Who is Fawad Khan? Why do we need actors from Pakistan when we have real good talents in India. We should give Indians the opportunity. Further, who is Mahira Khan? To hell with Mahiras. We have lovelier girls in India who should be given the break. Who is this guy Atif Aslam? A guy who cannot sing. We have millions of good singers in India. For example, Sri Ram who won the Indian idol and million others from all over India are real good and need to be given the break. Why Atif Aslam? Please for Godssake we do not want any - not a single one from Pakistan to be given an opportunity in India. We have enough good talent in India. Give them the break. Lets not show this soft corner for any Pakistani. If Brett Lee is ready to work in Bollywood. He is welcome. But, not any Pakistani. I do not want to mince my words. Anyone from a peace loving country is welcome to India. Pakistanis - no sir. They need not come here and we need not go there. This Ketkar guy, this youngster Mayank, this Rahul Singh etc are talking bullshit.
jae congress to krra sbb kush..naa dafaa 370 hoti naa bnhaa sae bagdtae..or naaj kasmir ki jae halat hoti...doda poonch & rajouri mai hindu rajpoot bahoot kmm hai fir v unhonae apna grr nhi shoda...
No they don't but our soldiers die for us for our nation. We can't behave as if we don't see it and treat them like quotation team or someone who kills and dies for money. There are hundreds of ways to earn a living they chose to protect our nation they deserve ultimate respect. No tax must be deducted from a soldier's family their children should receive best education coz their father died for the nation. We owe our freedom to speak freedom to exist in a desired way to them. Jai Hind.
Malini Dipu Pakistan will be in a better sitiation if it refrains from Bollywood, this will stop importing Bollywood movies (copied from the west) and growing Indian culture as well as importing rubbish from India. Pakistan should focus in making their own movies and shrink imbalancement of unfair trade with India.
who establish pakistani govt and nawaz sharif, simple answer. the people of pakistan..yes because there are democracy. Don't try to divide and rule because in the Universe everything whether it is live or not live is connected to each other by some property. There is an always relation between them. We just have to find out that.
Akshay Patel check the facts in regards to balance of trade, India is making a decent profit by exporting movies to Pakistan, in return a few of our artists go to India and a very few come here to perform as well, (and they love our hospitality unlike yours for our artists as you can see here), this is in addition to import from India where India is exporting telecommunications and cellular service while using her own models/ actors for advertising Indian product, I don't even recognize Bollywood, I only recognize Hollywood, so it's loss for Pakistan all around but our corrupt officials have no shame, soon an honest government will hopefully come and then true facts will get exposed, at this time I am glad all this is happening in India and expect a retaliation from Pakistan for banning all imports from India.
in no way i support MNS bt i definitely support their demand to kick these pakistani isi agents to b thrown out of d country..i would ask modi govt wt the fuck r u doing.U r demanding d world to isolate pakistan bt u itself r hesitating to do so..modiji charity begins at home..nw its time to call d bluff of these politicians b it congeess or bjp
Jahendra Ravji ya thus it concludes v must then sit back quietly accepting the fact nothing vl happen n our media should stop being jingoistic n doesnt play with d emotions of common man
they want support then support the Indian Muslims, there are multitudes of Brilliant Indian Muslims everywhere in India even in the Indian Army, how is Secularism related to supporting pakistani punjabi muslim only, are they the only muslims? These stupid pseudo- liberalists are chuttiyahhs!!!
The point is if someone is smart enough to criticise terrorist attacks in Paris and Australia then why are they restraining from condemning terrorist attacks on the country where they earn their livelihoods.
I understand why Pakistanis living in India might not want to condemn Pakistan, but if they are so scared to say anything, they should just go back. They only benefit from India, make lots of money and have such a luxurious life and that is not acceptable when our Jawans are being slaughtered... People to people contact is a two way street and we won't bow down every bloody time anymore!
We should stop our charity work for actors and singers of Pakistan . They comes to India for fame cuz they are not getting it in Pakistan..thats it. Its their personal interest and we should stop it. Now a days art changed with word M(money)+Art = MART (market), ultimately more then a nation. If directors or producers really want to upgrade art in society why on the earth talent from rural parts of India or regional actors are not taken. At the end of the day these talents of Pakistan or so called talent of Mart are not going to support India or sympathies India when we need it.. they are not Indian or understand the pain of an Indian.. but they are human who can eat bread and butter by Indian money.
You Dumbfuck, you think banning a few pakistani actors is gonna solve terrorism? What is going to happen after they ban the actors? Thats not the problem, people are the problem, please dont blame the entire country. Please take your head out of your ass.
+Aamir Masterofbling unless and until government of Pakistan don't bend.. to reduce their terrorist, I say ban all the actors, singers.. ban all the entertainment services... boycott pakistan, let the Gandhi ji's movement run all over again. lets show Pakistan the power of peace, without weapons.. and drive their government to kill all their terrorists. Aamir what do you think I don't care about Pakistani people..let me say I do care about them, but is his own government care about his own Pakistani people, everyday you will hear some kind of terrorists activities in Pakistan.. many people lose their life because of them...so we can't run away by reality.. either their government should understand the needs of their own public or either we bent their government to do so..in the mean time they aren't in heaven even in present.. and don't worry we will bend and empower your richie rich actors and singers too, they will raise questions against their own government..who aren't now for India. Freaking 70 years we waited, presuming they will change, and stop this.. but zero result achieved..Now enough is enough.. anymore I don't want my soliders to bleed in border .. for their corrupted policy. Teach wise lessons with best possible wisest form and Teach hard lessons with best possible hardest form.. we can't interchange hard with wise... now for 70 years we teach them in wisest ways and they didn't understand this.. now it's time to show them the hardest ways!!
This pakistani actor when go to pakistan immediately ISI contact this actor for information about india. Anyone can guarantee this actor don't give any information to ISI?
one major point to notice In this debate is .that #atifaslam , #fawadkhan #alizafar can speak against terror attacks in #paris and other countries but not for the country from where they are earning, country feeding them , the country who made them the STARS . it's pathetic to let it go. It is a serious issue to discuss , argue and to take action against it.
Guys I am totally against the Pakistani govt . Strict action must be taken against their agency. But still I am saying I love all the Pakistani artists . U guys tell don't u think atif aslam is one of the best singers in Bollywood. Or do u prefer chutiya honey Singh and baadshah. Ali Zafar and fawad khan are also damm amazing actors
What about the ten million immigrant that left Pakistan for India you whant to ban them and send them all back to Pakistan?we will be happy to take back the kapoors, the khannas, the kumars,the dutts,the roshans,the puris,the chopra, the sahnis ect I have very long list will take 24 hour to write some famous Pakistani that live india😅🤣
So basically Indians can defend pakistani actors, but those pakistani actors can't make a statement for being on one side wow! Rahul sing, mayank you guys doing great job.. Now a days pakistan don't need to defend itself nor there people because some indians do it for them.. *TUMNE THEKA LIYA HAI UNKE LIYE BOLNE K LIYE* Let them speak and defend or oppose thats none of your business. These so called old duded can;t even see the poor Army men who does it for 20k month salary he lets his life foregone for inner Love towards country but these so called "indian' are more specific and right about this situation. Just think once 18 men burnt to death how there family will see india and government what they are doing for them.
In all the debates i have seen so far by Arnab... only Arnab speaks and doesnt listen and expects his panelist to conduct themselves properly as debate's decorum ... quite funny ! :) This doesnt have anything to do with whether he is right or not just the way he conducts debates
this is what i called a "PART TIME PATRIOTISM" .......we sent them back after 26/11,they came back,we did when our soldiers were beheaded, they called back...same thing was repeated after pathankot attack and this thing will keep happening in future as well......there is no solution......so just chillax and enjoy the show....nothing is going to change
Namaste Arnab ji and to all sensible people who are for Bharat there, For the rest who are supporting ..lets take following steps: send their family members to fight along with our brave soldiers...wait n watch ....after sometimes if their family members die.....they should then b asked to dance play n drink with those terrorist n their supporters... These ppl should be lined up in front of our desh ka border and flet them face the bullets guns n tanks...all gazhal dance drink sports will come from their rear end...😡 Dhanywaad.
look I am only 16 years old and I am mature enough to understand that Pakistani actors don't mean harm to us and kicking them out won't make any sense......Like wtf !? Look I am from Mumbai the heart of Bollywood and I don't any logic in that..... I mean it is the reason we are a great country ... it is a reason Pakistani actors come here .... We are great country just kicking them out because they are Pakistani like Wow.... it will be a stupid act.... and if you wanna correct me use a good language don't use your " slum language " :|
Its OK for you to say that since you are 16. But we are in state of war like situations with Pakistan . We don't want an actual War with Pakistan but with Pakistan funded Terrorism . Internationally in UN our PM along with all global countries are trying to declare Pakistan a terrorists state so that there will not be any Business / trade from Pakistan with rest of World. We want Pakistan to realize their mistake , and stop funding Terrorism. We are raising this point globally in front of UN and our-self are allowing Pakistan artist to come to India and earn their living. WE WANT THEM TO GET FRUSTRATED AND WORK ON PAKISTAN's SPONSORED TERRORISM . PAKISTANIS CITIZENS HAVE LONG WAY TO GO AND WILL HAVE TO BE FORCED TO WORK ON THEIR TERRORISM PROBLEMS WHICH IS AFFECTING PAKISTAN AS WELL AS WORLD.
Srinivas Kandadai WTF.... you do realised what you said right ?? coz i didnt .... Like you are suggesting me to grow up before i have a opinion WOW......LOL
Nandan Warma Our country cant do that we have reputation ... And dont worry we will repay them for the attacks but it will a " face to face ".... No inside job like they do....and I dont think they will be frustated if we kick pak actors because remember they didnt do anything after thousands of childrens were killed in the peshawar attacks.... LOL ... " Frustate tab nai hue to actors ko nikaal ne baad kyu honge "....
I want to ask one question are our army people have some individual fight or problem with Pakistani army man, they represent our country and fighting for the country as a citizen and its duty of every citizen to fight by their profession if some country is doing terrorism in our country.
they don't just walk across border and start working, they got working visa from Indian immigration, and they haven't done anything wrong, after 9/11 when Indian were discriminated we called that racist and inhuman and now we are walking on same path
Gandu first of all I was born here , i don't what gills you talking about but you shouldn't be talking about it I read islamic history our own prophet himself married cousins Zaynab bint Jaktsh, who was not only the daughter of Umaimah bint Abd al-Muttalib, one of his father's sisters but was also divorced from a marriage with Muhammad's adopted son, Zayd ibn Haritha and I'm not making it up it's in Quran go check ( Sura Al-Ahzab 33:37). And Quran is Allah's word can't be wrong Not just him Muhammad also allowed the marriage of his daughter, Fatimah, to his cousin, Ali ibn Abi Talib, who became later calipha The second Caliph, Umar ibn al-Khattab, also married his cousin, Atikah bint Zayd ibn Amr ibn So cousin marriage is your culture is not mine so get your fact , when get some time off from throughing stones read some quran
Arnam goswai dude is a loud mouth, he has no respect for other debaters, he just butts in with his oily ass hair and barely gives other a chance to speak their mind.
No discussion, no debate, no arguments required on this subject. Pakistanis should not be allowed in India. And we need not show any soft corner to any Pakistani. Period. We have the whole world opened to us to find friends.
yes, all Pakistani artist should be banned which in slow poison support love jihad. We Indian should boycott all movies which have any thing to do as actor/ producer/director or any form with srk, amir khan, salman khan, akhtar family, mahesh batt family, karan johar (Dharma productions) and aditya chopra (Rani mukherjee's husband) productions. people will have to understand why these Pakistani artists are brought in our film industry, do we not enough talent, we do . this is the way indirectly to support
Dear Kumar Ketkar We don't bloody care about what BJP, Congress or any other political party did in the past..We want to boycott Pakistan in every form....including boycotting PAK actors. Then with complete credibility ask the world to isolate PAK. So Ketkar kindly work towards this...if u want to do service unto the Indian people. Jai Hind
Nothing personal against actors but we have to take a stand.With our soldiers dying and terror from Pakistan increasing we have to stop these Pakistani actors or anyone else from Pakistan from working in India!!
+abhinav kashyap i know that but her husband is pakistani and India is about to cut off all political and economic relations with Pakistan. Poor girl will become sandwitch
K we should also know that those artists came legally to participate in Indian economic activity ,they can choose to respond or not about terrorism,we may feel bad about that but certainly can't blame them and make hue and cry ,Indian self respect does not depend on Pakistanis response ,that only belittle us on the world stage,until before these incidents Pakistanis youth,started talking against their government for encouraging terrorism after these incidents differences rise to a new high that is what needed for political fringes on both sides want for political gains,even army rejected this stand by reject 5cr compensation fund from MNS ,our application of reason flooding away in the midst of hue and cry
Madhu Sudhan but why involve artists in all this rubbish. It's a matter of demand on either side there was a demand for Indian movies so we legalized it in Pakistan, should we also involve all rubbish in entertainment and also ban Indian artists, that is why from the very beginning I was in favor of keeping imports and export separate with India our balance of payment is much higher. 22 crore people watching Indian movies while destroying our own film industry and then bring Indian artists over and welcome them while disrespect in return, and India is always a third world country no matter what they think.
love you arnab....you put forth arguments for people of our side strongly. I just don't understand why these so called intellectuals and liberals behave like an intellectual indian. things are inter-related. they just need to look in that ways. Also, we are from the land of Gandhi. why can't they understand non cooperation movement works. And in current scenario we have to go for it. Had that been the case with America or any other country, things wud have been really different.
Arnab! you are a brilliant speaker but please 'respect the speaker'. Let them speak and not try shutting them up everytime!! If you are the only to speak then there is no point of inviting them! You can keep speaking all by yourself..!! Isn't it?
One simple question: If Indian actors can critisize the Indian government on the subject of "INTOLERANCE", then why not Pakistani actors take a clear stand against the Pakistani government on a more dangerous subject of "TERRORISM"?
If someone is working for me that means I'm the reason how he is making his living from which means I'm feeding him. By the same analogy, we are giving the salary to pakistani actors and if you can't speak for the one who is feeding you then you should go back to the place you came from.
Mr Arnab the Pak actors did not descend from heaven above and they are certainly not messengers of peace....we invited them here , our Indian embassy issued visas...we cannot hold them at gunpoint and make them sign their death warrant here.....and then force them out to Pakistan, where perhaps a similar situation awaits them or maybe even worse...why are we holding them to ranson and making them a scapegoat. The martyrs family members are not holding them responsible for the killings neither are they in any way connected with the attacks...
Javed Akhtar isn't a Muslim. He's an atheist. And just like Anupan Kher was denied visa since he spoke strongly against the Pakistan sponsored terrorism. Similarly, Javed has also been vocal about the same especially after what happened in Mumbai in 2008.
India still doesn't understand that a terrorist for one is a freedom fighter to another! One must try to eradicate the sole problem of why the person has gone to such extent of giving up his life. That life and the other lives that were taken is a price that is paid by the Government of India for neglecting the Issue of Kashmir. The people who fled IOK(Indian Occupied Kashmir) when they came to POK they were filled with hate against India and still are but they are in constant control of our Government but the clashes that have now been started by the people themselves in Kashmir by raising Pakistani Flag not in few groups but in huge masses means they don't want to live with Inda they want to be independent of India. This is what India should understand. Now we had a similar problem in Balochistan but we handled it by directing all the Foreign investment and even the people of Pakistan realised that the province is getting nothing for its development now its is getting 46 billion dollars worth of infrastructure. Anyway I still gonna get angry Indians madly commenting on my post so go ahead.
When attack on Peeshawar happened, SRK sent lots of Money to them. And today Uri attack happened and 18 Jawan killed. But no Khan came forward to condemn this and not only giving any Solidarity for them. Is Bollywood really a Indian Film Industry or Pakistani film Industry??
I am not a MNS supporter but This time I M WITH MNS. As an Indian i have FAWAD KHAN who has guts and sense to tweet after Paris attack and not on Uri even after this much oppose. Fawad is most welcome if he speaks against Pakistan sponsored terrorism.
After a long time , I felt that this debate was bullshit. I dont think everything said or done has to be vocalised. In this case, I fully support Mayank. I dont think just because they are Pakistani artists, they should be thrown back to Pakistan. In the films where Fawad Khan has acted I believe it was the Director's or writer's choice to have Fawad in the movie. And more than Fawad, it was Indians who benefited out of the movies. He has been paid only for the work has done. I dont think Fawad has to keep vocalizing the fact that he is from a terrorist state. I believe that Fawad or any other artist who hail from Pakistan should not be condemned as terrorist or a citizen from a terrorist state unless they have a direct contact or relation to a terrorist group.
what if they are coming here to steal the secrets of Indian army? will anyone who support their coming into india take responsibility if some terror happens ??
Enough of brotherhood, enough 2nd chances, enough compromises.... be it hate or love..make it clear.... Don't humiliate their stars but just ask them to leave our country.....
■■■ Patriots of india■■■ Arnab is trying to help you to choose from a real life options. ... You have to take a couregious step by making a decision. .. Are you with india or Pakistan ? All the patriotic indians stand beside india.. ★ Any person who is supporting terrorists and Pakistani lobbyists are Gaddar ....anti national. .. Simply put. . Do not sleep with the enemy. .★★★ ★ Meri Bharat Mahan ★
To Pakistan... I am an indian and i see this trend on indian side that whenever this attacks happen india just sends all the pakistani actors and cricketers back to their country and after few months they call them back... What the fcuk...if u are making a mind to boycott pakistan then do it on a forever basis...don't change decisions just to get the pakistani viewership, by inviting pakistani actors or play with pakistan cricket team to get good TRPs and earn money from it...make up your mind and isolate the pakistan like usa and rest of the world did to north korea... And muslims are nowadays getting lot problematic to the rest of the world making few good progressive muslims to suffer...sometimes i am thinking of converting myself to hindu as, in india all the muslims are converted from hindus only but i think like, which caste am i allowed to go if i convert myself ??...
and when it comes to giving or taking the daughter of someone else..how can it be possible without a caste ??...looking it with the social point of view then the effect would be drastic without a caste..
Uri Attack : Was It really An Attack Or An Incident? A lot of eyebrows have already been raised about the Uri attack and this has raised many valid questions here. Given the timing and circumstances of the attack, nothing can be ruled out. It could have very well been just an incident of fire? Which has been made to look like a terrorist attack, because all we could see on our television screens was just smoke rising out from the cantonment area. No gunshots, no dead bodies of supposed milliants involved in the attack, who were as per the army version given immediate burial. Why where they in such a hurry?
Why are the producers hiring actors from Pakistan. India already has a surplus of talented actors who are constantly trying to make a mark in the industry.
Kumar Ketkar was hilarious, he just rounded around Vajpayee & Modi without any logic and Prof. Behera went totally deaf and dumb on being asked a simple question 'how has the people-people relations benefited India'
That was actually a good debate!..when i started the video as an artist i was clearly in opposition but now i am with it because the points which arnab and team gave actually made sense..bechari ae dil he mushkil and raees ki to lag gyi ab:-)
YES. .RIGHT..GHAR WAPASI IS NECESSARY NOW Why don't the good people SPEAK UP and stand for the right rather than have DOUBLE STANDARDS .The name fame and money they get in India is really beyond belief...They dont get this popularity in their own Country. ..We can't be confused or diplomatic anymore.BAHUT HO GAYA AB
Why the Pakistani Artists should express sorry on the death of Indians? The intensity of hate in their heart is so much that they cannot utter the world sorry. They come here as they get nothing in Pakistan. Pakistan being a terrorist country they are also the kids and sons of the same terrorists. How they can criticise their fathers and their mentors. It is my request that they should go back otherwise something bad can happen to them, they should not wait for up to that bad events.
Who is Fawad Khan? Why do we need actors from Pakistan when we have real good talents in India. We should give Indians the opportunity. Further, who is Mahira Khan? To hell with Mahiras. We have lovelier girls in India who should be given the break. Who is this guy Atif Aslam? A guy who cannot sing. We have millions of good singers in India. For example, Sri Ram who won the Indian idol and million others from all over India are real good and need to be given the break. Why Atif Aslam? Please for Godssake we do not want any - not a single one from Pakistan to be given an opportunity in India. We have enough good talent in India. Give them the break. Lets not show this soft corner for any Pakistani. If Brett Lee is ready to work in Bollywood. He is welcome. But, not any Pakistani. I do not want to mince my words. Anyone from a peace loving country is welcome to India. Pakistanis - no sir. They need not come here and we need not go there. This Ketkar guy, this youngster Mayank, this Rahul Singh etc are talking bullshit.
Hari Iyer, please google who is Fawad Khan, Mahira Khan and Atif Aslam.
they r from a terrorist state.
Lol like Palmolive in brackets (Made in India, Bandra East Mumbai)?
you cant stop them ... get it
who is fuckking khan send them kalapani
when paris attack happened..they changing their instagram pic,twitter..nd when in India happened ....thy just mute..
Congress warned many times about Pakistan to bjp . see the situation going worst @ LOC
So now what you are talking about. All the rubbish happening and happend in India because of bloody fucking Gandi family.
jae congress to krra sbb kush..naa dafaa 370 hoti naa bnhaa sae bagdtae..or naaj kasmir ki jae halat hoti...doda poonch & rajouri mai hindu rajpoot bahoot kmm hai fir v unhonae apna grr nhi shoda...
The whole situation today is becaue of 60 years of congress incompatence..
Bhagao pakistanion ko .
I cannot believe such big men don't get a simple question Aranab. After 9/11 in America even George Bush said "are you with us or against us". !!!!!!
9/11 was an an inside job which happened under the presidency and also the involvement of Bush . Do your research.
But did he ban artists from the middleeast from coming to the US ?? :D
I did, it was said buy researcher but there was no proof
......INDIA BLAMED PAKISTAN BEFORE THEY HAD ANY PROOF........Silence
huh....PAK...NO need of proof , just do sargical strike.
do not insult the soldiers and their family..their children by allowing the Pakistanis to come here and make money using us.
No they don't but our soldiers die for us for our nation. We can't behave as if we don't see it and treat them like quotation team or someone who kills and dies for money. There are hundreds of ways to earn a living they chose to protect our nation they deserve ultimate respect. No tax must be deducted from a soldier's family their children should receive best education coz their father died for the nation. We owe our freedom to speak freedom to exist in a desired way to them. Jai Hind.
Malini Dipu Pakistan will be in a better sitiation if it refrains from Bollywood, this will stop importing Bollywood movies (copied from the west) and growing Indian culture as well as importing rubbish from India. Pakistan should focus in making their own movies and shrink imbalancement of unfair trade with India.
who establish pakistani govt and nawaz sharif, simple answer. the people of pakistan..yes because there are democracy. Don't try to divide and rule because in the Universe everything whether it is live or not live is connected to each other by some property. There is an always relation between them. We just have to find out that.
Akshay Patel check the facts in regards to balance of trade, India is making a decent profit by exporting movies to Pakistan, in return a few of our artists go to India and a very few come here to perform as well, (and they love our hospitality unlike yours for our artists as you can see here), this is in addition to import from India where India is exporting telecommunications and cellular service while using her own models/ actors for advertising Indian product, I don't even recognize Bollywood, I only recognize Hollywood, so it's loss for Pakistan all around but our corrupt officials have no shame, soon an honest government will hopefully come and then true facts will get exposed, at this time I am glad all this is happening in India and expect a retaliation from Pakistan for banning all imports from India.
in no way i support MNS bt i definitely support their demand to kick these pakistani isi agents to b thrown out of d country..i would ask modi govt wt the fuck r u doing.U r demanding d world to isolate pakistan bt u itself r hesitating to do so..modiji charity begins at home..nw its time to call d bluff of these politicians b it congeess or bjp
Farooque Khan thats nothing new my friend 😃
Jahendra Ravji ya thus it concludes v must then sit back quietly accepting the fact nothing vl happen n our media should stop being jingoistic n doesnt play with d emotions of common man
they want support then support the Indian Muslims, there are multitudes of Brilliant Indian Muslims everywhere in India even in the Indian Army, how is Secularism related to supporting pakistani punjabi muslim only, are they the only muslims? These stupid pseudo- liberalists are chuttiyahhs!!!
u speak my word bro
☆ Farooq bhaijan
LOL♥
The point is if someone is smart enough to criticise terrorist attacks in Paris and Australia then why are they restraining from condemning terrorist attacks on the country where they earn their livelihoods.
MAYANK YOU ARE WRONG! WE ARE RUNNING OUT OF PATIENCE! SO DON'T QUESTION OR DEFEND PAKISTANIS! IF THEY WANT TO WORK ,THEN DO WHAT ARNAB SAID!
TRUE TRUE TRUE.....
I love Arnab shouting..
I understand why Pakistanis living in India might not want to condemn Pakistan, but if they are so scared to say anything, they should just go back. They only benefit from India, make lots of money and have such a luxurious life and that is not acceptable when our Jawans are being slaughtered... People to people contact is a two way street and we won't bow down every bloody time anymore!
Don't over think. Why have we taken the responsibility of all the thinking in the world.
Call a spade a spade. These people are that 2-faced.
@48 venkatesh told the truth, They have business and personal benefits in this cocktail circute.
Kumar ketkar is pakistani
Yes but they r not responding to his question.
......INDIA BLAMED PAKISTAN BEFORE THEY HAD ANY PROOF........Silence
send back pakistan star back......
Mahadev u have to go back to kindergarten.
We should stop our charity work for actors and singers of Pakistan . They comes to India for fame cuz they are not getting it in Pakistan..thats it. Its their personal interest and we should stop it.
Now a days art changed with word M(money)+Art = MART (market), ultimately more then a nation. If directors or producers really want to upgrade art in society why on the earth talent from rural parts of India or regional actors are not taken.
At the end of the day these talents of Pakistan or so called talent of Mart are not going to support India or sympathies India when we need it.. they are not Indian or understand the pain of an Indian.. but they are human who can eat bread and butter by Indian money.
You Dumbfuck, you think banning a few pakistani actors is gonna solve terrorism? What is going to happen after they ban the actors? Thats not the problem, people are the problem, please dont blame the entire country. Please take your head out of your ass.
+Aamir Masterofbling unless and until government of Pakistan don't bend.. to reduce their terrorist, I say ban all the actors, singers.. ban all the entertainment services... boycott pakistan, let the Gandhi ji's movement run all over again.
lets show Pakistan the power of peace, without weapons.. and drive their government to kill all their terrorists.
Aamir what do you think I don't care about Pakistani people..let me say I do care about them, but is his own government care about his own Pakistani people, everyday you will hear some kind of terrorists activities in Pakistan.. many people lose their life because of them...so we can't run away by reality.. either their government should understand the needs of their own public or either we bent their government to do so..in the mean time they aren't in heaven even in present.. and don't worry we will bend and empower your richie rich actors and singers too, they will raise questions against their own government..who aren't now for India.
Freaking 70 years we waited, presuming they will change, and stop this.. but zero result achieved..Now enough is enough.. anymore I don't want my soliders to bleed in border .. for their corrupted policy.
Teach wise lessons with best possible wisest form and Teach hard lessons with best possible hardest form.. we can't interchange hard with wise... now for 70 years we teach them in wisest ways and they didn't understand this.. now it's time to show them the hardest ways!!
I wish kumar ketkar would have been at Taj hotel during 2008 mumbai attack . Kasab would have given him some good people to people connection.
This pakistani actor when go to pakistan immediately ISI contact this actor for information about india. Anyone can guarantee this actor don't give any information to ISI?
POSSIBILY VERY TRUE
Salman Khan fuck u😃
If Pakistan is doing something wrong then Pakistani Actors must pay for it so that they can understand the menace created by Pakistan!
We whant to come to India, to work in bollywood😅🤣
one major point to notice In this debate is .that
#atifaslam , #fawadkhan #alizafar can speak against terror attacks in #paris and other countries but not for the country from where they are earning, country feeding them , the country who made them the STARS . it's pathetic to let it go. It is a serious issue to discuss , argue and to take action against it.
with all these debates going...nothing will change and continues the same until some serious and resolute steps are taken towards change...
Guys I am totally against the Pakistani govt . Strict action must be taken against their agency. But still I am saying I love all the Pakistani artists . U guys tell don't u think atif aslam is one of the best singers in Bollywood. Or do u prefer chutiya honey Singh and baadshah. Ali Zafar and fawad khan are also damm amazing actors
chetan sir ur points are the theme of this debate.
Not just actors. Everything related to Pakistan should get banned in India.
TRUE...
What about the ten million immigrant that left Pakistan for India you whant to ban them and send them all back to Pakistan?we will be happy to take back the kapoors, the khannas, the kumars,the dutts,the roshans,the puris,the chopra, the sahnis ect I have very long list will take 24 hour to write some famous Pakistani that live india😅🤣
I liked the way,What Chetan Bhagat!He explained it all!
So basically Indians can defend pakistani actors, but those pakistani actors can't make a statement for being on one side wow!
Rahul sing, mayank you guys doing great job.. Now a days pakistan don't need to defend itself nor there people because some indians do it for them.. *TUMNE THEKA LIYA HAI UNKE LIYE BOLNE K LIYE*
Let them speak and defend or oppose thats none of your business.
These so called old duded can;t even see the poor Army men who does it for 20k month salary he lets his life foregone for inner Love towards country but these so called "indian' are more specific and right about this situation.
Just think once 18 men burnt to death how there family will see india and government what they are doing for them.
I am Pakistani my cousins Farah and Tabu are going to help me get into bollywood 😊
It might be politically correct but we cannot take back the right of begging from beggars.
In all the debates i have seen so far by Arnab... only Arnab speaks and doesnt listen and expects his panelist to conduct themselves properly as debate's decorum ... quite funny ! :) This doesnt have anything to do with whether he is right or not just the way he conducts debates
Mayank Shekhar's point of view is like If he is raped he will say "So What" if I am raped, at least I had sex !!!
"I'm not here to give Insurance Policies to Pakistanis." - Arnab Goswami.. 😂👍🏻
this is what i called a "PART TIME PATRIOTISM" .......we sent them back after 26/11,they came back,we did when our soldiers were beheaded, they called back...same thing was repeated after pathankot attack and this thing will keep happening in future as well......there is no solution......so just chillax and enjoy the show....nothing is going to change
munish kumar Singh
nothing can tear us apart........
Namaste Arnab ji and to all sensible people who are for Bharat there,
For the rest who are supporting ..lets take following steps:
send their family members to fight along with our brave soldiers...wait n watch ....after sometimes if their family members die.....they should then b asked to dance play n drink with those terrorist n their supporters...
These ppl should be lined up in front of our desh ka border and flet them face the bullets guns n tanks...all gazhal dance drink sports will come from their rear end...😡
Dhanywaad.
look I am only 16 years old and I am mature enough to understand that Pakistani actors don't mean harm to us and kicking them out won't make any sense......Like wtf !? Look I am from Mumbai the heart of Bollywood and I don't any logic in that..... I mean it is the reason we are a great country ... it is a reason Pakistani actors come here .... We are great country just kicking them out because they are Pakistani like Wow.... it will be a stupid act.... and if you wanna correct me use a good language don't use your " slum language " :|
+The Diplomat Yeah man so sad ... we have sooo many valuable topics to have a debate....what a media we have :(
Its OK for you to say that since you are 16. But we are in state of war like situations with Pakistan . We don't want an actual War with Pakistan but with Pakistan funded Terrorism . Internationally in UN our PM along with all global countries are trying to declare Pakistan a terrorists state so that there will not be any Business / trade from Pakistan with rest of World. We want Pakistan to realize their mistake , and stop funding Terrorism. We are raising this point globally in front of UN and our-self are allowing Pakistan artist to come to India and earn their living. WE WANT THEM TO GET FRUSTRATED AND WORK ON PAKISTAN's SPONSORED TERRORISM . PAKISTANIS CITIZENS HAVE LONG WAY TO GO AND WILL HAVE TO BE FORCED TO WORK ON THEIR TERRORISM PROBLEMS WHICH IS AFFECTING PAKISTAN AS WELL AS WORLD.
you r 16, sorry i am worried about ur up bringing
get mstured then we can discuss
Srinivas Kandadai WTF.... you do realised what you said right ?? coz i didnt .... Like you are suggesting me to grow up before i have a opinion WOW......LOL
Nandan Warma Our country cant do that we have reputation ... And dont worry we will repay them for the attacks but it will a " face to face ".... No inside job like they do....and I dont think they will be frustated if we kick pak actors because remember they didnt do anything after thousands of childrens were killed in the peshawar attacks.... LOL ...
" Frustate tab nai hue to actors ko nikaal ne baad kyu honge "....
I want to ask one question are our army people have some individual fight or problem with Pakistani army man, they represent our country and fighting for the country as a citizen and its duty of every citizen to fight by their profession if some country is doing terrorism in our country.
whatever Mr. Venkatesh said way really great... salute to u sir for taking such a stand
"nobody is going to give you a foolish declaration" ..epic!!!!
Arnab Goswami is a sociopath and he's exactly the sociopath we need. Glad he's on our side.
*Arnab should get admission in a university out of India and study journalism. He doesn't know how to conduct a programme.*
Mohammed used to rape a 6 year old.
He is from Oxford! :D
looks like a fan of Burkha Dutt to me.
they don't just walk across border and start working, they got working visa from Indian immigration, and they haven't done anything wrong, after 9/11 when Indian were discriminated we called that racist and inhuman and now we are walking on same path
why not !!!.might be a chance
we tried many way ,nothing worked. so last option is stop every exchange.
Gandu first of all I was born here , i don't what gills you talking about but you shouldn't be talking about it I read islamic history our own prophet himself married cousins Zaynab bint Jaktsh, who was not only the daughter of Umaimah bint Abd al-Muttalib, one of his father's sisters but was also divorced from a marriage with Muhammad's adopted son, Zayd ibn Haritha and I'm not making it up it's in Quran go check ( Sura Al-Ahzab 33:37). And Quran is Allah's word can't be wrong
Not just him Muhammad also allowed the marriage of his daughter, Fatimah, to his cousin, Ali ibn Abi Talib, who became later calipha
The second Caliph, Umar ibn al-Khattab, also married his cousin, Atikah bint Zayd ibn Amr ibn
So cousin marriage is your culture is not mine so get your fact , when get some time off from throughing stones read some quran
Gagan Gill Quran? I wipe my ARSE with the pages of Quran.
definatley all Pakistani celebrities has to go from India if they not clear about their decision on Uri Attack.
Why is Mayank acting lyk one the pakistanis hez a jerk and thrown out of india aswell. Proud of u Arnab Goswami
Arnam goswai dude is a loud mouth, he has no respect for other debaters, he just butts in with his oily ass hair and barely gives other a chance to speak their mind.
No discussion, no debate, no arguments required on this subject. Pakistanis should not be allowed in India. And we need not show any soft corner to any Pakistani. Period. We have the whole world opened to us to find friends.
Throw them out of India if they are not with us and boycott all movies which they are part of so our producers won't dare to caste them in movies
yes, all Pakistani artist should be banned which in slow poison support love jihad. We Indian should boycott all movies which have any thing to do as actor/ producer/director or any form with srk, amir khan, salman khan, akhtar family, mahesh batt family, karan johar (Dharma productions) and aditya chopra (Rani mukherjee's husband) productions. people will have to understand why these Pakistani artists are brought in our film industry, do we not enough talent, we do . this is the way indirectly to support
Dear Kumar Ketkar
We don't bloody care about what BJP, Congress or any other political party did in the past..We want to boycott Pakistan in every form....including boycotting PAK actors. Then with complete credibility ask the world to isolate PAK. So Ketkar kindly work towards this...if u want to do service unto the Indian people.
Jai Hind
Nothing personal against actors but we have to take a stand.With our soldiers dying and terror from Pakistan increasing we have to stop these Pakistani actors or anyone else from Pakistan from working in India!!
One question.....WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO SANIA MIRZA?
she is an indian residence
+abhinav kashyap i know that but her husband is pakistani and India is about to cut off all political and economic relations with Pakistan. Poor girl will become sandwitch
they can stay in some other easy to immigrant country like Canada. they are rich man.
citizenship can be acquired
nothing will happen , she is muslim
# m r venkatesh and arnab nailed them.
Jindal. Steel also should stop business in Pakistan
Well that's in indian interest..
Madhu Sudhan need to know your facts bud, have you ever seen India's balance of trade and balance of payments.
K we should also know that those artists came legally to participate in Indian economic activity ,they can choose to respond or not about terrorism,we may feel bad about that but certainly can't blame them and make hue and cry ,Indian self respect does not depend on Pakistanis response ,that only belittle us on the world stage,until before these incidents Pakistanis youth,started talking against their government for encouraging terrorism after these incidents differences rise to a new high that is what needed for political fringes on both sides want for political gains,even army rejected this stand by reject 5cr compensation fund from MNS ,our application of reason flooding away in the midst of hue and cry
Madhu Sudhan but why involve artists in all this rubbish. It's a matter of demand on either side there was a demand for Indian movies so we legalized it in Pakistan, should we also involve all rubbish in entertainment and also ban Indian artists, that is why from the very beginning I was in favor of keeping imports and export separate with India our balance of payment is much higher. 22 crore people watching Indian movies while destroying our own film industry and then bring Indian artists over and welcome them while disrespect in return, and India is always a third world country no matter what they think.
love you arnab....you put forth arguments for people of our side strongly. I just don't understand why these so called intellectuals and liberals behave like an intellectual indian. things are inter-related. they just need to look in that ways. Also, we are from the land of Gandhi. why can't they understand non cooperation movement works. And in current scenario we have to go for it. Had that been the case with America or any other country, things wud have been really different.
Arnab! you are a brilliant speaker but please 'respect the speaker'. Let them speak and not try shutting them up everytime!! If you are the only to speak then there is no point of inviting them! You can keep speaking all by yourself..!! Isn't it?
can they please fix the screen resolution
Arnab Goswami Hatsoff to you!!!!
Real fact revealed by You!!!
One simple question:
If Indian actors can critisize the Indian government on the subject of "INTOLERANCE", then why not Pakistani actors take a clear stand against the Pakistani government on a more dangerous subject of "TERRORISM"?
Mr. Ketkar is still in 1998, please somebody wake him up.
online version has more adds than tv
Please Upload HD Videos..This is not TimesNow standard
If someone is working for me that means I'm the reason how he is making his living from which means I'm feeding him. By the same analogy, we are giving the salary to pakistani actors and if you can't speak for the one who is feeding you then you should go back to the place you came from.
24:15 to 24:50 ....Arnab Rocks....keh kaar le lii yar tum ne toh ....bahot badia
Mr Arnab the Pak actors did not descend from heaven above and they are certainly not messengers of peace....we invited them here , our Indian embassy issued visas...we cannot hold them at gunpoint and make them sign their death warrant here.....and then force them out to Pakistan, where perhaps a similar situation awaits them or maybe even worse...why are we holding them to ranson and making them a scapegoat. The martyrs family members are not holding them responsible for the killings neither are they in any way connected with the attacks...
Javed Akhtar isn't a Muslim. He's an atheist. And just like Anupan Kher was denied visa since he spoke strongly against the Pakistan sponsored terrorism. Similarly, Javed has also been vocal about the same especially after what happened in Mumbai in 2008.
Javed akhter wife shabana azmi is the sister in law of Pakistani acter Jamal Hashmi father of farah and tabu
India still doesn't understand that a terrorist for one is a freedom fighter to another!
One must try to eradicate the sole problem of why the person has gone to such extent of giving up his life. That life and the other lives that were taken is a price that is paid by the Government of India for neglecting the Issue of Kashmir.
The people who fled IOK(Indian Occupied Kashmir) when they came to POK they were filled with hate against India and still are but they are in constant control of our Government but the clashes that have now been started by the people themselves in Kashmir by raising Pakistani Flag not in few groups but in huge masses means they don't want to live with Inda they want to be independent of India.
This is what India should understand.
Now we had a similar problem in Balochistan but we handled it by directing all the Foreign investment and even the people of Pakistan realised that the province is getting nothing for its development now its is getting 46 billion dollars worth of infrastructure.
Anyway I still gonna get angry Indians madly commenting on my post so go ahead.
good job venkatesh...i am with you.. on this.
So many ads in this video, even more than tv broadcast. Defeating the only reason I come here.
Mayank Sharma was the only person making sense here.
Lack of journalism ethics. LOL
Those sideburns though :D
Let Mayank Shekhar serve at the border for a month and then ask.
I love this show its better then comedy nights hahahahahazhahahahahaghahahahahahahahahahahha
Bajirao Mastani which has nothing to do with Pakistan was banned in Pakistan
arnub @10:15- let me put my view and then I will let you people debate,biggest joke😂
Chat Bhagat made a valid point...
Indian actors need to support India.
When attack on Peeshawar happened, SRK sent lots of Money to them. And today Uri attack happened and 18 Jawan killed. But no Khan came forward to condemn this and not only giving any Solidarity for them. Is Bollywood really a Indian Film Industry or Pakistani film Industry??
India first and the one who stands for justice and it's now needed the most.
I am not a MNS supporter but This time I M WITH MNS. As an Indian i have FAWAD KHAN who has guts and sense to tweet after Paris attack and not on Uri even after this much oppose. Fawad is most welcome if he speaks against Pakistan sponsored terrorism.
Arnav Just feeding the mob mentality of "bhagao saloko" Cheap stunts.
After a long time , I felt that this debate was bullshit. I dont think everything said or done has to be vocalised. In this case, I fully support Mayank. I dont think just because they are Pakistani artists, they should be thrown back to Pakistan. In the films where Fawad Khan has acted I believe it was the Director's or writer's choice to have Fawad in the movie. And more than Fawad, it was Indians who benefited out of the movies. He has been paid only for the work has done. I dont think Fawad has to keep vocalizing the fact that he is from a terrorist state. I believe that Fawad or any other artist who hail from Pakistan should not be condemned as terrorist or a citizen from a terrorist state unless they have a direct contact or relation to a terrorist group.
It is a reality in India that people give more respect Bollywood actors then our soldiers who are sacrifice there lives.
23:00 Arnab pissed at Kumar Ketkar sawal toh puchlene de
what if they are coming here to steal the secrets of Indian army? will anyone who support their coming into india take responsibility if some terror happens ??
Mayank shekar is irrelevant. When he has his own family member on the front line, only then will he realize what we're talking about.
Enough of brotherhood, enough 2nd chances, enough compromises.... be it hate or love..make it clear.... Don't humiliate their stars but just ask them to leave our country.....
■■■ Patriots of india■■■
Arnab is trying to help you to choose from a real life options. ...
You have to take a couregious step by making a decision. ..
Are you with india or Pakistan ?
All the patriotic indians stand beside india..
★ Any person who is supporting terrorists and Pakistani lobbyists are Gaddar ....anti national. ..
Simply put. .
Do not sleep with the enemy. .★★★
★ Meri Bharat Mahan ★
To Pakistan...
I am an indian and i see this trend on indian side that whenever this attacks happen india just sends all the pakistani actors and cricketers back to their country and after few months they call them back...
What the fcuk...if u are making a mind to boycott pakistan then do it on a forever basis...don't change decisions just to get the pakistani viewership, by inviting pakistani actors or play with pakistan cricket team to get good TRPs and earn money from it...make up your mind and isolate the pakistan like usa and rest of the world did to north korea...
And muslims are nowadays getting lot problematic to the rest of the world making few good progressive muslims to suffer...sometimes i am thinking of converting myself to hindu as, in india all the muslims are converted from hindus only but i think like, which caste am i allowed to go if i convert myself ??...
u r well welcomed bro...no need to choose a caste but it's just a dharma u can choose...
and when it comes to giving or taking the daughter of someone else..how can it be possible without a caste ??...looking it with the social point of view then the effect would be drastic without a caste..
Bhai u just hit nail on the head..
+Hussain Please don't we can do without 7th century lunatics
Uri Attack : Was It really An Attack Or An Incident?
A lot of eyebrows have already been raised about the Uri attack and this has raised many valid questions here. Given the timing and circumstances of the attack, nothing can be ruled out. It could have very well been just an incident of fire? Which has been made to look like a terrorist attack, because all we could see on our television screens was just smoke rising out from the cantonment area. No gunshots, no dead bodies of supposed milliants involved in the attack, who were as per the army version given immediate burial. Why where they in such a hurry?
you are real tatta bhai
Chetan Bhagat is making a lot of sense !!!! India need more people like Chetan Bhagat !
Why are the producers hiring actors from Pakistan. India already has a surplus of talented actors who are constantly trying to make a mark in the industry.
hello ajay do u how to speak
if someone insulting. abusing our mother we will take permission from father . we do act
Mr. Ketkar will speak only when Venkatesh stops,.... then he will only politicize the issue. Great man.
we should all boycott movies of Pakistani actors.
when they won't get any public response, they will go back on their own.
Rahul Singh is the most intellectual and sensible person in the panel
Kumar Ketkar was hilarious, he just rounded around Vajpayee & Modi without any logic and Prof. Behera went totally deaf and dumb on being asked a simple question 'how has the people-people relations benefited India'
So, business is above country. Time for people of India to destroy Bollywood.
That was actually a good debate!..when i started the video as an artist i was clearly in opposition but now i am with it because the points which arnab and team gave actually made sense..bechari ae dil he mushkil and raees ki to lag gyi ab:-)
People like Mayank etc are surely on either the payroll of ISI or of the underground fugitive till running the show from across the border.
YES. .RIGHT..GHAR WAPASI IS NECESSARY NOW
Why don't the good people SPEAK UP and stand for the right rather than have DOUBLE STANDARDS .The name fame and money they get in India is really beyond belief...They dont get this popularity in their own Country. ..We can't be confused or diplomatic anymore.BAHUT HO GAYA AB
Around 40th minute, Chetan Bhagat nailed it! MR was another rockstar!
i dont know how behra became a Professor i am really worried about his students
he is not only behera he is also Andha
Why the Pakistani Artists should express sorry on the death of Indians? The intensity of hate in their heart is so much that they cannot utter the world sorry. They come here as they get nothing in Pakistan. Pakistan being a terrorist country they are also the kids and sons of the same terrorists. How they can criticise their fathers and their mentors. It is my request that they should go back otherwise something bad can happen to them, they should not wait for up to that bad events.
What is the bollywood guarantee to Indian people that these pakistani actors will be actors only not terrorists in the future.
The only way to make these so called actors and Mayank understand Patriotism is , Send them to The Border to live and fight. Send them Now.
aai haai, arnab ki zulfein... those never ending sidechops. hahaha.