I think it’s pretty obvious who betrayed Black pearl. The only person who has a treasure of the Black Pearl presumably hers and can swindle their way with promises is Oyster. It also explains why she didn’t destroy what was supposedly a ship belonging to house oyster. Talk about but the elders being really corrupt
Captain Caviar being the exception tho, he seems to be just an honest captain wanting to protect the Lower Town and the Republic from threats, as well as living for the thrill and adventure at the seas, huge respect ✨✨
I think it might be someone from House Oyster since the ship was described as an earlier era design but it also could be her when she was rising to power 😐
Okay but what if captain ice cookie was in house oyster someone said in her lobby there was a picture of captain ice cookie so Maybe captain ice cookie helped oyster cookie to go to black pearl and shes mad at both of them
Theory: i believe oyster betrayed black pearl. In a cut scene caviar was talking about a ship that very much looks like the ships of house oyster. While he was saying that the ship we were seing on screen was the one on the very top. Later after caviar said to black pearl: "along with all this debri, that one singular ship is on the very top. Almost as if your cherishing it or it reminds you of someone." Or along those lines. Black pearl was enraged after that. Further proof is that oyster owns an item that very much reassembles black pearl. Even the description fits it. So in conclusion i belive that oyster betrayed black pearl by possibly leaving her but left a ship, then black pearl gave oyster a pearl to remind her of black pearl. And even after years black pearl is still hoping she will come back. Hoping the first ever cookie to ever understand her will comeback. However after the years even if she very much loves oyster. She cant help but think oyster realy left her. And so her anger grew and grew. To this point in time.
@@youbettersayyestomentos6514 Maybe it is true, but what if Oyster do not 'owe' Black Pearl something, but stole from her instead? I remembered in Black Pearl's loading screen it says something about 'if a mermaid loose their pearls, then they will fall to the darkness of the sea' or something close like that. What if Oyster actually stole Black Pearl true, clean, irridescent pearl away from her that turned her into the monster she is now? If so, Oyster said grand scheme seems to lead as either a bargain for loyalty (most unlikely, but remains a possibility) or eradicating Black Pearl for good so that no one will ever threaten her sea trades bussiness ever (most likely?)
@@charlotteillion2755 theres also oysters fountain where she seems to try to remember something but shrugs it off. She must've been young when she stole it and when that old ship was sailing with her on it, she must've told black pearl how she didn't remember whatever promise they had. Either that or oyster promised to bring it back but forgot.
My theory: Since Black Pearl said her wrath is a century old, Oyster can't have betrayed her. Instead, maybe House Oyster's ancestors? They might have got their eyes on the Black Pearl now currently in House Oyster's treasury, and befriended Black Pearl Cookie just to get it During their time with Black Pearl, she might have started to develop feelings for them After that, House Oyster's ancestors stole what they wanted and left Black Pearl forever, never to be seen again Since then, Black Pearl's rage built up inside her, and turned her into who we see today, letting out her hate on the Cookies she despised from anger Even then, she's still a lil desperate, since she still had a pinch of feelings for them, and even kept one of House Oyster's ships after she sunk it, now beautifully well kept and treasured on top of the century old pile of wrath she created (Sorry for the behemoth of an essay I created lmao)
lot of people say that Oyster is the one betraying Black Pearl but Black Pearl bio state her wrath is over a centuary old. I think the cookie who betrayed her is simply dead and Oyster heritated from it. She probably isn't even aware of its origin. at least that my point of view
23:21 she is talking about sorbet shark cookie! This is now clear to me that black pearl cookie is a reference to the sea witch Ursula from my little mermaid. 🧜♀️ ✨️ the crown on her head is a give away too and the fact that she has a staff.
I don't think she's a villain or antagonist. She feels betrayed and hurt by someone who made a promise to her. And if I remember correctly, Oyster has a black pearl from her gacha stuff. Maybe the cookie Black Pearl was friends with was Oyster or maybe she had feelings for a different cookie who broke her heart. She is doing this all out of anger and pain, not to be a horrible cookie. She just needs to be fixed :>
I love the voice actor for Black Pearl Cookie! They’re really amazing. The story is good too, but it ended up on a unresolved note. I hope we get some answers to what happened with Oyster’s Ship and all that jazz.
Her voice actor also voices White Lily Cookie. It's a complete difference cuz White Lily Cookie sounds like 😟☹️☺️, but Black Pearl Sounds like 😡👹☠️💀😈👿🤬😠
I have a small theory. Maybe the cookie who betrayed Black Pearl Cookie was Sea Fairy Cookie since Black Pearl Cookie began to sink all the ships and Sea Fairy Cookie didn’t want to do that
@@makushonjongramiresu1577 That wouldn't explain why the Boat at the top of Black Pearl's den is perfectly in shape and devoid of bruises though. She seems to give too much importance on her reputation as a terrifying monster, while making sure *nobody* could possibly think she had a "mere cookie" as a friend/lover/acquaintance.
Actually, I think it's might have been someone from House Oyster. Captain Caviar described the ship as bearing the symbol of House Oyster but of an older model. Perhaps one of Oyster Cookie's ancestor was on that ship along Black Pearl Cookie, and something happened that sunk the ship and turned Black Pearl Cookie into what she is now. Oyster Cookie might actually have known this story and sent Captain Caviar to confirm her suspicion.
Oyster almost definitely betrayed Black Pearl. Remember in the “House Oysters Collection/Luxuries”? One of the items was a “Lustrous Black Pearl” . The description was "A black pearl from the depths of the sea. You may marvel at its luster, but beware: its dark shade will carry you to the endless abyss of the pitch black sea." Which sort of means that it belongs to Black Pearl since shes from the depths of the sea (and also the name suggests otherwise). It’s probably not that specific pearl she’s after, since black pearls likely show up often in the Duskgloom Sea, but perhaps Oyster has something else that Black Pearl wants. Another theory is that Oyster made a promise to help Black Pearl Cookie by saying maybe like “If I save/help you, you give me black pearls (or whatever) in exchange” but Oyster betrayed BP after accumulating enough luxuries and broke the promise? Idk just a theory.
Black pearl was probably just a normal, kind-hearted mermaid who served as a protector of the sea (like the lore about them says), but either oyster or her ancestors betrayed her by stealing her pearl, cursing her into descending to the dark abyss, and now wants revenge on all cookies for what they've done to her. I know there's corruption amongst the republic elders/houses, but damn oyster is just messed up. Hell I think all the pearls used for the cookie legion were from other mermaids they betrayed, and unlike black pearl, those perished in the abyss, hence why we didn't see more mermaids till now, like what the hell man.
A theory: Oyster in her decor and on clothes has white pearl right- We can see in Black Pearl islands a mermaid, when we choose +crit,atk, etc.. But what if black pearl cookie was actually White pearl? Someone who oyster knew? But after she betrayed pearl, she turned into chaos/bad side.. who knows
@@hirtyu8981 Yes, I saw that too but forgot to mention it here Her story really is interesting, because comparing to other legendary cookies, we know black pearl in like 5% of whole history, knowing devsis I hope in next uptade when Candy diver cookie will come we will know about her more
24:11 I can't help but think Black Pearl cookie is referring to pirate cookie and squid ink. I love all the void details. Black Pearl cookie deceived in some way by a cookie, I love the thought of that. Looks like captain Caviar cookie struck a nerve.
Don't forgot at 23:18 Black Pearl Cookie mentioned "that silly, naive child who wanted to becoming a Cookie" implying to be Sorbet Shark Cookie himself
after rewatching the part when cap cavier was looking at the shrunken ships, the fact that he recognized that one of them was similar to house oyster's models and was left presumably unharmed gives me an idea that it could also be oyster after all in the beginning she did asked him to give her any info on what's happening in that area of the sea + in her decors, specially the fountain, a statue of a mermaid can be seen
Story games on roblox 😭out of all the things you could compare it to 😭😭 most of the story games on roblox are bad so it's not hard to surpass it's writing
did oyster cookie somehow betray black pearl? i mean captain caviar cookie said that the ship on top that looked like was being treasured looked like house oysters earlier design era, and the mermaid on oyster cookies decor, interesting...
wonder who's the one that betrayed black pearl ? People say it's oyster while the ruined mirror in black pearl's lobby has a reflection that looked like captain ice from CROB also i'm glad that candy diver is now a part of captain caviar's crew , hope to see more stories about them and the crew
This is what I think about candy diver cookie, Candy diver is a cookie who is looking for his friend after they traveled to the dusk gloom sea while they were adventuring they forgot where they were so candy diver headed to the sparkling corals but his friend was not there so for years candy diver cookie kept searching for his friend not knowing that his friend had died because of black pearl cookie, candy diver kept searching for his friend not knowing that his dough had already melted from staying in the dusk gloom sea for so long when he realized it he never tried taking off his helmet years had past and candy diver still thought his friend was alive so when he saw captain caviar he had hope that his friend may be alive but saw that it was captain caviar when captain caviar considered candy diver cookie as his friend it reminded candy divers friend and because of that they were able to leave when captain caviar requested that he take off his helmet he was hesitant but decided to do it leaving captain caviar in shock that his dough had melted and he was a wandering ghost who left his helmet on candy diver decided to keep diving into the dusk gloom sea to help other cookies just like he did with captain caviar
I think the friend might have become a ghost too Woah, there are many types of ghosts in cookie run: a ghost that is just like the alive cookie (onion), a ghost that is a white version of the alive cookie (pirate), a ghost that is different from the alive cookie (white ghost), a ghost that is a spirit (sherbet) and now candy diver. Their friend can turn into any of these
@@villona277yeaa if u didnt notice the salty ship navigator crew doing all the cleaning chores doesnt talk and at the very end of the story the last words were stars and dots etc which implies it's candy diver cookie itself who now works on the ship
I was right on a theory about her used to be good So she got betrayed which led her to this. Got betrayed by Oyster's ancestors. In her description, she has a century old wrath which means.. It's been a hundred years That's why that specific ship is not damaged, she's close to it I don't know why there's a photo of Captain Ice tho
apparently, Candy Diver Cookie's face reveal was just........... oh -Candy Diver Cookie's already been just water and two gumballs, it was already clearly seen at the trailer- ouch
It’s kind of surprising that captain caviar can just stay calm and brush off the negativity that black pearl spews at him, it’s like that one character that can’t be provoked in any way and can understand those who like provoking other people, along with their intentions 32:16 geez woman, calm down😧
it iss he approached her and in return for his voice she gave him the ability to turn into cookie so now while in his cookie form he only goes ooOOoOOoOoOoOooOOOOo, additional note: in their interaction sorbet shark cookie doesnt mind losing his voice at all and is happy to become a cookie
I actually like this story, but my main favorite is the cotton cookie and frost queen cookie story tbh, but this is probably one of top 5 fav favorite story’s
HSJXHXX WE R SIMILAR HAHAHA my fav is a mermaids tale and the cotton cookie sherbet cookie story is my 2nd fav, 3rd is this then the last is white lily cookies story, all i can rmb for now
But what about BPC's galaxy sparlky tail? How was she made initially? Is that where Sea Fairy comes in to the story? (You know, she's the lesbian water goddess that yearns to see Moonlight cookie again.) Speaking of which.. what would their relationship be like?
The true story: White pearl gave lord oyster her pearl. Black pearl was used to live in tearcrown. Black pearl as white pearl was trying to have strength and powers from a sea fairy tear. However, Absorbing the sea fairy tear has negative effects. Which happened to octopus cookie. Which turned octopus cookie into abyss monarch. And white pearl absorbed the sea fairy tear. Which shattered the sea fairy tear and was nowhere to be seen. Turning white pearl into his dark self. Maybe that's why black pearl felt betrayed and wants to kill anything for thise who set foot on HIS sea.
U were right up until the end, yes she gave lord oyster her Pearl and yes she absorbed the sea fairy tear but before that happened lord oyster had given (well sold) the Pearl to his enemy so that he could help restore house oysters reputation, he regretted his decision cause he did care for white Pearl cookie (i think he loved or had feeling a for her) but when she found out what he did she was mad and didn’t let him explain, then afterwards she absorbed the sea fairy tear and turned into black Pearl cookie
The truth: White Pearl Cookie liked Lord Oyster but at some point after giving him her pearl, he sold it to Captain Abalone Cookie his partner... that's when Lord Oyster went insane for the sea treasures... to the point she gets corrupted by painful realisations that the Land cookies r toxic and unforgiving to the point she used her home dormain's Sea Fairy's tear against the assailants... hence her current state, she STILL hates them
Lord oyster wasn't really bad and corrupt It was because of his whole family's situation and abalone smooth talking him into selling it He really regretted selling it after what happened
23:17 if black pearl mentions squid ink cookie, this means that she definitely knows it. I wonder how they met. this also could mean that squid ink was possibly the one sobbing at the start of the story- although it might’ve been black pearl faking tears as well.
@@Mx_Rabbit I'm not sure if it was fake..she could of been crying before they showed up, but she started laughing as she was getting ready to wreck another ship (wrecking ships seems to make her feel better or at least take her mind off the pain of betrayal).
Hmm Yall maybe Sea fairy and Black Pearl are sisters and by that time sea fairy was frozen so Black Pearl tried protecting her At the same time if Sea fairy was frozen she needs to be the bigger sister Could be true bcs she more powerful and can control the sea while black peark aka the little sis might just be starting to gain the power Maybe we will See cannon like this and MAYBE we will see a pacifist side of Black Pearl
Spoilers but if you do Holliday cake event (2022) there will be a scene where Captain Caviar invites Oyster to sit on a ship deck and eat a cake with him and his crew. His crew is expecting noble woman to refuse such offer as it not noble like to eat a cake on a deck. But she agrees without a moment hesitation. That makes me believe that she was a sailor herself. Thus photo of a sailor on Black Pearl screen. It’s not Captain Ice cookie. It’s young Oyster wearing same uniform. I believe that house oyster is somewhat “young” maybe only one generation old. Maybe Oyster was a sailor as a teen or young adult, stole Black Perl’s Pearl got some money and created noble house. She can be up to 80 years old (but just very healthy so she’s looking fresh). Thus the “century old grudge”. It’s not exactly 100 years, but maybe 50-60.
I'm pretty Oyster made a promise to Black Pearl Cookie but she had to leave her ship behind and Black Pearl cookie was waiting for her return and kept it in good conditions, thats why it still looks brand new. Probably years passed she was frustrated and her frustration turned into anger.
The character and design of the silent sea is incredible specially the new character black pearl cookie who has the power and manipulation of water Wich means that she can take any shape of water and make the crew suffer in silence,I love her regardless on how evil she might be
Black pearl cookie was once of the kind mermaids out there , but oyster broke it bc she value precious Valuables more than friendship,she literally broke the promise,she did not think some town would be in danger bc of it,for now..She kept thinking of what happened to her and personality..her looks,and everyone that despises her,Sheesh..sometimes elders arent thinking a second thought,or research,i mean they are mature adult,how could they broke a promise to an mermaid?Its absurd,yet she got betrayed,but she still have oyster cookie ship,thats why she values that only 1 ship bc it reminds her only friend..Oyster cookie,Bc no one dares to visit the sea,bc it is quite dangerous to see,But 1 greedy cookie,the black pearl,she visited the see to get the pearl,make black/white pearl cookie trust her bc of her high expectations,shes maybe so happy that she finally got a friend..
If anyone is wondering, or even sees this, is was revealed in crunchy dreams event that it was indeed oyster cookie ancestor who betrayed black pearl cookie
When i heard Black Pearl's sob's i emiadly thot it was squid ink cookie, but then when i heard the lafther in that moment i know that is not squid ink cookie
Those sobs reminded me of Sea Fairy's longing for Moonlight cookie. Could just be me though. She probobly does that to taunt divers or because her precious pearl is missing.
@@Creatorsan i actually thought that too. When my mum saw it, she said that she was told that mermaids cried or sang to lure pirates and divers into the deep
I always love connecting cookies to each other, and I've made some connections using this event. Until we get more information about who betrayed BP, I think it was either Oyster or Captain Ice.
I think it’s pretty obvious who betrayed Black pearl. The only person who has a treasure of the Black Pearl presumably hers and can swindle their way with promises is Oyster. It also explains why she didn’t destroy what was supposedly a ship belonging to house oyster. Talk about but the elders being really corrupt
Captain Caviar being the exception tho, he seems to be just an honest captain wanting to protect the Lower Town and the Republic from threats, as well as living for the thrill and adventure at the seas, huge respect ✨✨
I think it might be someone from House Oyster since the ship was described as an earlier era design but it also could be her when she was rising to power 😐
Why the heck did I think it was the diver?
Okay but what if captain ice cookie was in house oyster someone said in her lobby there was a picture of captain ice cookie so Maybe captain ice cookie helped oyster cookie to go to black pearl and shes mad at both of them
Ooo the plot thickens.
I had a bad feeling about Oyster since she was released.
Can we all just appreciate Rookie Cookie being all adorable and squealing over Captain Caviar's storytelling? 🤲
Is there no other word than "appreciate"?
it's gonna be weirder if it changed
Pufferfish cookie
@@kutakachicky can we just admire
Im your 1000th like❤
Whoever voiced Black Pearl Cookie needs an oscar. She gave such an amazing performance! That was some fine ass voice acting!
It’s the same woman who voices bernadetta from fe3h!! She’s so talented 🎀🎀
@@KAZUN0s Alongside Arle Nadja & Ayaka Kamisato!
@@KAZUN0s Yeah, it's Erica Mendez! The same person who voiced White Lily Cookie and Maki from Danganronpa and Ryoko from Kill la Kill!
@@AzulStryer not everything is abt Genshin
@@trustcatty2716 Yes I know but I explicitly mentioned Puyo as well
Theory: i believe oyster betrayed black pearl. In a cut scene caviar was talking about a ship that very much looks like the ships of house oyster. While he was saying that the ship we were seing on screen was the one on the very top. Later after caviar said to black pearl: "along with all this debri, that one singular ship is on the very top. Almost as if your cherishing it or it reminds you of someone." Or along those lines. Black pearl was enraged after that. Further proof is that oyster owns an item that very much reassembles black pearl. Even the description fits it. So in conclusion i belive that oyster betrayed black pearl by possibly leaving her but left a ship, then black pearl gave oyster a pearl to remind her of black pearl. And even after years black pearl is still hoping she will come back. Hoping the first ever cookie to ever understand her will comeback. However after the years even if she very much loves oyster. She cant help but think oyster realy left her. And so her anger grew and grew. To this point in time.
You have a point, remember Oyster cookie's event? There's something similar to a black pearl there
@@youbettersayyestomentos6514 Maybe it is true, but what if Oyster do not 'owe' Black Pearl something, but stole from her instead? I remembered in Black Pearl's loading screen it says something about 'if a mermaid loose their pearls, then they will fall to the darkness of the sea' or something close like that. What if Oyster actually stole Black Pearl true, clean, irridescent pearl away from her that turned her into the monster she is now? If so, Oyster said grand scheme seems to lead as either a bargain for loyalty (most unlikely, but remains a possibility) or eradicating Black Pearl for good so that no one will ever threaten her sea trades bussiness ever (most likely?)
@@charlotteillion2755 theres also oysters fountain where she seems to try to remember something but shrugs it off. She must've been young when she stole it and when that old ship was sailing with her on it, she must've told black pearl how she didn't remember whatever promise they had. Either that or oyster promised to bring it back but forgot.
You have a really good point there
Good theory
My theory:
Since Black Pearl said her wrath is a century old, Oyster can't have betrayed her. Instead, maybe House Oyster's ancestors? They might have got their eyes on the Black Pearl now currently in House Oyster's treasury, and befriended Black Pearl Cookie just to get it
During their time with Black Pearl, she might have started to develop feelings for them
After that, House Oyster's ancestors stole what they wanted and left Black Pearl forever, never to be seen again
Since then, Black Pearl's rage built up inside her, and turned her into who we see today, letting out her hate on the Cookies she despised from anger
Even then, she's still a lil desperate, since she still had a pinch of feelings for them, and even kept one of House Oyster's ships after she sunk it, now beautifully well kept and treasured on top of the century old pile of wrath she created
(Sorry for the behemoth of an essay I created lmao)
This is a ver smart theory. Pretty sure essays are welcome though lol, so no worries.
Lore comments are naturally like this so no worries. Great theory too.
Ayo, I have the same theory
Holy shit, you're right. House Oyster fucking loves treasures like Eclair.
@@krystalized1108 plottwist it was eclair 😳😳//j
lot of people say that Oyster is the one betraying Black Pearl but Black Pearl bio state her wrath is over a centuary old. I think the cookie who betrayed her is simply dead and Oyster heritated from it. She probably isn't even aware of its origin. at least that my point of view
Black Pearl has a scratched photo of Captain ice so its probably her
@@Myname-nx6vn you think Captain Ice is 100 years old?
@@Iskou307 oyster cookie isnt 100 maybe her ancestors stole it
it's probably an ancestor of oyster cookie
@@Iskou307 captain ice could be her ancestor
23:18 "silly, naive child" DON'T YOU DARE SLANDER SORBET'S DREAM LIKE THAT
Poor Sorbet😭
Someone should make a video of sorbet soloing her boss fight
@@MasterIsabelle She's to strong
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 NOT SORBET
So she was the one who made sorbet shark cookie have legs
23:21 she is talking about sorbet shark cookie! This is now clear to me that black pearl cookie is a reference to the sea witch Ursula from my little mermaid. 🧜♀️ ✨️ the crown on her head is a give away too and the fact that she has a staff.
Yeah i thought of the same thing!
I think she might’ve referred to squid ink, although that’s just my guess.
@@Starrial the key words "wanted to become a cookie" was the giveaway the it's sorbet shark cookie.
help no she isn’t..
@@sunsetklee yes she is?? did saying this make you feel cool or something lol
I don't think she's a villain or antagonist. She feels betrayed and hurt by someone who made a promise to her. And if I remember correctly, Oyster has a black pearl from her gacha stuff. Maybe the cookie Black Pearl was friends with was Oyster or maybe she had feelings for a different cookie who broke her heart. She is doing this all out of anger and pain, not to be a horrible cookie. She just needs to be fixed :>
tbf it sounds like she murdered countless of cookies
That's what villains are
Or just an antagonist
But not a villain
yeah honestly I want to help her get what was taken from her.
*Mike really has the power to finish Stories faster than most people do. He is like Dream Except it's a CRK Version of him.*
Nah Mikes faster
wha 😰 Dream not fast at all :\
Mike is better than Dream
IDK IF HE SHOULD TAKE A COMPARATION AS AN INSULT😭😭😭😭😭
@@zakae9390 Nope, it's not an "insult" to me. I think he laughs whenever someone says that to him
Caviar: perhaps the ship reminds ya of an old memory?
Black Pearl: and I took that personally
Candy Diver's costume in the last cutscene as the Salty Shark Navigator is pretty cute! I hope we can get that from the Boutique in the future.
i dont tend to like the game's soundtrack a lot but man the songs for this event are so fucking cool, candy diver's theme is so haunting i love it
I was like “omg this voice actor is so good to be true” then it didnt took me long to find out she was a voice actor of a danganronpa character aswell
damn.. that explains it
which dr character??
WAIT I FOUND OUT! The voice actor behind Black Pearl Cookie also voiced Maki Harukawa and Nagisa Shingetsu from Danganronpa 👍
My sibling said that voice was familiar and searched the va on youtube, Im not really watching danganronpa at all 😭
ayaka vc
"Is it the dark sea monster who devours coins?"
Kid I like your description of Squib
Ooo I wonder if Squib and her are related.
@@Creatorsan tbh I think they are even if not I'll make it a hc
Squib
They nailed the voice actors impressions again
in the beginning story absolutely not
the naïve kid, is she talking about sorbet shark? he is a shark, but now is also able to turn into a cookie.
*they are
@@adamk201_yt skull
she could’ve also referred to squid ink as well
I think shes talking abt sorbet
I love the voice actor for Black Pearl Cookie! They’re really amazing.
The story is good too, but it ended up on a unresolved note. I hope we get some answers to what happened with Oyster’s Ship and all that jazz.
There is a black pearl in oyster cookies house so that could mean she stole the black pearl and made black pearl cookie angry
The voice actor for Black Pearl also voiced White Lily, so yeah..
@@mxddie4006 she didn't have many voice lines for white lily.
for some reason i hear traces of white lily. most sound like she gonna murder pv
@@Krowos
W.L has like 5 voicelines
Her voice actor also voices White Lily Cookie. It's a complete difference cuz White Lily Cookie sounds like 😟☹️☺️, but Black Pearl Sounds like 😡👹☠️💀😈👿🤬😠
I have a small theory. Maybe the cookie who betrayed Black Pearl Cookie was Sea Fairy Cookie since Black Pearl Cookie began to sink all the ships and Sea Fairy Cookie didn’t want to do that
yeh like the story wasn't obvious enough 😐
@@makushonjongramiresu1577 Bro💀
@@makushonjongramiresu1577 That wouldn't explain why the Boat at the top of Black Pearl's den is perfectly in shape and devoid of bruises though.
She seems to give too much importance on her reputation as a terrifying monster, while making sure *nobody* could possibly think she had a "mere cookie" as a friend/lover/acquaintance.
Actually, I think it's might have been someone from House Oyster. Captain Caviar described the ship as bearing the symbol of House Oyster but of an older model. Perhaps one of Oyster Cookie's ancestor was on that ship along Black Pearl Cookie, and something happened that sunk the ship and turned Black Pearl Cookie into what she is now. Oyster Cookie might actually have known this story and sent Captain Caviar to confirm her suspicion.
envoy pfp W 💪
Oyster almost definitely betrayed Black Pearl. Remember in the “House Oysters Collection/Luxuries”? One of the items was a “Lustrous Black Pearl” . The description was "A black pearl from the depths of the sea. You may marvel at its luster, but beware: its dark shade will carry you to the endless abyss of the pitch black sea." Which sort of means that it belongs to Black Pearl since shes from the depths of the sea (and also the name suggests otherwise). It’s probably not that specific pearl she’s after, since black pearls likely show up often in the Duskgloom Sea, but perhaps Oyster has something else that Black Pearl wants. Another theory is that Oyster made a promise to help Black Pearl Cookie by saying maybe like “If I save/help you, you give me black pearls (or whatever) in exchange” but Oyster betrayed BP after accumulating enough luxuries and broke the promise? Idk just a theory.
Black pearl was probably just a normal, kind-hearted mermaid who served as a protector of the sea (like the lore about them says), but either oyster or her ancestors betrayed her by stealing her pearl, cursing her into descending to the dark abyss, and now wants revenge on all cookies for what they've done to her.
I know there's corruption amongst the republic elders/houses, but damn oyster is just messed up. Hell I think all the pearls used for the cookie legion were from other mermaids they betrayed, and unlike black pearl, those perished in the abyss, hence why we didn't see more mermaids till now, like what the hell man.
Unless Oyster is over 100 years old then it likely isn't them..Black Pearl was betrayed over a century ago
A theory: Oyster in her decor and on clothes has white pearl right-
We can see in Black Pearl islands a mermaid, when we choose +crit,atk, etc.. But what if black pearl cookie was actually White pearl? Someone who oyster knew? But after she betrayed pearl, she turned into chaos/bad side.. who knows
It is very possible that she has turned to the bad side, as you see a statue of her from a good version, when you pull her
@@hirtyu8981 Yes, I saw that too but forgot to mention it here
Her story really is interesting, because comparing to other legendary cookies, we know black pearl in like 5% of whole history, knowing devsis
I hope in next uptade when Candy diver cookie will come we will know about her more
Recent update thoughts? How do you feel about being mostly right :)
@@rubesty I feel wonderful 😽✨
Wow! This aged like fine wine, baby!
SO SHE WAS THE ONE WHO MADE SORBET SHARK A COOKIE! I CALLED IT!
@@nugudays no
@@nugudays
Sorbet shark cookie has been in kingdom for a little over a year at this point, if you didn’t know, that’s kind of on you.
@@nugudays don't scroll in the comments if you don't want spoilers
:O TWO CAT PFPS IN A ROW!?
23:18 Sorbet Shark
24:09 Abalone
28:26 Lord Oyster
And the worst of all is, Lord Oyster never managed to got things right with her 😭
I'm still not sure if this is his fault or Abalone cookie's fault
@@snowmationsI Thinks It's Abalone's Cookie'S Fault
I finally realized.
It's Sea Fairy's.
why? can u explain?
@@snowmations
@@kkikkodan She didn't give White Pearl the power. In the beggining of Mermaid's tale.
I thought the voice for the Desperate Chief Mate NPC belonged to OvenBreak's Pirate Cookie when the update trailer came out
so did I, I got hyped
(Spoilers)
Dang.... Imagine you made a friend who helped you out of a dangerous situation and ended up finding they're dead ☹️
so do you mean Scuba Diver Cookie, right?
@@stalloneandrew9961 Candy Diver Cookie
@@pppppaaaaarrrrriiiiisssss wait im confused, dead?
@@strawberrybreeze4 more spoilers
Candy diver is actually a ghost. Im pretty sure their friends and them died by drowning
@@pppppaaaaarrrrriiiiisssss ohhh i forgot about that 😭 wasnt rlly paying attention
One year later, we finally get some more lore.
24:11 I can't help but think Black Pearl cookie is referring to pirate cookie and squid ink. I love all the void details.
Black Pearl cookie deceived in some way by a cookie, I love the thought of that. Looks like captain Caviar cookie struck a nerve.
i'd say captain ice is also a candidate, since the cookie in the broken picture frame in black pearl's background resembles her a lot
Don't forgot at 23:18 Black Pearl Cookie mentioned "that silly, naive child who wanted to becoming a Cookie" implying to be Sorbet Shark Cookie himself
after rewatching the part when cap cavier was looking at the shrunken ships, the fact that he recognized that one of them was similar to house oyster's models and was left presumably unharmed gives me an idea that it could also be oyster
after all in the beginning she did asked him to give her any info on what's happening in that area of the sea + in her decors, specially the fountain, a statue of a mermaid can be seen
@@stalloneandrew9961 themself*
Sorbet shark is Non-Binary
It's been a little bit since this update, and I still can't get enough of that double-voice effect on Black Pearl Cookie
me too!! it makes her so menacing i love it
A literal cookie game has such good lore that most of the story games on roblox can’t compete. 10/10 I am recommending.
The Lore alone is enough to make a whole animated series and entire movie trilogy for god sake the world building is insane I love it❤.
Story games on roblox 😭out of all the things you could compare it to 😭😭 most of the story games on roblox are bad so it's not hard to surpass it's writing
did oyster cookie somehow betray black pearl? i mean captain caviar cookie said that the ship on top that looked like was being treasured looked like house oysters earlier design era, and the mermaid on oyster cookies decor, interesting...
I love caviar.. but dang black pearl has been through a lot.
The VA of Black Pearl Cookie did a great job especially with the laugh
to me the korean ver did all way better than this
Twizzly Gummy's Mommy 😰😰
wonder who's the one that betrayed black pearl ? People say it's oyster while the ruined mirror in black pearl's lobby has a reflection that looked like captain ice from CROB
also i'm glad that candy diver is now a part of captain caviar's crew , hope to see more stories about them and the crew
This is what I think about candy diver cookie, Candy diver is a cookie who is looking for his friend after they traveled to the dusk gloom sea while they were adventuring they forgot where they were so candy diver headed to the sparkling corals but his friend was not there so for years candy diver cookie kept searching for his friend not knowing that his friend had died because of black pearl cookie, candy diver kept searching for his friend not knowing that his dough had already melted from staying in the dusk gloom sea for so long when he realized it he never tried taking off his helmet years had past and candy diver still thought his friend was alive so when he saw captain caviar he had hope that his friend may be alive but saw that it was captain caviar when captain caviar considered candy diver cookie as his friend it reminded candy divers friend and because of that they were able to leave when captain caviar requested that he take off his helmet he was hesitant but decided to do it leaving captain caviar in shock that his dough had melted and he was a wandering ghost who left his helmet on candy diver decided to keep diving into the dusk gloom sea to help other cookies just like he did with captain caviar
Why Candy Diver Cookie’s friend didn’t become a ghost like them after they die?
I think the friend might have become a ghost too
Woah, there are many types of ghosts in cookie run: a ghost that is just like the alive cookie (onion), a ghost that is a white version of the alive cookie (pirate), a ghost that is different from the alive cookie (white ghost), a ghost that is a spirit (sherbet) and now candy diver. Their friend can turn into any of these
I am pretty sure Candy Diver Cookie are staying on the surface with Captain Caviar Cookie after helping him
@@villona277yeaa if u didnt notice the salty ship navigator crew doing all the cleaning chores doesnt talk and at the very end of the story the last words were stars and dots etc which implies it's candy diver cookie itself who now works on the ship
Oysters decor has a statue of black pearl on it, so more connections to those two
Oh god we have horror in the ocean now, this is not going to end well...
It’s like Iron Lung!😱
@@animiostudios Sea Fairy probobly knows about her. Who knows what they may have talked about.
Sea fairy does control water..
I was right on a theory about her used to be good
So she got betrayed which led her to this. Got betrayed by Oyster's ancestors.
In her description, she has a century old wrath which means.. It's been a hundred years
That's why that specific ship is not damaged, she's close to it
I don't know why there's a photo of Captain Ice tho
Candy Diver Cookie...
Is adorable
@@little_mx_perfect i agree
theyre memories are cute
Reminds me of Sorbet tbh
apparently, Candy Diver Cookie's face reveal was just........... oh
-Candy Diver Cookie's already been just water and two gumballs, it was already clearly seen at the trailer- ouch
14:51 *"your rent is due, Caviar."*
Black pearl is more meaner scarier and eviler then dark enchantress... i think
definitely not. she only attacks if they come near her waters. DE wants the entire world to be hers lol
@@kachosuffer7 oh yeah i forgot
(Seriously blackpearl voice is soo scary)
@@Dugong_8 the rookie cookie sounds just like cotton cookie and cream puff too
Hii😊
It’s kind of surprising that captain caviar can just stay calm and brush off the negativity that black pearl spews at him, it’s like that one character that can’t be provoked in any way and can understand those who like provoking other people, along with their intentions
32:16 geez woman, calm down😧
29:46 sounds a bit tsundere to me
I love how she's basically Pinkie Pie but evil and the terrifying concept of Cala Maria monsterous tendencies and size. Yes. JUST YES.
When black pearl said “your the first one to come here since that silly naive child who wanted to become a cookie” I couldn’t help but think of sorbet
it iss he approached her and in return for his voice she gave him the ability to turn into cookie so now while in his cookie form he only goes ooOOoOOoOoOoOooOOOOo, additional note: in their interaction sorbet shark cookie doesnt mind losing his voice at all and is happy to become a cookie
33:43, THE F**KIN ANIME SOUND EFFECT, I CANNOT BELIEVE- XD
Can we just appreciate the voice actors real quick? Like, Black Pearls VA absolutely slayed.
OH HI THERE-
@@RubyChocoCookie HEYYYYYYYYY
How did Black Pearl's VA keep their voice after the laughs?
im not even focusing on the main cookies…..the npcs are adorable
After finishing the mermaid tale, I come back to rewatch this
Your not alone. I appreciate them for this
Same lol
Same lmfao
Same lol
Same
I actually like this story, but my main favorite is the cotton cookie and frost queen cookie story tbh, but this is probably one of top 5 fav favorite story’s
HSJXHXX WE R SIMILAR HAHAHA my fav is a mermaids tale and the cotton cookie sherbet cookie story is my 2nd fav, 3rd is this then the last is white lily cookies story, all i can rmb for now
Did yall notice how Oyster and Black Pearl Cookie look so familliar? and yet there's a shell on both of their chest...
shellboobies
Because Pearl And Oyster are similarly related..
@@kutakachicky I'm starting a theory that Black Pearl and Oyster are twin sisters
@@Beta_Clouds LOL
But what about BPC's galaxy sparlky tail? How was she made initially? Is that where Sea Fairy comes in to the story? (You know, she's the lesbian water goddess that yearns to see Moonlight cookie again.)
Speaking of which.. what would their relationship be like?
Can’t believe this was 11 months ago now we finally know what really happened to her.
Captain caviar: I dont fear such a Barnacle head like you!
Black pearl: So you have chosen.. Crumble!
Captain Caviar: *Says heartfelt words*
Candy Diver: Wtf are you doing are you trying to kill us both?
her voice literally suits her character such ursula and medusa in one as the same picture 😂
i want to know her backstory too though
Well! I’m the future and we got her backstory…check out mermaids tale
The true story: White pearl gave lord oyster her pearl. Black pearl was used to live in tearcrown. Black pearl as white pearl was trying to have strength and powers from a sea fairy tear. However, Absorbing the sea fairy tear has negative effects. Which happened to octopus cookie. Which turned octopus cookie into abyss monarch. And white pearl absorbed the sea fairy tear. Which shattered the sea fairy tear and was nowhere to be seen. Turning white pearl into his dark self. Maybe that's why black pearl felt betrayed and wants to kill anything for thise who set foot on HIS sea.
U were right up until the end, yes she gave lord oyster her Pearl and yes she absorbed the sea fairy tear but before that happened lord oyster had given (well sold) the Pearl to his enemy so that he could help restore house oysters reputation, he regretted his decision cause he did care for white Pearl cookie (i think he loved or had feeling a for her) but when she found out what he did she was mad and didn’t let him explain, then afterwards she absorbed the sea fairy tear and turned into black Pearl cookie
Mike can finish the stories faster than anyone else 😇
Is it just me or do I love Candy Diver Cookie a lot? They’re so damn cute. I just wanna hug them and squeeze them tight.
25:12 why would she call me out like that 🥺
The truth: White Pearl Cookie liked Lord Oyster but at some point after giving him her pearl, he sold it to Captain Abalone Cookie his partner... that's when Lord Oyster went insane for the sea treasures... to the point she gets corrupted by painful realisations that the Land cookies r toxic and unforgiving to the point she used her home dormain's Sea Fairy's tear against the assailants... hence her current state, she STILL hates them
Lord oyster wasn't really bad and corrupt
It was because of his whole family's situation and abalone smooth talking him into selling it
He really regretted selling it after what happened
that’s not the truth lmao
23:24 maybe the child was sorbet shark bc he only talks normal in his shark/mermaid form
23:17
if black pearl mentions squid ink cookie, this means that she definitely knows it. I wonder how they met. this also could mean that squid ink was possibly the one sobbing at the start of the story- although it might’ve been black pearl faking tears as well.
@@Mx_Rabbit I'm not sure if it was fake..she could of been crying before they showed up, but she started laughing as she was getting ready to wreck another ship (wrecking ships seems to make her feel better or at least take her mind off the pain of betrayal).
23:18 shes talking about sorbet isnt she?
24:08 SHES THE ONE WHO KILLED PIRATE COOKIE!?!
wait where did you hear that from? pirate cookie is dead?
@@a_ish2213 yea he is dead
he literally transforms into a ghost in ovenbreak
@@SodaSizzle oh dear that's new to me,, I'll go see it now. Thank you 😊
(35:42) bro why isn't gumball diver cookie a playable thing he's my favorite in all this
they will be playable soon dw brotha
they're gonna be playable soon
I find it so interesting that all the legendary cookies currently in the game are related to water or a form of it in some way
She’s so creepy yet so gorgeous and I’m inlove 😭✨✨✨
1:23 wasn’t expecting to hear him saying “Shit or…”Ship”
Man white pearl cookie doesn't deserve to be evil back then 😢
Black Pearl cookie is a Material Gworl 😎💅
Yas
damn I love her voice
😂😂
@@ashlxserii White lily’s voice?
Hmm Yall maybe Sea fairy and Black Pearl are sisters and by that time sea fairy was frozen so Black Pearl tried protecting her
At the same time if Sea fairy was frozen she needs to be the bigger sister
Could be true bcs she more powerful and can control the sea while black peark aka the little sis might just be starting to gain the power
Maybe we will See cannon like this and MAYBE we will see a pacifist side of Black Pearl
Captain Caviar is so fine
AYOOOOO
he really isn’t
@@hijklmnop682
yes he is
HELP??
So capitn caviar just walked up to black pearl cookie roasted her entire race then just left with a ghost wow
14:46 black pearl do be checkin out submarine
Imagine: Your just chillin' in your submarine and suddenly an eye AS BIG YOUR ENTIRE BODY appears out of nowhere. I would shriek my lungs out.
Remember the Luxury that was a Black Pearl on Oysters Banner? The Description even talks about the Abyss
The ship at the top of the pile at chapter 8 kinda looks like Captain Ice Cookie's ship
Spoilers but if you do Holliday cake event (2022) there will be a scene where Captain Caviar invites Oyster to sit on a ship deck and eat a cake with him and his crew. His crew is expecting noble woman to refuse such offer as it not noble like to eat a cake on a deck. But she agrees without a moment hesitation.
That makes me believe that she was a sailor herself. Thus photo of a sailor on Black Pearl screen. It’s not Captain Ice cookie. It’s young Oyster wearing same uniform.
I believe that house oyster is somewhat “young” maybe only one generation old. Maybe Oyster was a sailor as a teen or young adult, stole Black Perl’s Pearl got some money and created noble house.
She can be up to 80 years old (but just very healthy so she’s looking fresh). Thus the “century old grudge”. It’s not exactly 100 years, but maybe 50-60.
Black Pearl cookies voice reminds me of Mona’s voice from genshin impact at this moment 23:24
Actually, the va of black pearl also voices a Genshin impact character, but not Mona. She voices Ayaka
I'm pretty Oyster made a promise to Black Pearl Cookie but she had to leave her ship behind and Black Pearl cookie was waiting for her return and kept it in good conditions, thats why it still looks brand new. Probably years passed she was frustrated and her frustration turned into anger.
why does the sea mommy laugh like a dolphin 💀💀
The character and design of the silent sea is incredible specially the new character black pearl cookie who has the power and manipulation of water Wich means that she can take any shape of water and make the crew suffer in silence,I love her regardless on how evil she might be
@@Mx_Rabbit which makes her evil
*I love hearing Caviar's submarine speak Morse code language.*
THE ROOKIE COOKIE WHEN THEY ARE HAPPY IR EXCITED THEY LOOK SO CUTEE
So sorbet did make a deal with Black Pearl..
Ariel movie cookie version
*ariel flashbacks*
*me getting the little Mermaid flashbacks*
I know just realised there is a reference to sorbet shark cookie when she was referring to that one shark who wanted to become a cookie. More lore
Black pearl cookie was once of the kind mermaids out there , but oyster broke it bc she value precious Valuables more than friendship,she literally broke the promise,she did not think some town would be in danger bc of it,for now..She kept thinking of what happened to her and personality..her looks,and everyone that despises her,Sheesh..sometimes elders arent thinking a second thought,or research,i mean they are mature adult,how could they broke a promise to an mermaid?Its absurd,yet she got betrayed,but she still have oyster cookie ship,thats why she values that only 1 ship bc it reminds her only friend..Oyster cookie,Bc no one dares to visit the sea,bc it is quite dangerous to see,But 1 greedy cookie,the black pearl,she visited the see to get the pearl,make black/white pearl cookie trust her bc of her high expectations,shes maybe so happy that she finally got a friend..
She is so pissed because of lord oyster
damn already at that part??
🐳s make me jealous af 😭😭
please elaborate
If anyone is wondering, or even sees this, is was revealed in crunchy dreams event that it was indeed oyster cookie ancestor who betrayed black pearl cookie
When i heard Black Pearl's sob's i emiadly thot it was squid ink cookie, but then when i heard the lafther in that moment i know that is not squid ink cookie
I thought that too. They sound quite familiar. But honestly i like that
Those sobs reminded me of Sea Fairy's longing for Moonlight cookie.
Could just be me though. She probobly does that to taunt divers or because her precious pearl is missing.
@@Creatorsan i actually thought that too. When my mum saw it, she said that she was told that mermaids cried or sang to lure pirates and divers into the deep
The crying sounds a bit like squid ink cookie
Fun fact the voice actor for black pearl is the same voice actor for Ayaka in Gension impact
Cap: No one will venture into the duskgloom seas since we found out who lives here
Squid ink cookie hanging out in the corner staring
I love this, balck pearl is my fave cookie
tysm mike i was sick of grinding for the story
I swear to god I love Republic Sailor cookie 2's voice acting lmao
Why do I like this story so much?
She sounds like junko enoshima but its prob just me
Edit: nvm she voice Maki from V3
Salty shark navigator is actually, candy diver cookie
LITERALLY WHEN I DID MY FIRST 10 DRAW OF THE UPDATE I GOT CAVIAR 😭
me too just a first 10 draw :)
SAMMEEE WITH A COPY OF SEA FAIRY
SAME
Why is she talking about cookies that way.. even tho she’s a literal cookie herself-
hypocrisy at it's finest
mercookie
I always love connecting cookies to each other, and I've made some connections using this event. Until we get more information about who betrayed BP, I think it was either Oyster or Captain Ice.