The fact that Alex lies about that not being his voice on the kennel and then supposedly realizing some “man’s voice” was apparently heard with Maggie and Paul down at the kennels (three minutes before they die) basically says everything. He’s guilty. Anyone who doesn’t see that is just foolish. Any other human father would be yelling “HOW DO WE FIND OUT WHO THAT IS!! Can I see the video!!!! Let me hear it!!!!”
Good point! I mean at that time, I don’t believe they had the video yet, they just had Rogan’s statement that he had heard a male’s voice. But if Alex wasn’t there, his reaction should be: let’s find out who it was, let’s talk to Rogan and see exactly what he had heard!
I believe that is why they came there in the first place. That’s why the lawyer said ,”I thought this was an update”. And tried to get him to shut up because he realized Alex was a suspect.
This man has to have ice running through his veins. Imagine picking up a shotgun, holding it steady enough to aim it at your son's head, knowing you are about to kill your own son and pulling the trigger TWICE. Then picking up the next gun, after you just blew your son's head off, aim it at your wife, keep the gun steady, and pull the trigger FIVE times. Then, the nerve to proclaim your innocence and put all your friends, acquaintances and family through a trial, subjecting them to the horror you created, just so you can get away with murder and live your life.
@@jenriordan He was a pill head about to be exposed for all kinds of financial problems and theft. He also didn't want to lose his law license. He definitely killed them.
Gotta love how his lawyer was firmly at his defense before the interview started...by the 20 minute his lawyers vibe totally changes as he looks directly at his client as he answers and his head sinks and he sits back as he realizes Alex wreaks of guilt. 😅
And that lawyer is Corey Fleming who has since been indicted on a whole host of crimes and has had his law license suspended. The low country is cleaning house!
That "lawyer" , Corey Fleming, who is trying to help Alex dodge questions is also his crime buddy helping Murdaugh scam clients and dividing up the money.
Alex had an attorney with him the night it happened. Like what? Who would care about a lawyer when you had just found your family dead. Also who wouldn't immediately tell police go protect my mom and my other son, someone is trying to kill us! He had zero fear about the rest of his family?
@@jewelsmall910 And lost his license to practice law too! No wonder he was so concerned about Alex being interviewed as a suspect. I loved in the beginning of the interview, when the lawyer tried to take over the interrogation, by demanding the police give THEM the information FIRST before Alex would answer their questions. No Sir, you do not run the police investigation!
"I am not comfortable you asking him questions as a suspect" as if it is possible to avoid any form of investigation on the murder of your immediate family..
In the US he has the right to remain silent and have an attorney representing him, Alec and his friend/attorney should taken advantage of his Miranda rights and left.
@@psfanboy79 He knows he's done, when you're there you will talk in the end. As weird as it seems. You are not smarter than this lawyers. They are still human. 99% of the people will talk, guilty or not.
@@TeaSpiracy If they'd pressed him too hard they risked him ending the interview. He's a top lawyer with his own uber expensive lawyer sat next to him. They've gotta play it safe at this point.
@@golfer5636 no I meant now and days.... I be busy is the now and days and between work at night it is more of a nap then a good rest so who doing it now and days not as in nowadays as in general present time.
I seriously think that this lying narcissist thought he was really going to get away with it. He thought he was powerful and untouchable. I’m so glad that justice was served on a person like this. This case gives me a little more hope and trust in our justice system
they just sacraficed one of their own to make you think that justice still exists, at a point he talked too much and they couldn't help him ... work on waking up
Thank God his son filmed that video just before he died. Without even realising it he was proving his dad was guilty!!! What a pathetic man! Just evil. His wife and son had absolutely no chance
I dunno, maybe he DID realize something was amiss with his Dad that day and that's why he recorded the video. Honestly, the video doesn't make sense otherwise because it's not really focusing on anything particular. It's almost like Paul felt he needed to record at that moment.
@@cardbored_ I believe Paul took that video to send to the owner because he thought the dog may have hurt his tail. If you listen to the testimony of his friend Rogan Gibson (the dog’s owner) he mentions Paul had been texting him about his concern for the dog’s tail and said he would send a video later that night. Nevertheless, good timing on the video.
It kills me that every time he is questioned, he fake cries for a minute then siffs snot and clears his throat the rest of the interview. Like that will somehow touch the hearts of the police.
Remember he's also an opioid addict. He's snorting it!! Just eating pills does not get them high enough, so they snort it. He couldn't use needles, doctors notice track marks...wives too.
Was he doing coke, too? His snot noises might have been intentional to deflect/distract from questions. Clear memories for distracting stories, “can’t recall” for most all of the important questions.
That is not fake crying, in my opinion. Alex is a hugely conflicted man, granted. His conflict lies within himself, not with Maggie and Paul. The body language that is being read all over the place needs to take this into account. Any evidence of lying, in my opinion, is that he knows he is conflicted within himself, and his lies are to hide from himself. This sounds complicated, I know. He may be guilty of many other things. I doubt he killed Maggie and Paul.
He killed Paul to get the family out of a trial, which might affect Buster, and he killed Maggie to spare her the abject disgrace & humiliation of losing her status in the community and all her money. Maggie having to work at the local Costco would have really killed her.
He killed Maggie because she was gathering financial records, had seen a divorce lawyer, AND was staying in one of their other homes...unsure if living apart for state pre-divorce requirements or irreconcilable differences.
@@megatkins6143 Yes.. I also thought that too. As I don't think he thought he was going to have to shoot Paul twice..then have the Explosion that happened..he then panicked..as you can tell by 5 shots with Maggie..he panicked..
It’s so odd that he can’t remember anything specific about his last dinner, last conversations & last moments with his son and wife. Something so traumatic would make it so that your memory retains EVERY SINGLE TINY DETAIL!!!!
He’s most likely lying about the conversations of that evening-can’t say how long he planned this but he did call Maggie take day and asked her to come home per her sister’s testimony on the stand-then he says here Maggie was worried for him-he lured her and Paul to their deaths.
They don’t care just see money and obviously if they are cheating all about the mistress.. look up what Chris watts done!! As the lawyer said just get a divorce but obviously wanted the money from the house for him and his mistress
And boats too! He said that Paul constantly misplaced boats, from one end of the state to the other. It would be nothing for Paul to drive the boat to Columbus and leave it there after the weekend with his friends. What?? He must have been so wasted that he couldn't find where he left his own boat, so he just left it there. Wow!
Never once does he refer to Paul as paw paw in this video like he constantly did during the trial to convince the jury that he had an affectionate name for Paul to garner sympathy from the jury
He never ever said pawpaw in any interviews until the stand. And even then it sounded fake. And no one has ever said that was a nickname for Paul not buster, John Marvin or his aunt.
I can’t imagine how these detectives do it! I mean I’m proud of them! However, when they’re sitting there in front of “the killer” and they asking reasonable questions and he’s answering them like he’s covering them up. I mean these detectives have BALLS of STEEL!! Bravo sir ! Bravo!
Agree. And if you want to see a textbook interrogation of a powerful yet guilty man, check out Sgt. Smyth of the Canada Prevential Police as he tears down massive pervert and killer Col. Williams of the Canada Air Force. Williams smelled hundreds of little girl panties and bras he stole from neighbors homes before he graduated to killing two women as he filmed killing them. Sgt. Smyth is a master interrogator and his work against Williams is being used in police acadamies around the world. I've watched it 3 times trying to anaylize it and it's mezmerizing.
Hampton County South Carolina business people, judges and law enforcement officials are complicit with helping Alex Murdaugh perpetuate his crimes especially his financial crimes... a lot more people should be going to jail for their misdeeds.
Maybe they will...they can't arrest them and try them during this trial anyways. Hopefully he goes down for the other sketchy deaths he was linked to as well.
Just look at the Stephen Smith death/murder on the Murdaugh Murders Podcast. The complicity in his death involves people from all levels within the legal system in that town from officers, Randy Murdaugh, the local coroner and even judges. Many have since quit or moved to pastures new for clear and obvious reasons. Heads should roll if that case ever gets to a court. It all seems to be allegedly linked to Buster who was supposedly in a relationship with Stephen and for obvious reasons the family did not want this to be publicised.
The level of greed is far beyond what most people can imagine. It becomes a little more understandable when we remember, “This is an attorney”Greedy people are over represented in law school, and they don’t get better when they graduate.
@@jenriordan that's not enough. He cries. Not every killer, especially a family killer, is emotionless. Also, they already made it clear that this guy could cry while representing his injured clients in court.
He knows he’s in trouble when key fob clocks him going in the office at 5:30. First sign of Alex not knowing what to say and registering that this detective don’t believe him no more. It’s very telling. He told a LOT of lies in this interview. Innocent people do not lie like that.
When AM was shot in the head he was extremely detailed on his assailant He remembered a type of gun, a type of car, definitely not a Ford, the man who shot him was good looking, the man was a very nice man, or thought he was. Now, as a emergency room nurse a patient with a head wound is either screaming, mute, rambling. We are trained to keep our patient calm. If our patient is not compliant we give them a mild sedative. There is exception to the rule. Here AM is volunteering minute details in this stressful position.
His lawyer did advise him not to, weren’t you listening? His attorney threw a fit in the beginning of this interview but Alex said he wanted to do it in an attempt to appear not guilty.
He thinks if he makes noises like he’s been crying that it would make the fake crying more believable. He keeps clearing his throat and sniffing like his tears were real. This has the reverse effect on me and makes me despise him even more. This man is such a terrible awful person. I’m glad he’s in prison.
That noise he’s making when he sucks in through his nose, that throat nasal mucus noise. My biggest pet peeve, I’m raging here but I can’t get enough of this at the same time. So fascinatingly evil
I think it's impossible to know how he should act since people grieve in different ways...and he is obviously grieving in my opinion. This being the first time I've heard him speak he is different than how I imagined he'd be...much more soft spoken. Much less like a monster or mad man. You can be a liar and thief without being a killer. With no physical evidence I'd be hard pressed to find him guilty....just not 100% convinced.
@@kathyann8974 Well, of course he’s trying to play all meek and mild...this is an interrogation, after all. The evidence is compelling...his father’s carer told the court that Alex visited that night (very unusual) and, although he was there for only 20 minutes, asked her to say he’d been there *twice* as long as that (just in case * anyone asked).* Sounds like he was setting up an alibi for himself. His voice was clearly heard on recording which placed him at the kennels, which he’s doggedly disputed, at the time of the murders. I’ve been watching his body language throughout and none of it adds up. Notice how controlled his ‘weeping’ is, how he surreptitiously peeks at whoever he’s with to gauge whether his performance is being bought. But that’s just my opinion..
Yeah I agree its like his an outsider to it basically, but he has the same tendencies as most killers, they fake cry but have a lot of memory loss that specific day, watching several crime interviews its easy to see tell tale signs, 🤡🤡
@@ravenblue7805 there’s no compelling evidence whatsoever that he murdered them, quite the contrary actually, and reading body language is not a good way to gauge anything about anybody.
I'm actually shocked that Murdaugh kept on with this interview and that his lawyer didn't advise him to stop--it becomes pretty obvious, despite what they say at the beginning, that the questions are focused mostly on him.
Not his lawyer. That's his friend. Watch his body language abou 20 minutes into the video as he realizes Murdaugh is guilty....... this one's a classic.
It is heartbreaking to think what Paul and Maggie had to go through in their final moments. The pain and the realization that your father/husband is going to kill you...may they rest in peace and let's hope they get justice 🧡
@@hmq9052 I think it's about several things. Alex's financial crimes were about to be revealed and he lost his job, Paul's boat case was troublesome, expensive and coming up for processing and Alex hadn't told Maggie everything, so the separation was possible with the revelations. Alex is also clearly very selfish and inconsiderate of others and used to the privileges of his position. It was all falling apart, so here's the end result.
Guilty guilty guilty... I mean this guy's family is murdered and he can't give a straight answer on anything how many times does he say "I can't remember"
I'm sorry but how dont you recall the very last moments you spent with your wife and son before they are brutally murdered?? I still have vivid memories of me with my dad on the day he died! And that was over 20 yrs ago and he died of natural causes! Those last moments you spent together are going to be playing through your head the second you find out something happened to them unless you're stuck replaying a darker more sinister memory from that day
I agree. The last words I heard from my mom before when died were when someone at the hospital gave her the phone and she said, "Hi baby..." Then she never said anything else. I remember the tone, everything. It runs through my head several times a week. Alex would be going over everything that was said/done trying to see if he could remember a shred of evidence to help find the killer.
It's unbelievable 😳 how can you forget that? The first interview he had with the police just when the first responders came, he didn't remember anything and now we know that he was there , and he visited his mom for less than 30 minutes but asked the lady to say to lie about the time, why? If there is nothing to hide?
I think he is guilty, but it actually isn't uncommon in a trauma to forget or even unintentionally block information like this. His mind would have been flooded and overwhelmed with adrenalin when he found them. I can tell you that I, right now, with no trauma, couldn't tell you what the last thing I said to my husband and kids was this morning before they left. If I came home and found them the way these folks were found I would HATE that I can't remember, but I wouldn't be able to.
@Dave P He didn't seem to have a problem with his memory. He was a successful lawyer and was able to scam millions from his clients. He kept a lot of balls in the air at once and still had the time, energy, and forethought to show up to all the kids' games. He remembers the details of that night.
Alex completely ignored his friend/lawyer’s advice during this interview. It makes me wonder if Alex will take the stand against his lawyer’s advice. Alex seems to need control over every situation.
He will take the stand, because he's a " lawyer " and will persuade them with his scintillating intellect and his down-home folksy charm... Of COURSE he'll take the stand. He's a narcissist!
because in these interrogations, the suspect always thinks being more talkative and open makes he/she look innocent and that they are trying to help. You should never talk to police,period. (im glad he did though!)
No he’s just doing his job. He was hired to defend Alex. Allowing Alex to be interrogated by homicide detectives is not something a good attorney is going to allow. Attorney did nothing wrong.
@projectkj7643 if you are paying for a lawyer to defend you it's going to be expected they defend you in anyway possible innocent or guilty .I'm just glad the lawyer let him talk his way into a conviction.
Alex’s voice is very slapstick when pretending to be sad which I’ve seen with other murderers. On another point, who apologises to Police when they attend a scene. It wasn’t as if it was a noisy party!
This man is literally a walking contradiction of himself. The pure evil in his heart and undertaking the unthinkable to his poor wife and son.. standing in front of each of them as he pulled the trigger to take their lives away from them... One can only imagine the literal disbelief and heartbreak they would have both felt before their souls left their bodies. May they rest in peace and may Alex be tormented until his final end. There are no words for what he has committed and then blatantly sits and lies and lies and lies..
You know, I've thought of that so much. I have three children and would die before I'd harm a hair on their pointy heads. (All adults, and there have surely been times I thought I could knock their heads together). And my sweet husband? For him to catch my eye knowing he's in my cross hairs would be infinitely more cruel than the blood clot that killed him. I will never grasp Alex's mindset or the cruelty.
@@pla5730 but not answering, a refusal to talk based on the grounds you may incriminate yourself, cannot be used against you. It COULD make you look guilty. Or it could also be indicative of you don’t trust police and think they’ll spin anything you say against you.
"Not if my times are right." 30:45 That's all I need to hear to know he was guilty. No one - nobody - would respond like this. That's the moment his house of cards fall. His friend/lawyer realizes this as his body language speaks volumes, literally subconsciously distancing himself from a killer once he realizes he's guilty. Alex clutching onto his right dominant arm is a guarded body language, where he's literally holding himself back and in a defensive prose - his right hand in a fist showing anger at the realization he's been caught.
Who else knows Maggie, Paul and Bubba that sounds exactly like Alex? Buster lied on the stand to protect his father as we all know that voice is Alex. Buster should not be allow to practice law imo as he lied under oath making a mockery of the integrity of justice system he will not protect.
His friend/lawyer with him was indicted after this interview took place. Not sure exactly when after it. I think his name is Corey Fleming I believe. He also lost his licence to practice law.
IF it was anyone else: Alex would have been with Paul and Maggie when the murders were committed as evidenced by the Snapchat video. So then Alex was spared, and he knows who did it. He would have been a witness. Or if you still don't believe it was him, we know he left the house at 9:06 according to the OnStar evidence. So he had to have heard SEVEN gunshots and then left the house without checking on his wife or son. If someone was waiting for Alex to leave the house to ambush Paul and Maggie, how would they know how long he would be gone? If they saw him leave, how would they know he wouldn't turn around because he forgot something. So then they had to find the family guns, ammo, find Maggie and Paul, kill them and leave before Alex returned.
There is no evidence to prove who the guns belong to. All that was made clear is that it was the same style weapons that they own. It's amazing how hard it is for some of yall to follow things that were made clear throughout the case. This feed is full of waterheads
There's nothing u can do to cover up that much suspicion. And his lawyer friends, silly for thinking they could get him out of this. How are people this evil??
@@geebee3100 😂Bet you feel a bit daft now. It amazes me that people say that when the evidence was clearly overwhelming. Many people fooled by his lies and crocodile tears.
@@katjagolden893 No. Not official suspects. Not even official persons of interest (POI). The police have to officially name suspects and POIs. If a family member or whatever can be ruled out right away, they are not named either of those. So no, not everyone is a "suspect". They need evidence (physical or circumstantial) to name someone a suspect.
Everytime he knows he's given away some piece of information that's put him in a compromising position he clears his throat: almost as if to clear his head to strategise and rethink how to twist what he has previously said and now make it fit.
I'm guessing here.. so, when you're the one on the spot, trying to focus on acting out a lie for a prolonged period of time, controlling your body movements while trying to bend the truth becomes difficult and taxing. Eventually one or the other has to give.
For the love of god The way this man talks How the heck was he able to get a Lawyers license Whoever gave it to him Must have been blind deaf and mute Unbelievable I bet his father bought it for him It's the only way possible What Money can buy
IF you believe that Alex did NOT commit these murders, you'd have to believe either a) the killer coincidentally showed up a moment after Alex left - assuming he was there up to the minute according to his recorded voice, or b) the killer was waiting for Alex to leave…. in which case he wouldn't have known Alex was going to leave at all. So why wouldn't the killer kill all 3?
@@brittneysurber2813 Also, there is no factual evidence, hereunto, that has presented on behalf of the defense to refute any possibility of A). Alex did the crime!
D) The killer decided to kill Paul never mind killer did not know who was in the house or on the property at that moment. Also the killer was after Paul only but had zero problem hunting down an innocent person Maggie who happened to be at the scene. Also that property was first class. Killer took a huge risk not knowing what secret cameras and security, etc were on all those buildings and property etc.
The clincher for me is he was at the kennel just mins before they were murdered and of coarse lied about it plus Maggie didnt want to come back to the house but Alex insisted she come, and same with Paul he told him he needed to come home. hmm? Motive? The lawsuit would be dropped now that Paul is dead and Alex would collect 9 million if Maggie was to die.
"I found out after the reason Maggie came down was cause she was worried about me".... *Bold face Lie* Sled: "what happened to the clothes you were wearing when you and Paul were playing with the tree" Alex: "I don't remember playing with a tree..." .... *Bold face lie* Who else thinks this man isn't GUILTY??? I mean there are 2 bold face lies and being deceptive in a 3 min span. Innocent people don't lie about questions he would obviously know the answer to. He knew him and Paul were messing with that tree and he knew Paul recorded it. That's not a minute detail. That's one of the last moments he had with his son and yet forgot it??? GUILTY!
I think he's probably guilty, but there is still a lack of physical evidence and his defence has done a pretty good job of creating reasonable doubt. SLED haven't been the best at evidence collecting either.
@D S R Ughh I'm so tired of people using that physical evidence bs. There is a mountain of evidence that points to him being guilty. Shoot even a few of them on their own is enough to convince a reasonable person to see that he's guilty. Just because there is no physical evidence in a murder doesn't mean you can't convict someone. There is like 20+ things that directly point to his guilt and all the lies he's told. Use common sense, if a guy is lying about a bunch of crucial details that an innocent man WOULD NOT lie about then it shows he was behind it. So let me ask you about 3 specific lies he's told and then how you can say "you're not sure"....1. He said that Maggie came down on her own to be with him when in fact he was the one who had her come and she was even saying to a friend it was really suspicious and he was up to something. 2. He told the police he didn't remember "playing with a tree" when in fact that was one of the last moments he spent with his youngest child before he was murdered which he obviously remembered and is in fact lying about, 3. The snap chat video where he was clearly there right before their murders. Now how on earth can you even just look at those 3 details of him caught in bold face lies and say you don't think there is enough to say he's guilty??? And that was literally like 3 things out of a pile of evidence that points directly to him. Also do you not realize that innocent people don't lie to investigators, especially about something your family was victim to? One lie ok you could say maybe it was a mistake but he has been caught in so many lies. I just don't understand people who actually say there is reasonable doubt. In my mind any doubt would be UNreasonable!
This is a good point. If I'd found 2 family members, obviously dead, on my property and I knew there was no other family there, I'd be driving out of there as fast as I possibly could. They're dead and I can't help them. I'm leaving before I'm dead too. I can't believe how he was comfortable enough to just be standing there when police showed up. You wouldn't catch me doing that, even if I had killed them. I'd be losing my mind with those bodies right there.
Maggie's sister said in court he was carrying a gun on him at all times as they all thought the family might be being targeted so why did he have to go back to the house to get a gun when he had one on him anyway? If it wasn't on him it would have been in his car.
So we are supposed to believe that a random killer knew that paul and Maggie would be at the kennels, at that specific time and they forgot to take their own weapons, hoping there would be some hanging about 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️
He’s making it sound like Maggie spent the night with him at Moselle? She was at the beach house and only came to Moselle after he called her to lure her to her death.
@@geebee3100 the media? What fvcking media? He called both Maggie and Paul to come up to Moselle. They were not there with him, Maggie told two people that she didn’t really want to go to Moselle. He summoned Paul to Moselle and they both end up being murdered there and he’s the only survivor. The English word for that is lured.
Question: Alex said in this interview and also in his second interview Maggie was at Moselle the morning of her death. Isn't this a proven lie. Her sister said Alex wanted her to come and she arrived after her Dr. Appt. At Moselle. Somebody please help me out. Was he lying about this? I think he was lying because he did not want investigators to know he lured her out to Moselle on date her death.
Based on what I have read he's lying. What I've read is that Maggie was living separate from him at the time at one of their other properties and on the day of the murders Alex wanted her to come to Moselle in the evening and they would go visit his father that's in the hospital. Maggie was apparently hesitant and wanted to just meet Alex at the hospital but he insisted she come to Moselle. She then apparently texted a friend saying that Alex was up to something and acting fishy before going to Moselle. She knew something was off. They never even went to the hospital, Alex used it as a lie to lure her there.
@Justin M Your 💯 % right!!! She wasn't there that morning of the killings and Alex said she was when the detective plainly ask Alex who left the house first that morning??? Why didn't the detective ask Alex right then WHY did he ask Maggie to come home that evening?? She was not there that morning and Alex didn't see her til him and Paul got back from riding around and then they ate supper and he says he was laying and snoozing on the couch and called Maggie twice and Paul and he NEVER goes down there to check on the or to tell them hrs going to see his Mom or even just to check on them since they didn't answer their phones. I think he went to his moms to hide that jacket and create an alibi by telling miss Shelly he'd been there 40 tto 45 minutes. Just out of the blue he tells her that if she's ask.... to say if anyone ask then that's what to say. Then to compensate her he .entions helping with the wedding or getting her a enter job at the school. Why...why?? Why didn't he go straight to see his dying dad and take Maggie since he said that's why Maggie was home? I believe it was because he was going to see his mom instead so he could hide what was in the jacket and jacket. I think he brought an extra tarp in able so Shelly would see that tarp laying right in the chair shes see cause thats the chair she sat in in his moms room. since he knows she saw him come in with the something balled up in his arms. He planned this murder in advance, no doubt in my mind. Plus all those people have heard his voice on the video just 5 minutes before Paul was killed. GUILTY, GUILTY, GUILTY!!!! HE WAS GOING TO LOSE MILLLIONS FROM THE BOAT CASE INCLUDING THE BEACH HOUSE MAGGIE WAS MOVING INTO BECAUSE THEY HAD SEPERATED. THATS WHY HE HAD TO ASK HER THE NIGHT BEFORE TO COME TO THE FARM. SHE DIDNT WANT TO! SHE TOLD HER FRIEND SHE FELT SOMETHING WAS FISHY AND HE LURED PAUL THERE. SO ALL EVIDENCE POINTS TO PAUL. WHEN DID HE CHANGE HIS CLOTHES HE WENT TO WORK IN THAT BLANCA SEEN. RIDING THE FARM HES IN A DIFFERENT SHIRT THAN BLNCA SEEN HIM LEAVE FOR FOR IN AND TRIED TO GET HER TO LIE AS WELL. HE WANTS EVERYONE TO LIE FOR HIM. THERES NO TELLING WHAT HE TOLD MAGGIES PATENTS WHILE GOING TO VACTUON WITH THEM AFTER THE MURDERS. HE HAS THEM BRAINWASHED BY NOW IM SURE. IT TO SHOW HOW UPSET HE WAS. HE PROBABLY CEIED AND REALLY PUT ON A GOOD SHIW FOR THEM. ANY RATE, I ARE HES LYING AND THAT HE LURED THEM TO THE FARM.
He can't remember if Maggie met him and Paul at the shed or at the house on the night of her and Paul's murder. Really Alex? Anyone else would recall every last minute and conversation they had and be reliving it over and over again.
He caught him so friggin offguard with the questions about killing Maggie and Paul. He turns beet red and provides the weakest denial I’ve ever heard in my life. His tone is so dejected and lacks confidence 🤯
I think he believed he was so smart that he wouldn’t be found guilty. It is heartbreaking to even imagine what horrible fear Maggie and Paul must have felt knowing that their husband/father who was supposed love and protect them was going to murder them. 😢😢😢
That’s a typical narcissist for you. That’s why a lot of these people are caught, they think they’re untouchable and too smart to get caught. Lucky for everyone else though
They probably had them programmed to lock after a few seconds of non usage. Like a the security all phones have as an option. I don’t lock mine…..personal preference
He's so slippery. During testimony, after Waters called him out about expecting us to believe a 5'2" 12 YO snuck onto the property with no weapons etc, Alex said, "You've got a lot of factors there, Mr. Waters, most of which I agree with, and some of which I dont." That was right after he fake sobbed and flat out said that whoever did this, "HATED Paul Murdaugh. HATED HIM!"
I do think something was strange about their home life. The housekeeper saying they just leave food out all night and there’s always clothes everywhere, and that their son just leaves guns wherever and there’s always guns laying all over. They don’t even know if guns have been stolen or not? They keep saying random items are missing from the house? Why? Drills are missing? these people are rich, they can afford a security system. Maggie was living in a different house than him? They haven’t made that clear. They haven’t made it clear what was going on with Buster either. Their cellphone records are strange too. Who makes 2 second calls over and over. They barely talk they just keep calling everyone all the time and hanging up within 8 seconds. There’s something we don’t know. Might never know. Even if he’s found guilty
Buster got kicked out of law school for cheating. I believe he was living elsewhere working at, like, some kind of restaurant or fast food job or whatever while he waited to be admitted elsewhere, I think. Home life is definitely a little odd. Seems the boys weren’t quite as mature as their social status and wealth would normally produce. That happens all the time of course but because this family was such a big deal in this town, I think it was exacerbated hardcore. Also, he’s not going to admit to what gun was stolen or when because he knows it was his guns that were used to kill his family. If he starts putting dates to things then they become evidence and he has to remember them and make them make sense. Also, they appeared to have so many guns that they kept in such an inappropriate manner that I can’t imagine anyone could keep up with all of them. So unnecessary, my lord.
They were in an area that didnt get a strong signal, their calls were often dropped, you must live in the city! In the south when you are in areas without a lot of urbanization there is hardly any kinda of service, we used to spend weekends at the cabin and we would have to go outside and walk in circles to get a signal on our phones.
The lack of response to ‘ we’ve established family guns are used’ says EVERYTHING
No way someone else planned to show up to kill them hoping to find guns laying around to use.
Right? And 5 foot 2 vigilantes on a mission! Lol
Unarmed, Spanish-speaking cartel member midgets on foot, who could outrun hungry wild hogs in the dark, no less. Seems legit.
The fact that Alex lies about that not being his voice on the kennel and then supposedly realizing some “man’s voice” was apparently heard with Maggie and Paul down at the kennels (three minutes before they die) basically says everything. He’s guilty. Anyone who doesn’t see that is just foolish. Any other human father would be yelling “HOW DO WE FIND OUT WHO THAT IS!! Can I see the video!!!! Let me hear it!!!!”
Good point! I mean at that time, I don’t believe they had the video yet, they just had Rogan’s statement that he had heard a male’s voice. But if Alex wasn’t there, his reaction should be: let’s find out who it was, let’s talk to Rogan and see exactly what he had heard!
100% this.
What’s the time stamp to what you guys are referring too?
30:27
@@Misunderstood_KV 30:27
Dude thinks he's the smartest man in the room when really he's just someone who's finally backed in a corner and can't talk his way out.
Exactly. He can't believe that the detective thinks he's guilty. Hey, Alex cry me a river.
He always thinks he's the smartest person in the room... keeps talking to prove he is NOT smarter than the average bear!!
THIS!
It’s very cringe watching him act🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
He says, "Obviously, no one else was out there." how does he know no one else was out there? He just found the bodies.
Suprise Surprise Surprise
He NEVER asks if they have found or are getting close to finding the killer!
because Alex knows he killed them and it's just a matter of time the detectives figure out it was him that was the murderer.
Right! Such a great observation.
I believe that is why they came there in the first place. That’s why the lawyer said ,”I thought this was an update”. And tried to get him to shut up because he realized Alex was a suspect.
He doesn’t need to ask, he already knows
Did they
This man has to have ice running through his veins. Imagine picking up a shotgun, holding it steady enough to aim it at your son's head, knowing you are about to kill your own son and pulling the trigger TWICE. Then picking up the next gun, after you just blew your son's head off, aim it at your wife, keep the gun steady, and pull the trigger FIVE times.
Then, the nerve to proclaim your innocence and put all your friends, acquaintances and family through a trial, subjecting them to the horror you created, just so you can get away with murder and live your life.
And stealing everyone's money...
He will never live his life.
And then ran over her with the ATV. Gonna be hard to explain why an intruder did that
Truly sickening
So many more just like him have came & gone. More like him are being born every day.
friend of mine after visiting me was killed in a vehicle accident 20 mins after leaving my house and i remember our entire conversation
How horrible… truly horrible.
I am so sorry.
Sorry… but yea exactly why AM can’t remember crap,! Liar
Aww ❤
My condolences.
Crazy how there's so much drama and trauma in this man's life...Drama and trauma that HE created!
Classic Narcissist
Pill head's don't murder people. Rob them of course but never kill them. He's innocent
@@jenriordan ha! Ok he's innocent because he's a pill head
Pill head's are looking for a fix. They don't kill people with money. He's innocent for sure
@@jenriordan He was a pill head about to be exposed for all kinds of financial problems and theft. He also didn't want to lose his law license. He definitely killed them.
Can’t stop watching these replays of this trial.
Erm, Snot easy to erm, stop, I'm the same (with Like, Watts and Kessinger too Like)
Same sis! I watch every night to fall asleep to and during the day as background noise. Obsessed!
I thought I was the only one who does that lol
Same. It never gets old lol
Also do this currently just finished watching Charlie adelson trial. Again lol. Now doing this one for the 4th time
Gotta love how his lawyer was firmly at his defense before the interview started...by the 20 minute his lawyers vibe totally changes as he looks directly at his client as he answers and his head sinks and he sits back as he realizes Alex wreaks of guilt. 😅
And that lawyer is Corey Fleming who has since been indicted on a whole host of crimes and has had his law license suspended. The low country is cleaning house!
funny b/c that lawyer has charges against him
@@blueneptune825 Cory should also have his law license revoked and he should never have the right to practice law again if or when convicted.
That "lawyer" , Corey Fleming, who is trying to help Alex dodge questions is also his crime buddy helping Murdaugh scam clients and dividing up the money.
Alex had an attorney with him the night it happened. Like what? Who would care about a lawyer when you had just found your family dead. Also who wouldn't immediately tell police go protect my mom and my other son, someone is trying to kill us! He had zero fear about the rest of his family?
"obviously there was no one else out there" Crazy how many times this guy basically confessed
Not once did Alex call Paul “PawPaw” here. If it was such a strong habit, it would have slipped once or twice.
his lawyer told him to use that term
Same attorney sitting there with him same one that was helping him steal people's money.
What a darn shame. He too is locked up finally.
@@jewelsmall910oh his lawyer is locked up now .?
@@colleenjoan8072 Corey Flemming. Siphoning money from at least one of Alex's cases. Locked up for 4 years in federal
@@jewelsmall910 And lost his license to practice law too! No wonder he was so concerned about Alex being interviewed as a suspect. I loved in the beginning of the interview, when the lawyer tried to take over the interrogation, by demanding the police give THEM the information FIRST before Alex would answer their questions. No Sir, you do not run the police investigation!
"I am not comfortable you asking him questions as a suspect"
as if it is possible to avoid any form of investigation on the murder of your immediate family..
In the US he has the right to remain silent and have an attorney representing him, Alec and his friend/attorney should taken advantage of his Miranda rights and left.
It is possible, you don’t have to say a word, let your lawyer talk for you.
@@psfanboy79 He knows he's done, when you're there you will talk in the end. As weird as it seems. You are not smarter than this lawyers. They are still human. 99% of the people will talk, guilty or not.
@@yknot000 Um, no one forced to come in for the interview--you know that, right?
I love watching detectives do what they do best. Interrogate the guilty!
I've watched a thousand interogation videos and this was a cake walk and he hardly pressed him. His privlege is so obvious in this interview
@@TeaSpiracy If they'd pressed him too hard they risked him ending the interview. He's a top lawyer with his own uber expensive lawyer sat next to him. They've gotta play it safe at this point.
@@neilsun2521if he was a "top lawyer " he wouldn't need a lawyer present during this interview 😂
It’s amazing how many people are taking naps right when serious crimes happen to people they know.
Yeah who the Frick has times for all these naps now and days?
@@Robert-00768nowadays
@@golfer5636 no I meant now and days.... I be busy is the now and days and between work at night it is more of a nap then a good rest so who doing it now and days not as in nowadays as in general present time.
@@golfer5636 (I have made this bed of nails and I WILL sleep on it lol)
Nowadays.....
I seriously think that this lying narcissist thought he was really going to get away with it. He thought he was powerful and untouchable. I’m so glad that justice was served on a person like this. This case gives me a little more hope and trust in our justice system
It’s because that family has been committing crimes for generations without any accountability.
Narcissists always believe they are the smartest ones in any room they enter and any encounters with others.
The judge was all kind and understanding to him at the end. Wonder if he would had the same treatment if he was a poor drug addict?
they just sacraficed one of their own to make you think that justice still exists, at a point he talked too much and they couldn't help him ... work on waking up
Narc is right
Thank God his son filmed that video just before he died.
Without even realising it he was proving his dad was guilty!!!
What a pathetic man! Just evil.
His wife and son had absolutely no chance
I dunno, maybe he DID realize something was amiss with his Dad that day and that's why he recorded the video. Honestly, the video doesn't make sense otherwise because it's not really focusing on anything particular. It's almost like Paul felt he needed to record at that moment.
@@cardbored_owhat video and where can I watch I guess I have to get to goggling
@@cardbored_ I believe Paul took that video to send to the owner because he thought the dog may have hurt his tail. If you listen to the testimony of his friend Rogan Gibson (the dog’s owner) he mentions Paul had been texting him about his concern for the dog’s tail and said he would send a video later that night. Nevertheless, good timing on the video.
@@bigmofosho87 Yeah, I didn't see his testimony until after I posted the comment! Very true!
@@cardbored_kids send snapchats every 5 minutes now.
It kills me that every time he is questioned, he fake cries for a minute then siffs snot and clears his throat the rest of the interview. Like that will somehow touch the hearts of the police.
Remember he's also an opioid addict. He's snorting it!! Just eating pills does not get them high enough, so they snort it. He couldn't use needles, doctors notice track marks...wives too.
Lol ..full of snot
Was he doing coke, too? His snot noises might have been intentional to deflect/distract from questions. Clear memories for distracting stories, “can’t recall” for most all of the important questions.
That is not fake crying, in my opinion. Alex is a hugely conflicted man, granted. His conflict lies within himself, not with Maggie and Paul. The body language that is being read all over the place needs to take this into account. Any evidence of lying, in my opinion, is that he knows he is conflicted within himself, and his lies are to hide from himself. This sounds complicated, I know. He may be guilty of many other things. I doubt he killed Maggie and Paul.
@Reine Marais The jury disagrees
How many different shades of red can Alex’s face turn lol
All he had to do to fix everything was to have just shot himself in the head.
The red 😈 s
Dude out here medium rare
@@lemmeborrowadollar7834 lmao
🟥🔴🟥🔴🟥🔴🔻🔺️🔻🔺️🟥🔴
He killed Paul to get the family out of a trial, which might affect Buster, and he killed Maggie to spare her the abject disgrace & humiliation of losing her status in the community and all her money. Maggie having to work at the local Costco would have really killed her.
He killed Maggie because she was gathering financial records, had seen a divorce lawyer, AND was staying in one of their other homes...unsure if living apart for state pre-divorce requirements or irreconcilable differences.
I think Maggie was killed because she witnessed Paul’s murder.
@@megatkins6143 Interesting. That is something I had not thought of.
Yes he also knew that she was about to find out about all embezzlement he did
@@megatkins6143
Yes.. I also thought that too. As I don't think he thought he was going to have to shoot Paul twice..then have the Explosion that happened..he then panicked..as you can tell by 5 shots with Maggie..he panicked..
It’s so odd that he can’t remember anything specific about his last dinner, last conversations & last moments with his son and wife. Something so traumatic would make it so that your memory retains EVERY SINGLE TINY DETAIL!!!!
Trauma can also make your memory worse.
Why do people keep insisting that people always remember their last words/moments with loved ones? It’s not the case for everyone.
He’s most likely lying about the conversations of that evening-can’t say how long he planned this but he did call Maggie take day and asked her to come home per her sister’s testimony on the stand-then he says here Maggie was worried for him-he lured her and Paul to their deaths.
It's scary to see how evil people allow themselves to get.
Greed took him down that evil road
It's part of nature..but we still have the power to choose.
I have second hand embarrassment over his terrible acting
Looks like Markle trying to act
those tears are because he doesn't wanna get caught. i SERIOUSLY hope the inmates get 2 him OR a vigilante gets to him.
Buster is no better. He hasn’t shown any emotions. That flaming red hair = the devil like his father.
@@gurumayne8684 Wow, some Christian you are. Shouldn't you be preaching forgiveness rather than revenge?
@@TheVAULTofHORROR why assume they’re Christians? That’s not very Christian-like…
Had to watch this again after the guilty verdict.
Why do husband/ wives thinks they can get away with murder when you know you're going to be the very first suspect!
Arrogance
That's probably why he lied he knew he was already suspect. At the scene would make it worse
All of them think they have bulletproof plan.
I always worried that if by some chance my wife died id be the first suspect! I protected my baby even more 😂
They don’t care just see money and obviously if they are cheating all about the mistress.. look up what Chris watts done!! As the lawyer said just get a divorce but obviously wanted the money from the house for him and his mistress
How all of your guns go missing without you calling to report them stolen..very suspicious
And boats too! He said that Paul constantly misplaced boats, from one end of the state to the other. It would be nothing for Paul to drive the boat to Columbus and leave it there after the weekend with his friends. What?? He must have been so wasted that he couldn't find where he left his own boat, so he just left it there. Wow!
Never once does he refer to Paul as paw paw in this video like he constantly did during the trial to convince the jury that he had an affectionate name for Paul to garner sympathy from the jury
Exactly! No sign of Pau Pau
Exactly!!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
He never ever said pawpaw in any interviews until the stand. And even then it sounded fake. And no one has ever said that was a nickname for Paul not buster, John Marvin or his aunt.
Did he really think no one would notice his phoniness?! Just goes to show how he’s so used to getting away with everything!
@DollishDes you're a hottie 😍
I have a bad feeling about Alex lawyer, I think he is not that clean himself
he is a crook himself
Really?? 😆
Why
Coming from Hispanic 😂
@@andrewvanderhoof2531he got 20 years for taking $$ from Gloria Satterfields kids through Alex.
I can’t imagine how these detectives do it! I mean I’m proud of them! However, when they’re sitting there in front of “the killer” and they asking reasonable questions and he’s answering them like he’s covering them up. I mean these detectives have BALLS of STEEL!! Bravo sir ! Bravo!
Heroes. Anyone who says otherwise about law enforcement is not seeing them in these crucial moments.
Agree. And if you want to see a textbook interrogation of a powerful yet guilty man, check out Sgt. Smyth of the Canada Prevential Police as he tears down massive pervert and killer Col. Williams of the Canada Air Force. Williams smelled hundreds of little girl panties and bras he stole from neighbors homes before he graduated to killing two women as he filmed killing them. Sgt. Smyth is a master interrogator and his work against Williams is being used in police acadamies around the world. I've watched it 3 times trying to anaylize it and it's mezmerizing.
balls of steal? asking fukin questions?
Paul really solved his own murder..
He didn’t seem to be worried about a murderer being on the loose.
Of course not. He just needed to look in the mirror.
Hampton County South Carolina business people, judges and law enforcement officials are complicit with helping Alex Murdaugh perpetuate his crimes especially his financial crimes... a lot more people should be going to jail for their misdeeds.
My thoughts exactly every American citizen knows politicians are corrupt yet nothing changes
Maybe they will...they can't arrest them and try them during this trial anyways. Hopefully he goes down for the other sketchy deaths he was linked to as well.
@AHD2105not just in the US! It happens EVERYWHERE tbh 😢
Just look at the Stephen Smith death/murder on the Murdaugh Murders Podcast. The complicity in his death involves people from all levels within the legal system in that town from officers, Randy Murdaugh, the local coroner and even judges. Many have since quit or moved to pastures new for clear and obvious reasons. Heads should roll if that case ever gets to a court. It all seems to be allegedly linked to Buster who was supposedly in a relationship with Stephen and for obvious reasons the family did not want this to be publicised.
@AHD2105 The oligarchs who bleed the populace and live like kings of old- much less corrupt😆
The level of greed is far beyond what most people can imagine. It becomes a little more understandable when we remember, “This is an attorney”Greedy people are over represented in law school, and they don’t get better when they graduate.
When you earn a good amount of money for years and suddenly are in debt, you don't understand what people will do to keep up appearances.
He's obviously innocent.. He cry's every single time he talks about Paul Paul's brain's on the sidewalk.
remember most politicians are lawyers
I think fettermans neck lump killed em
@@jenriordan that's not enough. He cries. Not every killer, especially a family killer, is emotionless. Also, they already made it clear that this guy could cry while representing his injured clients in court.
He knows he’s in trouble when key fob clocks him going in the office at 5:30. First sign of Alex not knowing what to say and registering that this detective don’t believe him no more. It’s very telling. He told a LOT of lies in this interview. Innocent people do not lie like that.
In the morning?
@@mjmartinez3244 pm
When AM was shot in the head he was extremely detailed on his assailant He remembered a type of gun, a type of car, definitely not a Ford, the man who shot him was good looking, the man was a very nice man, or thought he was.
Now, as a emergency room nurse a patient with a head wound is either screaming, mute, rambling. We are trained to keep our patient calm. If our patient is not compliant we give them a mild sedative.
There is exception to the rule.
Here AM is volunteering minute details in this stressful position.
Yup. Technology makes it hard to get away with murder these days.
He arrived at the office at approximately 12:30pm. He left the office at approximately 6:00ish according to OnStar.
I wonder at what point did his attorney finally start to realize “Holy crap, he may have actually done this”?
The moment he heard they were killed. They all know he's a pis
Think it was when cop said they confirmed it was the Murdaugh family guns that killed them.
He knows dude, he will not sit there if he lies to him. He's simply not allowed to share his info with anyone.
Makes no difference, if he can get his client off then he will do that to the best of his ability. And will sleep just fine at the end of the night!
I think they all know he is guilty, but they don’t care.
He can sit there laughing he thinks it is all about him; he is a narcissist and a coward. I HATE plea deals they make me sick and so does he!
I can’t believe no one advised this man not to talk to the cops. Forget being advised he was a lawyer he should’ve known better
But if he wanted to project innocence he does need to talk to the cops...
His lawyer did advise him not to, weren’t you listening? His attorney threw a fit in the beginning of this interview but Alex said he wanted to do it in an attempt to appear not guilty.
It started to backfire immediately when he couldn’t remember a single detail of that day😂
He needed to know what they knew, his lawyer friends sat next to him, each time.
He thinks if he makes noises like he’s been crying that it would make the fake crying more believable. He keeps clearing his throat and sniffing like his tears were real. This has the reverse effect on me and makes me despise him even more. This man is such a terrible awful person. I’m glad he’s in prison.
That noise he’s making when he sucks in through his nose, that throat nasal mucus noise. My biggest pet peeve, I’m raging here but I can’t get enough of this at the same time. So fascinatingly evil
He is much too polite much too patient for a man who is getting falsely incriminated for the murder of his wife and child
Excellent point, any innocent person would (and should) be irate!
I think it's impossible to know how he should act since people grieve in different ways...and he is obviously grieving in my opinion.
This being the first time I've heard him speak he is different than how I imagined he'd be...much more soft spoken. Much less like a monster or mad man. You can be a liar and thief without being a killer.
With no physical evidence I'd be hard pressed to find him guilty....just not 100% convinced.
@@kathyann8974 Well, of course he’s trying to play all meek and mild...this is an interrogation, after all. The evidence is compelling...his father’s carer told the court that Alex visited that night (very unusual) and, although he was there for only 20 minutes, asked her to say he’d been there *twice* as long as that (just in case * anyone asked).* Sounds like he was setting up an alibi for himself.
His voice was clearly heard on recording which placed him at the kennels, which he’s doggedly disputed, at the time of the murders.
I’ve been watching his body language throughout and none of it adds up. Notice how controlled his ‘weeping’ is, how he surreptitiously peeks at whoever he’s with to gauge whether his performance is being bought.
But that’s just my opinion..
Yeah I agree its like his an outsider to it basically, but he has the same tendencies as most killers, they fake cry but have a lot of memory loss that specific day, watching several crime interviews its easy to see tell tale signs, 🤡🤡
@@ravenblue7805 there’s no compelling evidence whatsoever that he murdered them, quite the contrary actually, and reading body language is not a good way to gauge anything about anybody.
I'm actually shocked that Murdaugh kept on with this interview and that his lawyer didn't advise him to stop--it becomes pretty obvious, despite what they say at the beginning, that the questions are focused mostly on him.
Not his lawyer. That's his friend. Watch his body language abou 20 minutes into the video as he realizes Murdaugh is guilty....... this one's a classic.
@@wynton921 that's jim griffin right?
@@unapologeticallyauthentic No, I think that's Saul Goodman.
@@wynton921 it’s his friend AND lawyer. He says that “I’m his friend but I’m also his lawyer”
@@unapologeticallyauthentic No. it's Corey Flemming. They were both in cahoots for the insurance claim for Gloria Satterfield's death.
It is heartbreaking to think what Paul and Maggie had to go through in their final moments. The pain and the realization that your father/husband is going to kill you...may they rest in peace and let's hope they get justice 🧡
I haven't been following this. Why did he do it?
Nah they were d!ckheads too
He didn’t kill them
@@taylorellison2719 The evidence tells otherwise.
@@hmq9052 I think it's about several things. Alex's financial crimes were about to be revealed and he lost his job, Paul's boat case was troublesome, expensive and coming up for processing and Alex hadn't told Maggie everything, so the separation was possible with the revelations. Alex is also clearly very selfish and inconsiderate of others and used to the privileges of his position. It was all falling apart, so here's the end result.
It was over when he said he had no memory of the leaning tree in the wind.
Guilty guilty guilty... I mean this guy's family is murdered and he can't give a straight answer on anything how many times does he say "I can't remember"
I loved the response from the officer to the lawyer “I need to this questions to get Alex out”
🤣
Him wanting to know who was shot first or second is just weird !!!!!
2 months later, he still had not given them the specific gun information.
He wasn't aware that his son was video taping him with the tree lol
I'm sorry but how dont you recall the very last moments you spent with your wife and son before they are brutally murdered?? I still have vivid memories of me with my dad on the day he died! And that was over 20 yrs ago and he died of natural causes! Those last moments you spent together are going to be playing through your head the second you find out something happened to them unless you're stuck replaying a darker more sinister memory from that day
I agree. The last words I heard from my mom before when died were when someone at the hospital gave her the phone and she said, "Hi baby..." Then she never said anything else. I remember the tone, everything. It runs through my head several times a week. Alex would be going over everything that was said/done trying to see if he could remember a shred of evidence to help find the killer.
It's unbelievable 😳 how can you forget that? The first interview he had with the police just when the first responders came, he didn't remember anything and now we know that he was there , and he visited his mom for less than 30 minutes but asked the lady to say to lie about the time, why? If there is nothing to hide?
If you was addicted to opiates for 20+ years, maybe your memory would work different too
I think he is guilty, but it actually isn't uncommon in a trauma to forget or even unintentionally block information like this. His mind would have been flooded and overwhelmed with adrenalin when he found them. I can tell you that I, right now, with no trauma, couldn't tell you what the last thing I said to my husband and kids was this morning before they left. If I came home and found them the way these folks were found I would HATE that I can't remember, but I wouldn't be able to.
@Dave P He didn't seem to have a problem with his memory. He was a successful lawyer and was able to scam millions from his clients. He kept a lot of balls in the air at once and still had the time, energy, and forethought to show up to all the kids' games. He remembers the details of that night.
Alex completely ignored his friend/lawyer’s advice during this interview. It makes me wonder if Alex will take the stand against his lawyer’s advice. Alex seems to need control over every situation.
Lol he did
He will take the stand, because he's a " lawyer " and will persuade them with his scintillating intellect and his down-home folksy charm...
Of COURSE he'll take the stand. He's a narcissist!
Guilty on all counts!
should have never had this interview, should have never taken the stand. he hung himself.
because in these interrogations, the suspect always thinks being more talkative and open makes he/she look innocent and that they are trying to help. You should never talk to police,period. (im glad he did though!)
His attorney was trying to bully them into NOT investigating. Unreal.
No he’s just doing his job. He was hired to defend Alex. Allowing Alex to be interrogated by homicide detectives is not something a good attorney is going to allow. Attorney did nothing wrong.
@@claymac7895I agree he was doing his job - doesn't make it right.
@projectkj7643 if you are paying for a lawyer to defend you it's going to be expected they defend you in anyway possible innocent or guilty .I'm just glad the lawyer let him talk his way into a conviction.
what stans out to me....when police arrived after 911 call..he asked 2 times Are they dead.... I would have asked are they alive not are they dead.
Stand
@@dauntlessdev9n499 ,thank you, left out the d . glad you read my comment
@@dauntlessdev9n499 stands 🤦♀️
He had a right to remain silent why didn't the attorney allow him to answer the questions?
When he gets asked did you kill Maggie and he says no but nods yes. Very telling.
Why would such an experienced lawyer even consider talking to the police?
His lawyer is there
@@ashleyyy1 you should never speak to police especially if you’re guilty with or with out a lawyer
Because Alex thinks he's the most intelligent guy in the room and his arrogance doesn't allow him to think anyone would think he's guilty.
But the way this lawyer ATTEMPTED to tell the agent how the meeting was going to go... oh no buddy !!
Because he’s a narcissist that thinks he’s smarter than the police.
Alex’s voice is very slapstick when pretending to be sad which I’ve seen with other murderers. On another point, who apologises to Police when they attend a scene. It wasn’t as if it was a noisy party!
This man is literally a walking contradiction of himself. The pure evil in his heart and undertaking the unthinkable to his poor wife and son.. standing in front of each of them as he pulled the trigger to take their lives away from them... One can only imagine the literal disbelief and heartbreak they would have both felt before their souls left their bodies. May they rest in peace and may Alex be tormented until his final end. There are no words for what he has committed and then blatantly sits and lies and lies and lies..
You know, I've thought of that so much. I have three children and would die before I'd harm a hair on their pointy heads. (All adults, and there have surely been times I thought I could knock their heads together). And my sweet husband? For him to catch my eye knowing he's in my cross hairs would be infinitely more cruel than the blood clot that killed him. I will never grasp Alex's mindset or the cruelty.
Alex nods his head up and down when asked if he killed Maggie and Paul. Dead giveaway as his body was was saying YES!
A friend and lawyer would never allow a friend to answer any questions.
He's doing this own free will to make it seem like he's innocent
you do know if he doesnt answer questions he becomes even more of a suspect and the detectives will focus more on him
As an attorney.. he knows by not answering he's making himself look more guilty and he's still trying to build his narrative
@@pla5730 but not answering, a refusal to talk based on the grounds you may incriminate yourself, cannot be used against you. It COULD make you look guilty. Or it could also be indicative of you don’t trust police and think they’ll spin anything you say against you.
He was claiming to only bra witness at the time. To everyone. Refusing to answer questions as a witness is more than a bit suspicious.
The continuous dry sniffling is so telling.
Imagine
Sitting here with a man
Who’s just killed his
Wife & son !
Well he didn’t “just” kill them….pretty sure this interview is a couple months after
"Not if my times are right." 30:45 That's all I need to hear to know he was guilty. No one - nobody - would respond like this. That's the moment his house of cards fall. His friend/lawyer realizes this as his body language speaks volumes, literally subconsciously distancing himself from a killer once he realizes he's guilty. Alex clutching onto his right dominant arm is a guarded body language, where he's literally holding himself back and in a defensive prose - his right hand in a fist showing anger at the realization he's been caught.
Who else knows Maggie, Paul and Bubba that sounds exactly like Alex? Buster lied on the stand to protect his father as we all know that voice is Alex. Buster should not be allow to practice law imo as he lied under oath making a mockery of the integrity of justice system he will not protect.
Well put
Lol 🙄
His friend/lawyer with him was indicted after this interview took place. Not sure exactly when after it. I think his name is Corey Fleming I believe. He also lost his licence to practice law.
Nice
must be hard to recount a story if all you can see in your mind is killing your son and wife, if that was the case, i see that sort of torment in him
Ok......someone went to the house to do a murder without a gun?????
Then they took guns from the house to do the murder??????
IF it was anyone else:
Alex would have been with Paul and Maggie when the murders were committed as evidenced by the Snapchat video. So then Alex was spared, and he knows who did it. He would have been a witness.
Or if you still don't believe it was him, we know he left the house at 9:06 according to the OnStar evidence. So he had to have heard SEVEN gunshots and then left the house without checking on his wife or son.
If someone was waiting for Alex to leave the house to ambush Paul and Maggie, how would they know how long he would be gone? If they saw him leave, how would they know he wouldn't turn around because he forgot something. So then they had to find the family guns, ammo, find Maggie and Paul, kill them and leave before Alex returned.
There is no evidence to prove who the guns belong to. All that was made clear is that it was the same style weapons that they own. It's amazing how hard it is for some of yall to follow things that were made clear throughout the case.
This feed is full of waterheads
@@rdd645 ballistics don't lie
There's nothing u can do to cover up that much suspicion. And his lawyer friends, silly for thinking they could get him out of this. How are people this evil??
His friend clearly isn't a criminal lawyer. Any competent criminal lawyer would have highly advised against doing any interview with the police.
@@invisibleliquid right. Every bit of damning evidence against him relates to the contradiction of his interviews with police
@@invisibleliquid ķƙķƙkkķkķkkķķkkķkkkkķƙkķ
@@geebee3100 😂Bet you feel a bit daft now. It amazes me that people say that when the evidence was clearly overwhelming. Many people fooled by his lies and crocodile tears.
@@geebee3100 The fact is he WAS there and he killed them. It’s done and dusted, move on. 👍🏻
Wouldn’t everyone be a suspect? And “anything to help” he really thinks they can’t prove it’s him🙈
The people closest to the victim, the last to see them alive are ALWAYS suspects
No, everyone is investigated, but you're only a suspect if they have a legit reason for you to be suspect.
@@katjagolden893 No. Not official suspects. Not even official persons of interest (POI). The police have to officially name suspects and POIs. If a family member or whatever can be ruled out right away, they are not named either of those. So no, not everyone is a "suspect". They need evidence (physical or circumstantial) to name someone a suspect.
Everytime he knows he's given away some piece of information that's put him in a compromising position he clears his throat: almost as if to clear his head to strategise and rethink how to twist what he has previously said and now make it fit.
As a lawyer you would think he would know how body language works. He has guilty written all over his posture
I'm guessing here.. so, when you're the one on the spot, trying to focus on acting out a lie for a prolonged period of time, controlling your body movements while trying to bend the truth becomes difficult and taxing. Eventually one or the other has to give.
@@Ims51 100%
Yes his body language is definitely one of guarding himself from detectives!!
Not to mention when he nods his head, “yes” while he says “No sir, not if my times are right.”
The sniffling gets me
It’s disgusting 🤮. The guy has no self awareness. The way he openly adjusts his crotch which he did in the 2 x car interviews 🙄
For the love of god The way this man talks How the heck was he able to get a Lawyers license Whoever gave it to him Must have been blind deaf and mute Unbelievable I bet his father bought it for him It's the only way possible What Money can buy
IF you believe that Alex did NOT commit these murders, you'd have to believe either
a) the killer coincidentally showed up a moment after Alex left - assuming he was there up to the minute according to his recorded voice, or
b) the killer was waiting for Alex to leave…. in which case he wouldn't have known Alex was going to leave at all. So why wouldn't the killer kill all 3?
C) the murderer did not bring his own weapons and just happen to find both the family shotgun and AR
@@brittneysurber2813 Also, there is no factual evidence, hereunto, that has presented on behalf of the defense to refute any possibility of A). Alex did the crime!
D) The killer decided to kill Paul never mind killer did not know who was in the house or on the property at that moment. Also the killer was after Paul only but had zero problem hunting down an innocent person Maggie who happened to be at the scene. Also that property was first class. Killer took a huge risk not knowing what secret cameras and security, etc were on all those buildings and property etc.
The clincher for me is he was at the kennel just mins before they were murdered and of coarse lied about it plus Maggie didnt want to come back to the house but Alex insisted she come, and same with Paul he told him he needed to come home. hmm? Motive? The lawsuit would be dropped now that Paul is dead and Alex would collect 9 million if Maggie was to die.
The killer could have been hired by AM.Perhaps he was too cowardly to be the active shooter.
Life's so much peaceful when you don't blast off two people with a shotgun and an AR...
"I found out after the reason Maggie came down was cause she was worried about me".... *Bold face Lie*
Sled: "what happened to the clothes you were wearing when you and Paul were playing with the tree"
Alex: "I don't remember playing with a tree..." .... *Bold face lie* Who else thinks this man isn't GUILTY??? I mean there are 2 bold face lies and being deceptive in a 3 min span. Innocent people don't lie about questions he would obviously know the answer to. He knew him and Paul were messing with that tree and he knew Paul recorded it. That's not a minute detail. That's one of the last moments he had with his son and yet forgot it??? GUILTY!
I think he's probably guilty, but there is still a lack of physical evidence and his defence has done a pretty good job of creating reasonable doubt. SLED haven't been the best at evidence collecting either.
@D S R Ughh I'm so tired of people using that physical evidence bs. There is a mountain of evidence that points to him being guilty. Shoot even a few of them on their own is enough to convince a reasonable person to see that he's guilty. Just because there is no physical evidence in a murder doesn't mean you can't convict someone. There is like 20+ things that directly point to his guilt and all the lies he's told. Use common sense, if a guy is lying about a bunch of crucial details that an innocent man WOULD NOT lie about then it shows he was behind it. So let me ask you about 3 specific lies he's told and then how you can say "you're not sure"....1. He said that Maggie came down on her own to be with him when in fact he was the one who had her come and she was even saying to a friend it was really suspicious and he was up to something. 2. He told the police he didn't remember "playing with a tree" when in fact that was one of the last moments he spent with his youngest child before he was murdered which he obviously remembered and is in fact lying about, 3. The snap chat video where he was clearly there right before their murders. Now how on earth can you even just look at those 3 details of him caught in bold face lies and say you don't think there is enough to say he's guilty??? And that was literally like 3 things out of a pile of evidence that points directly to him. Also do you not realize that innocent people don't lie to investigators, especially about something your family was victim to? One lie ok you could say maybe it was a mistake but he has been caught in so many lies. I just don't understand people who actually say there is reasonable doubt. In my mind any doubt would be UNreasonable!
Alex’s attorney knows they’ve walked into a trap. He wants him out of that room bad
How would Alex not be afraid to go back to the house to get a gun. Wouldn't he be afraid that the Killer was in the house?
This is a good point. If I'd found 2 family members, obviously dead, on my property and I knew there was no other family there, I'd be driving out of there as fast as I possibly could. They're dead and I can't help them. I'm leaving before I'm dead too.
I can't believe how he was comfortable enough to just be standing there when police showed up. You wouldn't catch me doing that, even if I had killed them. I'd be losing my mind with those bodies right there.
I would grab a gun and hunt the killer down. If anything happened to someone I love then I would go crazy 😜
He did! A way to cover gun shot residue on his hands from the murders.
Maggie's sister said in court he was carrying a gun on him at all times as they all thought the family might be being targeted so why did he have to go back to the house to get a gun when he had one on him anyway? If it wasn't on him it would have been in his car.
He had just come from the house so he knew nobody was there.
Doesn’t matter, though, lies anyway.
Guilty. And I’ve listened to him and the state with an opened mind and heart. Guilty!
"obviously, nobody else was out there". He didn't think the killer was out there? or did he slip up, meaning he was the only person out there?
Right!! I like your style Jeanie 👏🏾👏🏾
Confession through "projection".
Slip up
“Anything to help” accept telling the truth
So we are supposed to believe that a random killer knew that paul and Maggie would be at the kennels, at that specific time and they forgot to take their own weapons, hoping there would be some hanging about 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️
Alex is doing the same self soothing rocking in the interrogation room as he is doing in the court room
I noticed that right away too!
He’s making it sound like Maggie spent the night with him at Moselle? She was at the beach house and only came to Moselle after he called her to lure her to her death.
@@geebee3100 the media? What fvcking media? He called both Maggie and Paul to come up to Moselle. They were not there with him, Maggie told two people that she didn’t really want to go to Moselle. He summoned Paul to Moselle and they both end up being murdered there and he’s the only survivor. The English word for that is lured.
@@geebee3100 you’re projecting 😂
Question: Alex said in this interview and also in his second interview Maggie was at Moselle the morning of her death. Isn't this a proven lie. Her sister said Alex wanted her to come and she arrived after her Dr. Appt. At Moselle. Somebody please help me out. Was he lying about this?
I think he was lying because he did not want investigators to know he lured her out to Moselle on date her death.
Based on what I have read he's lying. What I've read is that Maggie was living separate from him at the time at one of their other properties and on the day of the murders Alex wanted her to come to Moselle in the evening and they would go visit his father that's in the hospital. Maggie was apparently hesitant and wanted to just meet Alex at the hospital but he insisted she come to Moselle. She then apparently texted a friend saying that Alex was up to something and acting fishy before going to Moselle. She knew something was off. They never even went to the hospital, Alex used it as a lie to lure her there.
@Justin M
Your 💯 % right!!! She wasn't there that morning of the killings and Alex said she was when the detective plainly ask Alex who left the house first that morning??? Why didn't the detective ask Alex right then WHY did he ask Maggie to come home that evening?? She was not there that morning and Alex didn't see her til him and Paul got back from riding around and then they ate supper and he says he was laying and snoozing on the couch and called Maggie twice and Paul and he NEVER goes down there to check on the or to tell them hrs going to see his Mom or even just to check on them since they didn't answer their phones. I think he went to his moms to hide that jacket and create an alibi by telling miss Shelly he'd been there 40 tto 45 minutes. Just out of the blue he tells her that if she's ask.... to say if anyone ask then that's what to say. Then to compensate her he .entions helping with the wedding or getting her a enter job at the school.
Why...why?? Why didn't he go straight to see his dying dad and take Maggie since he said that's why Maggie was home? I believe it was because he was going to see his mom instead so he could hide what was in the jacket and jacket. I think he brought an extra tarp in able so Shelly would see that tarp laying right in the chair shes see cause thats the chair she sat in in his moms room. since he knows she saw him come in with the something balled up in his arms. He planned this murder in advance, no doubt in my mind. Plus all those people have heard his voice on the video just 5 minutes before Paul was killed.
GUILTY, GUILTY, GUILTY!!!!
HE WAS GOING TO LOSE MILLLIONS FROM THE BOAT CASE INCLUDING THE BEACH HOUSE MAGGIE WAS MOVING INTO BECAUSE THEY HAD SEPERATED. THATS WHY HE HAD TO ASK HER THE NIGHT BEFORE TO COME TO THE FARM. SHE DIDNT WANT TO! SHE TOLD HER FRIEND SHE FELT SOMETHING WAS FISHY AND HE LURED PAUL THERE. SO ALL EVIDENCE POINTS TO PAUL.
WHEN DID HE CHANGE HIS CLOTHES HE WENT TO WORK IN THAT BLANCA SEEN. RIDING THE FARM HES IN A DIFFERENT SHIRT THAN BLNCA SEEN HIM LEAVE FOR FOR IN AND TRIED TO GET HER TO LIE AS WELL. HE WANTS EVERYONE TO LIE FOR HIM. THERES NO TELLING WHAT HE TOLD MAGGIES PATENTS WHILE GOING TO VACTUON WITH THEM AFTER THE MURDERS. HE HAS THEM BRAINWASHED BY NOW IM SURE. IT TO SHOW HOW UPSET HE WAS. HE PROBABLY CEIED AND REALLY PUT ON A GOOD SHIW FOR THEM.
ANY RATE, I ARE HES LYING AND THAT HE LURED THEM TO THE FARM.
You are correct!
She had been at moselle the night before and left that morning, came back that evening
@@clarissa8477 I'm pretty sure that is incorrect. She had been living at the Edisto beach house away from Alex. Alex lured her to Moselle that evening
"No, sir, not if my times are right."
He can't remember if Maggie met him and Paul at the shed or at the house on the night of her and Paul's murder. Really Alex? Anyone else would recall every last minute and conversation they had and be reliving it over and over again.
the investigators knews he was guilty.
He keeps crying without tears. Drives me nuts.
A juror was interviewed today. He said I never saw any tears, just lots of snot.
At this time, his lawyer/relative had no clue that Alex had been lying for months about his alibi. Keep that in mind when he says anything to help.
Cold blooded
Alec goes though Fifty shades of Red! 🤣
Its so obvious he is trying to find a way out and is hoping he doesn't get caught
Always heard a man wit a suitcase can steal more money than a man with a gun
Briefcase
@@MattHelmSA 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He caught him so friggin offguard with the questions about killing Maggie and Paul. He turns beet red and provides the weakest denial I’ve ever heard in my life. His tone is so dejected and lacks confidence 🤯
He's been beat red the entire video.
Maggie and Paul saw their killer. Sad!! I hope he see's them in his dreams every night for the rest of his life.
He doesn’t…. He’s deeply disturbed
I think he believed he was so smart that he wouldn’t be found guilty. It is heartbreaking to even imagine what horrible fear Maggie and Paul must have felt knowing that their husband/father who was supposed love and protect them was going to murder them. 😢😢😢
💰
That’s a typical narcissist for you. That’s why a lot of these people are caught, they think they’re untouchable and too smart to get caught. Lucky for everyone else though
Paul's phone locked at 8.49pm and 35 seconds and Maggie's locked at 8.49pm and 31 seconds, What caused the phones to get locked ?
They probably had them programmed to lock after a few seconds of non usage. Like a the security all phones have as an option. I don’t lock mine…..personal preference
The same way every phone gets locked?? The user locks or it automatically after a certain time it's not in use.
he never mentioned he had gotten fired that day. and the attorney with him. has been indicted too
Look at the guilty's body language. Crossed legs and arms.
He's so slippery. During testimony, after Waters called him out about expecting us to believe a 5'2" 12 YO snuck onto the property with no weapons etc, Alex said, "You've got a lot of factors there, Mr. Waters, most of which I agree with, and some of which I dont."
That was right after he fake sobbed and flat out said that whoever did this, "HATED Paul Murdaugh. HATED HIM!"
A good lawyer wouldn't let this "interview " go on for 2 hours...
Shouldn't Alex have called the police, the moment he realized the guns were missing? This is 3 months after the murders!?!
I do think something was strange about their home life. The housekeeper saying they just leave food out all night and there’s always clothes everywhere, and that their son just leaves guns wherever and there’s always guns laying all over. They don’t even know if guns have been stolen or not? They keep saying random items are missing from the house? Why? Drills are missing? these people are rich, they can afford a security system. Maggie was living in a different house than him? They haven’t made that clear. They haven’t made it clear what was going on with Buster either. Their cellphone records are strange too. Who makes 2 second calls over and over. They barely talk they just keep calling everyone all the time and hanging up within 8 seconds.
There’s something we don’t know. Might never know. Even if he’s found guilty
Most dont get rich playing fairly, definitely this family was doing some illegal stuff but we’re never gonna know what
Buster got kicked out of law school for cheating. I believe he was living elsewhere working at, like, some kind of restaurant or fast food job or whatever while he waited to be admitted elsewhere, I think.
Home life is definitely a little odd. Seems the boys weren’t quite as mature as their social status and wealth would normally produce. That happens all the time of course but because this family was such a big deal in this town, I think it was exacerbated hardcore.
Also, he’s not going to admit to what gun was stolen or when because he knows it was his guns that were used to kill his family. If he starts putting dates to things then they become evidence and he has to remember them and make them make sense. Also, they appeared to have so many guns that they kept in such an inappropriate manner that I can’t imagine anyone could keep up with all of them. So unnecessary, my lord.
They were in an area that didnt get a strong signal, their calls were often dropped, you must live in the city! In the south when you are in areas without a lot of urbanization there is hardly any kinda of service, we used to spend weekends at the cabin and we would have to go outside and walk in circles to get a signal on our phones.
A lot of rich people live messy lives. Literally and figuratively
@@t.m7999 I would even say MOST OF THEM do!