@Rafael Enriquez What the fuck did you smoke? You know IRL you dont put the stock at your chest as its presented in video games where magically your iron sights are in the middle of your eyes? Youve got these things called muscles you use to tilt your head to the gun or in this case launcher to aim down the sights, same here with the Panzerfaust. You have the panzerfaust either in your arm pit or on your shoulder with your hand above the release as your hold so the thing doesnt just knock you over when you fire it. Then you aim in your sights and press the release.
@@LocalDeepstateAgent I'm pretty sure he knows, he is just pointing out that in the game it looks like the panzerfaust is placed in the middle of the chest
PS has a genuinely good thing apart from the reload animations and details, it's the iron sights themselves. Most games prefer to use night time apertures for obvious reasons (using the real ones might cause a ton of players to immediately switch from iron sights to optical ones), in PS however, most of the weapons have accurate aperture sizes. It's a subtle addition which is actually needed in today's games.
it wont be sadly since most games are turning into arcadey shooters so people will want the wide open easy to look through iron sights that have become super trendy since call of duty made it trendy around mw2-black ops
I personally enjoy both sights myself, my eyes aren't really the best so the larger sights are nice, but the realistic ones are well, realistic, which is nice.
What I love about the PS reloads, regardless whether it's intended or not, is that the characters hand is sometimes shaking during a reload. Seems like a nice detail I wish more games had, it just shows that the soldiers are afraid/under pressure. You can see it well at the STG44 reload once the soldier pulls out a new mag (6:35) or the way the M1911 shakes (0:48).
I don't know if it's unintended roughness of the animations, but some of Post Scriptum's reloads look like the character's hands are slightly shaking from combat fatigue (like the M1911, for example), which I find quite fascinating.
I like how in post scriptum you can kinda see the soldiers hands shaking when using the 1911 my guess is the game is trying to show ptsd but I could be wrong and interpreting it for more than it actually is
BFV: *AcCePt iT Or dOnT bUy iT* Me: _Plays Post Scriptum_ Also EA and DICE: before the game dies, would you like to buy a WW2 TOM CRUISE DLC?? That will be 10 dollars lmao! Me: *Haha* me goes away from Battlefield Franchise.
Peter Nehemiah battlefields weapons are still very well done, I prefer battlefields reloads more than post scriptums. But everything else is just not good. The pacific was great tho
RuyXavier it was good with the pacific...... then they fucking cancel it? This was my first ever battlefield and my last I will never ever buy another one. I don’t care if this game in particular is not good but when they do absolutely no effort whatsoever to improve it and cancel the game when there’s 1 and a half year to the next battlefield I’m fucking done. Never buying battlefield again. Your right it is shit what a disappointment
@@enjoi9970 The whole PS and Squad community would beg to differ. Yes its a lot more realistic and "slower" to an extent but that doesn't make it boring. Of course boring is subjective, but at the same time you can't say something is boring because it is slower paced. Please don't tell me you thought RDR2 wasn't a good game either because it was "slow"?
The guns in Post Scriptum all actually sound different. That’s always been my one issue with battlefield, each gun sounds the exact same and especially in 5.
Which is actually bullshit. If you had some old worn out never taken care of Bren from the french resistance? Yes sure the mags gonna be wobbly. But the ones used by the actual fighting nations didnt wobble around like that. Also that is the only redeeming quality about BF5, a shaking magazine. Kinda weak for a supposing tripple A title.
@@LocalDeepstateAgent watch a video in slow motion of any bren-style action under recoil, the mag will akways shake a little. You can find some good quality footage of the Stoner 63/63A in this configuration that clearly shows it.
even the m4 or ak magazines shakes a little while shooting (especially can be seen on slow motion) but A LITTLE not that much like in bfV but yea, i can belive that carabines used in battle (especially on WWII battlefields) can be that much worn to wiggle that heavy magazines when shooting (which can cause jams btw c: and sorry for my weak english :c)
There's so much bass applied to everything in BFV, I much prefer the sharper cracks and pops of Post Scriptum. Feels like there is more variation to the sound profiles.
Not an expert, but after some light research I can say that the mp40 has a notch for the bolt that served as an extra safety/bolt hold open, so slapping the charging handle is accurate
@@felonytaxevasion2773 the bolt sits a good inch and a half in the notch, the gun would need to be vertically up in order to slap it out of position and even then its pointless since its open bolt so it wouldn't travel far.
After looking at pictures of the notch, it might be possible to hk slap it, if you came at the charging handle at an angle. But I haven’t seen anybody do that, so it would probably make more sense to have them not slap the charging handle
Well first of all, that isnt really a HK slap thats more a kung fu slice on the "release" and yes, it is perfectly fine since the MP40 has no real safety just a locking mechanism which you could slap out of locking with enough force. Ofc. no soldier in the war would even do that but its one way to show the MP40 reload in a tacticool manner.
The sound team of BFV was very good, i mean, they recreated the V1 rocket sound using a snowmobile with parts from a V1 but the Game Balance team uh, because of them it was sometimes unplayable. Anyway i prefer PS it has a very good immersion and obviously a well made game
yeah it's way too action movie like and doesnt even make sense since the mp40s bolt hold-open notch is hook shaped so you wouldnt be able to just slap the bolt handle free you would need to unhook it first
@@midas01tw i'm talking about the shape of the little slot to hold the charging handle in place not the shape of the charging handle itself, i know they switched from a hooked shape handle to a round nub shape
I’ve always liked how more realistic games like PS have more sharp sound effects than most triple A games. Many big franchises have sounds that should soft. I also like how the gun moves somewhat independently of the screen when firing, this is much more similar to recoil irl. In big games the entire screen will move with the gun, but here in PS we can see guns basically firing off screen when going full auto for too long. This goes to show the difference between the more realistic, tactical genre and the more arcade like ones. In games like PS the bullets come front be gun, but in bigger games like BF the bullets come from the eyes.
This is meant to be a “Small game is better at big game at realism” type deal however, we’re comparing an arcade game where basic realism is all that’s needed and is executed spectacularly vs a realistic combat game that executes it as well relative to how small of a team it had
Didn't see anyone talk about the shell ejections. Look at the first three pistols. BFV has the shells eject in different directions, while PS is pretty much all the same for all of them. Looks better if you have motion blur enabled as well. Edit: Not sure what's going on at 7:15 either.
MasterMindEcho Idk about an explanation, all I know is that PS uses actual physics instead of premapped animations for their bullets, that why they look identical
MasterMindEcho Battlefield uses physics alongside animation, the shell ejecting in bfv is a set animation, and when it hits the ground it utilizes physics for a few seconds before disappearing. In PS the shell is actually flung out of the chamber and physics does the rest,
Post Scriptum definitely takes the cake. Granted I was never really a fan of BF animations in the first place. PS anims are just more solid and satisfying.
Max Canadian you implied that you dislike it by saying nothing but something negative about it which leads anyone to believe that you have an overall negative view on the game. If I were to say “damn this food is tasteless” and nothing else any normal human being would think that you don’t like it
I respect the fact that Post Scriptum doesn’t make nearly as many compromises with the iron sights for the sake of usability. Battlefield and Cod have exaggerated how open peep sights are. They’re typically VERY small
I know most guns don’t get destroyed easily but the reloads in bfv feels both trying to act cool like and also it’s like trying his best to break the gun.....
i dont like how your character in BF5 just swings the anti-tank rifle and machine guns around when he reloads them while having the bipod out, i like how in PS when reloading your gun when the bipod is deployed it's still in that position which actually makes sense
Post Scriptum sounds like they mixed DOI sounds with real life recordings and added better gun mechanic sounds, very good. Battlefield sounds like they remixed sounds from Medal of Honor European Assault and other Battlefield titles.
It looks like PS has a more accurate representation of iron sights compared to BF5. Some like the M1911 look super sloppy and too open compared to PS. Edit: Brilliant job.
For some reason, the MP40 in Battlefield 5 has quite the recoil, even thos it fires 9mm The MP18 in Battlefield 1 has almost no recoil, and it fires the same caliber as the MP40
And also the firing rates of guns on Battlefield are non-realistic. Plus every gun basically looks like it just came from The factory and has seen zero field action
The recoil in Post Scriptum is pretty ridiculous on some of the guns, you'd think the Walther P38 was a handcannon with how high his hands jolt back with every shot lmao
To give you a perspective about how realistic Post scriptum is, They went out to record the tiger 131 ( the only working tiger in the world) so immersion could be achieved.
@@1Orderchaos no for real now I have played the game and at the edge of the map the game s graphics drop significantly if you want to see how the actual game looks like see this highlight 11.02
For the bolt actions i think bf5 is better. The attention to detail where they put their hand over the top while reloading while not empty as to not eject the round in the chamber is pretty cool. Also, the speed of the enfield is more realistic in bf5.
I dont know what settings you were running post scriptum on but it looks so much better the this on max settings. you almost mislead people on visuals. Post scriptum is 100x better then BFV in every way except spawn wait time.
I mean , one is clearly meant to be arcady shooter with some sandbox elements while the other is an game made to provide an realistic experience . Idk why are they being compared mad touted one as better as both are clearly games meant to provide different experience to players .
MufflerSponge wrong game, you’re thinking of cod ww2 (though interestingly there are some reports of black Germans serving in the armed forces in ww2).
Thanks to this video. I didn’t even know post scriptum even existed till I watched this. Now I think Post scriptum is better at realism but if they add more realistic environment like battlefield than this could get more popular than battlefield Series I think.
I dont know about you guys but even though PS is really impressive for being made by a small studio, I think that Battlefield 5 is miles ahead when it comes to pretty much everything.
I like PS more, but I must give a credit for bfv bolt action animation. At the "non fully out" reload,the character use he's left hand to block the round that already in chamber prevent it from extract, with out this move, the reload should be 4 rounds instead 3 rounds like PS
@Max Canadian I see you're on the hate train for PS here. Well the game isn't dead by far. And yes I have played bf3 and bf1. They are great games, but I prefer PS. If you can't accept other people's opinion's, go cry somewhere else.
what im not a huge fan of in recent battlefield games is they dont make the shots of the guns loud enough, you shouldnt be able to hear your guns action clank around so easily, it's almost like they are at the same sound level or even louder than the sounds of shots going off which is stupid. it should be totally muffled out by the noise of you firing like it is in PS unless the gun is suppressed which it would then make sense to be able to hear the action cycling
@@1Orderchaos Open bolt means when the weapon is ready to fire, there is no bullet in the chamber, when firing the bolt slams forwards and brings up a cartridge to the chamber, bolt locks, firing pin protrudes and fires the round, then extracts and ejects the spent shell case, finally the bolt locks back to the ready position due to either the gas pressure or recoil. That's basically how it works. If you know this already then just ignore me lol.
i noticed that with a lot of games they make the sight picture so big and open for all of the iron sights. call of duty definitely made that a trend. i like how in PS the sight pictures are accurate to how you would look through iron sights in real life
The m1928A1 is actually a little different than the M1a1 Thompson. Pretty sure the tommy was deployed a little later in the war and was an improvement on the previous model, the original model didn’t have a stock at all and I believe was called the m1919
@Max Canadian HAHAHA, I'm a battlefield fan as well but BFV was historical failure. It failed the players plus the majority of people nowadays came back to BF1, BF4, BF3 since BFV was shit. I played BFV on my cousin account and thought it really bad. My opinion on Post Scriptum + Hell let loose is better than BFV.
Tbh, I actually thought BF5 gun sound design is really nice. Post scriptums gun sounds are pretty nice to. But the sound design in BF5 is really nice, and prefer it more. I think people like Post Scriptums gun sounds more is because "An Triple A company is worse then a small company" which is true *most* of the time. But the sound design for BF5 is nicer then Post Scriptums gun sounds. But ill give Post Scriptums sound design some props though 🤘
Post scriptum and squad are both run by the same devs and they both have pretty much the same servers and they admin abuse so much if they don’t ban people they get their server removed by the game developers the games would be fun but mostly everybody quit and now it’s just a bunch of weird old men in their clans controlling the games pop pretty much making the game fun for themselfs with the help of the admins and banning everybody that swears and everybody that is good at the game I typed retard on these servers in chat a admin used vocal chat to talk to me telling me your not allowed to language and banned me for 3 days I’ve also been perm banned on other servers for similar things I would really like to just play these games but the community is so damaged and squad has a community ban list so if you get banned from 3 severs which the admins could ban you from their server with no proof making it so you can only play certain servers which have extremely long ques to get in because there is so many people on the ban list so everybody switched to hell let loose
I don't get the concept of locking a bolt back. I get in some guns like the MP5 it's a requirement to lock it back. But the MP50? Why would you lock back the bolt on a open bolt gun? It just seems like a waste of time to me.
A. It's a simple and very effective safety. B. If something malfunctions (specifically in the trigger group), the bolt may slam forward, pick up a cartridge, and fire it somewhere you don't want a bullet to go. It's the same reason they swapped from a hook style charging handle like the one on the MP-38. If that hook charging handle gets caught on say, the side of a half track, pulled back enough to clear the magazine, but not enough to engage the sear, you're gonna have a bad day.
The gun handling in Battlefield V seems overly aggressive and I don't know why the gun is held at an angle. And Post Scriptum, two-handed pistol shooting was not around during WWII.
Battlefield V's mp40 is actually wrong. It is correctly depicted as an open-bolt weapon whose bolt slides forward with every trigger pull in post scriptum
@Max Canadian I mean, I never see the bolt getting brought forward after getting locked back, which is what I know for sure you'd have to do with an mp5. I understand the reload when the mag isn't empty, but even when it was, it didn't look like the bolt was locked back. Correct me if I am wrong
@@PS-mw9cc you technically can reload an mp40 by pulling the bolt back and locking it in place on the catch first but him slapping it open doesnt make sense as the mp40 bolt needs to be unhooked from the catch before releasing so slapping it would be impossible. the bolt catch isnt just a flat notch it kind of hooks around
Sergeant Marcus Stacker actually it was pretty good, it would jam because of the hole in the side of the magazine and if you want to see the worst machine gun look at the American version of it.
Sausymayo simply isn’t true, all the locales in BFV are accurate to their real life counterparts color-wise (looking at real life images and comparing proves this). DICE just hasn’t added many darker areas other than the bombing of Rotterdam and that’s usually what people expect due to media over the past 20 years
The m1 garand's bolt is supposed to close automatically when you place the clip into the receiver yes but sometimes it doesn't and in that case it's perfectly fine to nudge it a little so it snaps shut
![[REALISM COMPARISON] Battlefield 5 vs Hell Let Loose vs Post Scriptum [GAMEPLAY]](/img/n.gif)
Post scriptum, a game made by small team did a better job with the explosives than a triple A game
BFVs PIAT is a joke!
I mean, both teams probably had different goals in mind. BFV probably wanted a fast-paced shooter while PS focused more on realism and gunplay.
Yes, I agree with all of you bois.
@@ethanng1454 the true neutral
True man plus Post scriptum gives that feeling that the guns punch harder than that of BF5
in my opinion:
BFV = Hollywood sound
Post Scriptum = real life
but i like them both anyway, both have strength and weakness
More like mine
ua-cam.com/video/5hbZhj1ohMo/v-deo.html
@@StabilizerGaming dude not gonna lie haha, you made my day!
I don't see any positives to BF5's sound design, it's too bland and brings little excitement when firing
@@1Orderchaos yup i agree with you
Noel G.A. I wouldn’t say that bro
BF5: here are the ironsights on the launchers
player: nice can I use them?
BF5: no
@Rafael Enriquez probably not that way but I think the ironsights are there to be used lol
Rafael Enriquez from another persons perspective they shoot it under the arm the way it was
Counter Strike: _smoothly slides from the room_
@Rafael Enriquez What the fuck did you smoke? You know IRL you dont put the stock at your chest as its presented in video games where magically your iron sights are in the middle of your eyes? Youve got these things called muscles you use to tilt your head to the gun or in this case launcher to aim down the sights, same here with the Panzerfaust. You have the panzerfaust either in your arm pit or on your shoulder with your hand above the release as your hold so the thing doesnt just knock you over when you fire it. Then you aim in your sights and press the release.
@@LocalDeepstateAgent I'm pretty sure he knows, he is just pointing out that in the game it looks like the panzerfaust is placed in the middle of the chest
Fun fact:
in both games mp40 Has quite a recoil, but in real life its badically recoilless. Its very big for a 9mm weapon
Bfv one has low recoil honestly
Nienawidze EA Post Scriptum recoil is almost none?
Nienawidze EA It’s constant recoil, meaning the bolt carrier never touches the rear of the receiver.
In PS you "hk slap" the bolt, which is impossible to do irl.
Ok, insulted wehraboo
Weapons in Post Scriptum are more realistic, especially their "feeling" and reload animations.
Nacjo Farmer true
Not here to defend BFV bcs it failed me hard, but the StG44 is wrong in PS, it incorrectly fires from an open bolt.
Chris Lee lmao what stg44 is correct in ps
@@91tears94 Nah it's not. Search for yourself, MKb42H fires from open bolt, MP44 changed that into close bolt.
@@chrislee3720 Nah dude hickok45 fired the the Stg44 and it fires with an open bolt.
Ay, bro where the ... 10:11
Rifat Hidayatullah lmao
Nice
Bruh this is amazing
Lol I get it
NECROME yes we know
PS has a genuinely good thing apart from the reload animations and details, it's the iron sights themselves. Most games prefer to use night time apertures for obvious reasons (using the real ones might cause a ton of players to immediately switch from iron sights to optical ones), in PS however, most of the weapons have accurate aperture sizes. It's a subtle addition which is actually needed in today's games.
it wont be sadly since most games are turning into arcadey shooters so people will want the wide open easy to look through iron sights that have become super trendy since call of duty made it trendy around mw2-black ops
Ikr the kar iron sight in bfv has like a huge channel cut out of it making precise shots actually harder to achieve
I personally enjoy both sights myself, my eyes aren't really the best so the larger sights are nice, but the realistic ones are well, realistic, which is nice.
My Condolences For Battlefield 5 For Being A Dead Game Now....
Time To Install BF4 Back
I didn't even delete it in the first place
Really
Watch here comparison video
ua-cam.com/video/5hbZhj1ohMo/v-deo.html
@@StabilizerGaming DONT PROMOTE UR OWN VIDEO HERE
@@StabilizerGaming Even I Realized That My Videos Are Shit , So I Didn't Bother To do So
@@StabilizerGaming Views Are Earn From Hardwork And Creativity Mate , Not Just Simply Recycling It....
I like how the player's hand shakes as he reloads in Post Scriptum.
looks like was back in the day,people were scared when reloading because they thought they will die eventually
Panic reloads
@Max Canadian what do you mean "yeah sure" of course people were scared of dying in World War fucking 2
@Max Canadian ps fanboy? tf is that mean?
Max Canadian Would you be calm and collected when pieces of lead are flying at you at nearly 2000 mph? Sounds like the troll here is you, my guy
PS has some amazing explosions.
but there are no after effect, but yeah it looks awesome
Or it is true that in the video the explosion is really not bad but you did not see the story mode of battlefield 5
What I love about the PS reloads, regardless whether it's intended or not, is that the characters hand is sometimes shaking during a reload.
Seems like a nice detail I wish more games had, it just shows that the soldiers are afraid/under pressure.
You can see it well at the STG44 reload once the soldier pulls out a new mag (6:35) or the way the M1911 shakes (0:48).
I don't know if it's unintended roughness of the animations, but some of Post Scriptum's reloads look like the character's hands are slightly shaking from combat fatigue (like the M1911, for example), which I find quite fascinating.
Holy shit the explosions in PS look incredible
I like how in post scriptum you can kinda see the soldiers hands shaking when using the 1911 my guess is the game is trying to show ptsd but I could be wrong and interpreting it for more than it actually is
i think its a combination of stress adrenalin tierdness and ptsd if and u have been moveing a lot of heavy stuff your arms start to shake
PS has some sexy ass animations
@@Hulbetley kid don't understand this joke. Me as adult understand it
they're actually pretty chunky looking. i assume they will become more fluid in the future though
FBI - Federal Bureau Investigation OH NO, YOU’RE HERE! 😱
Ja też nie
Post scriptum sounds almost perfect.
It's the only game to give me flashbacks with just sound 😅
The post scriptum M1911 animation remember me the battlefield 3 animation for the same weapon.
I like how Post Scriptum makes use of the Sten Mk V, a really nice improvement on the previous Stens to be sure
Oh, and it's Lee Enfield sounds are just beautiful
BFV: *AcCePt iT Or dOnT bUy iT*
Me: _Plays Post Scriptum_
Also EA and DICE: before the game dies, would you like to buy a WW2 TOM CRUISE DLC?? That will be 10 dollars lmao!
Me: *Haha* me goes away from Battlefield Franchise.
“Ok boomer” doesn’t translate well at all in this instance. Feel more like “Ok millennial” but oh well
@@NoobPTFO Sure sounds like a boomer
what the hell FBI OPEN UP!
@@NoobPTFO I cant believe people still use that fucking dead meme
Please stop using this terrible meme
Battlefield
How the mighty have fallen
Peter Nehemiah battlefields weapons are still very well done, I prefer battlefields reloads more than post scriptums. But everything else is just not good. The pacific was great tho
Dallas It’s a video game. Nobody plays PS because it’s too boring and nobody cares about realism at the end of the day
@@enjoi9970 hahaha find the player running around who don't have a clue what he doing
RuyXavier it was good with the pacific...... then they fucking cancel it? This was my first ever battlefield and my last I will never ever buy another one. I don’t care if this game in particular is not good but when they do absolutely no effort whatsoever to improve it and cancel the game when there’s 1 and a half year to the next battlefield I’m fucking done. Never buying battlefield again. Your right it is shit what a disappointment
@@enjoi9970 The whole PS and Squad community would beg to differ. Yes its a lot more realistic and "slower" to an extent but that doesn't make it boring. Of course boring is subjective, but at the same time you can't say something is boring because it is slower paced. Please don't tell me you thought RDR2 wasn't a good game either because it was "slow"?
The guns in Post Scriptum all actually sound different. That’s always been my one issue with battlefield, each gun sounds the exact same and especially in 5.
Well in real life guns also sound mostly the same so i guess thats realistic
*insert obligatory comment that "some game" is better than BFV*
It's pretty much true all around
Found the BFV shill.
BFV is ass
Bubsy 3d is better than BFV
*insert obligatory comment saying that you aren't wrong but also bf5 has some strengths*
12:39 pay attention Bren’s Magazine is being shacked while shooting!
Which is actually bullshit. If you had some old worn out never taken care of Bren from the french resistance? Yes sure the mags gonna be wobbly. But the ones used by the actual fighting nations didnt wobble around like that. Also that is the only redeeming quality about BF5, a shaking magazine. Kinda weak for a supposing tripple A title.
@@LocalDeepstateAgent watch a video in slow motion of any bren-style action under recoil, the mag will akways shake a little. You can find some good quality footage of the Stoner 63/63A in this configuration that clearly shows it.
even the m4 or ak magazines shakes a little while shooting (especially can be seen on slow motion) but A LITTLE not that much like in bfV but yea, i can belive that carabines used in battle (especially on WWII battlefields) can be that much worn to wiggle that heavy magazines when shooting (which can cause jams btw c: and sorry for my weak english :c)
XFurY_Osu its ok I understood
That1germanbritishrussianusamericanGuy You are shitting out of your mouth trying to find something to hate on😂😂
post scriptum feels soo damn relatable to most normal soldiers at that time
Because I'm sure you can relate
There's so much bass applied to everything in BFV, I much prefer the sharper cracks and pops of Post Scriptum. Feels like there is more variation to the sound profiles.
PS MP40 reload still bugs me with the HK slap, it doesn't make sense.
Lost_legion _army or the open bolt on the STG but other than that I love it regardless
Not an expert, but after some light research I can say that the mp40 has a notch for the bolt that served as an extra safety/bolt hold open, so slapping the charging handle is accurate
@@felonytaxevasion2773 the bolt sits a good inch and a half in the notch, the gun would need to be vertically up in order to slap it out of position and even then its pointless since its open bolt so it wouldn't travel far.
After looking at pictures of the notch, it might be possible to hk slap it, if you came at the charging handle at an angle. But I haven’t seen anybody do that, so it would probably make more sense to have them not slap the charging handle
Well first of all, that isnt really a HK slap thats more a kung fu slice on the "release" and yes, it is perfectly fine since the MP40 has no real safety just a locking mechanism which you could slap out of locking with enough force. Ofc. no soldier in the war would even do that but its one way to show the MP40 reload in a tacticool manner.
I like how in PS the player's hand trembles when he is reloading, it is as if he feels vulnerable or as if he is pushing something heavy
Fart hajsjdnajjdjkfk
The sound team of BFV was very good, i mean, they recreated the V1 rocket sound using a snowmobile with parts from a V1 but the Game Balance team uh, because of them it was sometimes unplayable.
Anyway i prefer PS it has a very good immersion and obviously a well made game
Diego Alf. BFV has the best balance out of any BF game lol stop looking at it with nostalgia googles
Enjoi Looks like you didn’t play BFV during all the TTK changes or you just suck playing other games from the saga like BF4 or BF1
Using propellers from a V1? The V1 flying bomb has no moving parts besides the reed valves in the pulse jet.
Pee hehehehehheh
For the V1 sound they actually did a snowmobile with a pulse jet engine, basically replicating the sound effect, not an actual V1 pulse jet
lmao the reload animation for the MP40 in Post Scriptum... try slapping it that way and you'll only bruise your hand
yeah it's way too action movie like and doesnt even make sense since the mp40s bolt hold-open notch is hook shaped so you wouldnt be able to just slap the bolt handle free you would need to unhook it first
Gameprojordan the later war models of the gun didnt have hook shaped charging handles
@@midas01tw i'm talking about the shape of the little slot to hold the charging handle in place not the shape of the charging handle itself, i know they switched from a hooked shape handle to a round nub shape
@@Gameprojordan i think its possible to balance the charging handle on the edge so you could hk slap it
Post Scriptum looks much better. Nicer reloads and recoil animations, unlike the bf5's guns just sliding up.
Even thought that Post S is more realistic, Battlefield has more fluid and really good animations
Killing floor 2 both
@HERETIC GAMER447 they still look nicer
Which fits both games honestly
@@badgermcbadger1968 What'u mean?
I’ve always liked how more realistic games like PS have more sharp sound effects than most triple A games. Many big franchises have sounds that should soft. I also like how the gun moves somewhat independently of the screen when firing, this is much more similar to recoil irl. In big games the entire screen will move with the gun, but here in PS we can see guns basically firing off screen when going full auto for too long. This goes to show the difference between the more realistic, tactical genre and the more arcade like ones. In games like PS the bullets come front be gun, but in bigger games like BF the bullets come from the eyes.
16:48 now look at that!
The way that magazine shakes in the sten. damn
This is meant to be a “Small game is better at big game at realism” type deal however, we’re comparing an arcade game where basic realism is all that’s needed and is executed spectacularly vs a realistic combat game that executes it as well relative to how small of a team it had
Didn't see anyone talk about the shell ejections.
Look at the first three pistols. BFV has the shells eject in different directions, while PS is pretty much all the same for all of them.
Looks better if you have motion blur enabled as well.
Edit: Not sure what's going on at 7:15 either.
MasterMindEcho Post scriptum uses a physics engine to simulate the shells ejecting, that’s why they act the same
@@m22gang65 Wait, why does 'using a physics engine' cause such a restriction? Is there some explanation from the devs available?
MasterMindEcho Idk about an explanation, all I know is that PS uses actual physics instead of premapped animations for their bullets, that why they look identical
@@m22gang65 I'm pretty sure most shooters do that. Battlefield certainly use physics for their shell casings.
MasterMindEcho Battlefield uses physics alongside animation, the shell ejecting in bfv is a set animation, and when it hits the ground it utilizes physics for a few seconds before disappearing.
In PS the shell is actually flung out of the chamber and physics does the rest,
Post Scriptum definitely takes the cake. Granted I was never really a fan of BF animations in the first place. PS anims are just more solid and satisfying.
BATTLEFIELD V: 'UNEDUCATED!'
POST SCRIPTUM: 'PERFECTLY EDUCATED!'
@Max Canadian How so may I ask?
Max Canadian oh god oh fuck a guy in the comments section dislikes the game objectively better literally in every way what will I ever do
@Max Canadian Yes...I have, unless you somehow bad at this game. It pretty fun...for the most part (beside the bugs).
Max Canadian you implied that you dislike it by saying nothing but something negative about it which leads anyone to believe that you have an overall negative view on the game. If I were to say “damn this food is tasteless” and nothing else any normal human being would think that you don’t like it
I respect the fact that Post Scriptum doesn’t make nearly as many compromises with the iron sights for the sake of usability. Battlefield and Cod have exaggerated how open peep sights are. They’re typically VERY small
the kick from each gun shots while aiming down sight in post scriptum is much better
I know most guns don’t get destroyed easily but the reloads in bfv feels both trying to act cool like and also it’s like trying his best to break the gun.....
i dont like how your character in BF5 just swings the anti-tank rifle and machine guns around when he reloads them while having the bipod out, i like how in PS when reloading your gun when the bipod is deployed it's still in that position which actually makes sense
I think you guys are forgetting battlefield games are ARCADE
Ethan [][] and I want a realistic shooter
Gabriel Hancock then fucking play red orchestra 2 or ps
Ryan Klein poelhuis oh my god your a fucking genius.
I still wonder why does BFV MG-42 cartridges sounds like Shotgun Shells? despite they are made of metal
the mp40 animation doing an HK slap bothers me so fucking much
Call of duty was everything ridiculously Hollywood, Battlefield wasn't that realistic but still, but post scriptum, that's awesome.
Post Scriptum sounds like they mixed DOI sounds with real life recordings and added better gun mechanic sounds, very good. Battlefield sounds like they remixed sounds from Medal of Honor European Assault and other Battlefield titles.
Missing Weapon NEXT: Coming Soon
P416
M1216
Oden
PPS-43
Magpul MDR
SR-3M
Knife (WIP)
Flash Grenade (WIP)
Sako TRG (WIP)
SCAR HAMR (WIP)
MG3 (WIP)
KS-23M (WIP)
Stfu
It looks like PS has a more accurate representation of iron sights compared to BF5. Some like the M1911 look super sloppy and too open compared to PS.
Edit: Brilliant job.
For some reason, the MP40 in Battlefield 5 has quite the recoil, even thos it fires 9mm
The MP18 in Battlefield 1 has almost no recoil, and it fires the same caliber as the MP40
Gun sounds on Post scriptum are unbelieveably accurate! In Battlefield every gun sounds like an elephant rifle and have a soft non-realistic recoil.
And also the firing rates of guns on Battlefield are non-realistic. Plus every gun basically looks like it just came from The factory and has seen zero field action
realism is a moot point in videogames.
@хле6 depends
The recoil in Post Scriptum is pretty ridiculous on some of the guns, you'd think the Walther P38 was a handcannon with how high his hands jolt back with every shot lmao
To give you a perspective about how realistic Post scriptum is, They went out to record the tiger 131 ( the only working tiger in the world) so immersion could be achieved.
ua-cam.com/video/bXlpQKIq_vs/v-deo.html
You can say the same for Battlefield.
Why lower the graphics quality so much for Post Scriptum? Makes it look inferior.
@Alexander Oskar Omon 4 sure
@@1Orderchaos no for real now I have played the game and at the edge of the map the game s graphics drop significantly if you want to see how the actual game looks like see this highlight 11.02
Sayak Majumder Lighting maybe not good?
Tbh, I like both. BF5 for just a bit of mindless fun in WW2 setting, and PS for a mostly accurate experience
I dont know why but
I've never seen m1A1 thompson in battlefield games before (except 1942)
every game they got M1928 and its triggering me
For the bolt actions i think bf5 is better. The attention to detail where they put their hand over the top while reloading while not empty as to not eject the round in the chamber is pretty cool. Also, the speed of the enfield is more realistic in bf5.
I dont know what settings you were running post scriptum on but it looks so much better the this on max settings. you almost mislead people on visuals. Post scriptum is 100x better then BFV in every way except spawn wait time.
I mean , one is clearly meant to be arcady shooter with some sandbox elements while the other is an game made to provide an realistic experience . Idk why are they being compared mad touted one as better as both are clearly games meant to provide different experience to players .
I don’t get why the sights in Battlefield are always goofy
People complain about them being cluttered or too blocky, but DICE includes wierd red dot like sights that they use anyway
They are designed for people who love fast aim then spray and don't care about realistic
Mr Hải Đăng yeah I figured they don’t care about realism since they put in black German females
MufflerSponge wrong game, you’re thinking of cod ww2 (though interestingly there are some reports of black Germans serving in the armed forces in ww2).
MufflerSponge there’s no black German females. Get your facts straight first
Wow post scriptum's explosion effects are really impressive 16:49
Thanks to this video. I didn’t even know post scriptum even existed till I watched this.
Now I think Post scriptum is better at realism but if they add more realistic environment like battlefield than this could get more popular than battlefield Series I think.
On a practical level of comparsion you can't compare these, because in BFV almost none use the standard iron sights
I dont know about you guys but even though PS is really impressive for being made by a small studio, I think that Battlefield 5 is miles ahead when it comes to pretty much everything.
I love how in post scriptum that when they reload the M1911 they wiggle their hand
I like PS more, but I must give a credit for bfv bolt action animation.
At the "non fully out" reload,the character use he's left hand to block the round that already in chamber prevent it from extract, with out this move, the reload should be 4 rounds instead 3 rounds like PS
Randomly came across your channel & would like to wish you goodluck to 2020 fam ❤️
BF: satisfying sounds and animation for kids and 12 year olds.
PS: realistic sounds and animations.
Im 12 and I think BF is shit.
@Godon Gurando is another T-800 OK You listen to anime music. Fuck off
@Max Canadian I see you're on the hate train for PS here. Well the game isn't dead by far. And yes I have played bf3 and bf1. They are great games, but I prefer PS. If you can't accept other people's opinion's, go cry somewhere else.
what im not a huge fan of in recent battlefield games is they dont make the shots of the guns loud enough, you shouldnt be able to hear your guns action clank around so easily, it's almost like they are at the same sound level or even louder than the sounds of shots going off which is stupid. it should be totally muffled out by the noise of you firing like it is in PS unless the gun is suppressed which it would then make sense to be able to hear the action cycling
As someone who shoots guns regularly, ps has more realistic noises, they replicate the sound of the bullets breaking the sound barrier
Finally a UA-camr who doesn't speak for like 20 mins before starting the actual video...
fun fact: most LEE Enfield rifle shooters from the British used to put there middle finger on the trigger and not the index finger like all rifles
Hmm why Stg44 has open bolt? Bf5 is right closed bolt
The devs must mixed it with the MKb42H...
@@chrislee3720 yeah Mkb42h is original open bolt
Sure I guess what ever that means
@@1Orderchaos Open bolt means when the weapon is ready to fire, there is no bullet in the chamber, when firing the bolt slams forwards and brings up a cartridge to the chamber, bolt locks, firing pin protrudes and fires the round, then extracts and ejects the spent shell case, finally the bolt locks back to the ready position due to either the gas pressure or recoil. That's basically how it works. If you know this already then just ignore me lol.
@@chrislee3720 I didnt know that thanks, but I still got a bit confused on some of this lol
Those sight pictures in BF5 remind me of something I've only seen in porn
i noticed that with a lot of games they make the sight picture so big and open for all of the iron sights. call of duty definitely made that a trend. i like how in PS the sight pictures are accurate to how you would look through iron sights in real life
Battlefield 5 is dead pretty much
The Explorer ye
Thats awesome
lil Peanut hey speaking of hardline, are any servers still up or do people still play it
lil Peanut cool, I hear bf4 is dying super fast it’s sooo sad
I'm glad people are gonna go back to bf1 and bf4
slapped the mp-40!
Damn nice animation
Why isn't anyone talking about how PS doesn't have the player model hold the pistols one handed, like in WW2?
The m1928A1 is actually a little different than the M1a1 Thompson. Pretty sure the tommy was deployed a little later in the war and was an improvement on the previous model, the original model didn’t have a stock at all and I believe was called the m1919
The M3 are nearly identical, which means they either both got it right, or both got it wrong.
4:57 tryna get Garand thumb
The recoil in Post Scriptum looks way more realistic than in BFV.
No argue, Post scriptum is better.
@Max Canadian HAHAHA, I'm a battlefield fan as well but BFV was historical failure.
It failed the players plus the majority of people nowadays came back to BF1, BF4, BF3 since BFV was shit. I played BFV on my cousin account and thought it really bad. My opinion on Post Scriptum + Hell let loose is better than BFV.
Wait a minute, am I the only one who noticed that the explosions in PS look very identical to Squad? The sound is identical aswell....
It's runs on same engine
Same developers
@@runertje5505 not the same devs, Periscope Games is a mod (now game dev) team backed by OWI
Tbh, I actually thought BF5 gun sound design is really nice. Post scriptums gun sounds are pretty nice to. But the sound design in BF5 is really nice, and prefer it more. I think people like Post Scriptums gun sounds more is because "An Triple A company is worse then a small company" which is true *most* of the time. But the sound design for BF5 is nicer then Post Scriptums gun sounds. But ill give Post Scriptums sound design some props though 🤘
Post scriptum and squad are both run by the same devs and they both have pretty much the same servers and they admin abuse so much if they don’t ban people they get their server removed by the game developers the games would be fun but mostly everybody quit and now it’s just a bunch of weird old men in their clans controlling the games pop pretty much making the game fun for themselfs with the help of the admins and banning everybody that swears and everybody that is good at the game I typed retard on these servers in chat a admin used vocal chat to talk to me telling me your not allowed to language and banned me for 3 days I’ve also been perm banned on other servers for similar things I would really like to just play these games but the community is so damaged and squad has a community ban list so if you get banned from 3 severs which the admins could ban you from their server with no proof making it so you can only play certain servers which have extremely long ques to get in because there is so many people on the ban list so everybody switched to hell let loose
I don't get the concept of locking a bolt back. I get in some guns like the MP5 it's a requirement to lock it back. But the MP50? Why would you lock back the bolt on a open bolt gun? It just seems like a waste of time to me.
Brandon Snodgrass Safety?
@@Castdeath that doesn't really make sense.
@@brandonsnodgrass7788 that notch is the only safety on the mp40
@@levialdrich9342 that makes sense I suppose
A. It's a simple and very effective safety.
B. If something malfunctions (specifically in the trigger group), the bolt may slam forward, pick up a cartridge, and fire it somewhere you don't want a bullet to go. It's the same reason they swapped from a hook style charging handle like the one on the MP-38. If that hook charging handle gets caught on say, the side of a half track, pulled back enough to clear the magazine, but not enough to engage the sear, you're gonna have a bad day.
When you fire your gun why does bf5 sound like the god of thunder is about to rain down on earth with his wrath
that's the echo sound bruh
The gun handling in Battlefield V seems overly aggressive and I don't know why the gun is held at an angle. And Post Scriptum, two-handed pistol shooting was not around during WWII.
Battlefield V's mp40 is actually wrong. It is correctly depicted as an open-bolt weapon whose bolt slides forward with every trigger pull in post scriptum
Funny finding you again
@Max Canadian I mean, I never see the bolt getting brought forward after getting locked back, which is what I know for sure you'd have to do with an mp5. I understand the reload when the mag isn't empty, but even when it was, it didn't look like the bolt was locked back. Correct me if I am wrong
@@PS-mw9cc you technically can reload an mp40 by pulling the bolt back and locking it in place on the catch first but him slapping it open doesnt make sense as the mp40 bolt needs to be unhooked from the catch before releasing so slapping it would be impossible. the bolt catch isnt just a flat notch it kind of hooks around
WAIT...Where’s the Chauchat..?
Harold Kwong somewhere in hell for being the worst machine gun ever
Sergeant Marcus Stacker actually it was pretty good, it would jam because of the hole in the side of the magazine and if you want to see the worst machine gun look at the American version of it.
Post scriptum MP40 reload did the HK slap
M3 grease gun has a silencer available as a specialization, it is not very fair to ignore it
Better graphics: BFV
Better sounds: Post Scriptum
Post Scriptum graphics are actually pretty decent. Go watch some videos.
Underpaid Mook they’re great but still not better than BFV.
@@ruhidmohamad BFV does have better graphics but it still kind of looks like a cartoon. The colours are overly contrasted.
Sausymayo simply isn’t true, all the locales in BFV are accurate to their real life counterparts color-wise (looking at real life images and comparing proves this). DICE just hasn’t added many darker areas other than the bombing of Rotterdam and that’s usually what people expect due to media over the past 20 years
The battlefield 5 guns feels like they have no weight to them, but post scriptum makes the guns feel clumpy and heavy
4:58 The same problem COD WW2 has...
The m1 garand's bolt is supposed to close automatically when you place the clip into the receiver yes but sometimes it doesn't and in that case it's perfectly fine to nudge it a little so it snaps shut
I've seen about 2-3 different of Garand reloads. There's the Garand Thumb, this one, and another one where it closes
BFV: B action movie directed by Michael Bay
Post Scriptum: WW2 Documentary
ngl though I'd still rather play Battlefield V (mainly because of the Pacific Update) than COD WW2
you can hear in your left how he grab a mag in post scriptum
6:31 small caliber bullets in a assault rifle in World War II
Post scriptum's gun sounds are damn good.
BF1 has better sound than BFV.
Not hard to be better then BFV
Why are PS's animations for American weaponry so stiff? Am I missing something?
It’s like everything they did right with BF1, they completely undid with BF5. I really do hope the next battlefield game is a winner.
I thought it was a contest until it got to the explosives part. Then BF5 became more of a disappointment then it already was.
Why is Post Scriptum in the windows xp background?