Texas Bowline
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 вер 2024
- This is a knot that I recently taught myself after having learning the Speir Knot from another channel. I changed that knot slightly, resulting in an altogether different knot. Having searched for this knot in various different publications, I was unable to locate it. I have decided to call this knot the Texas Bowline. However, if it is found to have been previously published, I will gladly edit this video to include the given name for this knot.
Hey Ben, you might appreciate this. If the Speir Loop is crossloaded it pops the knot structure into a Slipped Buntline ... your Texas Bowline collapses to a Slipped Cow Hitch. The Kalmyk does not collapse as the Eskimo Bowline works best under crossloading & also maintains structure with loading along the working-line-to-loop-end axis. In most cases unlikely a problem.
This is great ! I was able to collapse the knots as you describe, thanks for figuring this out. But I'm not sure about the "mechanics of collapse" yet. It's not really about cross-loading the loops: You sometimes need to pull on the standing end and one side of the loop (at least for one of knots, I'm not sure about the other). Have you experimented with this?
@@stephanddd That's right. The failure can be a combination of forces including cross loading & dynamic load line tension. Note that when the knot structure begins to fail, placing tension between the load line and each side of the loop will leave you either with a slip-knot version or with an unsecure granny knot-like structure - two versions of the same collapsed structure. Regardless, while for many noncritical uses Speir-type knots will likely work okay, I'm just unlikely to trust them for important tasks ... which means I probably won't bother use them at all. Already have too many knots in the toolbox.
@@JohnGreen_US Yes I can see how the "regular" Speir knot has an alternate collapse as a granny knot. Interesting. But same here, I enjoy tying the kalmyk loop if I ever need a quick-release fixed loop.
Seeing how they collapse, can't say I would call them bowline variations
Thank you for this information. I'll just master the kalmyk instead
Multitools and tying knots - love the educational knot tying! This is my first Texas Bowline that my 68 year old hand accomplished but not expertly! Idle hands bring on the devil's work - keep teaching! Mahalo!
Having tied the bowline for 65 years after learning it as a "one handed bowline" when a child, I will probably stay with it or the slippery version.
I have recently mastered the Zeppelin loop knot after having tied the Zeppelin bend for over 40 years. Whenever I encounter a 3 strand twisted lay rope with frayed ends, it is gifted an eye splice and a back splice to enjoy til the end of its days.
Very nice educational and informative video. Keep it up! 🤩
Also, enjoying the comments of people who tested the knots.
As John Green as suggested, these knots are not secure. I tested these knots, (albeit in their non-slipped versions with thinner rope to understand the underlying knot) and I found out they they collapse into other (cinching) knots. I would not include them in the bowline family. I feel like a bowline-type knot should strictly have a sheet bend in it. These do not, and so I personally would not trust them, but everyone should do their own due diligence. I'm a fan of your videos though, thanks! keep it up.
> I would not include them in the bowline family.
Agree! They do not stand up to any cross-loading as the bowline does.
Once I was able to sit at my work bench and practice this once or twice, I really like it. It will be a definite go to for loops around standing objects. Thanks for the information and the video.
Thx for this video. I do not want to spoil your Texas node in any way, but, as a matter of fact, it is just a Reef knot with a back bite ! Sorry for that, I am sure you will discover another one soon. Keep knotting, Cheers !
Just to note, in this video, you demoed turning the Speir knot loop backwards, and the Texas Bowline loop forwards. But in your Speir knot video, you also turned the loop forwards. I love the way you explain knots, and have adopted many of them. Thank you so much.
(Oh, I see that the Speir knot video is now "Speir Knot - Modified". Nevermind.)
Nice thanks
Esp for defining parts of knots
Hi Ben,
Just an unnecessary bit of additional info: in Russian the Speir knot is often called "."Firefighter's knot" (пожарный узел). It is used to quickly attach a rope for descending. I wouldn't call it a very secure knot, it is good when the load is static and only in one direction.
Another great video , Ben have you thought of Modifying one of your multitools by adding a small Marlin Spike Implement?
Thanks for this great knot. I find it dramatically easier to tie this from the opposite direction. In other words, simply pass the working end *over* the standing end, let it go, and grab the standing end of the loop *from the top*, then dip down and grab the bight. Isn't that so much easier?
That is a slipped thief knot, with one of the thief knot's working ends used as the standing part here. Make an unslipped version of your knot (pull the working end completely through instead of a bight in the last step), then pull apart the two loop parts, and it'll become obvious.
I'll stick to the Kalmyk...
This "new" knot is, as you said, a slipped thief knot: The Ashley Book Of Knots #1207
The Spier knot is super fast to tie and comes undone easilly. It is not secure under heavy loads.
I appreciate the video, but I'm still not sure which knot to use and which knot not to use. I am also uncertain which nautical knots I should not use in place of non-nautical knots I should use.
I imagine this is a very important distinction as it relates to tow boats. When travelling at various knots, which nautical knots should not, and should be, used.
I would recommend sticking to The Ashley Book Of Knots #71 (*The* Bowline.)
Just a thought maby a video on cleaning and mantince on multitools anyway love your videos👍
Great knot, thanks.
Subscribe because you pronounce bowline correctly
Thanks!
Would this Texas Bowline be appropriate to use when pulling a vehicle out of a ditch with another vehicle (perhaps connecting two trailer ball hitches)? Or would it bind up? What is the best knot to use in that instance??
No, this is a light duty knot. Best for your application is the Zeppelin Loop.
Hey thanks for replying. I followed your advice!! 😊
@@SMart7751 you’re very welcome.
As someone who never learned knots or really worked with rope before your channel is an amazing source of information. A question : Do you have a go-to knot for quickly tying bundles of things for transport? I've been working with a lot of cables/ropes/extension cords lately and haven't found a knot that's easy for a newbie like myself to remember that doesn't come undone from jostling.
Thanks!
I don't remember if Ben has this way of tying up rope, but there is a great guy from Georgia who's channel name is reallybigmonkey1 . He is a bushcrafter/ camper who has a great way to bundle rope so you can use as much as you need and the rest is still bundled. I don't know how to send links , I am a low tech kinda fella. Lol. But I use his method with rope and long extention cords. Hope this helps you
@@johndalessandro6433 Thank you for the tip, I'll check it out.
Canadian jam knot is a good one for bundles it's pretty easy to tie too
@@manbearpigno1 Thanks, I'll take a look!
Ashley Book of Knots, 1060, Variations harness loop knot.
Do you mean #1060 or page 1060? Because ABoK #1060 is a bight knot based on an overhand knot. Which doesn't seem related to this: slipped thief's knot that TXTC has "discovered".
Buenísimo felicitaciones!!!!
Good work
A Kalmyk knot without a bow is called a Cossack knot. Compare Eskimo with a bow and Kalmyk with a bow (return loop). You will see that the Eskimo Bowline does not disintegrate right away. And Kalmyk (by the way, it is also called Kozatsky, Evensky) disintegrates immediately.
That’s incorrect. The non-slipped version of the Kalmyk Loop is the Eskimo Bowline, not the Cossack.
@@txtoolcrib tie these two knots and you will see the difference. This is like the Dutch and English version of the bowline, but for the Kossak knot and the Eskimo bowline there is a fundamental difference. Try. This is interesting. Well, for the Kalmyk knot there is an authentic way of its formation
@@txtoolcrib You are wrong. The Dutch bowline and the English bowline are, in principle, the same in their functional features. But the Eskimo bowline and the Cossakc knot are two completely different knots, although they are looked similar. Tie it up. Check it out. You will see. In Kazakhstan, the Kalmyk knot is called by its own name, by the way.
Double-bowline with a "bite"(1:19) is what I use
Excellent
How would you tie to an object such as a tree or a post from the middle of a rope without using the ends of the rope?
Bowline on a bight.
Ben - Well! I guess you CAN teach an old scout new tricks!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
That’s awesome
siberian hitch
Kalmyck Loop
Totally different
Thanks!
Thank you very much