TWICE 'Strategy' (Secret Version) (Line Distribution)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 188

  • @kendrichbadando7950
    @kendrichbadando7950 День тому +142

    R.I.P Jeongyeon and Dahyun’s redemption lines
    2020 - 2024

  • @ognitha
    @ognitha 4 дні тому +255

    JEONGYEON's line is even worse here... and people have been saying she has "good" lines this era, like that's a HELL NO

    • @PragadeeshMuthu
      @PragadeeshMuthu День тому +21

      They changed it right...
      Strategy album line distribution jeo had 97 sec meanwhile in with youth 86 sec
      It's improvement 🥲

  • @fl-flunky
    @fl-flunky 4 дні тому +126

    Its nice but im glad they changed it. The final ver is way better tbh

  • @ifu138
    @ifu138 3 дні тому +60

    It's crazy that in the final version they gave one of the Jeongyeon prechoruses from this to Nayeon even though even if she kept both prechoruses jeongyeon still would've had less than nayeon in it, but heaven forbid the gap between the two leads is even slightly more equal i guess lol

  • @minaballerina
    @minaballerina 4 дні тому +110

    the chorus is imo the best thing about the final ver so i’m glad they changed it, but it’s fun to hear the demo

    • @Kpop_Thinghz
      @Kpop_Thinghz 4 дні тому +1

      What's a demo?

    • @Jurovey
      @Jurovey 4 дні тому +17

      ​@@Kpop_ThinghzWhen the song is not ready, a version to demonstrate what the final version will be like, like a guide

    • @Kpop_Thinghz
      @Kpop_Thinghz 4 дні тому

      @Jurovey ooooo , ok , thanks ❤️

  • @mysticoncedive
    @mysticoncedive 4 дні тому +96

    1:30 Sana sounds so nice here ❤

    • @xlyohxym
      @xlyohxym 22 години тому

      Big no

    • @Rocket_finds
      @Rocket_finds 22 години тому +8

      ​@@xlyohxymHuh? She fits this concept and she sounds so good

  • @ultonce
    @ultonce 4 дні тому +115

    Im so glad they changed the demo, this one is so bland

    • @wmnk_
      @wmnk_  4 дні тому +87

      apparently this is how it was done at first since it was supposed to be a bside, i guess they changed it since it got selected as tt

    • @what1568
      @what1568 3 дні тому

      ​@@wmnk_ Then the orig supposedly title track, like it like it has some possible changes too?

    • @thunderdunder
      @thunderdunder 2 дні тому +10

      @@wmnk_ If that's the case, I really hope JYPE can rethink things like this every time they make a title track. There’ve been quite a few title tracks that feel kinda offbeat.

  • @longbottomneville7239
    @longbottomneville7239 4 дні тому +121

    Nayeon 2-->1
    Jeongyeon 7-->9
    Momo still 6th
    Sana 8-->3 (insane)
    Jihyo 1-->2
    Mina 4-->5
    Dahyun 9-->7
    Chaeyoung 5-->8
    Tzuyu 3-->4

    • @chen_kpop
      @chen_kpop 4 дні тому +18

      My Jeongyeon😢

    • @longbottomneville7239
      @longbottomneville7239 4 дні тому +17

      @@chen_kpop yes! I wish album for Twice where Jeongyeon in top2, Dahyun top 4.

    • @chen_kpop
      @chen_kpop 2 дні тому +2

      ​@@longbottomneville7239yeah, if jype keep doing this, Jeongyeon will have less lines(totally) than Sana😢

    • @jadebayoba7073
      @jadebayoba7073 День тому

      So its trash

    • @fadligalih8150
      @fadligalih8150 15 годин тому

      Sana ku🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @randomhuman-630
    @randomhuman-630 3 дні тому +44

    1:29 i wish they kept this part in the final version

    • @xlyohxym
      @xlyohxym 22 години тому +8

      No, Mina definitely sounds better. Sorry

    • @PochyASF
      @PochyASF 21 годину тому +4

      FOREALLLLL❤

    • @randomhuman-630
      @randomhuman-630 18 годин тому +1

      @@xlyohxym it's fine you don't have to be sorry we all have different opinions

  • @hick.
    @hick. 4 дні тому +62

    WAS THAT THE CHORUS?😢

    • @SpicyPaisy
      @SpicyPaisy 4 дні тому +3

      😭😭

    • @kjsta124
      @kjsta124 3 дні тому +30

      This version was supposed to be a b-side and they changed it to be the title track

  • @mysticoncedive
    @mysticoncedive 4 дні тому +163

    They shouldve added the bridge to the version without Megan

    • @YatoKpop
      @YatoKpop 4 дні тому +28

      Thats what i was thinking

    • @ExoticsCollector
      @ExoticsCollector 4 дні тому +25

      Bro fr, the bridge part is very good!

  • @fzzzzbeecho.o
    @fzzzzbeecho.o 4 дні тому +135

    JYPE was like how is Nayeon not first in the original version, we have to release a secret version to make the distribution more “twice” like. 😂😂

    • @jett_fs
      @jett_fs 4 дні тому

      @@fzzzzbeecho.o that's what I thought 😭

    • @inawairuz87
      @inawairuz87 4 дні тому +4

      Hahaha so accurate!🤭😆

    • @boxshinimpact
      @boxshinimpact День тому +5

      Once hate Nayeon lol. Yall lowkey wanna make her a villain as always

    • @inawairuz87
      @inawairuz87 День тому +4

      @@boxshinimpact they hate her because of the line distribution? Sigh.. fans always like that! Btw..Nayeon is my most fav in Twice tho..the Queen will always be a Queen! The most popular one always has a lot of haters too..😮‍💨

    • @harumii-bv9lj
      @harumii-bv9lj День тому +1

      @@inawairuz87 Nayeon isn't the most popular member it's Tzuyu

  • @MYænter
    @MYænter 2 дні тому +16

    Everyone got the "Strategy Strategy" & "You'll be down on your knees" part but Jeongyeon not at all??

  • @jeongbun2386
    @jeongbun2386 4 дні тому +64

    Ig i wont complain abt Jeongyeon’s actual lines this time then lmao, thank GOD

  • @KpopEditionsBR
    @KpopEditionsBR 4 дні тому +69

    I knew it the pre chorus would be Sana... sad that we didnt got it in the official, but atleast we can hear her here

    • @snsdgivemetwice
      @snsdgivemetwice 4 дні тому +16

      Yeah , Me too
      I'm thinking the same, cuz often structure TWICE's song like that. If Tzuyu get PreChorus, Sana certain get same part too.. 😮 But damn the official is Mina

    • @trannam2202
      @trannam2202 3 дні тому +3

      i'm glad that Sana got a lot line in English song. And some annoying person commented that Mina suit better than her LOL. I mean that pre chorus part they sound great .

    • @snsdgivemetwice
      @snsdgivemetwice 2 дні тому +11

      ​@@trannam2202Sorry but Mina's voice still better than her in English. Because Mina's is fluent in English 😊

    • @trannam2202
      @trannam2202 2 дні тому

      @ yeah I know. But for me they sound great so nevermind

    • @eumesmo5533
      @eumesmo5533 День тому +4

      ​@@trannam2202 Sorry but Mina really suits the prechorus better than Sana

  • @lightborn
    @lightborn 4 дні тому +27

    Then I wonder if Like It Like It had such changes too or not 🤔

    • @zeniro943
      @zeniro943 3 дні тому +6

      I KNOWWW LIKE IN CURIOUS OF HOW IT WOULD SOUND LIKE IF IT WAS KEPT AS THE TITLE TRACK

    • @eumesmo5533
      @eumesmo5533 День тому +1

      Yeah probably it wouldn't sound like the version we got. Especially if Megan sang there too, they'd probably eat up the bridge and change who sings each part

  • @Ak_creation801
    @Ak_creation801 4 дні тому +53

    Thank god they changed the chorus

  • @suukka
    @suukka 4 дні тому +27

    changes:
    0:39 dahyun
    0:43 jeongyeon
    0:47 nayeon
    0:56 jihyo
    1:30 sana
    1:48 tzuyu
    1:57 mina
    2:07 bridge
    2:52 nayeon adlibs

  • @keinnosaurus
    @keinnosaurus День тому +5

    i’m glad they changed it. cause tzuyu and mina pre chorus is perfect the way it is though some of sana’s lines should’ve been retained.

  • @MinLeo_repost
    @MinLeo_repost 4 дні тому +45

    so this is where they hid Sana's lines 🤓🤓

  • @mekimleoo
    @mekimleoo 3 дні тому +7

    thank god they changed the chorus to what it is now, but they should've kept the bridge for the only twice version

  • @2Blu2
    @2Blu2 4 дні тому +7

    Omg ik theres like no space but i wish the bridge was aomehow in the final ver too lolll

  • @atne3484
    @atne3484 4 дні тому +18

    Someone should make a fair version using parts of the demo into the final to give Jeongyeon, Dahyun, and Sana more lines in the final version

  • @queencard97
    @queencard97 4 дні тому +63

    Woah Sana has lines in every part of the song here, she has 2 verses, a long pre chorus, a chorus, bridge and an adlib.

  • @ABCslurpthatD
    @ABCslurpthatD 4 дні тому +163

    So the company DO realize Sana has been getting too many lines and decided to hold her back this time

    • @wmnk_
      @wmnk_  4 дні тому +34

      😭

    • @mysticoncedive
      @mysticoncedive 4 дні тому +63

      I heavily doubt the company cares about that tbh. They probably just thought that part suited Mina better.

    • @minabonitap
      @minabonitap 4 дні тому +21

      Sana doesn't receive any lines from the dive album, in the same way she was last and didn't receive any good parts

    • @doIphindolphin78
      @doIphindolphin78 3 дні тому +1

      What abt nayeon and jihyo

    • @jaejae7090
      @jaejae7090 3 дні тому

      Main vocalist and lead?​@doIphindolphin78

  • @samfok4936
    @samfok4936 13 годин тому

    jihyo singing “youll be down on your knees calling me up begging me dont leave” is heaven 😭

  • @chwnxv
    @chwnxv День тому +3

    They should added the bridge to the original song

  • @q-kuinzu3020
    @q-kuinzu3020 3 дні тому +5

    Damn, all members has +10 seconds in their line but Jeongyeon even she is lead vocal

    • @ej13012010
      @ej13012010 День тому

      I've been saying b4 she gained weight cause of her condition her line distribution was okay but still kinda bad but after the weight gain they pushed her back

  • @snsdgivemetwice
    @snsdgivemetwice 4 дні тому +8

    LMAO 😂😂😂
    THIS IS SO PLOT TWIST
    In official realese : Sana get 2nd bottom 😮
    In the demo : get top 3 😂😂😂
    Maybe the reason, Sana didn't want to get hate because she often got 3rd or even 2nd position in Title Track. That's why she begged the producer to change the entire distribution structure. 😢
    Because she would definitely get hate, especially since Jeongyeon got 9th rank in the demo version. That doesn't make sense because she is LEAD VOCALIST and Sana just sub vocalist.

    • @lightborn
      @lightborn 3 дні тому +3

      Jeongyeon at the bottom of the main videos is a long-proven practice, a signal,etc. also bad positions in alcohol free, set me free, etc. So I'm not surprised. Anyway, her position doesn't change much in comparison to the final version. It's only +2 seconds and she's still 3 bottom. Sana should have just been given the pre-chorus, she loses the ad-libs in the final version anyway.

    • @HaewonVoiceCrack
      @HaewonVoiceCrack 3 дні тому

      ​@@lightbornAfter 2020, her lines are minimal, if not just one or two lines, since she's still in her medications. She's mad at Jihyo for giving her lot of lines during Alcohol Free era (First Time), So, her slowly gaining her lines back are good but still only one or two song where she got treated as sub vocalist (cough Keeper and Magical)

    • @Cryforme-
      @Cryforme- 3 дні тому +6

      This version wasn't supposed to be the title track- it was supposed to be the bside & Like it like it was the title track

    • @BlueJeans-u8o
      @BlueJeans-u8o 3 дні тому +4

      ​@@HaewonVoiceCrackYES! Jeongyeon receiving few lines at the time when she was still coming back from hiatus was acceptable, but now that she is well, her few lines are no longer tolerable. BETWEEN1&2 album made us hope that she would start being treated as a lead vocalist but then READY TO BE came along and ruined everything

    • @snsdgivemetwice
      @snsdgivemetwice 2 дні тому

      ​@@Cryforme-Really?

  • @swtvic
    @swtvic 4 дні тому +5

    i'm surprised that chaeyoung had way less lines originally, sad that dahyun had decent lines here but i'm shocked at jeongyeon having even less. i get that she doesn't fit the concept that much but seriously 9 seconds??? conflicted about sana's lines because she does sound good but i'm glad they let others shine since she's gotten a lot of lines in the other comebacks

    • @minabonitap
      @minabonitap 4 дні тому +1

      generalmente recibe Menos que Mina y casi lo mismo que Chae, Tzuyu o Jeongyeon solo que por alguna razon sana de igual forma queda en 4 o 5 lugar por que dura mas tiempo cantando

  • @jzngwoon
    @jzngwoon 3 дні тому +3

    Actually i want them to keep bridge somehow and make mochaeng part as outro / after bridge like its more good atleast when we comebine the bridge + original ver then jeongyeon will be more than just 7th place.

  • @sooji_thesnow雪
    @sooji_thesnow雪 День тому

    2:42 Chaeyoung: I'mma overtaking y-
    Dahyun: Awww!

  • @sana_boo
    @sana_boo 4 дні тому +17

    SERIA LA ERA DE SANA 😭😭😭😭

  • @φαντασία-ψ3ψ
    @φαντασία-ψ3ψ 4 дні тому +14

    I mean, thank you for changing it, not that it's not good but I found the final version better. Though I have to say i would love to see the bridge in the final version

  • @sarangnambiar8367
    @sarangnambiar8367 20 годин тому +1

    Did JYP producers really make this version so that they can give more lines to Nayeon and reduce Jeongyeon's lines even more. I request all Onces to stream Strategy OG version even more and try to give little to no streams to this version.

  • @BP-tm6ye
    @BP-tm6ye 4 дні тому +6

    Mina vocals in the chorus

  • @inawairuz87
    @inawairuz87 4 дні тому +8

    Wow i love this version too!😘 Queen Nayeon with the adlibs always got the feels likeee ❤️‍🔥

  • @mamobee
    @mamobee День тому +1

    I wish they kept Sana as the second prechorus, imo it suits her more than Mina, and I wish they kept the bridge. I'm really glad they changed the chorus though

  • @reinalim8292
    @reinalim8292 12 годин тому

    I prefer this version sounds much better

  • @mythicalrats7345
    @mythicalrats7345 День тому +1

    Its hard being a Jeongyeon stan😢

  • @ZaiFei-bh8dz
    @ZaiFei-bh8dz 4 дні тому +10

    Why Jeongyeon Has Lines 9 05?

    • @AhmdDfi
      @AhmdDfi 4 дні тому +5

      Cause in this demo she didn't get the chorus part

  • @KD_Line
    @KD_Line 4 дні тому +4

    Even at the demo dahyun didnt get the mochae part 😢

    • @snsdgivemetwice
      @snsdgivemetwice 4 дні тому +3

      But she's get same Prechorus twice.
      [OFFICIAL] 1st PreChorus is Chae 👉🏻 Dubu [DEMO]
      [OFFICIAL] 2nd PreChorus is Dubu 👉🏻 Still Dubu [DEMO]

  • @cypher1269
    @cypher1269 3 дні тому

    Could you make a line distribution of the original song + the bridge from the demo/secret version? It would be interesting I think!

  • @Yashen-09
    @Yashen-09 День тому +2

    So that's where sana's lines went 😅😭

  • @longbottomneville7239
    @longbottomneville7239 4 дні тому +13

    Dahyun not last, i love this version more

  • @seukos_k
    @seukos_k 3 дні тому

    glad this was made into a TT because if it was just this as the b-side i would’ve died for a performance so bad 😭 do wish the bridge made the final cut tho

  • @hduyquyen4126
    @hduyquyen4126 3 дні тому +7

    Give sana line😢😢

  • @Ken124jai
    @Ken124jai 16 годин тому

    The bridge itself is wonderful but the chorus😅

  • @ze_r0nsky
    @ze_r0nsky 4 дні тому

    You ate bestie

  • @theresnothingherebeb
    @theresnothingherebeb 18 годин тому

    I'm glad they changed it. Not hate to Sana but as a lead vocal (and even the 2nd best vocalist in twice by technique) Jeongyeon deserved her lines right now - even though actually it wasn't enough either.

  • @hoonstruckk
    @hoonstruckk 18 годин тому

    atleast the demo gave sana lines 😭

  • @БориславАмов-ю8е
    @БориславАмов-ю8е 4 дні тому +39

    The OT9 version feels so empty without Megan tbh😭😭😭

    • @moreandmomo
      @moreandmomo 4 дні тому +6

      this isn’t the ot9 version it’s the demo

    • @ali_yahhh
      @ali_yahhh 3 дні тому

      ​@@moreandmomobut it's not a demo, it's a variation in production(VIP)

  • @YatoKpop
    @YatoKpop 4 дні тому +17

    This sounds like a flop 😭😭😭. Thank god the actual version wasn't this.

    • @sana_boo
      @sana_boo 4 дні тому +1

      WHAT AJJAQ

    • @peruball2589
      @peruball2589 4 дні тому +5

      The only good part in this ver is the brigde fr

    • @twicelandyx
      @twicelandyx 4 дні тому +2

      it was supposed to be a b side i think

    • @Cryforme-
      @Cryforme- 3 дні тому +1

      ​@@twicelandyx yes & like it like it was supposed to be the title track

  • @reisgrimery3372
    @reisgrimery3372 2 дні тому

    This is prob the one they made for it to be a bside, when the members recommended it for title track, they made the new one.

  • @peruball2589
    @peruball2589 4 дні тому +4

    Thank goodness this version was not the final, the line distribution is worse than the final, the only good thing is the bridge

  • @haenzochiko4818
    @haenzochiko4818 День тому +1

    The chorus sounds so bland and the instrument been playing are almost all the same so it's hard to know which part are the chorus and which part are the pre-chorus... But it does sounds fun to listen to especially because we get to compare both this ver and the final ver

  • @jett_fs
    @jett_fs 4 дні тому +11

    The way JYP want Sana having more lines than Jeongyeon is actually wild

    • @EverPink_youtube
      @EverPink_youtube 22 години тому

      Jeongyeon rechaza muchas de sus lineas, y la voz de Sana encaja mejor en los precoros, al ser más suave que la de JY.

  • @NumberOneDahyunStan
    @NumberOneDahyunStan День тому

    Where did you find this?

  • @GaeuLiz
    @GaeuLiz 4 дні тому +1

    Will this appear to some music app?

  • @Lilenvy-07
    @Lilenvy-07 4 дні тому

    Puedes trabajar rn todo el album por favor 🙏?

  • @dhikarss
    @dhikarss 4 дні тому

    WAWWWWW

  • @mysticoncedive
    @mysticoncedive 4 дні тому +9

    Sana top 3 💜

  • @THEKLILLERBALDHEADBABYYUH
    @THEKLILLERBALDHEADBABYYUH День тому

    SHOULD OF KEPT THIS FOR DUBU😢😢😢❤

  • @meowdog6565
    @meowdog6565 22 години тому

    Sana singing more😍

  • @hirano5725
    @hirano5725 2 дні тому

    Good thing they changed the chorus the official one is way more catchy

  • @TomatoMaster-rg2nq
    @TomatoMaster-rg2nq День тому

    this version where dagyun gas lines❤ poor jeongy tho

  • @singingwhale977
    @singingwhale977 12 годин тому

    The chorus here is less catchy than the new one but i wish they kept the bridge.

  • @zyozone18
    @zyozone18 3 дні тому

    where did you get the demo from?

  • @Exreihoe
    @Exreihoe День тому

    Well at least sana got lines here

  • @yiwwwwwwy
    @yiwwwwwwy 4 дні тому +1

    Where is this from?

    • @ultonce
      @ultonce 4 дні тому

      @@yiwwwwwwy the digital album of strategy comes with the demo version, which was this because it was supposed to be a bsid3

    • @snsdgivemetwice
      @snsdgivemetwice 4 дні тому

      From album digital

    • @Sttevan_Bonahans
      @Sttevan_Bonahans День тому

      ​@@snsdgivemetwiceWhat is a digital album?

  • @singingwhale977
    @singingwhale977 3 дні тому +5

    I FOUND SANA'S LINES GUYSS, IT WAS JUST REMOVED CUZ IT ATE TO MUCH

  • @supernovea
    @supernovea 8 годин тому

    NO WAY THEY SCRAPPED MY BIAS HIGH NOTE (Sana) I hate u af jype.

  • @rollismusic1379
    @rollismusic1379 4 дні тому

    Where is this version found?

  • @SethVIB
    @SethVIB 4 дні тому +3

    I can't believe they've released this garbage version while both versions of NMIXX's O.O are locked in Beyoncé's basement.

    • @abumissu
      @abumissu День тому

      wasn't they performed both O.O versions in the past? and besides they're not even manage by the same division

  • @jo_valentinot
    @jo_valentinot 3 дні тому

    and Nayeon is still first in the original demo 😭

  • @soenaydesspa9306
    @soenaydesspa9306 4 дні тому +5

    They just won't stop having nayeon with most lines will they?, when she clearly wasn't first in the original twice strategy, poor jihyo getting overshadowed by nayeon's voice

    • @swtvic
      @swtvic 4 дні тому +7

      ...? she's a second apart from jihyo and in the official version jihyo is first

  • @cuongnguyenhuu712
    @cuongnguyenhuu712 3 дні тому +2

    I like this SOOOO much more than the final version (no offense but without Megan it just seems better somehow). The only thing I'd change is get rid of Nayeon's chorus to give it to Mina, get rid of Mina's Chorus to give it to Chaeyoung and get rid of Chaeyoung's chorus to give it to Jeongyeon. The final song was missing something and Jeongyeon's still in the bottom

    • @luv_mark
      @luv_mark 3 дні тому +7

      the final version is definitely the better one lol the chorus more hits

    • @cuongnguyenhuu712
      @cuongnguyenhuu712 3 дні тому

      @@luv_mark But it feels unfinished after megan's rap

  • @БориславАмов-ю8е
    @БориславАмов-ю8е 4 дні тому +1

    NAYEON❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @traverse_danikuuu
    @traverse_danikuuu 4 дні тому

    This version definitely sounded like a b-side 💀 im sorry this sounded real bland.

  • @thunderdunder
    @thunderdunder 2 дні тому +1

    The final ver is way better tbh

  • @lightofdawn7291
    @lightofdawn7291 4 дні тому

    Is this version official?

    • @wmnk_
      @wmnk_  4 дні тому +7

      yes, it's from their digital album

    • @Kae_la
      @Kae_la 4 дні тому

      @@wmnk_how do you get this version?

    • @swtvic
      @swtvic 4 дні тому

      @@Kae_labuy the album lol

  • @aeswags35
    @aeswags35 День тому +2

    Oh this is terrible

  • @БориславАмов-ю8е
    @БориславАмов-ю8е 4 дні тому +1

    5 seconds ago ❤😊

  • @_yellowcardeu_
    @_yellowcardeu_ 3 дні тому

    ngl thank god they changed it the final version chorus is by far the best part of the song and mina fits the pre chorus way better than sana

  • @Noah2419-me-n-u
    @Noah2419-me-n-u 4 дні тому +2

    I don't like this version 😭
    and without Megan

  • @karinasnooodles_
    @karinasnooodles_ 4 дні тому +3

    Are people smoking or what? This version is better, I can’t stand the final for a reason

    • @YatoKpop
      @YatoKpop 4 дні тому +25

      U seem to be the one smoking

    • @Kae_la
      @Kae_la 4 дні тому +1

      How do I get this version(

    • @peruball2589
      @peruball2589 4 дні тому +10

      This ver is so badddd

    • @bypaknox3629
      @bypaknox3629 4 дні тому +11

      This version is awful

    • @ExoticsCollector
      @ExoticsCollector 4 дні тому +2

      Ur the only one who saying that lol

  • @alexasnow5628
    @alexasnow5628 3 дні тому +1

    im glad they make this as a title coz Jeongyeon lines was 💀