Came here to know about your opinion, but I didn't expect such a beautiful explanation. It was really heart touching. Great job you earned a subscriber 👍
Was gonna say the same thing. How the 7th of October was so reminiscent of the Rumbling. Thise years os suffering ad pain, coming together in a culmination of worst of humanity. The riseing up in itself, where everybody is just stuck in an endless vicious cycle of conflict and war. So, the question is till how far should it go? At what point will someone stop and say no more killings....no more suffering
The problem is what do you do with that info? King Fritz tried to stop the cycle of hatred but Marley still oppressed the eldians outside the walls and still came to the island to kill all of the eldians who were left. It’s not just a cycle of hatred. It’s also just self defense.
Thats a very interesting question - "Who was wrong?" I think this answer is simple but also the closes to "objective truth": All were wrong. But thats boring. Within the story - and Id argue in reality too - the people with the biggest guns are the one that are the most right. Thats not a moral argument, but a pragmatic - as the saying goes: "History is written by the victors." The kind 2000 years ago who used the power of the first titan was right when he had the power, and all the kings after him until King Fritz. Kind Fritz decided to give up/not use his power and let the Marleyans win. Eren came along and decided: "Imma fuck you all up. No. matter.what" - and here we are. But I think going back to a more moral view of things: I agree with you that its just part of the human condition - everybody is right in their own way, they/we are in a cycle that began with the first crime, the first time an Apple was stolen, the first time a tribe "defended" their region fro another one. At the end of the day resources are limited, and we essentially want all of them anyway. And if others have some of the ressources, land, people, women, arts, etc. then how about "we" get them for ourselves?
Came here to know about your opinion, but I didn't expect such a beautiful explanation. It was really heart touching. Great job you earned a subscriber 👍
Same like Palestine vs Israel.
Was gonna say the same thing. How the 7th of October was so reminiscent of the Rumbling. Thise years os suffering ad pain, coming together in a culmination of worst of humanity. The riseing up in itself, where everybody is just stuck in an endless vicious cycle of conflict and war. So, the question is till how far should it go? At what point will someone stop and say no more killings....no more suffering
@@CoolnCarin5241actually October 7th is closer to the beginning of season 4 when Erin crashed that festival.
The problem is what do you do with that info? King Fritz tried to stop the cycle of hatred but Marley still oppressed the eldians outside the walls and still came to the island to kill all of the eldians who were left. It’s not just a cycle of hatred. It’s also just self defense.
Thats a very interesting question - "Who was wrong?"
I think this answer is simple but also the closes to "objective truth": All were wrong.
But thats boring.
Within the story - and Id argue in reality too - the people with the biggest guns are the one that are the most right. Thats not a moral argument, but a pragmatic - as the saying goes: "History is written by the victors."
The kind 2000 years ago who used the power of the first titan was right when he had the power, and all the kings after him until King Fritz.
Kind Fritz decided to give up/not use his power and let the Marleyans win.
Eren came along and decided: "Imma fuck you all up. No. matter.what" - and here we are.
But I think going back to a more moral view of things: I agree with you that its just part of the human condition - everybody is right in their own way, they/we are in a cycle that began with the first crime, the first time an Apple was stolen, the first time a tribe "defended" their region fro another one.
At the end of the day resources are limited, and we essentially want all of them anyway. And if others have some of the ressources, land, people, women, arts, etc. then how about "we" get them for ourselves?
I was right
Eren is wrong. Period.
Zeke is the most moral person of the show.