Oss Braa = what he is explaning here is that the particular move in heian sandan can also be interpreted as a throwing technique. In my opinion the turaround to the final two movements can also be interpreted as throwing techniques. I will check my judo book for the names of the corresponding judo throw and let you know. Greetings from South Africa
@@braachan1310 OK.. for the technique he is using you can have a look at O Osoto Gari. The othwr throw I mentioned = when you do the oi zuki before turning around for the last 2 movements (with hook punches over the shoulder and elbow strike to the body) = the oi zuki can be grabbing the opponents forearm, turn around, move in and get your arm around the neck (hook punch) and pull opponents arm in towards your body (empi uchi to the back) and do a hip throw = see O Goshi. Working the neck/head is easier than grabbing around the body. The last 2 movements of bassai dacan also be interpreted as a throw = see tai otoshi. Interesting stuff, enjoy experimenting. Basic judo throws helped me plenty with kumite and bunkai. Oss
I love karate, I from in American south, and I no understand, if you can do subtitles in Spanish or English I understand you. But the kicks no traductor, this is very important
Thanks for sharing the video. Sensei I think your videos are watched worldwide, and unfortunately all don't understand Japanese, so please transcribe in English so that we also benefit from your research and teaching. Arigato Sensei 🙏
For me, the question is that all this work is against oi suki fron a long distance. What happens wren the oponnent don't do a step ahead (ayumi) or y have to react closer. Have I the time to block and counter. It is the way you train the same the way you fight? For instance, if a Myke Tysson approach you fast and hook you close quarters, how do tou deal with? If karate is for self defence, we must answer this.
How convenient would it be if all attackers came at you with a useless oi zuki from a mile away and stood still with the other hand on the hip while they let you do whatever you want!
Not really the point here Bro = he is giving very valuable information and it need not be an oi zuki = it can be a grab for your jacket, hook punch = the application will be the same. If you want to reason this way then I guess it will make rifle training on a shooting range popping static targets just as useless...
@@zommellemmoz3999 Thank you. It's funny to hear hear these folks, a lot of whom probably have never trained in anything, or trained in a bad school become experts overnight. As a traditional man myself I too believe it's important to learn and understand the principles.of more hands on training. That doesn't mean the traditional applications wouldn't work. Of course they will. They'd work just fine against the common attacker, and in the mean time, if you can pick up boxing, or muay Thai, or bjj, or whatever's popping in mma, it can help traditional karateka understand how to turn ppl inside out. Let's just train. Less lecturing. Just train.
I think un oi suki is as useless as any other technik when applied without criteria. But I agree that training only against long distance oi suki is not valid.
やっぱり空手の本質は制圧ですね！ 少なくとも壊しではない。
何故壊しちゃいけないんだ？
@@y.f8264
結局は人間観の違いでしょう。
そのコメントから1年経ったようだけど、まだ誰かを壊したいですか？
高校のときだったか、協会本部の会議で型の解釈がこう変わったので動きがこう変わった。来年の試合からはこの動きでないと減点されるから練習しろ。協会は常に型の解釈を研究しているから変わることがある事を覚えておけ、と教わったのを思い出した。
型の解説動画めちゃくちゃ面白い。
これは！！！！
感動しました
凄すぎてビックリしました。
最近空手で平安三段やってますがまさか相手を投げることが出来ると型は思いませんでした
私も思いました‼️
Interesting video however I was more impressed that the JKA were finally practicing BO Kata too.
やっぱりかっこいい私も見ならいたい空手やってるから
最後の相手と接蝕しないはために成りました。
Naka Sensei - have you been to Fukuoka and trained with Shobayshi Kenshinkai Shorin Ryu under Yoshitaka / Nakano? do you have any videos????
Oss, I'm a karate a member of KWF from Africa , and I'm really asking for a translation for this video , Oss
Oss Braa = what he is explaning here is that the particular move in heian sandan can also be interpreted as a throwing technique. In my opinion the turaround to the final two movements can also be interpreted as throwing techniques. I will check my judo book for the names of the corresponding judo throw and let you know. Greetings from South Africa
@@zommellemmoz3999 thanks a lot my brother I really application what you did , Oss
Really! Greetings to Africa. Here is Brazil!
@@jmartinsesportes Hi there friend from Brazil , nice to meet
@@braachan1310 OK.. for the technique he is using you can have a look at O Osoto Gari. The othwr throw I mentioned = when you do the oi zuki before turning around for the last 2 movements (with hook punches over the shoulder and elbow strike to the body) = the oi zuki can be grabbing the opponents forearm, turn around, move in and get your arm around the neck (hook punch) and pull opponents arm in towards your body (empi uchi to the back) and do a hip throw = see O Goshi. Working the neck/head is easier than grabbing around the body. The last 2 movements of bassai dacan also be interpreted as a throw = see tai otoshi. Interesting stuff, enjoy experimenting. Basic judo throws helped me plenty with kumite and bunkai. Oss
This looks like the real thing.
I love karate, I from in American south, and I no understand, if you can do subtitles in Spanish or English I understand you. But the kicks no traductor, this is very important
これが本来の空手の在るべき姿なだろう。
求道者ですな。
体育館の床で練習はマジ辛い
ひょっとして四股立ちも似たような使い方なのかな
This guy is awesome!
板間で投げられたら痛いやろなー
So it's more of a low kick than a sweep.
Like a sith lord would say "good".
相手が組技格闘技の経験者じゃなきゃ投げれそうですが、経験者だと厳しそうですね
打撃でいかに崩すかが重要になってきそうですね
柔道やレスリングやってる相手にはかからないよね絶対
@@コハク-h8k 単発で大外刈りかけても柔道経験者からしたらビクともしないですし、やるなら柔道で言う崩しがないとまずかかりません。
打撃系格闘家が思ってるより組技経験者は重心が低く本当に投げにくいんです。
おそらく空手だと当身技で崩していくんでしょうけど、果たして投げと組みの融合をどこまで空手家ができるのか、と考えてしまうんですよね。
色々柔道の大外刈りと違う点は先生も述べられてますが、実際に柔道家にかかるかはなんとも言えないのでは？と思ったまでです。
せめて相手の方が柔道経験者なら信頼性も増すんですが…
長々と失礼しました。
素人なら余裕だろうな。
でも相手に大怪我させたら過剰防衛になるな。
Ddi anyone else heard "you ready" at 0:17
Sotogari of judo
What about when there's just street close involved.
Street clothes? As long as they are wearing a jacket or sweater
Gotcha thank u
We were just discussing this last class
サンボの足使いみたい
Thanks for sharing the video. Sensei I think your videos are watched worldwide, and unfortunately all don't understand Japanese, so please transcribe in English so that we also benefit from your research and teaching. Arigato Sensei 🙏
For me, the question is that all this work is against oi suki fron a long distance. What happens wren the oponnent don't do a step ahead (ayumi) or y have to react closer. Have I the time to block and counter. It is the way you train the same the way you fight? For instance, if a Myke Tysson approach you fast and hook you close quarters, how do tou deal with? If karate is for self defence, we must answer this.
Oss sensei
Uo si
How convenient would it be if all attackers came at you with a useless oi zuki from a mile away and stood still with the other hand on the hip while they let you do whatever you want!
Lol it's a demo. It's not that serious.
Not really the point here Bro = he is giving very valuable information and it need not be an oi zuki = it can be a grab for your jacket, hook punch = the application will be the same. If you want to reason this way then I guess it will make rifle training on a shooting range popping static targets just as useless...
@@zommellemmoz3999 Thank you. It's funny to hear hear these folks, a lot of whom probably have never trained in anything, or trained in a bad school become experts overnight. As a traditional man myself I too believe it's important to learn and understand the principles.of more hands on training. That doesn't mean the traditional applications wouldn't work. Of course they will. They'd work just fine against the common attacker, and in the mean time, if you can pick up boxing, or muay Thai, or bjj, or whatever's popping in mma, it can help traditional karateka understand how to turn ppl inside out. Let's just train. Less lecturing. Just train.
I think un oi suki is as useless as any other technik when applied without criteria. But I agree that training only against long distance oi suki is not valid.
This Sensei would kick your ass in a few seconds
Oss