Well.. We have seen him in firestar's quest and in graystripe's vow. Also he was mentioned in ravenpaw's farewell. So he cant be Bone or BloodClan Cat.
@@CytrynoweFutro And he was mentioned in Moonrise when LeafPool(paw) was stuck in the two legs cage. Riley told her that smudge was still a popular cat around the neighbourhood with a lot of friends or something Edit: Cody* (not Riley) and Dawn* (Not moonrise)
@@garlicbreadarmy_official all the person did was do editing and pretty much make different versions of the same image for different things for the used character(s). Aka this person used a editing app and used a picrew by somebody else, in this case harvestbrook, or whatever else it is the picrew maker goes by. They are on UA-cam I'm pretty sure.
my dude firestar isn't justified here, I mean, he abandoned smudge for some random dudes who like to kill eachother and THEN when smudge wanted to join to be with him, Firestar's just like, "mmmm no, sorry bud."
So now we can't choose their own path in life just because others will be sad? I'm sorry but that's just stupid. Fire liked the forest more and felt better there. Why should he stay at a place that he doesn't like, just to keep his friend happy? Plus, Fire wasn't the boss of Smudge. Smudge could have done it by himself, he was a grown a$$ tom, not a young kitten
Is this an AU based comment? First off Smudge wanted Rusty to stay; but staying meant for Rusty that he would have to accept getting 'fixed' by the cutter and the end of any potential lineage or desire for freedom. The second part never happens in the book but lets hypothesize. If Smudge had followed Rusty into the forest sometime afterwards of course Firepaw/heart would have advocated for him to be accepted into the clan. Most likely the issue would be out of his paws either Bluestar wouldn't have been able to accept him because of the xenopanic that would rise in other cats because of Bluestar's openness to bring in kittypets into the clan; something that cats like Tigerclaw would take advantage of. Or Smudge himself would be unable to adapt to clan life and so would eventually be rejected. There is also the issue of wether he attempted to join before or after being cut. Atleast in 'into the wild' it emphasises how being cut changes a cat making them lazier etc. As a kittypet Smudge after being cut doesn't have a care in the world, he doesn't have a legacy to worry about or any change in the future to prepare for.
Fun fact: Smudge was asked to join bloodclan, but he said no and managed to get the bloodclan cats to go away. But with barley, he was actually in bloodclan for a while and left, leaving and becoming a rouge. (Edit- I know this isn’t true, this is a fun fact about one of the theories a person made)
Okay, hear me out: After Firestar joins the clans, Smudge scared of what could happen to him tries to follow him but gets stopped by Tigerclaw alone. Smudge tries to fight him but gets injured and instead of running home thinking he would get taken to the vet, he ran to the city and meets Brick and Bone and lives with them as a cat they raised him. Scourge makes the clans (I dont remember whos older, Firestar or Scourge lol) but he joins the fight and after seeing tigerstar die then his best friend, 'die' (Aka lose a life) he runs away for good and goes back to his two legs nest but get adopted by someone else
I made an au on this back in 2020, I believe that he tried to look for firestar and got caught by animal control. A young cat said the cat looked tough so scourge broke him out. Scourge asked what his name was, (since Rusty had a name change, he thought he needed one too) so he said, “bone” then boom he became part of blood clan
@@Gacha_Moon112 not to spoil or anything if you haven't read the second series but, Cody mentions that Smudge still lives with his twolegs so I don't think Bone and Smudge are the same person
Theory: after Rusty left smudge felt lonely and left, he ended up at the city (bigger twoleg place) he starts to feel at home but then he meets bloodclan, he tries to defend himself but then scourge steps in and so smudge may join! He accepts and joins BC. As soon as the big battle starts he sees firestar, knowing that's rusty he stands still in shock before getting attacked from behind by another cat and so later firestar finds smudge dead.
Smudge couldn't have been bone, Firestar would've recognized him, and his collar would've been different. He's also seen in Firestar's quest with no noticeable scars.
I haven’t read the books and i know this isn’t true it’s just a theory like for example another theory is that sweetpaw died bc she was buried alive while in a coma but it’s false she died bc she ate crow food/rotten prey
The fact that I also only read the first book too 🤣🤣 I eventually kinda forgot about the Fandom then randomly these fan videos showing up on my feed- UA-cam tryna pull me back into the Fandom or what? XD
Imagine if this did happen! All the drama would be such a cool thing to the books, and which book would it happen in! The art style is amazing, I love it!
He said . “Oh Mary. Contrary.how does your garden grow.. come with me .. and you’ll be .the seventh maid in the row… “my answer .. was laughter soft as I lowered my head..”you’re too late .. I’m afraid … the flowers are already .. DEADDDDD…”
Smudge had black and white fur with amber eyes, and Bone has too. What if Bone had been Smudge all along and joined Bloodclan to fight Firestar as vengeance against him leaving him behind?
ok, but hear me out. (SPOILERS AHEAD) In the rise of Scourge, Tiny goes out into the wild just like Rusty and faces Tigerpaw, ThistleClaw, and Bluefur. Tiny gets injured by the apprentice, and runs away not going home, and goes into the city. After some conversations, and rumors he could fight a grown dog, he meets Bone and Brick. Lemme remind you, in the manga Bone is a grown cat, and Smudge might have been a teeny weeny kit. But I absolutely love this AU yall are making.
*Bad ending*: Smudge felt betrayed after Rusty(FireStar) left to join the forest cats, and wanted to show him what a wild cat really is. Good ending: Smudge accepted Rusty(FireStar) leaving.
Those who don't know: Rusty Known as firestar was a kittypet and smudge was his best friend but smudge ended up joining bloodclan and went completely rouge but firestar tried to tell him to join thunder clan with him so that they would never be apart again Hope this helps
Hey! It's Warrior Cat's Picrew! Pretty genius to use a build-a-doll Warrior cat picrew for different expressions and for a video. Probably should credit that tho.
If you were wondering the song is "secret garden" by EmpathP the title of the video is "[undertale] Secret Garden [original song]" the part in the video is the first part of the song
Because Fire paw left him at the kitty pets house when they were best friends just so he could be a warrior and he never came back to smudge and I think smudge went to blood clan and changed
Honestly, Smudge could win in a fight like this. I'm pretty sure he was already bigger than firestar before he turned into a thunder clan cat, and firestar possibly wouldn't be able to fight him since he didn't want to hurt his friend. (This is coming from someone who's only read the first book, so sorry if this is wrong)
Pleas put credit for the real artist, the one who make the picrew, the AU seems cool but you can’t make this with art of other people and act like you MADE ALL the thing
I think it'd be runny if you put smudge, barley, fireheart, and ravenpaw in the same room like Fireheart: WHICH ONE IS IT!?!?! Ravenpaw:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA barley and smudges collective brain cells: AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
I can’t watch this video anymore. The more I watch it the more SADNESS I get from smudge betraying firestar. Because smudge was my favorite cat too. But now they’re enemies and I HATE smudge for that. Firestar will always be top of my list for favorite warrior cat.
This is kinda random, but if I’m right, pinestar loved jake and was mates with him, jake is firestars dad, and scourges dad, and pinestar is tigerstars dad, so kinda firestar killed his half-brother and his step-brother
imagine, firestars childhood friend left him for his half-brother, reasonable since he left him for strange naked forest cats.
The last line 🤣
Yeah lol
THOS MADE ME LAUGH HAHA
I’m a strange naked forest cat 😃😃
“Strange naked forest cat” AYO WHAT-
Y'all, what if Smude actually joined Bloodclan and Firestar had to face him
I kinda wish that happend lol
Well.. We have seen him in firestar's quest and in graystripe's vow. Also he was mentioned in ravenpaw's farewell. So he cant be Bone or BloodClan Cat.
@@CytrynoweFutro And he was mentioned in Moonrise when LeafPool(paw) was stuck in the two legs cage. Riley told her that smudge was still a popular cat around the neighbourhood with a lot of friends or something
Edit: Cody* (not Riley) and Dawn* (Not moonrise)
@@TANGL3_BURR He isn't
Maybe he's bone?
“They took my balls, I took their lives”
bro what
LMFAO
WHERE DO YOU GET YOUR HUMOUR FROM😭
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
@@LeebittyNO BECAUSE THID ACTUALLY GOES IN THE SERIES💀
Wait I just realized that Firestar never actually said goodbye to smudge before he left the forest. Right?
woah, 550 likes, thanks yalls lmao
Like when firestar died.?
@@Rogue_ErrorXD mgm
@@SP1D3Rstudios ?
@@Rogue_ErrorXD mhm* sorry, that’s so embarrassing!
Well, it mentioned that he and Cloudtail went to say goodbye to Princess, so I’d assume that he sought Smudge out too… it never does say though.
Wow- pretty good AU. I can already tell Smudge was upset after FireStar left him to be with the clans. Bravo!
fr, the animating is great!
@@garlicbreadarmy_official all the person did was do editing and pretty much make different versions of the same image for different things for the used character(s).
Aka this person used a editing app and used a picrew by somebody else, in this case harvestbrook, or whatever else it is the picrew maker goes by. They are on UA-cam I'm pretty sure.
You know what isthe song?😅
Pls Antwerp ME...I really like this song...😢
Answer*
my dude firestar isn't justified here, I mean, he abandoned smudge for some random dudes who like to kill eachother and THEN when smudge wanted to join to be with him, Firestar's just like, "mmmm no, sorry bud."
Destined-for-prophecy-and-leader cats ONLY, SMUDGE
So now we can't choose their own path in life just because others will be sad? I'm sorry but that's just stupid. Fire liked the forest more and felt better there. Why should he stay at a place that he doesn't like, just to keep his friend happy? Plus, Fire wasn't the boss of Smudge. Smudge could have done it by himself, he was a grown a$$ tom, not a young kitten
@@zippywarriors1177 bruh he's just saying his thoughts (I'm not trying to be rude)
@@claustro131 and they’re trying to say THEIR thoughts? Hypocritical much?
Is this an AU based comment? First off Smudge wanted Rusty to stay; but staying meant for Rusty that he would have to accept getting 'fixed' by the cutter and the end of any potential lineage or desire for freedom.
The second part never happens in the book but lets hypothesize. If Smudge had followed Rusty into the forest sometime afterwards of course Firepaw/heart would have advocated for him to be accepted into the clan. Most likely the issue would be out of his paws either Bluestar wouldn't have been able to accept him because of the xenopanic that would rise in other cats because of Bluestar's openness to bring in kittypets into the clan; something that cats like Tigerclaw would take advantage of. Or Smudge himself would be unable to adapt to clan life and so would eventually be rejected. There is also the issue of wether he attempted to join before or after being cut. Atleast in 'into the wild' it emphasises how being cut changes a cat making them lazier etc. As a kittypet Smudge after being cut doesn't have a care in the world, he doesn't have a legacy to worry about or any change in the future to prepare for.
Fun fact: Smudge was asked to join bloodclan, but he said no and managed to get the bloodclan cats to go away. But with barley, he was actually in bloodclan for a while and left, leaving and becoming a rouge.
(Edit- I know this isn’t true, this is a fun fact about one of the theories a person made)
That is false. That would be a fun AU though! Rogue Smudge
That would be cool but it isn’t true
Okay, hear me out:
After Firestar joins the clans, Smudge scared of what could happen to him tries to follow him but gets stopped by Tigerclaw alone. Smudge tries to fight him but gets injured and instead of running home thinking he would get taken to the vet, he ran to the city and meets Brick and Bone and lives with them as a cat they raised him. Scourge makes the clans (I dont remember whos older, Firestar or Scourge lol) but he joins the fight and after seeing tigerstar die then his best friend, 'die' (Aka lose a life) he runs away for good and goes back to his two legs nest but get adopted by someone else
or Smudge could be Bone
@@notnamelesschannel6367 he's not
@@MercuriYT i know, it’s just a theory that i heard
Scourge is older than Firestar
I believe Scourge is Firestar's older half brother??
I made an au on this back in 2020, I believe that he tried to look for firestar and got caught by animal control. A young cat said the cat looked tough so scourge broke him out. Scourge asked what his name was, (since Rusty had a name change, he thought he needed one too) so he said, “bone” then boom he became part of blood clan
I thought: mh, he looks like Bone... Wait is Smudge Bone! : I was so shockt after that that I knew he was not the same enymore...
@@Gacha_Moon112 no I don’t believe smudge is bone in the darkest hour it has blood clan and still shows smudge as a two legged cat
@@pandaberry6873 I know but ITS wierd! But you can allso not no if thats Smudge or not.. only the Erins can know that
@@Gacha_Moon112 not to spoil or anything if you haven't read the second series but, Cody mentions that Smudge still lives with his twolegs so I don't think Bone and Smudge are the same person
The AU where Ravenpaw becomes Scourge and Smudge becomes Bone lives rent free in my mind at all times
Edit: guys do you not know what AU means
But we see Ravenpaw in The New Prophecy Midnight which takes place after the battle with BloodClan. Scourge died.
Yes. And we see Smudge in Firestar’s Quest, which also takes place after the battle. That’s why I said AU!
@@axelf9947 whatever, canon sucks. That AU is really interesting
..Now that I think of it, ravenpaw is scourge in the pirate scourge map..
@@F-o-x- isn’t that map by the Cheetahz dude?
Smudge: "You left me for a gang of naked gay cats in the woods."
Firestar: "At least I still have my balls."
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
For the person who dont know the animation is made with a picrew made by harvestbrook
Thank you SO much! I was about to ask , then get an answer like.. 2 months later! 😅
They stole this and every other short
"How many times have you watched thi-"
"*YES*"
100 times
It's made in picrew
Fr--
the old smudge is already dead...
Theory: after Rusty left smudge felt lonely and left, he ended up at the city (bigger twoleg place) he starts to feel at home but then he meets bloodclan, he tries to defend himself but then scourge steps in and so smudge may join! He accepts and joins BC. As soon as the big battle starts he sees firestar, knowing that's rusty he stands still in shock before getting attacked from behind by another cat and so later firestar finds smudge dead.
Nice AU!
As Rusty left Smudge when they were 6-12 moons old, Smudge could’ve grown and join Bloodclan by being the actual BONE-😀
Smudge couldn't have been bone, Firestar would've recognized him, and his collar would've been different. He's also seen in Firestar's quest with no noticeable scars.
Not quite. Scourge is much older than Smudge, and Smudge met an adult Bone as a kit
Smudge was much younger then Rusty. Rusty was 6M and i believe that Smudge was only 3M.
also, by the way, smudge went to the cutter.
Oooo! I would love an evil Smudge fanfic!
Me too! That would be awesome
For a sec I thought this actually happened bc im still on the 1st book of the 1st series so I was like “nOoOoOoOoOo SmUdGe YoUr NoT aLoUd To Do ThIs”
I haven’t read the books and i know this isn’t true it’s just a theory like for example another theory is that sweetpaw died bc she was buried alive while in a coma but it’s false she died bc she ate crow food/rotten prey
@@Orthodox_Romania it’s not a theory, this is not possible, it’s just a fun AU idea :)
Dude get ready for a heck of a rollercoaster
The fact that I also only read the first book too 🤣🤣 I eventually kinda forgot about the Fandom then randomly these fan videos showing up on my feed- UA-cam tryna pull me back into the Fandom or what? XD
how far are you now?
I CANT STOP WATCHING THIS
Same here
SAMEE
Ooh wait that would be so cool if smudge was really at bloodclan !
I imagine smudge responding to this if he was in bloodclan saying "its to late. You promised you would go only for a look and then left me"
Ох, я ощущаю ностальгию одновременно по 2 фандомам в 1 видео:')
Imagine if this did happen! All the drama would be such a cool thing to the books, and which book would it happen in! The art style is amazing, I love it!
He said . “Oh Mary. Contrary.how does your garden grow.. come with me .. and you’ll be .the seventh maid in the row… “my answer .. was laughter soft as I lowered my head..”you’re too late .. I’m afraid … the flowers are already .. DEADDDDD…”
Woah imagine if this was how it went the battle agenst blood clan would be way sadder then it already is
Smudge had black and white fur with amber eyes, and Bone has too. What if Bone had been Smudge all along and joined Bloodclan to fight Firestar as vengeance against him leaving him behind?
Cool au
Theory:WHAT IF BONE AND SMUDGE ARE THE SAME CAT THEY SHARE SIMILARITIES ESPECIALLY IN LOOK
It’s not true Smudge is in Firestars Quest and is mentioned in Dawn
ok, but hear me out. (SPOILERS AHEAD)
In the rise of Scourge, Tiny goes out into the wild just like Rusty and faces Tigerpaw, ThistleClaw, and Bluefur. Tiny gets injured by the apprentice, and runs away not going home, and goes into the city. After some conversations, and rumors he could fight a grown dog, he meets Bone and Brick. Lemme remind you, in the manga Bone is a grown cat, and Smudge might have been a teeny weeny kit.
But I absolutely love this AU yall are making.
This made me want to cry-
I've got ya
*Bad ending*: Smudge felt betrayed after Rusty(FireStar) left to join the forest cats, and wanted to show him what a wild cat really is.
Good ending: Smudge accepted Rusty(FireStar) leaving.
Those who don't know:
Rusty Known as firestar was a kittypet and smudge was his best friend but smudge ended up joining bloodclan and went completely rouge but firestar tried to tell him to join thunder clan with him so that they would never be apart again
Hope this helps
Only in this AU
@ShortehJordeh no, it actually happened which then led to smudge dying
@@Str4wbrry_L0tus yeah but he didn’t join bloodclan
@@ShortyJordyB Yea he did💀
@@Str4wbrry_L0tus but he didn’t replace bone like he did here
I love how this was created with Picrew! It's awesome!
What's the picrew name?
They stole this tho
Best AU I've found so far
It's stolen. You can see the original creators watermark, and if you check this person's channel, the tiktok accounts don't match up
OMG THIS IS SUCH A GOOD THEORY! What if after Firestar left Smudge decided to get revenge? Thats so cool!
Hey! It's Warrior Cat's Picrew!
Pretty genius to use a build-a-doll Warrior cat picrew for different expressions and for a video.
Probably should credit that tho.
This is my favorite use of Licrew this far.
If you were wondering the song is "secret garden" by EmpathP the title of the video is "[undertale] Secret Garden [original song]" the part in the video is the first part of the song
i personally think that smuge is too soft for bloodclan, but its an interesting thing to think about. Btw nice art!
it was made with a picrew
The animation is really good
It’s editing, and they stole it and every other short they posted
If anyone wants to know the song is secret garden
This is a really cool AU
omg if bone was smudge that would be crazy
this animation about warriors cats is very nice but why one warrior cats is crying
Because Fire paw left him at the kitty pets house when they were best friends just so he could be a warrior and he never came back to smudge and I think smudge went to blood clan and changed
because he left smudge at the kittypet place and is begging for him to come back
@@WarriorAnna17 oh that very sad i can't believe he left poor warriors cats
@@WarriorAnna17 meavy this warriors cats about blood clan she had a hard life in the past
they don’t even own the art on it
Smudge is bone, we all thought bone was scourge, but bone is actually smudge
It’s strange that Scourge and Firestar are half brothers but it never mentions it in the books 🤔
Was this made on picrew? Thats so cool!!
Yeah! I've seen it. Really creative
@@BingBongEditsthey didn’t make it tho
Smudge: you should of never left ಠ_ಠ
It would be really sad if smudge was in bloodclan
I remember I first saw this before I finished reading the first arc and I thought it was canon- 😭💀
This made me cry
FOR EVERYONE THIS IDEA WAS TAKEN FROM LESBIAN FROG LADY GIVE CREDITS TO ORIGINAL CREATOR!
Actualy made me cry WHYY-
(BAD SMUDGE! BAD,-)
This is actually practically the coolest POV i've ever seen for WC!!
IT'S SO UNDERRATED!
I'm crying 😭
What’s the adio called and/or from? I really want to know!
Secret garden
Honestly, Smudge could win in a fight like this. I'm pretty sure he was already bigger than firestar before he turned into a thunder clan cat, and firestar possibly wouldn't be able to fight him since he didn't want to hurt his friend. (This is coming from someone who's only read the first book, so sorry if this is wrong)
That kind of leaves me in a theory that what if Bone is Smudge? He is big and a bit chubby. That is a little disturbing for me.
Oxii o picrew não permite usar as imagens assim atoa não cara, eu sei que é um cat maker do picrew porquê ja joguei e conheço os traços do desenho
Please give credit to the Picrew link!
Yeah they stole this as of everything else
I love this! You need to make more! I been watching your videos for 2 minutes, and i love your videos!!!!
This would be an awesome plot twist in the books ngl
Pleas put credit for the real artist, the one who make the picrew, the AU seems cool but you can’t make this with art of other people and act like you MADE ALL the thing
Well its kinda fair beacuse FireStar left him to join ThunderClan
Imagine smudge actually accepted Fury's offer
I think it'd be runny if you put smudge, barley, fireheart, and ravenpaw in the same room like Fireheart: WHICH ONE IS IT!?!?!
Ravenpaw:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA barley and smudges collective brain cells: AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
What's the song name?
Secret garden?
@@mitsukitsayuri ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ᵐᵃʸᵇᵉ I'll look it up and see
@@mitsukitsayuri your right it is secret garden- also i scrolled through these chats to find the name of this song so you really helped
*Give me more*
Oh smudge was on blood clan? I didn’t know that! Maybe it’s bc I didn’t finish the books
No dw he didnt
What! Really good art!
it was a picrew
Y’all gave these people no credit
they used a picrew man
There should be a warrior cats version of what if and this could be one of the episodes "What if Smudge joind blood clan"
Why do they look like a better warrior cats mini maker
Firestar:oh smudge my best friend
Greystripe:👁👄👁
That would be so traumatic
That would be really interesting if he was a part of bloodclan
I honestly would like to see this in the books
Just a my theory,but imagine if barley and smudge are brothers and theire father is bone
this is so good! it's my favourite edit!
Too late, smudge already faced the cutter
What if smudge joined scourge and he was bone... as he might,ve been renamed like rusty became firepaw, fireheart and firestar
I can’t watch this video anymore. The more I watch it the more SADNESS I get from smudge betraying firestar. Because smudge was my favorite cat too. But now they’re enemies and I HATE smudge for that. Firestar will always be top of my list for favorite warrior cat.
Me: Firestar......you dont kill him......... *I WILL*
Those would be the famous last words of smudge
🗣️: “how many times have you wa-“
Me:”YES!”
When I first saw bone I honestly thought he was smudge bahaha 😂
10/10! I love this this is now my favorite and ur my favorite person
It had like 682 likes when I watched it, I'm so happy that it got famous!
The fact that smudge was still waiting for fire star even after firestars death for firestar to visit him 😢
I watched it like four times😂😊
A lot of people think Smudge joined BloodClan, but we can tell from the book "Into the Wild" that he wasn't meant for clans, including BloodClan.
Dramatic! 😢and sad 😔
Smudge is one of my favorites
smudges 2 brothers are the new leaders of bloodclan as scourge and bone are now dead.
Barley's*
This is kinda random, but if I’m right, pinestar loved jake and was mates with him, jake is firestars dad, and scourges dad, and pinestar is tigerstars dad, so kinda firestar killed his half-brother and his step-brother
I have watched this video practically hundreds of times. It is my favorite videos I’ve ever watched! 💕💕
The theory of Smudge being Bone has been swirling in my mind for a while
This would have been an amazing twist tho
He looks terrifying 😭😭
Smudge:The old smudge is already dead
Firestar: BUZZ CUT MOCHI
This is the most liked wcue short i ever seen ✨😭
Coming back to this 2 years later, im suprised i spent all this time looking for this.