Nah he was Anakins master. Manipulated him into doing shit for years until he turned completely to the dark side if he told Anakin to jump off that bridge he would have
This is obviously a radio drama, so there is no choice but for the "tell, don't show" route. I much preferred how it was in the movie, when you could actually "see" the emotions stirring within Vader as he was continuously looking back and forth between his son and the man who caused him so much pain.
Not to mention it would never work in a movie. Imagine such a lengthy conversation during the 5 or so seconds Vader carries Sidious. Besides, Sidious appears to be in pain and unable to react. That final line is really good, but only as an audio drama version. They would have to change that whole scene if they wanted to use it in the movie.
Tbh, these lines may be delivered in a corny, cheesy way, but that line of Sidious calling Vader a "slave" and Vader telling Sidious that he may be Vader's master but not Anakin's master would've gone hard as hell if they were actually implemented in the movie, it would've made Vader's betrayal even more epic and the slave line would've tied his character back to his origins.
Radio dramas are always like this cos obviously no one can see the action. If they just used the movie audio then we would all know what was happening because we have seen it loads of times but no words are spoken when Vader chicks the emperor down the shaft. At least not in the original version.
A little corny? Niblets contain less corn. It really isn't very well written at the end. You need short, powerful phases that convey the emotions of the moment, rather than sentence-length dialogue. Calling Vader a slave was the best part, but it is too wordy after that.
Made me tear up! 😢😭 It sounded corny but i could imagine it played out by the actual actors on screen. Hearing Vader actually stand up for himself after all this time was nice. Either would be fire! 😎🔥🔥🔥
As an old guy who saw it in the theater as a kid, I like that last part. Hearing "I am your Master!" "You are Darth Vaders master, but not Anakin Skywalkers." would have been cool because it drives home the fact that even tho he's still in the suit, that is no longer Vader. Remember, Anakin Skywalker was just a name to us at that point.
Im glad you said that because I could have sworn that I remembered that originally Vader doesn’t even say No! He was just completely silent. Thanks. I think I agree with you!
Correct. Him screeching no is one of a million sloppy edits Lucas has made. He's chopped the trilogy up 3 times now with well over an hour worth of edits.
In the Special Editions, at least. In the original cut/VHS version, Vader's completely silent and it's definitely a change that makes the scene not _as_ impactful. You could already see the conflict within him and can tell what's going on in his head without any dialogue. Years of being loyal to the man who screwed him over, the man who lied about being able to save his wife from death, the man who lied about his child's fate, the man who turned him against his own brother figure who _still_ had hope for him ever after the atrocities he committed, were over. This was Anakin's one chance to make things right. As the old saying goes: "Actions speak louder than words."
Now he says no and James Earl Jones' direction was "Now, Mr. Jones, imagine you've gone out into your front yard in your slippers to get the paper and step in dog poop. You have the initial realization that you stepped in something, then you actually lift your foot up and see that it curled up over the edges and is touching your foot". I don't know, the line delivery just sounded lackluster and a bit wedged in (well, it was). Now that I've heard this, they could have added in any of Vader's lines from that and it would have had a lot more impact.
Those were EU Vader's last words, the one that eats Rep-Med Vita Paste(TM) and gets his helmet polished with the woodoo hide and can't afford boots that fit.
Well, according to the latest version currently streaming on Disney, it's "NOOOOOO!" because they can't possibly just leave things alone and not alter them.
Possible lines for Vader when throwing Palpatine to his death: 1. How do you like those apples?! 2. Bet you didn't see that coming, did ya?! 3. Get your stinking hands off my son, you damn, dirty emperor! 4. How do you like it when the shoe is on the other foot?! 5. This is for that bullshit bad performance review! 6. Yippee-Ki-Yay, Motherf*cker!
I guess it depends on which of the 57 versions that Lucas has cut, and recut, and restored, and cut again, and edited in, and edited out, and cut some more.
I listened to this! I can remember the radio dramas! Heh, I guess they were kind of the audio books of the time back in the 60s, 70s, and early 80s, when I remember them from.
Well, I’m kind of glad that was not in the film: sort of cheezy. On the other hand can you imagine what Palpatine told his Evil apprentices about his death? “Vader became disobedient and threw me down the Elevator shaft!”
They lost the script, so instead Vader just had to say "nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo" for the entire duration these lines would've played out.
1:40 Palpatine: _"Vader! Release me! VADER!! I command you! Put me down!"_ Darth Vader: *_"I will... DOWN THE CORE SHAFT, DOWN TO YOUR DEATH!!"_* Palpatine: _"Vader! I am your master!"_ Darth Vader: *"Darth Vader's master, but NOT ANAKIN SKYWALKER'S!!!!"* Goes hard af 🔥🔥
@@jmwilliamsart does hell even exist in Star Wars? Like, where do the dead non-Force-users or the dead Force-users who didn't/couldn't become Force-Ghosts go?
Anakin was a slave, in the Clone Wars Episode almost turns to the dark side on the slavers and Ashoka learns how much anger for them he has, then knowing Palpatine lied about not one but two children, one being a little Padme, lied about him killing Padme, then calls him a slave in the heat of his anger! It added with watching Luke die makes him yeeting Palps literally way more meaningful and redeeming his character. Anakin literally ends his Jedi Path the exact same way as he started it... freeing himself from slavery. He also frees the galaxy from it's slavery, and brings balance to the Force! He is the Chosen One!
Palpatine: Vader what are you doing! Vader: Oh, I recently remembered this holocron I saw from Darth Bane. Palpatine: Uh-oh...I don't like where this is going... Vader: He said that Sith apprentices are supposed to kill their master's when the time was right. And with you being distracted by ELECTROCUTING MY SON it seemed like the right time. Palpatine: I vehemently disagree with your judgement on this matter. Vader: You can send me your appeal after you arrive in Hell. Mind the lake of fire. It can be a bitch. *toss*
Interesting, I didn't know this existed. I wrote a fan fiction in 2003 where Vader simply says to Palpatine in that moment when he's carrying him, too low to be heard: "You are no longer ANYONE'S master."
I think the only thing that would’ve really worked in this that was extra for the actual film, is if Palpatine were to say “Vader is my slave!” Before Vader grabs him whilst still yelling the iconic “NOOOO!” Then him saying “I am Anakin! and I am not your slave!” Then throws him down the shaft. That would be a pretty damn cool line as it confirms that Anakin is 100% back to the good side before he dies.
I like how Anakin reclaim his true identity. You are the master of Vader but not the master of Anakin Skywalker.
Nah it sounds corny
Agreed. Would have loved to see it in the movie.
@@eskanda3434 Hate to break it to you, but Star Wars is one giant corn-fest. And I say that as a fan!
Nah he was Anakins master.
Manipulated him into doing shit for years until he turned completely to the dark side if he told Anakin to jump off that bridge he would have
To be honest, this must have been horrifying to Palpatine after decades of thinking that he foresees and knows everything. Well deserved.
Thats what happend to the jedi. Becoming too complacent.
@@SucksToTellTheTruthYou become what you hate innit
@@MichaelNight yeah brother, and thats human nature. We become too comfortable. Look at rl. Thats why george lucas is a genius.
His overconfidence was his weakness.
luke: your overconfidence was your weakness
It all ended when he called him a 'slave' Palp's should have chosen his words more carefully.
He's a person, and his name is Anakin!!
Somehow Palestine returned
This is Sparta!
@@Reztuber101how could you possibly say all of Palestine is evil?
Got too comfortable and spoke too freely.
"Darth Vader's Master but not Anakin Skywalker's" is such a cold line
This is obviously a radio drama, so there is no choice but for the "tell, don't show" route.
I much preferred how it was in the movie, when you could actually "see" the emotions stirring within Vader as he was continuously looking back and forth between his son and the man who caused him so much pain.
Yup. If it’s not a Vader/Palpatine exchange then it’ll have to be Luke doing visual exposition despite being tortured to within an inch of his life.
Not to mention it would never work in a movie. Imagine such a lengthy conversation during the 5 or so seconds Vader carries Sidious. Besides, Sidious appears to be in pain and unable to react.
That final line is really good, but only as an audio drama version. They would have to change that whole scene if they wanted to use it in the movie.
Not Anakins master was nice.
Corny but nice.
Bit the movie emotions showing his redemption back to the lights idea was superb
Did that guy cause him pain
Agreed. Too much chatter!
Tbh, these lines may be delivered in a corny, cheesy way, but that line of Sidious calling Vader a "slave" and Vader telling Sidious that he may be Vader's master but not Anakin's master would've gone hard as hell if they were actually implemented in the movie, it would've made Vader's betrayal even more epic and the slave line would've tied his character back to his origins.
It's a really good line, but I don't see it working in the scene as it is. Works for an audio drama.
Darth Vaders master, but not Anakin Skywalkers was a powerful line
Damn, I felt that one. Got chills actually.
Turbocringe
@@TheRealAbraxas The delivery more than the line
A little corny, but I suppose that’s what makes it so fun. Nice adaptation.
In truth, they could've used a few lines of this in the movie although the movie is fine the way it is.
Man this isn't any better than some prequel dialogues
@@darthsidius9631it’s an audio drama ..
Radio dramas are always like this cos obviously no one can see the action. If they just used the movie audio then we would all know what was happening because we have seen it loads of times but no words are spoken when Vader chicks the emperor down the shaft. At least not in the original version.
A little corny? Niblets contain less corn. It really isn't very well written at the end. You need short, powerful phases that convey the emotions of the moment, rather than sentence-length dialogue. Calling Vader a slave was the best part, but it is too wordy after that.
Made me tear up! 😢😭
It sounded corny but i could imagine it played out by the actual actors on screen. Hearing Vader actually stand up for himself after all this time was nice. Either would be fire! 😎🔥🔥🔥
"Somehow...you'll Return."
“Vader, put me down.” Palpatine said calmly.
said lovingly 😂
(Exits stage.)
Say hello to Mace While you are down there Pal.
Died the same way he made Anakin kill Mace Windu.
"The lannisters send their regards"
First words as Vader to palpatine: “NOOOOOO” Last words as Vader to palpatine: “NO!”
The voices had like a Warhammer 40K style.
There was no War slammer in 1983, only atari and dungeon and dwagons, sorry nerd.😂🤦♂️🤦♀️
@@Workerbee-zy5nxhe just said its similar idk man i think youre the nerd here
@@FalkyRocket2222 yo mamma👈🤠💪
@@Workerbee-zy5nxare you being an asshole or are you just really bad at making jokes?
@@FalkyRocket2222 I think that guy has lost some of his marbles.
1.2k views in only 3 days?
That is a legendary start for a new channel.
Thank you very much I appreciate it!
" Mace Windu sends his regards..." Vader double taps Palpatine, the end.
Somehow Palpatine returned
Shitquels
@@MrCubFan415poopquels? dude that was weak af
Nah
@@Bendernity I can already tell you're edgier than a D20
what do you mean?
In the audio version the emperor was running on a hundred percent pure ham
As an old guy who saw it in the theater as a kid, I like that last part. Hearing "I am your Master!" "You are Darth Vaders master, but not Anakin Skywalkers." would have been cool because it drives home the fact that even tho he's still in the suit, that is no longer Vader. Remember, Anakin Skywalker was just a name to us at that point.
Im glad you said that because I could have sworn that I remembered that originally Vader doesn’t even say No! He was just completely silent. Thanks. I think I agree with you!
The "my son!" Is way better than the "no"
Correct. Him screeching no is one of a million sloppy edits Lucas has made. He's chopped the trilogy up 3 times now with well over an hour worth of edits.
“ can you fly, Bobby? “
Can you fly palpy?😂
Robocop lol
No. I tried... why?
I think the most fitting line would have been "This is the end for you, My Master".
And before he collapses after throwing him into the shaft, he says “so uncivilized” .
This is where the fun ends.
Just shout down as he's falling "I hope you land square on your balls, prune-face!"
Palpatine (After somehow surviving): "Another happy landing."
So cool. To think all he said was “No, nooooo!!!”
In the Special Editions, at least.
In the original cut/VHS version, Vader's completely silent and it's definitely a change that makes the scene not _as_ impactful. You could already see the conflict within him and can tell what's going on in his head without any dialogue. Years of being loyal to the man who screwed him over, the man who lied about being able to save his wife from death, the man who lied about his child's fate, the man who turned him against his own brother figure who _still_ had hope for him ever after the atrocities he committed, were over.
This was Anakin's one chance to make things right. As the old saying goes: "Actions speak louder than words."
He certainly did not. He was totally silent. You're watching a badly edited officially licensed forgery.
And there was me thinking he just spasmed uncontrollably while frothing at the mouth as that lightning went through him.
Now he says no and James Earl Jones' direction was "Now, Mr. Jones, imagine you've gone out into your front yard in your slippers to get the paper and step in dog poop. You have the initial realization that you stepped in something, then you actually lift your foot up and see that it curled up over the edges and is touching your foot".
I don't know, the line delivery just sounded lackluster and a bit wedged in (well, it was). Now that I've heard this, they could have added in any of Vader's lines from that and it would have had a lot more impact.
its like if star wars was adapted by theatre teachers who don't like star wars
That would have been amazing had that been said in the film
no
U mean nooooooo
But it wasn’t, so it didn’t happen.
Lol closed captions turned feeble into people.
"YOUR PEOPLE SKILLS ARE NO MATCH FOR THE POWER OF THE DARK SIDE."
Luke: and I took that personally .
Sounds like a case for HR.
It would seem he was mistaken
Palpatine “somehow” returning makes Vader’s sacrifice pointless
Technically, it was Anakin who said those things.
I believe Vader's last words were really I'm on fire again I can't catch a break fuck this hurts I smell hot dogs cooking
Those were EU Vader's last words, the one that eats Rep-Med Vita Paste(TM) and gets his helmet polished with the woodoo hide and can't afford boots that fit.
Vader's final line to Palpatine should've been like an action hero quip, as he threw him down the reactor shaft: "Gravity sucks, my master." 🙃
I heard Lucas was going to make a Definitive Edition where Vader’s last words to the Emperor would be “smell ya later.”
Vader: "I am his father!"
That dialog would have made the end of Jedi so much better.
Cheesy, but this is so cool.
I still prefer the original, you can literally FEEL the emotion radiating from Vader despite the mask being on.
Interesting, I like that voice of the emperor
Even though it sounds like an audio Book 😅
Darth Vader said no calmly ..
Vader: "Execute Order Fall Down and Go Splat!"
h/t How It Should Have Ended: The Rise of Skywalker
"...AND THE FORCE YOU RODE IN ON!!!!"
Well, according to the latest version currently streaming on Disney, it's "NOOOOOO!" because they can't possibly just leave things alone and not alter them.
Imagine if luke did died and vader throws he’s body down the reactor shaft, Thats dark
This is pretty cool. It enhances the emotions experienced in that moment by all 3 characters. Nice dialogue addition.
Vader sounds like Gandalf lowkey. “SIDIOUS!!! YOU SHALL NOT PASS”
This should’ve been in the movie
The 2011 version added in Vader repeating his infamous NOO!
Brilliant
Thank you
It would’ve been awesome if Vader had said that in the Blue Ray version instead of “Noooooo!”
Palpatine's mistake was calling Vader his "slave". That had to have triggered Anakin to wake up and reclaim who he was from Vader.
Luke is killing me😂😂
'i have had enough of you'
Possible lines for Vader when throwing Palpatine to his death:
1. How do you like those apples?!
2. Bet you didn't see that coming, did ya?!
3. Get your stinking hands off my son, you damn, dirty emperor!
4. How do you like it when the shoe is on the other foot?!
5. This is for that bullshit bad performance review!
6. Yippee-Ki-Yay, Motherf*cker!
And the tears rolling down🥺
Palpatine's last words: "Somehow I will return!"
Luke sounds like he’s on the receiving end of a bdsm film!
Now that's accurate line right there.
"RELEASE ME"
"Poor choice of words"
Vader last word. "ouch. Hey guys look I finally got it up*
The shaft is the tower interior. The last thing they want is an open port to the core. Not after the last time.
I guess it depends on which of the 57 versions that Lucas has cut, and recut, and restored, and cut again, and edited in, and edited out, and cut some more.
I listened to this! I can remember the radio dramas! Heh, I guess they were kind of the audio books of the time back in the 60s, 70s, and early 80s, when I remember them from.
Well, I’m kind of glad that was not in the film: sort of cheezy.
On the other hand can you imagine what Palpatine told his Evil apprentices about his death? “Vader became disobedient and threw me down the Elevator shaft!”
Certainly better than "Noooo"
Palpatine: “Put me down!”
Vader: “Poor choice of words.”
They lost the script, so instead Vader just had to say "nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo" for the entire duration these lines would've played out.
Vader sounded very emotional
Like Anakin
Vader: "I can't stay mad at you, my master."
"What are you doing?! I am your master!"
"I am altering the deal, pray I dont alter it further!"
1:40 Palpatine: _"Vader! Release me! VADER!! I command you! Put me down!"_
Darth Vader: *_"I will... DOWN THE CORE SHAFT, DOWN TO YOUR DEATH!!"_*
Palpatine: _"Vader! I am your master!"_ Darth Vader: *"Darth Vader's master, but NOT ANAKIN SKYWALKER'S!!!!"*
Goes hard af 🔥🔥
I would add these words “GIVE MY REGARDS TO DARTH PLAGUEIS! I’M SURE THAT HE’S WAITING FOR YOU IN HELL!”
@@jmwilliamsart does hell even exist in Star Wars? Like, where do the dead non-Force-users or the dead Force-users who didn't/couldn't become Force-Ghosts go?
"His lightsaber."
Vader’s last words to Palpatine are “his lightsaber.”
That stuff makes me real zappy🥹
Vader: "Spinning is a good trick".
What's more important? Power? Or the love of one's family? Some abusive asshole? Or the love of your children?
The first line of Palpatine sounds like Vader is the one talking. Confused me for a second.
This was so much more engaging and dramatic. I don't understand why they cut it off!
Either "NO!" or "His light saber", depending on what you accept as canon.
Vaser: "Hey, check out the plumbing while you're down there, would you. Engineering reports a sewage leak on deck 32"
Palpatine before being thrown : Dewit.
Vader: Wait what?!
radio....i miss this thing, oh wait i have voices in my head now
Damn, I never really thought about how a radio show would need to spell everything out through dialogue. Were they all like that?
Yes since there isn’t any footage going with it they needed all this extra dialogue needed to make it interesting since this is more of a audio movie.
They totally were, and it was often really well written.
That was awesome! I never heard the radio drama before. Looks like I know what I’m searching for!
Anakin was a slave, in the Clone Wars Episode almost turns to the dark side on the slavers and Ashoka learns how much anger for them he has, then knowing Palpatine lied about not one but two children, one being a little Padme, lied about him killing Padme, then calls him a slave in the heat of his anger! It added with watching Luke die makes him yeeting Palps literally way more meaningful and redeeming his character. Anakin literally ends his Jedi Path the exact same way as he started it... freeing himself from slavery. He also frees the galaxy from it's slavery, and brings balance to the Force! He is the Chosen One!
"Givin' YOU the shaft now!"
I'm so glad this is getting attention. The Star Wars radio dramas go hard
That will never heal if you don't stop picking it, my master. 🖖
“Hope you enjoy the Landing”
Vader: "Into the garbage chute, flyboy!"
His last line was Cereveza Cristal
Those were great radio dramas! The one for the original Star Wars was the best, though!
Palpatine: Vader what are you doing!
Vader: Oh, I recently remembered this holocron I saw from Darth Bane.
Palpatine: Uh-oh...I don't like where this is going...
Vader: He said that Sith apprentices are supposed to kill their master's when the time was right. And with you being distracted by ELECTROCUTING MY SON it seemed like the right time.
Palpatine: I vehemently disagree with your judgement on this matter.
Vader: You can send me your appeal after you arrive in Hell. Mind the lake of fire. It can be a bitch. *toss*
Vader: Can you fly, Bobby?
It’s all pointless because…‘somehow Palpatine came back’ 🤣🤣
The Nos and Yeses had me laughing.
wow i got chills going thro my spine from that and i think it should have been in the movie
I thought it was just Vader saying, “noooooo!”
"All the overtime I put in, I never got paid for any of it!"
In the release,Vader(or Anakin Skywalker)says "No"before throwing Palpatine down the shaft
Interesting, I didn't know this existed.
I wrote a fan fiction in 2003 where Vader simply says to Palpatine in that moment when he's carrying him, too low to be heard: "You are no longer ANYONE'S master."
I think the only thing that would’ve really worked in this that was extra for the actual film, is if Palpatine were to say “Vader is my slave!” Before Vader grabs him whilst still yelling the iconic “NOOOO!” Then him saying “I am Anakin! and I am not your slave!” Then throws him down the shaft. That would be a pretty damn cool line as it confirms that Anakin is 100% back to the good side before he dies.