While I would agree that not every member of a group should go solo, I completely disagree with the statement that a soloist has to be able to do everything. Take (G)I-dle´s Miyeon for example: When she did here solo release she was still terrible at rapping (and I would guess she would never have done it if Soyeon hadn´t forced her to do it in wife), if they perform she is also the most likely to screw up the choreo and here stage presence at least within the group is also on the weaker side. But her solo debut was great and successful because it just focussed on her voice. She doesn´t have to dance around when she performs her songs, all she has to do is sing and that is completely enough.
illit deserve the criticism not hate ...but if does not change the fact that they lack talent and skill and do not deserve to debut especially when they were competing against so many talented contestant hybe is at fault basically for producing idols like chinese factory
I agree with you half way on the plastic surgery opinion. Me and Yuna are the same age so I think it’s a mix of both hip pads and her just growing up. All my life, I’ve been skinny to the point that my doctor recommended me Ensure because I couldn’t gain nor maintain weight and I’m just now getting curves and gaining some weight at 20 years old. Yuna might be experiencing something similar and she’s most likely using hip pads a lot to accentuate it. But, she could’ve also had plastic surgery. All idols use some type of body enhancement(s) whether surgical or not it’s apart of the job because their selling a fantasy
Ahhh so let me get this straight. Main vocals with extreme talent but lacking in rap = no solo main dancers who can rap and dance but sing averagely = no solo visuals with deserved extra positions = no solo Rappers with enough talent to knock you off your feet but not too good dancers = no solo
good video, but I will venture to add something else that annoys me. Too many members in a group. I will say groups in excess of 5 members they tend to have TOO many members. People will hate me for this but I think that TWICE could be completely functional as a 5 member group instead of a 9 member group. it took me awhile to realize who was who in TWICE and then I realize that some members had only 1-2 lines in each song!!! when you have so many members then you will end up with useless members. I am not naming names but there are at least 4 members in TWICE that could form their own group and be successful. And yes, I love Babymonster (7) but I have heard very few lines from 2 of the members since Ahyeon came back. This doenst mean that 2 members are useless but they don't have anything to do!!! The 2 members who have little to do are; Chiquita and Rora. There are many groups that don't utilize their members well, and the reason is because the groups have too many members. I actually like 4 and 5 member groups like G-Idle and Blackpink they have the right amount and they have great stage presence without being cluttered. One example is the 6th or 7th member leaving and you barely notice that they are gone. Look at Jini leaving NMiXX, can you tell? or Kim Garam's absence from Le Sserafim? or even Soojin from G-Idle? If a group continues to be successful with fewer members that means you have excess members. I just prefer a smaller tight knit group.
Some people watch music reaction videos because they want to hear other people's opinion or the UA-camr is really entertaining. The annoying part is when their reactions suck or it lasts a few seconds.
bm just debut and they are not ready as such they have less experience .....what people mean by saying this is that they have a skill set charisma , sp and vocals of course to perform in coachella not that they should sing their 4 song on the coachella stage
I agree that not every idol is meant to go solo. I disagree with them having to be good at everything, some solid skill in one-two areas and solid basics in other are plenty enough and succesful soloist we have today prove it quite well. IU sings great and has good stage presence. Lisa rocks dancing and rapping while having some good singining basics, even if it's not her strength. Of course, there are also plenty of aces like Chungha or Jungkook but even they choose they strenghts wisely and don't force everything all at once. Jungook, being a good rapper, focuses on singing. Chungha, being a great dancer, uses a song like "I'm ready" to show it but for main track - so the one that gets performed live - she chooses easier choreography to highlight the vocals. Also, I think that IVE is a pretty bad example of a group with no soloist potential. Yujin is as promising as they come, Wooyoung already has proven she has what it takes to capture publicity and has a similiar skill set to IU: good vocals eith graceful stage presence and elegant, easy dance moved. Rei, if she works on vocals, potentially could also make for a good soloist with her stage presence and rap. So, as much as I believe there are group with no soloist candidates, IVE is ansolutely not one of them.
I have a little disagreement with your first point on going solo. Yes, not all idol are ready for solo and if you see very few kpop idols are considered SOLOIST like Hwasa, hyuna, yena, chung ha, iu, jungkook and many more. If you see one common thing in all of them is that no matter you are a fan of any other group you have an idea of them and can hum their at least 1 song. It means that they are good and they are doing their job great. And as per your opinion on Jisoo and Lisa i disagree. It might seem like i am just another blink defending blackpink but its more like talking about potential here. Lisa might have weak vocals but she has great stage presence, one of the best in the industry. you cant expect people to be perfect like you said they are also humans and they are alive. Its the balance that of skills that makes them capable. As for Jisoo she might have weak vocal and stage presence but her interaction with her fans is what makes the fan root for her. If they were not capable and people did not prefer to consider their skills then why would they pay thousands of dollars to get to their concert. And for ive its too early to say if they are capable or not. Just because you do not see anyone stand out does not mean they are not capable. Taking example yena is a successful soloist but in group she was not that much visible due to many members and line distributions. hope you get what i mean.
Yeah, I don't like Kookielit either. Their opinion is so biased that it's laughable. They're just a bunch of Itzy and SKZ haters down there, so they don't deserve any respect.
You said not everyone is capable of going solo because they don't have skill I agreed to it but your explanation didn't match what you said. It sounded more like you were rather discussing about the song then bp members ability. If you have issue with the song itself than that has nothing to do with the idols skill. For example you clearly like solo more than on the ground and lalisa but lalisa and on the ground needs more skill to perform. Solo is a simple song with basic vocal and rap and dance. If the idol releases one bad song then next time it can be super good.
lalisa is the most terrible solo song of bp and what she mean is not every idol is build to go solo here too lisa and jisso dont have enough skills to go solo since bith of tgem dont have good vocals thats hy their solos are vey medicoer and unbreable
@@garimasuhani7227 said who. Lalisa is the best. Only chorus could have been better. Raps are chief kiss. So shut your mouth. Lisa and Jisoo both have and they did too. Go cry about it..in fact Lisa has been dancing and singing even before YG. Was A trainee. People like you can only be insecure because you have to uplift your idol and it cannot be without downgrading who you are insecure about .
@@garimasuhani7227 get your facts straight. Lalisa would be the best if not for the chorus. The rap is simply super. Didn't like flowers but does that make jisoo a terrible soloist. Hell no. The song wasn't to my taste but jisoo did her job perfectly. Lisa isn't soloist material 👽 Lisa was the most talented trainee and right now the member being close to Ace. If she got chance to sing more she will support soon too cause she is very close to it. Lisa is the one with the most experience in dancing and singing both. She has been singing and dancing all her life. Even before giving audition for YG. Getting better with each song she featured in.. Lalisa Money Sexy girl Shoong Jisoo killed the stage with all eyes on me. You clearly are chaennie stan who always discredit lisoo.
It was an example. A simple an easy example. As far as I know all did as far as I know they all did great in sales but even if Lisa's songs were viral the songs of Jennie and Rose were the ones that growed better older.
@@belaytriks if you are going to talk about most liked. Then it's money>>>>>> It's so popular among none k pop fans too. Till this date money is fresh as new.
i don't think u need to be good at all the skills to go solo. For example, Lisa from blackpink isn't the most prominent vocalist, yet I could see her thriving in the industry as a soloist because she appeals to the masses. Appealing to the masses and industry is what really matters as the most talented person might not be recognised as a soloist. To appeal to the masses there needs to be a certain thing you excel at+something that makes you unique to a wide audience , especially because of how oversaturated the Kpop/music industry is today. If we look at a group like blackpink, most of the members (probably except jisoo) could thrive as soloists because they have unique qualities that most idols lack.
While I would agree that not every member of a group should go solo, I completely disagree with the statement that a soloist has to be able to do everything. Take (G)I-dle´s Miyeon for example: When she did here solo release she was still terrible at rapping (and I would guess she would never have done it if Soyeon hadn´t forced her to do it in wife), if they perform she is also the most likely to screw up the choreo and here stage presence at least within the group is also on the weaker side. But her solo debut was great and successful because it just focussed on her voice. She doesn´t have to dance around when she performs her songs, all she has to do is sing and that is completely enough.
Agreed like Jeongyeon for example I feel like she could go solo she has the voice for it
Not every soloist is going to be an ace and that's okay
I watch kookielit when i’m curious
(i don’t watch serious stuff, like ab**e or d**th, i mostly just watch stuff abt min heejin and blackpink)
Tbh I just watch reaction videos cuz it validates my feelings on what i feel about the comeback
illit deserve the criticism not hate ...but if does not change the fact that they lack talent and skill and do not deserve to debut especially when they were competing against so many talented contestant hybe is at fault basically for producing idols like chinese factory
I love soo much your videos!I also think that not each member of kpop group need to have solos.
I agree with you half way on the plastic surgery opinion. Me and Yuna are the same age so I think it’s a mix of both hip pads and her just growing up. All my life, I’ve been skinny to the point that my doctor recommended me Ensure because I couldn’t gain nor maintain weight and I’m just now getting curves and gaining some weight at 20 years old. Yuna might be experiencing something similar and she’s most likely using hip pads a lot to accentuate it. But, she could’ve also had plastic surgery. All idols use some type of body enhancement(s) whether surgical or not it’s apart of the job because their selling a fantasy
growing does change jaw stucture lip shape eye shape and basically the whole face and mostly all of idols had some work done and which is fine
Ahhh so let me get this straight. Main vocals with extreme talent but lacking in rap = no solo
main dancers who can rap and dance but sing averagely = no solo
visuals with deserved extra positions = no solo
Rappers with enough talent to knock you off your feet but not too good dancers = no solo
Lmao fr like you don't have to be the full package to be a good soloist, so many don't do it all and still thrive
good video, but I will venture to add something else that annoys me.
Too many members in a group. I will say groups in excess of 5 members they tend to have TOO many members. People will hate me for this but I think that TWICE could be completely functional as a 5 member group instead of a 9 member group. it took me awhile to realize who was who in TWICE and then I realize that some members had only 1-2 lines in each song!!! when you have so many members then you will end up with useless members. I am not naming names but there are at least 4 members in TWICE that could form their own group and be successful.
And yes, I love Babymonster (7) but I have heard very few lines from 2 of the members since Ahyeon came back. This doenst mean that 2 members are useless but they don't have anything to do!!! The 2 members who have little to do are; Chiquita and Rora. There are many groups that don't utilize their members well, and the reason is because the groups have too many members. I actually like 4 and 5 member groups like G-Idle and Blackpink they have the right amount and they have great stage presence without being cluttered.
One example is the 6th or 7th member leaving and you barely notice that they are gone. Look at Jini leaving NMiXX, can you tell? or Kim Garam's absence from Le Sserafim? or even Soojin from G-Idle? If a group continues to be successful with fewer members that means you have excess members.
I just prefer a smaller tight knit group.
Some people watch music reaction videos because they want to hear other people's opinion or the UA-camr is really entertaining. The annoying part is when their reactions suck or it lasts a few seconds.
Stop the way you really don't hate on idols is soo nice, you're the best, I agree with everything slayy girlie
tysm 🥰
bm just debut and they are not ready as such they have less experience .....what people mean by saying this is that they have a skill set charisma , sp and vocals of course to perform in coachella not that they should sing their 4 song on the coachella stage
Talks about kookliet profiting off idols while getting money for hating on bp😂..
I actually don't make money from this 😊 I content create for fun! Hope this helps
I think its high time yeonjun deserve to get a solo
I like reaction channels because I don't have very many friends who like kpop and I'm lonely :| sorry it is what it is
I agree that not every idol is meant to go solo. I disagree with them having to be good at everything, some solid skill in one-two areas and solid basics in other are plenty enough and succesful soloist we have today prove it quite well. IU sings great and has good stage presence. Lisa rocks dancing and rapping while having some good singining basics, even if it's not her strength. Of course, there are also plenty of aces like Chungha or Jungkook but even they choose they strenghts wisely and don't force everything all at once. Jungook, being a good rapper, focuses on singing. Chungha, being a great dancer, uses a song like "I'm ready" to show it but for main track - so the one that gets performed live - she chooses easier choreography to highlight the vocals.
Also, I think that IVE is a pretty bad example of a group with no soloist potential. Yujin is as promising as they come, Wooyoung already has proven she has what it takes to capture publicity and has a similiar skill set to IU: good vocals eith graceful stage presence and elegant, easy dance moved. Rei, if she works on vocals, potentially could also make for a good soloist with her stage presence and rap. So, as much as I believe there are group with no soloist candidates, IVE is ansolutely not one of them.
I have a little disagreement with your first point on going solo. Yes, not all idol are ready for solo and if you see very few kpop idols are considered SOLOIST like Hwasa, hyuna, yena, chung ha, iu, jungkook and many more. If you see one common thing in all of them is that no matter you are a fan of any other group you have an idea of them and can hum their at least 1 song. It means that they are good and they are doing their job great. And as per your opinion on Jisoo and Lisa i disagree. It might seem like i am just another blink defending blackpink but its more like talking about potential here. Lisa might have weak vocals but she has great stage presence, one of the best in the industry. you cant expect people to be perfect like you said they are also humans and they are alive. Its the balance that of skills that makes them capable. As for Jisoo she might have weak vocal and stage presence but her interaction with her fans is what makes the fan root for her. If they were not capable and people did not prefer to consider their skills then why would they pay thousands of dollars to get to their concert. And for ive its too early to say if they are capable or not. Just because you do not see anyone stand out does not mean they are not capable. Taking example yena is a successful soloist but in group she was not that much visible due to many members and line distributions. hope you get what i mean.
Yeah, I don't like Kookielit either. Their opinion is so biased that it's laughable. They're just a bunch of Itzy and SKZ haters down there, so they don't deserve any respect.
They come at every group 😭 super annoying channel I had to press dont recommend
You said not everyone is capable of going solo because they don't have skill I agreed to it but your explanation didn't match what you said. It sounded more like you were rather discussing about the song then bp members ability. If you have issue with the song itself than that has nothing to do with the idols skill. For example you clearly like solo more than on the ground and lalisa but lalisa and on the ground needs more skill to perform. Solo is a simple song with basic vocal and rap and dance. If the idol releases one bad song then next time it can be super good.
lalisa is the most terrible solo song of bp and what she mean is not every idol is build to go solo here too lisa and jisso dont have enough skills to go solo since bith of tgem dont have good vocals thats hy their solos are vey medicoer and unbreable
@@garimasuhani7227 said who. Lalisa is the best. Only chorus could have been better. Raps are chief kiss. So shut your mouth. Lisa and Jisoo both have and they did too. Go cry about it..in fact Lisa has been dancing and singing even before YG. Was A trainee. People like you can only be insecure because you have to uplift your idol and it cannot be without downgrading who you are insecure about .
@@garimasuhani7227 get your facts straight. Lalisa would be the best if not for the chorus. The rap is simply super. Didn't like flowers but does that make jisoo a terrible soloist. Hell no. The song wasn't to my taste but jisoo did her job perfectly.
Lisa isn't soloist material 👽
Lisa was the most talented trainee and right now the member being close to Ace. If she got chance to sing more she will support soon too cause she is very close to it. Lisa is the one with the most experience in dancing and singing both. She has been singing and dancing all her life. Even before giving audition for YG.
Getting better with each song she featured in..
Lalisa
Money
Sexy girl
Shoong
Jisoo killed the stage with all eyes on me.
You clearly are chaennie stan who always discredit lisoo.
It was an example. A simple an easy example. As far as I know all did as far as I know they all did great in sales but even if Lisa's songs were viral the songs of Jennie and Rose were the ones that growed better older.
@@belaytriks if you are going to talk about most liked. Then it's money>>>>>>
It's so popular among none k pop fans too. Till this date money is fresh as new.
every single idol has had surgery 100%
That's not really true. I'd say every idol has had cosmetic procedures done, but not necessarily surgery.
its mostly about the company choice of song and production than anything else..
i don't think u need to be good at all the skills to go solo. For example, Lisa from blackpink isn't the most prominent vocalist, yet I could see her thriving in the industry as a soloist because she appeals to the masses. Appealing to the masses and industry is what really matters as the most talented person might not be recognised as a soloist. To appeal to the masses there needs to be a certain thing you excel at+something that makes you unique to a wide audience , especially because of how oversaturated the Kpop/music industry is today. If we look at a group like blackpink, most of the members (probably except jisoo) could thrive as soloists because they have unique qualities that most idols lack.
Like what😅
Agreed