I randomly found those videos in 2023. She got an great live voice. Wish 2023 singers would sign live. An few do, but not many they heavily use backtracks.
I Love this song. She has such a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL AMAZING VOICE!!!! This is such a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL AMAZING PERFORMANCE of her Hilary Duff. She is a REALLY TALENTED SINGER with a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL VOICE!!!!
WOW she is really singing LIVE i always believe that she cant sing and that she use playback but after watching this i totally agree that she can sing even better than so many (singers) today who cant even sing for example *selena gomez* nicki minag *.....etc
She usually uses playback and sings with it or it's a pre-recorded track to give more of a live rendition. I'd rather a raw pre recorded track then an artist mouthing to their exact studio version
listen to hilary in this video... then miley cyrus in another live video. miley belches her chords and screams into the mic while hilary actually has singing talent. i miss her!!
I appreciate when they sing live, even if it's off pitch or tone at least I know I paid for a live show. But that outfit is horrid haha. Oh the fashion back then
Catchy song by a performer and troupe with lots of showbiz pizzazz and well practiced stage presence. Too bad her record company at the time, Hollywood Records, did not support a larger musical tour and professionally produced music videos. Any such videos seem to be owned by the mass media on which those one of a kind performances were aired, such as the Ellen DeGeneris TV Show (Warner Studios/ABC) - an A plus performance which is no longer available to the general public. As Gordon Gekko advised, "Greed is Good." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Gekko
she sounds soo good live!!!
I randomly found those videos in 2023. She got an great live voice. Wish 2023 singers would sign live. An few do, but not many they heavily use backtracks.
I Love this song. She has such a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL AMAZING VOICE!!!! This is such a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL AMAZING PERFORMANCE of her Hilary Duff. She is a REALLY TALENTED SINGER with a REALLY GOOD BEAUTIFUL VOICE!!!!
Oh my god. I was so obsessed with this back then. I still know all the lyrics 😭😭😭💜
WOW she is really singing LIVE i always believe that she cant sing and that she use playback but after watching this i totally agree that she can sing even better than so many (singers) today who cant even sing for example *selena gomez* nicki minag *.....etc
She usually uses playback and sings with it or it's a pre-recorded track to give more of a live rendition. I'd rather a raw pre recorded track then an artist mouthing to their exact studio version
This is probably dubbed
Sometimes she sings along with her playback to stay in pitch.
Now I'm enjoying! I love her and I aprecciate when she really sings ;) I was there, I went to her show in Brazil!!!
her voice is so amazing live !!!!
Her voice has really changed i like it i know its prerecorded but still i love this song :)
YOUR SIMPLY AMAZING HILARY !
Her voice sounds like pure Honey! Wow!
now that was soooo good!
Lizzie McGuire ❤️💜
Live !
Wow she's amazing !
LOve her
shes so amzing
refreshing, i love it!
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G :D!!!!
She sings amazing live!!!
LIVE. and awesome.
in this song , you can hear her real voice :) LOVE U
Her voice is perfect, just like her
How I miss her..
LINDAAAAAAA!!!!!!!PERFEITA !!!! VALEUUUU -BRAZIL
Jessica Kate the illegal
Jessica Kate
Me gusta el sonido de su respiracion, asi compruebo que de verdad es live :)
she sings really good live
wow Ferpect!!
you can tell it's live because her voice changed a lot since she had made Beat of My heart and you can hear her breathe..
Nice video .
live live live live =D
i prefer this version to the studio!
su voz entre más grande es preciosa!! como adoro a esta chica!!!❤
antonio guerrero performances
The people saying “her singing is so good” are wild 😂😂😂😂😂😂
i love you hilary
A singer who actually doesn't use auto tune!
shut up! she say to E! news that Dignity Tour was totally live! so I believe in her!
When was this performed? ;o
She is so good live!!
I dont know why shes always making playblack! :)
and I could tell him, "your mom was my role model when i was a kid!"
I'm sure she's already his hero too :)
She used to lipsynch a lot but i think this is really live.
All about you
listen to hilary in this video... then miley cyrus in another live video. miley belches her chords and screams into the mic while hilary actually has singing talent. i miss her!!
@yahiie so only lip sang like once or twice-- and that was when she was sick or lost her voice!
yum
search Jennifer cubberley
Her son would be like "OMG! My mom was HOT back then?"
I appreciate when they sing live, even if it's off pitch or tone at least I know I paid for a live show. But that outfit is horrid haha. Oh the fashion back then
@lDarkMagic well, she is not
her outfit is so libra..
joey nosi tvoju energy
Why worry ?
Chupito el pame, chupito el pame, chupito el pame , chupito el pame....
Catchy song by a performer and troupe with lots of showbiz pizzazz and well practiced stage presence. Too bad her record company at the time, Hollywood Records, did not support a larger musical tour and professionally produced music videos. Any such videos seem to be owned by the mass media on which those one of a kind performances were aired, such as the Ellen DeGeneris TV Show (Warner Studios/ABC) - an A plus performance which is no longer available to the general public. As Gordon Gekko advised, "Greed is Good." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Gekko
Pool
The glee shows
Lower
OMG! Thats not her singling! lol
se parece mucho a un recital de miley cyrus! como del 2008 obvio
vestuario, look, coristas, bailarines!
el recital de miley se parece al de Hilary mejor dicho.
Dignity hurts apparently
Interesting, that's the exact same thing that I hate.
The more talented the female singer, the less skin they show. It's disappointing.