Rebutting Dr. Zakir Naik "Vedas are Incomplete" Argument

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2019
  • In this segment of the video " The Rebuttal of Dr. Zakir Naik" we rebute the argument that the Vedas are incomplete and were met for a particular time period and a particular type of people who couldn’t grasp higher teachings.
    We are also showing how the only mean to understand the Vedas is through the parampara system.
    To know more about ISKM visit us at www.iskm.international/
    Lets stay connected by Subscribing to our channel now ua-cam.com/users/SriKrishnaMa...
    - Connect with us www.iskm.international/temples/
    - Like us on Facebook / skm.sg
    - Follow us on Instagram / iskm.sg
    - Subscribe to our ISKM Newsletter eepurl.com/cEEaXz
    Have more Questions Email us at: submit.iskm@srikrishnamandir.org

КОМЕНТАРІ • 70

  • @thiruchelvamnalathamby2592
    @thiruchelvamnalathamby2592 4 роки тому +16

    Well explained ! Thank you prabhu! Hare Krsna

  • @nikhilnirmal4131
    @nikhilnirmal4131 4 роки тому +27

    One day scientist accept sanatan dharma are only true or scientific

    • @UltimateHindu
      @UltimateHindu 3 роки тому +1

      कृप्या मेरा चैनल सब्सक्राइब करें और शेयर करे
      ua-cam.com/video/jg5wP8pzLi0/v-deo.html .............

    • @fashwealth95
      @fashwealth95 3 роки тому +2

      Already accepted

  • @RK.7789
    @RK.7789 4 роки тому +25

    Zakir nayak is not worth of talking about....

  • @ravinaga9435
    @ravinaga9435 4 роки тому +16

    Hare Krishna 🕉️🕉️🔔🔔🙏🙏👏👏

  • @nikhilnirmal4131
    @nikhilnirmal4131 4 роки тому +16

    Only sanatan dharma is only true or scientific. 🕉

  • @premanjandas6955
    @premanjandas6955 4 роки тому +10

    Excellent.

  • @ramzmesh7138
    @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому +20

    Zakir Naik Is Not Have Wisdom(Jnaninah) About Hinduism🕉️

    • @jagdishshukla8212
      @jagdishshukla8212 4 роки тому +6

      Koran is only for a group of people for a time period.

    • @ramzmesh7138
      @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому +2

      @@waseemabbas1730 U Must Watching "Apostate Prophet" 🤭

    • @ramzmesh7138
      @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому +5

      @@waseemabbas1730 I Can't Answering To Mlechchhah Like U 😝 False Muhammadean Religion

    • @aadhyadebnath3123
      @aadhyadebnath3123 4 роки тому +3

      @@waseemabbas1730 yes it's all for humanity not only one particular group of people

    • @amit_anand_jha
      @amit_anand_jha 4 роки тому +2

      @@waseemabbas1730 Why are you falsely quoting the shlokas. I somewhere showed you the exact shloka and gave you the meaning as well . Demigods worship takes one to higher planets like Janlokpa , Mahaloka , Taploka , Gandharvaloka etc . Stop doing "TAQUIYA" . Be brave enough to listen to the truth and if possible accept it .

  • @ramzmesh7138
    @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому +3

    Sir !!,,Please Explain About Maànduukhya Upanishad 😊🙏

  • @joydipbiswas-ki2hv
    @joydipbiswas-ki2hv 5 місяців тому

    What a great service done by Prabhu to expose the fraud in today's society! ❤

  • @Thebkblogs
    @Thebkblogs 4 роки тому +3

    👍👍👍

  • @Jai_Gauranga
    @Jai_Gauranga Рік тому

    Very meaningful, I've subscribed to this channel

  • @RajuSingh-dq9qt
    @RajuSingh-dq9qt 4 роки тому +2

    Hare Krishna hare Ramo

  • @tejaswini2998
    @tejaswini2998 4 роки тому

    Thank you so much Prabhu ji

  • @shankarkumarmagar6353
    @shankarkumarmagar6353 4 роки тому

    hare krisha

  • @nitishjha1221
    @nitishjha1221 3 роки тому

    Nice❤️

  • @tomaldebnath899
    @tomaldebnath899 3 роки тому

    Thank you provu.....plz bless me

  • @arkanjanchatterjee8102
    @arkanjanchatterjee8102 3 роки тому

    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @shawonmalakar3633
    @shawonmalakar3633 3 роки тому

    Haribol

  • @riturajsrivastava35
    @riturajsrivastava35 2 роки тому

    I love you

  • @user-lj4qs8hb4g
    @user-lj4qs8hb4g 4 роки тому

    Prji, is ISKM a competition to ISKCON?

  • @Yakna3622
    @Yakna3622 4 роки тому +1

    Bajaam govindam

  • @pavanrajput6876
    @pavanrajput6876 4 роки тому +12

    Ved & Bhagwat geeta are the real source of 🕉️ PARMATMA's knowledge but Quran is complete book of comedy

    • @ad9810974209
      @ad9810974209 4 роки тому +4

      Yes , you're right. Most of the people are not following Vedas as they are. Your Zakir Naik says, "Don't judge a religion by seeing it's people but by it's books". Then why are commenting like this? So our acaryas like Sankaracarya, Ramanujacarya, Madhvacarya, Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Thakur and many others have kept Bhagavad Gita on top of all Upanishads and Srimad Bhagavatam as the spotless purana which talks only about pure devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna.

    • @anuver007
      @anuver007 4 роки тому +1

      @Test Tube bro khajro temple was bulit to teach people about sexuality ..it's built on tha basis on kamasutra ...there nothing wrong in that

    • @ramzmesh7138
      @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому

      Well Said 😊👌 👌!!!, Actually Quran Written By Sadistic Muhammad 🤭

    • @ramzmesh7138
      @ramzmesh7138 4 роки тому +1

      @Test Tube Islam Most Worsted Religion In The World, !!

    • @Sush_AVR
      @Sush_AVR 4 роки тому +1

      @Test Tube ppl think religion means spreading lies folowing a cheater abusing ppl killing in the name of religion becming terorists suporting teroeists funding terorist nation terorism nd also its ok to lie to a non believer to cknvert them. Stop the DHANDHA OF COMVERSION. ADHARMA KE BAAP HO TUM LOG. Teroeists se kam hai mob launching nd temple pehle tumlog todey use suport kare toh khud ki ghar todke kisi aur ku dedo i will see will u give ur home to othrs who break nd rebuild it.
      Have some sense nd humanity.
      ADHARMA KE LOG

  • @raajesh2012
    @raajesh2012 3 роки тому +3

    Zakir kayak.. He himself incomplete.. His nothing but a joke.

  • @sanjayghosh387
    @sanjayghosh387 4 роки тому

    SPIRITUALITY MEANS
    1) REALIZATION THE DERIVATIVE SUBJECT OF "SPIRITUALITY " "THE SPIRIT" THAT WHICH IS ETERNAL AND REAL AND DIFFERENT FROM UNREAL PERISHABLE MATTER.
    2) SELF REALIZATION OF THE SPIRIT WITHIN, THUS AT THE SAME TIME ESCAPING FROM THE
    CONFINEMENT FROM MATTER BY THE EXPERIENTIAL REALIZATION OF SPIRIT IN THE FORM OF THE HIGHER EXPERIENTIAL CHARACTER OF BLISS.
    3) GOD REALIZATION : GOD IS A SUBJECT OF EXPERIENTIAL REALIZATION NO SPECULATION BY INTELLIGENCE , MIND OR SPECULATION SOUL IS RELATED WITH GOD BY CHARACTER OF BLISS, THUS REALIZING THAT PERMANENT EXPERIENCE OF THE OCEAN OF BLISS BY THE ETERNAL CONNECTIVITY BY DEVOTIONAL ACTIVITY OF THE SERVER AND THE SERVED . THUS MAKING GOD AS THE SINGLE MOST GOAL OF SPIRITUALITY, THE INDIVIDUAL SPIRIT , NOT ANY OTHER SUBSIDIARY GOALS , OR MIRAGE IMAGINED SPIRITUALITY , A CASTLE IN THE SKY ,THAT STEMS FROM THE EXPERIENCE FORM THE MATERIAL WORLD OF DUALITIES ,MEN ,WOMEN, HEAVEN AND PARADISE THE MATERIAL SENSES OF THE HUMAN BODY , THE MATERIAL WORLD , IT CAN THEREFORE BE INFERRED THAT THAT IS NO NO NO CONCEPT OF SPIRITUALITY, SPIRITUAL ACTIVITY , OR ETERNAL CONNECTIVITY TO GOD AS THE GOAL OF ALL SPIRITUAL ACTIVITIES IN ABRAHAMIC FAITHS , BUT IMAGINARY PROMISES OF MIRAGE THAT WERE SEEN , EXPERIENCED THROUGH THE GREEN GLASSES OF THE MATERIAL WORLD. THIS IS WHAT MAKES ABRAHAMIC FAITHS ALL FALSE AND RIDICULOUS .GOD THE SUPREME BLISS IS THE ULTIMATELY GOAL OF ALL SPIRITUAL ACTIVITIES,
    NEITHER MALE OR FEMALE DUALITIES, NOT 72 VIRGINS IF THERE ANY? NOR
    UNLIMITED SEX HAS ANY PLACE IN LORDS SPIRITUAL ABODE.WHEN
    CONSCIOUSNESS IS IN MATTER , IN THE DUALITIES OF MALE AND FEMALE ,THE SENSES,AND SENSE GRATIFICATION ,IT IS CALLED CONDITIONED STATE.WHEN THE CONSCIOUSNESS IS FREED FROM DULL MATTER AND LOCATED IN THE SPIRIT, IT IS CALLED THE STATE OF LIBERATION AND EXPERIENCE OF BLISS.THEREFORE SPIRITUALITY IS A LONG JOURNEY FORM THE LIBERATION MATTER TO THE FREEDOM OF THE EXPERIENTIAL
    UNDERSTANDING OF SPIRIT . SUCH IS THE EXPERIENCE OF A LIBERATED PERSON TO
    WHOM THE MATERIAL ILLUSION IE. MATERIAL BODY , MATERIAL PLEASURES,
    AND SENSE GRATIFICATION OF THE MATERIAL BODY ATTRACTION TO DULATIES OF MALE AND FEMALE BODY , HARDLY EFFECTS HIM AS HE IS LIBERATED , ACHIEVED SALVATION ANDLOCATED IN SPIRITUAL CONSCIOUSNESS IN EXPERIENCE OF SPIRIT ...BLISS
    A) EXPERIENCE OF SPIRIT DIRECTIONAL OPPOSITE TO THE MATERIAL
    EXPERIENCES OF SENSE GRATIFICATION THE GREAT DEVOTEE YAMUNACARYA, WHO SAID,
    “SINCE I HAVE BEEN ENGAGED IN THE TRANSCENDENTAL LOVING SERVICE OF OH
    LORD , REALIZING EVER-NEW PLEASURE IN HIM, WHENEVER I THINK OF SEX PLEASURE I
    SPIT AT THE THOUGHT, AND MY LIPS CURL WITH DISTASTE.” OF COURSE, LORD
    DOES SAY IN THE BHAGAVAD-GITA THAT THERE IS SUCH A THING AS SEX ACCORDING TO
    RELIGIOUS PRINCIPLES. BUT WHEN WE FINALLY EXPERIENCE SPIRITUAL PLEASURE, WE’LL
    REMEMBER OUR FORMER PLEASURES AND SEE THAT THEY WERE NOTHING.
    B) THE ETERNAL NATURE OF THE SOUL : CONTENTS OF THE GITA SUMMARIZED BHAGWATGITA 2 TEXT 23
    NAINAM CHINDANTI SASTRANI NAINAM DAHATI PAVAKAH NA CAINAM
    KLEDAYANTY APO NA SOSAYATI MARUTAH TRANSLATION THE SOUL CAN NEVER BE CUT INTO PIECES BY ANY WEAPON, NOR CAN HE BE BURNED BY FIRE, NOR MOISTENED BY WATER, NOR WITHERED BY THE WIND.
    C) THE EXPERIENTIAL NATURE OF THE SOUL THAT IT IS INDEPENDENT PURE BLISS LIBERATED FROM EXPERIENCE OF MATTER DUALITIES OF MALE ,FEMALE AND THAT OF SENSE GRATIFICATION.
    TAITTIRIYA UPANISHAD- PETAL 9
    CHAPTER 3 BHRIGU, THE SON OF VARUNA, APPROACHED HIS FATHER VARUNA AND SAID:
    "VENERABLE SIR, TEACH ME ABOUT BRAHMAN (SOUL)." TO HIM, THE SON, HE
    SAID THIS: "FOOD, THE VITAL BREATH, THE EYE, THE EAR, THE MIND,
    SPEECH." TO HIM HE SAID FURTHER: "THAT FROM WHICH THESE BEINGS ARE
    BORN, THAT BY WHICH, WHEN BORN, THEY LIVE, THAT INTO WHICH THEY ENTER, THEY
    MERGE-SEEK TO KNOW THAT. THAT IS BRAHMAN." HE PERFORMED AUSTERITIES.
    HAVING PERFORMED AUSTERITIES-HE WENT THROUGH VARIOUS LEVELS OF MATERIAL
    UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT IS SOUL? LIKE
    A) THE MATERIAL BODY IS BRAHMAN
    B) THE PRANA LIFE AIRS AS BRAHMAN
    C) THE MIND AS BRAHMAN
    D) THE INTELLECT AS BRAHMAN EVERY TIME
    VARUN CAME WITH HIS MATERIAL UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT IS SOUL , HE WAS
    TURNED BACK BY HIS FATHER , DUE TO IMPROPER REALIZATION AND FINALLY WHEN HE
    PRESENTED HIS PROPPER REALIZATION THAT SOUL BLISS IS BRAHMAN , HIS FATHER
    EMBRACED HIM , SAYING THIS WAS THE CORRECT EXPERIALIZATION OF THE SOUL ,
    OBVIOUSLY THAT ALSO MEANT HE STOOD LIBERATED FROM MATERIAL UNDERSTANDING
    SECTION 6 -BLISS IS BRAHMAN ANANDO BRAHMETI VYAJANAT.H .
    ANANDADHYEVA KHALVIMANI BHUTANI JAYANTE . ANANDENA JATANI JIVANTI . ANANDAM PRAYANTYABHISA.NVISHANTITI . SAISHA BHARGAVI VARUNI VIDYA . PARAME
    VYOMANPRATISHTHITA . SA YA EVAM VEDA PRATITISHTHATI . ANNAVANANNADO BHAVATI . MAHANBHAVATI PRAJAYA PASHUBHIRBRAHMAVARCHASENA . MAHAN.H KIRTYA ..
    1:HE REALISED THAT BLISS IS BRAHMAN; FOR FROM BLISS (ANANDA), VERILY, ARE THESE
    BEINGS BORN; BY BLISS, WHEN BORN, DO THEY LIVE; INTO BLISS, AT THE TIME OF
    DISSOLUTION, DO THEY ENTER, DO THEY MERGE. THIS IS THE WISDOM TAUGHT BY VARUNA
    AND LEARNT BY BHRIGU. IT IS ESTABLISHED IN THE SUPREME AKASA, IN THE HEART. HE
    WHO KNOWS THIS IS ESTABLISHED IN THE BLISS OF BRAHMAN. HE BECOMES A POSSESSOR OF FOOD AND AN EATER OF FOOD. HE BECOMES GREAT IN OFFSPRING AND CATTLE AND IN SPIRITUAL RADIANCE AND GREAT IN FAME.
    D) THE MATERIAL WORLD IS AN ILLUSORY PERISHABLE CREATION LIKE AN ILLUSORY EXPERIENCE OF A SECOND MOON TEXT 2: JUST AS A DREAM IS MERELY A CREATION OF ONE’S INTELLIGENCE BUT HAS NO ACTUAL SUBSTANCE, SIMILARLY, MATERIAL LAMENTATION, ILLUSION, HAPPINESS, DISTRESS AND THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE MATERIAL BODY UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF MĀYĀ ARE ALL CREATIONS OF MY ILLUSORY ENERGY. IN OTHER WORDS, MATERIAL EXISTENCE HAS NO ESSENTIAL REALITY. THERE CANNOT BE ANY PROGRESS IN SPIRITUALITY NEGATING THE EXPERIENCE OF SPIRIT , LIKE HOW THERE CANNOT BE ANY CONFECTIONERY ITEM WITHOUT ANY SUGAR OR SUGARY BASED SUBSTANCE , REALIZATION OF SPIRIT IS THE VERY KEY THAT OPENS THE DOORS TO SPIRITUALITY.HOW SILLY THAT THE HUMAN BRAIN THAT IS CAPABLE OF REALIZING THINGS HIGHER , FELLS THAT AN ORDINARY THING LIKE SEX THAT ARE AVAILABLE TO THE LOWEST OF CREATURES LIKE BUFFALOES IS SEEN AS A GREAT MERITORIOUS GOAL OF " SPIRITUAL ACTIVITY" I REALLY FEEL LIKE ASKING THIS FOOLISH FOLLOWERS OF ABRAHAMIC FAITHS AGAIN AND AGAIN A THOUSAND TIMES CAN ACQUIRING OF 72 VIRGINS THE GREAT , NOBLE AND TRANSCENDENTAL GOAL OF SPIRITUALITY???? AS ABRAHAMIC FAITHS HAVE NO CONCEPT OF THE SCIENCE AND DELIBERATIONS OF THE SPIRIT AND THAT OF THE SOUL AND SUPERSOUL BOTH RELATED BY ETERNAL BLISS, IT IS THEREFORE THAT THE ABRAHAMIC FOLLOWERS HAVE NO IDEA THAT THE SUPREME LORD IS INDEED THE SINGLE MOST GOAL OF ALL SPIRITUAL ACTIVITIES, IN THE DEVOTIONAL BLISS OF THE SERVER AND THE SERVED IN HIS ETERNAL ABODE. A PERSON HIS SPIRIT AND SPIRITUAL BLISS CONSCIOUSNESS OF AN INDIVIDUAL THAT GETS COVERED BY MATERIAL SENSE CONSCIOUSNESS OF MALE AND FEMALE DUALITY , A SECONDARY PERISHABLE WORLD SANCTIONED BY GOD TO ACCOMMODATE THE FALSE INDIVIDUAL'S EGO OF BEING INDEPENDENT FROM GOD , THROUGH THE THE INSTRUMENT OF DUALITY, OF MALE AND FEMALE BODY ,THAT VIA MUTUAL SEXUAL ATTRACTION BINDS INDIVIDUALS TO THIS ILLUSION AND PRODUCE MORE AND MORE ILLUSIONED SOULS , AND BIND THEM TO THE ILLUSORY PERISHABLE WORLD THAT IS A STUPENDOUS SCULPTURED ILLUSION OF THE LORD THAT FORCES HIM TO SEE THE MATERIAL WORLD AS REAL AND COVERING THE INDIVIDUALS SPIRITUAL SELF AS DESIRED BY HIM BY WAY OF BEING INDEPENDENT .YOU CANNOT TAKE A HORSE TO THE WATER BUT CANNOT MAKE HIM DRINK IT , IT TAKES IMMENSE COURAGE TO SEE THE TRUTH BUT IT THE ABRAHAMIC FOLLOWERS ARE CHAINED BY ABRAHAMIC FAITHS BY FEAR OF HELL AND LUST OF HEAVENLY PLEASURES CONSCIENCE COMPLETELY COVERED WITH PROMISES OF MUNDANE WORLDLY PLEASURES OF SEX AND SENSE GRATIFICATION THAT HAS NEITHER TO DO ANYTHING WITH THE SPIRIT ,OR HAVE ANY PLACE IN LORDS SPIRITUAL ABODE NOR THE GOAL OF SPIRITUAL ACTIVITY , TAKE GUTS TAKE GUTS TO COME OUT .SPARE THE LORD FROM SUCH FUNNY , ABSURD MESSENGERS AND THEIR IDIOTIC FAITHS ..WHO LARGELY PROVE THEIR FABRICATED GOD IS ALWAYS AFFLICTED WITH CHANGING AND ERRING MIND AND OF UNCERTAIN DECISION OR LARGELY SPEAKING PRONE TO MISTAKES AN ELEMENTARY AND ORDINARY HUMAN CONDITION, WHICH CANNOT BE A QUALITY OF AN ALL PERFECT GOD ,DUE TO HIS INABILITY TO SEE THE PRESENT PAST AND FUTURE .GUYS YOU ARE IN AN UNAUTHORISED SCHOOL WHICH WILL DAMN YOU TO HELL.TRY AND SEE THE TRUTH , VEDAS ARE ALL PERFECT THE WORD INCARNATION OF GOD, NON DIFFERENT FROM HIM ,WITHOUT MISTAKES , UNCHANGEABLE & ETERNAL . THERE
    IS NO CONCEPT OF SOUL IN ABRAHAMIC FAITHS . WHAT EVER REFERRED AS SOUL
    IN THE BIBLE OR RU IN THE QURAN IS A GENERIC POLICY STATEMENT , LIKE SOME
    ELECTRICITY THAT IS NEEDED TO CONDUCT THE BODY , AND ALL THIS BULLSHIT OF
    TRINITY DOES NOT EXPLAIN THE CONCEPT OF TRINITY THE FATHER . THE SON AND THE
    HOLY SPIRIT IS ANOTHER BULLSHIIT , WHERE IS THE NATURE AND THE EXPERIENCE
    OF THE SOUL EXPLAINED HERE ??? WHERE IS THE PROCESS OF REALIZING
    THE SOUL THUS CONNECTING WITH THE SUPERSOUL OR GOD EXPLAINED HERE ? WHERE IS THE PROCESS OF YOGA EXPLAINED HERE ??? THERE ARE FRINGE BENEFITS IN A PRAYER AND THAT ALSO THOSE PRAYERS THAT IS DEVOID OF ANY DIRECTIONS TOWARD SPIRITUAL PROGRESS AND SPIRITUAL DESTINATIONS, BUT GROSS PRAYERS SEEKING PROTECTION OR PROVISION OF BREAD,

  • @ramnivashyadav8902
    @ramnivashyadav8902 4 роки тому +2

    Dr Jakir is dog hare Krishna Krishna Krishna here hare hare Rama Rama Rama hare hare

  • @elangsiwan773
    @elangsiwan773 3 роки тому

    That is a good systematic substantiation of arguments against Zakir, perhaps its bit too much for a foolish person like him. But useful for Hindus to know their knowledge. Thanks

  • @SyedAsharun
    @SyedAsharun 4 роки тому +2

    😇😇😇
    Hare krishna, maha mantra
    Meaning - O Krishna, O energy of Krishna (energy of Krishna - god)
    Lahilaha illalah - there is no god but Allah, Allah (god)
    It clearly says that the energy of Krishna is god without second and allah means god without second
    Incase of mastering the spritual masters are the ones who receive the true directly and advice the people to follow it and prophet muhammad (peace be upon him). A person who doesn't know read and write recieved the truth and knowledge directly in cave Hira. The muslims follows his path to avoid the desire on this earthly life and lead the path to the next by following halal and avoiding haram because prevention is better than cure.
    😇😇😇

    • @abhaypadgaonkar9019
      @abhaypadgaonkar9019 4 роки тому

      But according to islam allah has no shape but krishna has.

    • @sayanhalder6752
      @sayanhalder6752 3 роки тому

      Don't try to equate this two
      You are doing kutark

    • @amanjaiswal5057
      @amanjaiswal5057 2 роки тому

      Sorry to say this but you are wrong instead of your own mental speculation try to learn it form samprdaya achryas hare means radharani and krishna you know when we chant mahamantra we call the lord to gives their mercy i hope you get it now
      Hare krishna ❤️ 🙏

  • @RajeshRajesh-xy5vp
    @RajeshRajesh-xy5vp 3 роки тому

    He is foolishly and idiotically interpretating the vedas he is unnecessary speak unnecessary and un wanted words which leads to provocation.