Character Critiques - Rudy The Bum Santa's Storyline [Bully]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 117

  • @JTmaxx
    @JTmaxx 5 років тому +21

    I love how Otto just charges at him with the snowball. It's one of the redeeming qualities of the arc.

  • @memorymangaming
    @memorymangaming 5 років тому +16

    i like to imagine that johnny vincent has been under a bridge waiting for jimmy the last few days and jimmy's excuse will be i had to help santa.

  • @danimajunior9507
    @danimajunior9507 6 років тому +27

    Rudy is The Hobo's secret twin brother.

  • @jimmyhopkins3748
    @jimmyhopkins3748 6 років тому +41

    I think these missions were made in the earlier stages of bully, explaining the meaner behavior, and sloppily added to scholarship and other versions to make it more interesting

    • @TheNathanNS
      @TheNathanNS  6 років тому +24

      That's actually a good point.
      In early Bully PS2 trailers, there's small snippets of Bully SE missions (Discreet Deliveries and one with Clint)
      So you might be right, that they were early Bully missions, scrapped but re-added. Also explains why they're so simple and buggy.

    • @JourneyLT
      @JourneyLT 6 років тому +6

      That's a thing, why does that Townie have two names? Is his real name Henry and his middle name Clint? That's a character you should really look at and why his missions make no sense.

    • @Eric-py8yy
      @Eric-py8yy 3 роки тому

      Bully was just made for money, Rockstar didnt expected that would make sucess

  • @ZimGirDib13
    @ZimGirDib13 6 років тому +55

    About the little kids having different personalities and voices, I just pretend that those aren't the same kids. They are just completely different kids with the same exact names. They really should've made new character models for those Christmas kids instead of reusing models. It doesn't make any sense. (Lazy developers...)

    • @danteautumn6342
      @danteautumn6342 6 років тому +2

      AuraShadow could be down to time constraints.

    • @parzival9651
      @parzival9651 2 роки тому +3

      They aren't the same kids they just got the same model hence why they're called "generic" kids

  • @frogglen6350
    @frogglen6350 6 років тому +17

    Plus, the Halloween mission is really fun and it's cool to see the kids in customs.
    It's not even mean spirited since all the kids are doing pranks

  • @TV-Tony
    @TV-Tony 5 років тому +9

    And I just remembered that Rudy is also the name of the homeless guy in the previous Rockstar game The Warriors as well. Kind of looks similar too, so they might have just used the same character model and slapped a Santa suit on him.

  • @deadpoolXYZ
    @deadpoolXYZ 6 років тому +52

    Thanks for making this video, I always hated Rudy's arc. The reason they are not side missions is probably because they are christmas themed and by doing them after chapter 3 would make them lose their purpose.
    I usually don't request but Petey is so useless in the storyline he deserves a spot.

    • @deadpoolXYZ
      @deadpoolXYZ 6 років тому +6

      In general, and no I'm not offended, everyone can have their opinion. I commented why i think he was useless in one of swegta's latest videos where he talks about his top 10 characters.

  • @SvanEsch123
    @SvanEsch123 6 років тому +18

    Hi, new fan, commenting again. I loved Rudy’s missions the first time. The Bum Santa was so funny and the missions were enjoyable to me. But after the second time I played the game, they got very old quick. Especially since Chapter 3 is my favorite part of the game and I’m always very excited to see Johnny and his story arc lol
    But I do get why Rudy was in the game, a game that is full of stereotypes. It does fit Bullworth as a whole.

  • @HarryScuderia
    @HarryScuderia 6 років тому +31

    Keep Making Character Critique videos. They are really good, Nathan

  • @TheNathanNS
    @TheNathanNS  6 років тому +33

    So who should I do next for the next episode of Character Critiques?
    John Marston or Earnest Jones? (I'll do both eventually)

    • @HarryScuderia
      @HarryScuderia 6 років тому +4

      TheNathanNS do Earnest Jones

    • @adam10s19
      @adam10s19 6 років тому +2

      Earnest Jones would be great

    • @LorshZontek
      @LorshZontek 6 років тому

      Earnest

    • @Bueller29
      @Bueller29 6 років тому

      TheNathanNS You Should Do Part 2 of beta bully bolwerth 3 floor

    • @nunny5070
      @nunny5070 6 років тому

      Earnest

  • @m.moosabutt8443
    @m.moosabutt8443 6 років тому +12

    I wish Rockstar create Bully 2 with same player Jimmy Hopkins

  • @vertebra00
    @vertebra00 6 років тому +4

    i might be a particolar case, but i played chapter 3 with all the Christmas mission few days ago (it's august) and... i felt so inside the story that i totally forget that was summer. When i watched my bedroom window and i saw kids play in shorts i rember that wasn't December

  • @ryanhouk3560
    @ryanhouk3560 5 років тому +6

    The weirdest inconveniency with the story is that the big game happens in the spring, not fall.
    That bugs me more than playing a Christmas mission in July

    • @parzival9651
      @parzival9651 2 роки тому +3

      Finally someone else mentions it!

  • @weirdface1846
    @weirdface1846 4 роки тому +7

    I feel bad for the normal santa lol and the dwarfs who got beaten up and got Christmas ruined also the exclusive christmas missions in scholarship and anniversary make chapter 3 the longest chapter in scholarship and anniversary

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    also the johnny missions were supposed to start at the school auto shop since johnny mentions new coventry during the cutscenes while hes already inside new coventry

  • @TheLuca2001
    @TheLuca2001 6 років тому +11

    I don't know why but I've always found the faculty members some really interesting characters. It's a shame most of them get to be just mere appearances on campus.

  • @captainunreliable4262
    @captainunreliable4262 6 років тому +4

    Love these types of videos, keep it up :p

  • @jtl5560
    @jtl5560 6 років тому +7

    Can you do the other bum that is a Vietnam veteran?

  • @cameronlorenz113
    @cameronlorenz113 6 років тому +5

    Greetings from Swegta!

  • @mrkaran3949
    @mrkaran3949 6 років тому +16

    An idea for a video bully ripoffs part 5 I have a list of bully ripoffs
    1.High school bully gangster.
    2.High school gangster bully fights karate girl game.
    3.Hello bully teacher 3d.
    4.Teacher vs American high school gangster bullying.
    5.American high school gangster.
    Have a nice day.

  • @AFlexibleGamer
    @AFlexibleGamer 6 років тому +15

    good character, poor execution

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    imagine ruining the kids childhood presents and decorations and santa evil af! Rudy is cruel heartless Jimmy too

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    Rudy was arrested off scren after christmas ends

  • @Sliver441
    @Sliver441 6 років тому +1

    Great concept you got here ! Keep up the good work

  • @SuperDuperSP
    @SuperDuperSP 6 років тому +11

    I guess I didn't miss much when I replayed canis canem edit on my ps4 😂.

    • @ashtube6801
      @ashtube6801 5 років тому

      Super Duper S.P

    • @MC-ru3pm
      @MC-ru3pm 5 років тому

      Same just missed the up in graphics in scholarship

    • @weirdface1846
      @weirdface1846 4 роки тому +1

      Be glad u didnt got to play nutcrackin

    • @Raver-1601
      @Raver-1601 3 роки тому

      Yeah the only good thing Scholarship Edition adds are the extra classes (and graphics too but I don't mind too much about it)

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    the townies were also part of chapter 3 during the beta and beta bully dint have snow at all CLint was in chapter 3 and mailbox armaggedon was in chapter 2 since the mission taking place in bullworth vale

  • @cryptocrew6456
    @cryptocrew6456 4 роки тому +2

    the this that gets me is that they reuse the same charecter modle from the other hobo. and no one ever talks about it

  • @Adnan_Murtadha
    @Adnan_Murtadha 5 років тому +1

    I really enjoy Rudy’s missions I just enjoy helping the guy

  • @Parker.H
    @Parker.H 6 років тому +3

    Keep it up you're really good!

  • @florvillota5
    @florvillota5 5 років тому +2

    Rudy missions should have been like Barry’s side missions in gta 5

  • @TheRobotjellybean
    @TheRobotjellybean 5 років тому +2

    I really enjoy mission like this, it could have worked in the story line better but the holiday missions are why I play bully year after year. I hope the next bully has season and holiday missions or I'll be disappointed

  • @therealronokpayne
    @therealronokpayne 6 років тому +1

    My question for Rudy the Red-Nosed Santa is why are they taking pictures with Santa AFTER Christmas?

  • @AFlexibleGamer
    @AFlexibleGamer 6 років тому +1

    "free vbux to be relevant for 2018"
    so fucking true xD

  • @ScottishScrub
    @ScottishScrub 6 років тому

    Or how the kids tell "Santa" what they want for Christmas either ON Christmas or even days after it...

  • @juicyjuice5083
    @juicyjuice5083 6 років тому +1

    I feel like Rudy The Bum is the same Rudy The Bum from The Warriors, also made by Rockstar.

  • @JDAranez
    @JDAranez 3 роки тому

    I found a glitch in balls of snow someone throwed a firecracker at me and it pushed me off the platform

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    the camera glitch is still not fixed i miss my color camera wish i had a ps2!

  • @MrFingerPL
    @MrFingerPL 6 років тому +10

    What graphics mods do you using?

    • @TheNathanNS
      @TheNathanNS  6 років тому +6

      Mostly just PS2 and beta themed mods.
      I stopped using ReShade ages ago.

  • @daylightanimation
    @daylightanimation 6 років тому +1

    I believe they don't have enough time to polish that mission properly...
    that's it

  • @LorshZontek
    @LorshZontek 6 років тому +4

    Great video so true also

  • @Cainblastem
    @Cainblastem 6 років тому +3

    You should do gary or edgar next time just a request

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    and the hobo santa talking to kids is creepy af! wheres the parents? wheres the police?

  • @Silly-Goose-OG
    @Silly-Goose-OG 4 роки тому

    His mission should have been side missions only accessed in chapter 3

  • @AFlexibleGamer
    @AFlexibleGamer 6 років тому

    finally another character critiques

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    i had the glitch too once

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    the santa missions should have been side missions optional they are not tied to the story they are not connected they make no sense ch 3 starts with the johnny mission chronologicaly

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    Rockstar was too lazy to make new models so they use old models instead the lazyness unfinished

  • @tbush6657
    @tbush6657 6 років тому +1

    I swear I did this mission on the PS2.

    • @ahsokatanosimp7970
      @ahsokatanosimp7970 5 років тому +1

      Well that's impossible considering Balls Of Snow Is a scholarship extra, 4 of the missions in scholarship being new and thos being one of them

  • @Prodawg
    @Prodawg 6 років тому +2

    12:19 that happened to me,
    So uhh rip.

  • @oshlagmz
    @oshlagmz 5 років тому

    NATHAN DA BUM IS DA HOBO JEEZ

  • @powersettingsm7172
    @powersettingsm7172 6 років тому +1

    just saying this i the best video you made out of a dead game.

  • @Oytun22
    @Oytun22 5 років тому +1

    I came here from the prankcall

  • @thewerewolff7248
    @thewerewolff7248 6 років тому +2

    i think this shouldn't be a character critque since you barely complained about ruddy himself and just focused on his missions just a thought

    • @TheNathanNS
      @TheNathanNS  6 років тому +6

      That's a fair point, I have an Earnest one coming today where I point that out.

  • @firstnamesurname3445
    @firstnamesurname3445 6 років тому +2

    Why do you, Simon and Swegta always upload around the same time?

    • @TheNathanNS
      @TheNathanNS  6 років тому +3

      Can't speak for the others, but for me it's so I can try and get as many people to watch the video at the time of uploading.
      Like I upload in evening since it's a perfect mix of Europeans being in the evening, while Americans are just coming home from school/work. By uploading anytime between 7pm - 9pm, I find I get the most "views" that way since it alerts most of my subscribers from those reigons. Uploading around say 3pm GMT would probably not even get me half the views I usually get since Americans (around 43% of my audience) wouldn't watch it when it goes live since most would be in school/work.

  • @tbxgaming7676
    @tbxgaming7676 6 років тому

    Nice video

  • @skinnyp8829
    @skinnyp8829 6 років тому

    Oh my god imagine battle royal on bully

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    Rudy is not tied to the storyline or connected in any way or his missions

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    wish i had a ps2 so i skip the annoying christmas missions! i hate those missions and having to do them everytime i play bully on PC!

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    these missions were unfinished and scrapped from PS2 then later readded to PC while still unfinished rockstar lazyness

  • @bradjusqitovlogs4044
    @bradjusqitovlogs4044 5 років тому +2

    Its ironic how he said kevin and jack because of call me kevin and Jackseptkye who are both irish

  • @Parker.H
    @Parker.H 6 років тому +1

    The Nathan NS Why do you think Rock star Left out black female students?

    • @Parker.H
      @Parker.H 6 років тому +1

      I mean kissable ones

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    the santa missions dont add anything to the story they are just a waste of time beacuse rockstar was too dumb and lazy to make them side missions and now slow down every PC player with 4 missions so we cant progress with the main story beacuse were stuck at broken christmas missions

  • @betuna9487
    @betuna9487 6 років тому

    Dam good shit

  • @TordaiJenoArthurJenci
    @TordaiJenoArthurJenci Рік тому +1

    Jimmy shouldnt talk to hobos

  • @ltnemesis4154
    @ltnemesis4154 4 роки тому

    How this managed to be twice as long as the Ted video is laughable

  • @twagon8854
    @twagon8854 6 років тому +1

    Top 10 Anime Filler

  • @giornogiovanna3477
    @giornogiovanna3477 3 роки тому

    Someone make a mod that removes this... Please.

  • @davidportillosalmeron9107
    @davidportillosalmeron9107 6 років тому +4

    Dude you sound like jack Thompson... stop 😂

  • @Bueller29
    @Bueller29 6 років тому

    22

  • @joe81106
    @joe81106 6 років тому +1

    1st viewer yet again