I swear, if they forget the brown hair with light tips on Mare, I'm going to die. It's such a subtle detail but it makes so much sense. It represents her well.
I know same! I SWEAR though if they make her white I’m gonna be so disappointed. The book describes her as having “brown” skin or a tan. I’m white myself, but I really hope Victoria doesn’t allow Mare to be pasty white when her character isnt
I disagree about the princes... Cal needs to be much broader and muscular. He needs to have a great build but a comforting look in his eyes, which by the way aren't blue. And he also needs to be much more attractive. The same with Maven. He needs to be much more attractive, and although I imagine him being shorter than Cal, he still needs to be stockier.
Nina is an amazing actress, but i feel she is more of Evangeline then Mare, if anything i feel Lily Collins would be phenomenal job of bringing Mare alive (she did so well as Clary)
Evangeline has to be someone more intimidating than Isabelle and the other girl didn't click. All the cast was spot on, except maybe for Maven. An idea: How about Natalie Dormer for Farley? I think she'd make an awesome one.
@@lotte1160 Um, chill a lil, girl. I imagined Evangeline being a little bit more bitchy, and Isabelle's face is just too cute for that. Edit: Got it. The person that I picture when I imagine Evangline is Eiza González.
If you look up their ages, Maven is the same age as Mare (17) and Cal is 19. I think Asa would be a great choice for Maven, he's 19 and he has the look of an overlooked brother. I also imagine Maven as skinny and tall, so having a big muscular guy would throw me off. Dominic Sherwood is a good actor though :) I just have to keep telling people why Asa would be such a good voice hahaha
But Dom has blond hair and the blue-brown eyes whereas Maven has black hair and "icy blue eyes". He is also described to be leaner and sort of on the scrawnier side, but Dom is more muscled than anything. I think there could be better people to portray him
dunno about asa or alex pettyfer, but I feel like you nailed most of these. this is pretty close to what I imagined while reading. I was expecting some dumbo for Cal but then that guy popped up and I was like......yasssssss
i think asa is so so so so perfect for the role of maven omg, i can just see him walking up to mare behind his soldiers wearing the crown he refuses to take off. If he doesn't get cast or denies the role i will be so devastated
Saoirse Ronan as Farley Paul Rudd as Julian Charlize Theron as Elara Russel Crowe as King Tiberias Alex Pettyfer as Kirlon Drew Roy as Cal Asa Butterfield as Maven Isabelle Fuhrman as Evangeline Lindsey Morgan as Mare I LOVE IT
Karyme Ruiz Mare is described as having olive skin, which is why I went with Nina Dobrev because she fits the description and is an incredible actress. But I definitely agree that if Mare is described as a POC, a POC of colour should portray her
Yes, but it's getting annoying because she's not suppose to be white. Even Victoria Aveyard herself said, 'Mare is half Mexican.' So in my personal opinion Mare should be played by someone who isn't white.(Which doesn't mean 'they're tan') But thats my opinion
Those characters are like bascically perfect. I have a always imagined cal with blonde hair too. Most of my life I have seen dream characters who seem nothing like the actual character but those are like. OMG PERFECT. Like asa butterfeild. AMAZING.
Even though mare is a POC I always imagined her to be a bit paler (not pasty white like a lighter tan), with flushed cheeks and a red nose. I never imagined Kelorn with blonde hair either I thought it was like a more light sandyish blonde.
Wow this was pretty spot on overall. Still unsure about Mare and Evangeline and I wouldnt agree with your choices about Maven. But the others were fantastic choices
I feel like lots of people don't agree with the choice for Maven, but personally, I believe Asa Butterfield would be an amazing choice for the role. He fits the physical description perfectly and I can imagine him playing the overlooked/ignored brother. I would much rather him than some typical Hollywood pretty boy 👍 You should check out his acting, he is starring in a new movie this Summer called, The Space Between Us, which I'm really excited about and in December he will be starring in the movie adaption of the book, Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children. Thanks for the comment!
She has OLIVE skinned. Also, in King's Cage, she is described as having sort of golden skin so... yeah. That's it. I mean no rudeness I just get annoyed when ppl get facts wrong
I legit stared at the thumbnail for ten minutes before I realized it was Asa Butterfield. I last saw him in Ender's Game, and he looked really different!
I think everything was spot on except for evagline (probably spelled that wrong) and mare. It might just be me but that's not how I really imagined them. Also to point out that everyone els I thought was the perfect cast 👏👏 props to you for this amazing cast (praying they get casted as the characters) Also can you do another video with ALL the characters like Gisa and Shade and Lucas ect
I like asa as Maven and all but Maven is mental and (in my mind) asa seems too innocent. He'd be good for most of The Red Queen but the whole betraying Mare thing, no. 😁
You nailed EVERYTHING and if this was the cast I wouldn’t be nearly as bummed as I was first seeing the hunger games picks. However, if I could nit pick a few things, I’d find a stockier actor for Cal that still has that warm, comforting and protective look in his face that’s still menacing at the same time. And maybe a more attractive Maven so the people who still love him get a little love 😂 Mave’s hard to cast. I don’t know how I’d describe her to you. Overall, amazing.
defininately 1st Farley and first Julian 2nd Elara great king 1st Kilorn great Cal and you NAILED Maven definitely 2nd Eve and I agree with Meg Mare is rly hard to nail none rlly fitted as her I guess the third kind of worked.. Great video though!!!
pretty much agre with this. asa butterfield is just perfect for maven, though he has the same blue eyes as maven. and isabella for evangline just... totally perfect.
This is so bomb, though I do think that Isabelle Fuhrman should have been Mare, and Dylan O’Brian as Killorn.... but other than that this is a dream cast!!
OMG I WAS LIKE YELLING YES YES YES A THOUSAND TIMES YES....plz SOMEBODY make this happen ALTHOUGH for Maven I thought it should be Asa Butterfield for sure... Mare though is hard to imagince but I think SOMETHING similar to this.... OMGGGG
I like nina as mare a lot....Im almost done with red queen and now all I picture is nina as her lmao...your list was really good especially Asa as Maven
Shittt...I seriously thought of Asa butterfield when I read Mavens description. It matches exactly and now seeing that other people thought of the same is insane. Im so ecstatic right now. It would be Perfect if Asa plays Maven
Evangeline is actually Asian it says in cruel crown something like "her small, slanted eyes looked like slits" or something like that and it says in the book she has slick black hair
Who else thinks Naomi Watts should play Farley but giving Naomi the dark brown hair just how she looks in divergent she is honestly the only character I see as a whole but for the other characters I can never see in my head or once the author mentions a new feature their face changes mare and shade are the hardest ones and whenever I see dream casts like this I feel like puking cause even though I can’t imagine them I wouldn’t want to put those people there!!!😁
I honestly think of theres anyone who should act for mare and most of the other reds i hope that they give them some kind of flaw instead of just making them flawless cuase i imagine mare to be looking very mal nourished also kilorn should be bit taller i also imagine them to have darker skin tones
Asa looks for like Maven...but man you just hit this on the nail... I feel like the people should pick out the characters. I read fifty shades of Grey and all those characters are wrong.
I don't know if you plan to have this song with the video, but OMG "Castle" by Hasley is so perfect for this book! The song gives off such a vibe for "Red Queen."
ASA BUTTERFIELD WOULD ACTUALLY FIT SO WELL WITH MAVEN, but there is someone else I think would look good as maven, search up “Dane dehann Valerian” the appearance of his character in valerian really matched Maven.
I swear, if they forget the brown hair with light tips on Mare, I'm going to die. It's such a subtle detail but it makes so much sense. It represents her well.
Moon o3o SOOOOOO true
Marin H GRAY tips
They are described as light tips though
This is actually my biggest fear
I know same! I SWEAR though if they make her white I’m gonna be so disappointed. The book describes her as having “brown” skin or a tan. I’m white myself, but I really hope Victoria doesn’t allow Mare to be pasty white when her character isnt
I totally agree with the Elara one!
fhatpotatou same. Though I think angelina jolie would make a good elara.
Charlize Thereon is so perfect, she gives me the creeps.
I disagree about the princes... Cal needs to be much broader and muscular. He needs to have a great build but a comforting look in his eyes, which by the way aren't blue. And he also needs to be much more attractive. The same with Maven. He needs to be much more attractive, and although I imagine him being shorter than Cal, he still needs to be stockier.
Maven is lean, not muscled
Tbh I know cal isn't the way he's described but I think he looks quite good anyways tho I don't really like Maven tbh (I mean nobody likes maven:)
@@aishab1596 lmao go to the war storm trailer all the comments are girls swooning over maven
@@aishab1596 i onestly prefer maven over cal
Starfire YAS
I think Cal needs to be more built, he is meant to be built, Drew Roy doesn't seem like he would be buff enough
I know Cal actually has black hair, but I've always imagined him having blonde hair😂
Bentley Bennett ikr i just had to keep on reminding myself that he had black
has*
I know!!! I also imaged kilorn with dark hair and eyes
I guess I imagined them as gale and peeta
Me too
SAME
Don’t forget that mares skin tone is a little darker. She has golden brown skin
Agreed
Plus mare is of Hispanic and Caucasian decent
omg paul rudd as Julian now I can't not picture it
ikrrrrr
Isn’t Julian in is like 50s or something. I always imagined him as being thinner and having hair almost white and looking older than actually is
@@lanistorm1542 actually he's about 40 if you calculate
Lani Storm paul rudd is 50 so it kinda evens out
You pretty much hit spot on with everyone except for Mare. I feel like she is really hard really hard to imagine but I did enjoy this.
I think Nina would do well
+andrea hicks same
Nina is an amazing actress, but i feel she is more of Evangeline then Mare, if anything i feel Lily Collins would be phenomenal job of bringing Mare alive (she did so well as Clary)
how about Chloe Moretz?
+Sheila Vang mare has brown skin
They need to make these books into movies I love them 😭😭😍😍
I think you nailed it on Maven, holy. But Mare is a tough one. I really like the dream cast you put together. Thanks
I think the only guy that'd be better for Maven than Asa is Timothee Chamalet. He's immediately who I pictured.
Sheila Vang *are you crazy!? Maven’s supposed actor is ugly as hell!*
char char that’s so mean. But I can’t stop laughing😂
Enid Rhee-Grimes
Ahhh yessss!!!!!! I watched The King on Netflix and felt like I was watching Maven, not King Henry V
Enid Rhee-Grimes same
Queen Elara and King Tiberias are exactly who i imagined the characters should be!
Same
2:17 That's a perfect Maven! That's exactly how I imagine him.
Evangeline has to be someone more intimidating than Isabelle and the other girl didn't click. All the cast was spot on, except maybe for Maven. An idea: How about Natalie Dormer for Farley? I think she'd make an awesome one.
OH MY GOSH YEEESSSSS
Ericka Alena Castillo *Isabelle is perfect, actually*
I think Dylan Sprayberry should play Maven.
@@lotte1160 Um, chill a lil, girl. I imagined Evangeline being a little bit more bitchy, and Isabelle's face is just too cute for that.
Edit: Got it. The person that I picture when I imagine Evangline is Eiza González.
Cara Delevingne?
Maven needs to be older. Dominic Sherwood would be PERFECT!
I think that the whole fandom agrees that Elara is Charlize Theron.
If you look up their ages, Maven is the same age as Mare (17) and Cal is 19. I think Asa would be a great choice for Maven, he's 19 and he has the look of an overlooked brother. I also imagine Maven as skinny and tall, so having a big muscular guy would throw me off. Dominic Sherwood is a good actor though :) I just have to keep telling people why Asa would be such a good voice hahaha
don't disagree hahaha
Cal has to be older than Maven. Maven's only 17 in the first book.
Elara is Charlize in my mind...and will forever be haha
But Dom has blond hair and the blue-brown eyes whereas Maven has black hair and "icy blue eyes". He is also described to be leaner and sort of on the scrawnier side, but Dom is more muscled than anything. I think there could be better people to portray him
mare is actually a dark-skinned person just like described in the book
Rawdha Al Hammadi she is not, she was described as having olive, goldenish skin
@@katyrubiola2317 She was described as brown skinned
Well her sister had red hair so she couldn’t have been to dark
dunno about asa or alex pettyfer, but I feel like you nailed most of these. this is pretty close to what I imagined while reading. I was expecting some dumbo for Cal but then that guy popped up and I was like......yasssssss
+Azure Kate SAMMMEEE
i think asa is so so so so perfect for the role of maven omg, i can just see him walking up to mare behind his soldiers wearing the crown he refuses to take off. If he doesn't get cast or denies the role i will be so devastated
victoria j yes! Or even Skandar Keynes could play maven
Awesomeness Time no Skandar Keynes can be Lucas
Saoirse Ronan as Farley
Paul Rudd as Julian
Charlize Theron as Elara
Russel Crowe as King Tiberias
Alex Pettyfer as Kirlon
Drew Roy as Cal
Asa Butterfield as Maven
Isabelle Fuhrman as Evangeline
Lindsey Morgan as Mare
I LOVE IT
I think that Evangeline was a blond girl
Zack Abramson nope she has silver hair
Zack Abramson silver. She has silver hair
No, her hair is silver, so it can basically be interpreted anywhere from a white, almost blonde to a really dark grey
it's ash-blond
No she had black. Hair in the 4th book
Halsey literally makes music for this series 🤷🏽♀️😭😍😍😍
Mare ain't white...
Karyme Ruiz Mare is described as having olive skin, which is why I went with Nina Dobrev because she fits the description and is an incredible actress. But I definitely agree that if Mare is described as a POC, a POC of colour should portray her
Yes, but it's getting annoying because she's not suppose to be white. Even Victoria Aveyard herself said, 'Mare is half Mexican.'
So in my personal opinion Mare should be played by someone who isn't white.(Which doesn't mean 'they're tan')
But thats my opinion
Mare has brown skin it says it on pg. 215 in the 2nd book
Yes I agree completely, if Mare is a POC, a POC should portray her.
well it actually said "golden" in the third book I'm currently reading
Those characters are like bascically perfect. I have a always imagined cal with blonde hair too. Most of my life I have seen dream characters who seem nothing like the actual character but those are like. OMG PERFECT. Like asa butterfeild. AMAZING.
They need to make a movie !!!!!
uh yeah !!!!!! if not then I'm gonna cry
+America Lechuga me too
They are
Mavis Vermillion what? When
Matthew Daddario would look so good as Cal, like if you look at him he’s got the same dark hair, bronze eyes and he’s tall. Perfect I’d say
YES!!
Even though mare is a POC I always imagined her to be a bit paler (not pasty white like a lighter tan), with flushed cheeks and a red nose.
I never imagined Kelorn with blonde hair either I thought it was like a more light sandyish blonde.
Asa needs to be maven i can literally imagine it
Yes
Nah, Timothèe Chamalet would be a much better Maven. He literally embodies him.
Wow this was pretty spot on overall. Still unsure about Mare and Evangeline and I wouldnt agree with your choices about Maven. But the others were fantastic choices
I feel like lots of people don't agree with the choice for Maven, but personally, I believe Asa Butterfield would be an amazing choice for the role. He fits the physical description perfectly and I can imagine him playing the overlooked/ignored brother. I would much rather him than some typical Hollywood pretty boy 👍 You should check out his acting, he is starring in a new movie this Summer called, The Space Between Us, which I'm really excited about and in December he will be starring in the movie adaption of the book, Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children. Thanks for the comment!
I just finished reading the book, and it changed my mind. Yes, yes yesss I do agree with you! I see the Asa Butterfield in Maven! Great choice!
elara, kilorn, evangeline, maven and cal. You describe them damn perfectly!! totally love it!
So many white people...Mare is dark-skinned!
Amy Hollinger I thought she was tan... she isnt black
She has OLIVE skinned. Also, in King's Cage, she is described as having sort of golden skin so... yeah. That's it. I mean no rudeness I just get annoyed when ppl get facts wrong
Annabeth Granger yeah she’s a poc
Amy Hollinger no she is not
@@minhcraft_ Yes, she is. Read the damn books
Maven and Cal casting... I could see those two... Great job!!!
This is sooo good!
I legit stared at the thumbnail for ten minutes before I realized it was Asa Butterfield. I last saw him in Ender's Game, and he looked really different!
I feel like Julian would look a bit older.... and have a smaller build.
Until I read Glass sword I had no I that Cal and Mavins hair was black. So I alwayd imagined Cal as William Moseley from Lion Witch and the wardrobe.
Cal and Maven have black hair...
Avoxx Targaryen Lol I meant to put black instead of blonde
I think everything was spot on except for evagline (probably spelled that wrong) and mare. It might just be me but that's not how I really imagined them. Also to point out that everyone els I thought was the perfect cast 👏👏 props to you for this amazing cast (praying they get casted as the characters) Also can you do another video with ALL the characters like Gisa and Shade and Lucas ect
YESSS I AGREE
btw shade should be hot af
I like asa as Maven and all but Maven is mental and (in my mind) asa seems too innocent. He'd be good for most of The Red Queen but the whole betraying Mare thing, no. 😁
Rachel Marlow maven is supposed to seem innocent and charming at first it makes the book more exciting
Asa don’t look like Maven really!
Am i the only one that imagined Maven as an innocent looking person and cal as a fully grown handsome man??
SAME! I pictured maven as asa and cal as gregg sulkin
mare TITANOS agreeed
You nailed EVERYTHING and if this was the cast I wouldn’t be nearly as bummed as I was first seeing the hunger games picks.
However, if I could nit pick a few things, I’d find a stockier actor for Cal that still has that warm, comforting and protective look in his face that’s still menacing at the same time. And maybe a more attractive Maven so the people who still love him get a little love 😂
Mave’s hard to cast. I don’t know how I’d describe her to you.
Overall, amazing.
I imagined Farley with freckles, green eyes but with a hint of blue in some places, pale skin, and dirty blonde hair.
vivi i imagined her with dirty blonde hair too
Charlie is exactly how I pictured Elara, no joke
defininately 1st Farley and first Julian 2nd Elara great king 1st Kilorn great Cal and you NAILED Maven definitely 2nd Eve and I agree with Meg Mare is rly hard to nail none rlly fitted as her I guess the third kind of worked.. Great video though!!!
Ok but the actor playing cal would have to put on some serious muscle mass
Unlike the other two, I think Nina Dobrev would be the perfect Mere. Just like her: brow eyes, brown hair and Newblood :)
OMG THIS IS SO amazing JUST IKE I PICTURED THEM OMG OMG OMG
pretty much agre with this. asa butterfield is just perfect for maven, though he has the same blue eyes as maven. and isabella for evangline just... totally perfect.
I totally agree with the first person about Farley and Angelina Jolie as Elara
Nina Dobrev was literally made for the role of Mare🤧👏
I GUESSED ASA WAS MAVEN AND I WAS CORRECT
because he has blue eyes and cal has bronze :)
yea Cal is hot and Maven is not TEAM CAL!
steficorn me toooo
@@abbykrehling5957 lmao you only choose Cal bc he's hot you're very shallow
in my opinion asa acting skills are sometimes retarded. no mean to hate if anyone likes him
I don’t think they got mare as good as they should have but everyone else was pretty much spot on
Tiberias: Joaquin Phoenix
Maven: Brant Daugherty
Elara: Michelle Fairley
Cal: Armie Hammer
Kilorn: Jake Abel
Ptolemus: Alexander Ludwig
Farley: Jenna Melone
Evangelia: Kaya Scodelario
Julien: Aiden Gillen
Mare: Alycia Debnam-Carey
Shade: Sam Claflin
Gisa: Isabella Fuhrman
Okay, I honestly love Asa Butterfield, he would make a perfect Maven in my opinion.
This is so bomb, though I do think that Isabelle Fuhrman should have been Mare, and Dylan O’Brian as Killorn.... but other than that this is a dream cast!!
I think Mare NEEDS to have long hair. Nina Dobrev as Mare, I love it!!
i like this cast so much it is he best one I have seen it's sooo good you totally nailt it wow !!!!!!!!!!!! =0
sorry I meen nailed
I’m so excited for the movie when does it come out???
Where are all the clips from?
Logan Lerman NEEDS to play Maven!! He fits the description of him PERFECTLY!!! Plus he's hot XD
Yeah...he seems too cute tho😂
We need red queen as a movie
I LOVE these books
nina dobrev is how i viewed mare in the book
OMG I WAS LIKE YELLING YES YES YES A THOUSAND TIMES YES....plz SOMEBODY make this happen ALTHOUGH for Maven I thought it should be Asa Butterfield for sure... Mare though is hard to imagince but I think SOMETHING similar to this.... OMGGGG
Farley--- Jeniffer Morrison
Julian--- Mark Ruffalo
Elara--- Charlize Theron
King Tiberias--- Russel Crowe
Kilorn--- Alex Pettyfer
Cal--- Drew Roy
Maven--- Asa Butterfield
Mare--- Cameron Bicondova or Nina Dobrev
Evangeline--- Isabelle Fuhrman
I pictured Russel king T. too
And kilorn like that boy from Disney channel with Sabrina carpenter..
Adelaide Kane as Mare and Matthew Daddario as Cal
perfect cast. I would only change cal. he had a bigger build. the choice you had was not buff enough
I like nina as mare a lot....Im almost done with red queen and now all I picture is nina as her lmao...your list was really good especially Asa as Maven
This cast is pretty much perfect
Disagree with Cal, Mare and Evangeline ones. Asa is soooo perfect for Maven, Alex its kind of good for Kilorn. And the one for Julian was perfect!!
Thanks for keeping it in the right age range 😂😂
😂😂
I could see that Noah dude from "to all the boys I loved before" as cal
Oh...true
Shittt...I seriously thought of Asa butterfield when I read Mavens description. It matches exactly and now seeing that other people thought of the same is insane. Im so ecstatic right now. It would be Perfect if Asa plays Maven
Same
TIMOTHEE CHAMALET AS MAVEN WOULD BE UTTER PERFECTION
Evangeline is actually Asian it says in cruel crown something like "her small, slanted eyes looked like slits" or something like that and it says in the book she has slick black hair
I came here because I saw Asa... Love himmmmm
Who else thinks Naomi Watts should play Farley but giving Naomi the dark brown hair just how she looks in divergent she is honestly the only character I see as a whole but for the other characters I can never see in my head or once the author mentions a new feature their face changes mare and shade are the hardest ones and whenever I see dream casts like this I feel like puking cause even though I can’t imagine them I wouldn’t want to put those people there!!!😁
For some reason I always thought of Kilorn being a red head
Can someone please answer and tell me honestly. Is this going to become a movie or not?
lol. I think the last one they showed is the best for Mare. She has darkish skin. I think the choices were perty gucci
I think Zendaya would make a good Mare she's spunky and charming.
nina dobrev as mare? no
Michelle SCCP CR Totally!!!
Love it but aren't they kinda old almost everyone is like between the ages 16-45 in red queen (main characters)
danggg charlize as elara
I honestly think of theres anyone who should act for mare and most of the other reds i hope that they give them some kind of flaw instead of just making them flawless cuase i imagine mare to be looking very mal nourished also kilorn should be bit taller i also imagine them to have darker skin tones
Asa looks for like Maven...but man you just hit this on the nail... I feel like the people should pick out the characters. I read fifty shades of Grey and all those characters are wrong.
Totally agree with maven
Mare = Lindsay Morgan
Kilorn = Chace Crawford
Gisa = Amybeth McNulty
Cal = Penn Badgley (or Drew Roy)
Maven = Timothee Chalamet (or Asa)
Evageline = Madelaine Petsch w/ white hair
Elane = Lily Cole
Farley = Teresa Palmer
Elara = Charlize Theron, no doubts!
Iris Cygnet = Sasha Kichigina (or Priyanka Chopra. Donut know exactly her name)
That's it!
I also pictured teresa!
For some reason I pictured Nicole kidman as elara
I feel like it would be really hard for them to make a red queen movie without Asa as maven I mean he's perfect for the role....
YES!
I think everyone is really good but Mare should be Nina. She’s the protagonist in vampire diaries and a total BA so she would be great for Mare.
This is the best cast i have seen
I agree with most of these, except for cal, maven and mare
I agree 1000% on maven looks wise
Jennifer Lawrence as mare
I think Calore brothers are bad choices :((
Inspired choices for Julian, but I’m p sure he’s supposed to be an old dude... maybe if they aged up the actors they’d fit??
I don't know if you plan to have this song with the video, but OMG "Castle" by Hasley is so perfect for this book! The song gives off such a vibe for "Red Queen."
WE DESERVE A BETTER CAL N MAVEN
ASA BUTTERFIELD WOULD ACTUALLY FIT SO WELL WITH MAVEN, but there is someone else I think would look good as maven, search up “Dane dehann Valerian” the appearance of his character in valerian really matched Maven.
me encanto :0
Evangeline actually had long blonde hair and Mare has dark roots with blonde ends...
Why is russell crowe so perfect as king tiberias?
What is the name of the guy which Jennifer Morrison attacks?