Realmente cuando escuchas esta musica tan bella, no puedes no emocionarte, esta maravilla toca la fibra mas intima del alma. Un genio Tchaicovsky!!!! .
@cornel999 No you have to see the whole movie to understand...this is a very good movie full of emotions and this is the final scene where you understand why she's playing that well! See the movie ;) "Le concert" with Melanie Laurent as the solist
J'ai bien aimé ce film qui montre que malgré toutes les tourmentes de la vie, un fil ténu unit toutes sortes de gens dans le monde entier et que même séparées des personnes peuvent se retrouver et triompher même sur plus fort que soi... car la musique est un pont sacré entre les individus que rien ni personne ne pourra jamais détruire!
They cut a scene! In the original version (I'm french), when Andreï calls Leonid through the glass at the airport, he give him the finger . Then Leonid did the "huh face".
It's a French production. The director is Romanian-born, that's all. But the money and almost everything else in the film is French. Even more, the director was born in Romania but left it to study and live in France. I'm not French, for the record.
apparently she spent about 6 months training with a professional violinist standing behind her who is the one playing the audio so that they could be more in synch, but she learnt just the posture and technique to imitate her just for this piece. so it's her performing it, but not her playing it.. if that makes sense?
Steven Gerrard, I think the real viollonist was Sarah Nemtanu, who was also the violin coach for Laurent for two months before the movie. With the Budapest Philarmonic. So we have a Romanian director, with a French/Romanian/Gypsy/Russian/Jewish cast, a Romanian violonist and a Hungarian orchestra... Who says the European union does not work???
Oué...Quel virtuosité de jeux d'acteurs! dans cette scène. cela me donne envie de regarder ce film. J'en profiterai pour lire le générique de fin et savoir qui joue cette scène? De toutes manières, il est très possible qu'un ingénieur du son soit passer par là...! excellente prise et arrangement du son en studio! et bravo à tous ces gens qui ont participer à ce film.
Sencillamente extraordinaria este Concierto, vi la película, admiro la música de Tchaicovsky, dejó un legado importante a la humanidad a travez de su música
Well. it seems that the lovely violinist is the baby who was smuggled in (into Paris?) when her concert violinist mother and her father were sent to a Siberian concentration camp ... the black and white bits are the past- the mother always played the Tschaikovsky concerto that the girl is playing - while in the camp, but without the violin. She was therefore called, 'the crazy one'. The father died of grief 6 months later. The baby was passed on to a couple of families, and I think wound up
...wound up with the director. So when she plays so miraculously, she brings the orchestra from possible tragedy not only musically but really- they get to tour the world and get a new life. That's what I got from it!
BRAVISSIMO,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111VOY A TENER QUE VER TODA LA PELICULA YA QUE CON SOLO OBSERVAR ESTA PORCION YA ME QUEDE CON LAS GANAS DE VERLA INTEGRA..
@surfboy don't fret. If you really believe in what you do and are happy doing it, with hard work and perseverance I'm sure you'll make it. Make the standards you set for yoursdelf your light at the end oif your tunnel. Strive for it and you'll get. there.And Iagree with you. She is indeed a marvelous violinst.
on the dvd they do an interview, combination of a good actress and a wonderful coach. same reason that Neo could say: 'i know kung fu', and not be laughed at.
She does a really convincing performance of this. Especially the bowing arm. I wonder how they did this. Is it her or a stand in? She even does vibrato on the notes with vibrato and straight tone on the notes that aren't vibrato. I've only been playing for 5 years, and she does a much better "fake" than I could ever do.
@cornel999 Not necessarily you must be French, you can also be Russian to understand it. The world doesn't end outside of the English culture... Indeed, the film is French-Russian. If you like it, like for a translated version that suits you.
In the bonus on the DVD, you will see that's not the actress who really playing. She has just learned the movement like a real violinist during six mounth for the final scene. And no, it's not horrible, it's just a little different that the real concerto, but I suppose this is done on purpose for the movie.
Couldn't agree more. Though the one thing that makes it obvious she's not the one playing it is that she's standing still, there's no "feeling" I might say. Really good acting nonetheless.
Not trying to be a nerd or anything but I'm a professional string player. It's not her playing, obviously, but i think that girl can actually play a little bit. There are people who specialize in training actors how to fake instruments. it could actually be that this actress practiced how to fake. she has a very nice left hand. The woman with the dark hair is absolutely a string player.
Watched the US trailer for some background, and it has almost nothing to do with this performance. While the story might be interesting in toto, the fact is this section is completely different than that trailer, and a whole lot better. Forget the rest...and just enjoy this! You'll pick up enough to understand what's happening.
I cried like a child when I first saw this scene
I alway cry like a child whit this scene!
Never thought i'd get so emotional over violin music and one of the best Happy Endings in a movie....
I cry every time I see this scene...
I am so glad that I could watch this last scene again on UA-cam I cried because it is so moving and beautiful Perfect harmony and sound
Tchaikovsky violin concerto is single most Greatest public violin work......
Questo concerto, questo violino, questo film riescono ad emozionarmi, a tirar fuori il meglio di me ogni volta che lo guardo....
Realmente cuando escuchas esta musica tan bella, no puedes no emocionarte, esta maravilla toca la fibra mas intima del alma. Un genio Tchaicovsky!!!! .
2024今見ても泣いてます。
I'm still crying when I watch it now 2024
Histoire encore plus tristement touchante en cette mi- fevrier 2024 . La musique parle d'elle même.
Un grand moment d'émotion, il faut prendre le temps de regarder le film pour mieux comprendre cette histoire folle..
@cornel999 No you have to see the whole movie to understand...this is a very good movie full of emotions and this is the final scene where you understand why she's playing that well! See the movie ;) "Le concert" with Melanie Laurent as the solist
J'ai bien aimé ce film qui montre que malgré toutes les tourmentes de la vie, un fil ténu unit toutes sortes de gens dans le monde entier et que même séparées des personnes peuvent se retrouver et triompher même sur plus fort que soi... car la musique est un pont sacré entre les individus que rien ni personne ne pourra jamais détruire!
one of my favorite ends, this movi is realy beautiful... and very funy :)
Sarah Nemtanu, a Romanian-French violonist and concertmaster of the French national orchestra.
They cut a scene! In the original version (I'm french), when Andreï calls Leonid through the glass at the airport, he give him the finger . Then Leonid did the "huh face".
It's a French production. The director is Romanian-born, that's all. But the money and almost everything else in the film is French. Even more, the director was born in Romania but left it to study and live in France.
I'm not French, for the record.
我最愛的電影，每年都要重看，最後的演奏可以重複聽一整天
진짜 희대의 명장면.. 처음에 서로 안맞다가 하모니로 하나가 되는 연출까지 완벽..
apparently she spent about 6 months training with a professional violinist standing behind her who is the one playing the audio so that they could be more in synch, but she learnt just the posture and technique to imitate her just for this piece. so it's her performing it, but not her playing it.. if that makes sense?
This movie was incredible! I advise you watch it.
A mi me emociona esta música tan bella y esa estupenda violinista que tan bien la ejecuta arrastrando con ella a la orquesta.
Steven Gerrard, I think the real viollonist was Sarah Nemtanu, who was also the violin coach for Laurent for two months before the movie. With the Budapest Philarmonic. So we have a Romanian director, with a French/Romanian/Gypsy/Russian/Jewish cast, a Romanian violonist and a Hungarian orchestra... Who says the European union does not work???
muy muy buena pelicula! esta escena es la mejor...
Oué...Quel virtuosité de jeux d'acteurs! dans cette scène. cela me donne envie de regarder ce film. J'en profiterai pour lire le générique de fin et savoir qui joue cette scène? De toutes manières, il est très possible qu'un ingénieur du son soit passer par là...! excellente prise et arrangement du son en studio! et bravo à tous ces gens qui ont participer à ce film.
Hermoso! No tengo palabras esta pelicula es pura belleza y pura emocion!!! Bravo!!
Mamma mia questo pezzo è da pelle d'oca STUPENDO
i B R I V D I!!!!! questa musica è straordinaria!!!!
every time i watch this, i almost cry.
Sencillamente extraordinaria este Concierto, vi la película, admiro la música de Tchaicovsky, dejó un legado importante a la humanidad a travez de su música
lo más bello de tchaicovsky😍
Looks like a good movie...has anyone seen it?
Just watch this great movie!!
Bellissimo,emozionante
I cried, too !
Hermosa solo de verlo me quedo ganas de ver la pelicula
semplicemente superlativo
Et oui ! La France est capable de faire de super beaux films elle aussi !!!
I love this movie
Is fantastic
Excelente! Bravo!
beautiful hall ...
Well. it seems that the lovely violinist is the baby who was smuggled in (into Paris?) when her concert violinist mother and her father were sent to a Siberian concentration camp ... the black and white bits are the past- the mother always played the Tschaikovsky concerto that the girl is playing - while in the camp, but without the violin. She was therefore called, 'the crazy one'. The father died of grief 6 months later. The baby was passed on to a couple of families, and I think wound up
merveilleux ☺ :)
...wound up with the director. So when she plays so miraculously, she brings the orchestra from possible tragedy not only musically but really- they get to tour the world and get a new life. That's what I got from it!
BRAVISSIMO,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111VOY A TENER QUE VER TODA LA PELICULA YA QUE CON SOLO OBSERVAR ESTA PORCION YA ME QUEDE CON LAS GANAS DE VERLA INTEGRA..
Awesome!
Bravo!
Wow!!!!
Genial!!!❤️
@surfboy No she's an actress, but she learnt the movements with the first violin of the Paris' Opera
Por favor pasen la película completa en español castellano. Es bellísima!!!!❤️
@surfboy don't fret. If you really believe in what you do and are happy doing it, with hard work and perseverance I'm sure you'll make it. Make the standards you set for yoursdelf your light at the end oif your tunnel. Strive for it and you'll get. there.And Iagree with you. She is indeed a marvelous violinst.
d'accord avec vous.
@davidjgburnett Melanie Laurent who played in "Inglorious Bastards" - Quentin Tarantino
멜라니 로랑
그녀는 천사와같이 아름답다..
on the dvd they do an interview, combination of a good actress and a wonderful coach.
same reason that Neo could say: 'i know kung fu', and not be laughed at.
@davidjgburnett Sarah Nemtanu is the violinist.
you can get this movie/DVD from Netflix. Very good one/
I love tchousky and all the classical era I know I set it wrong. it's 6am
lindo!!
She does a really convincing performance of this. Especially the bowing arm. I wonder how they did this. Is it her or a stand in? She even does vibrato on the notes with vibrato and straight tone on the notes that aren't vibrato. I've only been playing for 5 years, and she does a much better "fake" than I could ever do.
@cornel999 Not necessarily you must be French, you can also be Russian to understand it. The world doesn't end outside of the English culture... Indeed, the film is French-Russian. If you like it, like for a translated version that suits you.
Excelente película. No sé por qué hay gente que hace tanto problema. Gran película y punto!
@cornel999
.
You have to watch to movie to understand
:3 Oh my god !
In the bonus on the DVD, you will see that's not the actress who really playing. She has just learned the movement like a real violinist during six mounth for the final scene. And no, it's not horrible, it's just a little different that the real concerto, but I suppose this is done on purpose for the movie.
Couldn't agree more. Though the one thing that makes it obvious she's not the one playing it is that she's standing still, there's no "feeling" I might say. Really good acting nonetheless.
magari scontanto, ma cosa importa!
Gran film....
onde eu posso achar esse filme completo e dublado?
@cornel999 there are english subtitles when they speak ._. but if you refer to the context, you have to see the movie or else you won't understand
It's not a fake, it's her who plays. =)
Léo Cluzet, you're wrong. She is playing for real.
This is torture, I wanna see a real performance of this piece now!
no wonder the left hand looks really convincing
does anyone know the violinst that played the actual audio?
Mrekulli
Por que le cortaron?
good mimicking...
No it is bad mimicking, specially at the end.
she practiced a lot of air violon before shooting
@cicciontek Do you often make sweeping generalizations about enormous groups of people or is it just something you do on the internet?
I know that. I'm saying that it's the same actress playing both roles.
You have to be human to understand this...Just watch the movie, and then comment again :).
Cette scene, je pleurir.
@cornel999 See note added to my post!!
who's real violonist playing ?
@Willou725 Yes but who is playing?
It's the same girl playing the dark haired girl if you look at the credits at the end of the movie.
at what time???
Not trying to be a nerd or anything but I'm a professional string player. It's not her playing, obviously, but i think that girl can actually play a little bit. There are people who specialize in training actors how to fake instruments. it could actually be that this actress practiced how to fake. she has a very nice left hand. The woman with the dark hair is absolutely a string player.
Now that I look at the clips though, I dont think that's her hand. hahaha
Incredible - who is the soloist?
Watched the US trailer for some background, and it has almost nothing to do with this performance. While the story might be interesting in toto, the fact is this section is completely different than that trailer, and a whole lot better. Forget the rest...and just enjoy this! You'll pick up enough to understand what's happening.
What cut scenes?
I noticed they cut some scenes! so bad!
It's cut here...in the movie it's shown how the two french guys are kissing in the backstage xD
she has nothing on the face, she doesn't move ... the music is so alive, but the actress is sleeping !
She does'nt play, actually the bowing arm is hers, but the other no ! She began 6 months before the film, and just trained the bow !
haha, why did you cut the kiss?
Did you cut out the two guys kissing backstage?
Y'a mon papa a 5:02!! :D