAC____
    @ISAAC____ 6 років тому

    Thank you!

  • @meee9889
    @meee9889 6 років тому

    done my GCSE’s but love your videos

  • @musa123asad
    @musa123asad 6 років тому +1

    Do you reckon you'll have covered every poem this year?

  • @ليلى-ر6ظ3ف
    @ليلى-ر6ظ3ف 4 роки тому

    This is so helpful wow, thanks!

  • @Jamie-bm4em
    @Jamie-bm4em 6 років тому

    Please do one of these for Storm in the island sir

  • @ieatalot4189
    @ieatalot4189 9 місяців тому

    Sibilance, soundscape. I- shows his individuality, he’s resolving his conflict, and realises he wants to preserve his identity

    • @ieatalot4189
      @ieatalot4189 9 місяців тому

      Poets purpose- need it for top grades

    • @ieatalot4189
      @ieatalot4189 9 місяців тому

      What Makes a life worth living

  • @nicolemusic2242
    @nicolemusic2242 4 роки тому +3

    Thank you for your videos, could you argue that when the pilot emotionally dies(after being isolated from his family and community) that he ironically becomes a kamikaze pilot in the sense that they were taught to forget their emotions and ideas about war, to improve their fighting skills. So even though he turned back, could Garland be implying that ideas like living on in ‘history’ be failing people

  • @pratikshagurung5628
    @pratikshagurung5628 5 років тому +1

    Exam Tommorow guys

  • @lepxo1795
    @lepxo1795 5 років тому

    Would u be able to cover a Christmas Carol ?? Thankyou !!

  • @sineadharley823
    @sineadharley823 6 років тому

    Please can you do one of these for checking out me history?

  • @williamneville-jones2644
    @williamneville-jones2644 6 років тому +2

    Yo I got a grade nine in English lit in gcse !!!

    • @BobBob-qy6tl
      @BobBob-qy6tl 5 років тому +1

      William neville-jones how?

  • @basmatirollb5888
    @basmatirollb5888 6 років тому

    hi could you give me a good structure I can use and also can you write a grade 9 answer about Christmas carol

  • @TBC1599
    @TBC1599 6 років тому +2

    The soundscape analysis... that's way too airy-fairy and abstract. Like, the "a" sound doesn't make an "ah" sound - you're just exaggerating it. And how does the 'i' sound reflect identity??? You were trying to analyse these sounds but had to result to this absurd interpretation because quite simply, she just chose these words, not for alliterative purposes.
    I do understand that sound analysis has its place, but it has to be more realistic and deliberate than that (some examples here, of course, were more deliberate than others).
    And I get how you're trying to contrast these sounds, but it just seems WAY too subtle and exaggerated.

    • @MrSallesTeachesEnglish
      @MrSallesTeachesEnglish  6 років тому +2

      You don't have to like them - take what works for you, and challenge the stuff that doesn't. Identity = I is what I was getting at, but I am happy for you to reject the idea.

    • @em8136
      @em8136 5 років тому

      @@MrSallesTeachesEnglish could you mention it and use it as an alternative interpretation

    • @MrSallesTeachesEnglish
      @MrSallesTeachesEnglish  5 років тому

      @@em8136 Yes

    • @ahsiayo6015
      @ahsiayo6015 3 роки тому +4

      OK love calm down , if u don't like the idea , come up with you're own better ones

  • @roadworksahead1856
    @roadworksahead1856 6 років тому +1

    MR SALLES PLEASE REPLY!!!
    Please mark this question out of 8, I just finished watching your English language paper 1 video-
    How does the writer use language to describe Rosabel’s bus journey home?
    The write uses a compound complex sentence to convey rosabels bus journey home as long and tiring. He does this by adding several pieces of punctuation to the sentence ‘ rosabel looked out the window;the street was blurred and misty, but light....’
    This long compound complex sentence created the sense of chaos, perhaps reflecting how over wholeness rosabel was on her journey home. Perhaps this could be a message from the wrote to imply that public transport is not peaceful and empty like some of us readers may seem. However it could also suggest that rosabel is incapable of surviving a bus journey which involves crowds of people.
    The Writer also uses negative adjectives such as ‘black’ ‘greasy’ and ‘sickening’ to describe rosabels bus journey home. The adjective ‘black’ creates connotations of sinister and evil which could be suggested by the reader that public transport is not safe. The writer also uses pathetic fallacy to describe the bus journey as dreaded. The writer describes the weather as ‘dull’ ‘blurred’ and ‘misty’ which perhaps could foreshadow the outcome of rosabels journey home. This ultimately makes the reader feel sacred and increases the tension as public transport is very common so it being des tubes as negative makes the reader want to avoid it.
    PLEASE TELL ME WHAT MARK THIS WOULD BE!! I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS❤️❤️❤️❤️

    • @roadworksahead1856
      @roadworksahead1856 6 років тому

      First paragraph- ‘perhaps suggesting how OVERWHELMED rosabel was’ sorry typing error x

  • @real1cs546
    @real1cs546 4 роки тому

    btec mrbrugf