No se siente como algo especial. Quizás sea que técnicamente es algo único porque por las sensaciones creo que hay mucha música muy superior del mismo Beethoven. En particular la Novena me parece increíblemente superior.
Utiliza la fuga del Barroco para hacer una obra impresionista, tremendo!! que genio!! desde el clasicismo creo el romanticismo y desde el romanticismo hace una obra impresionista
This is a string orchestra version of that revolutionary awesome piece which was the initial finale of the quartet 13 op. 130. The publisher convinced Beethoven to separate it from the quartet, to compose a new finales (one of his last works) and to publish it separately. The incredible strength of this fugue led some conductors to extend the string quartet to a full string orchestra. My modest opinion id that it tends to thicken it and that Beethoven's version for SQ id more convincing, but the strength of this rendering is out of question.
This great masterpiece is much better with an ensemble of string players, rather than just a quartet. The depth and scope of the music demands more sonority among the instruments. I wish The Master had put this as the final movement of his Tenth Symphony.
This sounds wild and strange. To me, this string quartet remains a masterpiece that needs no addition at all. I wonder if Ludwig would have agreed to this, even if the orchestra sounds great.
IMHO, this piece is a bit too big for a quartet. Perhaps B realized that he didn't have long to live, so he expressed his remaining ideas in his Late Quartets and Sonatas.
Give it a rest. Listen to the string quartet version. There are plenty available. There is nothing wrong with presenting a piece of music in a different format or arrangement. Nothing sacrilegious out it.
Our beloved L van B Please, as we applaud orchestra and conductor, you MUST take thought for the dear price paid by the spouses of these string players, listening over, and over, and over again to the lone parts being honed and perfected for YEARS before this performance. They deserve a pension on that alone. Our beloved L van B - Eliminating Amateurs Since 1785.
A fugue is a multi-voice musical form that hinges on counterpoint between voices. Composers can write fugues for a single instrument (most notably a piano or other keyboard instrument), or they can write them for several individual players. The Fugue is one of the most complexed form of musical composition. This fugue was one of Bethoven last works. .
this musical masterpiece is beautifully disturbing. It's as if he revealed the most hidden human nature. He conceived a work that seemed to have shattered the "rules" of classical composition, bringing it into the contemporary era and for which his contemporaries were not ready neither culturally nor socially nor aesthetically. No wonder they were shocked and it was harshly criticized
I don't like the interpretation though the tempo in the meno mosso is good. The ritardando in the final is unnecessary. There are a lot of change in tempo and dynamism that are unnecessary.
I like to think that after a few hundred years or so, people are free to make interpretations of this song, such as having an orchestra, quartet, busker band, etc... Don't be super narrowminded people.
I can't help but find this work just plain weak and can't understand why some music lovers rate it so highly. The transcription doesn't make it any better. For me it remains a constructed, intentionally original thing that is not convincing.
This is a piece which requires deep listening skills in order to understand its emotional content. The piece is conveying something. It is conveying frustration, disorder, chaos, mental breakdown, and stress. Perhaps Beethoven was experiencing some of those issues when he wrote it. You just can't listen to a piece of music like this superficially and try to offer your opinion on it.
Olvida la teoría y escúchala como debe ser, ¿Por qué la música se ah vuelto algo lleno de egoísta? Es más, creo que Beethoven buscaba específicamente que tú sintieras eso
Con esta pieza, el divino Ludwig Van Beethoven se adelanto 100 años a su tiempo........ no me canso de escucharla.
Con esta música se adelanto 200 años y puede ser considerada hoy contemporánea Grandioso Beethoven
Es impresionante esta obra maestra. Beethoven adelantado a su época.
Esta obra salva a la humanidad por sí sola.
No se siente como algo especial. Quizás sea que técnicamente es algo único porque por las sensaciones creo que hay mucha música muy superior del mismo Beethoven. En particular la Novena me parece increíblemente superior.
Qué orgullo llamarme Ludwig!!!! Beethoven con su estilo siempre tan característico
😄
Cómo es posible que no haya escuchado esta maravilla hasta ahora.
Lo mismo me pasó! Soy beethoveniano desde hace 70 años y recién en este año la escucho!
Maravilloso. Que interpretación mas lúcida.
Muchas gracias 😊
Utiliza la fuga del Barroco para hacer una obra impresionista, tremendo!! que genio!! desde el clasicismo creo el romanticismo y desde el romanticismo hace una obra impresionista
No puedo dejar de llorar cada vez que la oigo, hace 50 años que la pongo y nunca se agota. Beethoven es Beethoven y dios es dios.
Nos encanta que te guste 😊
Como dice Ramón Gener: "Este tío tenía un teléfono con Dios!".
Su gran Virtuosidad; sólo puede ser superada por su: GRAN VIRTUOSIDAD, POR SU GRAN FUGA MUSICAL CELESTIAL.
Fenómeno musical extraordinario!
Herr erhalte uns unsere wunderbaren Rundfunksinfonieorchester !!!
Sublime
what a musical achievement 👏
This is a string orchestra version of that revolutionary awesome piece which was the initial finale of the quartet 13 op. 130. The publisher convinced Beethoven to separate it from the quartet, to compose a new finales (one of his last works) and to publish it separately. The incredible strength of this fugue led some conductors to extend the string quartet to a full string orchestra. My modest opinion id that it tends to thicken it and that Beethoven's version for SQ id more convincing, but the strength of this rendering is out of question.
bonita cancion, aguante Beethoven pa
This great masterpiece is much better with an ensemble of string players, rather than just a quartet. The depth and scope of the music demands more sonority among the instruments. I wish The Master had put this as the final movement of his Tenth Symphony.
Primera vez que escucho esta pieza de ese gran genio.....y estoy maravillado 🎉!!!!
Muchas gracias 😊
Il piu' grande miracolo di tutta la musica, come ha scritto Igor Stravinski!
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This sounds wild and strange. To me, this string quartet remains a masterpiece that needs no addition at all. I wonder if Ludwig would have agreed to this, even if the orchestra sounds great.
totally agree with u
it's kinda sacrilegious lol
IMHO, this piece is a bit too big for a quartet. Perhaps B realized that he didn't have long to live, so he expressed his remaining ideas in his Late Quartets and Sonatas.
@@tannhaeuserx464 You are right! this easy can be the X Shymphony finale.
Give it a rest. Listen to the string quartet version. There are plenty available. There is nothing wrong with presenting a piece of music in a different format or arrangement. Nothing sacrilegious out it.
Our beloved L van B
Please, as we applaud orchestra and conductor, you MUST take thought for the dear price paid by the spouses of these string players, listening over, and over, and over again to the lone parts being honed and perfected for YEARS before this performance.
They deserve a pension on that alone.
Our beloved L van B - Eliminating Amateurs Since 1785.
Realmente hermoso.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Gracias 😊
Top!
🥰
Εξαιρετική εκτέλεση!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you! 🤗
Dear WDR, could you (or someone) please tell me which (whose) adaptation for string orchestra are you using in this recording?
Dear Póta György,
it‘s Felix Weingartner.
Greetings from Cologne!
@@WDRKlassik , Thank you! :)
1:03 1:03 1:03
A fugue is a multi-voice musical form that hinges on counterpoint between voices. Composers can write fugues for a single instrument (most notably a piano or other keyboard instrument), or they can write them for several individual players. The Fugue is one of the most complexed form of musical composition. This fugue was one of Bethoven last works. .
You guys all sound ridiculous with fury over historicism. This sounds INCREDIBLE.
helps me sleep :)
Great, but it sounds less powerful than the original string quartet, and the motif is less clear.
I thought this was meant to be a string quartet piece?
It is correct that it is a string quartet. We play here the version for string orchestra by Felix Weingartner.
this musical masterpiece is beautifully disturbing. It's as if he revealed the most hidden human nature. He conceived a work that seemed to have shattered the "rules" of classical composition, bringing it into the contemporary era and for which his contemporaries were not ready neither culturally nor socially nor aesthetically. No wonder they were shocked and it was harshly criticized
The orchestration was made by the romanian composer Sabin Păutza.
No, no, no! LvB wouldn't agree ! It's his will, that the whole work of an orchestra has to be done by a string quartett. By the way: much too slow.
for my practice
p.2→1:49
C→3:22
역시 베토벤
이래서 베토벤에게 빠질 수 밖에 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
" 나 베토벤이야. " 라고 외치는 듯 ^^
이런 파격도 지향하는 베토벤을
하이든은 거리를 두면서도
속으로는 그의 시대가 오고 있음을 느꼈을 것.
I don't like the interpretation though the tempo in the meno mosso is good. The ritardando in the final is unnecessary. There are a lot of change in tempo and dynamism that are unnecessary.
I like to think that after a few hundred years or so, people are free to make interpretations of this song, such as having an orchestra, quartet, busker band, etc... Don't be super narrowminded people.
What an awful noise!
Escúchala con detenimiento, toma clases de música si es necesario.
This is slow to the level of boredom.
Yeah, it's very slow. Most performances I know take about 13-15 minutes which is a huge difference.
ah yes the famous B MAJOR grosse fugue…
Actually, in German, B-flat is called rather B, Natural-B called H, DUDE
There was an error in the English translation which we have corrected now. 😊
I can't help but find this work just plain weak and can't understand why some music lovers rate it so highly. The transcription doesn't make it any better. For me it remains a constructed, intentionally original thing that is not convincing.
This is a piece which requires deep listening skills in order to understand its emotional content. The piece is conveying something. It is conveying frustration, disorder, chaos, mental breakdown, and stress. Perhaps Beethoven was experiencing some of those issues when he wrote it. You just can't listen to a piece of music like this superficially and try to offer your opinion on it.
Olvida la teoría y escúchala como debe ser, ¿Por qué la música se ah vuelto algo lleno de egoísta? Es más, creo que Beethoven buscaba específicamente que tú sintieras eso