I can hear the difference yeah, but I'm a little skeptical to say it's nahyo, it could be bgv or different bgvs, but I really don't know EDIT: yeah i think its fr nahyo, still wouldnt be surprised if it wasnt but at least I can hear both now
Sabía que el coro era Nahyo, literalmente se escucha perfectamente la voz de Jihyo en la segunda parte y la primera por estructura es obviamente Nayeon (a parte de que en los filtros se la escucha a ella). Como Mina biased tengo que admitir que me pone triste, pero no soy estúpido y no me voy a poner a hatear un canal por una ld, es entretenimiento, que muchas veces la gente se olvida de esto.
So i guess i was right for once 😭 i always heard te oh oh oh as Nahyo, lowkey rhink that people just don't want them to be first and second (which i get honestly)
It sounds like Nahyo to me, the "oh oh oh"s sound different from each other, and Jihyo's voice (to me) sounds a lot like the bgvs, so I think that's why people think it's bgv
@@miam_k But it still sounds like Nayeon or Jihyo, and ddp will probably count the "oh oh oh"s of nayeon and jihyo in the line, so it doesn't really matter;--;
@@Miyeonijihyobias okay? the point I'm trying to make isn't "it's not nahyo because I don't hear them", I'm just sharing my opinion. ddp can make the videos based on their opinion just like I can comment my opinion under their video
Es curioso porque el coro la parte de Nayeon no se escucha como ella, a diferencia de la de Jihyo que si la llego a escuchar a ella, pero sigo pensando que son BV
Idk for Jihyos at 0:34 I kinda hear jeongyeon’s breath.. if that makes sense? The vocals you labeled as background vocals in 0:48 is what sounds like Jihyo to me 😅
imo the 0:34 sounds so far to be Jeongyeon, and structurally not make sense about 0:48, i don’t mark are the background vocalist, only put as the background vocals layer, but yeah, i kinda hear Jihyo, and some of Nayeon too, i think the girls do some background vocals, in other parts like Chae and Sana, sounds like them do background vocals in their respective lines, even if them are not accredited, but in the chorus i’m not sure at all, that’s why i don’t marked like and member or a bgv
Siempre he pensado que los oh Oh oh oh oh son del nahyo, pero al no haber tantas presentaciones de esta canción es muy difícil saber, sobre todo por las background vocals
Y la única presentación confunde aún más porque la enfocan a Dahyun en el verso de Sana y de ahí comenzó la confusión, porque puede ser tanto Sana como Dahyun pero se necesita URGENTE un live
@@avrilynicolas3247ya se confirmó que las chicas saldrán de tour a mitad de año, esperemos que canten esta canción en en encore (ruleta) y salga esta, de esa forma de podrá ver si son ellas, o si en verdad el coro es all o no a través del monitor
So not only would this mean Mina’s not first, but that means NaHyo take the top 2 spots in all 9 songs on Twicecoaster 😑. Amazing variety, JYPE, I don’t think I’ve seen one of their albums have this much variety with the top 2 since Between 1&2 🙄 /s.
No. Es una all line. Nayeon y Jihyo solo ignoran el "like crazy" y "like baby" porque se sobreponen con la línea principal. Si el resto del coro fueran líneas propiamente suyas, no deberían tener ningún problema en aunque sea hacer lip sync.
creo que eso no tiene fundamento, como dije anteriormente, el hecho de que las miembros ignoren sus líneas ni quiere decir, o que no sean ellas, o que sea “all”, tampoco creo que tiene que ver si son “Main o Lead Vocalist”, hay ad-libs en otras canciones, que como tu dices, son simples de hacer, y de igual forma Nahyo ignora eso. otro ejemplo es Ponytail, Nayeon ignora por completo el duo con Jihyo hasta llegar a la nota alta, e ignora la High Note, no por eso quiere decir que no es ella. aparte el único que puede decir si es “all” o no al 100% es el monitor, yo no estoy confirmado que no lo sea, simplemente es desde mi perspectiva a base de lo que hay.
@@snsdgivemetwice don't get me wrong but I know you from wanting Mina to be first or to have more lines, like in Oxygen which you insisted the intro was not Tzuyu, or when you wanted Ocean Deep to be the title track because then Mina would be first in a tt. so I kinda think you only think Nahyo doesn't sing there because Mina will keep her 1st position no judgement, no drama, just my observation
Yeah, definitely Nayeon and Jihyo at the chorus
Finally can hear the difference in the choruses
Same after all these years 😭🙌
Yeah, Definitely Is Nayeon And Jihyo 😍🙌🏻
R.I.P Mina First Place 😭
I think that Mina is still first actually
@Gidlestan12345 if you think that none of nahyos lines are "all" then no minas undebatably 3rd
@@cosmicld 😭 but yeah I always thought it's Nahyo I'm not dumb like rest of the fandom to think that for example fancy youu is all line
@@Gidlestan12345but it is though...😭
@@cosmicld yeah for Momo lines let's say that is all line 😭
i'm still thinking the "oh oh oh oh oh" shouldn't be counted as Nahyo but ok
I can hear the difference yeah, but I'm a little skeptical to say it's nahyo, it could be bgv or different bgvs, but I really don't know
EDIT: yeah i think its fr nahyo, still wouldnt be surprised if it wasnt but at least I can hear both now
Sabía que el coro era Nahyo, literalmente se escucha perfectamente la voz de Jihyo en la segunda parte y la primera por estructura es obviamente Nayeon (a parte de que en los filtros se la escucha a ella). Como Mina biased tengo que admitir que me pone triste, pero no soy estúpido y no me voy a poner a hatear un canal por una ld, es entretenimiento, que muchas veces la gente se olvida de esto.
Preach 🙌🙌
I still can't hear NaHyo in the "oh oh oh oh"😭
Mina is one of my biases but how do people not see the second "oh oh oh" as Jihyo lol
So i guess i was right for once 😭 i always heard te oh oh oh as Nahyo, lowkey rhink that people just don't want them to be first and second (which i get honestly)
Fine u caught me;-;...
Not in this song tho
I've never seen a line distribution as complicated as this one from TWICE
Trick It? Flow like waves?
It's been 7 years since Feel special and we're still yet to see a 100% accurate trick it distribution though
Next page (UPDATED)
1) Jihyo: 30.31
2) Nayeon: 30.28
3) Mina: 26.26
4) Tzuyu: 19.20
5) Jeongyeon : 14.22
6) Momo: 10.37
7) Chaeyoung: 9.80
8) Sana: 9.77
9) Dahyun:9.68
RIP Mina’s first place 😭😭😭😭
@ShadowPurple12425 true but the chorus is still not confirmed to be nahyo so it's uncertain that mina is 3rd, she might be 1st as well
@@SPRSH-gs4zx Ok :)
@@SPRSH-gs4zx Ok :)
@@SPRSH-gs4zx no dahyun is not last anymore with hose two ad-libs and neither chaeyoung
I literally can't hear nahyo in the ohohoh 😭
the oh oh oh oh oh oh is def not nahyo imo 😭
its the two bgvs
It sounds like Nahyo to me, the "oh oh oh"s sound different from each other, and Jihyo's voice (to me) sounds a lot like the bgvs, so I think that's why people think it's bgv
@@Miyeonijihyobias there's two different bgvs credited on this song, I do not hear nahyo so it's the two bgvs imo
@@miam_k But it still sounds like Nayeon or Jihyo, and ddp will probably count the "oh oh oh"s of nayeon and jihyo in the line, so it doesn't really matter;--;
@@Miyeonijihyobias okay? the point I'm trying to make isn't "it's not nahyo because I don't hear them", I'm just sharing my opinion. ddp can make the videos based on their opinion just like I can comment my opinion under their video
@@miam_k But it really sounds like Nayeon and Jihyo, so I don't think it's a matter of opinion
I honestly can't hear nahyo on the chorus
2 seconds ago ❤😊
Sooo Im guessing Nahyo is first and Second all over again 😂😢😅😭☠️
Now We Can Hear The Difference Of The Lines. But Are You Gonna Make A Line Distribution Of Next Page
yes obviously
Es curioso porque el coro la parte de Nayeon no se escucha como ella, a diferencia de la de Jihyo que si la llego a escuchar a ella, pero sigo pensando que son BV
I just love you so much, I always heard Nayho in the chorus
Idk for Jihyos at 0:34 I kinda hear jeongyeon’s breath.. if that makes sense? The vocals you labeled as background vocals in 0:48 is what sounds like Jihyo to me 😅
Damn looking at the comments I think I’m the only one that mentioned JY 😂😭
imo the 0:34 sounds so far to be Jeongyeon, and structurally not make sense
about 0:48, i don’t mark are the background vocalist, only put as the background vocals layer, but yeah, i kinda hear Jihyo, and some of Nayeon too, i think the girls do some background vocals, in other parts like Chae and Sana, sounds like them do background vocals in their respective lines, even if them are not accredited, but in the chorus i’m not sure at all, that’s why i don’t marked like and member or a bgv
No se escucha cono si fueran Nahyo es muy reconocible las voces sunan mas a voces de fondo
I'm still believe that's not NAHYO. 😊
Siempre he pensado que los oh Oh oh oh oh son del nahyo, pero al no haber tantas presentaciones de esta canción es muy difícil saber, sobre todo por las background vocals
Y la única presentación confunde aún más porque la enfocan a Dahyun en el verso de Sana y de ahí comenzó la confusión, porque puede ser tanto Sana como Dahyun pero se necesita URGENTE un live
@@avrilynicolas3247ya se confirmó que las chicas saldrán de tour a mitad de año, esperemos que canten esta canción en en encore (ruleta) y salga esta, de esa forma de podrá ver si son ellas, o si en verdad el coro es all o no a través del monitor
@@DDP121 Ojalá presenten Next Page y también Shadow o Bring It back 😢. Son de las canciones más confusas y necesitamos live
@@avrilynicolas3247it must be crazy what I'm about to say...
@@avrilynicolas3247lo de bring it back, es como el caso de 132 y hell in heaven, en el puente usaron tzuyu y Jeongyeon
So not only would this mean Mina’s not first, but that means NaHyo take the top 2 spots in all 9 songs on Twicecoaster 😑. Amazing variety, JYPE, I don’t think I’ve seen one of their albums have this much variety with the top 2 since Between 1&2 🙄 /s.
ready to be*
@@DahyunRockedMinaShocked Chae ties second place with Nayeon in CSL
@ It doesn't really matter but 0.1 seconds difference
@@DahyunRockedMinaShocked it's quite timer dependent, it's better as a tie imo
@@DahyunRockedMinaShocked it's quite timer dependent, it's better as a tie imo
Pero no creo que se cuente por que en vivo se ve que no cantan (aunque sean ellas
so, you'll count the "oh oh oh oh s"? i think mina won't be first then
yeah, i don’t have a reason to not counted 😅
Will we get to hear the tt adlibs? Even though we already know who’s singing them
uhhhhhh.... i am not sure that part is nahyo.
goodbye Mina first
No. Es una all line. Nayeon y Jihyo solo ignoran el "like crazy" y "like baby" porque se sobreponen con la línea principal. Si el resto del coro fueran líneas propiamente suyas, no deberían tener ningún problema en aunque sea hacer lip sync.
creo que eso no tiene fundamento, como dije anteriormente, el hecho de que las miembros ignoren sus líneas ni quiere decir, o que no sean ellas, o que sea “all”, tampoco creo que tiene que ver si son “Main o Lead Vocalist”, hay ad-libs en otras canciones, que como tu dices, son simples de hacer, y de igual forma Nahyo ignora eso.
otro ejemplo es Ponytail, Nayeon ignora por completo el duo con Jihyo hasta llegar a la nota alta, e ignora la High Note, no por eso quiere decir que no es ella.
aparte el único que puede decir si es “all” o no al 100% es el monitor, yo no estoy confirmado que no lo sea, simplemente es desde mi perspectiva a base de lo que hay.
@DDP121 dale
I don’t hear nayho at all in the chorus sorry 😭
it was debunked again lol. so mina's actual first first place is someone like me and not next page 😔
I can clearly hear Nahyo🥲
lmaoo nahyo do NOT sing oh oh oh parts
they obviously do lol
@@murilo6233that's just BGV, that's sound not like Jihyo or Nayeon at all. Lol
@@snsdgivemetwice don't get me wrong but I know you from wanting Mina to be first or to have more lines, like in Oxygen which you insisted the intro was not Tzuyu, or when you wanted Ocean Deep to be the title track because then Mina would be first in a tt. so I kinda think you only think Nahyo doesn't sing there because Mina will keep her 1st position
no judgement, no drama, just my observation
I still can't hear Jihyo in "Like Baby". I hear Nayeon, then Jihyo only in "oh oh oh" parts.
Yea that sounds like either dahyun or tzuyu lol
@@whatsopanime fr
So mina no first