Al moses, I love your videos, I've been watching almost ALL your videos for quite some time now, the questions you shed into light and the way you answer them through the quran in the most beautiful way, you've literally shed light into my miserable of a brain full of questions and doubts about the Islamic concepts and Ahadith, even tho I used to LOVE the stories of the prophet and wanted to be like him, I started questioning all of it as my consciousness began to grow in my late teenage years, being a 19yo in university, your videos have really given me a new perspective of the quran and it's meaning, forever grateful for your content, I will make it my life's mission to spread the true Quranic message of greater purpose into the world no matter how hard it seams, as the truth should never be hidden, it has been due long (almost 1200 years) that the true teachings of the quran have been hidden, in shorter words, thank you for your content and wisdom
جناب مؤسس بھا ی آداب۔ آپ کے سمجھانے کا بھت اچھا طریقہ ھے قران میں۔ ایک تذکرہ ھے گدھا اور طعام 100 سال گذر گے۔ اس پر بات کرتے تو ھمارے علم میں اضافے ھو گا۔ ایاز احمد۔ لاڑکانہ سندھ پاکستان
Assalamualaikum W Rahmatullahi W Warrakatuh.Aap ka Bahut Shukriya. Allah Subhan Taaala ka Bahut Bahut Shukriya. Allah Subhan Taaala. AAP ko sahatmand aur salamat rakhe. Aami
Very important topic outstanding explanation thanks for clearing misconception misinterpretation created by anti Qur'aan internal and external forces and incompetent scholars
Dear Moses,don't be reluctant,u may carry on your journey on way to Allah.its really blessing,like u people r doing jahaad.u will face abnoxious firqabaz,musrik,kafir etc.Very few people will acknowledge your efforts.its very difficult to preach true teachings in our society.Majority of people r indulged in rawayaats,concocted lies stories in the name of nabi,without knowing,confirming its authenticity.Mullah jahil n firqabaz r main tools,who dont't know Quranic hadith in the main stream.Allah bless u more.We were doing same practices before n following jahilliyat made concepts but understanding of Quran made us think,what r true teachings of Allah.
بالکل درست کوئی بھی مذہب ہو لیکن عمل قرآن پر عمل ہے تو وہ مسلمان ہے ۔ زیادہ تر احادیث میں وہی روایات ہیں جو توریت اور زبور کی ان کتابوں سے لی گئی۔ جو اصل سے ہٹ کر ان کتا بوں سے لی گئیں ۔جو انہوں نے خود مرتب کیں ۔جیسے ہماری روایتیں اور حدیثیں جو انسانوں نے لکھیں ۔ اللہ کی کتاب اور پیغام شروع دن سے ایک ہی ہے ۔
Hi Moses ! It would be interesting if you elaborate about Tauheed, Major Sins, Nikkah, talaq, adoption, Judgment day, Life after death concepts in the the holy Quran.
Asal Islam ke dushman ye nahin chahtay keh Sirf Allah ki Kitab par amal kia jaye. Un ke liye Quran bahut mushkil he awr os ko samajhne ke liye ghair Allah ki zaroorat he. Allaho Akbar wa lillahil hamd.
Junaid Al Baghdadi’s famous saying, “ If you understand the concept that water takes on the color and shape of the receptacle, you will understand a lot.”
اللّہ ﷻ محمدﷺ کے خاتم الانبیا۶ کے بارے قرآن میں کیا فرماتے ہیں؟ آپﷺ کی حیات طیبہ میں آپ نے جو احکامات فرماۓ ان پر عمل پیرا ہونے کے لۓ کیا اور کیسے کیا جاۓ !؟ اس ویڈیو کو اس موضوع پر آخری ویڈیو اس لۓ نہ کہیں کیوں کہ تشنگی برقرار رہتی ہے اور جینوئین سوالات کی گنجائش ہمیشہ رہتی ہے ۔
براہ راست اور بالواسطہ ایمان میں قرآن کیا فرق بتاتا ہے ؟ کسی نے قرآن کبھی نہیں پڑھا یا دیکھا لیکن اس نے فطرت اور امن پر زندگی گذاری ہو موت کے بعد وہ جنت میں ہو گا !؟
Reasons in not understanding the statement regarding Deen in Asian subcontinent especially india and pakistan etc is 1) sharp children goes to school for future to become doctors, engineers, adminstrator etc 2) very low level children goes to madrassa to learn Islam. Result sheet is clear what will be output.....❓
Mashah allah from my teen age year I had the same thinking and finally Allah made me meet you and listen to someone highly qualified saying what I was saying long ago to my friends and family but no one listened now I have more confidence yes Quran is only source to be followed anything else is jus historical book one thing I like to mentioned if you could help me understand is Wudu that is mentioned in Quran that you said it is not for body cleaning but Rashad Khalifa who I first listened regarding follow only Quran he said on his the great debate that wudu in Quran mentioned 4 parts and today Muslim are doing almost 10 parts and he is an Arab from Egypt and also a Phd how come he did not say that this wudu is not about cleaning body he just mentioned that Allah said 4 parts only and people are doing 10 parts so they are listening to someone else please clarify if he did not mentioned correctly check his video I am sure you must have seen his video if not check Rashad Khalifa the great debate thank you
@khalidhafeez6968 Read on Quran Thinkers website about Ghusl: the word Ghusl, Aughselu, is normally translated as washing, or cleaning or taking a bath, which is a wrong translation. The word is used in Quran in a much broader sense with much in-depth meanings of cleaning, cleansing, or removing the impurities mentally, spiritually and allegorically rather than restricted to physical cleansing only, basically in terms of removing the impact of Khutuwaat of Shaitaan
Salaam my Brother! Although my understanding in Urdu very very limited, still tried to follow with the slide, I must say it is absolutely clear to me we all should follow only one Book that is Quran. What I am also clear Allah created mankind, definitely gave (Day-1) a manual instructions which is Deen: “System of Life”. Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alaameen.
I have a genuine question about the transmission of the quran, the way the quran was transmitted was through mass spread and through memorization, and as you said the prophet wrote it at the time too, so if the quran has its own "lisan" (although I don't completely understand the term itself) the spelling and "zer zabbar" of the letters, shouldn't it be in the same "lisan" as the quraish at the time? Even if it was revealed to the prophet in the quran's own "lissan" through wahi, how would the written form be different from the "lisan" of the quraish at the time at the time when it was revealed to the prophet?
@@AlMosesPhD AoA moses, I read the book and I absolutely loved it, I really wanna get more of these types of sources of knowledge for me to understand the history of the quran, the authenticity, the "miracale-ness" etc but I also want books and sources to know how the hadith/traditional accounts/fusha/9th century banu abbasid court has potentially corrupted the true message/meaning of the quran, I really wanna cross check your positions and claims with sources and books but idk where to find them, help me out, give me sources or books to read, through which how you've developed your understanding of the Quran. Thank you.
Salamun Alaikum, I'm pretty sure that the Quran was revealed in the language/dialect of the Prophet Mohammad. May it be the Quraish dialect or any other dialect of the region/community. Certainly, Allah would not have introduced a new language or dialect otherwise, it would have been a very difficult task for the Prophet and the Sahaba to learn and spread the message of the Quran. Still watching your informative podcast in bits and pieces. Will continue to watch until the end, as this topic is close to my heart. Quran is all we need, and it is mentioned in several verses that, it is complete and detailed. "No ifs and buts"
SA, If it was in the quraish's dialect, then per the Quran's testimony, they shouldn't have struggled to understand its terms / vocab. There's plenty of research on it and I'll leave it at that
@@peace4us lissan of Arab means locution of Arab not language, there are many instances when the Arabs didn't understand what the messenger said even in the Qur'an for example , they didn't even know what ar rahman means there weren't many new words in the Qur'an that the Arabs were totally unaware of
@@UALIS123 He revealed it in his style, if you read the Quran, sorry can't remember the verses but it references a people ( quraish ) who exclaimed who is Rahman ! They knew Arabic but we're using the labels of Allah incorrectly, in English we use the word Gay to mean homosexual but it's original meaning is a happy person So the Quran was revealed in a clarification of the language
Assalamualaikum w Rahmatullahi W Warrakatuh. AlMoses Sahab . Aap ka Bahut shukriya. Allah ka Bahut Bahut Shukriya. Allah ne AAP ko jo ईलम ata kiya hai . Uska faida aqal wale Insan hamesha hasil karte rahenge aur Aap ki aur Aap ki family ki salamati aur Sahat ki dua Allah se Iltiza karte rahenge. I am Subedar Nafees Ahmad, Rtd. Bareilly.UP. India
عبادت اس حکمت میں ہے جو نبی کریم ص ہر نازل ہوئی اور جیسے انھوں نے کی۔ قرآن کہتا ہے کہ تمھیں حج کے دن معلوم ہیں۔ تو یہاں قرآن اس سنت یا روایت کو درست قرار دے رہا ہے جو کسی معدی کتاب کے لکھے بغیر رائج تھی۔ لیکن ہر روایت حدیث درست بھی نہیں۔ اور ہے حدیث یا روایت درست بھی نہیں۔ قرآن کے بعد سب سے قوی علم سنت سے ملتا ہے ۔ لاکھوں سالوں سے انسان علم نسل در نسل سنت کے ذریعے منتقل ہونے والے عمل سے گزرا ہے۔
موسی صاحب ! آپ کی اس موضوع پربقول آپ کے آخری ویڈیوہے جسے مجھے چھ ماہ بعد اتفاقأ دیکھنے کا موقع ملا ہے کئی جائزسوالات پوچھنے کا مجھے حق حاصل ہے ۔ وہ میں آپ سے اخلاق کے دائرے میں رہتے ہوۓ گاہے گاہے پوچھنے کی جسارت کرتا رہوں گا ۔
This informal way of speaking, i loved it so much... in my humble opinion keep some stuff like this comming people might be able to relate and understand more, also if possible make clips from long form videos to make your message massy.
Frankly, I liked it too. Hence, will try out this livestream way of talking instead of pre-recorded videos which take too much time. Also, good suggestion re short clips: will cut some out from here
Yes. One such ayah قُلْ أَيُّ شَيْءٍ أَكْبَرُ شَهَادَةً ۖ قُلِ اللَّهُ ۖ شَهِيدٌ بَيْنِي وَبَيْنَكُمْ ۚ وَأُوحِيَ إِلَيَّ هَٰذَا الْقُرْآنُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِ وَمَن بَلَغَ ۚ أَئِنَّكُمْ لَتَشْهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ اللَّهِ آلِهَةً أُخْرَىٰ ۚ قُل لَّا أَشْهَدُ ۚ قُلْ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَٰهٌ وَاحِدٌ وَإِنَّنِي بَرِيءٌ مِّمَّا تُشْرِكُونَ ﴿١٩﴾ Say, “What thing is more solemn in testimony?” Say, “God is Witness between you and me. This Quran was revealed to me, that I may warn you with it, and whomever it may reach. Do you indeed testify that there are other gods with God?” Say, “I myself do not testify.” Say, “He is but One God, and I am innocent of your idolatry.” 6:19
@@AlMosesPhD Thanks Moses bhai. This does clarify that the Quran was revealed to Nabi Muhammad. However, it doesn't explicitly say whether it was the ONLY thing revealed to him. What I'm trying to understand is: Was the explanation of the Quran also revealed to the Messenger which he then used to walk (follow) the talk (Quran)? Or was he using his own intellect and reasoning to make out the meaning of the message (Quran) while delivering it. I would appreciate your further advice. Thanks.
He was a nabi. He used his intelligence to 'apply' the Quran. It's the same job for us too. We will never know the prophet's understanding just as I cannot even guess what my wife is thinking / understands.
How can I catch your live sessions? I'd like to talk to you. Do you not believe that you are taking the allegory thing a bit too far? How many months is Hajj? Which months are they? What is your understanding of the verse where Allah says that He created the sun as a diya and moon as nur so we can calculate the years? Al Islam is not a name for a religion in the Quran.
اس دلیل کے مطابق: (اِتَّبِعُوا مَا اُنْزِلَ اِلَيْكُمْ مِنْ رَبِّكُمْ وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا مِنْ دُونِهٖ اَوْلِيَاءَ قَلٖيلًا مَا تَذَكَّرُونَ 7/3) قرآن خود ہی غیر اللہ کی غیر نازل حدیثوں سنتوں کی کتابوں کا منکر ھے - ھم تو قرآن کے پیچھے پیچھے چلنے والے ہیں۔
As u said current translation of Quran happened after 200 years of Mohammed I wonder which translation of Quran sahaba or others followers were following between the era of Mohammed to bani unmuay or banu Abbas’s Please clarify in detail Thanks
Quran says that it’s made simple by design for everyone to understand. then why the first few generations didn’t completely comprehend some of the aspects of the Quran.
So We have made this (the Qur’an) easy in your own tongue, only that you may give glad tidings to those who have Taqwa and warn with it the most quarrelsome people.” Surah Maryam (19:97) This is) a Book which We have sent down to you, full of blessings, that they may ponder over its Ayat, and that men of understanding may remember.” Surah Saad (38:29), And We have indeed made the Qur’an easy to understand and remember; then is there anyone who will remember” Surah Al-Qamar (54:17)
A Book, whereof the verses are explained in detail;- a Qur’an in Arabic, for people who understand. The Qur’an; 41:3 Verily, We have made this (Quran) easy, in your tongue, in order that they may give heed.” The Qur’an 44:58
@@snh4753 19:97 where is the Quran? Brackets are not a translation. 41:3 talks nothing of making it easy/simple 16:89 al-kitab is not the Quran. And either way, even that is not called 'simple' there
asalam alikum ...kia aap ny quran ka tarjuma kia hai? 2..arab k loog hamosh hain na tu wo quran par kaam karty hain aur sirf wo karty hain jo hukumat ki traf sy ho .aisa kun hai ?
कुरान में चार जगह ये बताया गया है की तू मुहम्मद को कैसे पहचानोगे उसकी पहचान बताई गई है।चारों जगह मुहम्मद अर्थात प्रशंसित व्यक्ति की विशेषता को बताया गया है।
AL Moses you have analytical, inquisitive mind and excellent critical thinking. Muslims following blindly so called hadees and distorted stories as narrated by illiterate Maulana, Maulvis. If we try to understand Quran we will be close to Allah Subhawatala.
Also laughed pretty hard when you raised the concerned questions such as "shirt kaise pehnna hai, haath konsa andhar dalna hai, konsa bahir nikalna hai, toilet mai pani na ho toh pathar kahan se lana hai, ghaas agar na ho toh patta kitna lamba hona chahiye"🤣 it's just the way you said it 😂 and the absurdity of the questions themself
Mai Quran sekh raha hu to Mera sawal hai Muhammad bin Abdullah ko kis buniyad par mai manu. Mai Kai logose kahta hu aap ka konsa firqa hai vo kahte hai Sunni to Mai kahta hu Quran me firqa parsti haram hai our ayat number bhi batata hu. Quran ke buniyad par kahta hu firqa parsti haram hai to aap kis buniyad par kahte ho ki Muhammad bin Abdullah the? Batai ye. muze aapse koi jhagda nahi hai aap Quran ke student hai isliye puch rahahu
Quran talks about the nature of man. It kind of puts a mirror in front of you and display’s your hidden flaws and man being man and created weak is reluctant to accept that. And thus in a way tries to sugarcoat the harsh realities. Peace.
Mohammad saw,,Deen e Ibrahim follow krte the,iska hukm Allah SWT,ne khud Mohammad saw ko diya,,, Mai , alhamdollilah Khud Deen e Ibrahim ko follow krta hu Deen Mohammad saw ki hayat tak mukammal tha,ye hi quran jo kaakaz me nahi thi,insano ne kagaz pe likhi Allah ne to mind yani dimag me utara Mohammad saw ke,,jo ham tak isi quran ki shakl me moujood hai Quran ka kram yani sequence Allah SWT ka hi hai Kyoki 2 ri sura me Allah khta ki ,, is jaisi koi 1 sura bana lawo Fir 11 hud me khta hai ki Is jaisi koi 10 sura bana lawo Yani 11 sura ho chuki thi Allah Hafiz 🌹
Outstanding Janaab Mosa Saheb. I fear you are in danger if you are in Pakistan please take care of yourself and your family. Apko Munker e Hadees aor Kuch aor ghalat elzaamaat Laga kr 😅😅😅😅 Ser yun se judda walon se galiyaan khaney ko tayeyaar ho jayein😂😂😂😂. Allah Rehem karey.. best wishes and Regards. ✅💯✅👍
Jisme aadab hi nahi woh hi saitan ka flower hai 💐 rasool alehis Salam bashar nahi qair ul basher hai saitan tumhara Khula dusman hai khabardaar hojao aqal Teri sifer hai ishq mera samshir hai 💐ya ali madad
Mohtram Musa sahib Whatever you are saying makes great sense and is very rational approach I am however a bit confused with regard to your idea about the Quranic language ( you say it is unique and was perhaps unfamiliar among the receiving groups / Qabail ) We must understand that language normally has a lot to do a lot , with the culture and the background of the receiving end / group / community It is important for any language used for communication purpose to enable receiving of information at the receiving end and there should be enough arrangements at the receiving end to receive the information in closest possible way so to successfully transmit the set of information into the receiving arrangement in best possible way . Otherwise if the releasing mechanism is unique and unfamiliar to the entire receiving end and adequate arrangements are not made then the objectivity of transfer of information will remain futile I am sure God must have made enough arrangements for such transfer of information for the people it really meant If for the last 1200 years humanity remained unaware / ignorant despite God’s initiative of sending the great information for liberating humanity then are the masses sitting at the receiving end responsible for this disaster / lack of communication and for their sufferings as during this period they remained sufferers due to their ignorance
Ghalib wrote in his time, yet his 'lisan' / style was different from others. Quran is that + 100 times to any other form of Arabic. Hopefully it makes sense
@@AlMosesPhD ASA Thing is that I am very convinced that the traditional translations in light of concocted literature has certainly distracted the Devine intents and made us totally handicapped to receive information in the purest form But again we don’t have intuitive qualities to understand this alien language despite desperation to understand Please educate us the best way to understand if we have to elevate ourselves from the norms of available dictionaries and literature My confusion stays 🙏🏻
@@AlMosesPhD Thanks for sparing your valuable time to respond to my question I have read somewhere I think Allama GA Parwaiz has mentioned which was quite convincing though , to understand what he mentioned requires elevation to somewhere close to his level. He mentioned that God has made arrangement to preserve not only Quran but its intent also. He mentioned that the literature available in prose remains subject to change over time in history due to many influences which affects the languages such as political objectives , influences of cross cultures due to cross migrations etc over time but it’s the Quslity of Poetry that if any subject is present in poetry then it remains frozen over time. It’s the unique poetic balance that keeps language intact. One can’t drop a letter or will make the poetic balance disordered Arbiun Mobin was the language of poetry of that time and was present among the culture of Northern Arab Qabail It is still there in those Qabail in the form of poetry There are 7 dictionaries compiled based on that language of Arab Qabail which have driven meanings from that poetic language / language of Qabail which he termed as the Qursnic language His great compilation “ لغت القرآن “ is perhaps based on those meanings I have tried to understand quranic intents using his lughat and found very satisfactory results I could feel things started shaping up in rational way Need to know your point of view also on this. I will highly appreciate if you could spare little more time to provide some guidance in this regard
aapko yaqeen nahi aayega mein Kuch maulavi Jo Hadiths ko dhal banake literally nafrat fela rahe hai unko jab meine logically bas puchha ki Quran mein toh Hadiths Ka naam nahi hai toh hadiths manna kaha se farz hai aur logo ne jo behave kiya bata bhi nahi sakti log matlab Allah ki qitab ko insano ki likkhi qitabo se compare karte hai I mean kya ye shirk Nahi ki aap actually Allah se zyada uske banai insano ko zyada tawajju de rahe hai?
Sa Mosa bhai aapne kaha quran har zmane ke logo ke liye tha he or rahega me sahi smjha hu na bataye kahi aapne dhoke yani galti se to nahi kaha jwab de plz ?
@@AlMosesPhD hm phir uska kya jo quran ne kaha , waiz aataina mosal kitab wal furkan laallakum tahtadoon, ke hamne di Mosa ko kitab or furka taki tum hidayat pao
![[ English ] Atheists' 10-Critical Questions about GOD & Religion ! Answered By Engineer Muhammad Ali](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ze95k0VqsM8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ English ] Atheists' 10-Critical Questions about GOD & Religion ! Answered By Engineer Muhammad Ali](/img/tr.png)
اللہ 1 نبی 1 قران 1 پھر مسلمان میں اتنا تضاد کیوں آج۔ سمجھ آئی بردر شکراٗ من القلب ❤❤❤
Al moses, I love your videos, I've been watching almost ALL your videos for quite some time now, the questions you shed into light and the way you answer them through the quran in the most beautiful way, you've literally shed light into my miserable of a brain full of questions and doubts about the Islamic concepts and Ahadith, even tho I used to LOVE the stories of the prophet and wanted to be like him, I started questioning all of it as my consciousness began to grow in my late teenage years, being a 19yo in university, your videos have really given me a new perspective of the quran and it's meaning, forever grateful for your content, I will make it my life's mission to spread the true Quranic message of greater purpose into the world no matter how hard it seams, as the truth should never be hidden, it has been due long (almost 1200 years) that the true teachings of the quran have been hidden, in shorter words, thank you for your content and wisdom
Keep learning my brother
جناب مؤسس بھا ی آداب۔ آپ کے سمجھانے کا بھت اچھا طریقہ ھے قران میں۔ ایک تذکرہ ھے گدھا اور طعام 100 سال گذر گے۔ اس پر بات کرتے تو ھمارے علم میں اضافے ھو گا۔ ایاز احمد۔ لاڑکانہ سندھ پاکستان
You are the first person who talks about Islam and makes sense to me . Thank you for your efforts ❤
Shukrya
اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو سلامت رکھے آپ بالکل سچ فرما رھے ھیں للہ آپ کی حفاظت فرمایں
Shukrya Zakaria bhai
@@AlMosesPhD
Sir kiya aap ka Quran pak ka tarjuma mil sakta ha?
@@AlMosesPhDBrother i couldn't join you on twitter
i want to know your books name & translation of Quran
i want to see my son like you ❤
app bilkul sach farma rahey hen ki quraan samajhna ek processes hi hey day by day
Mind blowing discussion ♡♡♡ very informative sir 👌
Thanks KS
Ma sha Allah! Excellent. Learned a lot. Bus ye batayein ap ne kaha mein shair bhi ban gya tha… apka dil toota tha kya? 😂😂😂
Mai Quraan Kareem ke haqayek ke khilaafwali sab hadisoka inkaari hu.
👍
Wonderfully Explained MahaAllah
Shukrya
Kya Muhammad bin Abdullah bhi riwayati nahi hai. Quran me to sirf Muhammad hai
Beautiful. Thanks.
Assalamualaikum W Rahmatullahi W Warrakatuh.Aap ka Bahut Shukriya.
Allah Subhan Taaala ka Bahut Bahut Shukriya.
Allah Subhan Taaala.
AAP ko sahatmand aur salamat rakhe.
Aami
You are the voice of thousands and thousands, though silent does not mean they are not there, so carry on carry on!
thanks brother
1:00:02 imam malik zumah ki namaz nahi padte the to rafranc to sher karaine take log padh sake
Very important topic outstanding explanation thanks for clearing misconception misinterpretation created by anti Qur'aan internal and external forces and incompetent scholars
Sir kiya aap ka Quran pak ka tarjuma mil sakta hai ?
I agree with you
Vast majority of us stand on the shore and are in awe of Ocean’s vastness and beauty and praise it’s Creator in an indirect way. Very few dive in.
I want to participate on your online live.please provide your link..
Assalamoalekum sir
Allah Aap ko Salamat Rakhay Aameen.
Aaki baaten bohat mudallil aur behtreen hen ...aur bohat Acchha kaam kar rahay hen ...
Sir this topic is not available within your other videos
SA. What do you mean?
السلام علیکم
بھائی جان میں آپکی باتوں سے اتفاق کرتا ہوں ۔
SA, alhamdulillah
Keep it up bro
Good work❤❤❤
Dear Moses,don't be reluctant,u may carry on your journey on way to Allah.its really blessing,like u people r doing jahaad.u will face abnoxious firqabaz,musrik,kafir etc.Very few people will acknowledge your efforts.its very difficult to preach true teachings in our society.Majority of people r indulged in rawayaats,concocted lies stories in the name of nabi,without knowing,confirming its authenticity.Mullah jahil n firqabaz r main tools,who dont't know Quranic hadith in the main stream.Allah bless u more.We were doing same practices before n following jahilliyat made concepts but understanding of Quran made us think,what r true teachings of Allah.
Nahi musha aap bahut achche Kam kareahe ho Allah pak aap ko khairofiddin se nawaje
بالکل درست کوئی بھی مذہب ہو لیکن عمل قرآن پر عمل ہے تو وہ مسلمان ہے ۔
زیادہ تر احادیث میں وہی روایات ہیں جو توریت اور زبور کی ان کتابوں سے لی گئی۔ جو اصل سے ہٹ کر ان کتا بوں سے لی گئیں ۔جو انہوں نے خود مرتب کیں ۔جیسے ہماری روایتیں اور حدیثیں جو انسانوں نے لکھیں ۔
اللہ کی کتاب اور پیغام شروع دن سے ایک ہی ہے ۔
God Bless man.
Hi Moses ! It would be interesting if you elaborate about Tauheed, Major Sins, Nikkah, talaq, adoption, Judgment day, Life after death concepts in the the holy Quran.
Asal Islam ke dushman ye nahin chahtay keh Sirf Allah ki Kitab par amal kia jaye. Un ke liye Quran bahut mushkil he awr os ko samajhne ke liye ghair Allah ki zaroorat he. Allaho Akbar wa lillahil hamd.
Sirf dushmin nahi, aam logon ke zehan mein bitha dya gaya hay kya Quran kafi nahi.
Junaid Al Baghdadi’s famous saying, “ If you understand the concept that water takes on the color and shape of the receptacle, you will understand a lot.”
اللّہ ﷻ محمدﷺ کے خاتم الانبیا۶ کے بارے قرآن میں کیا فرماتے ہیں؟
آپﷺ کی حیات طیبہ میں آپ نے جو احکامات فرماۓ ان پر عمل پیرا ہونے کے لۓ کیا اور کیسے کیا جاۓ !؟
اس ویڈیو کو اس موضوع پر آخری ویڈیو اس لۓ نہ کہیں کیوں کہ تشنگی برقرار رہتی ہے اور جینوئین سوالات کی گنجائش ہمیشہ رہتی ہے ۔
Dear Mosa, you are very hard working and literate. You are an eye opener. Now, its upto us all if we take advantage or not.
Thank you.
We all have the source--much better if we all read it properly
Wondherful wizahat Dr mosa Allah karey zoray bian aur ziada
shukrya
براہ راست اور بالواسطہ ایمان میں قرآن کیا فرق بتاتا ہے ؟ کسی نے قرآن کبھی نہیں پڑھا یا دیکھا لیکن اس نے فطرت اور امن پر زندگی گذاری ہو موت کے بعد وہ جنت میں ہو گا !؟
Reasons in not understanding the statement regarding Deen in Asian subcontinent especially india and pakistan etc is
1) sharp children goes to school for future to become doctors, engineers, adminstrator etc
2) very low level children goes to madrassa to learn Islam.
Result sheet is clear what will be output.....❓
That's a sadly accurate observation
Agreed with both
Mashah allah from my teen age year I had the same thinking and finally Allah made me meet you and listen to someone highly qualified saying what I was saying long ago to my friends and family but no one listened now I have more confidence yes Quran is only source to be followed anything else is jus historical book one thing I like to mentioned if you could help me understand is Wudu that is mentioned in Quran that you said it is not for body cleaning but Rashad Khalifa who I first listened regarding follow only Quran he said on his the great debate that wudu in Quran mentioned 4 parts and today Muslim are doing almost 10 parts and he is an Arab from Egypt and also a Phd how come he did not say that this wudu is not about cleaning body he just mentioned that Allah said 4 parts only and people are doing 10 parts so they are listening to someone else please clarify if he did not mentioned correctly check his video I am sure you must have seen his video if not check Rashad Khalifa the great debate thank you
@khalidhafeez6968 Read on Quran Thinkers website about Ghusl: the word Ghusl, Aughselu, is normally translated as washing, or cleaning or taking a bath, which is a wrong translation. The word is used in Quran in a much broader sense with much in-depth meanings of cleaning, cleansing, or removing the impurities mentally, spiritually and allegorically rather than restricted to physical cleansing only, basically in terms of removing the impact of Khutuwaat of Shaitaan
Salaam my Brother! Although my understanding in Urdu very very limited, still tried to follow with the slide, I must say it is absolutely clear to me we all should follow only one Book that is Quran.
What I am also clear Allah created mankind, definitely gave (Day-1) a manual instructions which is Deen: “System of Life”.
Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alaameen.
Salam, you've got it right
Salaam Brother! Is there any opportunity to have Bangla translation on your display please?
Any contact details please? (Email or WhatsApp)
@@MegaKahmed Salam, sorry I don't know Bangla.
If someone can translate, then I can add them as subtitles.
al.moses.phd@gmail.com
I have a genuine question about the transmission of the quran, the way the quran was transmitted was through mass spread and through memorization, and as you said the prophet wrote it at the time too, so if the quran has its own "lisan" (although I don't completely understand the term itself) the spelling and "zer zabbar" of the letters, shouldn't it be in the same "lisan" as the quraish at the time? Even if it was revealed to the prophet in the quran's own "lissan" through wahi, how would the written form be different from the "lisan" of the quraish at the time at the time when it was revealed to the prophet?
The Quran's Arabic isn't / wasn't ever spoken / used by any group of people.
Read Dr Ahmed Basssam Sai's book 'Miracle'
@@AlMosesPhD AoA moses, I read the book and I absolutely loved it, I really wanna get more of these types of sources of knowledge for me to understand the history of the quran, the authenticity, the "miracale-ness" etc but I also want books and sources to know how the hadith/traditional accounts/fusha/9th century banu abbasid court has potentially corrupted the true message/meaning of the quran, I really wanna cross check your positions and claims with sources and books but idk where to find them, help me out, give me sources or books to read, through which how you've developed your understanding of the Quran. Thank you.
Salamun Alaikum, I'm pretty sure that the Quran was revealed in the language/dialect of the Prophet Mohammad. May it be the Quraish dialect or any other dialect of the region/community. Certainly, Allah would not have introduced a new language or dialect otherwise, it would have been a very difficult task for the Prophet and the Sahaba to learn and spread the message of the Quran.
Still watching your informative podcast in bits and pieces. Will continue to watch until the end, as this topic is close to my heart. Quran is all we need, and it is mentioned in several verses that, it is complete and detailed. "No ifs and buts"
SA,
If it was in the quraish's dialect, then per the Quran's testimony, they shouldn't have struggled to understand its terms / vocab.
There's plenty of research on it and I'll leave it at that
@@AlMosesPhD I won't agree at this point, as it makes no sense that Allah will reveal his scripture in some unknown language or dialect
@@UALIS123 اللہ تو کہتا ہے کہ وہ قوموں کی طرف نبی بھیجتا ہے ان کی اپنی زبان سے ۔ آپ کی بات درست ہے۔
@@peace4us lissan of Arab means locution of Arab not language, there are many instances when the Arabs didn't understand what the messenger said even in the Qur'an for example , they didn't even know what ar rahman means there weren't many new words in the Qur'an that the Arabs were totally unaware of
@@UALIS123
He revealed it in his style, if you read the Quran, sorry can't remember the verses but it references a people ( quraish ) who exclaimed who is Rahman ! They knew Arabic but we're using the labels of Allah incorrectly, in English we use the word Gay to mean homosexual but it's original meaning is a happy person
So the Quran was revealed in a clarification of the language
Quran didn’t mention name musolman. Quran has said Muslim. We have named ourself musolman like yahud .
sir. aap ne salat par bahotsi aaya ke zarye se bataya phir bhi sala clear nahi ho rahi kya hai
koyi jaldi nahi.
ayaton pe dobara ghor karain, aur tafakkur karain
ماشاءالله بہت ہی بہترین بیان کیا ❤
shkrya
Allah S.W.T ka rasool Mohammad hai jo kisi ka baap nahi hai
Quran ki talawat aap kijuban achcha lagta hai musha bhay
Imaam malik jumah ki agar nz maz nahi padte the to rafranc sher please
Assalamualaikum w Rahmatullahi W Warrakatuh.
AlMoses Sahab .
Aap ka Bahut shukriya.
Allah ka Bahut Bahut Shukriya.
Allah ne AAP ko jo ईलम ata kiya hai . Uska faida aqal wale Insan hamesha hasil karte rahenge aur Aap ki aur Aap ki family ki salamati aur Sahat ki dua Allah se Iltiza karte rahenge.
I am Subedar Nafees Ahmad, Rtd. Bareilly.UP. India
Shukrya Subedar sahab
i want your take on word namaz and roza i mean the history of these terms.
السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ
سر آپ سے ڈارئیکٹ میسنجر پر کیسے بات ہو سکتی ہے ۔ میں پاکستان سے ہوں
SA,
al.moses.phd@gmail.com
خشیت اللّہ سے انسان کیا مراد لے ؟
Wow .bs wow .lajawab..pata nahi musalmn kb ilm sikhenge...abhi to sara ka sara islam hi ulat hai
apni aulad say start karna best hay
پلیز جواب ضرور دیں ۔رہنمائی کی بہت ضرور ت ہے ۔
بہت عرصہ سے جو کچھ میرے ذہن میں تھا اسے آ پ نے زبان دی
Kya jawab
Assalamo Alykum,
Janab aapki kawishein bht achi hain,
Phir hum Ibadat kese krein
SA, channel pe 'ibadat' pe video dekh lijyay
عبادت اس حکمت میں ہے جو نبی کریم ص ہر نازل ہوئی اور جیسے انھوں نے کی۔ قرآن کہتا ہے کہ تمھیں حج کے دن معلوم ہیں۔ تو یہاں قرآن اس سنت یا روایت کو درست قرار دے رہا ہے جو کسی معدی کتاب کے لکھے بغیر رائج تھی۔ لیکن ہر روایت حدیث درست بھی نہیں۔ اور ہے حدیث یا روایت درست بھی نہیں۔ قرآن کے بعد سب سے قوی علم سنت سے ملتا ہے ۔ لاکھوں سالوں سے انسان علم نسل در نسل سنت کے ذریعے منتقل ہونے والے عمل سے گزرا ہے۔
Salam sir ap ka bayan AS Ansari say bohat milta hai i like u
موسی صاحب ! آپ کی اس موضوع پربقول آپ کے آخری ویڈیوہے جسے مجھے چھ ماہ بعد اتفاقأ دیکھنے کا موقع ملا ہے کئی جائزسوالات پوچھنے کا مجھے حق حاصل ہے ۔ وہ میں آپ سے اخلاق کے دائرے میں رہتے ہوۓ گاہے گاہے پوچھنے کی جسارت کرتا رہوں گا ۔
Aap ne lafz ba lafz saari baaten sahi ki hen . Baaqi insaan bashar hay kahin ghalati ho gai ho may be possible...
plane, building, computer etc bananeki formula kon tikab me likkha hey. firbito Bana kese. akal se.
"جو رسول اللّہ آپ کو دیں وہ لے لو اور جس چیز سے منع فرمائیں اس سے بعض آ جاؤ " اسے کیسے سمجھیں ؟
Puri ayat parhain. Then us kay aglay aur pichli wali bhi
This informal way of speaking, i loved it so much... in my humble opinion keep some stuff like this comming people might be able to relate and understand more, also if possible make clips from long form videos to make your message massy.
Frankly, I liked it too.
Hence, will try out this livestream way of talking instead of pre-recorded videos which take too much time.
Also, good suggestion re short clips: will cut some out from here
Hi Moses bhai. Does the Quran explicitly say that Nabi Muhammad was ONLY given the Quran to follow/understand the deen? Appreciate your advice.
Yes.
One such ayah
قُلْ أَيُّ شَيْءٍ أَكْبَرُ شَهَادَةً ۖ قُلِ اللَّهُ ۖ شَهِيدٌ بَيْنِي وَبَيْنَكُمْ ۚ وَأُوحِيَ إِلَيَّ هَٰذَا الْقُرْآنُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِ وَمَن بَلَغَ ۚ أَئِنَّكُمْ لَتَشْهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ اللَّهِ آلِهَةً أُخْرَىٰ ۚ قُل لَّا أَشْهَدُ ۚ قُلْ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَٰهٌ وَاحِدٌ وَإِنَّنِي بَرِيءٌ مِّمَّا تُشْرِكُونَ ﴿١٩﴾
Say, “What thing is more solemn in testimony?” Say, “God is Witness between you and me. This Quran was revealed to me, that I may warn you with it, and whomever it may reach. Do you indeed testify that there are other gods with God?” Say, “I myself do not testify.” Say, “He is but One God, and I am innocent of your idolatry.” 6:19
@@AlMosesPhD Thanks Moses bhai.
This does clarify that the Quran was revealed to Nabi Muhammad.
However, it doesn't explicitly say whether it was the ONLY thing revealed to him.
What I'm trying to understand is: Was the explanation of the Quran also revealed to the Messenger which he then used to walk (follow) the talk (Quran)?
Or was he using his own intellect and reasoning to make out the meaning of the message (Quran) while delivering it.
I would appreciate your further advice.
Thanks.
He was a nabi. He used his intelligence to 'apply' the Quran.
It's the same job for us too.
We will never know the prophet's understanding just as I cannot even guess what my wife is thinking / understands.
@@AlMosesPhD That makes total sense. Thanks again.
How can I catch your live sessions? I'd like to talk to you.
Do you not believe that you are taking the allegory thing a bit too far?
How many months is Hajj? Which months are they?
What is your understanding of the verse where Allah says that He created the sun as a diya and moon as nur so we can calculate the years?
Al Islam is not a name for a religion in the Quran.
اس دلیل کے مطابق: (اِتَّبِعُوا مَا اُنْزِلَ اِلَيْكُمْ مِنْ رَبِّكُمْ وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا مِنْ دُونِهٖ اَوْلِيَاءَ قَلٖيلًا مَا تَذَكَّرُونَ 7/3) قرآن خود ہی غیر اللہ کی غیر نازل حدیثوں سنتوں کی کتابوں کا منکر ھے - ھم تو قرآن کے پیچھے پیچھے چلنے والے ہیں۔
👍👈
As u said current translation of Quran happened after 200 years of Mohammed
I wonder which translation of Quran sahaba or others followers were following between the era of Mohammed to bani unmuay or banu Abbas’s
Please clarify in detail
Thanks
I don't get into history, for reasons mentioned in this vid
Yes
bhai if u can further deliberate on the language of Quran plz.farrukh
Quran says that it’s made simple by design for everyone to understand. then why the first few generations didn’t completely comprehend some of the aspects of the Quran.
Where does it say that brother?
Read that ayah v closely
So We have made this (the Qur’an) easy in your own tongue, only that you may give glad tidings to those who have Taqwa and warn with it the most quarrelsome people.” Surah Maryam (19:97)
This is) a Book which We have sent down to you, full of blessings, that they may ponder over its Ayat, and that men of understanding may remember.” Surah Saad (38:29),
And We have indeed made the Qur’an easy to understand and remember; then is there anyone who will remember”
Surah Al-Qamar (54:17)
A Book, whereof the verses are explained in detail;- a Qur’an in Arabic, for people who understand. The Qur’an; 41:3
Verily, We have made this (Quran) easy, in your tongue, in order that they may give heed.” The Qur’an 44:58
And We have revealed the Book to you explaining clearly everything, and a guidance and mercy and good news for those who submit. The Qur’an 16:89
@@snh4753 19:97 where is the Quran? Brackets are not a translation.
41:3 talks nothing of making it easy/simple
16:89 al-kitab is not the Quran. And either way, even that is not called 'simple' there
خاتم النبیین مُحَمَّدُﷺ کے بارے آپ کی پوزیشن کیا ہے ۔
Prophet Muhammad was the last prophet for bani Israel but was a rasool for the followers of the Quran.
Does jinn aspartate creatures
Salat k sisale ki last video ka lonk send kr dain Mosa bhai
It should be the latest video if you sort by it
عزت مآب جناب موسی صاحب جس طرح آپ قرآن پاک سمجھا رہے ہیں میں اپنی کم عقلی سے سمجھ رہا ہوں
Where in Quran is it written that this Book was GIVEN to Muhammad s.a?
I've talked about the historicity and importance of history throughout the video.
The gentleman with this strange claim, I find no evidence for it.
asalam alikum ...kia aap ny quran ka tarjuma kia hai? 2..arab k loog hamosh hain na tu wo quran par kaam karty hain aur sirf wo karty hain jo hukumat ki traf sy ho .aisa kun hai ?
Salamun alaikum, mein na tarjma kya hay na irada hay.
Arab kay log bhi Quran pe buhat kaam kar rahay hain.
Musa Sahab Agar yah Arabi change hai to aapki samajh mein Kaise a rahi hai
Quran Kay words ko khud Quran mein istimal kartay dekh kar
@@AlMosesPhD o thik
कुरान में चार जगह ये बताया गया है की तू मुहम्मद को कैसे पहचानोगे उसकी पहचान बताई गई है।चारों जगह मुहम्मद अर्थात प्रशंसित व्यक्ति की विशेषता को बताया गया है।
کیا وہ جو دین اسلام اور دین قرآن کو نہ سمجھ پاۓ مگر اللّہ سے توبہ و استغفار کرتا رہےتو قرآن میں اللّہ اس بارے کیا فرماتے ہیں ؟
Quran mein Jo Islam btya gya hai woh bhut simple hai like don't tell lie ,respect parents etc y sub Kuch hai bus aur kiya
Walikum Assalam
SA
Good work
Dear Moses, thanks for the detailed discussion. Some people argue that ahadith provide context to the Quran, what do you think? Thanks.
Thanks. I've put my view clearly on role of hadith in the video
سب روایات کے منکر ہیں... قرآن مجید کی تعلیمات سے فیضیابی حاصل کرنے والا آیت کا منکر نہیں ہے....
100%
Qur'an has its own lexicon.
AL Moses you have analytical, inquisitive mind and excellent critical thinking. Muslims following blindly so called hadees and distorted stories as narrated by illiterate Maulana, Maulvis. If we try to understand Quran we will be close to Allah Subhawatala.
Also laughed pretty hard when you raised the concerned questions such as "shirt kaise pehnna hai, haath konsa andhar dalna hai, konsa bahir nikalna hai, toilet mai pani na ho toh pathar kahan se lana hai, ghaas agar na ho toh patta kitna lamba hona chahiye"🤣 it's just the way you said it 😂 and the absurdity of the questions themself
Mai Quran sekh raha hu to Mera sawal hai Muhammad bin Abdullah ko kis buniyad par mai manu. Mai Kai logose kahta hu aap ka konsa firqa hai vo kahte hai Sunni to Mai kahta hu Quran me firqa parsti haram hai our ayat number bhi batata hu.
Quran ke buniyad par kahta hu firqa parsti haram hai to aap kis buniyad par kahte ho ki Muhammad bin Abdullah the?
Batai ye. muze aapse koi jhagda nahi hai aap Quran ke student hai isliye puch rahahu
Jawab isi video mein hay.
Agar aap ko sahih nahi laga, to woh apka haq hay.
Assalaamualayekum Wa Rahmatullah Are you a student of Dr Hany?
Salamun alaikum, no but I respect his methodology and ilm.
Quran talks about the nature of man. It kind of puts a mirror in front of you and display’s your hidden flaws and man being man and created weak is reluctant to accept that. And thus in a way tries to sugarcoat the harsh realities. Peace.
وہ انسان جو ناخواندہ ہوں یا وہ لسان پر عبور نہ رکھتے ہوں اللّہ کی نظر میں دنیا اور خصوصأ برزخ اور حشر و آخرت میں ان کی کیا حیثیت ہو گی ۔
Salamunalikum
Mohammad saw,,Deen e Ibrahim follow krte the,iska hukm Allah SWT,ne khud Mohammad saw ko diya,,,
Mai , alhamdollilah
Khud Deen e Ibrahim ko follow krta hu
Deen Mohammad saw ki hayat tak mukammal tha,ye hi quran jo kaakaz me nahi thi,insano ne kagaz pe likhi
Allah ne to mind yani dimag me utara Mohammad saw ke,,jo ham tak isi quran ki shakl me moujood hai
Quran ka kram yani sequence Allah SWT ka hi hai
Kyoki
2 ri sura me Allah khta ki ,, is jaisi koi 1 sura bana lawo
Fir 11 hud me khta hai ki
Is jaisi koi 10 sura bana lawo
Yani 11 sura ho chuki thi
Allah Hafiz 🌹
Outstanding Janaab Mosa Saheb. I fear you are in danger if you are in Pakistan please take care of yourself and your family. Apko Munker e Hadees aor Kuch aor ghalat elzaamaat Laga kr 😅😅😅😅 Ser yun se judda walon se galiyaan khaney ko tayeyaar ho jayein😂😂😂😂. Allah Rehem karey.. best wishes and Regards. ✅💯✅👍
Paras'taare Ahaadees aur
Muhaddiseen:
Bukhari wa Muslim aur deegar shakhsee'yaat ke muqallid Log,
Jihaalat_bhari GUMRAAHI ka shikaar hain.
Yeh Naa_cheez unko
MUNKARe_QUR'AAN samajhtaa hai.
Ji haan, munkir Quran aik apt description hay
Brother Mosa! I slute to you. May Allah bless you.
Shukrya
Ap ko kon si ayat say pta chala k Nabi Muhammad munafqeen me ghiry how thy.
Or kesy pta chsla k Nabi Muhammad k Walid ka Nam Abdullah tha?
Salam,
Dekyay 'Kya mein Quranist hoon? Munkiri hadith?' apnay jawab ke lyay
i have not seen your video on saum
Jisme aadab hi nahi woh hi saitan ka flower hai 💐 rasool alehis Salam bashar nahi qair ul basher hai saitan tumhara Khula dusman hai khabardaar hojao aqal Teri sifer hai ishq mera samshir hai 💐ya ali madad
Ap faut shuda say madad lo gay, Allah say nahi?
Quran parhain.
Mohtram Musa sahib
Whatever you are saying makes great sense and is very rational approach
I am however a bit confused with regard to your idea about the Quranic language ( you say it is unique and was perhaps unfamiliar among the receiving groups / Qabail )
We must understand that language normally has a lot to do a lot , with the culture and the background of the receiving end / group / community
It is important for any language used for communication purpose to enable receiving of information at the receiving end and there should be enough arrangements at the receiving end to receive the information in closest possible way so to successfully transmit the set of information into the receiving arrangement in best possible way . Otherwise if the releasing mechanism is unique and unfamiliar to the entire receiving end and adequate arrangements are not made then the objectivity of transfer of information will remain futile
I am sure God must have made enough arrangements for such transfer of information for the people it really meant
If for the last 1200 years humanity remained unaware / ignorant despite God’s initiative of sending the great information for liberating humanity then are the masses sitting at the receiving end responsible for this disaster / lack of communication and for their sufferings as during this period they remained sufferers due to their ignorance
Ghalib wrote in his time, yet his 'lisan' / style was different from others.
Quran is that + 100 times to any other form of Arabic.
Hopefully it makes sense
@@AlMosesPhD
ASA
Thing is that I am very convinced that the traditional translations in light of concocted literature has certainly distracted the Devine intents and made us totally handicapped to receive information in the purest form
But again we don’t have intuitive qualities to understand this alien language despite desperation to understand
Please educate us the best way to understand if we have to elevate ourselves from the norms of available dictionaries and literature
My confusion stays 🙏🏻
@@hh-10000 We have talked about this. 'Quran kese samjhain' ye vid dekhyay
@@AlMosesPhD
Thanks a lot. The video is very useful and provides the required guidance with clarity. I am grateful from the depth of my heart
@@AlMosesPhD
Thanks for sparing your valuable time to respond to my question
I have read somewhere I think Allama GA Parwaiz has mentioned which was quite convincing though , to understand what he mentioned requires elevation to somewhere close to his level. He mentioned that God has made arrangement to preserve not only Quran but its intent also.
He mentioned that the literature available in prose remains subject to change over time in history due to many influences which affects the languages such as political objectives , influences of cross cultures due to cross migrations etc over time but it’s the Quslity of Poetry that if any subject is present in poetry then it remains frozen over time. It’s the unique poetic balance that keeps language intact. One can’t drop a letter or will make the poetic balance disordered
Arbiun Mobin was the language of poetry of that time and was present among the culture of Northern Arab Qabail
It is still there in those Qabail in the form of poetry
There are 7 dictionaries compiled based on that language of Arab Qabail which have driven meanings from that poetic language / language of Qabail which he termed as the Qursnic language
His great compilation “ لغت القرآن “ is perhaps based on those meanings
I have tried to understand quranic intents using his lughat and found very satisfactory results I could feel things started shaping up in rational way
Need to know your point of view also on this. I will highly appreciate if you could spare little more time to provide some guidance in this regard
قرآن فہمی میں کئی سوالات پیدا ہوتے ہیں جن کے جوابات آپ سے متوقع ہیں ۔
allah awr uske rsool ki ataat kro
if u say that this language is neither of badoos/quresh etc then how the Quran was understood by ppl of that time if it was not their language.farrukh
aapko yaqeen nahi aayega mein Kuch maulavi Jo Hadiths ko dhal banake literally nafrat fela rahe hai unko jab meine logically bas puchha ki Quran mein toh Hadiths Ka naam nahi hai toh hadiths manna kaha se farz hai aur logo ne jo behave kiya bata bhi nahi sakti log matlab Allah ki qitab ko insano ki likkhi qitabo se compare karte hai I mean kya ye shirk Nahi ki aap actually Allah se zyada uske banai insano ko zyada tawajju de rahe hai?
Apka kam message puhanchana hay, behas baray behas nahi
Sa Mosa bhai aapne kaha quran har zmane ke logo ke liye tha he or rahega me sahi smjha hu na bataye kahi aapne dhoke yani galti se to nahi kaha jwab de plz ?
Har zamanay kay lyay hay
@@AlMosesPhD sa mera matlab he Nabi Mohammad se pehle or bad wale sabhi logo ke liye
Kyoki is bat se ye sabit hota he ke quran hamesha se he ya kuch yun kahu al kitab
@@mohdkamil1095 Quran ka msg hamesha say same raha hay. Ye particular kitab Nabi Muhammad ko di gayi
@@AlMosesPhD hm phir uska kya jo quran ne kaha , waiz aataina mosal kitab wal furkan laallakum tahtadoon, ke hamne di Mosa ko kitab or furka taki tum hidayat pao