The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
"Jury selection and opening statements began Monday in a trial that mashes up Ed Sheeran's "Thinking Out Loud" with Marvin Gaye's "Let's Get It On." The heirs of Ed Townsend, Gaye's co-writer of the 1973 soul classic, sued Sheeran, alleging the English pop star's 2014 hit tune has "striking similarities" to "Let's Get It On" and "overt common elements" that violate their copyright. The two songs were released decades apart, but some say they sound seamless when paired together. "This must stop," Townsend's daughter, Kathryn Griffin-Townsend, said last month. "We have enough chaos going on in the world today, besides having to stand here and worry about other people stealing other people's belongings." The lawsuit filed in 2017 has finally made it to a trial that is expected to last a week in the Manhattan federal courtroom of 95-year-old Judge Louis L. Stanton." www.cbsnews.com/news/ed-sheeran-marvin-gaye-copyright-trial/
It's unfortunate for the bullshit put out. History repeats. I think of it as a compliment to the original. It's what makes beautiful music. Sadly, all is explored. I love all music from the past, and if the youth of today want to go ahead and use it to make music by all means, go ahead. I know where it came from, and so do you. I would rather hear a beautiful mesh up than an awful mesh up of a classic. No need for the hate...
@@michellemiranda6545 Ed just won! Which is good because we can't be this strict about "copying" when there's only so many chords that EXIST. similar chord progression does not mean copying. it's almost impossible to make a song these days that doesn't have SOME similarity to already existing songs and that's ok!
En realidad 1171karl me ayudó a realizar el Mashup yo sólo hice el video y la traducción. Gracias por comentar. Checa este video te va a encantar. Salu2 amigo 😁 ua-cam.com/video/HuAbpPyWOnE/v-deo.html
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
I’m aware of the lawsuit… I’m torn between both sides! However, the mashup was BEAUTIFUL!!! They need to collaborate and promote this… It’s effing awesome!
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
@@natecooke who said that?! Everyone knows the f’n song and everyone knows he’s dead! I was saying I didn’t know about the drama surrounding the lawsuit.… 😒 jackass
It is similar in tempo and so on, but I'm guessing these chord types are standards across the board. Any DJ will tell you about Beats Per Minute. Two similar records that mix well (exactly as we have here). But that I'm afraid is as similar as it gets. The family of Marvin are out for a bit of cash and I'm sorry, I am not buying it. I'm a huge Marvin fan (more than I am of Ed Sheeran) but these two songs are not the same by a long shot.
Totally different songs...same chord progression, but there are hundreds of songs using the same chords... there are only so many notes and chords available. But wow they sound great together!
Because he did and rightfully so, there’s a lot more to music production than u clearly know and mr gaye would be turning in his grave to see this be taken to court👍
Sheeran won, he took his guitar,he played like 50 songs to the jury, half where a couple hundred years before marvin, with the same chord progression.,
Listening to it the Marvin Gaye melody sounds different, even though the mashup blends nicely. Its a fune line because musicians hear things that maybe an untrained ear can't hear. With that being said the blend sounds good! Ed won his casr so its settled.
This mashup sounds amazing. Two distinctly different songs. Not my favourite songs but they just sound so good together like this. I don't think it's right what they are doing now to sue Ed Sheeran and didn't they sue Pharrell or somebody too? ...but all creative people are influenced by the ones who came before that is not right to sue them for it.
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
I'm so glad Ed won. They sound very different to me. I bet we could mashup many songs that are very different. I hope the losers also get to pay for Ed's lawyers.
Gaye’s co-writer’s heirs would have done better to work with Ed Sheeran in promoting something of this nature, which would have entered into the true spirit of music and appealed to Sheeran’s sense of fun. That would have been a creative, win win solution. By attacking as they did, it gives the impression that they make their living by cashing in on the talents of others.
The UK case was really a stretch and it was right that Ed won. However I gotta say that for this one, if you take out the melody, they're exactly the same.
@@patrickkuhn5069 it’s not just the chord progression. It’s also the same key, bpm and has the same drums, almost exactly. The reason it’s such a seamless mashup is because they are so similar.
@@beccivoyante they are in different keys, they transposed this for the mashup. the groove is the same for sure, and the progression too. but that happens a lottttt
Basically writting over Marvin classic and just changing words not rhythm. Of course it sound different because nobody sounds like Marvin. But they robbed a hit
The chords are slightly different, too. So the we're losing the harmonies in Marvin's song because the mashup is using the harmonies in Ed's song throughout.
The pre-chorus later in the mash up is technically Ed's but it's a 2,5,1 walk down basically the foundation of jazz and Marvin's chords werent revolutionary either 1, minor 3, 4, 5 has been used 1000 times before
I am no fan of Ed and his often lame feel-good music, plus he tries a bit hard - “visually” (wink) - in this video but these two songs are only similar in mood and a very common chord progression. Marvin’s estate does not have ownership this sound. Come on! His estate people are looking rather petty if not plain silly.
Give me Marvin over Ed any day. Ed sounds too much like calpadi a d sam smith. All as dreary as onr another. Marvin had soul and made you feel the song. Today's 'artists', if thry can be called such given they are so alike sounding to one another, don't do that.
Sounds like Ed borrowed a lot from Marvin's song. He has a tough legal case. Olivia Rodrigo only interpolated a little from other artists and paid up royalties immediately.
Ms Townsend must be running out of cash to sue over this. The mash up works but listen to the songs separately you wouldn’t associate them as one copied the other. Ridiculous. No wonder Me Townsend passed out of embarrassment.
I hear similarity, but much of it is not similar. Nope. I heard Marvin's song when it first released back in the day. Lol (long time ago) However, I'm older now, heard Sheeran's and it definitely not a copy of Marvin's. 🙏❤ Also, because of the age gap in the 2 songs, does not hold all truth Sheeran copied Marvin's. Many other tunes out there by young artist now a days, have similar notes to tunes created as far back as when Elvis Presley was known as King of rock n roll. Come on now ... Let the good times roll..listen to Christian music, many, many songs have same similarities...it's all good. 😊
Ed sheeran song is a hit, is because he Copied Marvin Gayes Hit. Let's Get It On! It's a No Brainer. He's not sampling, he copied the Whole Riff. I thought after 20 years all songs copywrites were dissolved anyway. It's definitely not about Greed, it's about Business. Just like any other Intellectual Property Lawsuit. /
If marvin gaye was alive... They would have a beautiful duet mash up!
It sound so good, the family should consider teaming up and making that a hit!
This fiya!!! I couldn't see anything until I heard this and now, I can't see anything but a dope blend of 2 iconic and very different songs!
This is so incredibly well done, just a beautiful mix of melodies complementing each other. Bravo !
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
They don't sound the same!
Just sounds so great blended together
This is beautifully meshed up. It's very classic. It has some similarities. But both songs are uniquely different.
"Jury selection and opening statements began Monday in a trial that mashes up Ed Sheeran's "Thinking Out Loud" with Marvin Gaye's "Let's Get It On."
The heirs of Ed Townsend, Gaye's co-writer of the 1973 soul classic, sued Sheeran, alleging the English pop star's 2014 hit tune has "striking similarities" to "Let's Get It On" and "overt common elements" that violate their copyright.
The two songs were released decades apart, but some say they sound seamless when paired together.
"This must stop," Townsend's daughter, Kathryn Griffin-Townsend, said last month. "We have enough chaos going on in the world today, besides having to stand here and worry about other people stealing other people's belongings."
The lawsuit filed in 2017 has finally made it to a trial that is expected to last a week in the Manhattan federal courtroom of 95-year-old Judge Louis L. Stanton."
www.cbsnews.com/news/ed-sheeran-marvin-gaye-copyright-trial/
It's unfortunate for the bullshit put out. History repeats. I think of it as a compliment to the original. It's what makes beautiful music. Sadly, all is explored. I love all music from the past, and if the youth of today want to go ahead and use it to make music by all means, go ahead. I know where it came from, and so do you. I would rather hear a beautiful mesh up than an awful mesh up of a classic. No need for the hate...
@@the44118 Ed sure tf don't sound black.
Mfers are just trying to get paid for anything. Typical.
You can't own a fukkin chord progression.
Geniud.
@@the44118 Get over yoself. Because a white person can sing a lil bit, you think they're trying to sound black.
😂😂😂
@@the44118 black people just love to say something dumb like white singers sounding black, like you own any form of art and youre a cringe gatekeeper.
I’m gonna steal “ Got to give it up “ and get famous!!!! Great idea... wish me luck
😂😂
Too late, Robin Thicke already stole Got To Give It Up and made Blurred Lines
genial 😍😍😍 y los efectos fantásticos
What a fuss!! I love both songs, they’re definitely similar (in a VERY subtle way) but theyre not the same.
Lo que no se puede negar es que el baile esta perfectamente echo para esta combinacion entre las dos cansiones quedo hermosa asi❤
Qué hermosa combinación
my favorite song of all time
This mashup is sooo good. Damn !
Beautiful!! Now pay up!!!!
just epic...love it !!
Beautiful mashup ❤
It ain't beautiful for Ed since he's facing trial and might have to pay 100 mil dllrs
No amigo eeeepicoquedo, full gold!!!
I’m glad I’m not the only one imagining things when I thought these sounded similar
Same. Whenever I hear Marvin Gayes, especially towards the end, I can't not hear Eds vocals matching up perfectly to it.
Wondering if Marvin Gaye family got paid
Chord progression is the only thing that is similar. Chord progression isn't able to be copywritten. Thousands of songs would be in trouble if so
The lawsuit has been reopened.....
@@michellemiranda6545 Ed just won! Which is good because we can't be this strict about "copying" when there's only so many chords that EXIST. similar chord progression does not mean copying. it's almost impossible to make a song these days that doesn't have SOME similarity to already existing songs and that's ok!
Damn this is good 💖
Hermoso
Muito bom!!!
Que genio eres 🤙🤙🤙
En realidad 1171karl me ayudó a realizar el Mashup yo sólo hice el video y la traducción. Gracias por comentar. Checa este video te va a encantar. Salu2 amigo 😁 ua-cam.com/video/HuAbpPyWOnE/v-deo.html
LOL NO WAY SOMEON THIS IS ACTUALLY GOOD WTF
Magnifique !
bravo Ed Sheeran.....keep writing songs dude
Both are amazing songs
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
I’m aware of the lawsuit…
I’m torn between both sides!
However, the mashup was BEAUTIFUL!!! They need to collaborate and promote this…
It’s effing awesome!
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
So you’re unaware Marvin has been dead since 1984.
@@natecooke Ed Sheeran is a music-stealing bastard. But what does Marvin's death have to do with music thief Ed Sheeran?
@@natecooke who said that?! Everyone knows the f’n song and everyone knows he’s dead! I was saying I didn’t know about the drama surrounding the lawsuit.… 😒 jackass
Axis of awesome would be proud!!
Not the same song but holy shit they go great together
Amo os dois, épocas diferentes e sucesso total ...vamos deixar assim gente como esta!!!!
cada um na sua e todos curtinho ...
It is similar in tempo and so on, but I'm guessing these chord types are standards across the board. Any DJ will tell you about Beats Per Minute. Two similar records that mix well (exactly as we have here). But that I'm afraid is as similar as it gets. The family of Marvin are out for a bit of cash and I'm sorry, I am not buying it. I'm a huge Marvin fan (more than I am of Ed Sheeran) but these two songs are not the same by a long shot.
I'm speechless 😮. They did that. I had to send it to my aunt. I'm so freaking on repeat. It's so sexy and soothing. 😮
wooow te salio genial el videoo :) :)
me gustaría ser vecina de la familia de Marvin Gaye y despertarlos todas las mañanas con esta canción
un truc de ouf. remix trop cool
wow, seamless mashup
🔥🔥🔥
RIP MARVIN ❤️
mola el remix
Much like love, better together than apart.
Totally different songs...same chord progression, but there are hundreds of songs using the same chords... there are only so many notes and chords available. But wow they sound great together!
Marvin Gaye has no equal. But this is a cool mix.
Idk how Sheeran got away with this. The songs sound identical and have the same runtime. Rest in Peace Mr. Gaye.
Because he did and rightfully so, there’s a lot more to music production than u clearly know and mr gaye would be turning in his grave to see this be taken to court👍
You can't copyright a c chord and g chord progression when 1000 songs before marvin did it. there's only so many notes that will go together
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing de Matt Cardle (2012) e Photograph de Ed Sheeran (2014). 😁😁😁
This is version is probably responsible for the $100 Million dollar lawsuit against Sheeran!
Sheeran won, he took his guitar,he played like 50 songs to the jury, half where a couple hundred years before marvin, with the same chord progression.,
Listening to it the Marvin Gaye melody sounds different, even though the mashup blends nicely. Its a fune line because musicians hear things that maybe an untrained ear can't hear. With that being said the blend sounds good! Ed won his casr so its settled.
lol you had the exact same idea as me XD
Somos uno mismo 🤣
@@fercho2147 🤣
@@fercho2147did you know about the lawsuit before you did this mashup.
Can you now do a mash up of Perfect and Unchained Melody please .
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣NOTHING LIKE' LETS GET IT ON '
Who's the DJ that made this mash?
This mashup sounds amazing. Two distinctly different songs. Not my favourite songs but they just sound so good together like this. I don't think it's right what they are doing now to sue Ed Sheeran and didn't they sue Pharrell or somebody too? ...but all creative people are influenced by the ones who came before that is not right to sue them for it.
It's not right to make money off of someone else's creativity.
Distinct HOW?
The kid Ed Sheeran also stole music from Van Morrison Marvin Gaye, Sami Swicth, and in this case the British court ordered the suspension of copyright payments. Sheeran also stole music from girl group TLC, and country singer Jasmine Rae. The song thief didn't stop there, he stole an entire song from singer Matt Cardle, he had to pay 20 million dollars for stealing Matt's song. Sheeran is a dirty, bastard thief.
@@BarryBlockZay617 Especially if they don't (at the very least) credit the original artist if the song is sampled.
I'm so glad Ed won. They sound very different to me. I bet we could mashup many songs that are very different. I hope the losers also get to pay for Ed's lawyers.
Bem diferente, mas ambas as músicas são lindas.
Nothing like it
Gaye’s co-writer’s heirs would have done better to work with Ed Sheeran in promoting something of this nature, which would have entered into the true spirit of music and appealed to Sheeran’s sense of fun. That would have been a creative, win win solution. By attacking as they did, it gives the impression that they make their living by cashing in on the talents of others.
The UK case was really a stretch and it was right that Ed won. However I gotta say that for this one, if you take out the melody, they're exactly the same.
Same with half the songs of today. You can use a simple 4 chord progression and play 100s of different songs
@@patrickkuhn5069 it’s not just the chord progression. It’s also the same key, bpm and has the same drums, almost exactly. The reason it’s such a seamless mashup is because they are so similar.
@@beccivoyante they are in different keys, they transposed this for the mashup. the groove is the same for sure, and the progression too. but that happens a lottttt
se parecen bastante. Lamentable porque amo esa canción y al artista. ojalá se arregle bien el problema.
Go ti hell
Oh lawd who did this lmao
São parecidas ! Não acho que é plágio .
Cuando supe del plagio me desepcionó mucho ed Sheeran 😿 pero casi todos los grandes lo han hecho tristemente.
I don't hear a similarity.
because he did a mashup rather than doing a side by side.
Lawyers already on it😂
hasta parece que Marvin Gaye es el que canta en el mismo escenario de gala en el que Ed baila
Basically writting over Marvin classic and just changing words not rhythm. Of course it sound different because nobody sounds like Marvin. But they robbed a hit
The chords are slightly different, too. So the we're losing the harmonies in Marvin's song because the mashup is using the harmonies in Ed's song throughout.
standard. so no lawsuit.
Quem diria que isso daria no que está dando...
I found nothing
Gaye's vocals are surprisingly effective over Sheeran's chord progression
Are you referring to the pre chorus chords? Because technically, Marvin used the progression first lol
@@94808G the chord progressions aren’t unique
Now Ed is getting sued
It’s because it’s Marvin Gaye…..
The pre-chorus later in the mash up is technically Ed's but it's a 2,5,1 walk down basically the foundation of jazz and Marvin's chords werent revolutionary either 1, minor 3, 4, 5 has been used 1000 times before
Caraca kkkkkkkkkkkkk mas achava que o compasso não dava treta de plágio... Acho meio sem noção. Mas claramente foi inspirado
Copiado
Música mesmo ...não apenas compasso
@@camilarosadasilva2530 copia descarada kkkkkkkk.
El ritmo o música es muy parecido
Yt people have always stolen BP's IP. There is no question.
copiou descaradamente
Agora a Adele e a do Martinho da vila , sim aquela foi plágio declaradamente.
so not the same song just a side that wants money
I am no fan of Ed and his often lame feel-good music, plus he tries a bit hard - “visually” (wink) - in this video but these two songs are only similar in mood and a very common chord progression. Marvin’s estate does not have ownership this sound. Come on! His estate people are looking rather petty if not plain silly.
I should sue BOTH Sheeran AND Gaye For STEALING ...MY ...UNRECORDED song I Entitled..." TAKE ME INTO YOUR LOVIN ARMS SO WE CAN GET....IT....ON!!!"
Well bye Ed he say he will quit music if he loses the copyright law suit. I guess he quitting because it does sound like Marvin gaye song
Now will cost him $100 mil
Give me Marvin over Ed any day. Ed sounds too much like calpadi a d sam smith. All as dreary as onr another. Marvin had soul and made you feel the song. Today's 'artists', if thry can be called such given they are so alike sounding to one another, don't do that.
just because you can apply it to the song does't mean it's the same.. let's just not make any more new music, let AI make it .. let's see who sues it!
They tried to get super slick with the lyrics
Q bueno que Es Sheeran le ganó,,💲no sé parece en nada las dos canciones, también va decir la q canta con J.balvi y Ed Sheeran
Not not not not
They’re two completely different songs honestly but they do mashup well lol.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Não acho q é plágio
O som da guitarra o arranjo em fim só sei que deu até Feat ❤
Se isso não é plágio...não sei o que seria.
Cara isso não é plágio é CRTL C , CRTL V
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
E Photograph de Ed Sheeran(2014) com Amazing de Matt Cardle(2012)?
same rhytm but different lyric.. that's all! both are original songwriters!
plagio
Es que si tienen el mismo ritmo aunque la letra sea diferente jaja es un plagio. Cómo si cojo el despacito y cambio a rapidito
You’re describing an interpolation. If Ed had presented it as such, there would be no problem
They are not the same song. Don't be idiots.
It's just most pops could be merged and mashed up nicely.
Sounds like Ed borrowed a lot from Marvin's song. He has a tough legal case. Olivia Rodrigo only interpolated a little from other artists and paid up royalties immediately.
Isso é plagio sim da melodia e do arranjo
@@mrt7440 uiii arriba arriba arriba, tacos, burritos, arriba arriba, sombrerooo
I’m chocked! Ed , I can’t believe! Shame
This doesn’t sound like Let’s Get It On at ALL!! You’ve ruined a great classic by mashing it up with this newer song. Yuck!
Ms Townsend must be running out of cash to sue over this. The mash up works but listen to the songs separately you wouldn’t associate them as one copied the other. Ridiculous. No wonder Me Townsend passed out of embarrassment.
Ed getting sued due to this mashup
I hear similarity, but much of it is not similar. Nope. I heard Marvin's song when it first released back in the day. Lol (long time ago) However, I'm older now, heard Sheeran's and it definitely not a copy of Marvin's. 🙏❤ Also, because of the age gap in the 2 songs, does not hold all truth Sheeran copied Marvin's. Many other tunes out there by young artist now a days, have similar notes to tunes created as far back as when Elvis Presley was known as King of rock n roll. Come on now ... Let the good times roll..listen to Christian music, many, many songs have same similarities...it's all good. 😊
Ed sheeran song is a hit, is because he Copied Marvin Gayes Hit. Let's Get It On! It's a No Brainer. He's not sampling, he copied the Whole Riff. I thought after 20 years all songs copywrites were dissolved anyway. It's definitely not about Greed, it's about Business. Just like any other Intellectual Property Lawsuit. /
Copied
This is like saying I own the English language and all the musical notes and you used them without my permission.
This is nothing next to Dua Lipas blatant rip off.