What Is Written in the Talmud? | Unpacked
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лип 2024
- The layout of the Talmud, one of the most important Jewish texts, has remained virtually unchanged since its earliest days in print. This layout reveals a compelling look at Jewish values. What part did Daniel Bomberg - a Christian printer in Venice play in its publication, what’s behind the concept of “daf yomi” (reading a page of Talmud a day) and why has the Talmud’s graphic design not changed for generations?
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:48 What is the written Torah?
01:10 What is the Oral Torah?
01:20 Why was the Oral Torah written down in the Mishna?
01:40 What is the Gemara?
02:15 What is the Talmud?
02:37 Commentaries on the Talmud
03:17 The printing press and printed editions of the Talmud
06:04 History of Daf Yomi or "Daily Page"
06:23 Jewish values in the Talmud's layout
06:58 Outro
Subscribe and turn on your notifications so you don’t miss future uploads!
ua-cam.com/users/UNPACKED?sub_...
Watch next - Why Did Hasidic Jews Get Hit Hard by Corona?
• Why Did Hasidic Jews G...
Recommended series - The Jewish Story Explained
• What Is the Jewish Peo...
Let’s connect:
Website - www.jewishunpacked.com
Instagram - / jewishunpacked
Twitter - / jewishunpacked
TikTok - / jewishunpacked
Facebook - / jewishunpacked
About Explainers: From ancient Jewish traditions to the modern State of Israel, we explain it all. Diving into anything and everything related to Jewish culture, history, and even religion.
Understand Jewish holidays, Israeli politics, Jewish diasporic communities, and more. Learn about Judaism in pop culture, debunking myths about Jews, and explore obscure Israeli landmarks. We’re asking questions as basic as “What is the Talmud?”, and as obscure as “How did hip-hop boost Kosher wine sales?”, and everything in between.
About Unpacked: We provide nuanced insights by unpacking all things Jewish. People are complex and complicated - yet we’re constantly being pushed to oversimplify our world. At Unpacked we know that being complex makes us more interesting. Because of this, we break the world down with nuance and insight to drive your curiosity and challenge your thinking.
#Jewish #Talmud #Judaism
The title of this video is misleading. You told us nothing of what is written in the Talmud. The vagueness in this video is odd and suggests there's something to hide. Not one example of an actual passage for us to gain some understanding of the culture.
Little hats hide a lot history
Talmud is studied for one's entire lifetime. How can one put Talmud into a 7-minute video?
As for "something to hide," this is your own prejudice speaking. It's your problem.
@Kurtlane I didn't ask for the entire book. The title suggests that there would be SOMETHING from the Talmud. I've watched videos that actually show what's written in it. They managed to do it in videos that ranged in length and from different channels from different perspectives. It's not difficult to put a passage or some form of context into a video.
Obviously, those videos don't show the entire book (only a moron would even consider that as a possibility) because that would be like putting the entire Bible or Quran or an Encyclopedia into a video, but they managed to show passages, explain history, etc.
This person clearly used the title for click bait, knowing that people are interested in knowledge and information, and they provided nothing at all.
I don't think judging something based on what's presented is considered 'prejudice', but if you say so. Click bait titles are akin to lying. This person is a liar. It's not just misleading...it's a straight-up lie. Nothing was "unpacked."
@@tstyleartistry , it does explain the basic division into Mishnah and Gemara. Beyond that, quoting any passage runs the danger of people mistaking that particular passage for the main message of the book. Why this passage, and not any other?
The Bible and the Koran are much smaller than the Talmud. Moreover, the Bible at any rate has a process of events following each other, which unifies it.
Koran was composed of bits of statements put together from pieces of paper, parchment, palm leaves, etc. with writing on it, and whatever was remembered by the last original reciters. So within Koran hides the traditional way of reading it, not from start to finish, but in a completely different way in which it was originally prophesied by Mohammed, or so it is believed, with (supposedly) later passages replacing earlier ones. Which makes it very difficult and debatable, since questions about which ones came earlier and which later will inevitably arise.
So, as you can see, Koran is quite hidden. Especially from non-Muslims, who are not allowed to read it. But "Muslims have something to hide" is not said. Certainly not as much as "Jews have something to hide." Why? Because anyone saying it risks getting one's head cut off.
And here we come to the true state of humanity, and how often people who are not allowed to "question" or criticize someone will switch their "questioning" or criticizm in someone else, who will not cut off their heads.
(I put "question" in quotes here because they "question" like a child tears a little animal into pieces. They cut off body parts of many people, burn people alive, and call it "questioning.")
Back to Talmud. It's like the Internet. Can anyone describe the Internet in the same way you demand Talmud to be described? "What is the essence of Internet? What is it really about?" And if you cannot -- "Oh, you must be hiding something, (expletives)."
No, you are not as innocent as you pretend.
@@tstyleartistry , I tried to reply. And was blocked.
Trying again:
Talmud is much larger than the Bible or Koran. Moreover the Bible has a certain rhythm, it moves as history moves. It's almost like it's possible to sum it up.
Koran is not like that, but I cannot say anything about it, or I'll be blocked.
Talmud is not like that either. It's like the Internet. Of course, you can ask, "what is written on Internet?" But is that a meaningful question? And does not answering it "suggests there's something to hide?"
Only one problem. You didn't explain that the Talmud is not from God it is Babylonian in origin.
The Talmud doesn’t claim to be scripture.
This is an ignorant comment, I am sorry. The Talmud isn't a divine book. It's an interpretation of the Mishnah, which is putting the oral Torah in writing. This is a hermaneutic-juristic-cultural masterpiece.
Ok why don't christians explain the the new testament originates from Greek mythology?
@@moses2031 What I said is a fact. Judaism today is a mixture of what God gave them and pagan Babylonian religion. That's not up for debate. God gave them the OT. Men have the Jews the Talmud.
@@SalvusGratiumFidem Dude before you criticize the books of others have a good look at your own religious book. It claims that an illegitimate person jesus who's mother was a whore was born of a virgin who had relations with G-D while she was betrothed to another man. This is completely pagan in influence so perhaps you should shut up about Judaism being influenced from Babylonian religion.
Ironically I can never find a copy to read it , why it's so secret ? What's in it to make it so secret?
A set is hundreds of dollars and sold in most Jewish book stores around the world
Read "The Talmud Unmasked". You will understand why it is hard to acsess for non-Jews. It really opened my eyes to why this people act as they do.
It condones adultery as long as it is not done with another jew. All sorts of weird stuff is in that book
@@cb6163 No wonder they are like that. If neuroticism and double standards was a religion....
@@Willy_Tepes Some of them let the Rabbis circumcise their babies by literally biting the foreskin off with their mouths. Some babies have contracted herpes due to this practice
The tosafists often dispute the opinion of Rashi. Also, whereas Rashi attempts to give a concise explanation of the text, the tosafists are more concerned with resolving additional questions or resolving apparent contradictions between different statements in the Talmud.
"3 years old and 1 day...."
@@MiloSatori that’s a misquotation btw
Yeah, sickening. But Woody Allen would be all for it.
@@af5000what’s the more accurate quote then?
@@PinchTheBarbif a woman had not joined the tribe by the time she had turned 3 years and 1 day, she and a priest would not be allowed to marry.
Easily debunkable, this passage is referring to the law of dowries, thus, they are still entitled to marry a high priest as they are still a virgin.
Keep it coming. I love this
You got it!
@@jfender8023 “Yeshuah” in what you’re quoting is in the feminine…not the masculine. Go learn Hebrew first before you make another fool of yourself.
@@christo-chaney - Making fools of themselves is the only thing Christianists excel at.
I read that one Rabbi said: "If the Gentiles knew what we teach about them (in the Talmud) they would hunt us down and kill us." A great introduction to this religion is the book" The Talmud Unmasked".
The Talmud Unmasked is a notorious antisemitic text. None of it is true. You are just another one spreading lazy antisemitism. Shame on you, lazy antisemite. 🤮
"The Talmud Unmasked" was written in the 19th century by an antisemitic priest who hated Judaism and who believed that Jews were drinking the blood of Christian children... And no, he had absolutely no idea what the Talmud was or how to read it! If you're a brainless antisemite who really hates Jews like he was, then this book is definitely for you!
very based
@@dat_berserk_gamer445__7 which verse
@@Leo-ii7bv Talmud doesn't have verses. your going to have to go to a archive and search for it by words used.
Correction to 2:50: Maimonides never wrote a commentary to the Talmud, Nachmanides did. Maimonides did comment on the Mishna though.
The Talmud is both the Mishna and the Gemara. But the Rambam also wrote a book about the Gemara, you can check out what survived here: tablet.otzar.org/book/book.php?book=378
Oh well.. Then technically you're right, he did write an unknown commentary that didn't spread and mostly lost. The choice to place Maimonides beside Rashi as a Talmud commentator still sounds strange to me, but at least not wrong and could be explained given his celeb status.
Thank you for sharing the word about Rambam's Talmud commentary!
(As to his Mishna commentary, it wouldn't make him Talmud commentator, since Mishna without Gemara isn't really Talmud. You wouldn't call R. Ovadia of Bartinoro a Talmud commentator, would you?)
A whole lot of nothing in this video.
One of the Jewish books, novels, novelties, stories, writings, texts, textings, scrolls, scollings, scripts, and scriptures
She makes it sound like the Talmud is like the best thing ever and it’s so positive that they reading he Talmud
Better than reading your bogus Quran and horrific Hadith... That's for sure!
@@GPBKM listen, I'm not Muslim myself(I'm Jewish) but perhaps you shouldn't be saying that, it's not so polite.
@@LakeTurtles, In the name of that Quran, millions of people have been slaughtered, and women are treated like objects! Not my problem if the truth hurts someone’s feelings… 🤷🏻♂️
In the name of Jesus Christ I pray for the Jews , at least the Jews for Jesus will be saved .
@@GPBKM dont worry about our women we treat them better than your $lutty Bikini Women, also Christians are statistically responsible for much more senseless deaths and violence than any other religion. Just look at ww1, ww2, the Spanish Inquisition, the colonisation of North America and Australia !
Very interesting! Where can I find the oldest book club online? Would love to learn together with others.
There are Daf Yomi groups all over the world. Just search "daf yomi [your location]" and you'll find a whole bunch
@@UNPACKED - Thank you!
Remember Sanhedrin 59a "A Goi who pries into the law is guilty of death.".
@@Willy_Tepes the goyim know, oh vey, shut it down.
Modern Talmudic Judaism is younger than Christianity/Catholicism. Judaism is a perversion and rejection of Jesus
"Reading one page a day" - the right word is learning one page a day.
Lebron is my dad
@@jfender8023 lol i think youre bible has some typos
@@jfender8023 I thought god was Yahweh?
not really. Jesus condemn Pharisees for doing commandment of man today as we look at this video. Talmud.
what Jesus want you and all people faithful with is. do Torah order.
because Talmud was born by human interpretation it considered like Apocrypha. not match with the original text.
@@endtimeslips4660 The Talmud is explaining the Mishnah and the Mishnah is explaining the Torah in short.
This should be called "How the Talmud is written" or "How the Talmud is structured"..
This is fantastically helpful, thank you so much
This book says we are cattle (farm animals) to be controlled by them
Where?
@@joshualeonpearl3724
"Even though God created the non-Jew they are still animals in human form. It is not becoming for a Jew to be served by an animal. Therfore he will be served by animals in human form."
"If you eat with a Gentile, it is the same as eating with a dog."
"The Jews are called human beings, but the non-Jews are not humans. They are beasts."
"The souls of non-Jews come from impure sprits and are called pigs."
@@PinemartenMusic Can you give references? I hear a lot of things about the Talmud but never get references
as it should, shabbat shalom goy
The Bible refers to us as sheep. And?
Maimonides didn't write a commentary on the Talmud. His main work is essentially a summary of the legal conclusion of the Talmud, but doesn't provide sources to where he derived those conclusions.
Maimonides said Africans were between human and ape.. I'm sure you know that because it's in his most well known work
@@malikialgeriankabyleswag4200 Based
@@mrpopo4294 No it's not based because they blamed it on white people after they did the slave trade using justifications from these books. It's just J-wish
@@malikialgeriankabyleswag4200 Lol. Many christians justified slavery of black slaves with colossians 3, 22
I wonder what they think of non-jews...
Much better than the thoughts of Muslims and Christians about Jews.
@@Jewish_Israeli_Zionist hahahahaha funny guy
Righteous gentiles have a place in the world to come.
(Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Hilchot Teshuvah 3:4 based on Tosefta Sanhedrin 13:1; Talmud Sanhedrin 105a)
It says (Job 37:23): "With justice and an a
bundance of kindness, He does not deal harshly." G-d does not withhold reward from gentiles who perform His commandments.
(Jerusalem Talmud Peah 1:1)
(Leviticus 18:5) "Which man shall carry out and by which he shall live." Rabbi Yirmiyah would say: We see from here that even a gentile who fulfills his laws is like a [Jewish] high priest....
(Midrash Sifra, Acharei Mot 9:13)
[Rabbi Akiva] would say: Beloved is man who was created in the divine image. An extra amount of love is given to him because he was created in the divine image as it says (Genesis 9:6) "For in the image of G-d He made man."
(Talmud Avot 3:14)
@@moses2031 You are speaking with a forked tongue
@@balocharyanwarrior5020 What a very intelligent response (not)
Amazing!!!
Amazing Dear
Thank you for this!
Great video, Soncino’s name would be pronounce Sonchino however, at least in standard Italian (Edit: however it would appear his name is written in Hebrew with a tsade שונצינו, so your pronunciation is correct!)
We were debating, since we know the town is pronounced "sonchino", but it seems like all talmudic experts pronounce his name with a tsade so that's what we went with.
Ha
Ok so if I wanted one “official” Talmud which one should I buy?
If you’re a goi will never get one
You'll only be able to get a fake copy nothing similar to the real
Artscroll are the most popular English translations from what I can tell (I'm a pretty religious Jew).
A detail swept under the rug: there are actually _two_ Talmuds, the Talmud Bavli (Babylonian Talmud) and the Talmud Yerushalmi (Jerusalem Talmud, also called the Palestinian Talmud). They're both written in Aramaic, but different dialects: the Bavli is written in Eastern Aramaic and the Yerushalmi is written in Western Aramaic, which are so different they can almost be called different languages.
Fun fact: while the Daf Yomi studies the Bavli, there is one tractate from the Yerushalmi that is part of the Daf Yomi cycle since it's missing from the Bavli.
I wouldn't call that a detail swept under the rug
The only average people (not great rabbis ) who learn yiroshalmi do it for hock
@Ploni Almoni they do in scholarly circles
“The Talmud was Palestinian” -Alternative Linda Sarsour
To what extent man goes to hear the devils words
Oral traditions of perversion, theft, murder, everything that the laws of God forbids in his Commandments
You are an antisemite. God has nothing to do with it.
Wow! What a scholar you are! Not.
All becomes legal by TALMUD, IS bibi applying on GAZA ??!!!
Excellent Job!!
Those CONFUSED WHITE PEOPLE are NOT JEWISH - they are KHAZARS & ZIONISTS who's parents, grand parents & great grandparents ARE from Poland & Germany. Within Judaism, there's a distinction between being ethnically Jewish (having ancestry from the Jewish people) and being a convert to Judaism (someone who chooses to follow the Jewish faith). I am Dominican - born in the Bronx, New York. I was raised Catholic. I took my Ancestry DNA in 2018 and discovered I was genetically Jewish. Then everything I read and studied about the 12 Tribes of Jacob, invasion of the Assyrians through the North and how the rest of the tribes escaped through the SOUTH and into Africa, years later came the Trans-Atlantic slave trade and so on. Negroes, Hispanics and Native Americans are the modern day descendants of ancient Israelites.
Sounds like you have an interesting story! But just FYI, the Khazarian theory is a dunked conspiracy theory: ua-cam.com/video/cw0G9COpeMY/v-deo.html Jews got to Poland and Germany because they were expelled there from Israel by the Romans.
Wicked things about Jesus are written in the Talmud
Give a quote and site the book, chapter and verse
@kooda Bro lol you can’t just site an entire chapter. Which verse do you have a problem with? That would be like saying Deuteronomy 2. You have got to be more specific.
@kooda Bro 105A has nothing to do with Jesus and even if it did what is it to you internal Jewish debate??
"The Talmud" is not one book made by a single author. The compilation happened for centuries. And it's not even canonical doctrine, but debate. If there's something bad about it, is everything in it bad as well, including all the people that wrote it and their relatives? It's like saying because one poem is bad from a compiled anthology of Greek poems, all Greek poets were inartistic, and ergo, all Greeks are ugly and vulgar. See, it doesn't follow at all.
In addition, it has never been completely ascertained that "Yeshua," which occurs more than thirty times was actually "Jesus." Yeshua was a very, very common name, as well as "Mariam." The accusation is not well founded AT ALL.
@@erlinacobrado7947 the thing is, it lines up w what the Rabbis believe today. I know about the curse word name used for Jesus Yashka. They dont call him Yeshua because they reject him. You can’t fool me with your coincidence talk.
this is like nested discussions on a reddit thread. THIS i can relate
Take our upvote.
@@UNPACKED Hi unpacked, do you think you could also make a video debunking myths about the Talmud? For example: people say the Talmud says you can deceive a non-Jew(which is just not true. It never says you can do that) they also say that the Talmud says that non-Jews are not humans(again, not true. Most likely based on a misinterpretation or just a thing made up by anti-semites to make Jews look bad) and much more. No one has done a video yet about this so I was wondering if you could? With the rise of antisemitism worldwide, I feel like a video like this is somewhat crucial.
sometimes there is reason for antisemitism. I dont know if those reasons are good or not. @@LakeTurtles
salaam,
a sincere query
do you, in your Religious Book
a Verse that is similar
to a Verse from the Al Quran?
bismAllah
لْ اَتٰى عَلَى الْاِنْسَانِ حِيْنٌ مِّنَ الدَّهْرِ لَمْ يَكُنْ شَيْـًٔا مَّذْكُوْرًا
Is there not a period of time
when each human
is nothing yet
worth mentioning?
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
Has there come upon man,
a period of time
when he was not a thing mentioned?
- Saheeh Quran
Quran 76:1
salaam
Amazing 🙏❤
Important topic and great execution, thank you!
evil it is evil you liars
You too
No cookonging on sabbath or basking how do you stay fed how do you keep from being starving to death?
You are supposed to prepare food before. Also you are allowed to violate the Sabbath if you are in mortal danger.
Had to watch this for my class and did not learn much about the Talmud lmao
Very little about what it says
1:26 as Jews began to migrate?? What happened to the other 12 tribes?
We all know that when the Assyrians destroyed Samaria in 733 BC. The Jews, Levites and Benjamin had long moved to Jerusalem. So if the Jews migrated, where did the other 12 tribes migrate to?? Remember God did not allow His tribes to intermarry or share their blessings.
So by this logic somewhere on this planet are another 60, 70, 80 perhaps 100 million Israelites
Atlease 700mil, due to israel not judah(jews) being called fruitful and forget for a reason where they then moved out to Europe and across the Middle East, therefore Europeans, Turks, Arabs and the Israelites if not Hispanics too
Look at the blessings given by God to the various tribes and see who today holds that identity.
Thou shalt be called great. Thou shalt be a company of nations. Thou shalt possess the gates of your enemies. I will bless them that bless thee.
Who else but Protestant western Europe and UsA/ commonwealth.
Is not the British the same as Ish Brit,- man of the covenant!
They moved across the fertile crescent, and into what is today know as Africa, they would become Beta Yisrael (mostly Dan), The Zulu (mostly Gad), and peoples such as the Igbo, Yoruba, and Ashanti; the Lemba Tribe of Mozambique serve as proof that the Northern Kingdom dispersed into that region. The Southern Kingdom would also mostly disperse into Africa before being scattered to the four corners of the Earth via the colonial slave trades. They are still dispersed to this day and we are waiting for the Most High to regather them. Most people who call themselves Jewish today aren't even bloodline decendants of Ya`aqov (Jacob), in fact, they are most likely bloodline descendants of his twin brother Esau and of his grandson Amaleq. Don't let these people deceive you any further.
@@ahkwyatt8174arely any of these people carry the Y-DNA marker “J1” that was carried by Jacobs sons, which means they are not his descendants.
@@ahkwyatt8174were you perhaps kangz an sheeeit ?
is ben shapiro related to yehuda meir shapiro?
Probably not, since Shaprio (sometimes Shapira) is a pretty common Jewish last name.
@@UNPACKED thank you I didn’t know it was common im just learning a bit of other religious practices and books it’s really cool.
Thank you. Please teach me more? Is there an online location where I can tap into a daily reading of a page? 🙏
the book says to kill non-jews.
Sefaria.
"the Jewish Talmud", as opposed to someone else's Talmud?
Like saying a Jewish Synagogue.
Not everyone knows that the Talmud pertains to Judaism.
😁 It reminds me a Jewish Synagogue.
@James Coble They might have co-opted the term but there is still only Jews have formulated the Talmuds, Jerusalem and Babylonian.
The Koreans have their version of Talmudu
I think you have things in this video that are not exactly right. The tosfot said their own opinion on things in the Talmud.
Yes, they were providing their understanding and interpretations of the Talmudic text.
Thats why you shoul read the Quran. Final revelation. All the books before Quran have changed. Including Taurah, Talmud and bibles.
@@mohdnazirismail2024 how is the Quram the "ultimate source" when your book came about 500 years after the Judaic texts? The Quran has been "interpreted" by Islamic scholars with different end results. History behind the Quran tells a whole different story.
@@Mr82Peluche Read. You will know. Do it
@@mohdnazirismail2024 Quran is filled with blunders about biblical history and even basic beliefs of other people and scientific blunders. So no thanks.
I thought it was primarily rabbis who read the Talmud. I stand corrected.
You guys are doing great public education work with this channel.
Wow I have learned so much Gemara and never knew about all of this. I always wandered how the unique design of the Gemara came about. Great video yet again
Lmao
@@jfender8023 Talmud isn’t a cult. Spend some time researching the Talmud…meaning try reading a few volumes of the Talmud yourself and see what it says.
@@jfender8023 look up the actual definition of a cult. You’re accusing Jews of adding to Gods word but that’s exactly what Christianity does with the New Testament. And also none of those quotes exist in the Talmud. Most of those so called references not only aren’t volumes of the Talmud, but numerous ones don’t even exist at all…meaning the books you’ve named are nonexistent. Yore Deah isn’t a volume of the Talmud, nor is Hoshen HaMishpat, nor is Bamidbar Rabbah. None of them! You got this crap from an antisemitic website that made up these references that doesn’t exist.
@@jfender8023 do you even know what any of those texts are? My Talmud sets (got 3 of them) don’t need dusting off. I read a page of the Talmud front and back every day. How much of the Talmud have you read?
Does the Talmud not say that Goyim are cattle meant to serve the Jews? Does it not also contain blasphemies against Jesus Christ?@@christo-chaney
So what's written in the Talmud😂😅
Baba kamma 13a says jews can lie to non-jews
@@CCP-Lies No, it doesn't, as Chullin 94:5 says and Maimonides commentary to Kelim 12:7, it is forbidden to lie even to an idolatrous gentile.
Very informative, thank you!
Now where on the same pages about this. 😇
What does it say about Women not teaching or allowed to speak in the church..
The thing about women being silent in churches is a Corinthians verse. Jews disbelieve the New Testament.
Women not teaching I haven’t heard much about.
I am Muslims and read the talmud . I am offended when he said that Mary was unclean and Jesus he is hell burn in his fire . But in a other side he order Jews to respect Islam and his teachings
Polk Olkj hi I was wondering if that was like someone’s opinion in the Talmud?
@@triherh9373 Actually it wasn't an opinion. It was a statement and there were no disagreements which means all the Sages agreed. But many Rabbis today say that this story is not about Yeshu (Jesus) because it took place after the destruction of the second temple.
@Bronze Spectre Not really, it depends on many factors. People can stay decades in Gehinom. And it is very known between Jews that Yeshu is there until this day.
@Bronze Spectre I mean that because the story took place more than 50 years after Yeshu died, the one called Yehoshua HaNotzri in the Talmud may be someone else. Just someone with the same name from Nazareth.
@@davidcohenboffa1666 Very convenient..Actually it is indeed about jesus. It was censored in the middle ages to avoid persecution after authorities found out about this vile and horrific stuff about Jesus and Mary. So they had to change the time period and details and names so that it doesn't look too similiar.
Tossed out of hundreds of places throughout time.
The explanation is that these expulsions happen for no reason whatsoever and they have always been unfairly persecuted.
The reasonable explanation is that these expulsions happen because behavior becomes intolerable to their host.
We are living through a modern iteration of this historical pattern
Exactly. If you’re kicked out of every place you settle maybe you should ask yourself if you’re the problem
they said some stuff about gentiles because they were being oppressed by gentiles at that time that the Talmud was written so it may have made sense why they didn't think of them that highly
Absolutely true. Lending money to good Christian citizens and expecting to be repaid. Those insolent infidels. Then crying wolf when we justly cancel those debts. Their very existence is a breach of peace in civilized societies.
First, "out of every place" is simply not true. Jews have not been kicked out of the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, China, India, Georgia, and many other places.
Second, there is a very clear reason why. Because people are evil. I could write a lot more on this subject, but at the end it will boil down the same thing: people are evil. Just look in the mirror.
@@LakeTurtles it’s all part of the victimhood pattern
Why do you purposely crackle your voice?
This was very helpful. Short and to the point. Thank you
Yo I was there at Metlife when that happened!
Did you find Waldo?
@@UNPACKED I saw him there lol,
Comments on comments on comments, That's some comment-ception right there
That was actually quite fascinating. Other than being not Jewish, I don't think I'd be intelligent enough to study the Torah.
guys i'm in india, where can i buy authentic talmud?
As someone from India don’t bother with the Talmund go right to the source go to Aryan sun myths the origin
You will hate your own life after reading this sh*t
Scholarship, Debate, History, Memory, Community....what about Truth?
Be quiet and respect other people's religions. A lot of the things people say about the Talmud being racist is either a misinterpretation or something read out of context or something anti-semites made up to make Jews look bad.
They try their darndest to find truth. Some of the arguments in the talmud go on for pages.
@@LakeTurtles anti-semites can go to hell for all i care....im focused on Facts to uncover the Truth.
@@happypiano4810 i hope their premises are based on Fact and not Opinions. Thats a sure way to get misguided.
@@A.--.
As close as you can get with an oral tradition. The written tradition is significantly more accurate, and therefore debated less.
Old hebrew doesnt mean its dead
What did the Lord say about this?
Deuteronomy 4:2
2 Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you, neither shall ye diminish ought from it, that ye may keep the commandments of the Lord your God which I command you.
Revelation 22:18-19
18 For I testify unto every man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add unto these things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this book:
19 And if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book.
Ok so then why did christianity completely discard the Hebrew Bible and replace it with their new testament?
Talmud doesn’t add to the Tanakh, it seeks to explain how to apply it. Also your New Testament isn’t accepted in Judaism.
@@moses2031 We don’t discard it We literally read old Testament
@@moses2031What do you mean, we LITERALLY read and believe the old testament.. 😂
@@faithmgtow Yeah and how many commandments from the Torah do you follow? Almost all the commandments given by Moses in the Torah aren't followed by christians because they discarded the Torah in favor of believing in jesus. Just read your new testament:
For the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ (john 1:17)
By calling this covenant “new,” he has made the first one obsolete; and what is obsolete and outdated will soon disappear (hebrews 8:13)
For all who rely on the works of the law are under a curse... Clearly no one who relies on the law is justified before God (galations 3:10-11)
So this is equivalent to Islam's record keeping of hadeeth.
Like an elaboration/manual on what's instructed in the Torah/Quran.
Good to know my understanding of Judaism is not that bad.
Shalom/Salam.
It's a combination of ahadeeth, tafsir and stories of their scholars
It is more of a manual in fraud, lies, deciet and murder..
No not exactly
Hadiths are said by the Prophet (pbuh) only.
You mean after 100 A.D. You will never write Christ out of history.
Who cares? We still have more prosperity than your cult does.
Jesus is idolatry to Jews You don't say "100 years after Horus became king"
@@LakeTurtles Orthodox Jews go by their own calendar
@@MattHolstein for religious purposes? Yes. For everyday talk? Not so much and if they are doing a video like this for which the adience is non-Jews, then they use the normal calendar.
Did you know that the talmud gives an accurate number of stars in the universe in brachos part two in the beginning of the art scroll addition
That's pretty good. How did they verify this and are they correct?
Yes. I believe page 32B
@@alg11297 two different study's using a super computer in America and europe got similar numbers
@@TagMahirTzedek That's pretty good considering they thought there was 4 planets.
@@shlomeMendlovits What would that number be?
so how does ketuboth 11b fit into this?
❤anti Jesus Christ
It indicates that dowry should not be changed in the case of rape so long as the rape was before the woman was 3 years and 1 days
When Ketubot 11b says "it is nothing", it means not that it is permitted, but as it relates to the dowry, she keeps virginity, and for example, can marry a high priest, nonetheless it is forbidden elsewhere.
Even HaEzer 23:1 - He should not marry a girl who is unable to have children.
Yevamot 33b:12 - Seduction of a minor girl is considered rape.
Kiddushin 41a:8 - It is prohibited for a person to bethroth his daughter to a man when she is a minor.
Niddah 13b:5 - Those who play with children delay the coming of the Messiah.
Issurei Biah 21:18 - A man should not marry a minor who is not fit to give birth.
“CE” lol rough start
John 8:44
she has no idea there are 2 talmuds
What's the dead language again?
Aramaic (specifically Babylonian Aramaic).
Interesting. I have a book written in Aramaic and there are Aramaic speakers today I've Been Told.
Maimonides was SPANISH, from Córdoba
Yeah but then moved to Egypt and that’s where he wrote most of his work
التلمود ( مجموعة شراءع وسنن وتقاليد اليهود)
Hmm, I wonder what this scripture says about Jesus Christ. I’m sure they say nice things about him since the jewish people are God’s chosen people after all!
Your hero said nice things in John 8:44.
Nothing
@@Shmully nice one shmully
jewish lore be like
King Saint Louis IX pray for us and pray for the conversion of the jews. King Saint Louis IX thank you for your example of burning the blasphemous book that is the talmud.
Who is King Saint Louis IX?
the talmud is not blasphemous because blasphemy is beautiful, also this event never happened, and your profile picture is jewish
you left out all the intersting vesrse like
Kethuboth 11b: When a grown-up man has intercourse with a little girl it is nothing, for when the girl is less than this,6 it is as if one puts the finger into the eye. As the sight returns, so will her virginity return.
It is nothing, ONLY as it relates to marriage. This is still an issue.
As @happypiano4810 said, "it is nothing" within the context of 11b doesn't mean intercourse is permitted, it simply means she maintains virginity, nonetheless, it is forbidden, see below.
Niddah 13b:5:
Those who play with children delay the coming of the Messiah.
Yevamot 33b:12:
Seduction of a minor girl is considered rape.
Kiddushin 41a:8:
It is prohibited for a person to bethroth his daughter to a man when she is a minor.
Shulchan Aruch, Even HaEzer 23:
He should not marry a girl who is unable to have children.
So what is the ultimate purpose of the Talmud? What value does it add to one's spiritual growth? Does it help a person draw closer to or away from God? This is like the 3rd video I've watched & I still don't understand.
no it’s just a demonic book. I can explain to you in detail what’s in it if you want
if you read it trust me you would see it’s from the devil fully
The goal is to learn how to THINK about Jewish law. It generally does this through debate. It consists of a lot of:
Person A says: X. Person B says: Y. Person C asked person A: What is your reasoning for this? (Person A cites a verse). (Person B cites the same verse and explains that it means Y)…
If you want the general consensus on the law, you’d read something like the Tur, or the Shulchan Arukh. If you want the meat and bones of the law, you read the Talmud.
@happypiano4810 Sounds like a philosophical discussion. So is the Law that is being referred to in the Talmud from The Ten Commandments in the Book of Exodus or is this a different law that is not in the Book of Exodus?
@@lulukazhila6309All the laws given in the first five books of Moses (written law), and the explanations, safety fences, and decrees based on that law (oral law).
There is a Babylonian Talmud and a Jerusalem Talmud which one is more authoritive?.
Why werent they wearing mask?
Because in January 2020 COVID wasn't a thing yet in the US?
The shutdown happened 2 months after this event.
it s like a giant game of telephone
Talmud says in Messeched Megillah, page 6b, If a person says I have worked hard but have not found [success], don’t believe him. [If a person says] I have not exerted myself, and I have found [success], don’t believe him. [If he says] I gave it my all and I have found [success], believe him!
@@jfender8023 very little there r more and if u read that u will hate them
@@jfender8023 when I google “ereget Raschi Erod” I just find antis*mitic websites so I imagine that the book isn’t real. There is a website called sefaria that has the entire Talmud and that book isn’t there so you clearly have just made it up.
There is no book in the Talmud called Coschen Hamischpat either so you clearly again lying.
The schene Luchoth haberuth is an obscure Hebrew book from the 17th century and is not from the Talmud. The fact that you say page 250 b proves that the quote is false as each book page is individually numbered.
There is no book in the Talmud called “Jalkut Rubeni Gadol”.
Jebamoth 94b talks about marriage. It doesn’t say anything like what you are claiming it does. UA-cam isn’t letting me post the link but you can check on the sefaria website and see yourself that it doesn’t say that.
There is no book in the Talmud called “Jore Dea”
Sanhedrin 74b doesn’t say that. Once again I can’t post the link but you can check on the sefaria website and see that it doesn’t say that.
Sefer Ikkarim isn’t part of the Talmud. It is a totally separate book from the 15th century and it doesn’t say that.
Once again Coschen Hamischpat isn’t a real book.
Avodah Zara 4b doesn’t say that. You can check on the sefaria website.
"The Akum who are not enemies of us must not be killed directly, nevertheless they must not be saved from danger of death. For example, if you see one of them fall into the sea, do not pull him out unless he promises to give you money."
@@Willy_Tepes lol
they said some stuff about gentiles because they were being oppressed by gentiles at that time so it may have made sense why some of them didn't think of gentiles that highly
Very interesting and raises a lot of question what is the different between Talmud and Satanic verses of RASHID I can't understand the books that contains so much hate discrimination and racism
Huh? Rushdie's book Satanic Verses is a work of modern fiction and has absolutely nothing to do with Judaism. It is, in some ways, a commentary on Islamic culture, however.
Where did you get this strange idea?
@@RobespierreThePoof Got it through some strange beliefs and some strange behavior by some religious groups
You should watch this video: ua-cam.com/video/bOImkx2ecY8/v-deo.html
Unless our righteousness exceeded that of pharasees, we will not enter the kingdom of heaven. Amos 12:5...Matthew 5,6,7...1 John 4, revelations. Amos 5:12
Thanks! I'm developing a curriculum about the history of American Jewish community and red-lining. Would love to see a video about this!
very good and educational video
I don't know much about the Talmud, though some on UA-cam have given negative ideas in it. Definitely, there must be some truth, that would explain something of Talmud students attitude in a video. Some Christians were taking part in some walk with across. Students spit on the feet of Christians, as they were passing by. It's not anything to blame all with, yet, it is what it is.
You should watch this video: ua-cam.com/video/bOImkx2ecY8/v-deo.html
Revelation 3:9
Idol worshipping pagan
Perhaps before you push the diversity thing you should read what the Talmud actually says
@@jfender8023 that only applies to Jewish people by the doctrine of the author, sorry.
@@jfender8023 check the Hebrew word for “yeshuah” and you’ll see that it’s grammatically feminine…not masculine.
@@jfender8023 I happen to know Hebrew. Grammatically the word “yeshuah” is feminine. Check any Christian book on learning Hebrew and you’ll see it.
@@jfender8023 look it up in the Brown Driver Briggs Hebrew lexicon. It’s a Christian publication. It says that “Yeshuah” is a noun and feminine.
@@jfender8023 actually I do know Hebrew and I’ve even taught classes on it. I lead services regularly at my synagogue and we use Hebrew language n every service. When I read a Jewish text I read it in the original Hebrew or Aramaic. There is no evidence that Jesus was ever called “Yeshua” in his life. It’s a made up Hebrew name that Messianic Christians came up with in the 60s & 70s in an attempt to convert Jews to Christianity.
Since when is Hebrew a dead language?
Aramaic is the dead language, but also Hebrew was considered a dead language (a language that "no longer has a community of native speakers" even if it's used by people - like Latin) until it's revival about 100 years ago.
We actually read about that as well - and even there it is mentioned that while it was used to help Jews from different countries communicate, neither side was a native speaker.
The definition of a dead language is not that it is wiped from the world - Latin is plenty dead but there are plenty of people who can speak it. It's that there are no communities of native speakers. Hebrew was used almost exclusively for religious purposes, and those Jews that wrote the letters in the Genizah of Cairo probably didn't speak it amongst themselves.
That's the article we read :)
I think she was talking about the Aramaic which dominates the Talmud.
@@UNPACKED Aramaic/ Syraic is still spoken though in syria in the christian village of maloula.
Ah interesting.
Avraham, your father, was glad that he would see my day; then he saw it and was overjoyed.”
“Why, you’re not yet fifty years old,” the Judeans replied, “and you have seen Avraham?” Yeshua said to them, “Yes, indeed! Before Avraham came into being, I AM!” At this, they picked up stones to throw at him; but Yeshua was hidden and left the Temple grounds.
Yeshua is the messiah
Jesus answered, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. (john 14, 6)
vs
I am the LORD, that is My name;
I will not yield My glory to another,
Nor My renown to idols. (Isaiah 42, 8)
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. (john 1, 1)
vs
Thus said the LORD, the King of Israel,
Their Redeemer, the LORD of Hosts:
I am the first and I am the last,
And there is no god but Me. (Isaiah 44, 6)
I and the Father are one.” (john 10, 30)
vs
To whom can you compare Me
Or declare Me similar?
To whom can you liken Me,
So that we seem comparable? (Isaiah 46, 5)
Calling him Yeshua or the New Testament BRIT CHADASHAHAHAHSHAHAHAH is not going to convince Jews. Seriously stop coming on Jewish videos to missionize. It is not our fault that Jesus didn't meet the blatant Messianic requirements.
@@BarHawa What are the "blatant messianic requurements,"
@@ahkwyatt8174 Being an actual descendant of King David who restores the Jewish nation altogether and brings peace to the whole world while fathering children of his own. Not a godman who asks people to drink his blood
I am a Christian that has always been fascinated by the Hebrew roots of Christianity!
He is calling you a field slave and cow
@@JoeMama-wl7hn no he’s calling him a “worshipper of stars” which is what akum actually means because christianity is considered an idolatrous religion in Judaism
If you want to know of the Hebrew roots of Christianity, read the Torah, which is the old testament of the Bible. the Talmud is wicked....here are some quotes "Sanhedrin 106a, says Jesus' mother was a whore: "She who was the descendant of princes and governors played the harlot with carpenters." Also in footnote #2 to Shabbat 104b it is stated that in the "uncensored" text of the Talmud it is written that Jesus mother, "Miriam the hairdresser," had sex with many men. "Jesus was a bastard born of adultery." (Yebamoth 49b, p.324). "Mary was a whore: Jesus (Balaam) was an evil man." (Sanhedrin 106a &b, p.725). "Jesus was a magician and a fool. Mary was an adulteress". (Shabbath 104b, p.504)."
@@missrose1654 First of all, the Talmud is talking about 3 different jesus’s that lived around a century before the jesus of the New Testament lived, the ones in the Talmud were all executed by the Sanhedrin and the Sanhedrin were not able to give the death penalty during the roman occupation, 2nd, even if the Talmud was talking about your jesus, the New Testament makes him look wayyyy worse than the Talmud does, examples of this include when he stole food on Shabbat, when he allowed his disciples to steal food, when he tried to make excuses for breaking Shabbat, because not only did he steal by picking crops from that farmer’s field when it was not even the time of year for gathering but he also broke the law that says you’re not supposed to harvest on Shabbat because it’s working, then he open carried the food, he also addressed his mother as “woman” which is very disrespecful in almost every culture and back then you could be stoned for rebelling against your parents, according to Matthew’s gospel, jesus was descended from the wicked king jeconiah, I don’t know if you’ve read Jeremiah or not but it says that God cursed Jeconiah’s family and all of his descendents are BANNED from ever taking the throne of Israel, then there was the failed prophecy he made about the Temple’s destruction of “not one stone will he left on top of the other”, well the Muslims built two structures on the temple mount after he said that so there’s stones still standing on top of the other, according to christianity jesus was sinless because he never had sex in his life and remained unmarried, this is a HUGEEE sin in Judaism because the Torah says “be fruitful and multiply” so if he never had a wife and children that alone is a very big sin. Christianity’s roots are not Hebrew at all, they are pagan and greco-roman
@@themosinguy6508 wow. Thank you for clarifying what Jewish people really think of Christianity. Now I understand the hatred that Jewish people felt towards me when I was in Israel. I for one would never hesitate to break the Sabbath if it means saving a person's life. Btw, I know and you know the Jesus that is being referred to in the Talmud is Jesus Christ of Nazareth.
Video title: What is Written in the Talmud ? Video awnser: The talmud has this layout because of: ..... Thank you for not awnsering the basic question.
Maybe this video will answer it: ua-cam.com/video/bOImkx2ecY8/v-deo.html
Genesis 1:27-28 So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.
And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.
The Talmud is one shady book
Give a specific quote that you have a problem with and site the exact location of this quote in the Talmud. If you can’t do this then you obviously don’t know what you are talking about.
It’s not even A book
@@abg44 Based
@@slev6592 he gave you specific references, aren't you going to answer?
@@abg44 when I google “ereget Raschi Erod” I just find antis*mitic websites so I imagine that the book isn’t real. There is a website called sefaria that has the entire Talmud and that book isn’t there so you clearly have just made it up.
There is no book in the Talmud called Coschen Hamischpat either so you clearly again lying.
The schene Luchoth haberuth is an obscure Hebrew book from the 17th century and is not from the Talmud. The fact that you say page 250 b proves that the quote is false as each book page is individually numbered.
There is no book in the Talmud called “Jalkut Rubeni Gadol”.
Jebamoth 94b talks about marriage. It doesn’t say anything like what you are claiming it does. UA-cam isn’t letting me post the link but you can check on the sefaria website and see yourself that it doesn’t say that.
There is no book in the Talmud called “Jore Dea”
Sanhedrin 74b doesn’t say that. Once again I can’t post the link but you can check on the sefaria website and see that it doesn’t say that.
Sefer Ikkarim isn’t part of the Talmud. It is a totally separate book from the 15th century and it doesn’t say that.
Once again Coschen Hamischpat isn’t a real book.
Avodah Zara 4b doesn’t say that. You can check on the sefaria website.
Jesus Christ loves you
John 8:44 exemplifies his love.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Yes the pharisees where children of the devil He exposed them for the hypocrite they where
Clearly he doesn't love people very well then.
Pretty good but I recommend studying the 5th chapter of Tanya with an Orthdox Rabbi to understand more about what Torah study is.Also do more research on the events leading up to the giving of the Torah.They already knew all 613 well before,so why the need for all the fireworks?
2711 whole complete pages of the Talmud , reading a page each following day. But they still missed WHO is the ONE TRUE HOLY ALMIGHTY ETERNALLY LOVING AND LIVING MOSCHIACH. WE DO NOT READ ISAIAH 53 ( THE SUFFERING SERVANT = ( YESHUA SEH HAELOHIM )AND CALLED IT - THE FORBIDDEN CHAPTER. BUT WHY? Is there something VERY INTERESTING OR VERY DANGEROUS IN ISAIAH 53?.. DAF YOMI HOPEFULLY INCLUDING THE WHOLE HOLY BRIT HADASHA TOO. TODAH RABAH RUACH HAKODESH. SHALOM ALEICHEM SHALOM
There is nothing forbidden about Isaiah 53. Any copy of the Tanakh will have it included. The suffering servant is not Jesus it is the Jewish people.
@@slev6592 So the jewish people were bruised and pierced for "inequities" of the world when the same jewish people are described as deaf and sinful in isaiah?? There are two suffering servents talked about in Isaiah. One a sinful plural jewish nation as a whole then a singular individual who was bruised and pierced for the inequities of others. Read it again.
@@alangervasis look at the context of Isaiah 53. Read Isaiah 52 and 54. It is clearly talking about the Jewish people. The Tanakh often refers to the Jewish people in singular. As well as this there is plural used in Isaiah 53.
Isaiah 53 is actually discussed in the Talmud so I'm not really sure where you got the myth of the "forbidden chapter" from.
@@alangervasisI don’t see the contradiction. We were sinful, so we were punished for our sins. Also, we can be talked about in singular. For example, any time we are called Jeshurun.
The talmud was written by the hearts of desperately wicked men which is now called rabbinical Judaism. Jesus said Beware of the traditions of men in the wisdom of this world that comes to nothing in the end. Much like Catholicism with their catechism which is not scriptural, nor is it biblical. In the talmud carrying the writings of the Kabbalah of Jewish mysticism which is also witchcraft condemned by Moses. Overall, Beware of the worldly religions of the world that reject Christ and the writings of the Apostles in the doctrine of the Apostles which coincides perfectly with the Prophets who wrote the Tanaka and the writings of the New Testament by the apostles. One day every knee will bow and every tongue will confess Yeshua hamashiach.
Do you wanna explain what the Talmud says about Christians??
exactly, they are always so secretive about it when talking to gentiles.
nothing bad about them, jews invented christianity so why would they hate their children?
@@NBrioDaZueraRules Judaism is a rejection of Jesus.
@@oswaldm6035 jesus followed judaism nevertheless, early christianity was a sect of judaism and not a seperate religion like it would later become, also your profile picture proves you're gay
@N. Brio Da Zuera old testament Hebrewism and modern day Judaism are historically, biblically, and genetically disconnected from one another. Judaism started after the destruction of the temple in 70ad. Also just because i think the good guys lost ww2 doesnt make me gay
These people are dangerous. But time is on THEIR side. Not ours.
Would you mind explaining what you mean by that?
Avinu revealing the Stars to one Man within the promise gifted us with a trail of star dust greater than all the sands of the earth,we just have to find the ones that become pearls and it takes our whole existence to search with that kind of Love a more perfect one that we can even fathom. Torah is eternal and mankind is finding that out. Let’s hope we take enough time to do Teshuava.
Evil