N25 got a top 10?! It's nice actually. I would like say overall of your opinion I would agree. I kinda sad why Nene comms such an average since I'm bias on her. But she's deserve to get at bottom place. So, your fav songs is the Wall, 1, Bake no Hana, and Jackpot sad Girl right? Shinonome in the top 3 such accurate to me.
Sorry but hereby my little long rant about commission vs song I feel like this tier was made with a little too much bias as it was made as a tierlist more of the SONGS rather than the Commision work (meaning, taking into thought how the producer took the character and made a song from that), a lot of the characters that have songs that are truly characteristic or express the character so well are just… so low, I guess it’s because it’s a song itself ranking? More than commission itself with the character in mind? A lot of, for example, Niigo and WxS have been commissioned by composers who are actual fans of their characters, a big example is Tsukasa who has most of his comms done by producers who are Tsukasa oshi’s themselves and thus put a lot of care into his comms to be as filled and wonky as his sekai is, but in a personal taste standpoint, if you dislike that kind of music that’s just doomed from the start. As the ranking of the songs? It’s good, it’s your own opinion!
the ranking was for how the songs sound which was made pretty evident by how I only talk about how they sound and actively disregard the lyrics 😭 to me it doesn't matter if a song is great and fits a character well if it's not an enjoyable listening experience if I were to do a video on how accurate the lyrics were to the character they would pretty much all be equal since generally the lyrics for comm songs are fitting for who/what they were written for with few exceptions just think of the video as a fun way to see other people's opinions, not necessarily some end-all-be-all list of which characters' comms suck, because I definitely don't have the authority to decide that anyways 😭
replace an with kohane and I think I agree... Though I think tsukasa has the best coms in WxS simply because of mr showtime and the consistency also on how well the songs reflect the theme. Rui definitely ties though because of cdb, mafuyu does have some great comms but I'd say the best comms in the game are Akito or Honami due to consistency of all their songs being great or at the very least decent
i do not like flyer or kohane as a character (which means I feel less strongly about the messages of the songs, and am more likely to look at them from a "does this objectively sound good to me" point) so she was always destined to be lower down honami has good comms but she doesn't have a 5th yet. if she got a good 5th (like, before the video was made) she'd be up higher, but it's not out yet and I'm not going to assume it's good because of all the flop shizuku commissions that exist tsukasa is honestly only so low down because I don't like tondemo wonderz nor filament fever and I don't listen to mr. showtime enough to feel attached to it because of who the producer is. i know it's objectively a good song but I just don't care about it no comment on akito because he's already second place and that's basically the "best" when we disregard oshi bias 😭 mafuyu is just my favourite and she never would've ended up anywhere but first place even if she got an absolutely trash comm that I didn't like so it's honestly better to disregard my opinion because I think as long as her comms aren't blue paint level bad I'll love them 💀 average her out to like 5th-7th place and readjust everyone and that's the "accurate ranking"
moonlight immediately got copyright striked 💀
N25 got a top 10?! It's nice actually. I would like say overall of your opinion I would agree. I kinda sad why Nene comms such an average since I'm bias on her. But she's deserve to get at bottom place. So, your fav songs is the Wall, 1, Bake no Hana, and Jackpot sad Girl right? Shinonome in the top 3 such accurate to me.
Sorry but hereby my little long rant about commission vs song
I feel like this tier was made with a little too much bias as it was made as a tierlist more of the SONGS rather than the Commision work (meaning, taking into thought how the producer took the character and made a song from that), a lot of the characters that have songs that are truly characteristic or express the character so well are just… so low, I guess it’s because it’s a song itself ranking? More than commission itself with the character in mind? A lot of, for example, Niigo and WxS have been commissioned by composers who are actual fans of their characters, a big example is Tsukasa who has most of his comms done by producers who are Tsukasa oshi’s themselves and thus put a lot of care into his comms to be as filled and wonky as his sekai is, but in a personal taste standpoint, if you dislike that kind of music that’s just doomed from the start. As the ranking of the songs? It’s good, it’s your own opinion!
the ranking was for how the songs sound which was made pretty evident by how I only talk about how they sound and actively disregard the lyrics 😭 to me it doesn't matter if a song is great and fits a character well if it's not an enjoyable listening experience
if I were to do a video on how accurate the lyrics were to the character they would pretty much all be equal since generally the lyrics for comm songs are fitting for who/what they were written for with few exceptions
just think of the video as a fun way to see other people's opinions, not necessarily some end-all-be-all list of which characters' comms suck, because I definitely don't have the authority to decide that anyways 😭
SHIHO #9???? AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHH FINALLY SOMEONE WHO LIKES HER COMMS 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
just for ultra c kohane is top 1 with 10 point
so true ultra c so fire
MMJ 😭😭😭
replace an with kohane and I think I agree... Though I think tsukasa has the best coms in WxS simply because of mr showtime and the consistency also on how well the songs reflect the theme. Rui definitely ties though because of cdb, mafuyu does have some great comms but I'd say the best comms in the game are Akito or Honami due to consistency of all their songs being great or at the very least decent
i do not like flyer or kohane as a character (which means I feel less strongly about the messages of the songs, and am more likely to look at them from a "does this objectively sound good to me" point) so she was always destined to be lower down
honami has good comms but she doesn't have a 5th yet. if she got a good 5th (like, before the video was made) she'd be up higher, but it's not out yet and I'm not going to assume it's good because of all the flop shizuku commissions that exist
tsukasa is honestly only so low down because I don't like tondemo wonderz nor filament fever and I don't listen to mr. showtime enough to feel attached to it because of who the producer is. i know it's objectively a good song but I just don't care about it
no comment on akito because he's already second place and that's basically the "best" when we disregard oshi bias 😭
mafuyu is just my favourite and she never would've ended up anywhere but first place even if she got an absolutely trash comm that I didn't like so it's honestly better to disregard my opinion because I think as long as her comms aren't blue paint level bad I'll love them 💀
average her out to like 5th-7th place and readjust everyone and that's the "accurate ranking"
@@sou.p nice 👍
Future me, will honami come first?
no!
wait what's the 'funny mv' you mentioned for akito i genuinely can't figure it out LOL
@MintiiLi fuel 💀
@@sou.p why? what's wrong with it
@MintiiLi it's just very unserious to me
cooked