Perpetual Motion - Free Energy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 тра 2016
- See my new perpetual motion machine here:
• Perpetual Motion - Bha...
See my newest science fair project here:
• Video
I made this for my science project on renewable energy. Its a perpetual motion machine known as an overbalanced wheel... Bhāskara's wheel to be exact. It took a ton of work to get just right; I had to clean and grease the bearings several times, water wasn't heavy enough so we had to dissolve a TON of salt in the water to increase the weight, and then we had to tape coins to the wheel in several spots to get the wheel as perfectly balanced as possible.
“The hardest part in designing a ‘Perpetual Motion Machine’ is deciding where to hide the batteries.”
Lmao that's genuinely hilarious.
Hahaha..😄
Or air compressor
Comment of the century
Or the jump cut where he spins it by hand every few revolutions.
this is your standard overbalanced wheel. It conserves its momentum very well and will continue spinning for a couple of minutes, even hours if it is accurate enough. The problem is that the bearings will slow it down, and if you try hook up a generator, it will stop much faster than that.
I saw another video where the wheel slowed down but then would speed up again. It was because the support was wobbly and one bottle was wobbly. The wheel was able to keep overcoming that problem and speed up after each minor slow-down.
This is mind blowing! Simply brilliant! I can not begin to contemplate the full scale of impact this will have to mankind. I don't know if anyone else has experienced this side affect but by watching the video backwards on my phone the battery went from 15% to 45%. It actually charged it. I repeated this several times but could not get to full charge. I guess that's because this is just a prototype. Marvellous
Ah yes, Quality comments!
Love the sarcasm!
Ça marche ce
Ça marche ce truc
what you've done there is called a flywheel: the large ammount of mass on the salty water bottles makes it very inert, thus a lot of energy is required to both spin it up and to stop it.
eventually it will stop due to friction on bearings and air resistance, but it takes a while.
Adding another flywheel next to it increases momentum of slowdown.
You don't know that it will stop. There is another video with a larger wheel and less bulky bottles. I think it can run forever.
It will run a lot longer if you fill the bottles with water completely.
Moust interesting... Can you please tell me what kind of fan you are using?
Amitai Medan .. SOMEONE call the fireman cause this burn is goin nuts
Amitai Medan .. SOMEONE call the fireman cause this burn is goin nuts
There's no fan, this would actually work. But it wouldn't work forever. Maybe a few minutes, maybe a few hours. But the friction between the wheel and the frame would eventually slow it down to a halt. The claim of "Free Energy" is the biggest problem I have with this. Yes, you can make this. Yes, it will work. No, it will not produce free energy. Energy creates a load. Even the smallest load on a machine like this would grind it to a halt.
So no, there's nothing fancy to this. No fans, nothing like that at all. The motion you see is created by the water movement, which is why it stutters at times. But will it sustain itself? Not really. Not for more than maybe a few hours in a perfect world scenario. Even the wind outside could manage to stop it.
Matthew Rosenblatt It seems you're blind... watch the tree on right side of the video, it moves as usual on quite windy day.
its beyond me as to y im part of this comment.i never comment on this b4. but patent ur method genius...!!!
We can see the boy's t-shirt shaking in the wind produced by a leaf blower pushing on the upper bottles !
tubeseek41
Force on the wheel created by gravitation on bottles going down and bottles coming up is equal hence wheel will not keep moving.
tubeseek41 great pick up... busted
tubeseek41 it's the natural wind.. trees moving in the background..
Doesnt matter if its being blown by the wind or the leaf blower, it doesnt change the fact that the thing wouldnt work without wind.
I like the way you muted the video so we can't hear the leaf blower
The secret to this magnificent device is the fan blowing on it to make it spin. Notice there's no sound in the video.
And the shirt is moving spicious at 1:00.
@@mw.9098 0:55
causes friction = not perpetual
Thats not what perpetual means.
The one thing engineers are trying to overcome is the ratio of energy output to fight friction vs energy created. Friction is the enemy, but having it present doesn't mean it's not perpetual.
Air causes friction.
+enigmalfidelity no fucking shit I'm too lazy to type out a paragraph so props to you
+enigmalfidelity and friction causes wear on the parts of the machine which eventually breaks down making it not perpetual. magnets become demagnetized only constants like gravity are parts.
yep
lol you said energy created you lose.
There's a reason why this video has no sound. If it did, it would reveal what keeps the wheel turning. Look at 56 seconds into the video when the boy gets close to the wheel. You will see wind moving his shirt.They are capitalizing on advertising revenue from people who have hope.If I had the power to remove these obvious fakes, I would delete this video. We have enough of this kind of thing. If Chase really cares to make this world a better place I think he would delete this video... right?
Yes, I can see the kids shirt moving. They probably have a weed blower aimed at the bottles.
Всё верно
When will people realize perpetual motion is impossible due to friction?
um... what?
The universe as a whole is currently considered to be a closed system, so i guess the argument could be made that the universe as a whole is a perpetual motion device. Except it isn't. Energy is constantly dispersing (entropy is constantly increasing). A perpetual motion device requires motion. A hot object that never cools is not considered a perpetual motion device. Once all energy in the universe disperses enough nothing will move, not even atoms. Everything hits absolute zero, all motion ceases, everything comes to a stop. It's called the cold death of the universe. Reality will still exist, but nothing will move at all
martin d
Well, forget time and space for a minute and let's keep our feet firmly on the ground here on Earth. Perpetual motion is impossible due to friction so there is no free energy. Crikey, why do we have nuclear power plants, wind turbines, solar etc. Show me a house running on 'free' power!
When the kid has a science test. 'Energy can neither be created or destroyed. True or false?'
Kid: false.
Kid wrong
Somewhere there is a high school physics teacher crying.
a turbine would be more efficient to capture wind than bottles ...
the weight of water in the bottles are what keeps the wheel spinning. not the wind
If you believe that you might want to drink yourself, kappa
+Clorox Bleach you don't understand physics
u are everywhere, Bleach
Gaming Flame
It could be a bunch of people with the same username Maybe
People, perpetual motion doesn't exist, at least in the universe we know.
You live on a gigantic model of perpetual motion. Or are you going to tell us that some power station moves the Earth?
Good point.
Ron Armstrong Thats not perpetual motion...
Mr Me I find it weird how people say that but they said the same thing bout the shnuk helicopter, it was never supposed to leave the ground but yet the military uses the shit out of them.
Taylor Underwood But thats something different.
Because of physics a perpetuum mobile is impossible.
I think it's nice that the father is bonding with the son, stimulating creativity, tinkering, not watching tv all day. That's very important and fantasizing about perpetual motion is no different than a hobby for that matter. So, keep tinkering! Having said that, the laws of physics say you can not get more energy from a closed system than the energy you put in. Also, any form of energy when converted from one state to a different state has a loss or dissipation of the original energy onto unwanted forms (like heat, friction, imperfections, etc.)
Wow thats amazing!
"We added salt to the water because it wasn't heavy enough" really made me laugh. I wonder if anyone believes this crap. The sad thing is that it showed up in my recommended. I feel a bit offended by UA-cam tbh
I can't tell you how many videos just like this I've had to click "Not interested" on. And now that I've watched this one, I'll have to start all over. /le sigh
Leaving a dislike makes the video not count for your future recommendations
Allylilith aegwynn You only get recommendations based on what you watch...
yes, I watch a lot of gaming an sciencs related stuff. So youtube obviouly thinks that this is science.. Oh God
'perpetual motion' titles should automatically be changed from category: science to category: bin
Allylilith aegwynn
Perpetual motion is a a branch of science and categorizes in physics science...
I started laughing my ass off when I first saw it. You were explaining the perfection of your water on the left side and the machine was at a complete stand still.
Awesome job! ❤
Perpetually entertaining. Cheers!
Energy can not be created nor could it disappear, but it can transfer from one kind to another with the effectiveness of no more than 99%, meaning there's always going to be a loss.
It'll stop eventually. The overbalanced wheel moves the center of mass below the axle, so as it loses energy due to friction, it will eventually just behave like a pendulum.
i got really excited about this before reading the comments...yo got me
I love the smile of that boy what the work did with his father
try first running is for a week continuous... see if it stops. If it doesn't then you've got a 100% Perpetual Motion machine!!!
It won't work for a week because perpetual motion machines only work in practice. You can get close but you can never reduce friction to 0.
Also wouldn’t the motion be stable
Even if you make something that moves perpetually, the SECOND you try to draw any energy from the system to do any useful work it'll come to a screeching halt. Therefore no energy is created.
If you could get something to work you could then scale it up in size until the resistance is overcome by momentum - theoretically
You are the only smart person here. Everyone else thinks this is fake
@@icegod4849 because it is fake. The kid's shirt is blowing at 0:55. They're clearly using a leaf blower.
@@alt8791 I doubt a leafblower has the capacity to spin 1 water bottle much less than 8.
@UCRyR6cozsSAruFz6nfL9YRA I didn't know of a leaf blower stronger enough when directed at a specific location to also move a trees branches 30ft+ away. Unless they have people deliberately shaking trees and bushes its called natural wind. Fucking moron.
Congrats! Very usefull work for you
great idea
Oh by the way, free energy does exist, I know this. While was filling up my car, I saw this blonde pull up in a Camaro. She started flirting with the attendant while he was filling up her car. The fuel didn't cost her a thing.
Jon Pelsan haha I was about to go off but I kept reading 😂
APPARATUS FOR COLLECTING ATMOSFERIC ELECTRICITY
USA PATENT OFFICE Filed July, 10, 1900
@@vasivasili4851 That's about as free as wind-energy, just with a much lower output.
hahahahahahaha
lol nice
I can see a fan blowing air to run this "bottle turbine". That is why muted sound. Regards,
thats also why the screen is zoomed in so much, and never once zoomed out
You never learn physics, don't you?
LearningZone No these machines work but they are not actually perpetual because they eventually stop moving due to the first two laws of thermodynamics
Bendy Metal so they dont work
My Bubba Oh Bubbaness they only make illusion of Perpetuum Mobile
Very good idea
Smart idea to be developed
0:55. This wheel has also the power to flap kids tshirt.
Good point, but it could be windy outside
perpetual or not.....i think it was great for father and son to do this project together both learning and having fun.......👍
I can't Imagine how stressful this would of been to get just right.
quiet innovative!
add sound, I want to hear the blower that was moving your son's shirt
what they didn't tell you was... the leaf blower was a perpetual machine! :)
@@craigeillison9650 hahahah, no the generator powering the leaf blower was the perpetual machine.
I'm a simple scientific nerd, I read this title, I dislike the video.
Sena same
I just logged your comment in Volume 20 in the ongoing compendium I call THE BIG BOOK OF SHIT NO ONE CARES ABOUT
You could have left out the word scientific by the way.
Sena same, bro
@Edward Owens If you are making a BIG BOOK, and gosh - must be very successful to be on Volume 20 then somoene must care, even if it is only yourself.
Sena Same ,thank you.
It's not free, you pushed it, that was the cost. You just kept it going. BUSTED
thank you, your video is helpful
kenapa dia bisa berputar terus ya..?
apa karena tekanan air itu ya..?
Iya sih pengaruh gravitasi sehingga turun tapi saya tidak yakin 100% karena sangat tidak mungkin, kalau air bisa keatas itu pengaruh gaya dari luar bukan dri alatnya
you dont have any sound.... hmmmmm... suspicious... what fan are you using?
Cancer good luck getting a fan to spin this wheel, I'd love to see you try
Casper Born he probably ment leafblower
Rail lmao what a troll
0:55 Check the t-shirt. also search for another like this and they show how they move it with a fan
hahhhhhhhh
Awww your son is so adorable
Good job
lol I can see your shirt blowing in the breeze! this is hilarious, thanks
Duct tapes water bottles to a tyre and spins it. "This is the real deal!!! Free Energy!!!" 😂 I'm done with this world
do you know English? it says that he needed a lot of work to get it right
groszak1 to get what right
good work
The T shirt of the boy moves from the wind of the blower > gotcha!
That's a cool fidget spinner
Aidan Brondo it's not amazing. Just clever camera angles and a fucking leaf blower
Dear god I just found a cancerous comment
yeah
Perpetual energy is physically impossible.
The energy source is the wind, whether it be a leaf blower or something along those lines, the movement of air is the machines energy source. No wonder why the video has no sound, all you would hear would be a big ass leaf blower.
(BTW, perpetual energy is impossible due to friction of the axis point & the law of energy conservation, which states that energy can neither be created or destroyed.)
Você que pensa.
Eu penso que é fake
custo zero, não custa nada tentar.
Hunter Sills energy can neither be created nor destroyed , but can be convertible with two unlimited energy source , one is gravitational force and other X ?? that's the question . if we can found the X then free energy is possible .
Dracula Reloaded
Nope, of course it will never be possible. Sorry but there are laws of nature.
Pretty cool
well done!
00:56 The boy's t-shirt reveals his fan throwing wind in the bottles!
0:53 why is the front of that kid's shirt flapping like he's in the way of a leaf blower, and why is there no audio?
I've been following perpetual motion and free energy devices for half of my life I'm 57 at first glance I was thinking the wheel rotated clockwise and I'm thinking this won't work because the water is farther away on the left side then it is the right then you started it and it went counterclockwise I have to admit I'm going to remain open-minded if there's no fans in the background which I don't think there is I believe it works at least I want to believe God bless and thanks for sharing this video
Excelente respuesta y comentario, y pues el que lo dude que lo haga, así despejara sus dudas....saludos.
Guy in the background ran in like a freakin titan 😂
Kid has a test on being good. 'Is it okay to lie?'
Kid: yes.
NEGATIVE: Never ok to LIE!! Telling kids that is Not CooL!! You know ALL LIARS go to a Hot Magical Place called HELL ( or HADES) Right??? Jesus Christ (Almighty God) ain't CooL with people Lying you know!? You need to Repent!!
0:56 we can c the wind on the kid shirt.... they are using a leaf blower...lol
Damn....he had us at first...😂😂
No he isn't his shirt would be flapping much faster. Im just saying that he most likely isnt using a leafblower, im not saying this is real. Perpetual motion is not possible
nice special effects
Gravity catches and pulls the water (like a waterfall) Neat device!
Journeyman Except it doesn’t, because it’s fake.
To all the none intellectual children here. This is fake you will never have overbalancing wheel that can bring that overbalanced weight back up.
Ignore the grammar and mind the facts
Brian Patton I think the grammar makes the substance of what you are saying.
Brian Patton your grammar and the fact that you didn't hit the edit button to fix it shows that you are very "none intellectual"
Only can be possible in zero gravity haha
According to all known laws of aviation I just wanna know what your name is in reference to?
Energy can neither be created nor be destroyed it can only be transferred from one form to another
Yes, but gravity is also energy created by earth. This video might be wrong but we can create such machines with the help of gravity
No, still no
In that way the orbiting satellites are perpetual motion machines
Ruman Mulla you had to comment this why?
+koushik
Gravity is a force, not an energy form. Forces can be used to transform energy from one form to another, but not generate energy out of nothing.
Example:
Having water flow from a high point into a turbine and out at a low point.
Positional potential energy from the high altitude into rotational energy of the turbine into electrical energy in a generator and some heat energy losses.
Those are the energy forms.
The forces at work converting the energy forms into each other are gravity for the water and turbine, and electromagnetism for the generator.
very accurate plans for something like that I found on Avasva
very nice video thanks
It's not a perpetual motion machine as you used your hands for it to move.
idiot
The world is full of gullible people like YOU, only too willing to throw
their money at the guys who never show their faces or give you their
names and address, just a an email address you can send a check to.
You should type me more nonsense that I don't care to read..
Teedo it's quit stupid what you said though
lmfao.. ok.
Sadly not infinite energy since eventually these do stop spinning, but you are a brilliant kid for being able to do this experiment so well. Good job!
The water on the falling side is farther from the center of the wheel. So it has more leverage.
If you could increase the difference in distance, you would have more force.
I'm IMPRESSED!!!
The design with rods and weights is even better.
Good idea
let me know when you make a video where it shows how to get "free energy" as in not paying the energy bill
Mark Magana wind mill
oh yeah huh? fuck me
LOL.... one way wud be when we can efficiently start to reclaim all our car kinetic energy.... wasted as heat in braking..
Lol he has compressed air he muted so we wouldn't hear such device being used....
Very nice
my leafblower senses are tingling
0:56 exposed they are using blower if u watch his shirt
No lol his shirt would have been flapping back and forth much faster if it was a leafblower
Btw just saying he probably isnt using a leafblower, im not saying this is real. As we all know perpetual motion is impossible.
Just because the bearings will "rot" doesn't mean it isn't perpetual motion. It's more about if this device can sustain a load without putting more energy in than you will get out. Even a slight input with your hand is energy in. Full props to you mate. Give stuff a crack and see what you come up with. One day this or something you come up with may actually produce energy... Never know unless you give it a go! Good work.
IM GONNA MAKE SOMETHING SIMILAR!
Great vid!!
Hate to crush your dreams, kid, but it's fake.
The fact that it wasnt moving at the start of the video proves the fact that unless acted upon, eventually the wheel will return to that state (not moving).... a true perpetual motion machine, once completed, would start to run as soon as you finish building it, and would remain that way forever.
I'm no expert of any kind in any field but I really find that logical that it made me laugh! I tried browsing and searching on the internet but did not find lots of answers or ideas that would actually help someone with the least or no background about the idea of a perpetual motion machine/device or just physics in general. I am grateful that I came across this video and comment section. *I really think your comment is an eye opener, if not for everyone, at least for me.*
A perpetual motion machine will never work on earth as there is just too many factors, resistance, and the way energy scatters around in forms of, for example, sound, heat, and light. I was thinking perhaps it could work in a perfectly isolated space or just at the space, itself. However, I realized that even the sun is vulnerable to limitations too.
I just want to note that even though I may have sounded or displayed doubts or disbelief of true perpetual motion, I really find this video interesting and helped me as a student. I made an improvised version with shorter bottles and motorcycle bearing (with little or no lubricant). It only lasted for less than 20 seconds.
Tonight, on things that never happened: A kid and his dad manage to break the laws of physics in their garage with some salty water!
it would stop eventually because of friction.
even if it doesn't stops, there is no way you can harness energy from it.
Nilaksh Singh protip: he used a leafblower
That YOU know of.
No way to generate energy that would be useful as that would cause friction. But you do not need a leaf blower to make this move. There are working wooden models you can see operating after being started. But no friction applied or it will stop. Adding even a very small generator would cause it to slow and stop. Perhaps if that energy could be applied to a piston with a magnet that moved inside a coil to power a small led, like a flashlight that you shale to power for a few minutes, but nothing more. I have a tiny bike duel colored led generator for a bike. It is wind driven obviously, but it could be affixed in such a way to power it. Those type things could be used, but only because they are essentially frictionless.
You can harness energy from an alternator belt fed from the bike rim or use larger rim it is very possible and your mind is limited if you can't see that this concept can easily work
+Dave
There is always friction from the bearings, the air, and the water sloshing in the bottles. Add to that the turbulence losses in the sloshing water, this thing won't run longer than maybe 30 seconds no matter how hard you push it initially.
Bad ass my guy
Why is everyone hating on the guy for moving it to get it started... perpetual motion simply means it'll never stop. This certainly will, but initial spin or not does not matter.
That's awesome! Have you ever just let it spin to see how long it will go?
I hope for the sake of humanity that you are sarcastic
+erik engdahl I don't think he is :(
+Andrew Foot I don't want to live on this planet anymore
I don't blame you
+Andrew Foot do you tink NASA would reply to my email
wow, what's a video. at first, I thought that it will be flying away.
Perpetual motion machines dont exist and that's not how flying works
@@sourhill2292 he's an Indian, of che will think of something stupid and un real
Fine example of devolution!
very cool
Now for the real physics experiment, explain why this won't work
A DimeShort The wheel will stop eventually, due to friction.
The second law o thermodynamics.
@@user-ns3si7hw1t what if we used magnets to suspend the wheel in the bushings?
変態person i don't see how that could help, for this to work you have to place the wheel in the absolute zero gravity, absolute vacuum and built the wheel with absolute frictionless joints. With all i said above, it will eventually, stop.
変態person I you meant to use the magnets to push the wheel, the magnets don't stay magnetized forever, it will degrade over time.
it started turning backwards at the end lol, if this "worked" you would not need to push it to get it going lol
exactly! That is what i have been saying forever. It needs to start under its own power. Not applied by hand or any other force. I need to want to work. In fact. it should be "stopped" by hand and start the minute you let go. Otherwise there is no solution, just can't be done other than fake UA-cam video for the less educated in physics. No insult meant. Just facts.
@@vigilanterc so glad im not the only one that thinks that way, it must be stopped, not started lol
jaco kruger yeah all true epic gamers know that the only way to get infinite energy is to use the golden rectangle
It needs a initial force but that’s not why it doesn’t work it’s bc there’s friction
it's because friction keeps it not running but it also keeps it running
Sam odkryłem darmowe źródło energii. Podłączyłem się kablem do sąsiada...
After starting it with his hands it did go on it's own the only question is how much faster and if it would have continued. It really needs to be a couple hours long to prove the point.
Come on dude you muted it so we wouldn’t here a fan, and everybody knows energy can’t be created but only transferred
Rajesh Koothrappali pro you don’t see, the water dropping in the bottle, do its work end ever will have water dropping
It's still cool bro and he built it with his dad and deserves appreciation. 😒 🏅
Vivendo em Outro NIVEL no the unbalanced wheel just shifts the center of gravity. Even if he somehow manage to find an absolute frictionless bearing, it can't power anything, not because of the low output, because it will lose it energy and eventually, stop.
"Overbalanced" is not a term that has any scientific or engineering meaning or application other than to describe mechanisms like this. This is an age old futile attempt to make a "perpetual motion" machine. It is obvious why the sound is omitted in this video. If you observe the mechanism carefully, you will see it is decelerating and accelerating in response to some external force, most likely, a blast of air. If you think about this mechanism (or any other for that matter) you can imagine that, on average, every drop of water is making the same path around the center of the wheel. Sure, some go higher...some go lower...but the average is the same. There is nothing that adds energy to the system at any point. There is, however, something that removes energy from the system: Friction. This has been pointed out by several earlier respondents. As a lifelong practicing engineer, my big question is: What is the purpose of making such a machine? What do the creators hope to prove or disprove? Upon what theory are they basing their ability to create energy from nothing? These questions go back well over 400 years BTW.
Shane Edmonds great explanation.
Shane Edmonds they made it for a science fair. Lol
I would have said getting 1.7million youtube views is worth making such a machine for.
Shane Edmonds I'm impressed by the fact that you think you know what your saying, but you really don't. First off, no this is not a perpetual motion machine, but not because of external force. The reason why it's able to spin so long is the fact that the movement of the water is being used to conserve energy. Think about each water bottle in this scenario as a mini battery. The initial push allows the potential energy of the bottles on the left to become kinetic, with the opposite being true for the right. This conserves energy in the system, but the effects of friction and air resistance will eventually slow it down. The slow down and sped up movement is just the result of moving water being unevenly affected. Lastly, perpetual motion is possible, just it requires an absolute vacuum with near absolute zero temperatures (Bose-Einstein condensates have been observed to have no friction)
Samuel Undef3 Yes they are possible with BEC's in a vacuum but their practicality is non existent. So called, "Free Energy" doesn't exist, trying to draw energy from a perpetual motion machine would only induse friction.
where can i buy this fidget spinner
I’m in the UK, if I’d built little water wheels similar to this for the ends of my gutters and rain channels, then I would have had free energy all bloody year.
Last year I wouldn’t have had one watt.
Excellent! And I also think it's excellent that your dad does things like this with his kid! The world could use more of that !
Not perpetual.. Tha fact that it started out standing still proves that at some point it will need a boost of energy to keep running
I did some experimentation and found that if you use a high quality Scotch Whiskey, particularly an Islay single malt such as Laphroiag 30 y/o as the liquid medium, you can increase the power output by factor of at least 15455122542555887.0231145X or better.
It’s 2023, I’m so amazed at how many people still keep falling for all these perpetual motion machines on the internet.
This is 529% fake
1309274237482342% fake ***
+Time Turner Wolf there is to much friction and it will eventually slow down and stop
Your math curriculum is even more fake
How is it fake? Neutrons and protons spin infinitely and don't ever slow down or stop. That is perpetual motion. I guess all of the atoms in our bodies and in the observable universe are 529% fake, right?
Shaded Zaleph his "machine" is being rotated by a fan or a leaf blower
in my house we obey the laws of thermodynamics
Amen.
Thermo dynamics was a scam
You can see his shirt blowing from the fan that there using to keep it spinning hahaha
Totally agree had happens if you put any load on the axle to generate even the smallest amount of energy