Drugstore Tubing Mascaras Review (BEST vs. WORST)

Everyone loves a good tubing mascara but what's the BEST drugstore tubing mascara? Today, we test out six drugstore tubing mascaras and a wear test for each one.
1:46 - L.A Girl Volumatic Volumizing Tubing Mascara vs. Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes! Mascara
5:04 - Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions Mascara vs. L'oreal Double Extend Lash Extension Effect Mascara
9:48 - No7 Stay Perfect Mascara vs. e.l.f Cosmetics Lash XTNDR Mascara
PRODUCTS:
L.A Girl Volumatic Volumizing Tubing Mascara (Black):
go.shopmy.us/p-4917941
Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes! Mascara (Black):
go.shopmy.us/p-4917910
Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions Mascara (Black):
go.shopmy.us/p-4917967
L'oreal Double Extend Lash Extension Effect Mascara (Black):
go.shopmy.us/p-4918004
No7 Stay Perfect Mascara (Black):
go.shopmy.us/p-4918130
e.l.f Cosmetics Lash XTNDR Mascara (Deep Brown):
go.shopmy.us/p-3298309
My Favorite Amazon Products: www.amazon.com/shop/maesitler
COME SAY HI:
Instagram: / maesitler

[@jennyyu8674]

Hi Mae, try the new essence mascara primer called Curl fixing (I only use a light coat since it's a little harder to remove). It's amazing & helps keep your lashes curled, no matter what mascara you put on. I use the Milani lash extensions with it & my straight Asian lashes stay curled all day. The lash extensions work better when it dries out a little, try it again in a few weeks.

[@MaeSitler]

Thanks for the recommendation! I just bought it 😊

[@liadanducky]

Such a handy review! Thank you!

[@gwendolyncarson6127]

Elf I love best out of all tubing mascaras. I’ve tried them all❤

[@cambaprincess9976]

Great reviews, what's your favorite eyelash curler?

[@Internal-m.d.]

Try Sensai 38C mascara. They are absolutely the best. Even the price is a bit more than the drugstore ones.

[@adelyashahidi]

Hi Mae! Thank you for this review! So, I only can use No 7 on my super oily eyelids, and this is what works best: apply the second coat right after the first one without letting the first dry. The same with the third coat if you’d like to. Gives me more volume without horrible clumping. If you let the first coat dry down, it WILL really dry, and the second coat will look horrible. I actually now can build it up pretty well. I guess because it is such a dry formula it stays well on my eyes. It’s really hard to find though so I am hoping for good results with the Elf one

[@spaingirl87]

I was utterly disappointed by the Milani one too. I actually returned it. It was wet for me too and weighed my lashes down. The L’Oréal one I also agree on that is was difficult to remove. The only other tubing mascara I tried was Tarte tartlette and it is decent. It is also wet but doesn’t weigh down as bad too me. I’ve had it for almost 3 months and still wet. I’m going to try Hemish a Korean brand that has a tubing mascara and also maybe the hourglass one

[@audreyso1201]

Thanks Mae for sharing🌺🌺🌺

[@carold8950]

Thank you! I also have Asian lashes and this helps greatly. ❤

[@thejunebuggirl8338]

I love NO 7. It could be amazin. They’re known for having old products around or even selling knock offs. Mine builds easily. Is still dry enough it doesn’t make my lashes fall, and gives me good desperation! The only downside is I feel like the tube doesn’t last as long as others. I think because it starts drier, it dries out faster.

[@elainelee4828]

I heard tubing performs better after a few weeks of being opened, they need to be dry up a bit. I just started exploring them.

[@x3AnnyLinh]

Please let us know if you find the other no.7 mascara and saw a different result :)

[@alicebrown2007]

Essence bye bye panda is truly not a tubing mascara and it smears . .