Are colleges obstructing free speech for Pro-Palestinian student activists? | UpFront
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 кві 2024
- Marc Lamont Hill discusses student activism for Palestine with Columbia University student organiser Maryam Alwan.
As Israel’s war on Gaza persists for over half a year, many university students in the United States have expressed solidarity with Palestinians.
Students at Columbia University set up a Gaza solidarity encampment and have called on the University to sever ties to Israel. Tensions escalated on April 18 after school officials called in police to arrest protesters. Dozens of students faced suspensions and were evicted from campus housing.
Since then, similar protests have sprung up from coast to coast - and they’ve been met with similar crackdowns in the name of safety. Is free speech being threatened at American universities?
This week on UpFront, Marc Lamont Hill talks to Maryam Alwan, an organiser with Columbia Students for Justice in Palestine, about what these students are trying to achieve despite attempts to limit free speech on campus.
USA needs some democracy.
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
We have democracy moron. We invented it.
It's a constitutional Republic, not a democracy.
Education in USA for dollars and power .see Gaza
@@OGKenG It is both.
Now this beautiful young woman is intelligent, cares about humanity and has given up a lot for humanity. Thank you brave young woman❤. You are protesting for me too because I’m disabled and can’t get out, so thank you for that too!
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
Well spoken, my Friend!
islam is lucky there is no camera in khalifa empire. islam is doing big genocide more than israel and no one noticing it
Let Gaza Live ✊ Not In Our Name ✊ STOP ARMING ISRAEL 🪖💰💥
🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑👽👽👽👽👽👽👽👽👽
Tell that to Hamas
@@OGKenG
From their words you shall know them.
Who initiated this mess? The Palestinians of Gaza. If you are Jewish you and some Christians are always willing to sacrifice their faith to feel good. Why Muslim s always stand with other Muslim.
islam is lucky there is no camera in khalifa empire. islam is doing big genocide more than israel and no one noticing it
Since no one is taking any ACTION, but merely TALK endlessly ... the top universities are in ACTION - these are the future heroes of the country - instead of sitting ducks!
Action? They just sit there and scream free Palestine . How does this exactly help Palestinians?
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
@sayjustwordstome Democracy runs on the voice and will of the people. If you do not understand it than you never experienced democracy.
@@sayjustwordstomeIt was student protests EXACTLY like these that ENDED Apartheid in SOUTH AFRICA ....AND ENDED THE VIETNAM WAR! You can fact check. These amazing young people are our future.
@@user-dd2ew4fr8s ABSOLUTELY!
Free USA from AIPAC
CUFI as well
Quran says Israel 🇮🇱 43 times no Palestine in Quran.
We all should stand for innocent helpless kids of Palestine.
It's not Israel. It's Bani-Israel. Lack knowledge @@itachiofthesharingan67
It's not Israel. That's Bani-Israel. Lack of knowledge about Holy Qur-aan ❤@@itachiofthesharingan67
Indeed… the world should start seeing Palestinians as humans
After dragging the country into this mess, where are those Hamas leaders?......gaza's sky is black but qatar is always sunny
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
@@itachiofthesharingan67Your dreams will be not fulfill. Because your dreams are loaded of sin.
@@itachiofthesharingan67🇮🇱👞✡️💩👠🤛🤡👹
@@armaanjain1508 Do not assault them, collect their identities, create a database, and flag them so that they will not be hired by companies or any other institution in the future...
We don't have to worry about "free Palestine" We now have to worry about "free America"
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
I don’t care what you believe. I think if you’re being peaceful and following school guidelines, you deserve to have your say. That’s our right as Americans.
The problem is when they block roads, sidewalks and school building so Jews can’t pass. Suggesting Jews should die, saying you’re Hamas, saying from the river to the sea because of the implication. I mean they’re not saying they want to combine the land and share it with the Jews. It’s suggesting Jewish genocide.
Are you fu**ing serious right now? You’re the problem. You can’t break laws and school rules then cry that your free speech has been taken from you.
You people are just so stupid man I’m done with this.
It's an eye opening for the American citizen to understand the freedom of speech, As democratic leader of the world, and what happens to our tax money,
To me it's worse than North Korea,
WE once claimed Saddam Hussain and Gadafi looted all the citizen wealth, Now
i prefer that some private investigator should check all the elected members assets and bank A/C even at swiss bank,
Example Obama served 2 term, when enter POTUS he had nothing but left office worth 70 million ( 8 years x 400000 (400k) salary=3200000 (3.2 million without tax so where did he get 70 million according to google?
Yes, You are right. Free USA from AIPAC
Free America from radical Islam and communist agitation.
At last the world knows what is going on and on in Palistine .Students are respected .
No they are pathetic clowns
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
Students are the future generations of a country. They should voice out against any injustice in their own country and around the world!
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
Free Palestine Free Speech NOW
Free speech my foot. UT has censored probably over a hundred of my posts. The moment you or your comments start to matter, censorship is there.
Is there any free speech in middle east.
Palestinians aren't welcome
And Americans complained about Russia and Iran 😂🤦🏽♂️
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
And well we should.
then move to Iran Russia no-no but you are still in the USA 🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱👺👺👺👺👺👺
The real Fascists will tell you to leave to country if you don’t agree with them.
@@Matthew_Loutner
Criminals complaining about crimes what an Irony
Good for you Maryam! and good for you Aljazeera
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
Proisrael said in front of media cameras: "We are afraid and feel unsafe about this demonstration😢". but they stood watching and even broke through the pro-Palestinian demonstration😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tell babyface Sinwar to stop the war.
@@JackFieldBandtell nethanyahoo and minions stop killing in west bank. There no Hamas there
@@JackFieldBand
They were afraid of students harm but not afraid to support killing of innocents children and consequences of genocide.....so disgusting they are just heartless.
@@JackFieldBand
From their words you shall know them
Start calling things by their right name. Do not call it "war in Gaza." It is "genocide in Palestine. "
Please tell me where the country of Palestine is located. I can't find it on any map.
@@OGKenG Feigning ignorance does not exonerate you. By your comment you just demonstrated you believe in genocide. This is due to your lack of conscience, the main defect which is the hallmark of your tribe. Read Franz Kafka's "The Trial."
The first known mention of Peleset is at the Medinet Habu temple, which refers to the Peleset among those who fought against Egypt during Ramesses III's reign, and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. The Assyrians called the same region "Palashtu/Palastu" or "Pilistu," beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to an Esarhaddon treaty more than a century later. Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term. Whilst these inscriptions are often identified with the Biblical Pəlīštīm, i.e. Philistines, the word means different things in different parts of the Bible. The 10 uses in the Torah have undefined boundaries and no meaningful description, and the usage in two later books describing coastal cities in conflict with the Israelites - where the Septuagint instead uses the term "allophuloi" (Αλλόφυλοι, "other nations") - has been interpreted to mean "non-Israelites of the Promised Land".
The term Palestine first appeared in the 5th century BCE when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories. Herodotus provides the first historical reference clearly denoting a wider region than biblical Philistia, as he applied the term to both the coastal and the inland regions such as the Judean Mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley. Later Greek writers such as Aristotle, Polemon and Pausanias also used the word, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus. There is no evidence of the name on any Hellenistic coin or inscription.
In the early 2nd century CE, the Roman province called Judaea was renamed Syria Palaestina[a] (literally, "Palestinian Syria"), and also incorporated some other, smaller, territories. This may have occured either before or after the suppression of the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135.
@@OGKenGplease read a book 🙄🙄🙄
@@MK67934
I did read some books. Still can't find a country named Palestine.
Poor Palestinians. Power and money is against them.
A Nation doesn’t last in scope Of Gun or powe or money its only Last on Ideas Beyond intellectuals and critical thinking that's what's happening in Western streeth and üniversities
Short answer: Yes they are. We pretty much have Free Speech on anything in the US except anything negative involving a certain country in the Middle East.
“ students United “❤ students around the world
We need your support, we need your voice
Humanity depends on you
Future depends on you
You are the Guardians of future, not the past !!!
What a beautiful brave intelligent young woman. Impressive
Quite inspirational listening the students' viewpoints for their campus movement ❤😂 Keep up protesting..
Should be horrible to live in a non democratic country... so sad... 😢
The United States INVENTED modern democracy moron.
This is a constitutional republic. Get it right.
@@OGKenG Dude. You are telling people who live in foreign countries to "get it right."
@@Matthew_Loutner
If they don't live here, why are they commenting on something they don't know about? Maybe keep their fingers off the keyboard until they learn reality, ok?
A constitutional Republic is a form of democracy. 🤦♂️
I hope all these students remember the politicians speaking against the protest in November on Election Day.
These students can't think past the current hot button topic. They can't even pick out the country of Palestine on a map, can they?
Of course they're going to remember! I take these students and their opinions more seriously than 90% of the comments on this subject. These students have done their research, educated themselves on the issues including prior to October 7, they analyze issues in multiple dimensions. And they have values, morals, concern for others that rise above their own individualistic interests, that should be commended.
@@OGKenG 'OG'..the arrogance, hey? Are you a Zionist? Just checking, similar attitude, arrogant, superiority..
By all means, you have the floor, share with us all your superior wisdom, knowledge, oh, great one?
When you know what you’re doing is right, and you’re being punished for doing what is morally correct, something is terribly wrong.
That’s the whole world presently😢
Thank you, good reporting.
Brave students speaking for those without a voice. I’m proud of you.
Hamas has a voice. WTF are you talking about?
As long as there are human loving people in this world, such protest will continue against Israel's Genocide in Gaza with the help of US.
Tell babyface Sinwar to stop the war.
@@JackFieldBand
its amazing to see , there is no protests happening in Saudi Arabia , Qatar , UAE and Egypt , No Arab nation is willing to help Hamas
islam is lucky there is no camera in khalifa empire. islam is doing big genocide more than israel and no one noticing it
Israel is our western brother and that will never change. Stop trying to destroy the western world. @@jhegre
Free Palestine
Free Gaza from Hamas.
Free Gaza Free Speech
Palestine the exception for free speech!!!
Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 Will be Free
No such place as Palestine.
This is free country.
I do not understand why the 🇺🇸 government insists on sending a person such as the 🇺🇸 Secretary of State to Israel to work on completing a deal, and he has not succeeded in a single mission since the war began. Why do they insist on a person who has proven his failure every time? And not only that, but he has made matters worse?! The answer is simple because he is personally the one obstructing the deal
It is just for show. Just like the U.S. talking about a 2 state solution. They have never wanted a 2 state solution. If they did we would have had a 2 state solution decades ago.
Maybe his mission is to make them fail unless Hamas surrenders unconditionally.
Building a tent city on a nice lawn and harassing Jewish students has nothing to do with "free speech".
Indeed
No, elaborate more, please? I could argue with you that the law enforcement aggression against the protesters is unjustified, excessive and an attempt to subjugate one's right to free speech.
Where were all these police and there aggression when Trumps mob stormed the capital building, incited by Trump and his media allies...
Merely ordinary folks are being targeted in Gaza residential area❤❤
Salam Salam to all the brave students of America Europe
Senators must be investigated for AIPAC links
Since no one is taking any ACTION, but merely TALK endlessly ... the top universities are in ACTION - these are the future heroes of the country
Hey Marc,is this the Vietnam moment? Watching in South Africa.
As an American, yeah, it is
Overwhelmingly peaceful protests.
🤣👍
*It's time to raise all your Voices against extreme brutality of Israel on Palestinian innocent children, helpless women 🇵🇸✊ If you remain silence then you're not human.*
You are not human.
In the present world there is freedom of speech,but freedom is not guaranteed after speech...
In this country you are guaranteed free speech but you are not guaranteed to be free of the consequences of your speech.😉
@@socaljarhead7670 freedom of speech but no freedom after speech...got It.
Free Free Free Philistine ❤❤❤❤
No no thanks.
Free the US from Israel too. This is what these kids are doing too
So proud of these students, keep the faith.
Saya akan terus mendukung anda,walau dalam sebait doa ❤
Yes. Next question.
AIPIG has to go!
Absolutely and they are using violence to do so
Keep up the great work protesting❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🇨🇦
So many languages, and she decided to speak Facts.
Congratulations to all the student Heros for standing against Genocide❤.
We all human and deserve better. Don’t treat me different because I live different place in the world.
It clearly states in the university rules that demonstration is protected activity
Thank you for standing up for humanity & justice 🙏
😂 good one
Why the migrant students blame democratic countries for the political issues/ decision? Why there are no University worth the name in their own countries where students can pursue a quality education?
Qatar talking about democracy 😂😂😂
"We are all judged by what we do at home and not what we say abroad.”
What a wonderful young woman x the youth is our hope x stay blessed
Sack columbia president, she is a disgrace
Ceasefire now..... ceasefire now....🇮🇳✍️
Very well stated young lady....
No it is mainly to prevent illegal encampment on private university grounds. They to leave but the students did not comply.
Thank you Meryem...❤
Is there free Speech in Qatar, Saudi Arabia? 😂
I strongly condemned those who crubing free speech and freedom of expression
You must hate hamas
If they hit you and you said ouch!- they’d acuse you of antisemitism.
The self-proclaimed "home of democracy."
America, Land of the free. Yep looks like democracy is alive and well here.
Land of the free has-been a lie now exposed for all to see. Thank u zion
So sad . So helpless these students
People need to understand what is free speech and what is not free speech
If we like what you are saying then it is free speech
If we don't like what you are saying then it is not free speech , it is antisemitism
You guys are peace full..
A freedom movement need to start in US to implement real democracy where everyone able to condemned crime against humanity committed by anyone.
The plural of campus is campi, isn't it?
The police brutality here is worst than HK.
Police State breaking up peaceful protest violates Constitutional right
It is time for alternative universities to be considered since the current ones are compromised and seems that the government wants only one particular group to have a voice.
POWER TO THE STUDENTS.
These student are the hope of America, even of the world. They are the breath "Freedom" dont let corruption throttle them
They ate the Hitler youth
Free Speech and Free Hate Speech are 2 different things
If they understood what peaceful protest meant & understood that they need permits sometimes. They can’t block roads/highways/bridges, etc.
BB's MO: Divide & Conquer.
Current Stateside op: Terminate With Extreme Prejudice all free speech and assembly
that deviates from BB's agenda.
In the US, that means: Total Acquiescence (to all BB's programs and pogroms).
In Gaza: Total Victory (= Final Solution).
Speak now and forever defend your tongue.
They (USA & Police) must obey their Master in I5rael
Thank you to the students who are making a sacrifice their own future to be a voice for the voiceless.
🌎❣️🇵🇸🌎❣️🇵🇸🌎❣️🇵🇸🌎❣️🇵🇸🌎❣️🇵🇸🌎
you are future leaders and will bring peace and justice to the Palestinian people. inshaAllah
I’m a Jewish woman married to an Arab woman. I wish people can share a balanced and equal relationship like we do. We don’t fight fiercely, we kiss fiercely. 🫂🤼♀️
What does it mean😮
Yuck!
That is very sweet. :)
Did you have a North Korean child...
@@ponzitizen And is it transgender?
Thanks a lot who raised their voices against BRUTALITY & GEN😢CIDE.
She is absolutely right about
Media's & some Hypocrites conspiracy against this peaceful movement.
Peaceful protests are not illegal 😊
But they're not very peaceful...
@@JackFieldBand only after the police start roughing people up
@@smokindauberdoo4208
Yes. That was and is horrible !
@@JackFieldBand
@@JackFieldBand According to the chief of police the were 100% peaceful...
God Bless Them ! FREE PALESTINE ! 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️
I stand with these students! ✊️🇵🇸👍
Great intervier
Netanyahu is the President of the United States of America and Israel at the same time 🤔
Imagine Al Jazeera...commenting on free speech...that word doesn't exist in the vocabulary of arabs!😅
What an amazing young woman!! 🌻
WHOLE YOUNG GENERATION AND STUDENTS FROM WESTERN COUNTRIES ARE BEING APPRECIATED ON GHAZZAH ISSUE BY ALL MODERATE INTERNATIONAL WORLD.... ZINDABAAD ❤
Her Parents should Very Proud of her Principals and Integrity 🙏🏽
She is American. I imagine her parents support Israel and are ashamed of her.
(And they should be.)
Thank you Al Jazeera for the TRUTH!
😂😂😂
They are messing with the wrong generation.
What are the investments?
US Democracy??
Innocent people are being harassed
Yes
The 1st amendment only applies to congress . It’s the first five words
Netanyahu spoke and crackdown started.!
Coincidence?!
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
I learn cool words today