Which Diamond Is The Traitor Responsible For Pink Diamond's Death!? - Steven Universe Wanted Theory
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2017
- PINK DIAMOND'S SHATTERING WAS AN INSIDE JOB! LET'S LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE, AND POSSIBILITIES WE CURRENTLY HAVE! Let me know who you think is the true culprit.
►Subscribe for more Steven Universe! / sliceofotak. .
►Follow me on Twitter!
/ sliceofotaku
►Follow me on Instagram!
/ sliceofotaku
Music:
►Malik Bash - • Malik Bash - Ghosts [N...
Icon by:
►Kitsune Zakuro - / kitsunezakuro
Outro Art:
►Discount-Supervillian - / discount-supervillain
Outro Music:
►Mykal Williams (CARTOON UNIVERSE) - • Temple Laundry
Check out my brother's channel!
►CrowToons - / crowtoonsnow - Фільми й анімація
![Pink Diamond Was Supposed to Be RED DIAMOND? [Steven Universe: Wanted Theory] Crystal Clear](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EKBZIEXk3Uo/mqdefault.jpg)
I hope blue Zircon is ok. It takes a lot of guts to do your job so well that you accuse your own tyrannical rulers.
ΝΙΚΟΣ ΝΙΚΟΣ I think she's most likely shattered because when Steven barely came in yellow was already considered to shatter Steven for just looking different
yea same
Ikr! I feel she'll be shattered! I hope not, though. She's such a likeable character!
ΝΙΚΟΣ ΝΙΚΟΣ I bet off screen somehow Lars and the off colors somehow recruit her
Smasherfan88 Cool theory!
I don't think YD's anger is necessarily a sign of guilt. Assuming that she is innocent, YD has every right to be angry. She was just accused of killing someone who is essentially a sister! It's understandable that she would react violently, because the very idea would be unthinkable to her.
Yes but YD doesn't seem to care as much for her fallen sister and cares more about getting what she wants, after all she wants people to forget Pink Diamond
+Professor Quack
10000000000000000% agreed.
Not to mention the affront to her godhood.
That's a response that is normal and expected from a god accused by a mere mortal.
Don't say sister. Gems aren't related.
Wize Demon Well, she said "Yes, of course we still love her, and we're always thinking of her."
Professor Quack yes, but she already got extremely defensive before blue zircon accused the diamonds of shattering pink diamond. So there's that.
Apparently in Rebecca sugars writings she wrote that White Diamond said the trial was a waste of her time
That's just what I heard from another comment
Makes sense.
She is all powerful
(white not rebecca)
Pheme Speaks I mean, Rebecca too..
If anything Rebecca is more powerful because she chooses what's going to happen
Do you remember this comment
Yaeh you was right congratulations ♡
Remember when Steven first learned about Rose murdering Pink Diamond? How Pearl and Garnet acted? They acted disgusted, remorseful, as though they knew FOR A FACT that Rose Quartz did it... And yet now we know that she didn't. Now, we saw in the Answer that Rose and Pearl(and more than likely with other rebel gems later on) made terror attacks on the diamonds and their forces, so it wouldn't be a stretch to say that Rose, Pearl, and Garnet had all showed up to do one such terror attack. However, as Zircon stated, the killer had to have been able to get past everyone, including Pink Diamond's Pearl, without raising a ruckus in order to land the blow. But like we saw in the Answer, Rose's terror attacks are flashy and loud, the ANTITHESIS of what would be needed. Not only this, but Rose Quartz is a warrior, not a spy. Her design was as a defensive warrior, big and strong. But what if both Rose and the killer were there? Then that same old question would rise again. Why would Pearl and Garnet lie about it to Steven? But, what if they've been tricked? We've met gems who can see the future, gems who can freeze both gems and humans in mid air with a wave of their wand, telekinesis, and more. Would it be such a stretch to say that there's a gem out there who can alter the past? Or, more accurately, CHANGE THE MEMORIES of gems? Let's take this to it's logical conclusion. What if the gem who slew Pink Diamond were ALSO able to change the memories of everyone around her? Then it would make PERFECT since why the murder weapon was reported to be Rose's Sword, as doubtless no one outside the Rebellion would know it could never shatter a gem, thus making it the obvious murder weapon to the killer. Steven assumed it was the Breaking Point, but REMEMBER, Rose poofed Bismuth because she couldn't agree with that. This also ties into her not being the killer, as Rose was a HEALER, and would NEVER shatter a gem willingly. OR, I could be completely wrong. But, c'est la vie. We won't really know 'till we're told.
Oooh that's a good theory! I like to think that the culprit is White Diamond, and like you said, maybe she does have the ability to change the memories of Gems.
When one thinks of it, the Diamonds show that they can manipulate essential aspects of Gems. Yellow Diamond, with her electrokinesis, seems to be able to alter the *body* of Gems (as shown when she destabilizes and poofs Yellow Zircon). Blue Diamond, with her pathokinetic aura, can alter the *emotions* of Gems (as shown by her mini-breakdown in "The Trial" and perhaps explains why Steven was crying her tears). Perhaps White Diamond has the ability to alter the memories or the *mind* of Gems. All of this can explain how and why the Corruption song/light works. They joined powers (by fusion?) into an attack so deadly that it was able to alter *the bodies, emotions, and minds* of Gems (both rebel and non-rebel) stranded on Earth. Perhaps the altered memories is a side effect of the corruption song. The Crystal Gems may have been mostly protected from the corruption spell (by Rose's Shield?), but a little bit still got through and affected their minds a bit.
@Pm Perhaps she considered her new status as "Near goddess murderer" a good thing for Earth, as it would keep Homeworld off Earth's back. Obviously, it had been rather effective, or so she thought.
Dalamus Ulom Garnet and Pearl reacted the way they did because they believe that Rose was the one to shatter Pink Diamond as she potentially could have told them that she was the one to destroy her. But just because she took the fall for Pinks shattering it doesn't automatically mean it's true. She was already a war criminal and probably took the fall or even the credit from someone else. There's a bigger conspiracy going on that Yellow and even Rose could be involved in. Can't wait to learn more :3
So the killer is.......
the trolls from frozen
+Dalamus Ulom
At first we thought it was rose, but look how the story twisted. If a diamond were to murder pink diamond outside the palenquin either she shapeshifted and hid. Someone that big can NOT hide from the whole army. She couldn'tve killed in private or else everyone would've not been commanded by a shattered gem. So I agree it was probably a gem like that, but maybe not that powerful or else she would've killed in private. Maybe her powers only activate at a certain time so she killed in front of pink diamond. Or it could've been another quartz soldier who stole the sword. But that much power in a gem would mean she would've killed all the gems. So I agree. It was another gem. The scriptwriters have to throw us for a twist! That's why steven universe is so awesome...And now looking back I find a long written message bc I
Y'all making theories and I'm just like, "BLUE ZIRCON! MY BABY!!"
Kala Keys I agree because Zircon is my birthstone(December).
302 is eternal life My birthstone is a Emerald (May) but Zircon is my innocent blue cinnamon bun! She doesn't deserve any punishments!
blue zircon protection squad
SAME! SHE'S WIFE!!!
SHES MY SISTER
Well, there's a Gem with access to all of Pink Diamond's security systems, a Gem that Pink would have trusted, that would have been able to persuade her to leave her palanquin... her Pearl.
SbAsAlSe HONRe Gasp!
SbAsAlSe HONRe yes but how would a pearl still shatter her like with her weapon in fact maybe the diamonds personal pearls might not even HAVE weapons who knows tho who knows
Kaper Juice Draws maybe our pearl shattered pink pearl
Anissa Andromeda Maybe our pearl is Pink's pearl.
SbAsAlSe HONRe that's ridiculous.
The more i think about it, the more i think her Pearl somehow did it. I mean, maybe her pearl was a follower of Rose Quartz but more radical like Bismuth. She had everything to win, be free, everyone be free and the war ending. If most of Pink's gems are lighthearted and energetic like how Blue's gems are diplomatic and logic, it wouldn't be against reasons that her Pearls would backstab her. She would be allowed near Pink and would be the closest when she is out of her Palanquin. As the Sapphire relies on fact before being able to view the future, none of them would have considered a Pearl as a possible threat, same as the Agates. Maybe she even shapeshifted into Rose so that either she would gets the kill and be viewed as a bigger threat and be seen as an hero in the eyes of her followers, or use Rose as a scapegoat. Yellow, somehow knowing that it was a Pearl, the lowest of the low, who shattered a Diamond, would hide that fact and cover it up to avoid any other gems thinking that if a Pearl could shatter a Diamond, can't they? A Rose Quartz shattering a Diamond would be better. But what about Rose's sword that can't shatter gems? No one said the sword used was Rose's, it could be any sword, and we know a Pearl that uses Swords.
But, what if Yellow Diamond didn't know anything? What if she was more like a Father in a trial against the murderer of his daughter? This would explain why she didn't want to hear anything, how she wanted to get it over quickly, she wanted ROSE TO PAY for her crimes. Seeing how Rose was being exonerated by B.Zircon and proved to be innocent, it must have put her in such a rage. Like a Father who believe his daughter was murdered by that GUY, seeing that guy getting away with what he did must be disgusting and Yellow couldn't get it anymore, she wants the murderer to pay and to pay right now before the "system" does not allow it anymore.
(If The Crystal Gem's pearl was White's pearl, this theory would make sense) During the trial, when Zircon asks "Where was her pearl?", both Yellow and Blue pearl were startled by her words. When Eyeball said that Rose shattered Pink in 'Back to the Moon', pearl got really messed up and afraid. Maybe all of the pearl's were in on it, including Pink's pearl. They must've set it up, and every time someone mentions Pink's shattering, it messes them up. This could also lead to why pearl joined Rose, maybe so she could escape her diamond because White figured it all out (This would also explain White's absence during the trial). Whatever they did, pearl knows about it, and it's really messed her up.
Anubscorpiak Mantis You've brought up a very good point, but there's a problem. If she shape shifted into Rose wouldn't people have seen, since Pearls always stand in front of their diamonds, and since pearls are always with their diamonds, Pink Pearl wouldn't have a chance to join the crystal gems.(Unless she was a pearl reassigned to Pink Diamond and joined the Crystal Gems before then) Apart from that, I think your theory is incredible and well thought out, and personally I think any of the diamonds being the one to shatter Pink Diamond is too obvious.
OH MY GOD ARE YOU SAPPHIRE!?? YOU PREDICTED A SINGLE PALE ROSE
I think it's White Diamond. Hear me out!
Did you know the ONLY thing that can break a diamond is - another diamond!?!
Now people think it's Yellow Diamond cause of her guilty face and the Pearl's reaction.
But I pose a second opinion!
As stated by Eyeball, Pink was destroyed by a sword. But, in the Bithmuth episode, Bithmuth said that the sword can only destroy the physical form of a gem!
I believe that Rose Quartz poofed pink diamond and then presented it to the only other gem that could shatter a diamond - another diamond!
But which one?
In the episode, "Friend Ship" (Go watch it) you could see a mural on the wall. You can inspect three gems. One is clearly Rose Quartz holding a gem, a very pink gem (a.k.a PINK DIAMOND) presenting it to a White Gem, or White Diamond.
Isn't it fascinating how one of the highest-ranking gems didn't bother to attend the trial of the alleged shatter-er of Pink Diamond. Maybe because White Diamond didn't want to become a suspect once all the evidence starts pointing towards her!
Any thoughts...? I know I'm horrible at explaining.
THANK YOU!!!!!!
holy jesus
agreed
Sofia >
*MIND BLOWN MEME*
Nice theory
yellow diamond: i didn't do it
zircon: why the fuck you lyin
Why you always lyin'
mmmm oh my god, stop fucking lyin'
*mmmm oh my god, stop fukin'* using old memes
Motιoŋlέѕѕ I'm betting it's white
Motιoŋlέѕѕ LMAO😂😂😂😂😂
Motιoŋlέѕѕ When yellow diamond got triggered, I be like "why she bein' a lil defendy"
I think that Pink new she was in danger, she had a feeling that someone wanted her out of the picture. She obviously can't go to white, and it will kill blue to know. So she goes to Yellow. Yellow tells her to stop over reacting, that no one was after her. But when Pink really does get shattered, Yellow feels tremendous guilt for not taking her seriously. That would explain why it seems like she's hiding something from Blue. It would crush Blue to pieces to know they could have prevented it if Yellow had only taken their little sister seriously.
I agree with this very much!
Lauren Brown Holy gem that is brilliant
Lauren Brown I still think yellow did it, and then she felt some guilt after because she shattered her sister diamond
I think it was Yellow Diamond or White Diamond. The reason I think it was yellow is that she never was sad about her being shattered. Also in The Trial she just wanted to shatter Steven real quick so they could stop thinking about her so nobody notices it was her. The reason I think it was White Diamond is that why would she be hiding? She probably is hiding to hide from being guilty. Both of them would make sense.
Karen Robb I don't think it was white diamond as in the background you can she her, and she is huge. In fact I think that home world is part of white diamond. in the moon base the mural of white diamond shows that she is holding home world, but I noticed that around the edges of home world (on the mural) there is a gap between home world and her, a ring of nothingness where White diamond has no abdomen or stomach. it would make sense that home world is part of white diamond. since I think it is, it would be almost impossible for her to go to earth and shatter pink. on a side note maybe white diamond is blue, yellow, and pink's mother so to say or the original diamond that planted the other diamonds... in herself, since she is home world.
The Crewniverse is obviously trying to push White Diamond as the culprit. With the way that she wasn't at the trial leads us to beleive either she was insanely busy with something INSANELY important as to miss her "Sisters" murder trial, or she didn't care at all about Pink Diamond. Idk about you people, but i'm stuck on the idea that white diamond did it.
Blue_Wolf SAME!!
Why? I dont understand why bring someone that has never appeared in this whole series yet? I think it's understandable for White Diamond to not attend the court
I mean, Holly Blue Agate wasn't in the series yet either until "The Zoo" happened.
I'm thinking either White Diamond shattered Pink for her possible empathy for humans or seeing Pink as a threat to her, or that Pink asked Rose to shatter her for whatever reason. Maybe Pink wanted the rebellion, possibly because she saw the wrong in what they were doing.
crashstart maybe as a parallel to rose giving up her life for steven to exist maybe pink gave her self up for the crystal gems earth or do rose herself to continue to exist peacefully
okay so for some reason everyone keeps saying yellow diamond is suspicious and yes, maybe she is but 1- that'll be way to easy and Rebecca sugar would never do something THAT easy to pick apart. and 2- I'm pretty sure she was acting so angry and impulsive to contrast the difference between her and blue diamond. it's kind of like what they say about sisters, if there are (for example) four sisters, one is usually more impulsive and angry, one is usually more wise, one is usually a crybaby and the last one is usually the more compassionate sister. And I am by no means saying that yellow is NOT suspicious but I just find it that hard to believe that Rebecca Sugar would do something so simple. There's something we're all missing here; maybe we just need the last piece of the puzzle to figure it out and that's white Diamond. We have to wait until she comes into the picture before making any assumptions because we don't even know anything about her, and her introduction could open an entirely new can of worms. (I'm not saying WD killed pink)
I agree with lily. I read a comic by Rebecca (not saying the name) It actually SHOWS that blue diamond loves pink d and yellow was mad because blue WAS and WANTED to support pink with her love of earth and sense Yellow HATED earth and started using it as a nest and to destroy earth she'd have to get rid of pink and SHATTER (not shatter the GEM but the feeling for earth) the emotions towards blue when it comes to pink. So she would HAVE TO SHATTER PINKS DIAMOND!!! It's easy. No offense Yellow
And i'm not saying that it might've not been white but i mean if blue LOVED pink and ADORED her love for earth and started thinking about supporting her but yellow hated earth it just makes sense.
It makes more sense that Yellow did it, but it still doesn't make much sense considering Yellow D also loved Pink D just as much. She only hates the Earth because it's where her sister died and it's what Rose fought for. What real motivation does she have for shattering someone she was likely close to?
I think your wrong the obvious conclusion would be to think rose quartz did it since everyone is implicating her. So idk how thinking yellow did it is an easy thing. That’s a very shocking ass thing
Lucas Martinez well idk about loving her just as much she seems pretty over pink diamonds death and annoyed that blue is still crying over it
If Ever someone wants to Sue me, I want Zircon as my Lawyer.
XxTigerReaperxX same tbh
XxTigerReaperxX same
XxTigerReaperxX but which one the green one or the blue one
CATTASTIC RINEARSON What the fuck do you mean green one? It's yellow. Also, the yellow lawyer isn't a Zircon.
Pr3h1 st0r1c oh my bad
Yellow has the power of destabilization.
DragonMaster 45 No She has te power of NECK
Bonnie The Bonnie I want to feel the inside of her neck *wink*
Seefido The heck?
Bonnie The Bonnie *POWER OF NECK*
DragonMaster 45 yellow give that good succ
Why would it necessarily have to be a Diamond? When the blue Zircon says "It was one of YOU!" He could also have been including the Pearls as suspects, who were in frame when he said that. They would have the power to orchestrate it "my diamond told me to to tell you" and very little is known about Pearls' motives other than just serving the Diamonds.
They are servants to the diamond's rember when pearl faked being saphires pearl. On the episode why would the be able to kill pink
Trent Jones what are you talking about😧 he said only a.diamond 💎 could do it
the only gems that can shatter a diamond is another diamond
Trent Jones the dimonds would shatter there pearl
what if white diamond the fusion of all diamonds??
that would explain why she never shows up
nah, if Blue and Yellow were to fuse, they'd make Green Diamond, most likely a dark green. But add White Diamond to the mix and its a light Green Diamond. People have speculated on this before man
nooo! if pink diamond would be still around, and all of the (all 3) would fuse, maybe the outcome would be white diamond? for example the additive color model, where cyan, magenta and yellow together are white! (pink diamond, yellow diamond and blue diamond)
that would explain why she is never there.. because they are no lange abel to fuse!
White Diamond's gem is on her forehead so it can't be a fusion of pink, yellow and blue. Even WD was a fusion, she would have multiple gems
After pink was shattered, her gem was removed from the gem symbol but white was not. Therefore...
when people disprove the theory but like.... you still wanna hold onto it........ i want white diamond....... to be a fusion,,,
...I think it was Onion, who has ultimate power and authority, and is the most powerful being in Steven Universe...
BlankKnightt seriously, that little pain? I doubt that highly.
BlankKnightt im convinced
Of course!
Don't speak ill of my onion
*makes circle with hands on chest*
Pff, obviously!
No shattered pieces.... no confirmation of death. Is Pink Diamond even dead? Can memories be altered, and can the murder scene everyone witnessed be staged in a way where it was convincing?
Smother me in Bacon, Baby I have so meny questions now!
Indeed, there isn't any reason for the likes of Eyeball Ruby to lie about what she saw, let alone insist that it was Rose Quartz...
But if Pink Diamond and Rose Quartz were secretly in collusion, perhaps for the entire Rebellion itself, then it would be child's play to fake a shattering.
All Rose would need to do is poof Pink Diamond's body, then swap her Gem out with a Glass replica with a bit of slight of hand, easily shattering the Fake Diamond with her sword while everyone watched.
Thus, the Crystal Gem Rebellion would have appeared to have done the impossible, shattering a DIAMOND, a feat that would surely scare Homeworld off of Earth.
...What could possibly go wrong?
Smother me in Bacon, Baby omg that is so right I mean no gem 💎 no evidence of death and a biased witnesses who is too say that she can be hiding somewhere on earth 🌏
Well that's just it, Pink Diamond and Rose would only need something that LOOKED like Pink Diamonds' Gem that would then be easily shattered.
They could have very well had a pink glass "diamond" ready to swap in, and Rose could then make a big show of smashing it in front of Pink Diamonds' Court, giving them plenty of eye-witnesses to relay the news back to Homeworld.
Hmm...Zircon spoke in a which suggested that there wouldn't have been any possibility of a Rose Quartz gem able to seek an audience with Pink Diamond directly. A soldier gem such as Rose Quartz who possess such a low status couldn't have breached the security around Pink Diamond without an alarm. ESPECIALLY, a Rose Quarts gem recognized as being traitor would have escalated situation if she'd appeared anywhere near the area Pink Diamond and her court inhabited.
Honestly, all of this is so bizarre. No Sapphires alarmed her, Pink Pearl is missing, and nobody was there to protect Pink Diamond.
Whomever, if they actually committed murder, had to be so cunning and allusive because she even slipped passed future vision of her sapphires. This person must have been a diamond or a high ranking Gem whom shape shifted...no..no..no..no..no..no..even that can't work. Do you know why? It's because we know the site of her shattering was an open and exposed area and this mystery assassin would have been detected shapeshifting, right!? Also, a high ranking gem would naturally receive so much attention that all eyes would be on her..
The only real lead we have is the sword. Eyeball said she remembers her sword and Blue Diamond mentioned the sword as well. We have to know what the sword looks likes because it certainly wasn't Roses' sword. If a sword...someone skilled enough with a sword..it couldn't have been Pearl because she's a..Pearl and she would have been..a harmless fly whom was ignored so badly that she may have been able to get close to pink diamond. I don't know maybe Pink Pearl did it LOL (sorry..i was rambling)
None of this makes logical sense. The factors that impeded our understanding is no alarm went off and the sword...
It was PINK DIAMOND HERSELF
SliceofOtaku! I just realized white diamond could have done it because in the mural thing in the temple it shows Rose what looks like to be presenting Pink Diamond or something. Then, White Diamond seems to look like she's gonna destroy it!
Other than that, keep checking for clues SliceofOtaku! Pls, notice this! I feel like people are gonna steal my idea! •w•
Honestly I think it's white diamond cause like.... where she at tho? She could have shattered her, shattered the witnesses, and fled.
Complete Corruption I have to disagree, white diamond has no reasons for shattering pink diamond while there are many reasons yellow diamond could've done it. (jealousy, power, the attention of blue diamond)
SilverXtreeem but we don't know anything about white D. who knows what she thought about pink d
I think white diamond is home world
Like we saw her head thing so that could by her head and home world is her body
Sinister Squirrel speaking of pink d , what colour do you think lars' dingdong is
bettydog 1 I would think pink as well. Lmao.
i dont think yellow shattered her, but i think yellow had something to do with it. and the fact that the sword cant shatter
Exactly. Pink Diamond could NOT have been shattered by Rose's sword, because the sword was made specifically for only poofing gems, not shattering them.
Also, who is Pink Diamond's Pearl?
I believe that the Pearl we knoe belongs to white diamond(Pearl is so pale that at times, she even seems white. Blue pearl is blue in hue, Yellow pearl is yellow in hue, ect.)
So who was Pink Diamond's pearl?
-Fantasy is my Reality-
Also, the diamonds' personal pearls have gems in the same spot of their diamonds.
-Fantasy is my Reality- steven coulda said that honest Steven coulda conducted himself way better during the trial.
Gus Hersey I don't know. She definitely ahas something to do with it as yellow zicron said to Yd "We won the case my diamond!" Maybe this means the trial was arranged by yellow diamond to turn out how she wanted it to turn out. She wanted to move on during blue zicrons speaking. She is too dodgey
Jedijazz4 Yeah, I agree. But, I didn't really expect anything different. that's steven for you...
I love how it looks like zircon is speaking with your voice at 0:18 (that called sync up? Idk)
ITS BLUE DIAMOND!!! Want to know how I know? Because how did Blue D. Know Pink D. Was shattered by a sword ? And When Zircon said it was 1 of those 2, Yellow D. Could possibly know Blue D. Shattered Pink D. Because her attitude got so suspicious when Zircon said it was one of those 2 and Yellow D could be trying to protect Blue D. And also, it's always the one you least expect because you would think it's not Blue D because of the way she keeps crying but she could be faking it or those could be real tears from the guilt of shattering Pink D!!!
well, there is a way she could know, yellow diamond could've told after she did it, or white diamond if she did, and I believe she would believe it, as Rose's main weapon was a sword.
This is turning into a game of freaking Clue or something
Awkward Potato I know right
Awkward Potato it was Miss scarlet in the ballroom with the candle stick.
Blues Clues
Blue diamond say that it was a sword, but Bismuth say that the sword can't shatter gems and all the blue diamond subordinates have the strongest personalities of the gems(Lapiz, Sapphire, Aquamarine), including the attorney gem, plus Blue diamond has the power to implant feelings in others and for last she wants everything pink related (the zoo for example)
Brings a whole new meaning to the one of the lines from What's the Use of Feeling Blue: "Why would you want to employ her subjects that destroyed her". I know that YD was moving the rose quartz bubbles when she says that, but that movement was probably just a misdirection to distract the viewer and make the viewer think about Holly Blue and the Famethyst. I feel that the Crewniverse was alluding to what was going to happen in the Wanted special and Zircon's assessment. And further proving that YD knew something. Idk, just something that my brain cooked up in the shower.
it was pink diamond. she is presented as a very caring gem, and so if she was truly that nice, she wouldn't want a huge war, so stages her death to limit the lives lost in the war
Gray Wolf u got that from another video
How in the world did you know?
Gray Wolf holy shit are you Jesus??
ding ding ding you were CORRECT
Okie dokie Lars has a portal in his hair like lion right? Ok we're on the same page, and Steven healed Lars and that turned him pink which means rose healed a regular lion and turned it pink lion is not pink pearl or pink diamond.
UniWormIDK MinecraftandRoblox Sir that is a VERY good point.
UniWormIDK MinecraftandRoblox I think that it might mean Lars can warp to earth? Maybe can warp that far because he's connected to lion.
I also think Lars is going to become a bad ass leader of a new rebellion on homeworld
What if lion is pink diamond? Rose watched something shatter her and healed her like steven did with lars? Anyway Pink might of cared for earth as it was her only colony, yellow wanted the rescources and only way to get them would be to kill pink? Maybe because she was a diamond she couldn't be healed fully, just partially.
UniWormIDK MinecraftandRoblox Lars should be able to shoot portals out his mouth. I think that's how he will get home in the near future
THANK YOU. This is not even an argument anymore. If Steven's powers simply brought Lars back to life, just Pink and with a portal to Rose's pocket dimension(and also a lack of a need to eat and sleep), then we can say the same thing for Lion. Lion was a normal lion in Rose's pack, we can see that in Buddy's Book, where the lion that wakes up Jamie has the same shaped nose as lion, yet no other lion in the pack has that. Lion was then killed, maybe due to natural causes, maybe due to a gem monster. Either way, Rose brought Lion back to life, and before she died, put all of her artifacts beneath the tree within her pocket dimension. Don't you think it would be odd if Rose, say, had the power to turn gem shards into a living entity(a LION, nonetheless), which gives said entity the same powers as another one of the powers that she already has? That just makes things complicated.
I think White Diamond is a God, they showed her image being huge in the home world sky, and her mural shows her holding a world (which could be home world).
maybe but the gems has the "moon goddess" sooo I dunno.
What if White Diamond is actually Homeworld itself? What if she's the planet that all the gems in existence live on, and she's the only reason their planet is still habitable?
Christie Parks I've actually thought that that for some time now. That she is essentially the creator of it all
Hanna-Leigh Adams I personally like to think that White diamond's 'ship' is homeworld, that way, blue diamond, yellow diamond and pink diamond would have to reassemble a whole body of sorts with their ships (arms and legs with white's being head and torso) if they came by to visit...dunno, just a thought.
As soon as you wrote that my mind went to Power Rangers
Slice of otaku the type of nights that to cry because a tv show is going to end
Fun to learn... Pink diamond shattered pink diamond
*IIITTTTTTSSSSS JJUUUUUSSSSSSS AAAAAAA THEEEOOOOORRRRRYYYYYYY!!!!!!*
LOL blue zircon be matpat on the shiz 😂
You're not funny.
That's where you're wrong buddy pal chum kiddo bucko mate
I'm writing that down.
Fizzy Fruit YT omg imagining zircon saying game theory sounds just like mat pat
its loving jesus legal jet??
am I the only one who thinks blue peal has one eye because in the trial when blue diamond made everyone cry blue Pearl had one tear...
Maybe? Might just be a design but I like your thinking
I mean, it would be similar to Sapphire and we know it can happen...
She was on a lateral angle
MissLonely :3 You still would've been able to see the tear when it reached the bottom of her rounded head.
milkymotels - that's what I think I just rewatchef the part and it's only one I thought I was bugging lol
3:53 - "it's too clear-cut"
Heh. Diamonds. Clear cut.
I'll see myself out.
Maybe we haven’t seen white diamond yet because she’s so very old that she’s reaching the limit of gem lifespans, getting sickly and dying, maybe even having some kind of gem Alzheimer’s? And the other diamonds don’t want to alarm the populace, so they keep it a secret. And maybe it’s been happening for thousands of years, and that’s why they made Pink Diamond, and why Pink Diamond’s shattering was such a huge deal. Maybe they needed to replace White Diamond, and that would take centuries of training and so on to get her on an even keel with the other diamonds. It would also explain why she wasn’t at the trial for Steven.
well, Rebecca said that white diamond thought the trial was a waste of her time
This whole thing has left me _SHOOK_
(edit: Dang, all these likes came in faster than Topaz.)
(edit #2: Over 200? Holy cow. All these likes make me feel like I'm on another world.)
(edit #3: You've all shattered my notifications.)
(edit #4: All these likes make me feel as happy as Ruby and Sapphire being together)
(edit #5: I'm going to feel blue when all these likes come to a stop.)
(edit #6: Woke up to over 800 likes. Holy crap, guys. That is a huge cluster of likes.)
Pandata OMG ME TOO 👌🤣
Pandata IM. S H O O K
Pandata same...
Pandata We all know Yellow diamond has something to do with Pink Diamonds shattering...
TokenBlackGuy, I definitely agree
Yellow definitely knows something
Jennie Hollo
Yup she was the one that stole my Dr. Pepper
IM ONTO YOU YELLOW DIAMOND
The background used for your personal character, on the left side I couldn't help but notice the "clouds" are in the shape of white diamond.
The Blue diamond theory explains yellows actions pretty clearly to me, good theory!
Oh I predict that sliceofotaku will uplaod a video! What a mystery
Are you that Sapphire?
Duck Tales It was Padparacha not Sapphire
L and B Productions padparacha is a type of sapphire
L and B Productions padparacha is a type of sapphire
Aesthetic_Addy I foresee a wondrous joke in your future about sliceofotaku video. How fortunate
Been hearing about memories being altered. And maybe that's just it. White Diamond has the power to alter memories. It's like a power similar to Blue Diamond who alters emotions and maybe Yellow who alters anger (?) and she lashes out her anger through poofing a gem's physical form. Just a theory. I mean WD has her gem in the forehead presumably she is mentally-adept while BD and YD have their gems on their hearts meaning they are emotionally adept. And combine all their altering powers would equal a power able to corrupt a gem. Disrupting them mentally (WD), emotionally (BD) and physically (YD)
WD did it and altered everyone's memories.
Allen Calub I Like this theory.
But just asking, if Pink Diamond wasn't shattered, what would hers be?
Allen Calub there are parts of your comment I like a lot
that is a good theory, and if you think about it it explains how white diamond (or all the diamonds if they really did fuse)was able to corrupt the gems on earth and make them forget, if they forgot it
this makes a lot of sense! :D
I'm so happy someone could piece together that the only way to break a Dimond is with another Dimond if they r going by how strong each stone is
The person who shattered Pink Diamond IS... No one she faked it.
ITS NOT BLUE!!! Why would she cry actual tears and want B.Zircon to explain what happened, when it could be revealed its her. When BZ said "...it was one of YOU" Blue was in shock. BECAUSE, she knew that she didn't do it....so that meant maybe her sister DID IT! WHICH SHOCKED HER! Then when Yellow went Ballistic (obviously guilty), Blue said "Yelloiw stop it why are you doing this!" With obvious anger, She was once again asking a question because she found her sister GUILTY. It might not be yellow...BUT IT DEFINITELY WASN'T BLUE!
Huggie Auggie Good theory, but gems don't have sisters
Huggie Auggie yellow diamond might be guilty about pink diamonds murder because she went ballistic ... and we cannot say weather or not white diamond could have killed pink diamond ... because we don't know much about white diamond there for I cannot say anything about white diamond because we don't even know her!
it could be an act...you have to consider the possibilities. It could be anyone
well... DUH! yellow d is guilty
+TheCrystalClod Thank you, but I think they are sisters. Sisters come from the same source. Of course In the Gem world it's a little different, but I'm pretty sure they are Gem Sisters. :/
the trail was my favorite episode up to date😊
You misspelled trial
Golden Opportunity Lars head was awesome
I wonder how Sadie is going to act
Golden Opportunity My fav was Off Colors because it actually made me cry.
*trial
Also saw you at Momocon- I was the splatoon inkling with the ink roller.
_casually looking for comments after a single pale rose_
I think the real killer was actually Pink Pearl! If you listen to Zircon, after she says "And where was her Pearl!?" Blue and Yellow Pearl immediately look guilty, but there are reasons why they aren't the culprits. (Since they're always by the Diamond's side.) When they look at eachother and feel guilty, their scared for Pink Pearl since all of the Diamond's Pearl seem to have a close relationship, so them looking at eachother signifies them pretty much saying, "Oh crap. She's caught her pink handed!"
I hate how everyone is guessing Either White or Yellow diamond. Don't y'all think it can be a possibility it's Blue Diamond? I know she was crying and wanted to find out how Pink was shattered but what if Blue unknowingly shattered Pink and wanted to find out how she did it that's why she was like "It was a Sword"
It's Blue Diamond. It's too obvious to be yellow. seeing how blue acts with steven, so vicious but then can switch back to being the victim. It's like she's trying to convince herself. Obviously yellow is the clear choice, but it's almost like blue has an alternate personality sometimes. In horror movies it's always the one you least suspect. Like she's psycho. so I'm voting blue.
BigMushroom Top- Yellow Pearl looked at Blue Pearl to see her reaction as Blue Pearl stared on. Which leads me to believe Yellow Pearl, much like Yellow Diamond, knows more than Both Blue Diamond and Blue Pearl. Because, to me anyway, It seemed they where more shocked then guilty. Like, the both of them realized Zircon had a point, that had Pink Pearl been there she would/should have warned her Diamond of danger. Unless she was to busy fusing with that possible Ruby ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°). Just kidding. Although I seriously think P.D's Pink Pearl is part of Rhodonite fusion.
BigMushroom Top pearls can also create illusions of gems. perhaps pink pearl tricked everyone into thinking rose did it.
I think pink pearl was our pearl and she did it for rose
My theory is that it was Pink Pearl, seeing as she was very close to Pink Diamond at the time, and as Zircon said, Rose herself appearing from nowhere would be very unlikely, along with Rose's dislike for shattering etc. As the leader of the rebellion though, she is the best candidate for pinning the blame on.
Once more, Pink Pearl would have the same gem placement and colour scheme as Rose, so amid the confusion, if Pink Pearl shapeshifted into her, it would be very easy to make it look like it was Rose that did it, convincing bystanders such as Eyeball (who seems fairly certain in what she saw) that it was in fact Rose.
Her motive however, is a mystery. She could be working of her own accord, hating her position as a Pearl servant and deciding to shatter her enslaver, perhaps being one of the Rebels.
She could have been doing so as part of Pink's own plan to shatter herself, for whatever reason that might be.
Or perhaps she was ordered to shatter Pink by another Diamond, who then was able to cover it all up, be it Blue, White or Yellow...
Strangenesses The Person double agent?
Strangenesses The Person What? Stop pulling things out of your ass. We know literally *nothing* about White Diamond.
Adele Brown
Also, when they mentioned Pink Pearl it got quite for a second-
Adele Brown No i dont think this is true because while Eyeball and Steven were in space Ruby knew the exact color Rose gem was and it's not likely that pink pearl did it since pink gema are slightly different colors.
Adele Brown I like to think about other gems but there is just a fact of reality about diamonds that only a diamond can cut another diamond
Greg is the guilty diamond.
Until we see or know of what happened to Pink Diamond's shattered gem I'm assuming that Rose and Pink worked together so Pink could fake her death.
TheCrazyTalkKid kind of right?
almost
Blue diamond would literally have to be a psycho to shatter pink then get super depressed over someone else doing it XD
She doesn't come across as... entirely sane, but I agree she's a very unlikely suspect.
Me: white diamond didn't show up
you: duh she's the main leader of all gems
me: the case is about death of 1 of 3 leaders of all most gems
you: white diamonds a murderer
XD
the monster legend maybe White Diamond is just the fusion of Yellow Diamond and Blue Diamond + Pink Diamond
@katzdroid9 No that can't be because fusions have all of the gems of the gems fused and white diamond only has one gem on her forehead, therefore, she cannot be a fusion
the monster legend it seems to me like yellows decided to take some more power and used the rebellion as an excuse. white diamond simply feels herself above the others or some other reason.
Pink diamond. Pink Diamond Shattered pink diamond.
If you were a gem you would most definitely be a Zircon. xD Being that you are so good at gathering such info!
Knowing that rose was a rebel, yellow diamond could only place this on her. since she isn't part of the diamonds army, and hard to get it was a perfect cover up!
remember the mural with Rose holding the diamond and someone attacking her??... well who does it look like.
JanuaryzOwn Do you know what episode???
TMNT _fan can't really remember but it's a mural on a ceiling in an episode ...lemme do my research
JanuaryzOwn Thank you so much 🌹💎!!
Found it.. it's the episode where they go inside the pyramid.. there's images on google
JanuaryzOwn the teacups episode?
white diamond
dude it makes so much sense
Why are people saying that it is possible for another gem to shatter pink diamond, look how powerful yellow diamond is she literally poofed a gem with her finger and zapped the next one. How can a rose quarts even go against a diamond, they are extremely op
ty sam
OP? This is not roblox
The Evil Person Who comments The term OP has existed looong before Roblox
The description of the event makes it sound like a sneak attack, and if you plunged the right weapon through her gem...
...which goes back to Zircon's point. Pink Diamond, her guards, and her Pearl would have to be really incompetent to let Rose Quartz get into a position where she could pull that off.
And the sword isn't capable of shattering gems.
ty sam ALSO HER SWORD IS N O T A B L E T O S H A T T E R A G E M
Blue loves pink
Yellow loves Blue
Yellow attacks pink to get blue
yellow blames pink's worker
Blue is sad
Blue's lawyer discovers that it was Yellow
Yellow is mad
Kennedy Ozemwogie Oooh what a scandel!!
Lil MOnster I Know right!
That made no sense.
how?
Kennedy Ozemwogie that was the best thing I've ever heard.
0:22 you just answered the question without knowing it.
What if Pink Diamond was shattered by her own pearl? Maybe she wanted more power and she thought she would get it by shattering Pink Diamond. We don't exactly know everything about Pink pearl so she might have thought differently about the power and work than the other pearls or maybe the pearls have more power now than before to prevent them from shattering their diamond. Maybe Pink Pearl even had the power to cover it up as well.
SplattingPichu You're partially right...
Are we going to talk about the massive white diamond in the Homeworld sky? Like, in depth?
Random Commenter Ikr
too *_thicc_* to exist
more like too *_thicc_* to reply.
more like too _thicc_ to reply to themself
you're right, too _thicc_
iiCheezdoodleRBLX Did you just reply to yourself? XD
I like the theory about Blue Diamond. It would explain why Yellow Diamond was acting like she was hiding something. I personally think the emotion at the end of "What's the use of feeling Blue" from yellow diamond was her feeling guilt for hiding important information form Blue Diamond, while also morning for Pink Diamond
Hey Otaku, if you look closely at the floor beneath the gigantic chairs ,u can see it is coloured blue and yellow but if u look even closer, there's a thin line showing the white platform.Its just a theory. Hopefully you read this
yellow diamond is like the red herring here.. or should i say, yellow herring
kkourbe
Boi
kkourbe yasssss
Omg so my friend and I just had a theory a week ago that the trial can support!!! Here is goes... sorry it will be long, and hopefully I'll post it at other places on you tube.
So my friend and I made the theory that Yellow shattered Pink and the reason why. So (get ready x,D), Yellow wanted the cluster, and what perfect planet to incubate it on than Earth. But the thing is, Pink ruled over the earth and moon. Pink didn't allow it since she probably cared about the Earth and Humans. That's not hard to believe when you look at the gems. When gems are made they are made for a certain diamond. When you look at the pearls and other gems not considered defected, they exhibit the traits of the diamond they were made for. When you look at Rose and hear about her, she loved the Earth, she loved the Humans, she exhibited emotions that other gems would consider Human. Which Rose Quarts were a new race a gem made by the one and only Pink Diamond. So it would only make sense that Pink wanted to keep the Humans and Earth going. (Which would also explain the zoo she started). So Yellow was mad because Pink wouldn't allow it.
Now lets look at the day explained when Pink was shattered and some information later described in the trial. When Pink was shattered it was said to be by a sword. A sword owned by Rose. But we all know her sword can't shatter gems. We also learned that there were no other Rose Quarts in her guard and army at the time. Why, because they were bubbled. Which explains why all the Rose Quarts that were bubbled, were in pink bubbles. The only Rose Quart that was out was our Rose. Remember also, Pink stepped out of her pedestal (if I got the name right x,D). If it was someone who rebelled against her, why would she step out then? It makes no sense, why would you get closer to your threat? So Pink obviously knew her killer very well, too well actually.
That brings us to the amazing points Zircon said. Where was Pink's guards at the time? Where was the sapphires to warn her? Where was her pearl to alert her? They were there, but they sensed no threat because they didn't assume it. Why, because it wasn't a gem from the rebellion it was Yellow Diamond. A gem with HIGH AUTHORITY. A gem that others were made to serve and protect. Yellow then shattered Pink (with who knows what) and blamed it on the rebellion, more so their leader, Rose Quart. They why they say a sword was used. Because the gems knew Rose used a sword. So Yellow would make Pink's court say a sword. The other diamonds and gems would clearly believe that.
So what happened to the court then? Well we thought that out too. We see in the case of Jasper, she was part of Pink's court and was moved to Yellow's. So the gems that were there that day, either got moved to Yellow's court for close watch, throw in prison, or shattered because they threatened to tell. That explains why there is no pink pearl. And with eyeball, he seems easily bribed. So he probably got a chunk of something so his mouth would stay shut. That's why he's a little out of it. Experiencing something so traumatizing could of sent him over board. That could also be why Yellow is different from what Peridot explained to us. Yellow probably has a lot of guilt for what she did. And acting out when Peridot was trying to save the Earth could of gave her bad memories. That also explains why she wan't to end the trial so quickly. She can't stand facing her demons. The song "Feeling Blue," also shows her breaking a little. She was talking about the gem which she betrayed and committed a horrible act to. So Yellow is slowly breaking inside.
Those are some "little" things that my friend and I talked about. Sorry it's so long! T~T
I would love you hear what you guys think and maybe spread this around, but please give me and my friend credit. (Sorry I don't have a name for him.)
Thanks! ^.^
Oh just for future reference it's a palanquin. Your theory is another very plausible one. The only little problem I see , is the fact that rose held herself responsible. If it wasn't her, why would she say that? I dunno. Rose is pretty mysterious anyway.
Cindy Kruth True. But maybe there is a reason. There is still stuff about her we don't know. Maybe she did it to protect someone. Maybe she did it so no one else close to her got blamed. Maybe she took it because she knew other home world gems wouldn't believe her word over a Diamond's word. We don't know. Hopefully we will know. Thanks for your input though. Makes me think a little more.
PandaCub this a great theory but the cluster is supposedly or at least mostly the shards of crystal gems, so it doesn't make so much sense that there was the idea of the cluster before pink diamonds shattering. also peridot says that it was after the earth was realised to no longer be a viable colony that the cluster was thought of and created then planted in the earth to incubate. on the contrary if they were to put the cluster in the earth it would destroy the crystal gems for sure, but pink obviously would want this as the earth was her only colony. but in writing that I realise that your theory does make sense so now I'm confused.
would not want this
PandaCub
Omg! I thought the same!!!
I listen all the way to the end for that "love you," yo!
My theory is that it was White Diamond and she used her pearl to do the deed, they did it together and pearl(our pearl) is deeply hurt for her action because she didn't want to do it but was forced to do it by her diamond. This is an example of how pearl is tired to be ordered without having her own freedom to choose.
I think Pink Pearl shattered Pink Diamond. And the reason for this is because she's the closest to her Diamond and her Diamond obviously trusts her more than any other gem besides the other Diamonds. She'd be the closest one to her Diamond. She'd be the one walking outside the palanquin first. Also Rose was already branded a threat several years before Pink was shattered how would Rose sneak past them all. Pink Pearl would look a lot like Rose while shapeshifting. It makes sense....but why?
XxTheSmollestCinnamonRollxX
My first thought too
XxTheSmollestCinnamonRollxX I dont agree so. Her Sapphire would see the future.
You're right, but what would be her Pearl's motive for doing this? She can't just do it for no reason. There has to be other sides of the story to prove this.
Inky IMeanImNotInky Have you forgotten how future vision works? Future vision only works if the Sapphire is actively searching for the possibilities of future outcomes. If Pink Diamonds Sapphire hadn't been actively monitoring Pink Pearl's possible future paths or Pink Diamond's possible paths then there's no way they would have saw this coming.
Normally Sapphires only use their future vision powers when their Diamonds ask them of it and for very specific things. As Garnet said she can't actually predict the future only possible outcomes.
So no I'm not wrong. You just forgot how future vision works X'D
I'm sorry buddy.
ItsGenYetAgain! That's what I am wondering...why would Pink Pearl shatter her Diamond?
Yeah I agree I think crewniverse is trying to make us think YD is responsible
Memo Memo
But looking back at every interaction with yellow diamond. She seems hella guilty. From the first time we saw her to today.
what if it was WD though, after all it is weird she was not present at all in the trail, surely she would want to know as well unless she already knew or actually helped shatter pink. She may be a higher up but it seems weird she has not appeared at something so important don't you think?
Memo Memo Probably is someone who we don't expect
i really like blue pearl in that episode. its cute because she is drawing the whole time, its adorable
Nice Video! You bring up some good points. It never crossed my mind Blue would have been the cause. Even by doing so inadvertently. I also didn't consider Rose wasn't responsible for the shattering. I simply thought one of the Diamonds lured P.D to a vulnerable position, giving Rose the opportunity to shatter her. Personally, I hope It's the theory of P.D asking Rose to assist her in shattering herself or it be White Diamond. I don't know why, but I picture W.D practically being a soci/and or psychopath and either had or destroyed Pink herself for being the weak link in the chain of command.
**Starts to syllable clap** boy we need a full review off all these episodes! Make it like 40 min long! I don't care 😭 I need my Otaku rant!!!
White diamond probably did it but yellow diamond had to see it or been in it and loves her other diamond to much to see her shattered too
I love that you didn't talk about white diamond yet because you don't have enough information about her. People should do that while they make theories as well as deal with others around them. We shouldn't judge someone without enough information about he/him.
Before the video played, there was an advertisement about diamonds. Coincident? I think not!
why has nobody ever thought that pink diamond might not have been shattered, but just bubbled by rose quartz after being poofed and hidden away into an unknown place to us
what if she planned all of this with rose quartz and Yellow diamond found out anyway
Can diamonds be poofed?
It's Blue Diamond. It's too obvious to be yellow. seeing how blue acts with steven, so vicious but then can switch back to being the victim. It's like she's trying to convince herself. Obviously yellow is the clear choice, but it's almost like blue has an alternate personality sometimes. In horror movies it's always the one you least suspect. Like she's psycho. so I'm voting blue.
***** not possible, as those shards aren't all pink
diamonds dont poof, rebecca sugar already talked about this.
It can't be Blue, it does seem like Yellow had an act into what happened, but I think White did it. Pink Diamond killing herself sounds so 13 Reasons Why
It's Blue Diamond. It's too obvious to be yellow. seeing how blue acts with steven, so vicious but then can switch back to being the victim. It's like she's trying to convince herself. Obviously yellow is the clear choice, but it's almost like blue has an alternate personality sometimes. In horror movies it's always the one you least suspect. Like she's psycho. so I'm voting blue.
Yellow Diamond... welcome to your tape. LOL
Blue Pearl how's everything going?
Hey I actually posted a vid on blue diamond yall should check it out. Thank you!
hey, just so you know the massive structure that is seen in the wanted episode tittles looks very similar to white diamonds hair style.
I can't think of Yellow as the shatterer for the simple fact that in the song "What's the uso of feeling, Blue?" you can see how much Yellow Diamond loved Pink and misses her, it was not hate or guilt, it was sadness
Who else really empathizes with Blue and feels she is really beautiful, mature and intelligent
I guess all the likes just prove people's agreement with you, and personally, I'm one of them X3
Here's a theory:
Pink Diamond actually develops a liking for Earth either because of Rose, or Rose is inspired by Pink, either way they're both sympathetic toward Earth. This isn't unlikely because why else would Pink Diamond have the Zoo at all if she didn't care for organic life in some way?
Maybe somewhere along the lines she develops such a strong attachment toward Earth that she herself begins to question why other forms of life cannot exist, and that's what inspires Rose to fight for Earth and rebel against Homeworld, their shared amazement for Earth.
Hearing that a Diamond herself would care for another world, White Diamond authorizes Yellow to dispose of the traitor, in hopes of wiping out any further thought of rebellion. Now hang on because there's more things that I'll pull from other episodes coming up.
Now we don't know when Pink Diamond was Shattered, and let's face it, if it were just Rose as the leader of the rebellion, wouldn't Homeworld forces easily be able to wipe out a few gems? Yes they had numbers, but Homeworld had more gems and better tech. So, someone of great power had to be at play if the Gems wanted to stand a chance right?
So what if Pink Diamond was actually the first Crystal Gem. She and Rose become close, and Pink shares her true feelings toward Earth with Rose, an already caring and sympathetic woman herself.
Together they begin to take in and appreciate the life of Earth, and the freedom it has, so very different from the life they know, and they begin to wish to live the same way. They begin finding gems with like them all over the planet, hoping to give them a life of happiness and freedom out of Homeworld's reach.
Homeworld hears of this, especially being that a Diamond, one of the highest in authority, is going against the ways of Homeworld, and they plan to put the whole thing under wraps because the whole system would crash and the Diamonds out of authority.
War is raged for Earth's freedom and the protection of its life forces. Yellow Diamond goes to Earth and shatters Pink Diamond, let's assume toward the end of the war, and let's also assume that the Crystal Gems are winning, because let's face it, in the episodes that they talk about the war it sounds like they held they're own very well for what they could, and we have Rose, Pearl, Garnet, and Amethyst to show that there were survivors.
Now how do you make take down the other side if you can't win in battle? Sabotage. And one of the strongest forms of sabotage? Betrayal.
So if you're still reading at this point, other than my congratulations, I'll give you how this all ties together.
Yellow Diamond goes to Earth in secret under White's demands to take out Pink so that the Diamond name and their authority isn't threatened. She shatters Pink, and tells everyone that it was Rose Quartz, already a criminal to Homeworld but also one of the higher ups of the Crystal Gems, further tarnishing Rose's name but also causing the Crystal Gems to turn on each other and their forces come tumbling down from the inside. The Diamonds, then corrupt the gems of Earth, which allows them to contain the Rebellion to Earth but ALSO keep anyone who may have seen Yellow shatters Pink silent. All the Rose Quartz gems are then poofed and bubbles, not because they are feared because of Rose's supposed shattering, but ALSO because they're able to heal the corrupted gems. You corrupt any witnesses, you bubble anyone whole could heal them so that the truth doesn't get out, but what else do you do it you don't feel that's enough? You destroy the evidence, aka: the Cluster. Destroying the Earth also destroys any Gem that may have knowledge of Pink Diamond's shattering, but also allows the Diamonds to colonize Earth like they originally planned. The evidence is destroyed, the Earth gets colonized, the reach and authority of Homeworld expands, and all the while the Diamonds get to remain in authority without every having to worry about any of the evidence coming back into the light. I mean, it could all just be coincidence, but there are so many effects the actions of the war can have, and we've only looked at it from the Crystal Gems' perspective.
Maybe Pink Diamond was shattered because she wanted to preserve the Earth and created an army of our cast and lovers who started standing their ground against the ways to Homeworld's cruel ways. Maybe Ross was blamed to harden her criminal reputation while turning the Crystal Gems against each other. And maybe all the gems were corrupted so they could be silence and the Cluster place so any evidence of Pink's shattering would be erased. But hey that's just one man's theory.
Zach Alita makes sense but rose took the blame which is weird
Danny Mac maybe the Diamonds have far superior shapeshifting skills to where they can even change there color? Or maybe Rose made some sort of deal with the Diamonds where if she was to take the blame something else would be spared? Either way I don't think it was actually arose who shattered her, that'd be too obvious and Rose is too nice anyway.
Danny Mac, or if you look in the comments of the "Corruption Powers" theory video, someone theorizes the White Diamond can effect the mind of Gems, since Blue has emotion and Yellow physical. So maybe White edited the memories of the Gems so they all think Rose was at fault.
Blue Diamond. It's too obvious to be yellow. Blue used her mind manipulation to make it seem like pink diamond was shattered by rose which is why one of the rubies thought they saw it. To keep her secret safe, she made yellow believe she shattered pink with her mind manipulation. She also used it on herself to make her believe she is innocent. Obviously yellow is the clear choice, but it's almost like blue has an alternate personality sometimes. Like she's psycho. so I'm voting blue. Also white is too good to go to a trial she is the almighty she doesn't need to go.
Zach Alita COME ON EVERYBODY THIS COMMENT IS FUCKING GOOD IT DESERVES A PIN AND 1k LIKES
I liked how blue diamond looked shocked, and yellow was pissed.
I just want to say, I freaking knew it.
Ever since the zoo, Yellow seemed to be trying to sweep aside anything to do with Pink Diamond, but at the time I thought there were too many holes in the idea... but now, NOW I'm sure she's hiding something.
Did you see the way Yellow Diamond was acting towards Steven and his lawyer she was ready to shatter him without hearing his or Roses side of the story. Blue Diamond was the only one who was trying to hear Stevens or Roses side of the story I believe Blue Diamond wouldn't shatter Pink Diamond she loves her way too much for it.
Where was Pink Diamonds Pearl or where was her army because all diamonds are suppose to have their pearls with them and their armies that can make you think what really happened to Pink Diamond.
Zircon is a she
Nate L -- they are talking about Steven, silly.
how do you know Blue isn't putting up an act
Crimes of passion are quite real my friend.
I still wonder where Pink's Sapphires. Couldn't they have known that Pink would be shattered?
Our Sapphire didn't predict that she would fuse with Ruby into Garnet, and we know that Sapphires can only see the most likely outcome (Garnet's future vision is more developed, she can see many paths, not just one). So it really could have just been a surprise like Garnet's first fusion.
tanukigalpa sapphires see many paths it's just that our sapphire saw nothing because she wasn't just herself she become something else so vision wasn't there. Kinda like the theory that sardonyx knew she lived in a cartoon but Pearl and garnet didn't know because when your in a fusion u don't have the same exact abilities or atleast remember
Awesome Person Your question makes me wonder how far in the future Sapphires can see. Our Sapphire can see pretty far, but she could be a special case (see, the off color Sapphire with "present time vision" has a delay, so, I do believe not all Sapphires can see much far in the future, I think each Sapphire has a limit as to how much they can see), if we consider that, it could be easy to trick a pink Sapphire to leave the place to somewhere else far away or/and keep her busy just enough so she can't alarm PD about her shattering (or attract her somewhere the Sapphire herself can't alarm anyone and be poofed).
tanukigalpa Sure, but any path where a diamond could be shattered should bring plenty of alarm. Even if it was a tiny chance if they knew who would do it they'd probably make sure that they stayed as far from pink as possible. Unless… they worked with Pink's executioner
Yellow could have told them to be quiet or they'll all be shattered
Someone just put up the sword fighter episode and something struck me once I watched it in the beginning of the show the crystal gems was watching they talked about how the leader of the lonely sword was always in the background watching in the shadows and how he was always hinted in the cover of the show through pics
I had an ad about a diamond shop lol
*DON'T TUMBLE MY ROCKS*
Like this to make this the new saying
Chisk Cheese i notice the puns after 2 minutes of reading it...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Chisk Cheese i
Chisk Cheese I
I don't think it was a Diamond. The pearls look suspicious when Zircon asked where Pink Diamonds Pearl was, almost as if they know something more about it then they're leading on.
I agree!! There reactions was suspicious!
That would make sense, they are very close to the Diamonds but we know how they may feel worthless due to what the Diamonds only use them for. Possible Pink Diamond was the easiest to get close to, we may not know her but she seems like a more kind Diamond than the rest. I hope we don't have to wait long for new episodes, god damnit
Corroded. Perception in off color the fusion that looked like garnet had a pearl like gem and it was pink
Corroded. Perception a good backing on it being a diamond is that only diamonds can cut or destroy other diamonds in real life. It's definitely a possibility.
Mohamad Nael gems in fusion change color? I'm pretty sure it was because of their fusion. Plus rhodonite even said she originally belonged to a Morganite. Plus the fact pearls gem is on her chest not her stomach which would correlate with pink diamonds gem placement.
Yellow diamond looked really surprised when Steven admitted guilt.
i never considered one of the diamonds going crazy like yellow did for a moment bc considering how loyal her ppl seem, i feel like shattering all the diamonds and become dictator of homeworld would be easy for a diamond, espeically with that zapping power that destroys their form.
it was mr smiley
CreepyTurtleಠ_ಠ
THIS COMMENT SHOULD BE AT THE TOP!!
Blue Diamond. It's too obvious to be yellow. Blue used her mind manipulation to make it seem like pink diamond was shattered by rose which is why one of the rubies thought they saw it. To keep her secret safe, she made yellow believe she shattered pink with her mind manipulation. She also used it on herself to make her believe she is innocent. Obviously yellow is the clear choice, but it's almost like blue has an alternate personality sometimes. Like she's psycho. so I'm voting blue. Also white is too good to go to a trial she is the almighty she doesn't need to go.
but what if rose was forced to "shatter" pink diamond, but because her sword only poofs, she poofed her instead and bubbled her away without yellow diamonds knowledge? eyeball mentioned she saw rose with her own eye - what if the locked chest in lions mane contains pink diamonds bubbled gem? or her pearls gem, who may have witnessed it and could shed light on the situation?
Pink diamond's pearl is our Pearl
how can it? Pearl's pearl is on her head, not lower down, the Pearl's gems have been in the same place as their leaders nor is Pearl pink, she is more white. So I don't believe she is Pink's Pearl
Wize Demon could it be Pearl was White's? And since White must be greater power and Pearl was closer to a more powerful gem...did she maybe lure Pink away? Fandom says Pearl rebelled against White and fought with Rose instead. If a great Diamond has a Pearl to do her bidding, would Pearl have used that against Pink to lure her to Earth? If not then what other gem would be close enough to Pink?
EDIT:AHA! MAYBE I HAVE THE ANSWER TO THAT. Recall Bismuth pointing other gems who fought with them. Snowflake. there is a Snowflake Agate
An Agate, Pink's agate!!
Many believe Pearl is White's Pearl because of where her gem is which does make sense on how Rose got her somehow. Maybe some of PD's army helped rebel and knew the truth?
Wize Demon That's what I think
i just tgought of something, what if yellow diamond wanted to use planet earth as a way to birth the Cluster for a large gio weapon, but Pink was incharge and said she wanted to use the planet to make a colony for more jems. it makes sense since we had peridot explain that finding planets to make new gems were in short supply so most gems end up a bit deficient, to the point that newer version have no special powers. this would also explain why whenever we see yellow she discuss on wars, plans of attack, and wanting to get her geo weapon. Yellow may have fought with pink about it, resulting in her death.
Who did it was not on my mind, what was on my mind was what will the crystal gems do about this + wondering if we will ever see these new gems and/or Lars again + what happened to Lion that he was dead + thinking of all those theories about the shards of pink diamond being lion being crushed along with myself being crushed because I supported those theories, but you know, I thought of that too. I think this special is giving you a LOT of information to think about.