God, Your Greatest Gift to Mankind is still with Me because, actually, I love him MORR than I need him but, I DO NEED him a lot because he is just that much MORR closer that I AM to You (these thoughts work in Mine Own Celestially Earthern mind anyway)...
Cmonkey1980 no one ever really points out how brilliant his vocals are probably cause he’s more known for his incredible song writing but I totally agree I put him up there as one of the best British singers. Years of refusal made his voice really shine.
"...I know it's over And it never really began But in my heart it was so real... Love is natural and real But not for you, my love". Truer words have not been spoken for me. This live version sounds even more melancholy than the original. Is it just me?
i'm chilean, and very few people here can talk in english, because we talk in spanish, so they're smiling because the melody of the song is beautiful, but most of them don't understand what the lyrics, it's like you hear an spanish song with beautiful melody and don't know it's about a love ending...
you can tell morissey means everything he sings. he writes from the heart. he has experienced hate, love, heartache. that's what makes his music so amazing. i guess that's why at times i cry when listening to him, but at other times can't help but laugh and smile
To all those people complaining about the crowd: You should know that these is The Viña del Mar International Song Festival from Chile (my home country), which means that not all the crowd paid exclusively to see morrisey (as I would`ve done lol) And also most people don`t speak english. However I`m pretty sure there are plenty of die hard fans in there but it`s just that we can`t see them because the director keep focusing on those girls they constantly show for some reason... That, I can not defend xD Anyways this is still one of my favourite live performances of this song.
En la galucha cantabamos a todo pulmón ese temazo y emocionados, pero solo mostraban a las cuicas que solo hacian la mímica sin saber ni de que se trataba la letra, los verdaderos fans estabamos arriba cantando cada tema de verdad¡¡
Recuerdo haber estado tan triste por no haber ido a Viña ese año y tampoco haberlo visto en Santiago. Hace poco lo vi en Chile por primera vez, su voz sigue siendo increíble, se gana el escenario con su desplante. Lloré un poco ese día, pero estaba tan feliz de poderlo ver y sentir en vivo, fue maravilloso.
I love this version. You can hear those cheerful voices, giggles, laughters...And after 3:10, everyone becomes spellbound, and not even a noise is made after that point. Morrissey is really magical.
that crowd looks fake as fuck. this song has so many feels and they seem like they're attending a friggin LadyG concert lol. Morrissey at his best, regardless. Love him always!
hahaha you got that right... the problem is that show in Chile is been broadcast live to the entire country.. and the fuckin' national TV in Chile fuckin sucks..
Not in the same way we can understand. The subliminal meanings; the double-entendres that Morrissey is famous for. People who have a degree in poetic history have to decipher his lyrics. And there's no need to insult mate. I'm entitled to my opinion.
estuve ahi, y nadie se sabia ninguna cancion de Morrissey, estuve ahi y lo cante todo, se rieron de mi al lado mio por estar verdaderamente feliz de ver a mi artista favorito, y que pensaba que nunca lo vería en vivo, y estuve ahi y cante todo y me dio lo mismo, Morrissey es un lujo de esos que se dan una sola vez en la vida.
Scavenger3000 in all seriousness, it is cultural. British people see tragic music as "suicidal" whereas South Americans tend to see it as romantic 👍 it's called "ranchero" or "corrido" culture. Seeing beauty and romance, in tragedy
Dispite his flaws, etx...I love his tongue and check humor and how he reaches my soul and ends up being the only one that touches me. Tomato, tomaato. Love never dies.
why are they so happy, this song makes me remember all the things ive been through in a very young age and the days i've been outside cold and far from home and cry every time i hear it....
¡El público más apático del universo! Yo en su lugar habría estado bañada en lágrimas intentando gritar a todo pulmón la canción, pues estoy segura que tanto sollozo y suspiro me harían casi imposible articular alguna palabra. ¡GRANDE MORRISSEY! ♡ ¡Y MI CANCIÓN FAVORITA DE THE SMITHS! :,)
I saw Morrissey a few years ago and it was a great show. He is one of those rare singers who's voice hasn't changed or aged since he was a young man. I wish I could say the same for my face.
Morrissey forgot his own lyrics when he didn't say "if you're so good looking, then why are you on you're own tonight" still a beautiful song though...
Uy no da pena ajena ese público.. esa canción era para que se pararan y la cantaran a todo pulmón, pero por lo visto no la conocen y menos al que se las está cantando. u.u
Calmado viejo , es sólo mi opinión. Obviamente no todos fueron a verlo a el, simplemente que poco o nada vi algun espectador conectado con dicha presentacion. Trata de entender que no todos pueden pensar o percibir algo igual que tu.
+Emi Monte Chile es el mejor país de sudamérica actualmente, de eso no hay duda. Por eso año a año nos estamos llenando de argentinos, peruanos, bolivianos, ecuatorianos y especialmente de colombianos que no vienen a hacer absolutamente nada importante. Pero en fin. Si ese publico de mierda no cantó es porque Morrissey llegó al festival equivocado, es un festival farandulero, ideal para gente que aplaude a Shakira, Daddy Yankee. RBD, etc. Dos días después, Morrissey se presentó en el Movistar Arena en Santiago y él mismo dijo haberse impresionado por la actitud ferviente- Chilenos, qué menos se podía esperar.
Cuando vino al Festival yo tenía como 12-13 años y me agradaban ciertas canciones de Moz y los Smiths, pero no era fan. Ese día lo escuché desde mi living y me pareció bueno. Pero ahora que ya soy mayor y me metí a fondo en su música, ¡lamento profundamente no haber ido a verlo en ese momento! Por otra parte, qué maravillosa interpretación. Es uno de mis temas favoritos, y he de admitir que en esta ocasión me sacó lágrimas. Es triste ver que enfocaban a esas personas, no cachaban la profundidad y la belleza de lo que estaba frente a ellas :'(
que hubiese dado por estar allí.... Pero me conformé 3 años atrás viéndolo en la tele cuando con cuea conocía a Morrissey, y Ahora soy un Amante de el y The Smiths
Agree on that one. Besides. This is art, and a show as well. People is suppose to enjoy, not suffer it. And Morrisey himself doesn't look that "sad" actually :D.
I love The Smiths.I know just about all lyrics to their songs and watching Morrissey sing is this song is heart wrenching. You can see it's coming straight fom his heart.
You know what i really love about this band, more and more and more and more now....years after the fact.....not only is their music so meaningful, beautiful and melodious.....they also practice what they preach...how many bands can say and or lay claim to that huh! They say what they mean and mean what they say. They are multi talented and ....they are Vegan too. My hat comes off for them ~♥~
All the people in these comments complaining that the crowd are too "happy" and they're not crying their eyes out. It's music. People react to music in different ways. Maybe they're just happy to be witnessing one of the best songs off one of the best ever albums, by one of the best ever bands, performed by one of the best ever frontmen.
I miss you dad so much..sometimes it can pass one day not to think of you, but even than you are with me..in my heart, in my mind..I'm ok, don't worry about me..you know that I'll be good and strong. I love you more than my life..
Qué desagradable cuando viene alguien notable al Festival de Viña y en medio de las canciones muestran las caras de los llamados "famosos" en las primeras filas. Corta toda la inspiración.
Para su información, nunca mostraron la galería. Y fue donde quedó más la grande. Con una amiga llevamos un lienzo enorme que desplegamos entre muchos en "First of the Gang to Die" y fue lo más parecido a sentirse hooligan viendo un partido de fútbol británico. ¡Mucha euforia! Y nada comparado a lo que mostraron en la transmisión.
The words are so real. You can see Morrissey genuinely meaning every single word. Modern Poetry is an understatement as to how good this song is.
Thank you. Yes musical poetry. Wilde singing. He's so pouring his soul. ....why are they smiling?
It’s hard to find a very emotional singer like him.
God, Your Greatest Gift to Mankind is still with Me because, actually, I love him MORR than I need him but, I DO NEED him a lot because he is just that much MORR closer that I AM to You (these thoughts work in Mine Own Celestially Earthern mind anyway)...
The last song I would like to hear before I die
same
yes
Definitely a song for the funeral or death bed along with "I shall be released" by The Band.. Sad & Beautiful just like Life
Cedric Desruelles me too
Cedric Desruelles this is sad why u make me sad omg
Morrissey Cried During This...So Genuine.
he really put his heart into that. you can see how much that song really means to him.
Man, he is still such a wonderful singer. Doesn't miss a note, and that's even when he's playing around with the song a bit. What a talent!
Cmonkey1980 no one ever really points out how brilliant his vocals are probably cause he’s more known for his incredible song writing but I totally agree I put him up there as one of the best British singers. Years of refusal made his voice really shine.
There is and never will be a singer on par with Moz.
Another fleeting one-sided romance over. Still, I've always got this song to bury myself in.
+rob poynter This is why I'm here as well!
same man
It takes strength to be gentle and kind. It takes guts to write lyrics that way.
"...I know it's over
And it never really began
But in my heart it was so real...
Love is natural and real
But not for you, my love".
Truer words have not been spoken for me. This live version sounds even more melancholy than the original. Is it just me?
👍🏻
she needs you
more than she loves you!
That she doesn't love you, but she needs someone.
@@lewiswrigley8841 exactly, she is needy, not in love
@@liasz1548 but... no one needs me
it's eerie to see people grinning emptily as they experience one of the most beautiful and poignant songs ever written
Ik snap het ook niet! I
You don't understand fans enjoying beautiful music? Ok.
I love you pal..i live in bury in manchester.always been a big fan of urs..since i was a kid .im now 46..but still listen.
Okay but why is everyone in the crowd smiling I'm tearing up just watching this
They smile, Cause thay are not real fans.
+sujoymusic cause they weren't on their own that night
they're smiling for the camera cause they're posing.
they smile cause they don't undestand english
i'm chilean, and very few people here can talk in english, because we talk in spanish, so they're smiling because the melody of the song is beautiful, but most of them don't understand what the lyrics, it's like you hear an spanish song with beautiful melody and don't know it's about a love ending...
"I don't know where else I can go"
It is heartbreaking.
OMG I'm in tears..the way he treats that last line ...singing and phrasing it in different ways is a work of art
When he says he doesn't "perform", he really means it. Brilliant man.
I cry each time I listen to this song!
Me too!!! I'm actually crying right now...best song ever!
cakmakypn I always break up when he gets to the 'it's so easy to laugh...' bit
This song got me through high school over and over again...I think I might owe Morrissey my life...must be why I've seen him 27times in concert
such a magnificent song performed by a breath taking artist
This song breaks my heart but I feel a little better after listening to it .
you can tell morissey means everything he sings. he writes from the heart. he has experienced hate, love, heartache. that's what makes his music so amazing. i guess that's why at times i cry when listening to him, but at other times can't help but laugh and smile
Love is natural and real,but not for you my love,
Not tonight my love...
Love is natural and real, but not for such as you and i my love🎶
I had almost forgotten how much I loved him till I watched this and it all came flooding back.
This Song ALWAYS Destroys Me...So Many Should've Beens Turned Into Nothing...
To all those people complaining about the crowd:
You should know that these is The Viña del Mar International Song Festival from Chile (my home country), which means that not all the crowd paid exclusively to see morrisey (as I would`ve done lol)
And also most people don`t speak english. However I`m pretty sure there are plenty of die hard fans in there but it`s just that we can`t see them because the director keep focusing on those girls they constantly show for some reason... That, I can not defend xD
Anyways this is still one of my favourite live performances of this song.
:)
You don't have to explain, the people complaining are idiots.
At 0:45 looks like he's going to cry because none of these people know this beautiful song! I want to cry watching those people !
En la galucha cantabamos a todo pulmón ese temazo y emocionados, pero solo mostraban a las cuicas que solo hacian la mímica sin saber ni de que se trataba la letra, los verdaderos fans estabamos arriba cantando cada tema de verdad¡¡
Sí, los de Viña solo graban a la gente de primera fila que está ahí únicamente para hacerse notar.
Recuerdo haber estado tan triste por no haber ido a Viña ese año y tampoco haberlo visto en Santiago. Hace poco lo vi en Chile por primera vez, su voz sigue siendo increíble, se gana el escenario con su desplante. Lloré un poco ese día, pero estaba tan feliz de poderlo ver y sentir en vivo, fue maravilloso.
Takes only morrisseys lyrics to get my attention. A genius!! He is due for a hug after a song like this. Thanks Moz!!
This always makes me cry, it's so sad ... Yet the crowd seem to be ecstatic.
The best version I've heard. And I've heard it a thousand times.
he is so precious
He touched me again...with his invisible hands.. but with his heart. great love and respect...
one of the best live performances i've seen of this song.
I love this version. You can hear those cheerful voices, giggles, laughters...And after 3:10, everyone becomes spellbound, and not even a noise is made after that point. Morrissey is really magical.
This is rare.
Really beautiful performance, shows he's still got it, all these years on and still a great live singer.
From 4:30 in is the best he's sang since The Smiths. that's very technical singing he's doing there not easy to do in that range
His voice has vastly improved since The Smiths.
I guess u havnt heard ANY of his solo stuff. His voice vastly improved after the smiths
the ending. he sang so good
4:25 Estaba bostezando la muy forra? Sabés lo que daría por escuchar este tema en vivo !! :@
XD
that crowd looks fake as fuck. this song has so many feels and they seem like they're attending a friggin LadyG concert lol.
Morrissey at his best, regardless. Love him always!
hahaha you got that right... the problem is that show in Chile is been broadcast live to the entire country.. and the fuckin' national TV in Chile fuckin sucks..
I don't think they understand what he's singing about, because they speak Spanish...
Christopher Gillett And that ,means they absolutely just can't understand any English, right? You're so dumb.
Not in the same way we can understand. The subliminal meanings; the double-entendres that Morrissey is famous for. People who have a degree in poetic history have to decipher his lyrics. And there's no need to insult mate. I'm entitled to my opinion.
Christopher Gillett I agree with you completely.
how dare anyone show up and not know the words.
and still smile on those sadest parts of the song...
Fucking assholes
The people in the video, not you guys
Maybe they dont speak english
@@generalsarco4035 yeah they didnt
Love is natural and real, but not for such as you and I.
At least we have the mutual understanding of misery, and nobody can take that away.
If proof were ever needed that the voice never ages
I have always loved Morrissey for being such an emotional and sentimental artist, he gives everything on stage. He puts all that he is in his music.
Que gran privilegio haberlo tenido en este festival ❤
estuve ahi, y nadie se sabia ninguna cancion de Morrissey, estuve ahi y lo cante todo, se rieron de mi al lado mio por estar verdaderamente feliz de ver a mi artista favorito, y que pensaba que nunca lo vería en vivo, y estuve ahi y cante todo y me dio lo mismo, Morrissey es un lujo de esos que se dan una sola vez en la vida.
Love is natural and real but not for you my love, not tonight my love...
Why the f**k are you dancing and smiling like you were listening to Tom Jones? This is beautifully tragic and intense...
Scavenger3000 actually when I saw the mozzer preform Tom Jones was in the line up. lol
so you are telling people how to react to music? You must like to hear yourself criticize others. weak
Omg...it was a spontaneous "why you do that?"..."criticize" is a big word...relax!
Scavenger3000 South Americans aren't miserable British twats. Different cultures
Scavenger3000 in all seriousness, it is cultural. British people see tragic music as "suicidal" whereas South Americans tend to see it as romantic 👍 it's called "ranchero" or "corrido" culture. Seeing beauty and romance, in tragedy
RIP ANDY ROURKE ❤
to give such a soulful performance in front of such an indifferent crowd truly magical
HIS VOICE IS AWESOME...LOVE HIM!!!
Apart from the rank version this is without doubt the 2nd best ....the crowd are as fake as a bag of saggy quims though
Listen to the thank your lucky stars version it's another live cd. You'll thank me later 😉
My favourite Morrissey performance, so much emotion so true. Legend
Tal vez tengo una mala percepción, o no veo bien, pero este concierto está lleno de gente que no se nota emocionada en lo absoluto :(
Dispite his flaws, etx...I love his tongue and check humor and how he reaches my soul and ends up being the only one that touches me. Tomato, tomaato. Love never dies.
why are they so happy, this song makes me remember all the things ive been through in a very young age and the days i've been outside cold and far from home and cry every time i hear it....
great song, beautiful people, brilliant viewing... and amazing vocals from Moz
Theres people singing but the cameras are focusing on the posers
Thy would right lol
¡El público más apático del universo!
Yo en su lugar habría estado bañada en lágrimas intentando gritar a todo pulmón la canción, pues estoy segura que tanto sollozo y suspiro me harían casi imposible articular alguna palabra. ¡GRANDE MORRISSEY! ♡ ¡Y MI CANCIÓN FAVORITA DE THE SMITHS! :,)
My favorite mellow/heartbreaking tune. Love the unique style of Morrissey´s music!!
Nadie se enteró de lo que estaba sucediendo ahí?
I saw Morrissey a few years ago and it was a great show. He is one of those rare singers who's voice hasn't changed or aged since he was a young man. I wish I could say the same for my face.
Morrissey forgot his own lyrics when he didn't say "if you're so good looking, then why are you on you're own tonight" still a beautiful song though...
vasquez. i. He shortened it you twit as he used to when he was in the smiths
One of the best songs of all time! Sang to absolute perfection!! Goosebumps every time I see this!!
Uy no da pena ajena ese público.. esa canción era para que se pararan y la cantaran a todo pulmón, pero por lo visto no la conocen y menos al que se las está cantando. u.u
Calmado viejo , es sólo mi opinión. Obviamente no todos fueron a verlo a el, simplemente que poco o nada vi algun espectador conectado con dicha presentacion. Trata de entender que no todos pueden pensar o percibir algo igual que tu.
Ausland
ok no problem ;)
+GUILLO TINA Chilenos, q mas podes esperar...
+Emi Monte Chile es el mejor país de sudamérica actualmente, de eso no hay duda. Por eso año a año nos estamos llenando de argentinos, peruanos, bolivianos, ecuatorianos y especialmente de colombianos que no vienen a hacer absolutamente nada importante. Pero en fin. Si ese publico de mierda no cantó es porque Morrissey llegó al festival equivocado, es un festival farandulero, ideal para gente que aplaude a Shakira, Daddy Yankee. RBD, etc. Dos días después, Morrissey se presentó en el Movistar Arena en Santiago y él mismo dijo haberse impresionado por la actitud ferviente- Chilenos, qué menos se podía esperar.
Cuando vino al Festival yo tenía como 12-13 años y me agradaban ciertas canciones de Moz y los Smiths, pero no era fan. Ese día lo escuché desde mi living y me pareció bueno. Pero ahora que ya soy mayor y me metí a fondo en su música, ¡lamento profundamente no haber ido a verlo en ese momento!
Por otra parte, qué maravillosa interpretación. Es uno de mis temas favoritos, y he de admitir que en esta ocasión me sacó lágrimas. Es triste ver que enfocaban a esas personas, no cachaban la profundidad y la belleza de lo que estaba frente a ellas :'(
I can't help quotiing you, cause everything that you say rings true💖
All you have to do is look at the crowd , it’s special , you can see and feel the way they connect . He’s that good
gracias por subir todos tus videos de MOrrissey en viña.
Can easily listen to this over and over. The Smiths is magical music. Morrissey's lyrics and vocals can transform any mood.
que hubiese dado por estar allí.... Pero me conformé 3 años atrás viéndolo en la tele cuando con cuea conocía a Morrissey, y Ahora soy un Amante de el y The Smiths
Hipsters wanna cry to this song to seem deep, to add depth to the soul. Let the crowd smile if they want, they're happy.
Agree on that one. Besides. This is art, and a show as well. People is suppose to enjoy, not suffer it. And Morrisey himself doesn't look that "sad" actually :D.
No way! This is a very fuckin sad song which deserves the hottest tears ever cried!
Ok, just a joke... or maybe not
I love this song, but man...drags my heart over broken glass and hot coals.
I love The Smiths.I know just about all lyrics to their songs and watching Morrissey sing is this song is heart wrenching. You can see it's coming straight fom his heart.
It’s so easy to laugh it’s so easy to hate it takes strength to be gentle and kind
so easy to hate takes goods to be gentle and kind. So true and profoundly true
I think the song says 'guts' .. same meaning as when it says 'strenght'
Estuve ahí, fue increíble la presentación de Morrissey!
Moz gracias por tu musica..IDOLO.
I got to hear this live in Dallas in 1986 with the Smiths. How nice to hear it live again.
Lovely plaintiff quality to Morrissey's voice. He's living every word of that song. Band is great as well an Morrissey can pull off a red shirt
bravo...este senor!!! que letras mas poeticas
To those people complaining about people grinning and smiling, is because they can’t hide the joy of seeing him!
Morrissey stop it! I'm drenched in tears
I would be bawling my eyes out❤❤❤
Que publico de mierda! La mujer en el minuto 4:00 esta dichosa, totalmente fuera de lugar. Hermosa la versión igual, muchas gracias por compartir.
He's beautiful 😍😍 so perfect !!!
Es hermoso, nunca lo he visto en vivo, pero parece que siempre canta sus canciones con el corazón en la mano, es magnifico.
You know what i really love about this band, more and more and more and more now....years after the fact.....not only is their music so meaningful, beautiful and melodious.....they also practice what they preach...how many bands can say and or lay claim to that huh! They say what they mean and mean what they say. They are multi talented and ....they are Vegan too. My hat comes off for them ~♥~
Mozzer that was beautifully sung. Heartbreaking! Band sound ace as well.
It's so easy to laugh, It's so easy to hate...
It takes strength to be gentle and kind... 💙
¡Wow! Canto este tema a gritos, no comprendo como no disfrutaron de la misma manera estando en vivo.
lo mejor de ese año en el festival! lejos!!
All the people in these comments complaining that the crowd are too "happy" and they're not crying their eyes out. It's music. People react to music in different ways. Maybe they're just happy to be witnessing one of the best songs off one of the best ever albums, by one of the best ever bands, performed by one of the best ever frontmen.
Very awesome video was uploaded on my birthday
I miss you dad so much..sometimes it can pass one day not to think of you, but even than you are with me..in my heart, in my mind..I'm ok, don't worry about me..you know that I'll be good and strong. I love you more than my life..
I think this is my favorite song of morrissey. This song is exactly what i feel everyday :)
By far the awesomeness cannot be measured, got me thru some hard days.
MAESTRO, !SI SUPIERAN LO QUE DICE ESA CANCIÓN¡..........,! ES PARA LLORARLA¡........, LA VOZ NO LE CAMBIA, ESTOS SON LOS CANTANTES DE VERDAD..........
14 people couldn't quite realise when it was over.
he seems nostalgic looking when he sang it ...thats me i guess=p
Qué desagradable cuando viene alguien notable al Festival de Viña y en medio de las canciones muestran las caras de los llamados "famosos" en las primeras filas. Corta toda la inspiración.
Para su información, nunca mostraron la galería. Y fue donde quedó más la grande. Con una amiga llevamos un lienzo enorme que desplegamos entre muchos en "First of the Gang to Die" y fue lo más parecido a sentirse hooligan viendo un partido de fútbol británico. ¡Mucha euforia! Y nada comparado a lo que mostraron en la transmisión.