Partita in C Minor, BWV 826, Johann Sebastian Bach, Karmen Grubisic - Piano
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
- 0:00 - Title Page
0:04 - Sinfonia
5:05 - Allemande
10:33 - Courante
12:38 - Sarabande
15:14 - Rondeaux
16:41 - Capriccio
Recorded on February 27, 2021.
Not afraid of expressive freedom this interpretation. A breath of fresh air. Sometimes Bach is played in a rather anaemic way. Not here!- i like it
i was appreciating that she played it straight.
damn brother tell me who else you listen to.
i will probably like them
Bach to me has always been full of life. Thank you for your kind words!
❤
id prefer academic way
I think the piece could have done without the melodramatic and rather indulgent movements and flourishes. Let the music stand on its own. No need to wave your hands about for attention.
Wonderful depicts Bach genius, repects what I believe are passages that should be played in the “Bach traditional way” and what a creativity to show Bach genius in a superb interpretation full of freedom and no attachments, I guess Bach would aplaude.
Absolutely wonderful. This is Bach playing of the first order. Superb tempos, crystal clear articulation. Perfect!
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
That is very kind, I appreciate it :)
Thank you!
Your disciplined dynamics are so in-sync with your retards! Wish I had that kind of control. Brava! 🤗🎹💕💓🎶🎵
Every piano student should be required to see the left hand wrist freedom at 18:53. Incredible performance!
I just didn't want that to end. Absolutely wonderful. Thank you, Karmen, for all your years of hard work.
I cant decide which one is more elegant the piano, the music or the pianist?
La pianista ❤❤❤❤❤17.9.2023
perfect tempo, meticulously crafted phrasing... It's a very delicate interpretation
Thank you very much :)
I highly doubt you’ll read this, and I don’t comment on youtube videos hardly ever, but you play in the most wonderful fashion. How much would a man have to go through to see you play in person?
I started learning to play piano after I retired. It was so difficult to tell my fingers what to do. When I was so discouraged, somebody told me to play Bach. I have been playing Bach ever since. I love Bach. Listening to your performance confirms why I like Bach, how Bach could be so helpful. So great performance. So musical voicing. Bravo!
There cannot be someone more beautiful than you, if I am not the pencil that draws your happiness, I will be the eraser that erases your sadness.
I didn’t believe that’s possible to “own” Bach until now
FANTASTIC thank you
You're so kind, thank you!
@@bwv232 thank you, but I’m not kind, you are fantastic and I wish you the best
I know what’s take to get an expression in art,
Best wishes
Fantastic rendition you've done! I love the personal touches you've included, it really adds to the music and makes it your performance.
What a magnificent rendition. The legato touch, the moments of rubato and your weighting of the different voices were all sublime. According JSB's masterpiece with a fresh and original sensibility
I don't understand anything about music.
@@FringeWizard2 thats good. everyone else here is an absolute nerd
I really appreciate when the beauty of a performance moves me to tears.
Chapeau bas! Very moving and interesting interpretation. Without distorting Bach. Thank you so much!
Absolute brilliance, what a joy to listen.
As a professional pianist i must say this is one of the best renditions of this piece. I compliment for the depth of the interpretation. It takes a lot of work to find a personal way of thinking this kind of music without exaggerate things and sound out of context. And you did it wonderfully.
Bravo 👏 Just as I love my Bach ! Rhythmically precise & alive yet freshly interpreted with beautifully & immaculately marked dynamics, phrasing & voicing. The slower mvts were also beautifully introspective & pensive. You made my heart sing. Many thanks 👏🏆
Bravo! Brought tears to my eyes; truly magnificent!
wunderbar gespielt mit einer diskreten romantischen note, grosse interpretationskunst. bravo
Vielen Dank! Das war mein Goal mit dieser Interpretation.
Very unique interpretation! It showed new sides of the piece to me! Wonderful!
It is a delightful experience to simultaneously listen to beautiful music flowing from your fingers and watch the pure and sincere passion that makes a girl irresistible.
Stunning performance! Standing ovation to you!
Dam.... I came back for the QUALITY O_O WOW
Bravo !
Really !
Sincérement c'est incroyable!
Bravo, such an emotional reading of a stunningly gorgeous piece! Bach was likely the greatest musician of all-time and this is an amazing performance. Thank you for sharing!
Wow, the sound she achieves is just incredible 🤩
Superbe interprétation pleine d'énergie, de vie et d'élégance .... Bravo
immense pleasure, thank you very much! a quite solid performance
Beautiful!
Thank you. You gave us great pleasure. Beautiful playing.
I planned to work while this played in the background but instead I am on the edge of my seat listening, incredible rendition, thank you
Wonderful, many heartfelt congratulations Karmen!
Wonderfully conveyed. Very expressive. Thank you
The 2nd keyboard partita is usually one I sort of skip over but oh my god you just made me appreciate it so much more. This was just fantastic-what a lovely interpretation.
I'm so glad!
@@bwv232 the word "interpretation" is so utterly lofty and pompous. I just say, "I LIKE THE WAY YOU PLAYED IT". If you want classical music to extend to new audiences, stop using BS terms like "interpretation", because it excludes them. They'll never get, that that's just a snobby code for "HOW IT'S PLAYED, which they could understand !
@@michaelholme ... In no particular order: First, OP used the word interpretation, not the channel, so your @ was misplaced. Second, interpretation has a distinct meaning from _how_ something is played; it is not a 'BS term', and was used correctly here. Third, it's not your place to talk down to people for using a word you think is too advanced for beginners, even if that were correct - which it is clearly not. For the small percentage of the population that would be intimidated by a word like interpretation (and I imagine it must be a _very_ small percent indeed), then hopefully the fact that this is a message _between two people who clearly DO know what it means_ would mean even the most obtuse reader could let it lie. It might behoove you in future comments to re-examine your ideals pertaining to this topic, and to approach similar situations with caution, being yourself aware of this issue.
In other words? Don't be a dick. People can talk however the f*** they want.
P.S. The word pompous means "affectedly and irritatingly grand, solemn, or self-important". There's only one comment in this thread that fits that description.
@@michaelholme Haha!! No, "interpretation" is not some obscurely technical term. It's a commonly used word that keeps its common meaning in this context. There are terms that you could make that complaint about, but that's not one of them. Don't underestimate people so severely!
@@GreeneyedApe I've played classical piano for 34 years. Taught it, and listened to much piano. For the longterm survival of classical music in the widest sense, we HAVE to break the dominance that the middle-class has over it. Poncey terms like "interpretation" are an example of the unnecessary exclusivities and jargon, that are rife.
Simplemente perfecto.
An absolute delight. Thank you
crazy skill, mad respect.
Definitely, it was an excellent performance with an excellent technic and full of feelings. Very good job.
Beautiful on all grounds.
Piękna gra - dziękuję i życzę dobrego dnia.
Es hermoso y sin igual, Grubisic es capaz de expresar las ideas de Bach ,su orden y belleza sublime, de una manera tan apasionada que llena el alma.
Bach is one of my favorite composers. Good interpretation.
I am stunned. Just a random youtube recommendation - and for 20 minutes i moved to another dimension. Great performance, thank you very much
Truly incredible emotion and energy given by your playing. I have only just discovered your work and look forward to experiencing more.
I never knew befor Bach can sound so gently-love
MASTERLY played! BRAVO!!
Outstanding. Never heard you playing before. I definitely thoroughly enjoyed this performance.
no soy de escuchar musica clasica pero disfrute tu interpretacion, gracias por esos 20 minutos de paz mental
You make the piano sound like it's speaking. Beautiful and unique performance, thanks for sharing.
Bravissima!!!Mille grazie Patagonia Argentina.
Amazing timing and precision.
Bach would be proud. magnificent playing. great job!
Je n'ai pas entendu une proposition de discours sur cette partita aussi pertinent depuis Glenn Gould.
Bravo et merci
Purely beautiful…
Absolutely beautifully played - some parts sounded a bit like Schumann! Bach’s music is astounding! Thanks for posting! 🍒🍀🦋🎹🎶💐🦜🥰🌹🎈🦜🦎🎈😀
Many thanks!
Non of it sounded like Schumann: Robert or Clara. They didn't write out-and-out counterpoint like that. What Schumann piece do you mean?
I throughly enjoyed this. Great performance!
Glad you enjoyed it!
What wonderful playing. I've often struggled to get into Bach when compared to later composers as his music tended to be unintuitive to me, but this is, in a word, beautiful. Thanks for sharing and helping me appreciate some new music!
I still don't know how to get a Bach repertoire lol, with dedication I can learn a piece but then I'll eventually forget it when learning a new one, this is just a big struggle to retain, very difficult for me to wire/map memory landmarks
I love listening to this while working
..... impeccable
Bach é muito foda! E a moça também arrasa.
Think i fell in love. In a spiritual and physical way 💘
This is beautiful! 👏👏👏
jovencita..crei que el arte habia muerto,veo que en usted renace...
Very Beautiful.
Absolutely fantastic rendition!👋
This is a beautiful performance and I think yours is my favorite over other recordings. I love your dynamics and expression.
Bravissima! 🌹🌹🌹
Actualmente estoy trabajando en mi libro de poesía. Tu música me acompaña mientras leo y releo los mismos poemas.
Sublime!
My God, my heart... that was breathtakingly beautiful. You have captured the inimitable poignance of both the piece and the instrument.
Wonderful interpretation !
I really enjoyed it, well done 👏🏻👏🏻
Amazing. And she doesn't even flinch when something hits the window or explodes at 15:55
Beautiful
love this
i think i just fell in love
both for the playing and for you
You're impressive. And so young. Your instructor, as well as you personally, deserve UA-cam's congratulations.
You play for 20 minutes non-stop without reading the notes of the piece. You must have practiced to the point of suffering. 😨
Well done Karmen.Played with much freedom as in Bachs time.Lovely..A wonderful exciting journey.
Merci beaucoup, encore...
Beautifully played!
It is amazing! ❤
Sparkling brilliance!
Thanks for tremendous effort!
effort not as important as result in this case.
did you even listen?
joker.
Thank you! It's my pleasure.
I like this. Thank you for playing it.
Qué belleza! Tu interpretación tiene reminiscencias del estilo de Glenn Gould ❤ adoré
Just what I needed. perfection.. Thank you for sharing:)
So glad you enjoyed!
incredible
¡Absolutamente genial! :)
very well played! great job :)
Thank you :)
Great performance!
High sound quality and a magnificent pianist, that's all i need for a gratefull midnight before getting ready for sleep. Be proud of in what have you become because that talent befits the most value reward, a clearly well fed soul.
A most inspired rendering. I really like your accidental choices in the final movement.
I appreciate it :)
What a piano!!! It is being wonderfully played with a.. Words fail me. 😊
Absolutely tremendous playing. I am so jealous.
Super émouvant bravo pour l'interprétation
Merci!
Яркое, рельефное, цельное, стилистически продуманное исполнение! Браво!
Cпасибо большое!
thanks for the upload.
this rocked me
this lady can do it great. Bravo.
i see one beuty and listen another, that's great video.
Brilliant!
Es perfecta la COLA del piano! me encanta
XD ya me esperaba un comentario asi
Maravillosa !
¡Gracias!