I agree with you very much. The CCP used a lot of rural manpower during the Chinese Civil War, which is better than the Kuomintang’s use of urban manpower.
@@kkf54353 Yes, the cause of that incident was quite complicated. As far as I know, it was those ex-IJA Taiwanese soldiers who really started it. The tension between KMT authority and Taiwanese was very tough, like a barrel of dynamite which only need a spark to explode.
@@kkf54353 Also, even though KMT's rule in Taiwan was terrible at that time, this incident actally had little to do with democracy, if not nothing at all.
Before 1947/2/28: 1946 “This is the Shame” TIME “s confiscated by the Chinese Army that took over the island, under U.S. tutelage, last fall. But the resumption of trade with tropically lush, industrially rich Formosa was a sweet-&-sour business. Formosans complained that the Chinese occupation army was looting stocks, letting crops, refineries, railroads and power plants go to rack & ruin. “ “Japan Got the Atom. Chen Yi rounded up scores of "collaborators" while his pooh-bahs made themselves snug. Last week "Down with the Governor!" posters appeared all over the island. In two towns, hungry natives burned sugar godowns. Formosans greeted the few visiting Americans with: "You were kind to the Japanese, you dropped the atom on them. You dropped the Chinese on us!" Thoughtful Chinese on the mainland began to agree with the Formosans. Said Ta Rung Pao, China's counterpart of the New York Times: "Fundamentally speaking, China was not qualified to take over . . . she lacks the men . . . technique . . . commodities . . . capital. She governs, but is inefficient. She takes, but she does not give. This is the government's shame."” “ Most foreign observers in Formosa agreed that if a referendum were taken today Formosans would vote for U.S. rule. Second choice-Japan”
I came to see your channel, and clearly can say that your efforts of summary, details, sources, explanation, musics in every videos are showing you are working hard. Guess I need to learn these designs, thanks for sharing this my Formossan friend!
In fact, the Nationalists significantly outnumbered and were better armed than the Communists, who relied merely on rural support and basic "millet plus rifles." The Communists succeeded through mass mobilization and winning the hearts of the people, with their ultimate secret weapon being a commitment to practical reality. In contrast, the Nationalists represented the aristocratic class (also referred to as the bourgeoisie), characterized by their daily focus on self-interest and fear of personal loss, making their downfall inevitable. Regardless of whether the Communist Party still retains its original principles today, having risen from humble beginnings to become a global power second only to the USA, it is evident that their ability to focus efforts on major initiatives continues to propel the Chinese people further.
That was only the case in 1945. By 1948 the war had turned conventional. The CCP was able to stood up a large conventional army using captured Japanese/Nationalist equipment and was launching counterattacks. And lmao, the CCP today is ONLY focuses on retaining its own power. The entire power structure in mainland China is weighted towards keeping themselves in power.
I am really inspired by your work, you inspired me to make my own! The amount of effort you put into this is amazing! I am working on a big project, the Qaraba Wars which will take me a long time, but keep on going! Don’t let anyone stop you.
I'm glad you said that. Same, mate, I discovered your channel, and I hope you can keep going on such a big project, and I'll be looking forward to this new video!
War Destiny [Mapping] Same here, I am currently on September 1992, I hope I can reach Jan, 1993 on the 10th of May, When I get out of school for summer break, I hope I can speed run this project and get it done faster.
I love it how you don't just give up after May 1950, but continue with a week-by-week cadence, and not a month-by-month cadence, that almost everybody else uses. :D
I’ve spent about 100,000 hours studying English humor and Western culture, and many years studying Chinese culture and jokes. My native language is Chinese. I teach Chinese in humorous way and with cute pictures. Hope somebody recommend my videos to those who want to learn Chinese.
The first phase of Chinese civil war was interrupted by the Japanese invasion. After the Japanese surrendered, the second phase started after a failed peace talk between CCP and KMT
It’s so surreal seeing that picture of Mao Zedong and Chiang Kai-shek toasting to the defeat of Japan at the end of World War II… Especially when, if this video is any indication, the KMT and CCP went back to fighting each other the first instant they could!
@@akend4426 Even moreso because before the start of the war proper, Chiang literally ignored a lot of Japanese advances in order to fight the communists.
Fighting already started prior to Japanese surrender. The CCP constantly attacked and subjugated NRA units in Northern China throughout the war. The United Front was dead years before the war ended.
The imprisoned KMT generals after learning that communist PVA entered Korea and held back the US-led UN army, are like believers that learnt their god is not invincible.
Is that why China lost astonomical losses in Korea? over 300,000 Chinese compared to the US's 30,000. Everyone knows China's only strength is its manpower. They would get stomped in a true modern war. All they did in Korea is attack an exhausted and leaderless allied army and even then they barely managed to push them back. For their effort all they got was a puppet state that has to beg for food every couple of years... lol
Before the war, many of the country's top generals did not think they could win. After all, the United States was now a strong industrial power, while China was still an agricultural country and even had famine at home.
Well, its pretty easy to close your door to brag about your victories that noone recognizes....I guess Putin will brag about how he kicked the western dog armies in Ukraine , if the internet didnt expose how weak is the Russian army.
@@Huajierenmeiluziye pretty easy to say that when the US was deliberately holding back from bombing the north due to UN regulations. If the US was allowed to take off the gloves Hanoi would have been a parking lot
After that video I think it should be good to make another about the Korean war (more detailed than existing ones) with background (deploying Soviet and U.S. troops in the northern and in the southern parts of Korea respectively after its liberating from Japanese; creating Nothern Communist and South pro-Western Korean governments; the direct military actions).
IMO he's quite capable to emerge victorious (or at least to be sort of in control) among the cutthroats that were the warlords. Just that being ruthless and transactional aren't enough in turning the tide and lead his regime through the most turbulent times.
@@theolich4384 Yeah I guess. He does deserve credit for leading the second northern expedition and the country through WW2 but he was far from being strategically brilliant and was more of a "Stalin" type of military leader. Plus he recruited many of the warlords back into his government such as Yan xishan.
The communists got the peasants on their side and didn't fight the imperial Japanese as much. The ROC was battered from the fight, and Mao claimed himself lord of the embers. The peasants did not know that a few years later, millions of them would die in Mao's "Great Leap Forward" and "Cultural Revolution". Tragic.
@@olivius8891 To be exact, it was not only peasants. During that time, the order of China was completely broken down. Under natural and man-made disasters, all walks of life stopped working and started endless infighting.
“How to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.” ~By Chiang Kai-Sheik. Because let’s face it: Even though the Soviets handing over Manchuria and a bunch of captured Japanese equipment to the communists, the KMT really should’ve won.
Yep. The Nationalists had military advisors, a modern air force, tons of arm shipments and other military aid… The U.S. did everything short of sending large numbers of ground troops to aid the KMT, and Chiang still managed to lose.
The Soviets held important ports like Dalian though until after the Korean War; while carting much of the Manchurian assets off back to Europe, the Soviet "aid" to PRC were to be paid back later by raw materials. The Russian expansionist mindset made sure had N. Korea proceeded well, they'll want to have a pie on the Korean Peninsular too; if Kim failed to manage it and asked for "assistance" from the Soviets, even better. Bizarrely the Chinese and N.Koreans, surely aware of Stalin's scheme, were able to create a status quo around the 38th parallel without the direct involvement of the Red Army.
From what I know, the KMT leaders were hopelessly corrupt and their forces had been exhausted by the IJA, while the CCP gathered its forces in the countryside while mostly avoiding the Japanese. The fact that the KMT sacrificed millions of Chinese people to slow down the IJA (like in the Yellow River flood, which killed at least 400,000 people) didn't help
War is not a simple computation of armed force strength Army morale, organisation of supplies, and most importantly the support of people You can research a bit on how corrupt KMT was around that time
one question: the red flag with 5 stars beginned to be used after prc founded. but before that the party flag doesnt look like this one. this begin to use in 80s
舟山群島似乎被遺忘了，國軍在1950年5月撤出後該島隨即被中共占領，但在視頻中，它似乎直到1951年6月才變成紅色。 The Zhoushan Islands seem to have been forgotten; they were occupied by the Chinese Communist Party in May 1950, but in the video, it does not appear to have turned red until June 1951.
If democracy really can make China rich and strong in 19th centry , then the Communist Party will not defeat the Kuomintang had the support of the United States. Any ideology were produced with the support and belive of people... After many years , the china mainland keep their thought to try up,and fail and change other ways and keep to try more. Finally had done the rise task at 20th centry , amost people were live better than pass. Look at the US and taiwan, in addition to denying the 92 consensus, they also regard mainland China as a threat, and use all means to discredit and suppress it in an attempt to take it down . The so-called "freedom democracy" cannot tolerate other ideologies better than they in this world. This is true "dictatorship" of the US govment. And the US were Interests launch/promote multiple wars in various countries at that 20 years, which is a threat of the world at all.
![War Destiny [Mapping]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/xr68rEVX-4ASilw8hCHzAjDd6xVAdcAjkgX4RHxdYkpjA3-8dtNlUmstF9PgznnWfecPvQMHpA=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
The communists effectively used their gargantuan manpower more efficiently than the nationalist used their gargantuan manpower.
The strength of the CCP
1945-1946: 1300000
1948-1949: 3000000
I agree with you very much.
The CCP used a lot of rural manpower during the Chinese Civil War, which is better than the Kuomintang’s use of urban manpower.
😞The Kuomintang failed and lost mainland
@Andrew Yu Young Earn Really impressive comments man, thank you
What corruption and zeal does to the opposing factions of the previous conflict
真的很難想像工作量，辛苦也感謝你了!
Ermmm yeah you’re getting reported to china
Amazing, so much research and hard work in this, you deserve alot more subs
Thank you very much!!!
I did spend a lot of time collecting information😅
Your support is my motivation ：D
@@WarDestinyMapping no way! I appreciate that :D
Amazing video! You even noted the insurgency in Taiwan, which is often neglected by many people.
Yes, the Feb 28 incident. But people in taiwan just easily painted as "pro-democracy" event because of political reason.
@@kkf54353 Yes, the cause of that incident was quite complicated. As far as I know, it was those ex-IJA Taiwanese soldiers who really started it. The tension between KMT authority and Taiwanese was very tough, like a barrel of dynamite which only need a spark to explode.
@@kkf54353 Also, even though KMT's rule in Taiwan was terrible at that time, this incident actally had little to do with democracy, if not nothing at all.
@@mastermirror3888 Bush is a liar democracy means killing people
Before 1947/2/28:
1946 “This is the Shame” TIME
“s confiscated by the Chinese Army that took over the island, under U.S. tutelage, last fall. But the resumption of trade with tropically lush, industrially rich Formosa was a sweet-&-sour business.
Formosans complained that the Chinese occupation army was looting stocks, letting crops, refineries, railroads and power plants go to rack & ruin. “
“Japan Got the Atom. Chen Yi rounded up scores of "collaborators" while his pooh-bahs made themselves snug. Last week "Down with the Governor!" posters appeared all over the island. In two towns, hungry natives burned sugar godowns. Formosans greeted the few visiting Americans with: "You were kind to the Japanese, you dropped the atom on them. You dropped the Chinese on us!"
Thoughtful Chinese on the mainland began to agree with the Formosans. Said Ta Rung Pao, China's counterpart of the New York Times: "Fundamentally speaking, China was not qualified to take over . . . she lacks the men . . . technique . . . commodities . . . capital. She governs, but is inefficient. She takes, but she does not give. This is the government's shame."”
“
Most foreign observers in Formosa agreed that if a referendum were taken today Formosans would vote for U.S. rule. Second choice-Japan”
The best video about the Chinese Civil War there is, amazing
Thank you
I came to see your channel, and clearly can say that your efforts of summary, details, sources, explanation, musics in every videos are showing you are working hard. Guess I need to learn these designs, thanks for sharing this my Formossan friend!
Thanks!! I'm glad you found me and like my vid. Same, I also found your channel and you are a good Korea mapper.
Nice to meet you!! :D
In fact, the Nationalists significantly outnumbered and were better armed than the Communists, who relied merely on rural support and basic "millet plus rifles." The Communists succeeded through mass mobilization and winning the hearts of the people, with their ultimate secret weapon being a commitment to practical reality. In contrast, the Nationalists represented the aristocratic class (also referred to as the bourgeoisie), characterized by their daily focus on self-interest and fear of personal loss, making their downfall inevitable. Regardless of whether the Communist Party still retains its original principles today, having risen from humble beginnings to become a global power second only to the USA, it is evident that their ability to focus efforts on major initiatives continues to propel the Chinese people further.
That was only the case in 1945. By 1948 the war had turned conventional. The CCP was able to stood up a large conventional army using captured Japanese/Nationalist equipment and was launching counterattacks.
And lmao, the CCP today is ONLY focuses on retaining its own power. The entire power structure in mainland China is weighted towards keeping themselves in power.
共产党的鬼话你还真信了？抗日战争基本是国民党在出力，共产党在抗战前都快被国军剿灭了，结果八年抗战反而越打越多，共产党竟然有脸宣称自己是抵抗日军的中流砥柱。至于武器装备，日军投降后，共产党在苏联的支持下快速接受了东北，整编了几十万伪军和几万投降日军，这个时候共军武器装备就已经不弱于国军了。长春围城战被共军活活饿死几十万平民不知你知不知道，还好意思说国军腐败？作为一个正在从封建社会向现代社会转型的国家有哪个不腐败？从底层民众到上层精英没几个人有现代国家意识的情况下怎么可能不腐败，共产党上台后腐败就少了吗？哪怕 90 年代的共产党都比当年的国民党腐败更甚，共产党夺取政权根本不是革命，而是一场农民起义，共产党煽动底层暴民推翻了地主和资本家，却把国家拖进又一场深渊。
@@michaelma8776
长春围城？因为共产党围城的时候想不到国民党居然不发粮啊，打完长春才发现仓库里都是粮食，可是国民党愣是扣着不发，这谁想得到？
共产党得到了四国联军的支持😂😂😂
@@wangzai77
什么得道多助失道寡助
I am really inspired by your work, you inspired me to make my own! The amount of effort you put into this is amazing! I am working on a big project, the Qaraba Wars which will take me a long time, but keep on going! Don’t let anyone stop you.
I'm glad you said that.
Same, mate, I discovered your channel, and I hope you can keep going on such a big project, and I'll be looking forward to this new video!
War Destiny [Mapping] Same here, I am currently on September 1992, I hope I can reach Jan, 1993 on the 10th of May, When I get out of school for summer break, I hope I can speed run this project and get it done faster.
Keep going👍
@@centralmapping6566 What happened to your vids?
@@GoldenHawk_ i deleted them
I love it how you don't just give up after May 1950, but continue with a week-by-week cadence, and not a month-by-month cadence, that almost everybody else uses. :D
I’ve spent about 100,000 hours studying English humor and Western culture, and many years studying Chinese culture and jokes. My native language is Chinese. I teach Chinese in humorous way and with cute pictures.
Hope somebody recommend my videos to those who want to learn Chinese.
In Chinese history, the attack from north to south has always had a great advantage.
except the Northern Expedition of 1925-27
韩信也是北上的
The Ming Dynasty attack Mongolians form south to north in 1368
满洲一枪不放直接投降，不但没受损还被日本开发。其他省份跟日本打成一锅粥，最后让叛徒收割了胜利果实。
@@SleepingSoul520 how did that turn out for the ming in the end? Jurchens manchu ruling over them for century.
This is indeed amazing, keep up the great work!
Thank you for your appreciation! 😄
做的很不错啊，不过我记得1945年外蒙已经控制了达里冈爱和阿勒泰山的大片区域
謝謝，你的疑惑是對的，查閱了相關外蒙古時期的疆域分佈，外蒙確實有控制阿勒泰地區，不好意思在動圖中忽略了這點
@@WarDestinyMapping台湾人做的吗
无所谓，关键是这些区域现在已经实质掌握在我们手中，总比国民党地图开疆强。。。
这视频在b站搬运后挺红的！现在五千多赞！看起来你这个解放地图是b站里最准之一！朝韩战后的边界好像偏北了一点
这种视频在B站能过审？
@@hikawaokazaka7091直接发不行。UP主把藏南改了，还有1949年10月1日后的台湾顶上加了“中国台湾”，并同时移除了民国国旗，还有后面的领袖都剪了才能过
The first phase of Chinese civil war was interrupted by the Japanese invasion. After the Japanese surrendered, the second phase started after a failed peace talk between CCP and KMT
俄乌战争以后突然发现蒋校长打得着实不错。全面进攻真的持续了10个月
America, they are weak. My war lasted more than 20 years
@@عليياسر-ذ5ب Iraq shall be free, brother
普總統不如校長遠甚😂
校长扛了五年，真伟大吧凯申😂
优势在我！
国际歌有西班牙语，德语，希腊语等许多语言版本，当时共产主义比中世纪伊斯兰哈里发扩张的势头还要凶猛，苏联成功后，共产国际这个组织在西班牙，法国，德国，意大利，巴尔干半岛南欧国家，东欧，东亚掀起了革命暴动。希特勒，墨索里尼，蒋介石，日本军部兵变都是这种背景，用民族主义凝聚人心，蒋介石没有搞定纷乱军阀，是形式统一
当资本压迫人民过剩时，共产主义的火苗就会燃烧
民粹主义法西斯能和共产主义相提并论?共产主义是全世界全人类共同发展共同富裕
@@zhchen2263 共產主義是個笑話
@@Колсон-з9ы 苏联短短二十年，就从一个落后的初级工业国家变成了世界第一的军事强国。到现在苏联解体了几十年，他的加盟国依旧在吃苏联的老本。
中国也是短短几十年从一个落后的农业国，变成了现在世界数一数二的国家。事实在面前，你要怎么否定？
你这不是对社会主义的侮辱，也是对美国的侮辱。美国这么看重的竞争对手，让你觉得美国的决策层很可笑？
@@Колсон-з9ы 而国民党蒋介石，唯一的作用就是面对日本没有投降。
国共本就是一体，国共第一次合作，成立黄埔军校，才有了北伐战争的胜利。不然国民党就是个笑话，实力还不如一般的军阀。
北伐战争胜利后，孙中山国民党才开始壮大。孙中山去世后，国民党的实际领导人是汪精卫；但是蒋介石手里有兵权，他单方面清缴共产党。这才让国共分裂。
日本入侵后，他想的是依靠日本人，削弱其他军阀、在日本人打张学良的时候。他的主要方向还在清缴共产党，和占领其他军阀的地盘。造成其他军阀对他也是阴奉阳违。不然以共产党的实力，当时如何能逃掉？而且还能再延安生存下来。
🍫🌳💗🧡🌳🍋
up主辛苦了！谢谢你给我们重新观看了一遍历史
！
不是up主，这里的叫法是youtuber吧
@@yufengzhang-lp1nz UP主（uploader），即上传者，网络流行词。指在视频网站、论坛、ftp站点上传视频音频文件的人。up是upload（上传）的简称，UP主是一个日本传入的网络词汇。
ew
Technically the war never ended, because the Usa continue to support the rump state regime on Taiwan island.
Surplus amount of detail War Destiny, can't wait to see what else you have in stock for videos!
Thanks!! But I think there are still some inaccurate info, I will continue to correct my historical notes.
I'm currently making second Sino-Japanese war combined with the First Chinese Civil War civil war, but it will take some time!
@@WarDestinyMapping Nice, thats glad to know. Is this going to include the 10 years civil war in China? (1927-1937)
@@NiIog Yes, but it will start in 1931, because of the 918 Incident.(Empire of Japan invaded Manchuria)
@@WarDestinyMapping ok
作为重庆人，我看到在Nov.30.1949那天重庆板块变成红色，这个视频的作者非常了不起！
Wow, amazing work.
Thanks!!
Great video,I am very looking forword to your new work.
很棒的动态视频，真希望看到第一次国共战争的视频
👌👍我可以將這個加入我的計畫中
謝謝!
I like how he maps the Korean War simaltaneously
Keep going, my friend👏
Thank you!!! :D
The portaits and names at the end of the video are a great addition!
for a Chinese,it’s glad to see a so fantastic video about the communitist and it’s great to show tibet and Aksai Chin
Thank you for admiring this work and found interesting here, I did spend a lot of time looking for those info
只不过一个战线视频有必要在下面乱扯吗，简直败坏两岸人民的素质🤣
@@一只特别中二的沙雕 username check out.
@@一只特别中二的沙雕 很正常的，现在碰到类似这种话题的视频搞的我都不敢打简体字了😂
雀食，我在视频下面一打简体字就有人开始骂我了，食不食油饼？
做得很好
非常棒的动画，大佬费心了。希望两岸不必再兵戎相见。
然而血海即将在人们面前掀起怒涛，提前准备点兵器吧，不为杀死别人而是而是为了自保。
和平统一，一国两制！
台湾闹独立，年轻人被洗脑成傻叉，那必须兵戎相见
只要搞獨裁專制的馬列黃俄政權共產黨垮台，兩岸早就統一了
@@Xiayan0910 可惜香港问题做了一个很不好的示范，导致台湾现在更加警惕了，哎
能输掉那么大的江山也是需要点实力的
Man, what can I say.
It’s so surreal seeing that picture of Mao Zedong and Chiang Kai-shek toasting to the defeat of Japan at the end of World War II…
Especially when, if this video is any indication, the KMT and CCP went back to fighting each other the first instant they could!
Before the surrender of Japan even!
@@akend4426 Even moreso because before the start of the war proper, Chiang literally ignored a lot of Japanese advances in order to fight the communists.
更离奇的是，侵华日军首领冈村宁次被国民党蒋介石庇护，无罪释放了。原因竟然是冈村宁次有非常丰富的对付共产党的经验，成为国民党对付共产党的军事顾问。
Fighting already started prior to Japanese surrender. The CCP constantly attacked and subjugated NRA units in Northern China throughout the war. The United Front was dead years before the war ended.
这可以打脸说共产党没有抗日的
I love the attention to detail. Great video
每个细节都诠释的非常到位 真的厉害
做的真棒
只可惜這個戰爭似乎還沒結束，至今還是對立情況。國共內戰一直到今日還是沒有宣示結束戰爭或是任何一方投降招降，那天突然打起來真的不意外
不会打的，战争是最不昂贵最不划算的政治手段
@@sentenshaw1887和平是战争前提下建立起来的
除非是台湾自己作死挑衅，不然共产党真没必要进攻台湾。
以今天中国的实力，完全可以通过政治手段和经济渗透，文化媒体渗透来统一台湾。
如果中国大陆愿意和美国达成某系利益交换，台湾直接就会被卖给大陆。
These videos explain war better then anything
國共內戰傷亡人數
國民黨 傷亡 171.1萬人 被俘458.7萬人 投降 63.4萬人 易幟115萬人
共產黨 傷亡 111萬人 (其中26萬人陣亡 85萬人受傷) 被俘 失蹤 19萬人
都是中国人。可叹，愿祖国和平。
所以真想不懂为什么到现在付出了这样的代价，依然有人还想要独立继续打仗，而不是和平统一。
@@genli4245 對你們來說是統一 對台灣人/世界來說可是侵略 搞清楚自己的立場 你們是侵略者
@@Pigga-k8k 侵略个屁！这是中国内战，两边互相杀绝了都不算侵略懂么。
@@genli4245 因為我們在守護的是中國人廢除帝制那年希望看見的制度，即使我們不覺得自己是中國人，我們還是在守護辛亥革命當年希望的精神。
1949後的法西斯極權仔是懂什麼？
Thank you for such a brilliant work! That truely need a deep dive into history and must cost you a lot of time! again thank you for the masterpiece!
Absolutely Amazing!
😊 Thank you!!! It took a lot of time to make this animation :D
@@WarDestinyMapping I hope you continue like this. Also, What's the next project you have in your mind ?
Ofc👍👌
My next project is also about the battle in China: "Northern Expedition" 北伐戰役
@@WarDestinyMapping Oh ok. Im looking forward 👍
😄Thank you
同志奮發努力 革命必將成功
我討厭共產
不錯的視頻
感恩先烈
这样来看，解放战争中有一块非常重要的解放区：河北中南部。1947年重点进攻，陕北和山东解放区被极大缩小，剩下的解放区要承担大量军队的开销，经济非常困难。而河北中南部作为一块相对平静的解放区，又是大平原，这里生产的大量粮食可以供给陕北、山东，极大缓解了两地的物资短缺和经济困难。不看战线的话还真的看不出来河北的解放区有多么重要。
不用看战线, 自古以来 河北四州, 河南中原 就是产粮食大平原大平地, 刘秀 曹操 袁绍,唐朝河北三镇, 都是得到河北 都会做大做强
@@kakalee3464 一般战乱时期河南河北基本上都是被打烂的状态，不仅没有多余的粮食支援战场，还经常造成大量流民迁徙，进一步加剧其他地方的粮食压力（当然也可以补充人力）。而在解放战争时期，河南、山东都是主战场，唯独河北中南部相对平静，这个稳定的大后方产粮区太关键了，没有河北的话陕北和山东不知道能不能挺过47年。
不是解放戰爭，就是國共內戰
“解放战争”这个称呼就算了吧，毛蒋不过在争夺对中国的统治权而已，而且毛是更烂的那个，“解放”后就是反右、大跃进、土法炼钢、三年饥荒、文化大革命……
因为当时的河北中南部抗战之后就没什么可以大兵团长期占据的城市战略要点，譬如邯郸在抗战之后人口也就一万多人，城市规模也就是类似于现在的乡镇，在军事上面的意义还不如有正太铁路经过的石家庄以及冀北的张家口，再加上46年的邯郸战役国军败了之后就没再从平汉线向北进攻，反而把进攻重点转向苏北和山东。冀南当时也就永年城一个收编了前土匪的民团利用明清时期的城防欺负当时的解放军没有攻坚能力一直到47年才跑路
Truely one of the best such videos I have seen for ages! Good work!
再一次理解了解放战争的不易❤做的很不错
最后鹿死谁手还不知道，不要忘了青天白日满地红旗直到今日还在迎风飘扬
@@トマト天津飯你这句话简直是21世纪最好笑的笑话
@@トマト天津飯看在你坚持一个中国的份上我都觉得应该夸你了
@@トマト天津飯无所谓😂经济战比真枪实弹厉害的多
@@トマト天津飯所以你希望战争？还不要被网上的魔怔人带偏了，大多数中国人并不关心台湾人的生活，统一是政治层面的事情
即使再看一遍也很难想象国民党为什么会输
校长在你还想赢？
@@weizhao2064 我在必不成功是吧
年少时嘲笑长辈口中的校长
中年时嘲笑自己了解中的校长
晚年时和晚辈一起嘲笑校长
入土后当面嘲笑校长
最后复活赛打赢校长🤣
@@siegfriednibelung 哈哈
军事失败背后是经济失败。简而言之，国军败于财政枯竭。几波美国援助打光了，后面就越来越拉胯。国民党作为一名义上统治中国的政党，基层管理能力简直惨不忍睹，占中国人口最多的农村，长期被乡绅和地主把持，这帮人会缴税吗？国民党税收的大头是关税和盐税，这两项和被地主截胡的农业税相比就是小巫见大巫。反观中共，党组织深入基层，军队所在地就推行土改，彻底消灭地主阶级，长期被地主截胡的农业税流入中共财政。民国地主一般收取佃农7成赋税，共党打掉了地主，收取4成左右，农民收入翻倍，又获得土地，自然全力支持中共。战场上出现一边倒的局面一点都不意外。小常识，民国农民占总人口至少九成。
look what I found, my classmate you are so amazing.👍
Thanks! (謝謝!)
看到后面全部变红色，真的觉得很窒息
你说的对但是刚开始的时候国民党兵力是共产党的两倍
我也是
I came here because Yan Xishan's video got unlisted
The imprisoned KMT generals after learning that communist PVA entered Korea and held back the US-led UN army, are like believers that learnt their god is not invincible.
Is that why China lost astonomical losses in Korea? over 300,000 Chinese compared to the US's 30,000. Everyone knows China's only strength is its manpower. They would get stomped in a true modern war. All they did in Korea is attack an exhausted and leaderless allied army and even then they barely managed to push them back. For their effort all they got was a puppet state that has to beg for food every couple of years... lol
Before the war, many of the country's top generals did not think they could win. After all, the United States was now a strong industrial power, while China was still an agricultural country and even had famine at home.
Well, its pretty easy to close your door to brag about your victories that noone recognizes....I guess Putin will brag about how he kicked the western dog armies in Ukraine , if the internet didnt expose how weak is the Russian army.
@@solinvictus4367The biggest industrial country can't beat a bunch of farmers
@@Huajierenmeiluziye pretty easy to say that when the US was deliberately holding back from bombing the north due to UN regulations. If the US was allowed to take off the gloves Hanoi would have been a parking lot
After that video I think it should be good to make another about the Korean war (more detailed than existing ones) with background (deploying Soviet and U.S. troops in the northern and in the southern parts of Korea respectively after its liberating from Japanese; creating Nothern Communist and South pro-Western Korean governments; the direct military actions).
Epic video!
Thank you!!😁
loved it!
I am glad to hear you say that😊
To be objective, Chiang was a pretty shitty negotiator, revolutionary, and national leader. His one redeeming characteristic is being strong willed.
IMO he's quite capable to emerge victorious (or at least to be sort of in control) among the cutthroats that were the warlords. Just that being ruthless and transactional aren't enough in turning the tide and lead his regime through the most turbulent times.
@@theolich4384 Yeah I guess. He does deserve credit for leading the second northern expedition and the country through WW2 but he was far from being strategically brilliant and was more of a "Stalin" type of military leader. Plus he recruited many of the warlords back into his government such as Yan xishan.
@@joshzhang7041 History hahahahaha republicans will kill each other what's wrong with that
@@theolich4384 But the skills of court battles and factional infighting won't help you win on the battlefield
然而毛是更烂的那个，战争结束后，就是反右、大跃进、土法炼钢、三年饥荒、文化大革命……
Marvellous 🤩
Thank you!!! :D
Nice 👍🏻
Thank you :D
when Mao said " It's Zedongin' time" and Zedonged all over the KMT.
WE felt that. 🥶👌
很直观
太棒啦，终于能让老外看到了
hey man love the work im subbing. this makes me want to play hoi4 again lol
头像阴间
the Chinese communists really did the impossible. gj to em
i love how much detail this has
even india breaking up is here thats crazy
Incroyable ! Excellent travail !👏👏👏💐💐💐
I'm Chinese,I love this video!
太帥了 阿遠
LONG LIVE THE GLORIOUS PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA 🇨🇳
Republic of China 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼
1912 ~ Present
republic of China1912-1949
@@wangming8740 taiwan: I am a joke to you?
@@dominx1751 taiwan is not ROC
地方割据政权，就像南梁在南成陈建立的时候就结束了，后面江陵那个叫西梁，正好也是外族保护下的傀儡，跟你们挺像
@@High_lord_of_Formosa 共產黨不也是投靠異族嗎，最早的境外反叛勢力有臉說別人
Nationalist leaders: generals with a lot of medal, good clothes and cool hats
Communist leaders: a couple of farmer looking guys🤣
who wins?
The communists got the peasants on their side and didn't fight the imperial Japanese as much. The ROC was battered from the fight, and Mao claimed himself lord of the embers. The peasants did not know that a few years later, millions of them would die in Mao's "Great Leap Forward" and "Cultural Revolution". Tragic.
@@olivius8891 I mean, the other China wasn't any better lol. They massacred millions of people before the war as well
@@olivius8891 Damn America, Korea, and Vietnam, damn the gangs
@@olivius8891 To be exact, it was not only peasants. During that time, the order of China was completely broken down. Under natural and man-made disasters, all walks of life stopped working and started endless infighting.
@@olivius8891 中共共产党信仰的是马列主义，是要建立一个社会主义国家，信仰归信仰，但真正要怎么建立有谁有现成的方法吗？都是摸索着前进，或者模仿苏联，在信资和信社的道路选择上国家也走了很多弯路。抛开历史背景环境就以结果来论就是莫名其妙。照你的逻辑世界历史上所有国家的建立和伟人的诞生都是一部部血泪史，都包含着无数人的牺牲。就像是拿着现代的科学技术来批判以古人的认知一样，不能说你错了，但是也不能说明你比古人更有智慧。
It’s sad how I’m every war there is always more civilian deaths then military deaths…
I love the details of this Map!
“How to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.”
~By Chiang Kai-Sheik.
Because let’s face it: Even though the Soviets handing over Manchuria and a bunch of captured Japanese equipment to the communists, the KMT really should’ve won.
TRUE
Yep. The Nationalists had military advisors, a modern air force, tons of arm shipments and other military aid…
The U.S. did everything short of sending large numbers of ground troops to aid the KMT, and Chiang still managed to lose.
The Soviets held important ports like Dalian though until after the Korean War; while carting much of the Manchurian assets off back to Europe, the Soviet "aid" to PRC were to be paid back later by raw materials. The Russian expansionist mindset made sure had N. Korea proceeded well, they'll want to have a pie on the Korean Peninsular too; if Kim failed to manage it and asked for "assistance" from the Soviets, even better. Bizarrely the Chinese and N.Koreans, surely aware of Stalin's scheme, were able to create a status quo around the 38th parallel without the direct involvement of the Red Army.
From what I know, the KMT leaders were hopelessly corrupt and their forces had been exhausted by the IJA, while the CCP gathered its forces in the countryside while mostly avoiding the Japanese. The fact that the KMT sacrificed millions of Chinese people to slow down the IJA (like in the Yellow River flood, which killed at least 400,000 people) didn't help
War is not a simple computation of armed force strength
Army morale, organisation of supplies, and most importantly the support of people
You can research a bit on how corrupt KMT was around that time
Гражданская война- это всегда плохо
非常有必要，因为这是中国内部的一次格式化。所有不利于社会进步的糟粕都被一扫而空，血与火锤炼出新生的中国。
Это не Гражданская война, а война против эксплуататоров.
А война с эксплуататорами - это хорошо.
@@TheElmar27 loss of life will always be a tragedy even when nessicary
没有这场内战，中国的人民还有被地方军阀和买办政府继续剥削
你的视频是所有解放战争中最好、最完整的，尤其是50年代后青海西部和武夷山还有湘西地区，甚至缅甸北部国民党军范围都标得特别清楚！
one question: the red flag with 5 stars beginned to be used after prc founded. but before that the party flag doesnt look like this one. this begin to use in 80s
fact
是的
我们在上世纪80年代改了党旗
yes
We change the party flag in 1980s
其實歷史會說明一切，到了今天中華民國依舊存在，不屬於中共政權的一部分
台独不得好死
@@吴彦祖-b2y 聽起來你挺有本事的。怎麼個死法？
内战没打完，不急。
事實就是台灣島不屬於PRC政權
中華民國不等於台獨
正所谓天无二日，民无二主。割据的势力，终究是要统一。20世纪最后10年，国民党在美国的支持下还有那么一线可能主导统一。
阿克赛钦是1962以后才夺回的吧？还有喀喇昆仑走廊也是1963年才和巴基斯坦勘界划回的
这个视频有些细节不是太准，不过还好😂
Hey, i love ur videos. Can you do a tutorial how to do war animations like yours?
This is a good proposal, no problem
I may put "YT short"
@@WarDestinyMapping thanks
@@WarDestinyMapping I also want to learn how to make map animations, Waiting for tutorial
ua-cam.com/video/EfMeAPqJzkM/v-deo.html
太強了呈遠哥
😄 感謝
最直观的感受，星星之火，可以燎原！
實際上，在被你有意或者無意忽略掉的西藏地方與西康省，國共雙方也展開了戰鬥。
They were stupid
把西藏地方画成外国，已经表明一种态度
@@jfz9125 這種態度就是有一種沒有文化的“美”。
@hofaeair 國共雙方都在西藏地方展開過直接戰斗，並且西藏地方的寺院和噶廈也在國共雙方之間選邊站，西藏地方戰役持續到1950年尚未結束。
@@jfz9125 当时的西藏政府脱落国共双方的控制，也不认为是国共双方的下属
Nice
Thank you
很震撼，这简直就是国家级别的延时摄影，每一次版图的推进背后都预示着无数的家庭家破人亡，父母失去儿子，孩子失去父亲，太残酷了
中国国民政府如现在中国经济会如何呢
@@jtl9614 引用平行宇宙的理论，任何好的和坏的情况都会出现。。😊或者说，当我说了跟没说一样也行。。🙃🙃
@@你猜我是谁-b4j 民主国家
@@jtl9614
其實很難說
因為這樣國府就是直接面對蘇聯這王八蛋了
中蘇方面的問題會提早發生衝突
國軍面對蘇軍應該是打不贏(但少了越戰與韓戰)
往好的方看，若中蘇關系正常下無戰亂
如果中華民國還在對岸的話
依「國民政府建國大綱」軍政時期、訓政時期與憲政時期
2023的今天應是憲政時期…
中華民國的自由民主將會在東亞發光發熱
而且經濟發展會更早
@@VirgoTw_1990 现在我市旅游景点全是民国初期阶段的建筑翻新,外墙翻新,小巷里全是70年以前古代建筑没人住变危搂了
舟山群島似乎被遺忘了，國軍在1950年5月撤出後該島隨即被中共占領，但在視頻中，它似乎直到1951年6月才變成紅色。
The Zhoushan Islands seem to have been forgotten; they were occupied by the Chinese Communist Party in May 1950, but in the video, it does not appear to have turned red until June 1951.
1953年之后剩下的福建那支部队是啥？
就叫國民黨伊斯蘭叛軍
国共内战中最关键的战役之一就发生在我的家乡。在这场战役中，数百万父老乡亲推着小推车踊跃支前，在人民的支援下，华野全歼国军第七兵团，黄百韬畏罪自毙身亡。
如果要说到为什么家乡父老最终选择支持中国共产党，就不得不谈谈当年国府炸毁花园口大堤，组建“还乡团”，放纵国军抢劫、残害平民等暴行了。
谁能想到后面是一条更大的贼船
不如天安门广场坦克道
蒋介石没有能力治理国家，部下毫无军纪贪污腐败已经不能用严重来形容了，民国政府垮台只是时间问题，得民心者得天下
@@nsjsjdamoaa 那也还是比蒋好啊
@@wot9392 老毛只是他们合法性的来源而已，你猜今天中共内部认不认可老毛？今天的中共明显走的当初国民党路线，什么大一统 什么中华民族伟大复兴，尤其像蒋介石时代的国民党。
Nice!
Thank you!!!
Imagine if Toyotomi Hideyoshi entered the chat as a warlord in the chinese civil war as a third party
As a citizen of the Republic of China living in Taiwan, I feel very sad.
In what sense?
@@communistdeer better dead, then red.
@@osamisimidzu Reminder that the Soviet Union and Communist China is not even close to communism.
Long live the Republic of China!
@@richardthomas5362 Long live the People’s Republic of China!
發現聯合國軍不大行呀😂
那几十万韭菜军是被谁干死的
正面战场上日本人很有优势，联合国军死伤惨重是没办法的事
沒有人願意投入到一場毫無利益的戰鬥之中，美國扶持南韓損失那麼多士兵的生命就是一個錯誤
没想到52年国军还在内陆有控制区
有是有，但老蒋管不了
想你了，牢常
不得不说如果当年国共如果可以协商谈判来解决分歧，也许现在的中国已经是世界第一了，也不会有什么台海危机这种事情。
你当苏美是做慈善的
当年中国要是组建联合政府，美苏会分别渗透国共两党，各自扶持代理人。中国会因为这种内耗，无法集中力量发展，甚至埋下分解的危险。
中共不願交出軍權，老蔣一心想軍政統一，沒有共識當然不用談，如同92共識沒有共識一樣😂
@user-xo4er4cm7b 很可惜现在两岸又在重复当年蒋介石和毛泽东的错误，不知道100年后如何看待今天的故事 。
@@星空-s1p交出军权又是一场四一二
Respect to great country and culture like that of China from India.
Everyone is a descendant of a long-standing civilization 🎉
蔣校長想用快速軍事行動解決東北民聯
普大帝也想用快速軍事行動解決烏克蘭
蔣校長初期佔很大的優勢（廢話！上一個被這麼大的實力差給幹爆的還是明朝，而且還是反賊遍地的時候）
普大帝初期也佔很大的優勢（說實話，快速白給行動前沒人會拿俄羅斯跟烏克蘭比的…）
蔣校長跟自家的各種軍閥鬧得不愉快（東北軍:?!#%&/¥§）
普大帝跟自家的挖鉻啦鬧得不愉快（弗拉雞米你等著，2萬瓦鉻啦勇士很快到你家）
蔣校長經常優勢宰我
普大帝也經常優勢宰我
蔣校長的江湖諢號是花園口戰神
普大帝的江湖諢號是卡霍夫卡戰神
蔣校長的小弟們經常倒賣武器（洋基佬：我援助哪去了？）
普大帝的小弟們也經常倒賣武器（參見車臣戰爭）
蔣校長沒有統一全國（指西藏，外蒙）
普大帝也沒有統一全國（指蘇聯）
蔣校長是當時的五常之一
普大帝也是當時的五常之一
蔣校長把一手好牌打得比紅薯粥裡的紅薯還稀爛 （指把只有100萬人的東北民聯軍動員戡亂戡到400多萬）
普大帝也把一手好牌打得比紅薯粥裡的紅薯還稀爛（指如何在兩個月裡向天下人證明蘇聯紅軍正統在烏克蘭）
蔣校長在國內最大的反對派是康米黨（物理意義上的）
普大帝在國內最大的反對派也是康米黨（政治意義上的）
蔣校長的後勤系統很廢
普大帝的後勤系統也很廢
蔣校長在國內的支持度一直在下降（指被暴打一頓後丟到台灣島）
普大帝在國內的支持度也一直在下降（啊～挖鉻啦鴿鴿的步戰車，已經填滿了羅斯托夫呢～）
蔣校長有一大堆給他洗地的（聽我貢歐，蔣公是因為心善才自願不打共軍跑到台灣島上吃滷肉飯（雖然蠻好吃的）的厚）
普大帝也有一大堆給他洗地的 （就算整個東北全給他了之經典黃俄語錄）
蔣校長曾經被逼宮過（西安事變）
普大帝也曾經被逼宮過（挖鉻啦兵變）
蔣校長活了下來（第二次不管三七二十一先一起把狗日的北洋/小鬼子暴打一頓扔出玄關再關起門來內訌殺康米）
普大帝也活了下來（要以核畏跪，不要搞握力鬥）
逼蔣校長宮的人沒有什麼好果汁吃（指張被關，楊被殺）
逼普大帝宮的人也沒有什麼好果汁吃（休～～崩💥）
蔣校長的戰績直到現在還被人拿出來鞭
普大帝的戰績直到現在也還被人拿出來鞭
蔣校長發家於舊政權崩潰（大清亡啦）
普大帝也發家於舊政權崩潰（一摸就碎的聯盟）
綜上所述，普大帝就是蔣校長
800 000 против 600 000, преимущество за мной！
蒋校长基本盘比普大帝拉多了，虽然国民党名义上控制着整个中国，但是整个国民党几乎可以说是没有自己的基层组织，对自己本身的占领区域掌控力度太差了，而且国内各系军阀也是听调不听宣，只能说是名义上统一中国，实际上离掌控整个国家差了百八十万里。
普京支持率越来越高了😂
再加一个蒋校长和普京起势都是出于旧政权崩溃
@@Kevin-cz8qj 可以有
可惜了
Amazing
Thanks
If democracy really can make China rich and strong in 19th centry , then the Communist Party will not defeat the Kuomintang had the support of the United States.
Any ideology were produced with the support and belive of people...
After many years , the china mainland keep their thought to try up,and fail and change other ways and keep to try more.
Finally had done the rise task at 20th centry , amost people were live better than pass.
Look at the US and taiwan, in addition to denying the 92 consensus, they also regard mainland China as a threat, and use all means to discredit and suppress it in an attempt to take it down .
The so-called "freedom democracy" cannot tolerate other ideologies better than they in this world. This is true "dictatorship" of the US govment.
And the US were Interests launch/promote multiple wars in various countries at that 20 years, which is a threat of the world at all.
clear understanding
Typical communist mindset
"If democracy can make china XXX"
China was and is not a democratic state.
KMT is a totalitarianism regime
五毛 copypasta detected.
作為臺灣人我只能說影片做的太好了
持續加油，中華民國萬歲
可能吗？统一大势是历史的选择，不以个人意志为转移。中华民国已经成为中华民族的历史了，就和清朝一样。
@@simiandong1638 中華民族從來沒有什麼共匪的概念
你應該是列寧後代而不是他媽的炎黃子孫
@@Edwin21221 都是中国现在中国国民党在大陆我们也不会不要他
中华万岁
@@simiandong1638 歷史的選擇不是由你我決定的，天下合久必分分久必合，並不會只有大一統的選項。中華民國並沒有成為已逝去的歷史，今年2023年是民國112年，且中華民國依然存在台澎金馬，這就是最好的證明。
青海那里是怎么回事啊？
对啊直接大溃败