Everybody Hates Gwyneth Paltrow
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
- Gwyneth Paltrow's wellness routine went viral and Tess Holliday and Abbey Sharp lost their minds.
Today we're going to talk about Gwyneth Paltrow's viral interview with the Dear Media podcast, where she shared her wellness routine that includes bone broth, a paleo diet and simple intermittent fasting.
I didn't think much about it - but the internet went wild, including plus-size model and fat activist Tess Holliday and internet media dietician Abbey Sharp. Their responses were so off the wall that I just had to make a video.
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 - Everybody Hates Gwyneth
0:56 - Gwyneth Paltrow's Wellness Routine
2:01 - Abbey Sharp's Reaction
11:21 - Tess Holliday's Reaction
~*~
✉️ Send me a Video Suggestion! ✉️
geni.us/video-suggestions
💬 Join me on Discord! 💬
geni.us/join-our-discord
👀 Check out our subreddit! 👀
/ kianadocherty
⭐️ GET MY GUIDE! ⭐️
How to Change: A Guide to Breaking Bad Habits and Getting Motivated
Get it here: kdocherty.com/how-to-change-p...
🤓 MY RECOMMENDED BOOK LIST 🤓
geni.us/kiana-book-list
💖 FOLLOW ME! 💖
IG: / kianadocherty
TikTok: / kianadocherty
Reddit: / kianadocherty - Розваги
The fact that Tess Holiday thinks she has ANY right to comment someone else's diet is mind blowing!
And her jealousy is so dang obvious.
Yes, it's mind blowing.
exactly, plus, you can tell based on how people react to "I often have bone broth for lunch" who does and doesn't do their own cooking. There is a mile of difference between home cooked bone broth and store bought broth that that difference can be hundreds of calories, good calories, and nutrition. I don't think Paltrow ever said "I warm up a cup of tyson chicken broth and call it a day"
Amazing how fat positivity people are all "food does not have moral value - all food is good food!" and then the second they see someone eating a vegetable they call that person a scourge on society for "encouraging unhealthy eating"
Exactly. And also since no-one else can comment on her at all.
Gwyneth Paltrow is 50 years old and Abby Sharp is concerned that intermittent fasting will affect her fertility?
OMG, thank you!!!! When I was 35 with a 7 year old I side eyed people that asked me when I was going to get remarried and have more kids. I’m now 46, and I still get asked! 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️
She is promoting starvation, tf you are on
Abbey Sharp couldn't conceive naturally herself either, but dares to comment on others' reproductive health.
lol ya I was confused not that too, happy I'm not the only one doing a double take.
Yeah, that was confusing af. I don't think Gwyneth wants another Baby and if she does, she has the money to find another way
Tess also posted about this on her Instagram and I was SHOCKED to see that so many of her fans called Gwyneth “saggy” and “old looking” and Tess actually commented “hahaha!”
Whatever happened to all bodies are beautiful and not shaming other women?
They love beauty standards when they can fit them.
I agree with you. But many like Tess are hypocrites.
I’ve noticed some peoples narratives are limited to those who conform. Pitiful. Rather circular, and they don’t see the limitations in their own behavior shunning those who choose different lifestyle nonetheless looking a little different too
They are garbage people.
Tess should lose weight.
"People in the Palaeolithic died young, therefore we should eat processed food" is a hilarious shortcut.
The whole "People in the Palaeolithic died young" argument against the Paleo Diet is beyond stupid and ridiculous. They died young because they did not have homes that had Plumbing and Heating in them, and they did not have things like medicine and hospitals filled with different medical equipment.
Right??? I laughed so hard with your comment.
she never said we should eat processed food, where did you pull that out from?
@@Bimtorbacisi actually, Abbey quite literally does say that we should all eat processed food. If you don't do it you have orthorexia according to her. Wild take and extremely unprofessional for a dietician
@@i.c.3300 yeah that’s definitely a heavy message with her. She literally has videos shaming people for being conscious of reading nutrition labels and not wanting processed foods in their home
I'm also confused by Abbey Sharp's response. It's weird to see a dietitian shame someone who is speculated to have an eating disorder.
Especially when the dietitian is also in recovery for ED herself. Of all people she should know better!
Her content is consistently trash
Because she isn't a dietitian anymore, at least not mainly, she's an influencer, that means
views > real advice.
Yes totally
The minute she did a video on Dr. Dray, I stopped watching her videos...
Hot take: it’s not healthy to be super obese and it’s not healthy to be severely underweight. If someone establishes a diet where they remain healthy and active, then who gives a crap. Paltrow’s suggestions aren’t for everyone. Tess’s suggestions aren’t for everyone. Abbey’s suggestions aren’t for everyone. Nuance is vastly important. Jfc.
YES. This is very important because for example, intermittent fasting just comes natural for me as well as calorie counting. So when I see Abbey getting triggered over these things that helped me to lose weight and thus become healthier, I just roll my eyes.
Tess’s suggestions aren’t for anyone.
THANK YOU. My thoughts EXACTLY.
But what she said she ate (even though hopefully she left some things out and should have been encouraged by the doctor to expand a bit) was far too few calories for an averagely active woman. That was absolutely clear. They should have been more clear about exactly what they were talking about, and not that this is all she eats in a day.
Goop = Poop 😮💨
People saying she’s “shrivelled up” - she’s effing 50 yrs old and she’s letting herself age semi naturally. The shrivelling people are seeing is wrinkles. And sure if you have more body weight then your face fills out a bit more, but being thin does not necessitate an ed. she has always naturally had a thin figure.
Psh! Wrinkles aren't part of the toxic beauty culture like fat is! Wrinkles are actually evil unlike fatness. Why are you calling me fat anyway, whore?
(Sarcasm just to be clear)
Virgie Tovar is 40 and she looks like she could be gwyneths eccentric aunt.
True
Funny thing is that if she actually listed everything she ate in a day people would still be upset. It’s a lose lose situation for her.
People hate this most of all because a woman as slim as Gwenth Paltrow would obviously eat less calories than the average viewer.
I mean she kinda earned public hate for all her goop scams. Now its turn of Abbey Sharp for all the pro fat anti slim hate she is mongering
I really find it wild that Abby discounts paleo because of shortened lifespans that had more to do with infant mortality, disease, war and famine than actual diet.
Right? Like who’s gonna tell her that it wasn’t processed food that saved us, it was penicillin 😂
RIGHT?!?? That rang a bell right away when I heard it. Shocking!!!!!
Exactly. She doesn't know that it based on AVERAGE lifespan. As in so many kids died before the age of 5 that it brought the average down. She needs to learn what a mathematical average is. What an idiot.
This whole "eating like our ancestors" thing is very vague anyway. Which time and region of the world are we talking about?
For real! The water wasn’t even clean!!
‘Two women with EDs project their insecurities onto a third, weird, woman’ would have been a good title for this video too. (Even though Holiday is clearly lying about the ED she has)
Honestly that would have been the title if this was a Michelle McDaniel video lol 😂😂😂
Tess has an Ed, not anorexia but possibly BED. But she will never admit that and use the opportunity to actual be a role mode because it doesn’t fit her agenda.
@@aishwaryasivakumar8525 In hindsight I should have put ‘lying about which ED she has’ for greater clarity.
I agree entirely with your assessment of the matter.
I know ED stands for eating disorder, but I keep thinking of erectile dysfunction.
she still has a ed it's just not An0. She is overweight, and the only way to get that is by overeating which is a ed.
I used to be a nanny for a kid that HAD to eat paleo! He had terrible allergic reactions if he had anything outside of it. He’d get stomachaches and his entire body would ache and he would just cry for hours. Paleo isn’t “bullshit,” Abby just needs to get a grip!
paleo is not a balanced diet and is not supported by science and certainly is not suitable for children. If that kid had genuine allergies he needed a tailor made diet by a registered pediatric dietician from a children's hospital.
Sorry but one kid's specific medical condition doesn't provide support for the efficacy of a diet on the general population. If my sister eats shrimp, she will die. That has nothing to do with your shrimp habits.
@@callie8007 eggbrain bc op didn’t say that you’re just making you’re own words
@@Divinebabalon OP argued that the paleo diet is legitimate because some kid had an allergy. That doesn't mean the paleo diet is effective. It just means they nannied a kid with an allergy.
Paleo diet has been around since 1979!!! Mainly developed because scientists had seen a huge increase in obesity and health issues in tribal people exposed to western diets. So yep for many there is a long history that this diet works
Influencer: "I try to eat a balanced diet with plenty of fruits and vegetables."
Abby Sharp: "DISORDERED EATING!!"
Influencer: *Glances at the mirror*
Abby: "BODY CHECKING!!!"
So tired of her.
Yep Abbey is still deep in her eating disorder...
“I’m not going to judge”. Then proceeds to judge - Tess Holiday
The hypocrisy makes me so angry
It's in the same vein as "No offense but..." before going full offensive.
This is what Kiana is doing
I'll still subscribe to her, but she judges fat ppl with much less, suddenly when it's a skinny ppl video she doesn't want to jump to conclusions 💀💀💀💀
@Akushi Bluepaws Creations kiana is a hypocrit too
Tess Holiday wants to "cancel" someone for not eating how she does... yet who can forget even one time of watching Tess eating massive amounts of food? She wants to be left alone to do as she pleases. She needs to offer the same basic respect to others.
YES!!! THIS!!!
And I'm sick and tired of her still claiming she has anorexi* .
Every comment she made was just a projection of what she does. Talking about spreading health misinformation and then concern trolling about her diet. That's what someone with no self awareness looks like.
She just wants to feel ok being obese so bad. But she can't.
She's basically has Amber's mentality imo 😊
I followed Abbey for a long time after I had a baby and was struggling with postpartum body image. She is so abrasive but tries to disguise it as cutesy sass. I appreciate that she tries to put a more scientific/research-based mindset out there but… she doesn’t seem like someone I’d want to be friends with. She seems like someone that would be nice to your face while talking massive amounts of shit behind your back.
Also: I love it when you swear, Kiana 😅😂
OMG YES. That is why she always seemed "off" to me!!
I don't think she promotes science anymore. She seems to have gotten aboard the "health at every size" train. She comes across as a grifter.
For someone who claims to be anorexic, Tess really had the audacity to criticize someone most likely is actually anorexic
Ikr! If she really was anorexic, she would know that skinny shaming someone with an ED and telling them they’re not eating enough is, to many people with EDs, like complimenting their disordered behavior.
I honestly don't know and so am asking; is it possible to be overweight an anorexic? I know bulimia or binge/purge ED can cause obesity, but I thought the hallmark of anorexia was underweight?
@FairbrookWingates you can be overweight and anorexic, it's called atypical anorexia, however, most people just don't believe tess holliday specifically
@@hiitsjasper Thank you for the answer.
@@FairbrookWingates I'd like to add that atypical anorexia still involves weight loss, so if overweight people have it for long enough, they should eventually cease to be overweight. In most cases, it's just an effect of developing restrictive behaviors when you happen to be at a higher starting weight.
I am so tired of attacking food choices in either direction. People want “thin” and “health” banned but 10,000 calorie cheat meals or full days of eating only candy and processed food is considered self care and love. What happened to health at every size ? If Gooper Gwen wants to be 100 lbs then isn’t that a size and therefore healthy. It’s literally in the title of your movement.
Goop = Poop 😮💨
Exactly. Some of this fast food shouldn’t even be considered food. But I guess cuz it tastes good it’s supposed to be self care.
"then isn't that a size and therefore healthy?" THIS. HAES only claims health when it fits their narrative 🙄🤦🏼♀️
SO TRUE
People need to understand self love isn't just about doing whatever you want to do, but what you need. Sometimes that means getting a milkshake and a massage, or having nothing but hot soup, or cutting out a toxic relationship, or going to the gym even though you hate it, or going to a party to fight your social anxiety and depressioon because you haven't seen your friends in weeks. Not the commodofied version the beauty industry is trying to sell us
I used to be down with Abby Sharp but wow, she's condescending. Kiana, thank you for your *actually* balanced take on this.
honestly, Abbey has always rubbed me the wrong way. Even when she was saying some accurate stuff, there was something that just didn't sit well with me. I think that this video made me realize what about her was bothering me.
She lies about what she eats. If you eat like she she claims to and work out like she claims to, you will be 250lbs minimum.
@@samanthaecotothermia7896 I figured Abbey’s content is geared to people with food restriction disorders. She’s completely absurd in how she nitpicks careful eaters even though there’s many physical disorders that demand you cut off certain foods. She acts like the whole world is anorexic sufferers who should eat whatever they intuit and absolutely should never worry about weight gain.
@@jakestroll6518 yeah I think this is the problem. People with those EDs need to hear diets being called stupid. But to the rest of us she comes across like a super patronising know it all.
@@jakestroll6518 I was watching Obese to Beast and he made a good point that in order to eat intuitively you need to know what calories and nutrients are in your food. Kiana gave the example of cutting out carbs to see how it felt. She learned from that . Now she is more mindful and possibly a more intuitive eater because of it.
Abbey Sharpe has been driving me insane for a while now. Also someone who used to watch her a lot and it was helpful for a time, but now she’s so judgmental, so condescending, and anyone who doesn’t eat like her is “wrong”. If someone eats a highly processed carb product with no nutritional value that’s fine, but god forbid someone eat red meat in any capacity.
Right!
I've been waiting for someone to do a deep dive on Abbey. Either she was always a rageaholic and hid it well, or she's become mentally unwell from all her time online. Despite her age she reminds me of insecure teenagers who need to get off of tiktok but refuse to.
@@kimberlyji-young555 data male did it! It’s really good
This!
She is trying to cater to TikTok kids. If you have a diet , your fatphobic. If you mention calories, you’re a horrible person.
Abbey Sharp is such a bully. I watched this clip and never once thought she only eats bone broth for lunch, she's really tall and naturally thin, she's been the same weight for years and is not dramatically losing weight. I fast until noon too and quite enjoy a 2 meal a day plan, it works for me.
Due to a chronic pain condition and the need to take pain meds on a TOTALLY empty stomach, I used to fast for 20+ hours every single day so my meds would work. I'd eat one huge meal after my meds kicked in then go to bed. Lived that way for years. Abbey has no idea what she's talking about most of the time and accuses people of body checking in almost every video. God forbid people look at themselves on camera.
I fast due to religious reasons , all muslims fast once a year for a whole month (unless you are physically ill or have to travel , sick , on your period ... ect.) from dawn until sunset , so we all have an ED ?!
Finally. I think Abby is delusional
Perhaps someone should explain to Tess that simply saying, "I'm not judging anyone," doesn't erase the judgment you are about to spew.
Same goes for Abbey. Abbey is constantly like "I'm not SAYING she has an eating disorder, buuuut..."
4:02 “Paleo protein whatever the fuck that means.”
It means chicken, beef, pork, or fish basically any food usually thought of as protein.
Lol right, that was such a silly statement for her to make.
I think she meant "I don't know what Paleo means, and I am NOT going to spend five seconds finding out." I also thinks she believes that saying "Whatever the fuck that means" lets her audience know that it's "nonsense."
Right. Imagine claiming to be a dietician and not understanding what paleo protein means. I’m guessing she’s now a vegan.
Yes, the paleo diet has been around forever lol. I know she knows what that means
Yeah Abby, it means meat
I agree that women seemed to be judged way more about our diets. I've literally had coworkers come up to me at lunch and make inappropriate comments about what I was eating, and how much I was eating. I've never seen this happen to male coworkers. I got so sick of people making intrusive and disrespectful comments about my lunches and diet that I stopped eating in the lunchroom and just eat at my desk so I can enjoy my meals in peace.
Pure envy, no doubt. They don´t want you to success. Projecting on you their own lacks
@pichichipichi That's a lot of built up, internal animosity causing people to play 20 questions about someone's lunch while they're trying to enjoy a meal and a few quiet moments in peace 🙄
@@JennyFB1281 Well, the office is one of the natural breeding grounds of the "shit-stirrer". People who are bored with their own lives so they get a little excitement from gossip, tearing someone else down about something physical, or encouraging/having affairs. Sometimes it's not blatant (the passive aggressive types are the most irritating, the blunt ones are easier to avoid because you know what's coming and can shut them down or leave). I've encountered a few of those; they never left the mean girls' clique in high school in their head. It's one of the reasons I hate office gigs and one break room setups.
Exactly, he asked: what is your wellness routine? Then she answered: fastening at night, bone broth, greens... and following a non inflammatory diet. What the other people heard??!! I'm from a Mediterranean country, I'm over 50 and I follow this kind of wellness routine. I haven't had an eating disorder in my life and I couldn't feel better!
Ugh, I freaking can't stand Gwyneth 99.9% of the time, but I agree with your take on this. She said a thing, people went mad. Let's go back to critiquing the ACTUAL inaccurate and dangerous and manipulative stuff she (and her company) says and let the girl eat what she wants
the amount of people that agree Gwyneth is a crazy lady but have to defend her right now because she didnt even do anything wrong this time
Ngl if GP released an April fools ‘day in the life’ where she started the day with a big gulp and taquito, I would live.
lmfao i'd love to see that too - she'd probably explode though
"Foods that would kill Gwyneth Paltrow in 10 seconds."
Bahahahaha that would be awesome
That would be heckin hilarious 😂
Lmao! Maybe next year
as a recovered anorexic it honestly hurts to have what i and many other people go through downplayed by tess. anorexia isn't just hating your body and eating less. most people go through that. anorexia is a sickness an obsession. it can be (and was for me) heart attacks, brain damage, and seeing life through a narrow tunnel. i hate when people say u don't have to be underweight to be anorexic. u don't have to be underweight to have an eating disorder, but anorexia is very complicated and severe and i'm not gatekeeping anything i just think the disorder deserves to be talked about for what it really is and the term shouldn't be used so loosely. it's like just being a little sad and coming out as suicidal.
I agree it sucks to have someone downplay anorexia, and congratulations on recovering :) but I feel like it’s worth mentioning that atypical anorexia exists, and you absolutely can be anorexic but not be underweight, because atypical anorexia is all of the same symptoms of anorexia nervosa (an intense fear of weight gain, and an extreme restriction of food and energy intake without extreme weight loss or very low body weight) which means a person can be anorexic even if they have a body type that is considered normal or above average. Not attacking you, just felt like mentioning it 😊
@@hamsterstyle6152 of course, i think its really sad many people think they aren’t “sick enough” for help. eating disorders are never okay and should be targeted as soon as u have a problem, regardless of weight. and thank you for ur kind words!
Growing up, my friends would insist I was anorexic because I skipped lunch. I was 13 years old, but even then I knew their accusations were a slap in the face for people who are really suffering
Let me tell you a story. My dad is super morbidly obese. And one time he told my doctor, "Vanessa doesn't eat". My mom said, "She does eat, an apple, a yogurt". And my dad responded, "Yeah, all that junk". Even your own blood gets jealous of you for being skinny. I can swear.
Gweneth's diet reminds me of my mom. She eats a ton of soup/broth, nothing processed, nothing fatty, nothing fried. Same physique as Gweneth too. Turns out she's not an almond mom, she just has a really sensitive stomach. If she tried to break a fast with anything but broth she'd be sick all day. She says she has no temptation for junk food because it'll physically make her sick. The detox thing is dumb, but everything else might actually be the only way she'll feel well.
Has your mom ever been tested for pancreatic in sufficiency? Sorry for asking personal questions but if she's struggling to get vitamins because her limited diet it may be worth looking into
I was never thinner than when my gallbladder was going bad on me, that's certainly true.
Same with my mom, only she's also allergic to dairy and doesn't have meat too often anymore since it upsets her stomach. Another catch that would make Abbey Sharpe mad: Mom's also an R.D. and has been since the 90s. So any cherry-picked claim from Abbey could easily be discredited by her if I showed her a clip of stuff Abbey has said.
What you described about your mom Do you mind sharing if she had an illness what it Was? I'm curious because I recognize similar stuff in myself. It's an issue I've had since I was an adolescent. 35 and it's still a severe problem I'm trying to solve that's why I ask but you don't have to answer such a personal question.
@@skylarsaysstuff very important question! My friend had the same issues for months and she found out she has pancreatic issues. Its very important to check!!
Your points about women's wellness vs male's biohacking are SO ON POINT!!! No one cares about what men are doing!!
Of course they do listen to biolayne
Exactly, women’s diets are judged no matter what we do. And the fact is we women have to waaay eat less food in order to maintain or lose weight than men do. We have to work twice as hard.
@@cwb1400 Sadly it is not just the diet, even the way we dress, style our hair, whether we use make up or not, everything is judged.
Women are judged more for our appearance and clothing and makeup but it's getting quite close recently with all the body building and performance enhancing drugs. Have you heard of Liver King? I'm pretty sure a lot of people make fun of carnivores eating testicles etc. There's and entire channel called Bro science. Chill. And I'm a feminist btw.
What? Men are going through so much more bad shit. They just don't talk about it.
Bone broth is a great breakfast if you have stomach issues like I do. You get calories and it doesn't come back up! Also starting the day with something warm in your belly is super energizing!
True I also often have what could be for lunch for breakfast and it keeps me for longer and get the calories. And having something warm quite honestly feels much better than just bread and cheese.
@@katerinaaqu I try to make it with chicken and beef but The fat breaks down in your body way slower than sugar and carbs such as breakfast cereal so its actually really filling and you feel good after eating it. I sometime add soup mix which in my country is usually whole barley lentils and beans. legumes are pretty much nutritionally whole and the barley provides subsence and fiber especially if your sensitive to fat it absorbs it a bit in your stomach
@caradanellemcclintock8178 I see. For me since we cook with olive oil and such we have not very greasy food around usually so anything works for me for breakfast. Usually if there is something that includes rice or protein is often available. If there isn't there is always a pair of eggs handy or a soup that has as main ingredients a mixture made out of wheat and eggs usually boiled for a few minutes with a little butter and then you add cheese. Usually nothing else is required.
Crab sounds interesting. Chicken is definitely a frequent choice too
@@katerinaaqu I try to have at least one protein in the morning usually eggs but sometimes leftovers I cant function properly without it. I use coconut oil or olive oil so the food isnt usualy very greasy but I have a mild gall bladder issue so straight oil with no fiber to absorb it gives me a tummy ache thats usually only an issue in broth but adding thew soup mix basically fixes that problem entirely
@caradanellemcclintock8178 I see. I do not have such issue so any leftover is fine to me. Sometimes I might avoid intense tastes in the morning but seriously depends
I’m not a fan of Gwenyth at all, but I agree with your take on this one. I think intermittent fasting is fantastic and there is nothing wrong with bone broth or paleo. If she feels healthy, then it’s working for her.
As a longtime Abbey viewer, I've only recently started to notice some of the EXTREMELY problematic things she does. She mystifies weight loss so much and makes it seem impossible to pander to HAES.
It's also incredibly sad to see her bust out the pitchforks whenever a thin beautiful women's diet is being dissected simply for having discipline and prioritizing wellness, which clearly, looking at Abbey, we can tell she does too. We have eyes.
Just to touch on SOME of the bullshit she perpetrates:
• ''Counting calories doesn't work because food manufacturers are allowed to be up to 30% off on their labels of the actual calories'' (aka, all your efforts are futile and achieving a healthy caloric deficit is impossible)
• '''All intentional weightloss is unsustainable and 98% of dieters gain the weight back and MORE within 5 years'' (aka the bread and butter of fat acceptance, a study not only refuted 50 years ago, but completely misrepresented in its data in order to argue this point)
• Making metabolic adaptation seem like starvation mode and saying that weightloss slows down your BMR by up to 500 calories and that you'll never be able to maintain it. This is true, and the very simple answer to it is that a smaller body takes less energy to run and function. That's it. Me at 110lbs and me at 196lbs do not have the same energy requirements. Also, it IS true that you'll have to be mindful about your diet and exercise for the rest of your life if you want longterm results. If you go on a crash diet and then right back to what you were doing before, your body will go right back to what it was before.
• This is part of both her personality and her attempt to appeal to the creators she's talking about, but she has way too many positives to say about everyone's food choices (except when it comes to thin beautiful women lol) In reality, lucky charms is not a good breakfast. Period. It's not an evil food, but it's not a good meal and cannot be equated to a filling high protein meal.
• In my opinion, she is very untruthful in how she portrays her own diet (at least in the portions she claims to eat in). The breakfast in her Emma Chamberlein video alone is upwards of 800 calories with the butter, oil, two huge pieces of bread, 1.5 avocados, honey, eggs, etc. All extremely calorically dense foods. In her Hailey Bieber video, she shows herself eating THREE full, adult sized breakfasts and tries to dunk on Hailey (hate her btw) for choosing to eat eggs OR oatmeal OR a different sort of protein (which is completely normal). For her height and EXTREMELY low weight, that is almost half or more of her maintenance calories, especially given that she says all the time that she hates exercise/only does gentle movement when she feels like it (which will not significantly increase your energy output whatsoever). In other videos, she'll show herself eating TWO full adult sized breakfasts (a full on avocado toast with an egg, plus a bowl of oatmeal and add-ons) and jokingly say she's just indecisive.
While I absolutely understand that she feels a responsibility not to encourage people eat less in order to look like her, I think it's really unfair to show yourself eating a body builder amount of calories (2500+) while looking very very very thin and just be like 'see? it's my natural set point weight!' when no one who is truly mindful of their diet has ever overturned the laws of thermodynamics. Of course, her cop out to this would be 'im an intuitive eater and I don't always eat everything I serve or cook for myself', which is a very lame excuse. Show what you DID eat then.
*By the way, Gwyneth's diet is very concerning. Not excusing it at all, and I think it's very alarming that she would rather stick herself with IVs then eat the healthy, whole foods that would yield her the same nutrients and benefits.
I remember her LATE NIGHT snack recipe with protein bar. It might be 1000 calories 😂
@@sekar9901 don't tell me - was it builtbar who sponsors all of her content? 😂
@@ninacael yess. 😂
Abbey completely lost me with Amberlynn Reid. No, she doesn't need to make slight changes to her diet, the girl is 600 pounds with a 15-year Internet history of failing diets and continuously gaining weight. She needs inpatient and therapy, not necessarily in that order. Abbey's advice was irresponsible, out of line, and more akin to, "You're doing FINE, GIRL!" than "Molly, you in danger, girl" that Amber needs to be hearing.
Gotta love when people who aren’t overweight themselves, try to tell people who are overweight or obese, that them purposely altering their diet and lifestyle to get in shape is such a bad thing!
Lol, so scummy.
Newsflash, the large majority of people will get fat if they unrestrictedly consume processed foods, their palatability and artificial intense flavors and high calorie density make the brain/body want to keep consuming them. This has been seen in zoo monkeys or other animals that get their hands on our junk food.
These “RDs” advocating for no special dieting at all and expecting your body to just magically lose weight on its own is so harmful for overweight/obese people who need to be making a change NOW
Three points
1.- Your disappointment about Gwyneth not being crazy enough was hilarious, loved it 😂
2.- I used to like Abby's videos but for some time now I feel like she's too controversial and getting things wrong like in this case.
3.- God I seriously dislike Tess, I used to not care about her but the more I see about her the more I dislike her. Yeah, she complains about Gwyneth giving bad food advice when she advocates for not using the word healthy, also her insisting on a restrictive ED, damn.
Point #3 is especially true for me. I always had my thoughts about her body but I keep them to myself and I've only ever seen her on accident. I never looked up a video of her, but she's so obviously a gigantic bitch (pun not intended). I think the word people use is "cry bully" and she's so obviously manipulative.
Long covid is so much scarier than just covid. Imagine barely surviving covid just to have chronic pain indefinitely that has no well studies treatment :/
My dads best friend died of long COVID a few weeks ago. He was so healthy before and then he was sick and just never got better. He was like an uncle to me. So when the rest of the world moved on we were still dealing with it. There are so many who are still dealing with the illness and the trauma 😔
I had a really bad viral infection 30 years ago and essentially never fully recovered and have chronic pain and fatigue
You might be the only reasonable health/diet influencer out there. I've been unintentionally doing IF all my life because I don't feel hungry in the mornings; don't understand why anytime someone goes without food for a few hours Abbey Sharp believes they're anorexic. I also thought it was a well-known fact that the importance of breakfast has been fabricated by food companies to make more money.
I also only drink black coffee until noon, my first meal is always at 12pm and I only eat twice a day. I´ve naturally eaten this way my whole adult life, I didn´t realize this meant I have an eating disorder according to Abbey Sharp
That honestly sounds more like intuitive eating.
This is honestly so ridiculous. There is no way that she could be subsisting normally on only 300 calories, and it's crazy to even think that regardless of what Gwyneth said. Do people not realize that if someone was literally starving themselves that they would eventually become extremely emaciated? Yeah, Gwyneth is skinny, but she doesn't look like she's dying or anything. She's obviously getting calories from somewhere to stay alive and function. It's honestly embarrassing coming from someone like Abbey who should know how starvation would manifest visibly on someone's body.
Exactly!!
It’s mind blowing how ignorant so many people are.
Yep. Clearly Gwyneth is maintaining a general weight somehow.
The other two women are obviously jealous and it's so embarrassing for them.
Not to mention Gweneth Paltrow has been skinny for 20+ years.
Yeah, are they crazy? 300 kcal daily, she would probably die in a month or two from malnutrition. She might eat low calories food and she probably is, but 300 is a death sentence.
She DOES look like she could have early onset osteoporosis though.
Im definitely not her doctor, but she is around an age where women start losing bone density fast if they don’t nourish themselves properly. Also, she doesnt seem like someone who has enough muscle and with all the restrictions in her diet, my hypothesis might not be that far off.
Also, I wonder: what good is a “wellness routine” for if you are running the risk of developing such brittle bones that you can seriously injure yourself by falling off a chair??? Like, I dont get it.
as soon as I saw Tess Holliday and Abbey Sharp in the same sentence I had to click immediately. Two women I can't stand, oh boy this will be a wild ride
I understand Tess Holiday hate, but why Abbey Sharp??
@Yana Abramchuk she's bullied a lot of people imho.
@Yana Abramchuk I can't speak for everyone, but what annoys me most about her is she will say she's trying to help and put trigger warnings and that while also putting extremely attractive pics of the people she's speaking of in the thumbnails, knowing very well there are plenty who don't care about her saying it's dangerous, they're gonna try copy them anyway, I find that she's pretty biased too, people will always jump at skinny people's unhealthy diets judging them while eating like a whale themselves and thinking they're healthy, it needs to be a balance but a skinny person gets insane amounts of abuse while fat people get called a hero when they're just as unhealthy as eaxhother
@Jessica She's using those pics in the thumbnails to get as many views as possible because her relevancy is based upon theirs. But yes it could be seen as encouraging people to copy them. I feel like Abbey is just one of many online nutritionists who say "eat whatever you want" and are embraced by HAES people because they are telling them what they want to hear. Imho Intuitive Eating is not a good idea for someone with an ED and her and a lot of people act like it is. I just feel like a lot of things she says are harmful to people on both extremes of weight. I'm in recovery for BED and doing generally well and losing weight and I am 200% certain she would tell me to eat a LOT more than I do. And that would harm me if I listened.
Why abbey?????? She’s a little cookey and that annoying girl you low key can’t stand but she can come to lunch. she’s not bad !!! She’s just annoying, but she means well!
i don't know why people are freaking out so much about this. i watched her harpers bazaar "everything i eat in a day" and it was basically a detailed meal-by-meal of what she eats, and from watching this recent clip i feel like her diet didn't change at all. she has stated in this previous video that she eats dinner early and that she doesn't like to eat breakfast (which i think it's really normal, in fact, i know more people that don't eat breakfast than people that do eat). she said that for lunch she's usually at the office and will buy food from someplace nearby or something like that, she also said that she eats a lot of one-pot dinners, lots of veggies, and that there's always a side vegetarian dish because her daughter is vegetarian. she stated that she loves fries and pasta and that she does go out to eat those (i'm assuming that she goes out to eat those on some weekends or when she's craving them).
maintaining a certain diet during the week because is what makes you feel good physically is not a bad thing. she doesn't have to say that she eats sweets or cereal every day just to make it relatable. she is an older woman that made it clear that she has health issues, and regarding this i defend her because my mom also started having health and stomach issues around gwyneth's age and she didn't take care of herself back then and now she has to follow a very restrictive diet every day to decrease inflammation.
people are too quick to make assumptions and completely ignore key points of what someone is saying (because she did say that she is having health issues, specifically inflammation!). we need to stop trying to shame everyone for choosing a different life than we would.
not the first time Abbey Sharp just speaks without actually thinking. At this point she's just jumping the hate train to stay relevant like every other person on tiktok who speaks without having actual relevant information about what they are talking. She just assumes things like everyone else on tiktok and its dangerous and annoying..
As someone who actually struggles with anorexia, Tess Holiday insisting she has a restrictive ED and continuing to speak for (and over) people with restrictive EDs is simultaneously offensive and laughable.
I‘m not saying that she doesn‘t have an ED but anorexia??? Come on.
Tess Holiday is a slap in the face to anyone who has anorexia
thank you!! the word is used way too loosely and it's offensive
PLUS!! nobody noticed that but like literally how can you have a """restrictive""" ed and so called """""""""anorexia"""""""""""" and criticize and expose and throw shade at someone who has a restrictive ed??? that doesn't make sense. she literally laughed at her mocking her diet but like if she had anorexia she would have been comprehensive and compassionate right??? tess holiday is a mad b*tch and i hate hypocrites like that. the fact that nobody bat an eye about this literally forgetting about her saying that she has anorexia infuriates me. we live in a miserable society.
She literally didn't mention ALL her food like a food diary. She mentioned breakfast and vegetables and then - paleo. So that could be a lot of food and or calories
that's exactly what I thought!
Bingo. Paleo is very clearly not just vegetables. Why would she use that word, if she was only eating vegetables?
Yeah but she does look like a skeleton. So I don’t trust she’s eating that much.
I’m health class we watched your “If you eat fast food, this happens to your body” video. You can’t describe the excitement I felt when I heard your voice! That was the best health class ever tbh. I hope you see this!
What Tess had to say in her video literally proves that she doesn’t really struggle with a restrictive ED.
THANK YOU for calling out Abbey Sharp! I cannot stand her holier than thou attitude.
Amazing video as always!
👏👏👏
I used to like her when she started, but these days she is more concerned about being politically correct than giving out a good advice as a dietitian. Also her thumbnails were getting snobbier with each passing day, thus decided to unfollow her!
@@namkhanorsang4637 her thumbnails put me off too. They're so tastless. Abbey claims to be super against 'body checking' but always puts half naked girls in her thumb nail just because it generates clicks.
"health shaming" is so real especially for us women! and you're so right, no one cares when it's the dudes doing long fasts etc lol but if it's a girl it's like OH NO PROMOTING EDS
Yeah but it also has to do with the fact that people think men can’t have eating disorders, when the only thing you need to qualify for the possibility of an e.d is being a human.
Nah. It’s really general. I see so many comments under dudes videos who are fasting trying to convince them that they have a eating disorder or some crap.
@@remigal899 i have never seen one in any male vid that has come across my feed - but i am not a man and not on man-gym-tok or whatever lol
@@vimmiv well If you’re not on gym tok then you probably won’t see. But since I am, I see those videos. ~_~
Jep, and it often (not Always) is mixed with beautiful misogyny and fertility shaming/ speculation. Because obviously absolutely every women needs to be able and willing to reproduce, everything that hinders her makes her unvaluable and a moral failure, even if it's not her fault. I'm a little bit dramatic, obviously, but Abby herself arguing with fertility when Gwyneth is in her 50 and has aduld children (?) Is a perfect example of that.
Abbey Sharp :
claims to not shame anyones' coffee choice
Abbey Sharp:
Shames someone on just the evidence alone from 10 second video clips.
Also Abbey Sharp : struggles to meet her 1 million follower quota.
Abbey sharp is haemorrhaging followers and it's for a reason. People used to like her content before when she was sincere. Now she's just overreacting to everything on the internet and her dietitian certificate whatever is losing its credibility.
Exactly! Perfect comment
I have a form of autoimmune arthritis and I eat mostly whole foods (in addition to medication) because the impact it has on my pain levels are NIGHT and DAY. By whole foods I mean anti-inflammatory foods such as veggies, healthy fats, lean protien and by limiting added sugar, red meat, alcohol and so on. Changing my diet has greatly increased my quality of life and eating the way I do some may think is restrictive or limited but when I look at certain ultra-processed foods all I see is waking up the next day with worse joint pain. My point is, food is SO impactful on someone's wellbeing, especially if they have a chronic condition. It's awesome Abbey Sharp and similar infulencers want to take the guilt out of enjoying calorically dense, ultra-processed foods but there is the reality that these foods are objectively harder on the body and if someone is already chronically sick choosing to take this added strain away is an extremely self caring as opposed to restrictive. SIDE NOTE: Gwynth Paltrow is extremely problematic in many other ways so I also find it funny I'm defending her.
I suffer from digestive issues currently and oftentimes eating things like soup or taking longer breaks in between meals really helps me feel better. These women seem to be oblivious to the fact that so many people deal with health conditions that they often don't even publicize, and "wellness" is often far from being about the fear of weight gain. If I had a dollar for everytime someone told me to "eat more" or "eat normal food", I would be a millionaire, and I'm not even skinny. If Tess Holliday can eat whatever she wants and feel great, that's actually a privilege, since a lot of people in our day and age deal with an array of symptoms, intolerances, conditions etc. I'm tired of body positivity activists complaining about everything being about weight when they're the ones who make it about weight all the time.
Update: Yup, exactly what I thought. I commented this at the beginning of the video and now that I'm further in Gwyneth does speak about a chronic illness. Body positivity activists who know nothing about this better shut up. Chronic illnesses wreck your physical and mental health, and any form of relief feels incredible. Let this woman eat her bone broth!
This is so true. My friend had to have his gallbladder removed and now he has a lot of dietary restrictions, and unfortunately his co-workers are not as understanding as our friend group, he complains that they grill him constantly about what he eats, I can only imagine how annoying it might be.
I have severe fibromyalgia and many people don’t know the digestive issues that accompany it. So yeah I’m with the broth soups, rice porridge, very little meat.
I have EoE and am on a six-food elimination diet as part of my current treatment plan. Having people look at my sideways because I bring my own food/snacks everywhere is the absolute worst.
THISSSSSS
Excellent points about the internalized misogyny that makes Gwyneth SOO controversial and hated and "wellness" so often denigrated whereas "bio-hacking" bros are either venerated or ignored - no moral panic or body-shaming for them. You're so right that the question was specifically "tell me about your wellness routine" NOT "walk me through what you eat in a day" too, context is KING and sensationalizing snippets makes for exciting content but it's not fair or good faith critique. Truthfully I'm tired of people hating on Gwyneth so hard, it feels like hating on Nickelback at this point - generic and boring. It's the "accepted" thing to hate and critical thinking is encouraged to be left by the door - Gwyneth = bad is enough. 🙄
I think because men tend to leave men alone where look at the people attacking Gweneth Paltrow, I don't see many men doing it. Some dudes do get too invested in what women are eating but that's gotta be like 10%.
@@Aaron-kj8dv shiiiid I feel like 10% is huge. All the thousands of clips of this kind of nonsense and I've only ever seen 5 men and only two of them were straight iirc.
I do think on the men’s side there’s a tendency to not really give a shit about what’s going on with men, so while women are nitpicked to hell and back, so long as a man doesn’t cause any sort of issues external to himself the most you’re gonna get is a “men can cry to” from an instagram post and that’s about it for any sort of concern.
@@Slinkwater lol fair enough. Generally speaking guys don't care what other guys do. I wonder why there's a gender difference in that because I don't care either.
I know some people will have a conspiracy theory take on "actually it's the patriarchy..." but I'd like to know the actual reason, I think it's interesting.
@@Aaron-kj8dv the only patriarchy at fault is the feeder community 🤣
Wow I’ve never even considered the disproportionate outrage between men and women’s wellness! Very good commentary!
The way she eats seems pretty healthy to me. Our bodies don't need as much as people think they do. On top of that it looks like she's eating a good amount of healthy fats, fiber, and protein. That's what enables her to fast for a long period of time. The fact that she breaks her fast with bone broth is actually really good. You don't want to throw anything heavy into your stomach as soon as you break your fast. I think she's done her research and this is what works great for her.
Agreed we don't do labourious work like we used to do in ancient days, we don't need that much food. Tiktok Dieticians just want us to keep eating food while it's not healthy and according to our lifestyle
as someone who also has a chronic illness, an anti-inflammatory diet has saved me when my doctors gave up on trying to help me. I was in pain every single day, constantly so tired I could fall asleep within two minutes wherever I was and barely able to live anything resembling a normal life of someone in their early 20s. My doctors essentially told me "welp, tough shit, there's nothing we can do"
so I started researching and landed on an anti-inflammatory diet (which seemed just logical to me since I have an inflammatory health condition but somehow my doctors never thought of that.) Since then I've radically changed my diet and ever since I am ALIVE again. I'm barely ever in pain and overall my symptoms have decreased by at least 70-80%. Do I always love having to adhere to so many diet rules, no. But I know the alternative and I'd rather worry about eating right than worry about how I'm going to be able to have a job or a life when I'm sleeping 16+ hours a day and am in constant pain. I sometimes get really emotional because I still so vividly remember how _miserable_ I felt for years to the point where I had forgotten that it ever had been any different. And now most days I feel just so happy and alive. It sounds so strange to say, but I essentially felt like a zombie for a couple of years, it really feels like coming back to life and finally being awake again. Like seeing the sun again after a long dark winter.
Same. Thank you for sharing 💕
Doctors prefer pills over diet. Glad you started to feed your body well and listened to it.
I’m so glad you found a way out of the dark. ❤ Huge hugs for sticking with the tough fight. I was incredibly lucky to have had a GP that was like a second dad that helped me through my primary immunodeficiency. No matter what, never feel bad or embarrassed about bringing your own oil or salad dressing with you!!! 🎉😅
I am so so so happy for you, and I had a similar experience. 19-20 I was barely functional, although it manifested as severe and debilitating dysautonomia and panic attacks. Yes, throughout my 20s friends would make fun of me sometimes for passing on unhealthy things, but to feel like garbage and not be able to function just wasn't worth it for me.
Can you tell us what you eat? Anti inflammatory? Thank you.
Tess wonders why people are afraid to be fat? I'm afraid to be fat. I've seen friends die early and be put on meds for high blood pressure. Youth doesn't last forever. I'd like to spend more time being old.
Yes, I also love trail running (it relaxes me) and I am afraid that being fat would make that joy in my life very difficult and perhaps dangerous to continue.
I wish I had the discipline Gwyneth has. This diet doesn't seem bad at all and its a lot better than taking ozempic.
The thing is, as awful as it is to promote disordered eating, Paltrow is not a medical professional. She is a human in the spotlight with a lot of pressure to look a certain way. She could have a disorder, yes, but that doesn’t make her a bad person just because she’s a famous person with a disorder. As someone in recovery, I hate the way people with eating disorders are treated like bad people who want to harm others. Gwyneth didn’t say “you should do this too.” She said it’s what works for her and what’s important to her. Which is really no one’s business but her own and that of her doctors. And just because she said she has bone broth for lunch doesn’t mean she ONLY has that for lunch. She just mentioned that’s part of her routine. Tea with breakfast is part of my routine. Doesn’t mean I don’t eat food with it. It’s just that the tea is part of my routine because it’s always the same while what I eat may vary. I really just wish we would stop commenting on how others eat in general
Lost 50 pounds on paleo and had insane levels of energy. Started sleeping REALLY well and just felt good. I had been diagnosed with Crohns Disease and all my symptoms completely went away. I even went off all medications and felt fantastic. I switched to a paleo keto to lose my last few pounds to get to my goal weight and have even more energy. I didn't k ow if was possible. I ended up going off both because my husband eats like a 14 year old and I ended up giving in to temptation. Weight and symptoms came back (shocker). But now that I have recently returned to AIP/Paleo, things are rapidly improving. I'm hoping my skinny husband's recovery from stage 3 colon cancer will keep him eating healthier as well. 🙏🙏🙏
If you do the shopping and/or cooking you could get that to change. I get it though, my dad eats like an out of control 7 year old and it destroyed everyone's diet in the house.
There's just a lot of hypocrisy in a woman who still struggles with Orthorexia calling out another woman for her diet supposedly being too healthy. She really did jump to a lot of conclusions there. Idk, I have always gotten bad vibes from Abbey that she's just looking to criticize people for not eating enough.
She’s only doing it because she’s got ortho. It doesn’t occur to her that she is not the benchmark of humanity and that other people can seek a healthy diet without getting an ed.
Is abbey the one orthorexia? She does seem to project a lot. Behaves as if her entire audience is just recovering from a restriction disorder and should only ever hear that eating is good. Unfortunately her young audience don’t know that.
@Jake Stroll Yes Abbey has done videos about her past Orthorexia, recovery, and relapse.
... and she probably does prolonged fasting and doesn't tell anybody LOL
I think Abbey is frustrated and struggling with her own ED, and that’s why her entire channel is now about tearing down slim women who eat vegetables. I liked her when I discovered her several years ago, but now it seems like a lot of projection and kowtowing to fat activism.
I had only bone broth for a few days when my IBS was going crazy and my colon was spasming so much I was limping. It helped immensely!
Would I tell people to eat like that all the time? Of course not. But if your digestive system having a tough time it's a good idea to let it rest for a day with IF and bone broth🤷🏻♀️
That's great. I'm a big sucker for stories about people healing IBS with diet.
@@KattBon sadly I didn't heal it, just that particular flare-up.
I do a once a year a 3 day water fast, and that healed up my ibs
Kiana, thank you for always making quality content. Seeing your videos pop up in my feed brightens my day. I like to wake up with them sipping my morning tea. I've watched just about all of your videos, they're so informative! x
So according to these women, you can paint your hair, you can eat too much food, but Gwyneth cant do whatever the hell she wants with her food ? INSECURE :)
You nailed it x)
@@jennynovoa8586 True!! Gwyneth isn't insecure, she knows what is best for her personal well-being. No matter it is common sense or not. It is great that she is open and honest. That is far from insecurity. Sometimes, I think people mix up such psychological terms...
Right! Lol
GOOP = POOP 💩
They also forget she is public figure and needs to be in very good shape especially as female actress. That takes a work and thats a huge privilege to have and she gets paid accordingly. I would do 10x the shit she does for 10x less lmao.
What really made me mad was nobody actually bothered to listen to the full podcast clip in which she explains that she also likes to Goop kitchen Green soup, which is kind of a creamy type of soup and what else she eats for dinner with the side of said vegetables (like sweet potato noodles, fish, grain free tacos, etc.). So without the cuts it actually shows that she eats pretty normal meals.
I did paleo/whole 30 for two months. It was so complicated and so much work that I wasn’t able to sustain it longterm, but it definitely wasn’t an unhealthy diet. I learned so much about food and my body, and detoxing from sugar also enhanced the sweetness of natural foods for me in a way that weren’t as enjoyable before. I remember having fresh peach for dessert and it being as heavenly as the best slice of cake.
I was questioning myself when everyone understood her answer differently from me. I'm relieved I'm not alone any more 😅
LOL i was like.... am i nuts or.... was that not the question at all hahah.
This is why I love Kiana’s channel. It’s objective and analytical. She doesn’t jump on a bandwagon or constantly push an agenda. She explores things from a common sense angle and it’s helped her platform become something more than a conversation about nutrition and dieting. It’s about the way the wellness and food debate is framed by others.
Your videos make me want to research and do presentations on things I care about for no ones approval but mine
This is such a good compliment
Yup. I too would love to make well informed, well edited videos on stuff I am passionate about.
Ah this is so good! The comparison of women’s wellness routines to men’s bio hacking is SPOT ON 🎉
Thank you for changing my mind about this... I was quick to judge Gwyneth Paltrow too but your response makes a lot of sense... I also realize we are judged as women from the outside world pretty harshly and I was really quick to do it myself... A lot of people just jumped to a conclusion based off her body type and that really doesn't make it any better than one of these shame someone with a bigger body... I've been on both sides of this spectrum now and experienced judgment and comments whether I'm in a big or smaller body and it's exhausting... I just learned to tune everybody else out.... Thank you again for this perspective :-)
ah yes, so body shaming is okay when it's the thin women? make it make sense. no one looks twice if someone gorges themselves on fast food, but the minute someone doesn't its all noise 🙄 love your videos kiana
'She is the size of a dried piece of spaghetti' really rubbed me the wrong way😐 Straight up bully behaviour
“No one looks twice if someone gorges themselves on fast food” are you sure?
@@222222ania people do look twice yes…but SAY anything and you get attacked by ‘fat enablers’. I guess that’s the difference.
Thank you for making this video!!! I used to really enjoy Abbey's videos but it often feels like she's just looking for ways to make anti-diet culture arguments where there doesn't need to be one, and then goes and panders to fat acceptance without owning that that's what she's doing. It's made it difficult to enjoy her content :/
Yes, she’s definitely part of the strange over-correction that happened in the 2010s. There was definitely a harmful side of diet culture but that doesn’t mean that every diet is a problem. I pray she never has a diabetic type 2 client because she’d take them off their doctors advice for sure.
You said this perfectly. I feel like Abby approaches each video she makes with the pre-defined mindset that “this person follows diet culture or is restrictive” when a good chunk of the time their diet doesn’t do anything to suggest that.
The whole "People in the Palaeolithic died young" argument against the Paleo Diet that Abby made is beyond stupid and ridiculous. They died young because they did not have homes that had Plumbing and Heating in them, and they did not have things like medicine and hospitals filled with different medical equipment.
Hello, your green shirt is lovely! It's my favourite type of green :D. I wanted to let you know I've watched all your videos and they've really help me better understand food/diet + types of calories (fat, protein, carb etc). For the first time I've been struggling with being over weight. My boyfriend who trains Strong Man as been helping me understand calories in take verse energy output but he's VERY hardcore about it! Lol! So, I appreciated your simple type of one-on-one explanation with encouragement, understanding and explanation.
I've personally never dealt with binge (sp?) eating due to food intolerances but thanks to your videos explaining how people become obese, the mindset, how to change behavior, and just a generally being a personable/relatable UA-camr... I really really appreciate what you've created on this channel! It's so easy to feel alone and confused with trying to understand diets + exercise/calorie output. I can now properly understand the food struggle my boyfriend went through, which were lost on me. I also feel more confident on my style of diet + exercise. Thank you so much!!
You asked for all the smoke and I love it! You make great content and I can tell you love what you do keep it up
It's like a battle of the worst people imaginable and I can't defend any of them.
Why do you have a Rafflesia of all things as your profile picture? I mean no offense or criticism, I am just curious.
Totally agree Eibar
@@drbuni Vileplume's one of my favorite Pokemon and it's the plant that inspired the Pokemon.
Abby is obsessed with overeating, sweets, and protein. She's so against eating fruits and eating healthily that it's just crazy for me. I remember when she judged Milles' day of eating (he's also a dietician and goes by Healthy Crazy Cool on yt) and she completely cut out his breakfast from her reaction because it consisted of 10 persimmons.
She isn’t against fruit tf?
She's a populist dietician whose advice is not based on dietary science but on what sentiments are popular right now and what type of content gets her views and followers. She also CLEARLY projects her ED thought patterns onto the people she's critiquing.
But, eating 10 persimmons in one sitting doesn't sound good either.... Fruits are indeed source of fibers necessary for our boddy. But, some of them are high in sugar compare to the others. And having too many of them in one sitting doesn't make it any better.
All the people agreeing with Tess on her page, saying ‘Tess is glowing and Gwenyth is frail and dehydrated!”
Thats because Tess uses filters and moisturizer.. um.. doesn’t mean her habits are safe or healthy either.
And EVERYONE saying ‘ED DISGUISED AS WELLNESS’ towards GP. SAME TO TESS! Same to Tess 😤
Thank you so much for making this video. I'm not a big fan of Gwyneth Paltrow and how much she has capitalized on harmful "wellness" practices for women (and I'm not excusing that, because it's reprehensible), but the Internet's response to her diet was off the rails. I was shocked by the extreme lack of empathy in everyone's response, especially since most people seemed to recognize that her diet could be a form of disordered eating, and therefore, probably NOT something that Paltrow is in control of. It stunned me that most people jumped on the bandwagon to shame Paltrow for her diet and appearance (even with the clear understanding that she MAY have an eating disorder), all in the name of "informing an impressionable youth" that her diet was unhealthy. To my mind, all that does is encourage the "impressionable youth" to be cruel to someone who may be in desperate need of help and empathy.
Abbey Sharp is toxic. She’s nasty. I liked her for a short while but then it felt mean girl.
I remember she made a video once about how everyone should just keep ice cream in their freezer and eat a scoop every day. It just seemed so disconnected from the reality of what binge eating is like. I wish I could keep an entire carton of ice cream in my freezer and not eat the entire thing until my stomach hurts. It is so tone deaf to completely ignore people who say “I can’t have junk food in the house because I will eat until my stomach hurts” and tell them oh no it’s fine. Like congratulations you don’t struggle with binging, how awesome for you? Do you want a gold star? It just felt like weird bragging and not caring about people’s real struggles at all.
I find her so condescending and nitpicking nowadays
Like no shit a random 14 yo on tiktoks weiad isn't perfect in balance.
Idk she is annoying to me
I don't even know who she is. Clearly been living under a rock. But from the clip I saw... really? She's for real? Urgh!
Have you done a video about Abbey Sharp yet? I watched some of her videos years ago and I feel like she used to be a decent person with good advice. I can't believe what I'm seeing now, it's so sad.
Agreed: I’d love to see this
Hey Kiana! Just wanted to pop up to tell you that I've been watching your videos for a while and I absolutely love them! I almost never comment on yt but wanted to let you know that I really enjoy them. Please keep up with the amazing well-researched content😄
Ive been watching your videos ever since you've been making them and its really nice to see you start being more comfortable on camera!!! Keep up the good work!!!!
Kiana always over here with the critical thinking 95% of the internet seems to lack 👏 thank you for delivering the much-needed sanity this sphere is so sorely lacking
From what i can tell Abbey Sharp just doesn't like any form of diet restriction regardless of whether or not it benefits the Person. Some people have food addictions and therefore abstain from foods that will trigger them (sugar, simple carbs etc) since moderation doesn't work for them. Nobody would tell an alcoholic to just drink less so why is abstinence of certain foods a problem?
Even SHE has food restrictions, she has SIBO.
The whole "People in the Palaeolithic died young" argument against the Paleo Diet that Abby made is beyond stupid and ridiculous. They died young because they did not have homes that had Plumbing and Heating in them, and they did not have things like medicine and hospitals filled with different medical equipment.
I constantly get Noom ads when I watch your channel. You should do a video on it!
So happy you’re uploading more 😭 I love your videos!
thank u so much for talking about this & also especially for calling out abbey. that woman is so dramatic sometimes and a lot of her nutrition advice would have just encouraged my binge eating problems if she was the only source of information i had. (we all know how well "intuitive eating" goes for us bingers...lol)
When I was 14 I was put on paleo as a way to reduce the amount of migraines I had. It had for others so the doctors suggested we try it. As a teen it didnt help me, but experimenting with it as an adult worked wonders for my brain. It absolutely does not mean you are trying to lose weight.
Interesting. Did you have classic migraines or a different type?
LOVE your videos! So nice to hear someone talking some sense! Keep up the hood work :)
I struggled with fertility for 4 years!! I started doing alternate day fasting, I would fast for 24 hrs and eat normal for 24 hrs and got pregnant within a few months. Both of my pregnancies I got pregnant while fasting
How have you realised fasting would help? Are there some studies showing correlation between fasting and fertility or something like that?
@@JohnSmith-pf8jq I was fasting for personal reasons and just happened to get pregnant the first time and the second time I was fasting to lose weight. It was just something I put together after the fact. I believe fasting has great health benefits for certain people. I don't know if there was correlation or just coincidence, but when I began fasting my period skipped a cycle both times and then the following cycle I got pregnant. So I do believe that fasting does something to the menstrual cycle.
@@beequeen626 Thanks for the answer, that's really interesting. I never realized fasting could have health benefits beyond weight management.
Thank you for this. I saw all the freaking out but also heard in her video what you talked about: she’s only talking about PARTS of her day. And she’s not that different from 85% of celebrities and all their specialty routines. Like, just ignore it and take care of your body the best you can 👍
They're celebrities, they're on camera, they have to look phenomenal. I'm a digital librarian, I'm thrilled if my husband wants to pound me twice a week, to be blunt.
I'm down 80 lbs on my weight loss journey and your videos helped me get a better understanding of the food industry and diet culture. Thanks for the great work!
sheesh that's a great job, congrats!
Yayyy congratulations way to go
Great job!
I will never get enough of your videos, Kiana! Hope you are doing okay!
I’m quite sure people talk bad about those who eat healthy because it goes viral easily. There’s a huge gap in positioning in our society and people like you, who take all sides into consideration, are lacking. So thank you for this!
When 2 people are fighting and you can't sympathize with any of them, as they both are questionable, in my country we say "the toad f***s the viper". Pretty much describes this situation too.
The viper and toad are very representative of those two women lmao
Fight of piss and shit
I will be using this from now on.
I read that book you recommended, “Salt, Sugar, Fat”. It was really informative. Thanks for staying nuanced.
Thank you for posting yet another great video!
Unrelated - your green top really flatters your eye color and complexion! 😊
I feel like such an asshole towards her now. I didn't even THINK about what she was going through and just saw her through the GOOP lens of how crazy it all was. Honestly, thank you for this video. It was a new take that no one talked about. Especially with how she's suffering and how she has to take care of her body because of it.
Also, how there’s horrible person made this video saying awful things about her when she’s eating a very healthy diet. She exaggerated from a shot clip, what should I eat in a day?
It’s just so funny that when people say “I do this” everyone thinks it means “you all should do this”. like can we talk about ourselves and not have to explain that “I” and “me” doesn’t mean “YOU”. FFS. Even kids know the difference between I/Me and You.
I did 16 hour intermittent fasting while breastfeeding, and it was SO great for my body! I had so much energy and felt great. So I’m sure 18 hours is fine for at least some people 😅
Great video, your content is always so well researched and presented in a kind and thoughtful manner. I was just thinking "why did I stop watching Abbey Sharp?" and you just reminded me.
I agree with your take on this. I’ll just add that bone broth is recommended to end intermittent fasting because of all the nutrients and low carbs. It’s also easier on your stomach lining which is vulnerable right after fasting.