That ending talking about how Science Fiction allows us to talk about contemporary issues from a hypothetical perspective really hits home. So many people think sci fi is just about laser guns and FTL travel, but it's so much more. It really gives a writer freedom to explore ideas without stepping on toes, but still allows its viewers to think about how it applies to them. Great video as always, wish I had more to add but you seemed to nail it.
agreed. Speculative fiction allows us to view our contemporary issues through a lens we aren"t used to, thus circumventing the reflexive defenses we have for our position on this issue we would engage in in a more forwards presentation of the issue.
Very important is that we don't actively inject contemporary biases though. If you want to talk about problems or ideas that affect today without it being poisoned ahead of time, you can't actively represent contemporary 'sides' or people representing those 'sides'. You see it all the time. Characters clearly and intentionally or even explicitly meant to represent, say, Trump. Or Musk. Or Bezos. Or whoever the media apparatus has decided is bad today. It gets in the way of telling a good story. And that's the main problem: People constantly want to preach their beliefs without making their story worth listening to to begin with.
There is a series of novels by Mick Farren that are set in the same universe (ish). In one novel, it ends with the aliens coming to humanity and dominating them through a mind control weapon. The main character's last act of defiance as a thinking being is picturing a monkey smashing something. The next novel in the sequence is set a long time into the future where humans are raised on worlds at kept at a stone age level of technology so they can be harvested as soldiers for their alien masters' war.
Colony being unable to finish its run was truly tragic. It was one of the best alien invasion sci-fi shows I've ever seen. However, it wasn't just about resources. Like "Falling Skies", Earth was just a battlefront between two alien empires and the mechanical invaders were both harvesting our resources and "toughening us up" so humans can fight for their masters.
Wrong it's actually great, people retroactively pretending the movies message is way more obnoxious than it ever actually was is always the same clique I hear about it, and it's a very disingenuous one
I forgot about 'Alien Nation'. Saw that in my teens and thought: 'Pinto Bean bald caps in LA...a bit on-the-nose.' I'd love to see your take on the various authoritarian dystopia stories with an eye to which most closely resembles our current 'situation'. I'm of the opinion we're closer to a combination of 'Harrison Bergeron' crossed with 'Idiocracy' than we are to '1984'. So much attention on avoiding 'Big Brother' let 'Big Mother' sneak right up on us.
@@feralhistorian Last I checked Alien Nation was going to have a reboot but then they turned it into its own original thing. I think its supposed to premier on Paramount.
It really took me far too long to realize how blatant of a reference that Striders are to the fighting machines. And in more ways than just having three legs
WRT the use of tanks in the war of the world's scenario, I think turtledove did a fairly good job in his Worldwar series. At least in the first couple of books. He made very good points on how war economies work and how a force coming across the stars does not have unlimited resources to throw into the fight when the home team isn't completely devoid of technology. He also brought in the perspective of the invaders as individuals rather than a monolithic block all with everyone holding the same opinion.
Yes, Worldwar was great. Not only with the Lizards having to adapt 1940s tech to manufacture their own munitions but our own nations rapidly adapting their tech down to our own level. I still feel a little bad for Ussmak. Little scaly dude couldn't catch a break.
@@feralhistorian I tried comparing him to willie from V or Albert from Alienation but I somehow find less pity for Ussmak. Somehow the other two aliens are more personable than Ussmak
I'm just glad it was the first Turtledove althistory WWII story I read, because there's finding a niche and then doing what Turtledove did. WWI and II where the Confederacy had won the Civil War had a few interesting thoughts (even if American!Hitler is a played out trope,) but it turns out replacing technology with magical artifacts on a one-to-one basis doesn't add much, even with gratuitous race swapping.
@@feralhistorian guns of the south was half "those racist bigoted old southerners" and the other half was smug turtledove horseshit. he really has a tin ear for southern social behaviors and all his southerners are self hating whites who just havent been shown the wisdom of magical negroes. if AWB was there to do as they claimed, they would have been running things when they showed up. its a bit too far of a leap to think they wouldnt have gone full technocrat with gearing the south up to take on the world. One airplane could have changed the civil war and zero aircraft, yet they have tons of gold Krugerrands, and millions of AK's. it had promise but has plot holes stephen king would be able to drive a dumptruck through
Right at the end there you got me thinking about the "Men in Black" franchise. The day-to-day job of an MIB agent would actually be some combination of witness protection, ICE, and a protective service for foreign dignitaties. During the opening scene of MIB2 we even see agent J taking a new Rookie on a welfare check which goes badly and ends in a police shooting. And we laugh because it's happening to resident aliens and not real people.
When I was little, my dad was watching TV and I had an early bed time. I asked him what he was watching. He was a natural born Chicagoan, and said, "Warda Whirls". It sounded amazing - weird laser sounds, shooting, it sounded amazing! Who or what was Warda and why was it whirling? I was fascinated, but soon fell asleep. All these decades later, I still think of it as "Warda Whirls"
The 'musical' is really a live performance of what many consider a seminal adaption of the novel: Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of The War of the Worlds. This was a double album released in 1978, with many different mainstream musical artists of the time contributing their talents to the production. Notable is the narration throughout being done by the velvet baritone of Richard Burton, and some incredible album art illustrating the major story beats of the novel, such as the cylinder, the Thunderchild and the Red Weed. It may be somewhat dated when you compare it to modern musical productions, but making it required many advancements in musical recording technology, almost all of which have survived to the present day. There is a SACD version that is remixed into 5.1 surround which is absolutely worth listening to, as having Jeff Wayne's orchestral-pop main theme crash out with the strong strings is quite the experience, especially for a first-time listener. It was one of the first times I was exposed to the surge of 1970s concept albums (ELO's Out of the Blue being another stand-out, with the vinyl double-album coming with a press-out cardboard model of the ELO saucer-station), and I've been a fan of the genre ever since (Another sci-fi one is Mitchell/Coe Mysteries: Exiled. Steve Coe is not, as far as I know, any relation to myself, but my dad bought it solely for that reason). Anyway, another excellent video from you, FH! Definitely spot-on about the varying allegories that are almost continuously discussed in science fiction. If only people would learn to listen to them…
I had completely forgotten about that album until I ran across it while hunting for more obscure War of the Worlds spinoff clips. I need to track down a good quality copy of the live performance, I've only watched parts of it on a sketchy youtube dub of someone's VHS copy.
There was an old DVD of it released in 2006 that still features Richard Burton's narration from the album. Its rendered on a terrible giant talking head, but afterwards they replaced Burton with Liam Neeson and its just not the same. From what I can tell the later versions are sold under the "New Generation" label, and they have different instruments and sometimes melodies. Honestly, the original album from the 70s is the best, but the 2006 DVD is the closest live performance you'll get to that version. The videogame is also good if you can track down a copy. It crashes randomly on modern hardware though, so if you have an old Windows 7 kicking around play it on that.@@feralhistorian
@@feralhistorian And since you've proven you can survive the singing of Justin Hayward, you could watch the BBC series 'Star Cops'. Come to think of it, it was so long ago and obscure, I'm not entirely sure if it existed. But the Justin Hayward theme music is still burnt into my memory.
@@PhaedrusAK Yep, BBC. Late 1980's (87/88?) A very short lived series, I seem to remember the BBC was always having strikes around that time which hobbled many shows.
EARTH: FINAL CONFLICT Would have been worthy of mention. Created by Gene Roddenberry (Star Trek) and made after his death. The series was about a resistance movement fighting against Aliens who have come Earth peacefully but for some ulterior motive. The show was '90s syndicated, produced in Canada, Cheese at it's best!
To defend the tank point, if we're trying to describe a modern day "Garrison" force, it's somewhat quicker to move tanks into a defensive line than field pieces. More expensive of course, but part of tanks role is mobile artillery. Battle lining them in battalion sized formations is ridiculous, but it isn't entirely out of their role to place them in defensive embankments to serve as field guns. In fact, outside of the Soviet Sphere direct fire artillery was pretty much completely phased out.
'Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy'is the most accurate depiction of our current society. The earth being 'bulldozed into oblivion' to build an intergalactic highway.
America's alien invasion movies from the fifties, especially WotW and Earth vs. the Flying Saucers, struck me as having a real Pearl Harbor mentality to them. The attacks were unexpected and massively devastating. They also played out like fears of a Soviet nuclear strike by again being unexpected and massively devasting plus centered on highly strategic targets like Los Angeles and Washington D.C. Steven Spielberg's WotW was a little different. There was greater focus on the people trying to escape the invasion. It was almost like Spielberg was trying to put you in the shoes of people in Poland trying to escape the Nazis. Just the sort of thing I would expect from someone who directed Schindler's List. If you've never seen it before, I recommend the 1970s British series UFO. It plays out more like the Battle of Britain. You have interceptor pilots stationed on the moon battling repeated aerial assaults on the Earth. Just goes to show you how each country's experience of WW2 shaped the way it envisioned an alien invasion.
Great points. I vaguely remember watching UFO a few times when I was a kid. I'll have to give it another look as I slowly work my back through to some British sci-fi.
There was a series conceived by Gene Roddenberry called “Earth. The Final Conflict” in the first series of which it was difficult to see whether it was about alien invasion or about humans unreasonably resisting alien aid. Certainly humans working for the aliens became somewhat Fascistic.
I liked They Live as an allegory over all other alien invasion films. It was entertaining, humorous and thought-provoking all at the same time. John Carpenter is a subversive genius in the horror/sci-fi genre of cinema.
Man, I have to say that I am incredibly lucky to have been gifted your channel via the algorithm. I haven't encountered a video yet that was less than 'good' and I don't expected to. You given me numerous thought experiments and potential discussions to have with my family.
Another sci-fi book series that explores some of these themes is, oddly, the “Doom” series. Yes, it is a series of books based off the Doom first person shooter video games of the 90s, and they’re far better than they had any right to be.
By the way, check out the 1998 BBC short-lived TV series Invasion:Earth. a masterclass in the pointlessness of defending against an overwhelming attacker unless you are prepared to sacrifice everything and then gaining a pyrrhic victory at best . Bleak but well worth watching
I remember it at the time. I second this. I have the soundtrack somewhere. The main American actor (who was also a producer) wanted to make a second season showing the continuing 'war' but the BBC had a habit of only funding short lived series, a sort of 'one and done'.
"There was even a musical." Dude, I don't know whether it's down to exposure or differing cultural perspectives (UK versus US), but hearing Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of The War Of the Worlds referred to as an 'also-ran' hurt. I felt instantly indignant! :D
Jeff Wayne's is fucking baller. my dad had it pirated off the radio on reel to reel. i remember being about 5 years old, waking up at night, creeping into the room where he was listening to the unscrewing in the common. I was transfixed.
My parents scarred me and my two younger brothers for life playing a cassette copy after dark on interstate road trips. Ooooooh laaaaarrrrrr!! Beee woo, beee woo, beee woo.... Decades later I still can't listen to that album at night on a lonely highway.
Spielberg’s War of the Worlds has a subtext of the shock of 9/11 with its setting in New York, the ordinary work day shattered by alien invaders and destroyed architecture, humans turned to ash, the flyers of the missing, and the futility of the war on terror (demonstrated by the tanks) as some sort of holy enterprise.
If ever there was a movie that needs to be remade, it's THIS ISLAND EARTH. It would probably need to be a miniseries as I don't think you could really tell this story in a two hour movie.
It's a book rather than a film, but I highly recommend 'Starships of the First World War' [Edit: _Spacecraft_ of the FWW]. The premise is that Humanity's big reverse-engineering-fueled tech bonanza following the events of War of the Worlds was _not_ in mechs (tripod or otherwise) or heat-ray weapons, but the real meat of it was in the antigravity systems built into the Martian landing cylinders. Cue all the major powers developing fleets of interplanetary warships as soon as their recovering industries allowed. Initially, there was a frantic rush of early designs built to defend against a Martian second wave - but when that never materialized, second- and third-generation ships were built for a punitive expedition to Mars. And eventually, of course, the designs grew into serving more or less the same roles that real-world navies do: to project national power and keep the neighbors honest. On the surface, the book is concerned with each nation's approach to developing its ships and doctrine, written in a similar vein as an introductory illustrated history book, like a Jane's Guide or an Osprey Books entry. But under that layer, it also casually drops a lot of tantalizing world-building hints about what happened to the Martian civilization (almost entirely collapsed well before the Earth fleet arrived) and how, while we could replicate the technology, the underlying science was much weirder and less well understood. It's unlikely, but I really want them to do a sequel.
Your channel is awesome. I just found this channel, and now I watch it all the time, literally. Great content and incredibly insightful and eye openeing takes on these topics and subjects. Keep 'em coming 🧔🏿♂️
I realized I have binge watched a couple of these without actually subscribing, so I just took care of that. May I say this is fascinating the way you have blended history, politics, philosophy, and science fiction. And though I have not seen coloony, Earth Final Conflict, and especially the original V for me are fascinating invasion tales because they get into the blurred lines of collaboration. V was disturbing in that way, though the later tv series wasn't worth much. And it's interesting to see the Jeff Wayne musical at least mentioned. I only know a few people who know what I am talking about when I recommended it. Anyways, this is great stuff.
@@slappy8941 the first day I discovered Feral Historian I did watch four or five at my treatment. One way or the other I don't know if this proves anything. I would invite folks to engage in a discussion of the books or movies that are covered here. Been awhile since I read some, others like Fitzpatrick's War are new to me. Would love to engage the actual material if you are interested.
Yes. What he said. I don't really have anything else to add to the topic of the video. The video was great, and I can't really think of anything to add right now. Instead, I will mention a layer of the readaptation of stories. And why I so dislike the Tom Cruise version of War of the Worlds. The book is quite wholesome, as it follows a man moving through England during the Martian invasion in the attempt to get to his wife. And then, the book has a happy ending, being reunited with her. I love stories that get really dark but then have a happy ending. Been years since I read it. And now I want to read it again. In the Tom Cruise of the Worlds on the other hand, not only has the story shifted to the United States. The life situation of the main character is completely transformed. In the book, we have a loving marriage. In the movie, we have a divorced man, broken home, his two kids are sent back and forth with their mandated dual custody, and both his kids hate him. While his ex-wife that he still has feelings for, well she is with another man. So really, they did a great job adapting the movie to our modern way of living. I haven't seen any other versions of the story. But now finding out that there is a musical... now that... now that is something. Absolutely most definitely... something. Something for sure. Sure is something that is.
@@feralhistorian Also, sort of connecting to Colony. The dad of one of my neighbors was in the Norwegian resistance movement, fighting the Germans wherever he could. In many parts of the country they could only move at night, because of the large number of German sympathizers, especially in rural areas of many smallholders. Our pre-war Labor government wanted to join into the USSR. Not just become a friend or ally with the Soviet Union, but to actually become a Soviet Republic under Moscow. And then, many had been radicalized by the Soviet invasion of Finland, where a great deal of Norwegians from east in the country went to fight as foreign volunteers. Creating these solid pro-German areas in various places. Creating this sharp divide in Norwegian society. Then, another almost neighbor, he joined "Hirden" as a teenager. He did this to preserve law and order. He struggled a lot later in life. Not because of anything he may have done, but because everyone hated him. Previous friends, family, neighbors, they all hated him. Thankfully, our post-war purges were mild compared to Denmark, Holland, and France. So, at least he survived. Then a third almost neighbor (dead now but I know his grandson). His farm was constantly robbed by fellow Norwegians during the war. Constantly. But he turned the other cheek. The German presence in the region was pretty high, being only 8 miles away from Stavanger Airport. So, if he had reported it, there could have been a crackdown. Which would have made him a collaborator according to pretty much everybody. But, being a devout Protestant, he turned the other cheek, and allowed both animals and produce to be stolen. He was so devout in fact, that when the post-war Labor Government seized 4/5ths of his extensive property, he did not take them to court. Which was a good thing for me, because my grandfather would buy one of these land-cleared farms they made from his property 30 years later, which is why I have this farm today. On the other side of the little mountain almost bordering my farm, around 2 miles away. The man living here was a well-known ideological National Socialist during the war. We're talking having a massive swastika on the wall, picture of the Fuhrer, the whole shebang. But any and all signs of his ideology evaporated as soon as the war ended. In all haste, he had made sure to burn it all to avoid the post-war purge. Which worked. The local school had a teacher who became very well-known in the area for being a bit part of the "Teacher's rebellion" or "Teacher's Protest" in 1942. Where the teachers refused to implement the Nazi oriented education demanded by Quisling. I forget details about him, but I am pretty sure he survived the war and continued to teach afterwards. Sadly that school building was demolished before I was even born. The Stavanger Airport was basically built to become the international airport that it is today by the Germans. Where it served as a vital base to bomb the English. And a lot of the industry and the large industrial concerns of the region were either started or were expanded to become what they are today because of the occupation. Like one, although I forget his name now, started his business making steel wheelbarrows for the Germans during the war. --------------------- I wish we could get more stories about what happens after the occupation. But then again, every European country that was occupied by the Germans wants to forget what they themselves did after the war.
Re. your almost-neighbor joining Hirden; I see how someone gets there. Naturally we tend to slap the wartime black and white filter on it even decades later, but the reality is always very grey. It’s one of the things I think Colony did well, at least in the first two seasons, particularly with the resistance bombing a line of recruits for the redhat police force, recruits who were there because they needed to feed their families. It gets hard to pin down the definitive good guys and bad guys in that kind of situation. Thanks for posting this, I appreciate the different perspective. As an American I can intellectually understand what happened, but culturally WWII is something that happened “over there” for us. Everyone’s grandfather fought, everyone’s grandma worked in a shipyard or a factory, but actually being invaded and occupied was always a fairly distant prospect.
I spoke with someone who worked on the that film (Let's call him M. As far as I know he still works in Hollywood), He had previously worked with the director who had been pushing to have it made. Sadly he died and Stephen Spielberg got the gig. M said every time he met with Stephen and the studio during initial stages and pre production, the original vision would shift slightly. When asked if he was proud of the film as made, he said, at first he was, then each time he saw it, the less he liked it. It was not what was originally intended.
Not sure of how i got to this clip, but am happy that i did. Very interesting analysis providing perspectives i never would have come up with on my own. Thanks!
I would love an analysis on the factions and species in a setting like Mass Effect and how much they draw from Human concepts from the Cold War and memories of distant cultures.
While I'm a sucker for any post-apocalyptic or dystopian novel or film, the older I get shows like Resident Alien and films like Mars Attacks! are the ones I enjoy most.....
I don't know if you are familiar with any video games in the genre, but X-Com is a great series on the subject. From being an organized military to being a militia insurgency. It's pretty fun.
That initial blurb about Alien Nation made me think of District 9. Obviously both stories are told, and consequently turn out, differently. Similar premise though.
There is so many cool things you've touched on. But I suppose the two things I will recall is the SG-13 patch, and that someone else actually knows about "Alien Nation."
Guns, Germs, & Steel (Diamond, non-fiction) ruined several parts of War of the Worlds to me. Basically it just emphasized how ridiculous it is to think that the foreigners would die to our diseases, instead of (predominantly) the other way around. And also it's ridiculous to think we'd have a hope of defeating foreigners from "across the ocean", since the very act of sailing that ocean proves dramatically superior technology, to a degree unlikely to be overcome by determination alone. _Metaphorically_ it's fine, and I just have to suspend disbelief enough to enjoy otherwise fun romps like Independence Day without getting hung up on the impossibility of it all. Also, this vid was a staggeringly deep and fascinating analysis of way more content than I expected it to be (which is probably just my error, since I've seen quite a few FH videos at this point; I knew what to expect going in). Well done!
I think ur essentially assuming that they arrive in an Americas and not in a Trans-Saharan Africa. There are reasons to assume they arrive in a Trans-Saharan Africa instead like if the civilization has eradicated its own disease, left its own home world and live in artificial habitats for the most part while earth is essentially, where Humans started and have always lived. They are also technically superior to us, so that doesn't contradict the book, so I don't see it as a criticism. Given the aliens were more defeated by disease than by human determination.
@@ikengaspirit3063 What? No, how is that related to any of the points I made? Immune systems develop by evolution. The longer evolution evolves a species in a disease-rich environment, the better the innate immune system. Well by default, assuming roughly equal evolution, it suggests these aliens have simply existed as an intelligent species longer and that's why they're here, but it suggests their immune systems are similarly more inherently advanced than ours. Now there are factors that will cause an organism to evolve weaker immune systems over time: like if the environment contains no diseases whatsoever or if medicine tech always saves basically everyone, regardless of how weak their immune system (which thus causes those weak genes to be passed on to a new generation). But those factors are likely the result of things like (a) advanced medicine tech which would also defeat human diseases and (b) advanced quarantine strategies (the most obvious and basic of which is that _they flew here in space-worthy spaceships which are airtight._ ). So each of those reasons why their immune systems would be weaker are also reasons they wouldn't be bothered by human germs.
@@ikengaspirit3063 Nothing I said even remotely assumed that. It doesn't matter. What matters is how immune systems and diseases on a planet evolve over time. (And medicine technology too.)
I implore anyone who wants to check out the musical to start with the original 1970s album first. The updated versions aren't bad, but they're not as good as the original and you just can't replace Richard Burton as the narrator.
I was lucky enough to see the revival tour before they replaced Richard Burton's voice over and most/all of the cast with younger versions. To me, there was a definite decline in quality with the younger ones.
Fallen Skyes the TV series turns Earth into a proxy of an intergalactic war too. War of The Worlds the Musical?, wow I like most of the versions, even the funny Mars Attacks.
Half Life 2 would’ve been a great example here too, especially with the combine doing the exact same thing with recruiting human volunteers to police humans for slightly better rations and healthcare. But as I understand it, this is a film/tv/historical channel and video games don’t necessarily fit here
Half Life 2 was out during a period when I wasn't doing any gaming, part of a whole body of great stuff that I never played. At some point I want to go back to it, but time will tell if that actually happens.
Fascinating video (as usual). On the concept of alien civilizations using Earth for resources: are you familiar with the video game "Prey" (Xbox1/Playstation 2 era, I believe). Very good game (IMHO) with an interesting take on the topic (again, IMHO). Also, an aliens with inscrutable motivations: Lovecraft? I look forward to every new video
I never got around to playing Prey. One of these days I really should. I suspect Lovecraft is going to come up sooner or later. Got a couple things in mind.
@@feralhistorian Just don't confuse it with the more recent game of the same name (trademark squatting, IIUC.) Lots to think about with that one, too, but it's a very different sort of alien invasion.
In V it wasn’t just the water. It was also us. They said they were going to take many slave soldiers to fight their enemy. Makes you wonder who the enemy was. They also were eating us.
Your description of "colony" is so awfully similar to our own current society that im convinced that humanity currently actually is occupied by some other group. Some group that may be a close subspecies of human or even just fully human, but certainly doesnt consider itself as mainline human. Certainly the current society is only possible if our elites are deeply convinced that they are some kind of special favored community, while everyone else is just cattle to be managed or exterminated.
Thank you very much for this interesting video essay. I mention that I am planning an audio adaptation of WAR OF THE WORLDS for next year, and really wanted to focus on something deeply individual in terms of theme. Not survival per se, nor colonialism in any form nor any analog for Muslims or Foreigners or even corporations. Rather the question of "what will we refuse to do to survive?" Much more BEYOND THUNDERDOME or THE LAST OF US rather than INDEPENDENCE DAY or V:THE SERIES. So in a way a return to the novel's roots--the Martians are a mirror of us, of what we can choose to become. Again, thank you.
That said, a video talking about the game's story as a whole (early access as it is) and thoughts on the goals of the various human factions (the one word summary of their motives: Resist, Submit, Exploit, Escape, Cooperate, Destroy, and Appease) would be right up this channel's alley.
surprise you did not mention district 9 when talking about alien nation. which both start the same way alien refuges where one is giving a chance to enter our society but still deal with prejudice the other is put into a camp.
@@feralhistorian yeah it has kinda disappeared, what I liked about it was that the Aliens continued to try to conquer Earth but wasn’t overt w it. It really took on more of an Invasion of the body snatchers feel. Great video! Thanks!
The final season of War of the Worlds was a complete deviation from the beginning. It seemed like the new showrunner simply took some concepts he wanted to use in a series and ran with them, ignoring the original premise. He wasn't shy about eliminating characters from the original cast, either, killing off Ironhorse and Drake (ostensibly because he "didn't know what to do with a character in a wheelchair"). Might as well have cancelled the show outright, as the changes killed it, anyway. ='[.]'=
Have you encountered a story in which an ancient alien species returns to earth, as it was originated from it and forced to leave only to discover durong landing that the planet is already occupied by a new peoples?
Edit: Never mind. What I found is what she was remembering after all. (Sigh) Does anybody have a link or a search term to find the War of the World's musical? My wife has been trying to find it and.I'm failing.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
That ending talking about how Science Fiction allows us to talk about contemporary issues from a hypothetical perspective really hits home. So many people think sci fi is just about laser guns and FTL travel, but it's so much more. It really gives a writer freedom to explore ideas without stepping on toes, but still allows its viewers to think about how it applies to them. Great video as always, wish I had more to add but you seemed to nail it.
"Star Trek: The Original Series" used this to great affect back then.
agreed. Speculative fiction allows us to view our contemporary issues through a lens we aren"t used to, thus circumventing the reflexive defenses we have for our position on this issue we would engage in in a more forwards presentation of the issue.
Very important is that we don't actively inject contemporary biases though. If you want to talk about problems or ideas that affect today without it being poisoned ahead of time, you can't actively represent contemporary 'sides' or people representing those 'sides'. You see it all the time. Characters clearly and intentionally or even explicitly meant to represent, say, Trump. Or Musk. Or Bezos. Or whoever the media apparatus has decided is bad today. It gets in the way of telling a good story. And that's the main problem: People constantly want to preach their beliefs without making their story worth listening to to begin with.
As a former media prof, I can say your analysis is very astute and detailed. "Ubuntus with spears can't stop the British Army, but malaria can."
I think you meant Bantu, Ubuntu is a nebulous phrase related to unity and interconnectedness.
I thought it was a programming language.
@@donkeysaurusrex7881 operating system
The language takes its name from this vocabulary word
Such an interesting analysis. Humanity being just in the way of some other peoples' wars is something that is, in a way, terrifyingly realistic
It's unfortunate that Colony didn't get to finish its story. It was taking that on directly, though taking its time about it.
I really enjoyed Colony. God I hate it when they just up and cancel a show without a send off.
There is a series of novels by Mick Farren that are set in the same universe (ish). In one novel, it ends with the aliens coming to humanity and dominating them through a mind control weapon. The main character's last act of defiance as a thinking being is picturing a monkey smashing something. The next novel in the sequence is set a long time into the future where humans are raised on worlds at kept at a stone age level of technology so they can be harvested as soldiers for their alien masters' war.
@@ptonpc Is it worth a read?
I loved the setting of Colony. Really enjoyed "Captive State" too, which is kind of the same premise.
Colony being unable to finish its run was truly tragic. It was one of the best alien invasion sci-fi shows I've ever seen. However, it wasn't just about resources. Like "Falling Skies", Earth was just a battlefront between two alien empires and the mechanical invaders were both harvesting our resources and "toughening us up" so humans can fight for their masters.
And not to mention the alien nation was AI in robot suits.....
Yeeees. Colony was freaking awesome. Shame it got canned...
I'm surprise you didn't bring up District 9. But awesome video!
I'm a little surprised I didn't even think about District 9.
@@feralhistorian _District 9's_ setting is basically _Alien Nation_ with more elaborate alien costumes.
@@feralhistorian no one does, its trash
@@DaytonaRoadster at least it didnt have degenerate "artists" like chappie
Wrong it's actually great, people retroactively pretending the movies message is way more obnoxious than it ever actually was is always the same clique I hear about it, and it's a very disingenuous one
The fact that the Richard Burton intro to The War of The Worlds wasn't used is outright criminal.
I forgot about 'Alien Nation'. Saw that in my teens and thought: 'Pinto Bean bald caps in LA...a bit on-the-nose.'
I'd love to see your take on the various authoritarian dystopia stories with an eye to which most closely resembles our current 'situation'. I'm of the opinion we're closer to a combination of 'Harrison Bergeron' crossed with 'Idiocracy' than we are to '1984'. So much attention on avoiding 'Big Brother' let 'Big Mother' sneak right up on us.
I've been making a lot of Harrison Bergeron references these past few years. There's quite a few aspiring Handicappers General out there.
She has, unfortunately
@@feralhistorian Last I checked Alien Nation was going to have a reboot but then they turned it into its own original thing. I think its supposed to premier on Paramount.
Half Life 2 also comes to mind. Especially since the changes to the enviroment are partially by accident
It really took me far too long to realize how blatant of a reference that Striders are to the fighting machines. And in more ways than just having three legs
WRT the use of tanks in the war of the world's scenario, I think turtledove did a fairly good job in his Worldwar series. At least in the first couple of books. He made very good points on how war economies work and how a force coming across the stars does not have unlimited resources to throw into the fight when the home team isn't completely devoid of technology.
He also brought in the perspective of the invaders as individuals rather than a monolithic block all with everyone holding the same opinion.
Yes, Worldwar was great. Not only with the Lizards having to adapt 1940s tech to manufacture their own munitions but our own nations rapidly adapting their tech down to our own level.
I still feel a little bad for Ussmak. Little scaly dude couldn't catch a break.
@@feralhistorian I tried comparing him to willie from V or Albert from Alienation but I somehow find less pity for Ussmak. Somehow the other two aliens are more personable than Ussmak
I'm just glad it was the first Turtledove althistory WWII story I read, because there's finding a niche and then doing what Turtledove did. WWI and II where the Confederacy had won the Civil War had a few interesting thoughts (even if American!Hitler is a played out trope,) but it turns out replacing technology with magical artifacts on a one-to-one basis doesn't add much, even with gratuitous race swapping.
That's usually why I don't finish Turtledove books. He does a lot of one-for-one equivalency.
But Worldwar and Guns of the South stand above.
@@feralhistorian guns of the south was half "those racist bigoted old southerners" and the other half was smug turtledove horseshit. he really has a tin ear for southern social behaviors and all his southerners are self hating whites who just havent been shown the wisdom of magical negroes. if AWB was there to do as they claimed, they would have been running things when they showed up. its a bit too far of a leap to think they wouldnt have gone full technocrat with gearing the south up to take on the world. One airplane could have changed the civil war and zero aircraft, yet they have tons of gold Krugerrands, and millions of AK's. it had promise but has plot holes stephen king would be able to drive a dumptruck through
"We're a road trip twinkle " great line
"Twinkie"
Right at the end there you got me thinking about the "Men in Black" franchise.
The day-to-day job of an MIB agent would actually be some combination of witness protection, ICE, and a protective service for foreign dignitaties.
During the opening scene of MIB2 we even see agent J taking a new Rookie on a welfare check which goes badly and ends in a police shooting.
And we laugh because it's happening to resident aliens and not real people.
read the malibu comics MIB the movies lightly reference since theyre so dark.
When I was little, my dad was watching TV and I had an early bed time. I asked him what he was watching. He was a natural born Chicagoan, and said, "Warda Whirls". It sounded amazing - weird laser sounds, shooting, it sounded amazing! Who or what was Warda and why was it whirling? I was fascinated, but soon fell asleep.
All these decades later, I still think of it as "Warda Whirls"
The 'musical' is really a live performance of what many consider a seminal adaption of the novel: Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of The War of the Worlds.
This was a double album released in 1978, with many different mainstream musical artists of the time contributing their talents to the production. Notable is the narration throughout being done by the velvet baritone of Richard Burton, and some incredible album art illustrating the major story beats of the novel, such as the cylinder, the Thunderchild and the Red Weed. It may be somewhat dated when you compare it to modern musical productions, but making it required many advancements in musical recording technology, almost all of which have survived to the present day.
There is a SACD version that is remixed into 5.1 surround which is absolutely worth listening to, as having Jeff Wayne's orchestral-pop main theme crash out with the strong strings is quite the experience, especially for a first-time listener. It was one of the first times I was exposed to the surge of 1970s concept albums (ELO's Out of the Blue being another stand-out, with the vinyl double-album coming with a press-out cardboard model of the ELO saucer-station), and I've been a fan of the genre ever since (Another sci-fi one is Mitchell/Coe Mysteries: Exiled. Steve Coe is not, as far as I know, any relation to myself, but my dad bought it solely for that reason).
Anyway, another excellent video from you, FH! Definitely spot-on about the varying allegories that are almost continuously discussed in science fiction.
If only people would learn to listen to them…
I had completely forgotten about that album until I ran across it while hunting for more obscure War of the Worlds spinoff clips. I need to track down a good quality copy of the live performance, I've only watched parts of it on a sketchy youtube dub of someone's VHS copy.
There was an old DVD of it released in 2006 that still features Richard Burton's narration from the album. Its rendered on a terrible giant talking head, but afterwards they replaced Burton with Liam Neeson and its just not the same. From what I can tell the later versions are sold under the "New Generation" label, and they have different instruments and sometimes melodies. Honestly, the original album from the 70s is the best, but the 2006 DVD is the closest live performance you'll get to that version.
The videogame is also good if you can track down a copy. It crashes randomly on modern hardware though, so if you have an old Windows 7 kicking around play it on that.@@feralhistorian
@@feralhistorian And since you've proven you can survive the singing of Justin Hayward, you could watch the BBC series 'Star Cops'. Come to think of it, it was so long ago and obscure, I'm not entirely sure if it existed. But the Justin Hayward theme music is still burnt into my memory.
Basically the best version of the story that is not the novel or the 1950's film.
@@PhaedrusAK Yep, BBC. Late 1980's (87/88?) A very short lived series, I seem to remember the BBC was always having strikes around that time which hobbled many shows.
The fact that this video only has 10,000 views after six months is borderline criminal.
Now it's at 20K. This channels is gaining! Including me.
@@Sekir80 that's great to see. I think his biggest problem is his thumbnails. I love them, but the algorithm favors MrBeast-style slop.
Too intelligent for many people today.
"We're a road trip Twinkie..." Hahaha, you crack me up!
EARTH: FINAL CONFLICT Would have been worthy of mention. Created by Gene Roddenberry (Star Trek) and made after his death. The series was about a resistance movement fighting against Aliens who have come Earth peacefully but for some ulterior motive. The show was '90s syndicated, produced in Canada, Cheese at it's best!
I have fond memories of watching random episodes of that show way back. It always felt like it fell short of its potential, from what I recall.
@@feralhistorian The final two seasons really jumped the shark. But before that, it was actually generally excellent.
To defend the tank point, if we're trying to describe a modern day "Garrison" force, it's somewhat quicker to move tanks into a defensive line than field pieces. More expensive of course, but part of tanks role is mobile artillery. Battle lining them in battalion sized formations is ridiculous, but it isn't entirely out of their role to place them in defensive embankments to serve as field guns. In fact, outside of the Soviet Sphere direct fire artillery was pretty much completely phased out.
'Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy'is the most accurate depiction of our current society. The earth being 'bulldozed into oblivion' to build an intergalactic highway.
America's alien invasion movies from the fifties, especially WotW and Earth vs. the Flying Saucers, struck me as having a real Pearl Harbor mentality to them. The attacks were unexpected and massively devastating. They also played out like fears of a Soviet nuclear strike by again being unexpected and massively devasting plus centered on highly strategic targets like Los Angeles and Washington D.C. Steven Spielberg's WotW was a little different. There was greater focus on the people trying to escape the invasion. It was almost like Spielberg was trying to put you in the shoes of people in Poland trying to escape the Nazis. Just the sort of thing I would expect from someone who directed Schindler's List. If you've never seen it before, I recommend the 1970s British series UFO. It plays out more like the Battle of Britain. You have interceptor pilots stationed on the moon battling repeated aerial assaults on the Earth. Just goes to show you how each country's experience of WW2 shaped the way it envisioned an alien invasion.
Great points.
I vaguely remember watching UFO a few times when I was a kid. I'll have to give it another look as I slowly work my back through to some British sci-fi.
For me UFO has held up a lot better than Space 1999 even with its lavender wigs
@@stardog62 I would love to see a playful reboot of UFO. But they better include the sexy gals in their lavender wigs and mini skirts! Lol
There was a series conceived by Gene Roddenberry called “Earth. The Final Conflict” in the first series of which it was difficult to see whether it was about alien invasion or about humans unreasonably resisting alien aid. Certainly humans working for the aliens became somewhat Fascistic.
I liked They Live as an allegory over all other alien invasion films. It was entertaining, humorous and thought-provoking all at the same time. John Carpenter is a subversive genius in the horror/sci-fi genre of cinema.
I Love how colony is very similar to the combine from half life 2.
I'm very disappointed that colony was discontinued
Man, I have to say that I am incredibly lucky to have been gifted your channel via the algorithm. I haven't encountered a video yet that was less than 'good' and I don't expected to. You given me numerous thought experiments and potential discussions to have with my family.
Nothing will beat Jeff Wayne's version.
Damn Falling Skies was cool. Colony was my jam too.
Brilliant videos as always. And your references of nerdy sci fi is off the charts!
Nice choice of jacket. SG-1, you have a go!
Excellent video - well thought out and great production as ever! Thank you
What was the name of the animated section at 11:27 ?
It's from War of the Worlds : Goliath, which can be viewed at ua-cam.com/video/dwdS_lTzGak/v-deo.html
It’s like fighting fire with a sword. Oof! That is a breathtaking simile and very apt for this topic. ❤
Really really loving your videos, so few people really look into these movies and books on a deeper level
Another sci-fi book series that explores some of these themes is, oddly, the “Doom” series. Yes, it is a series of books based off the Doom first person shooter video games of the 90s, and they’re far better than they had any right to be.
By the way, check out the 1998 BBC short-lived TV series Invasion:Earth. a masterclass in the pointlessness of defending against an overwhelming attacker unless you are prepared to sacrifice everything and then gaining a pyrrhic victory at best . Bleak but well worth watching
I'll give that a look.
I remember it at the time. I second this. I have the soundtrack somewhere. The main American actor (who was also a producer) wanted to make a second season showing the continuing 'war' but the BBC had a habit of only funding short lived series, a sort of 'one and done'.
It was a terrific series and a great deal of fun. 😊
Just re-watched that recently. Still good.
"There was even a musical."
Dude, I don't know whether it's down to exposure or differing cultural perspectives (UK versus US), but hearing Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of The War Of the Worlds referred to as an 'also-ran' hurt. I felt instantly indignant! :D
I didn't give it its due.
Jeff Wayne's is fucking baller. my dad had it pirated off the radio on reel to reel. i remember being about 5 years old, waking up at night, creeping into the room where he was listening to the unscrewing in the common. I was transfixed.
My parents scarred me and my two younger brothers for life playing a cassette copy after dark on interstate road trips. Ooooooh laaaaarrrrrr!! Beee woo, beee woo, beee woo.... Decades later I still can't listen to that album at night on a lonely highway.
I love this channel’s approach to scifi breakdowns. Like a literary analysis!
Spielberg’s War of the Worlds has a subtext of the shock of 9/11 with its setting in New York, the ordinary work day shattered by alien invaders and destroyed architecture, humans turned to ash, the flyers of the missing, and the futility of the war on terror (demonstrated by the tanks) as some sort of holy enterprise.
Such a great analysis! Please keep them coming.
If ever there was a movie that needs to be remade, it's THIS ISLAND EARTH. It would probably need to be a miniseries as I don't think you could really tell this story in a two hour movie.
How has nobody mentioned the Tripods trilogy by Jon Christopher?
It's a book rather than a film, but I highly recommend 'Starships of the First World War' [Edit: _Spacecraft_ of the FWW]. The premise is that Humanity's big reverse-engineering-fueled tech bonanza following the events of War of the Worlds was _not_ in mechs (tripod or otherwise) or heat-ray weapons, but the real meat of it was in the antigravity systems built into the Martian landing cylinders.
Cue all the major powers developing fleets of interplanetary warships as soon as their recovering industries allowed. Initially, there was a frantic rush of early designs built to defend against a Martian second wave - but when that never materialized, second- and third-generation ships were built for a punitive expedition to Mars. And eventually, of course, the designs grew into serving more or less the same roles that real-world navies do: to project national power and keep the neighbors honest.
On the surface, the book is concerned with each nation's approach to developing its ships and doctrine, written in a similar vein as an introductory illustrated history book, like a Jane's Guide or an Osprey Books entry. But under that layer, it also casually drops a lot of tantalizing world-building hints about what happened to the Martian civilization (almost entirely collapsed well before the Earth fleet arrived) and how, while we could replicate the technology, the underlying science was much weirder and less well understood. It's unlikely, but I really want them to do a sequel.
I hadn't heard of that one, but now that I've found it I'm definitely giving that a look.
That novel sounds awesome!
YOU GOT A GREAT
CHANNEL! THANK YOU 😊
Your channel is awesome. I just found this channel, and now I watch it all the time, literally. Great content and incredibly insightful and eye openeing takes on these topics and subjects. Keep 'em coming 🧔🏿♂️
As a historian your take on "the greatest story never told" would be much appreciated
I realized I have binge watched a couple of these without actually subscribing, so I just took care of that. May I say this is fascinating the way you have blended history, politics, philosophy, and science fiction. And though I have not seen coloony, Earth Final Conflict, and especially the original V for me are fascinating invasion tales because they get into the blurred lines of collaboration. V was disturbing in that way, though the later tv series wasn't worth much. And it's interesting to see the Jeff Wayne musical at least mentioned. I only know a few people who know what I am talking about when I recommended it. Anyways, this is great stuff.
Binge watching means watching multiple videos in a row, not two.
@@slappy8941 the first day I discovered Feral Historian I did watch four or five at my treatment. One way or the other I don't know if this proves anything. I would invite folks to engage in a discussion of the books or movies that are covered here. Been awhile since I read some, others like Fitzpatrick's War are new to me. Would love to engage the actual material if you are interested.
Yes. What he said.
I don't really have anything else to add to the topic of the video. The video was great, and I can't really think of anything to add right now.
Instead, I will mention a layer of the readaptation of stories. And why I so dislike the Tom Cruise version of War of the Worlds.
The book is quite wholesome, as it follows a man moving through England during the Martian invasion in the attempt to get to his wife. And then, the book has a happy ending, being reunited with her. I love stories that get really dark but then have a happy ending.
Been years since I read it. And now I want to read it again.
In the Tom Cruise of the Worlds on the other hand, not only has the story shifted to the United States. The life situation of the main character is completely transformed.
In the book, we have a loving marriage.
In the movie, we have a divorced man, broken home, his two kids are sent back and forth with their mandated dual custody, and both his kids hate him. While his ex-wife that he still has feelings for, well she is with another man.
So really, they did a great job adapting the movie to our modern way of living.
I haven't seen any other versions of the story.
But now finding out that there is a musical... now that... now that is something. Absolutely most definitely... something. Something for sure. Sure is something that is.
That's a really good point about the Tom Cruise film. I hadn't considered that angle.
@@feralhistorian Also, sort of connecting to Colony.
The dad of one of my neighbors was in the Norwegian resistance movement, fighting the Germans wherever he could. In many parts of the country they could only move at night, because of the large number of German sympathizers, especially in rural areas of many smallholders.
Our pre-war Labor government wanted to join into the USSR. Not just become a friend or ally with the Soviet Union, but to actually become a Soviet Republic under Moscow.
And then, many had been radicalized by the Soviet invasion of Finland, where a great deal of Norwegians from east in the country went to fight as foreign volunteers.
Creating these solid pro-German areas in various places.
Creating this sharp divide in Norwegian society.
Then, another almost neighbor, he joined "Hirden" as a teenager.
He did this to preserve law and order.
He struggled a lot later in life. Not because of anything he may have done, but because everyone hated him. Previous friends, family, neighbors, they all hated him.
Thankfully, our post-war purges were mild compared to Denmark, Holland, and France. So, at least he survived.
Then a third almost neighbor (dead now but I know his grandson). His farm was constantly robbed by fellow Norwegians during the war. Constantly.
But he turned the other cheek.
The German presence in the region was pretty high, being only 8 miles away from Stavanger Airport.
So, if he had reported it, there could have been a crackdown. Which would have made him a collaborator according to pretty much everybody.
But, being a devout Protestant, he turned the other cheek, and allowed both animals and produce to be stolen.
He was so devout in fact, that when the post-war Labor Government seized 4/5ths of his extensive property, he did not take them to court.
Which was a good thing for me, because my grandfather would buy one of these land-cleared farms they made from his property 30 years later, which is why I have this farm today.
On the other side of the little mountain almost bordering my farm, around 2 miles away.
The man living here was a well-known ideological National Socialist during the war. We're talking having a massive swastika on the wall, picture of the Fuhrer, the whole shebang.
But any and all signs of his ideology evaporated as soon as the war ended. In all haste, he had made sure to burn it all to avoid the post-war purge.
Which worked.
The local school had a teacher who became very well-known in the area for being a bit part of the "Teacher's rebellion" or "Teacher's Protest" in 1942.
Where the teachers refused to implement the Nazi oriented education demanded by Quisling.
I forget details about him, but I am pretty sure he survived the war and continued to teach afterwards.
Sadly that school building was demolished before I was even born.
The Stavanger Airport was basically built to become the international airport that it is today by the Germans. Where it served as a vital base to bomb the English.
And a lot of the industry and the large industrial concerns of the region were either started or were expanded to become what they are today because of the occupation.
Like one, although I forget his name now, started his business making steel wheelbarrows for the Germans during the war.
---------------------
I wish we could get more stories about what happens after the occupation.
But then again, every European country that was occupied by the Germans wants to forget what they themselves did after the war.
Re. your almost-neighbor joining Hirden; I see how someone gets there. Naturally we tend to slap the wartime black and white filter on it even decades later, but the reality is always very grey. It’s one of the things I think Colony did well, at least in the first two seasons, particularly with the resistance bombing a line of recruits for the redhat police force, recruits who were there because they needed to feed their families. It gets hard to pin down the definitive good guys and bad guys in that kind of situation.
Thanks for posting this, I appreciate the different perspective. As an American I can intellectually understand what happened, but culturally WWII is something that happened “over there” for us. Everyone’s grandfather fought, everyone’s grandma worked in a shipyard or a factory, but actually being invaded and occupied was always a fairly distant prospect.
I spoke with someone who worked on the that film (Let's call him M. As far as I know he still works in Hollywood), He had previously worked with the director who had been pushing to have it made. Sadly he died and Stephen Spielberg got the gig. M said every time he met with Stephen and the studio during initial stages and pre production, the original vision would shift slightly. When asked if he was proud of the film as made, he said, at first he was, then each time he saw it, the less he liked it. It was not what was originally intended.
Only found your videos yesterday, very enjoyable watch I have to say! Thank you.
Thank you for your amazing analysis! I enjoy all your vids!
This video just randomly popped up in my feed and I gotta tell ya dude this video was great! instant sub from me!
Not sure of how i got to this clip, but am happy that i did. Very interesting analysis providing perspectives i never would have come up with on my own. Thanks!
Your closing lines always get me. 🤣
I know I'm just some random person on the internet but I really like your videos. Keep them coming!
Online, we're all randos.
Well done, you are a gentleman and a scholar. It is rare to find analysis of this level anymore.
For that alone the video was entertaining.
Glad to see you mention Colony.
It was a missed opportunity to not mention how Colony brought "global elitism" into the alien invasion formula.
I would love an analysis on the factions and species in a setting like Mass Effect and how much they draw from Human concepts from the Cold War and memories of distant cultures.
The Jeff Wayne War of the Worlds was, and still is, a prog masterpiece.
But still they come!
Modern adaptations always seem to omit the episode of the Artilleryman.
While I'm a sucker for any post-apocalyptic or dystopian novel or film, the older I get shows like Resident Alien and films like Mars Attacks! are the ones I enjoy most.....
I love what you do man. Keep it up!
idk how the algorithm gave me this video, but you have earned a sub
I don't know if you are familiar with any video games in the genre, but X-Com is a great series on the subject. From being an organized military to being a militia insurgency. It's pretty fun.
That initial blurb about Alien Nation made me think of District 9. Obviously both stories are told, and consequently turn out, differently. Similar premise though.
@Feral Historian
I would love to hear your thoughts on Captive State, District 9 and maybe even Fantastic Planet. Thank you!
Superb presentation. 👍
There is so many cool things you've touched on. But I suppose the two things I will recall is the SG-13 patch, and that someone else actually knows about "Alien Nation."
Algorythm comment algorythm comment
Also Falling skies mentioned!!!! I loved that show as a kid
Hey, the musical is fire and so is the War of The Servers.
Guns, Germs, & Steel (Diamond, non-fiction) ruined several parts of War of the Worlds to me. Basically it just emphasized how ridiculous it is to think that the foreigners would die to our diseases, instead of (predominantly) the other way around. And also it's ridiculous to think we'd have a hope of defeating foreigners from "across the ocean", since the very act of sailing that ocean proves dramatically superior technology, to a degree unlikely to be overcome by determination alone. _Metaphorically_ it's fine, and I just have to suspend disbelief enough to enjoy otherwise fun romps like Independence Day without getting hung up on the impossibility of it all.
Also, this vid was a staggeringly deep and fascinating analysis of way more content than I expected it to be (which is probably just my error, since I've seen quite a few FH videos at this point; I knew what to expect going in). Well done!
I think ur essentially assuming that they arrive in an Americas and not in a Trans-Saharan Africa. There are reasons to assume they arrive in a Trans-Saharan Africa instead like if the civilization has eradicated its own disease, left its own home world and live in artificial habitats for the most part while earth is essentially, where Humans started and have always lived.
They are also technically superior to us, so that doesn't contradict the book, so I don't see it as a criticism. Given the aliens were more defeated by disease than by human determination.
@@ikengaspirit3063 What? No, how is that related to any of the points I made?
Immune systems develop by evolution.
The longer evolution evolves a species in a disease-rich environment, the better the innate immune system.
Well by default, assuming roughly equal evolution, it suggests these aliens have simply existed as an intelligent species longer and that's why they're here, but it suggests their immune systems are similarly more inherently advanced than ours.
Now there are factors that will cause an organism to evolve weaker immune systems over time: like if the environment contains no diseases whatsoever or if medicine tech always saves basically everyone, regardless of how weak their immune system (which thus causes those weak genes to be passed on to a new generation).
But those factors are likely the result of things like (a) advanced medicine tech which would also defeat human diseases and (b) advanced quarantine strategies (the most obvious and basic of which is that _they flew here in space-worthy spaceships which are airtight._ ). So each of those reasons why their immune systems would be weaker are also reasons they wouldn't be bothered by human germs.
@@ikengaspirit3063 Nothing I said even remotely assumed that. It doesn't matter. What matters is how immune systems and diseases on a planet evolve over time. (And medicine technology too.)
Outstanding l truly enjoyed your comintary....and like the Stargate jacket
You get a chuckle out of an artillery gun on an armored vehicle in a line formation getting ready to attack? 73 easting as now entered the chat.
Info Request: From what film, TV series, or adaptation is the "Floating Black Sphere" scene derived, as seen between 0:27 and 0:35?
It's from a 2019 BBC adaptation. www.imdb.com/title/tt8001226/
I implore anyone who wants to check out the musical to start with the original 1970s album first. The updated versions aren't bad, but they're not as good as the original and you just can't replace Richard Burton as the narrator.
I was lucky enough to see the revival tour before they replaced Richard Burton's voice over and most/all of the cast with younger versions. To me, there was a definite decline in quality with the younger ones.
Well done Sir
Good Video
Gotta love that the Los Angeles collaborators are Red Hats. Seems a little too accurate.
Fallen Skyes the TV series turns Earth into a proxy of an intergalactic war too. War of The Worlds the Musical?, wow I like most of the versions, even the funny Mars Attacks.
Are you telling me that this show Colony, is basically Half Life 2?! I gotta see this
The big difference with “Alien Nation” is that we cannot interbreed with the invaders. It’s us or them.
We will see about that
Half Life 2 would’ve been a great example here too, especially with the combine doing the exact same thing with recruiting human volunteers to police humans for slightly better rations and healthcare. But as I understand it, this is a film/tv/historical channel and video games don’t necessarily fit here
Half Life 2 was out during a period when I wasn't doing any gaming, part of a whole body of great stuff that I never played. At some point I want to go back to it, but time will tell if that actually happens.
Fascinating video (as usual). On the concept of alien civilizations using Earth for resources: are you familiar with the video game "Prey" (Xbox1/Playstation 2 era, I believe). Very good game (IMHO) with an interesting take on the topic (again, IMHO). Also, an aliens with inscrutable motivations: Lovecraft? I look forward to every new video
I never got around to playing Prey. One of these days I really should.
I suspect Lovecraft is going to come up sooner or later. Got a couple things in mind.
@@feralhistorian Just don't confuse it with the more recent game of the same name (trademark squatting, IIUC.) Lots to think about with that one, too, but it's a very different sort of alien invasion.
This break down is cool and all but now I just want an SG patch
In V it wasn’t just the water. It was also us. They said they were going to take many slave soldiers to fight their enemy. Makes you wonder who the enemy was. They also were eating us.
I'm disappointed you didn't include MST3K's version of "This Island Earth". ;-)
Your description of "colony" is so awfully similar to our own current society that im convinced that humanity currently actually is occupied by some other group. Some group that may be a close subspecies of human or even just fully human, but certainly doesnt consider itself as mainline human. Certainly the current society is only possible if our elites are deeply convinced that they are some kind of special favored community, while everyone else is just cattle to be managed or exterminated.
Thank you very much for this interesting video essay.
I mention that I am planning an audio adaptation of WAR OF THE WORLDS for next year, and really wanted to focus on something deeply individual in terms of theme. Not survival per se, nor colonialism in any form nor any analog for Muslims or Foreigners or even corporations. Rather the question of "what will we refuse to do to survive?" Much more BEYOND THUNDERDOME or THE LAST OF US rather than INDEPENDENCE DAY or V:THE SERIES. So in a way a return to the novel's roots--the Martians are a mirror of us, of what we can choose to become.
Again, thank you.
The musical is amazing btw
Well I'm convinced I'll have to play Terra Invicta again!
A Protectorate run-through would seem most appropriate given the video... but you might be looking for more of a cleanser than an example, I suppose.
That said, a video talking about the game's story as a whole (early access as it is) and thoughts on the goals of the various human factions (the one word summary of their motives: Resist, Submit, Exploit, Escape, Cooperate, Destroy, and Appease) would be right up this channel's alley.
For me, it's either humanity first or the academy.
"They Live isn't a movie, it's a documentary."
- John Carpenter, Roddy Piper
surprise you did not mention district 9 when talking about alien nation. which both start the same way alien refuges where one is giving a chance to enter our society but still deal with prejudice the other is put into a camp.
The War or the Worlds tv show at the end of the 80’s was pretty good too.
I remember liking that one too. I was intending to reference it here but it seems to have largely disappeared, save for worse-than-usual VHS rips.
@@feralhistorian yeah it has kinda disappeared, what I liked about it was that the Aliens continued to try to conquer Earth but wasn’t overt w it. It really took on more of an Invasion of the body snatchers feel. Great video! Thanks!
The final season of War of the Worlds was a complete deviation from the beginning. It seemed like the new showrunner simply took some concepts he wanted to use in a series and ran with them, ignoring the original premise. He wasn't shy about eliminating characters from the original cast, either, killing off Ironhorse and Drake (ostensibly because he "didn't know what to do with a character in a wheelchair"). Might as well have cancelled the show outright, as the changes killed it, anyway. ='[.]'=
🤔 I just *knew* you would follow up that line with “but malaria can…”
Maybe I’m psychic or something?
( 😏! )
This is a fantastic video you’ve earned my subscription!
I looks forward to the next War of the Worlds adaption where the over confident aliens get bogged down in trench warfare
"Our billionaire Chad aren't literal space aliens..."
They got to him.
Whoever wants peace among nations must seek to limit the algorithm and its influence most strictly.
Throughout this video, I was thinking: "I wonder if he is going to talk about/show X" and then you did.
Have you encountered a story in which an ancient alien species returns to earth, as it was originated from it and forced to leave only to discover durong landing that the planet is already occupied by a new peoples?
4:48 - WTF, is that Benedict Comberbatch in effing Independence Day?!?
Edit: Never mind. What I found is what she was remembering after all. (Sigh)
Does anybody have a link or a search term to find the War of the World's musical? My wife has been trying to find it and.I'm failing.
What is the first alien invasion story
They Live should get a sequel, where the alien overlords are invaded by another species.
What about District 9. or is that not really an invasion as they sort of broke down