Kim is a top tier winner. I don't get the hate she received for WaW. She had a pregame reputation that was nearly impossible to overcome. She was a top 5 player on that season.
Most of these people are not disgraced at all. They’re just disliked by vocal sections of the fan base. And why should they care? Internet trolls can’t stop them from spending their money.
There’s a lot of good players here like Natalie, what this Intro is referring to is people who have a bad reputation in survivor from certain appearances
@@lafingscarecrow I never said he deserves to get bullied. I said the backlash is justified bc his game was terrible, so calling him a “disgraced player” isn’t really applicable.
Link to the video where this idea was suggested to me in the description. I asked the commenter if they wanted to be given credit by name, and they declined.
Why is spencer a disgraced player? I loved him personally and don't think he should be there. But honestly good selection, I would agree with all of these completely!
I loved this video, unfortunately I’m more of a pre-All Stars kind of guy and will admit I haven’t seen all of the seasons, so some of these people I’ve heard of before but never seen them play
You should watch the newer seasons, especially those from Cambodia and afterwards. It’s a completely different game than pre all stars, but it’s fascinating to watch!
It was suggested to me to do an intro for a season of players whose reputations have been damaged, offering them a chance to prove themselves. That's what this video is.
If this was an Actual season, this would/should be the Cast placements from Start of the game to the end of the game: 20th Vecepia 19th Shirin 18th Stephenie 17th Bob Tribe Switch: 16th JT 15th Chris 14th Vytas Merge/Jury: 13th Danni 12th Jud 11th Andrew 10th Kim 9th James 8th Aubry 7th Natalie 6th Erik 5th Amanda 4th Noura Final Three: 3rd Ron- 0 Votes 2nd Kellee- 2 votes 1st Spencer- 8 votes Final Vote: 8-2-0
@@aScentlessApprentice Knock it off! I can list these competitors however I want, Besides, Spencer did have a good chance to win Survivor Cagayan if he made it to the final two, because everyone on the Jury before him (Sarah, Morgan, LJ, Jeremiah, Jefra, Tasha, and Trish) said they would've voted for him if he made it to day 39!
Vecepia is usually viewed negatively by many Survivor fans, Aubry was voted out with an idol and an Extra Vote in her pocket, James and Kelle went out with 2 idols.
@@dinohall2595 i feel like Aubrey is kind of like JT, every time she returns she plays a worse game. Koah Rong- a great game, almost won and imo deserved the win Game Changers- pretty much left out on every vote, but managed to get herself to final 5 EOE- voted out 5th, with an idol and an extra vote in her pocket
naw first of all its not a good idea, second of all this cast is literally fucking drawn from a hat the casting is worse the game changers everyone would just hate on the casting so much they couldn’t enjoy the season
Kim is a top tier winner. I don't get the hate she received for WaW. She had a pregame reputation that was nearly impossible to overcome. She was a top 5 player on that season.
Most of these people are not disgraced at all. They’re just disliked by vocal sections of the fan base. And why should they care? Internet trolls can’t stop them from spending their money.
W
I wished that Francesca made it to this cast lol
but then she would be the first boot again!
@@patriciomarce1344 she would for sure then have to eat that rock
k if where talking about 1st boots to bring to this cast i say chicken hed be a DAMN good time
There was nothing that Natalie did to be “disgraced”. She played a flawless social game and quickly realized what she needed to do to win and did it.
There’s a lot of good players here like Natalie, what this Intro is referring to is people who have a bad reputation in survivor from certain appearances
Revisionist history right here folks
@@winstonrusso7744so how's that work with the theme? Natalie doesn't have to atone for winning
David: uploads
Everyone: gotta think of a good comment quick!
The most deserving person of a second chance in survivor is absolutely Kellee, but there is no way she ever goes back on the show.
Fr but I can't blame her for staying far far away
Ok living for this
why isn't ben driebergen on this list? i mean he has been disgraced by pretty much the whole world (which he doesn't even deserve)
He absolutely deserves backlash for his win lol he played terribly in the end game and on WAW he had no shot of winning despite playing a decent game
@@voodoomcspaghettipants4082 so basically he deserves to be bullied by scumbags like you because of how he won? gtfo
It's not his fault, but still
@@lafingscarecrow plus, he won 1 mil by playing a shitty game so I likely doubt he gives a shit about the hate🤷♂️
@@lafingscarecrow I never said he deserves to get bullied. I said the backlash is justified bc his game was terrible, so calling him a “disgraced player” isn’t really applicable.
Link to the video where this idea was suggested to me in the description. I asked the commenter if they wanted to be given credit by name, and they declined.
Bob is the goat idc what nobody says
Goat in greatest of all time or goat that you bring to the end?
I could easily see Kim winning this season
This rlly good !
Thanks--I appreciate your suggestion!
I wouldn't really say Kellee needs to atone but otherwise not bad
Why is spencer a disgraced player? I loved him personally and don't think he should be there. But honestly good selection, I would agree with all of these completely!
I loved this video, unfortunately I’m more of a pre-All Stars kind of guy and will admit I haven’t seen all of the seasons, so some of these people I’ve heard of before but never seen them play
You should watch the newer seasons, especially those from Cambodia and afterwards. It’s a completely different game than pre all stars, but it’s fascinating to watch!
Varner and maybe Nick could’ve been on this list
Missed Sophie from the cast she redeemed herself in WAW but she got blindsided so she couldnt finish her business😢
And she is still underrated
Ron? Kim?
aubry has no real business being here
I’m confused, is this survivor all stars 2.0 or disgraced players, besides Natalie and Chris lol
It was suggested to me to do an intro for a season of players whose reputations have been damaged, offering them a chance to prove themselves. That's what this video is.
no I mean, some of them have clean records
@@Goof248 Such as?
Vecepia
Erik
If this was an Actual season, this would/should be the Cast placements from Start of the game to the end of the game:
20th Vecepia
19th Shirin
18th Stephenie
17th Bob
Tribe Switch:
16th JT
15th Chris
14th Vytas
Merge/Jury:
13th Danni
12th Jud
11th Andrew
10th Kim
9th James
8th Aubry
7th Natalie
6th Erik
5th Amanda
4th Noura
Final Three:
3rd Ron- 0 Votes
2nd Kellee- 2 votes
1st Spencer- 8 votes
Final Vote: 8-2-0
Savage will be voted out on day 21 AGAIN just like in pearl islands and cambodia
Agreed! Good one!
Spencer could never win, he doesn’t understand people well enough
@@aScentlessApprentice Knock it off! I can list these competitors however I want, Besides, Spencer did have a good chance to win Survivor Cagayan if he made it to the final two, because everyone on the Jury before him (Sarah, Morgan, LJ, Jeremiah, Jefra, Tasha, and Trish) said they would've voted for him if he made it to day 39!
James and steph in the same tribe 🤔
Wait what's wrong with vecepia, audrey, james and kelle?
Vecepia is usually viewed negatively by many Survivor fans, Aubry was voted out with an idol and an Extra Vote in her pocket, James and Kelle went out with 2 idols.
@@dinohall2595 i feel like Aubrey is kind of like JT, every time she returns she plays a worse game.
Koah Rong- a great game, almost won and imo deserved the win
Game Changers- pretty much left out on every vote, but managed to get herself to final 5
EOE- voted out 5th, with an idol and an extra vote in her pocket
amber is a great person for this cast
What about a season called forgotten players
I love this idea. Here comes Patricia Jackson, Ryan Aiken and Yve Rojas
@@jackpellford8007 I was thinking like half of Guatemala and Fiji’s cast
Now available here: ua-cam.com/video/E2pKRY9lv8Y/v-deo.html
🙂
Thanks. I wish as a twist one of these obscure players were randomly cast on a season. Now THAT is a cool twist
Why is Danni here?
She was third voted out in her long-awaited return as a result of a strategic error on her part.
Thank you for saving me the trouble of watching this. Danni is my favorite female winner.
Only one id change is Kim
what did amanda and kim do wrong neither one has had a bad game
Amanda lost in the finals twice due to a bad FTC performance and Kim was voted out after stepping out of a challenge for peanut butter.
@Raheem Fielder-Bey Do you have a source that confirms this? I'm not aware of challenges being rigged.
@@dinohall2595 supposedly tony broke the rules and kept his hand on the wall or something
people give so much crap to bob xD
naw first of all its not a good idea, second of all this cast is literally fucking drawn from a hat the casting is worse the game changers everyone would just hate on the casting so much they couldn’t enjoy the season