“He never called it what it was” *chills* “You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath” *more goosebumps* “You said if we were closer in age..” *tears* ”..it’s supposed to be fun turning 21” *💔* “ …but the punchline goes I get older but your lovers stay my age” *dead* Love your reaction 🥰
I was 52 driving to work bawling my eyes out when Red TV came out earlier than morning. Went straight to A2W (10 min) and let the waves wash over me. It's stunning really. I don't know how she improved on: "And you call me up again just to break me like a promise So casually cruel in the name of bein' honest I'm a crumpled-up piece of paper lyin' here" but she did...by adding: "They say all's well that ends well, but I'm in a new hell Every time you double-cross my mind"
“Can someone check Jake. Is he ok?”😂 “What did this man do?”🤣 7:12 my favorite part of the song! “And you call me up again just to break me like a promise”👌
I totally agree with you about this version being unforgiving both in her delivery vocally speaking and the lyrics choices she made (the saving grace is that the video show Taylor being actually really happy while singing it, she is amazing like that)... I need years to recover from this, and I already had an hard time with the "original" version, aka I needed a good cry ever so often while listening to it, to think that this is worse..I will not survive
The first part is angrer with a bit of bittersweetness from the lovers stay my age line, but then it's more of a quiet hurt. It's just a girl, asking a boy she loved if he remembers their story. The only way Jake would make it out alive is if he just acknowledged it. Yes, I do. I remember.
Loved that you played the entire outro of the song just listening, it's so beautiful and mellow and somehow makes the whole emotional weight of the song and lyrics really just sink in. Great reaction!
I totally agree with you, this is her best song, art and work,and if not the greatest probably one of the greatest songs ever made in music history. The lyrics, are so damn poetic and despite being so long, it's not repetitive. You can clearly visualise the experience she went through because of how beautiful and detailed it is. Indeed, the entire song is just so cinematic. Taylor, you are a gem.Been a swiftie since "Lovestory" came out.You are a living legend. 💅
I’m in a healthy relationship now and I’ve been taken to a place of remembering…how it felt to be completely heart-shattered by someone and the months of emotional repair I needed. We all have that one situation that changed us forever. I feel this song. Deeply. Well done, Taylor. ❤️
Lol “I am drunk” hahahah that made my day thanks. Tay,or gives us the complete version, including getting back together(when no one had to know) and then her birthday and then hers trying to call again, to finally letting it go. Genuis
I came here directly from your MIDNIGHTS (TIL DAWN EDITION) REACTION. I've never noticed your channel before, but between your two reactions, here and there, it's time to dive into your body of work. I also just subscribed. Taylor Swift is my favorite artist, and I can't wait to see your reactions to her art. Thanks for your efforts to make intelligent assessments.
Excellent job reviewing this song. I have probably watched 20+ utube videos of people reviewing this song. Yours was by far the best. Keep up the great work
Literally, this is still my exact reaction every time I listen to it. Every time is just as good as the last, and HOW MANY SONGS can actually live up to that?
6:00 I feel you, honestly, I had to mourn the original All Too Well to be able to fully appreciate the new one, because it completely changed my perspective and the way I saw it / the relationship.
Im so late to your channel .... You had me at "I'm drunk, i had a bottle of wine" 😂😂😂 i died and came back. I love when people know the shortened version before they react to the original. Your mind was blown!! All our minds were blown, but your reaction was real and amazing and heartbreaking all at once. Loved it ❤
I will forever love this song especially this version! Thank you for this reaction. I can see that it has affected you emotionally just like most people who listened to it. She is amazing!
Aww. I loved your reaction and your opinion of Taylor’s talent is so genuine and beautifully relayed. Thank you for being so open and emotional with us. That was a beautiful reaction. 🫶🏼🥰
“What did this man do??” WELL the scarf is allegedly a metaphor for her virginity as well as being a real scarf, so in theory, he stole her virginity (the one thing he didn’t give back, “crumpled up paper” is a religious metaphor for saying you can’t be the same after losing it), never said I love you even though they dated for like 6 months (that we know of, on and off), kept going back and forth for months, gaslit her into thinking it was her own fault, bailed on her birthday??? then told her she was too immature for it to work. He was using her as arm candy and for clout he never actually cared, that’s what she’s realizing. Also rumoured he cheated on her or at least lied about who he was seeing (state of grace? I think?). Great vid by the way!
What the f- I mean I didn't know that and I absolutely wasn't ready for it now Wow I'm just..... I don't have any words Thank you for this! Now I know more about this situation
in lover she says all's well ends well to end up with you ...i love how it comes full circle lol
She is so good 😭😭
“He never called it what it was” *chills*
“You kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath” *more goosebumps*
“You said if we were closer in age..” *tears*
”..it’s supposed to be fun turning 21” *💔*
“ …but the punchline goes I get older but your lovers stay my age” *dead*
Love your reaction 🥰
Perfect summary.
Seriously 😅
Perfectly said 😂😅
"Did the twinflame bruise paint you blue?" Line too lol
As an elder Swiftie, I'm not even a little bit ashamed that I had the same reaction. You don't listen to this song, you live through it ❤️😊
Facts 🙏
Been listen to her since her Tim mcgraw song tay swift rock i wonder how this all to well song if she rap it i think it would be cool
I was 52 driving to work bawling my eyes out when Red TV came out earlier than morning. Went straight to A2W (10 min) and let the waves wash over me. It's stunning really. I don't know how she improved on:
"And you call me up again just to break me like a promise
So casually cruel in the name of bein' honest
I'm a crumpled-up piece of paper lyin' here"
but she did...by adding:
"They say all's well that ends well, but I'm in a new hell
Every time you double-cross my mind"
“Can someone check Jake. Is he ok?”😂
“What did this man do?”🤣
7:12 my favorite part of the song! “And you call me up again just to break me like a promise”👌
Sucks to be Jake Gyllenhaal rn 🤣
I totally agree with you about this version being unforgiving both in her delivery vocally speaking and the lyrics choices she made (the saving grace is that the video show Taylor being actually really happy while singing it, she is amazing like that)... I need years to recover from this, and I already had an hard time with the "original" version, aka I needed a good cry ever so often while listening to it, to think that this is worse..I will not survive
The first part is angrer with a bit of bittersweetness from the lovers stay my age line, but then it's more of a quiet hurt. It's just a girl, asking a boy she loved if he remembers their story.
The only way Jake would make it out alive is if he just acknowledged it. Yes, I do. I remember.
You’re totally right. I love that explanation. Thanks for sharing!
Loved that you played the entire outro of the song just listening, it's so beautiful and mellow and somehow makes the whole emotional weight of the song and lyrics really just sink in. Great reaction!
Thanks so much for the feedback! I’m glad you appreciated the video 🙏
I totally agree with you, this is her best song, art and work,and if not the greatest probably one of the greatest songs ever made in music history. The lyrics, are so damn poetic and despite being so long, it's not repetitive. You can clearly visualise the experience she went through because of how beautiful and detailed it is. Indeed, the entire song is just so cinematic. Taylor, you are a gem.Been a swiftie since "Lovestory" came out.You are a living legend. 💅
I’m in a healthy relationship now and I’ve been taken to a place of remembering…how it felt to be completely heart-shattered by someone and the months of emotional repair I needed. We all have that one situation that changed us forever. I feel this song. Deeply. Well done, Taylor. ❤️
Agreed! Thanks for sharing 🙏
Yes
Wow, thank you for pointing out the instrumentation.. makes it so much more emotional
Glad you enjoyed it! I loved the instrumentation so much. I also broke down the Sad Girl Autumn version of you want to take a look!
This song just got 10x sadder
😭😭😭
Lol “I am drunk” hahahah that made my day thanks. Tay,or gives us the complete version, including getting back together(when no one had to know) and then her birthday and then hers trying to call again, to finally letting it go. Genuis
I came here directly from your MIDNIGHTS (TIL DAWN EDITION) REACTION. I've never noticed your channel before, but between your two reactions, here and there, it's time to dive into your body of work. I also just subscribed. Taylor Swift is my favorite artist, and I can't wait to see your reactions to her art. Thanks for your efforts to make intelligent assessments.
Excellent job reviewing this song. I have probably watched 20+ utube videos of people reviewing this song. Yours was by far the best. Keep up the great work
Wow, thank you so much, Rob!! I really appreciate that. Will definitely be making more videos!
That’s no longer the most soul crushing line of the song….I’m like ohhh just wait. She’s off the charts as a storyteller. She’s just on another level.
Totally agree!
Literally, this is still my exact reaction every time I listen to it. Every time is just as good as the last, and HOW MANY SONGS can actually live up to that?
Taylor is an absolute Genius! Great reaction video, appreciate your reaction and comments.
Totally agree! Thanks, Barb!
The punchline Hits hard 🥲
Big time 😭
“I’m gonna need days…”
Welcome to our world ❤️🔥❤️🔥
Haha seriously! I’ve been a fan since 2006, our world is very emotional 😭
6:00 I feel you, honestly, I had to mourn the original All Too Well to be able to fully appreciate the new one, because it completely changed my perspective and the way I saw it / the relationship.
Really appreciated this reaction, sincere, intelligent. Thanks.
Thanks so much!
"Everytime you double-cross my mind..."
Amazing lyric!
Im so late to your channel .... You had me at "I'm drunk, i had a bottle of wine" 😂😂😂 i died and came back. I love when people know the shortened version before they react to the original. Your mind was blown!! All our minds were blown, but your reaction was real and amazing and heartbreaking all at once. Loved it ❤
I will forever love this song especially this version! Thank you for this reaction. I can see that it has affected you emotionally just like most people who listened to it. She is amazing!
Thanks, Elisa! Glad you liked the video. And agreed!
Aww. I loved your reaction and your opinion of Taylor’s talent is so genuine and beautifully relayed. Thank you for being so open and emotional with us. That was a beautiful reaction. 🫶🏼🥰
“What did this man do??” WELL the scarf is allegedly a metaphor for her virginity as well as being a real scarf, so in theory, he stole her virginity (the one thing he didn’t give back, “crumpled up paper” is a religious metaphor for saying you can’t be the same after losing it), never said I love you even though they dated for like 6 months (that we know of, on and off), kept going back and forth for months, gaslit her into thinking it was her own fault, bailed on her birthday??? then told her she was too immature for it to work. He was using her as arm candy and for clout he never actually cared, that’s what she’s realizing. Also rumoured he cheated on her or at least lied about who he was seeing (state of grace? I think?). Great vid by the way!
. Na na
Yeah, F Jake Gyllenhall!
What the f-
I mean I didn't know that and I absolutely wasn't ready for it now
Wow
I'm just..... I don't have any words
Thank you for this! Now I know more about this situation
I dont really think its a metaphor lol but ok
Enjoyed watching your reactions🤗
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it!
I loved your reaction, so honest, had a lot of fun watching it, thank you!!
Hey Sam, thanks for your comment. I’m glad you enjoyed the video!!
He was only in age but not in maturity or emotions. He was a man-child.
Sounds about right 😐
The most vicious dis-track since "hit em up"
Hahaha
This is brutal!! Let's keep going.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😅😂😂😂
Most likely Jak* is in a witness protection program after this song AND the Short Film.
ROFL...
Hahaha probably
This video deserves all of the views!!
Haha, thank you Eric!
Keep coming to your reaction. Love it.
Kanye could never......
👀
I believe she’ll be performing it on SNL. 👀
Agree 100% . Periodt.
Love your reaction!
more of her pls
Definitely!!
You precious, genius bean 🥺🥺🥺
I hope you react to the short film she made of this song
loved the reaction!! pls react to the short film toooo
Thanks so much! I’m trying to make more videos for sure. Still figuring things out. Thanks for being here!
❤
I thought the song deserved a Pulitzer before the 10 minute version
Love your reaction! please react to the whole red album Taylor's version if you can
Thanks so much! I’m glad people are liking this. I’ll be making more!
Pure sugary Hallmark!!! Poor Jake, does he get a reply?
actually this is the original version and she cut it into 5 min one on red album.
Right!
You have earned a follower sir.
Thanks, Kimberly! Glad to have you here!
You should really check out yebba “my mind” that’s another song that’s a whole story in a song
Yes!! Great song, I have to give it another listen. Thanks!
Where is reacted for short movie all too well?
Of course there’s different lyrics. It’s 10 minutes long! 😂
Please react to the ALL TOO WELL SHORT FILM 🙏🏼🙏🏼🥺🥺
I tried but still figuring out how to get yt to not block it for copyright 😅 either way, more Taylor coming soon I promise!
🤣
Exactly.."WHAT DID HE DOOOO?"😡
I thought she is singing about John it’s the she .
Cool
Thanks!
< 3
Would love to see Taylor and Lin Manuel team up.
❤