What are the best new designs for your favorite superheroes? [Live Discussion]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @thomasarcanine
    @thomasarcanine 4 роки тому +46

    One thing I got reassurance from this:
    Most of Alex Ross's redesigns are dope...

  • @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
    @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache 4 роки тому +26

    The Only Complete Redesigns That Broke the "Stop drilling you hit oil" Rule:
    Richard Rider's Annihilation Nova Suit
    Extremis Iron Man
    Sinestro Corps Sinestro
    Danny Ketch Ghost Rider
    Nightwing's Blue V Suit
    Darwin Cooke Catwoman
    And this one is just for me, but all Heisei Kamen Riders

    • @nansboard
      @nansboard 4 роки тому +1

      Debatable with like, Blade. All the other though, yes.

  • @diefty94
    @diefty94 4 роки тому +40

    Black t-shirt, red "S" Superboy.
    Laura's Wolverine suit.

    • @luckysix1015
      @luckysix1015 4 роки тому +3

      I wish Laura kept the black and white version after Logan came back.

  • @austincole7286
    @austincole7286 4 роки тому +25

    Sal,Joel,AND Jason at the same time? That's too much comic power in one podcast,I dont know how you kept the screens from melting from pure awesome

  • @crazygene
    @crazygene 4 роки тому +11

    Netflix's Daredevil really works too.

  • @levidu99
    @levidu99 4 роки тому +29

    Black Costume Spider-Man will always be my favorite redesign to the point where i think i like it slightly more than the regular costume, the Kaine Scarlet Spider costume is cool and way better than the og Kaine design
    And i don’t use ComiXology because their pricing sucks in my country, I wish they adjusted the prices depending on the currency like the Marvel app

    • @Yungtacosss
      @Yungtacosss 4 роки тому

      Well they literally have FREE comics on Comixology right now so..... just grab those while you can.

    • @architeuthis3476
      @architeuthis3476 4 роки тому

      Totally right. As iconic as the original costume is, the black costume Spider-Man is the best by a long shot.

  • @dennisssmith430
    @dennisssmith430 4 роки тому +4

    Wonder Woman’s Rebirth redesign is (IMO) by FAR the greatest, most perfectly balanced character design I have ever seen! 😍 It is the PERFECT blend of warrior-goddess grandeur and pure feminine beauty.

  • @AiggEbe
    @AiggEbe 4 роки тому +11

    Storm's mohawk look in the 80's is still my favorite redesign

    • @architeuthis3476
      @architeuthis3476 4 роки тому +3

      Seriously! They gave her that look as a joke, but it worked really well! I think they should have kept it!

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +1

      I like it, but I like it when it's used sparingly. I don't think it should be like her default design.

  • @asf8648
    @asf8648 4 роки тому +8

    Some of my favorite Superhero redesign
    Nightwing's Blue and Black suit with fingerstripes. So much better than his 80s diso suit and so iconic that changing it to red caused fan outrage.
    Captain Marvel's redesign from bathingsuit to the current Red, Blue, and Gold. It's gorgeous, powerful, and looks like something an air force pilot would wear.
    Scarlett Witch's black pants and red trench coat look from her most recent series. It's 100% more stylish and cool than the red bathing suit and M crown.
    Star Fire's 2015 and 2017 looks where she's still sexy but in a fun and cute way. She looks like she's wearing clothing that's fashionable and that she would actually enjoy. Both are head and shoulders above the Lobdell Red Hood run.

  • @Doddser
    @Doddser 4 роки тому +24

    110% agree with the Armoured Spiderman from Slott's all new all different run being wayyy better in the game than in the comics
    Lmao just noticed my profile pic is literally the ANAD Spidey suit from the game 😂

    • @ScriptZac
      @ScriptZac 4 роки тому +3

      I feel like the only person in the world who liked the ANAD Spider Man armor, lol. Then again, I liked New 52 Superman too, so clearly my opinions are wrong...

    • @karsten128
      @karsten128 4 роки тому +1

      @@ScriptZac While I disagree with you on New 52 Superman, I too really liked the ANAD Spider-man armour in the comics.

    • @ScriptZac
      @ScriptZac 4 роки тому +1

      @@karsten128 The covers especially were really dope.

  • @erikjones9957
    @erikjones9957 4 роки тому +4

    My two favorites is the black suit Spider-Man, and the pre-New 52 Superman's black and silver suit that he wore when he was thrown into the New 52 universe, which in of itself is a redesign of his 90s black and silver suit

  • @kingcoheed1208
    @kingcoheed1208 4 роки тому +8

    I love the Scarlet Spider designs both Riley and Kaine. I also love the Third Spider Armor, the Anti Sinister Six one.
    I enjoy armored Wonder Woman, not the Gold Eagle but the Silvery one with the massive Kite Shield

  • @N94able
    @N94able 4 роки тому +5

    I could listen to you guys talk about costumes all day.
    Really good stuff.

  • @kevinkruger1686
    @kevinkruger1686 4 роки тому +7

    Some new looks i like are Martian Manhunter new 52, Jaime Reyes Blue Beetle, Thor after civil war, ShadowMan, Mr. Terrific, Archangel, & Donna Troy Wonder Girl

  • @chimeraantking954
    @chimeraantking954 4 роки тому +5

    Loved Moon Knight's Egyptian Armor from the Warren Ellis run and the redesign from Art Station mainly because it made the beak more compact along with other small changes.

  • @smallmanbigmouth2699
    @smallmanbigmouth2699 4 роки тому +5

    Wolverine's brown & yellow suit is one of my favorite redesigns

  • @ethangohl
    @ethangohl 4 роки тому +15

    I'm actually kinda surprised that you guys talked a lot about Batman-adjacent characters, but never took a deep dive into Batman himself. A great episode nonetheless. I personally like Barry Allen's current suit (I like the lightning accents added in the past few years), and I really like the Batman Rebirth suit (the one with the purple cape and the yellow accent around the emblem and belt.

    • @DanV900
      @DanV900 4 роки тому +2

      Ethan Gohl I’m surprised that you said you liked the lightning accents since I have never heard anyone else say that. It just seems unnecessary for such an iconic costume.

    • @ethangohl
      @ethangohl 4 роки тому +2

      @@DanV900 I think everything about the classic suit is great, but there's something about the yellow lightning accents on his chest that I really appreciate.

    • @welshinc5782
      @welshinc5782 4 роки тому +3

      I agree about the flash redesign, but it depends on the artist. The reason why I think they didn't go deep into batman, is because they did it not so long ago

    • @architeuthis3476
      @architeuthis3476 4 роки тому +2

      Batman would take an entire episode (I might be remembering it wrong, but I think they did one just on his costumes). As heretical as this may be to say, I actually like some of his movie costumes better than a lot of his comic costumes.

  • @famousthaneus9810
    @famousthaneus9810 4 роки тому +5

    Whatever misinterpretations I have of your demeanor, I will say that you, Sal, are really great at reflecting on the industry & delivering the information in a clear/digestible way. All love here

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +2

      Much appreciated, Tay!

  • @DanV900
    @DanV900 4 роки тому +4

    Darwyn Cooke’s redesign of the Catwoman costume in the Brubaker run is incredible. That was perfect. The new design after the failed wedding with the armpits cut out looks stupid.

  • @Martin_TheCollector
    @Martin_TheCollector 4 роки тому +1

    I personally love Batman's suit before New 52 happened, when he returned from "dying" and all the way through Batman Inc. The one with bat-symbol on the chest that lights up (and no undies outside the pants). Just too awesome, especially when David Finch and others penciled it. Spidey 2099 is my top favorite too. The original design.

  • @jordanrodrigues8435
    @jordanrodrigues8435 4 роки тому +1

    I think Scarlet Spider's ankle pouches are brilliant. It's perfect character design. Spider-Man is one of the only characters where the flexibility makes the stylistic choice also practical for the character. Like Spider-Gwen having a hood because the spider sense makes up for the lack of peripheral vision. The Character informs how the suit is designed and becomes part of the world and reality. Something unique and only what that person would choose.

  • @fragile4408
    @fragile4408 4 роки тому +3

    I love the one year later Robin redesign. I just love that design for Robin. On the marvel side of things I absolutely love the Silver Centurion armor.

  • @r.babylon2885
    @r.babylon2885 4 роки тому +1

    My favorite Nightwing costumes are...
    1. The classic black/blue, but with the eagle. The tips of the eagle wings stretch either over the shoulders and connect at the back, or they reach down the arms into the fingers.
    2. The New 52 red/black with the eagle, but with red accents scattered on the suit.

  • @ScriptZac
    @ScriptZac 4 роки тому +2

    Some of my favorites are Spider-Woman's leather jacket, Carol Danvers Captain Marvel, Black Suit Spider-Man (obviously), Laura's Wolverine suit (both of em), and Barbara Gordon's Batgirl (take your pick, Burnside, or Murphy's).

  • @MrAl360
    @MrAl360 4 роки тому +4

    Hearing that Spider-Man 2099 shout out made my day.

  • @Bobbybillybillbob
    @Bobbybillybillbob 4 роки тому +2

    Right in the beginning I'd say my favorite redesign would be any of the recent black skin suit Catwoman over the classic purple dress, green cape exposed hair Catwoman

  • @willmackinnon9397
    @willmackinnon9397 4 роки тому

    Scarlet Spider suit is my favorite spidey suit. When i started getting into new comics as a kid, Ben had just been introduced and i was so into it

  • @morlath4767
    @morlath4767 4 роки тому

    X-Men Jim Lee - Absolutely! That was my introduction to the X-Men and I fully agree that they'll always be iconic. I think the Wolverine Yellow/Blue and brown switches have become more a sign of his psychology (at least in fandom) but his one with the shoulders was fantastic. Also, I totally agree with Sal in that Rogue's jacket look is HER look. Aside from the ripped shreds of her Savage Land time, jacket-Rogue is Rogue. I'm also with Sal in the yellow-blue uniforms were solid and the Jean Grey one is my favourite.
    Beast - The character who has had the best and worst redesigns in comic history!
    Wolverine sans Adamantium - I refuse to accept that this ever existed. Or it's a failed Sinister clone while Logan is off Samaruai-ing off somewhere.
    Black Suit Spider-Man - I really respect that design (not talking of the symbiote stuff). Just like Sal says, it really works for the shadows and him climbing buildings.
    Scarlet Spider - I don't mind this one (even the pouches). To me, it's like a take on Rogue's jacket mentality and a more grungy version of Spider's outfit. It's visually different to the normal Spider suit without making it totally different to where you couldn't connect to its origins.
    Wonder Woman - I do like the "newer" version. It's probably my favourite version of the entire collection of her outfits but I really wouldn't mind if she had pants. Pants aren't an issue at all (especially if it's armoured) but her black biker shorts and jacket combo is just...I have no words.
    Kyle Rayner's Green Lantern - I can't stand his big mask. It looks far more like a villain mask than a hero's. I do like his outfit but I think it would work better if it was for a different hero.
    Great video guys and I'm surprised there wasn't any Batman talk here until that quick Batman Beyond look.

  • @quirqq
    @quirqq 4 роки тому

    Spider-Women's original red and yellow costume is my favorite. I like costumes that can be unisex.

  • @JohnClark-tt2bl
    @JohnClark-tt2bl 4 роки тому

    I think Todd McFarlane is my favorite Spiderman artist. I liked the exaggerated way he drew him. All the weird positions he'd pose him in, was very unique.

  •  4 роки тому +2

    This was such a great stream guys

  • @nohero1339
    @nohero1339 4 роки тому +2

    Always loved the Ben Riley Spider-man suit

  • @slinger0083
    @slinger0083 4 роки тому +1

    Ben Reilly’s Spider-Man and the Superior suit 2.0 were great.

  • @JaredRmz
    @JaredRmz 4 роки тому +1

    The best reimagining for Iron Man gotta be the Ultimate Iron Man fronthe Ultimates, is distinct enough and so unique

  • @marcusjavier8901
    @marcusjavier8901 4 роки тому +2

    My Favorite Superhero/Supervillains Redesigns
    Darwyn Cooke Catwoman Design
    Nightwing Blue V Suit(the one during the mid 90s to late 2000s,Before Final Crisis and The Rebirth Redesign)
    Jim Lee X-Men 90s Costumes(It Iconic)
    Mr.Freeze(BTAS)
    Beast Boy Mike Mckone Redesign(during the geoff johns teen titans series)
    Robin Neal Adams & Norm Breyfogle Redesign(Tim Drake Robin Costume Pre Infintie Crisis)
    Superboy Geoff Johns & Mike Mckone Redesign(The Red & Black S T-Shirt "Suit")
    Thor Oliver Coipel & Chris Samnee Redesign(the 2007 & 2011/Mighty Avenger series)
    Aquaman Peter David & Martin Egeland Redesign(The Hook Hand 90s Design)
    Wally Wood Daredevil Redesign(The Classic Red Costume)
    Nova Scott Kolins & Skottie Young Redesign(during The Dan Abnett Cosmic Marvel Saga & 2007 solo series/new warriors skottie young miniseries)
    Brainiac(STAS) Redesign
    Black Canary Ed Benes Redesign
    Ms.Marvel Dave Cockrum Redesign
    Flash Greg LaRocque & Francis Manqul Redesign(the darker shade of red and white lenses look wally had during the early to late 90s and the new 52 suit)
    Starman James Robinson & Tony Harris(Jack Knight Starman during the Early 90s & 2000s)
    Huntress Jim Lee Redesign
    The Shade By Tony Harris(Post Zero Hour Suit)
    Adam Strange Planet Heist Redesign
    Neal Adams Green Arrow Redesign
    John Stewart(DCAU)Redesign
    Hawkeye David Lopez & David Aja Redesign
    Batgirl The Batman Redesign
    Iron Man Adi Granou Redesign
    Moon Knight Declan Shalvey Redesign
    Static John Paul Leon/DCAU Redesign
    Fantastic 4 Future Foundation Redesign

  • @jimhogarth9678
    @jimhogarth9678 4 роки тому

    Some of my favorite redesigns: Batman New 52, Ultimate Captain America, Tim Drake's Robin, Silver Centurion Iron Man, Chuck Dixon Nightwing.

  • @andreasesser4641
    @andreasesser4641 2 роки тому

    Cockrum's original costume designs for the Uncanny X-Men were so strong, its hard to really improve on. You can only polish them. Like Byrne did. And later Lee. My favourite is Byrne though.

  • @brysongrenfell867
    @brysongrenfell867 4 роки тому

    Neal Adams Batman suit and the Greg Capullo Batman rebirth suit are two of my favourites. I love me a Batman with some colour.

  • @bAd12cheZ
    @bAd12cheZ 4 роки тому +1

    Maybe Supervillain redesigns in the future? I could watch these guys talk comics for years, and I have.

  • @Peecamarke
    @Peecamarke 4 роки тому +1

    GREAT trio for elseworlds!

  • @BBmetalhead04
    @BBmetalhead04 4 роки тому

    This is a hot take, but I always liked the Udon Taskmaster costume over the classic cape and pirate boots (sorry Sal). To me, Taskmaster always looked like he raided the bargain bin of a costume shop and cobbled together what he could find. I liked the more streamlined and tactical look of the Udon costume.

  • @samuelanderson1862
    @samuelanderson1862 4 роки тому

    I LOVE water-bearer Aquaman!
    While story its self not to great the concept I loved and fueled my own ideas for fan fiction regarding DC superheroes. As to make Superman look more alien I use the electric blue with red, blue and yellow suit

  • @matt15
    @matt15 4 роки тому +1

    I love supes with the undies but his rebirth costumes are the best ones without them

  • @carlosarjon7189
    @carlosarjon7189 4 роки тому +3

    This is easily the best episode of EE

  • @rgreenway2604
    @rgreenway2604 4 роки тому

    Wait?! Are you not showing the many examples of what's being described? I only slightly remember any of this. SHOW THE SUITS. The before and after is why i clicked on this in the first place. Love the shows Sal.

  • @FloorTankMain
    @FloorTankMain 4 роки тому

    My favorite has to be Superboy’s costume within the year before he got the boring t shirt and jeans look. I think it was 2001/2002..? I loved the colors, his hair, he actually had a bit of scruff like he was getting older. It was fun and it was nice. Too bad it changed so quickly with the move to Smallville.

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому

      I still think that leather jacket might hold up.

  • @architeuthis3476
    @architeuthis3476 4 роки тому

    Didn't get mentioned: Punisher.
    I'm personally a fan of the version that's just an old guy in a skull Tshirt, a la Tim Bradstreet cover's for the Max run. Most of the spandex costumes are basically minor variations of the same thing (sometimes they add a coat), but John Romita Jr's version is the only one that looks really cool. If we're counting alternate versions of the Punisher, then the Frank Castle: Sorcerer Supreme costume is narrowly beats-out the Frankencastle and War Machine costumes. The worst is the Purgatory costume (and that hurts to say because Bernie Wrightson is my favorite comic artist).

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +1

      I can't believe how wasted Wrightson was on that Punisher book. He needed something like Man-Thing.

    • @architeuthis3476
      @architeuthis3476 4 роки тому

      @@comicpop He really was! Although I don't think anyone blames Wrightson for _Purgatory,_ the art didn't help (Wrightson clearly knew what kind of a story it was).
      But I sort of understand why Marvel sought him out for that job: the guy is a master of light/darkness (and other high-contrast art) and one of the best monster designers in comic history. It would have made more sense to give him something like a limited _Doctor Strange_ series and just tell him to take as much time as he needed to make it look awesome. _Man-Thing_ would be an excellent choice because it was created by Len Wein about the same time the two created _Swamp Thing_ together!
      I don't know if yoo've read his sequel to Mary Shelly's classic (which he did the definitive illustrations for), but I'd be happy to send yoo a copy of his final (RIP) piece: _Frankenstein: Alive! Alive!_ if yoo wanna do a Back Issues about it.

  • @grantnewton4230
    @grantnewton4230 4 роки тому

    I love Humberto Ramos’ Spider-Man

  • @Velvet_Intrigue
    @Velvet_Intrigue 4 роки тому

    grear talk i just wish you'd do more screensharing of the redesigns

  • @cwash7708
    @cwash7708 4 роки тому +1

    At 38:25 I liked that costume.

  • @crazygene
    @crazygene 4 роки тому +1

    Classic Spider-Man costume: Mike Wieringo

  • @dertitan4870
    @dertitan4870 4 роки тому

    Who had great redesignes outside the big 2 is Spawn. Capullos design still is the best ever, but I also love the redesign of Jonboy Meyers.

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +2

      I still can't get over that big boot thing...

    • @dertitan4870
      @dertitan4870 4 роки тому +1

      @@comicpop I still think that he needed the weight of the big boot, so that his air filled head couldn't carry him away like a balloon.

  • @jonathaneilbeck2263
    @jonathaneilbeck2263 4 роки тому +1

    Red and black Tim Drake Robin costume.

  • @frozenwing123
    @frozenwing123 4 роки тому

    spider-woman in her biker outfit
    I also dug armor wonder woman from New 52

  • @michaeldancyii9901
    @michaeldancyii9901 4 роки тому

    I was trying to watch live but could not find it on the page😰😭😭

  • @joshburke8430
    @joshburke8430 4 роки тому

    Yeah it is Tusk. I found a picture of the toy on google.

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому

      Thank you! I still have no idea what book he's in.

  • @FloorTankMain
    @FloorTankMain 4 роки тому +3

    Class Cain was the best Batgirl 👍💕

  • @motheshogaming5593
    @motheshogaming5593 11 місяців тому

    Brian Stelfreeze designed Nightwings black suit

  • @bAd12cheZ
    @bAd12cheZ 4 роки тому +3

    I love the Batgirl of Burnside redesign.

  • @knowbodyhere3966
    @knowbodyhere3966 4 роки тому

    Cassandra Cain's Batgirl suit

  • @1bruceeric
    @1bruceeric 4 роки тому

    I'm with Jason the Highlander tv show was great.

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +1

      Loved the idea, but don't deepen the lore! All you need is the song. #nowatchers

  • @travispagan3824
    @travispagan3824 4 роки тому +1

    YES

  • @ggameboy10
    @ggameboy10 4 роки тому

    Spider armor mk1

  • @1bruceeric
    @1bruceeric 4 роки тому

    Future Foundation Spider Man suit and for the FF too.

  • @jaysondoritos
    @jaysondoritos 4 роки тому

    Pre new 52 Red Robin

  • @FloorTankMain
    @FloorTankMain 4 роки тому

    Why on earth when Jason started talking about the Batman and Robin redesigns did I assume he was talking about Dick and Tim during Prodigal and not Dick and Damian OTL I’m a dumbass

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому

      When you have multiple versions of things that happened, like Dick becoming Batman, it all blends together. No worries!

  • @jonahi1304
    @jonahi1304 3 роки тому

    Gotta say one character that changed a lot but nobody really notices is the Hulk. Not costume (a bit though) but face and stature. He has a history like Beast where there's a lot of hits and misses. Not a fan of 90's handsome hulk

  • @breannamartins9992
    @breannamartins9992 4 роки тому

    Spent a lot of time googling these designs I wish more had been shared on screen :/

  • @cliftonhatchett1724
    @cliftonhatchett1724 4 роки тому +1

    Mcfarlane had the best Spiderman.

  • @roccoborghetti4693
    @roccoborghetti4693 4 роки тому

    My favorite redesigns:
    Batman New 52
    Superman Rebirth (1st Rebirth suit but with red boots and a yellow buckle on the original design sheet)
    Superman Man of Steel 2013
    Wonder Woman Rebirth
    Ultimate X-men
    Flash New 52
    Nightwing Rebirth
    Batgirl New 52 (black suit/purple cape)
    Robin One Year Later/TNBA
    Ultimate Fantastic Four
    Extremis Iron Man
    MCU Captain America
    Romita Sr. Spider-Man.
    Raimi Black Suit Spider-Man
    Martian Manhunter New 52
    Aquaman New 52 Justice League 1-6
    Geoff Johns Hal Jordan Green Lantern
    Superboy New 52 and Rebirth

  • @sacredgeek
    @sacredgeek 4 роки тому

    No mention of Sandman?

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  4 роки тому +1

      Show's only an hour, man.

  • @mr.spider3362
    @mr.spider3362 4 роки тому +2

    Would like Jason as the permanent guest instead of Joel tbh. He offers up Nd seems to care so much more lmao. Every episode he’s on is the most entertaining

  • @roccoborghetti4693
    @roccoborghetti4693 4 роки тому

    I honestly despise the Kingdom Come Superman suit. The “S” looks better in the “Batman Beyond” Superman suit but that whole suit is changed. The Kingdom Come suit is just too much like the original suit that the “S” just looks dumb and I can’t get passed it.

  • @saintlugia
    @saintlugia 4 роки тому +2

    I will hate this if batgirl wasn't discussed

    • @luckysix1015
      @luckysix1015 4 роки тому

      Which batgirl redesign? I hope it’s not the one she has in heroes in crisis with the stupid headband ears instead of a cowl.

    • @saintlugia
      @saintlugia 4 роки тому

      @@luckysix1015 no either the Cassandra cain suit steph brown suit or burnside suit

    • @luckysix1015
      @luckysix1015 4 роки тому +1

      saintlugia Those suits are all fantastic, I would probably pick Stephanie’s suit out of the three in a “this is the one batgirl design.” But yeah the artist new what they were doing making them,

    • @DanV900
      @DanV900 4 роки тому

      saintlugia They discussed the Cassandra Cain and Burnside suits.