Trent's already been playing midfield under Southgate with walker at RB.... it's nothing new. Heck he's been playing cm/cdm on the national level since the u16s.
But for real though, is it possible though to play that high level City/Barca/current Arsenal high line/high press style of play at the international level? I'm assuming the players on the pitch need a reeeeeally good understanding of relative positions (not to mention the highest level of trust) for it to be pulled off successfully.
It's just silly that they're questioning his preference for Ramsdale even though Jack was trying to explain the basis of his selection which is driven by the system he prefers to play in. For obvious reasons, they picked their team based on their preferred system with no playing out the back and back-3 to allow the wing-backs to contribute more in attack.
Jack's pick is a better pick to me than those other two. He's more pragmatic without prejudice. I am a City fan but would never start Walker because he has missed many games that I think it would be too early to start him.
@@Drizzle8481 I thought he picked only 3 Arsenal players. And don't forget Arsenal is the most inform team in the Premier at the moment. Do you remember when Spain won World Cup most of their players were from Barcelona because they were the best inform team. Same to Germany when they won in Brazil most of their players were from Bayern Munich.
Ben White and Saka have a good understanding/ relationship playing RB/RW. No point taking white unless you are going to take advantage of that and start him.
Unfortunately no number of Arsenal players are going to make England play good football. Trent and Walker are obviously more natural choices in their system.
Jack's right but for whatever reason pundits love to underrate arsenal players. Saka is the best rw in the squad. Ramsdale is a better all around goalkeeper (watch the recent Ben Foster video with the GK coach if you don't believe me) with much better distribution. White is the best English defender on form. He's one of only 2 players to make over 20 tackles at over a 70% success ratio and is a fantastic reader of the game and England best progressive passing defender behind trent.
@@andyh323so you know more about being a pro goalkeeper than a Premier league goalkeeper and a premier league goalkeeping coach? You sure you want to go with that?
I would have loved to see Harvey Barnes included. He’s a quality player, powerful with loads of pace, two good feet and can score and assist. If the media had been intelligent enough to pick up on it, and campaigned like they did for Maddison, I think the lad would have been a better choice than grealish or sterling.
He’s not as good as you think. Leicester fan, he’s good for us but he doesn’t offer anything different to rashford and sterling, and they both do it better than him so it wouldn’t make sense
You know the crazy thing is all three England 11 picks would work against any team in their group. But when they start getting into the later rounds with more technical oppositions is where it gets a bit crazy where one player has a slight edge over the other. Thank god I am not Southgate 😁
Sterling better than Saka with Walker at CB. Good god. Thanks, I needed that laugh.😂 Edit: Not to say Walker is a bad player. Very good, just not at CB in a 2 with an injury, even if he can start.
His idea is straight up the way Arsenal plays atm, Trent is Zinchenko's role except on the opposite side. The squad profile he picked is very similar to Arsenal's. The other 2 laughing about his team weird, Both are even putting Foden on the right when he doesn't even play there for the past 3 seasons, that space is occupied primarily by De Bruyne, Silva and Mahrez. Just check their heatmap. Why the hell would you not put Saka and Foden in their best spaces / position. And the last guy even omitted Saka, England's POTY from his squad, crazy.
Im an Arsenal fans and I totally understand Jack's tactics but in a tournaments mode that will have only 1 week to train, Southgate will be playing the most basic style since it is the most efficient style. Like what England did last WC, putting all tall player and hoping to score from set pieces. Maguire will forever be Southgate no1 choice. Maybe a smaller country with less competitive fixture and thus more training time, Jack's style might work
Ramsdale, White RB Walker Stones CBs Trippier LB, Rice holding mid Bellingham and Maddison, Saka RW with good partnership with white on the right flank, Kane CF Rashford LW
Wiltshire starting 11 is pretty good but only I don’t agree is Luke Shaw .. I would put tripper… Ben white is another I’m not sure quite frankly not much experience!
White has to go alongside Stones at CB. Saka has to start obviously. Despite Pickford's heroics for England, if England want to take the next step, Ramsdale must start as well
Wished people stopped talking over Jack, I actually feel like he goes a lot deeper than the others and sees the game differently. Is a bit wasted with people speaking over him when he is getting into tactical ideas.
I wouldnt start Ramsdale but id like him to. White and Saka have to start because White is probably the most composed player on that team. Never seen him panic.
You were laughing at Jack when he say TAA from right back would go in midfield with Rice and others defenders form line of 3 center backs? What you laugh to? Some of the best teams doing that for years
Ramsdale doesn't start - Pickford has had an outstanding season. Plus its like boxing you have to beat a champion, you can't remove Pickford unless you are head and shoulders better than him, and Ramsdale isn't.
Funny how none of the three teams included McGuire, but Southgate will probably play him. If McGuire plays and gets caught out of position and too slow to recover, I hope Southgate will finally realize what everyone else has been saying.
Trippier has to start. He’s can go left or right. He’s been the most consistent on both ends for the last year. Mainly because of health but that part of the game.
No. Jack described a 3223 system with the ball but Arteta sets up with more of a 235 with the ball with the full backs either side of Partey and the 2 attacking mids between Jesus and the wide forwards.
The only way maguire gets into the England team is if they play a back 3. This is because maguire has no pace whatsoever and that’s why Kyle walker plays as one of the 3 center backs to make up for pace. Another reason I think tomori should have gone. Maguire is awful and doesn’t know how to play in a back 2, as he shows for man utd.
You can't have Walker as a centre back. He can't read the game well enough to play centre back. His pace gets him out of trouble but he constantly let's players in behind him and a centre back you have to know when ease off and make sure the game is played in front of you not behind you. Awful awareness and positioning. Would play Stones and White as the centre backs, Walker or Trippier on the right and Shaw on the left.
Playing saka in lw is so stupid from bent. Saka is meant for the rw role. He came on against germany and changed the game alongside mount. Playing three at the back is just a negative approach against iran.
the most enticing for sure. I completely trust Rice as a single pivot. He's super tidy on the ball. And watching Jude and Maddison, even though they have next to zero experience playing alongside each other, is very interesting as well.
Whenever there's a good black player and a not so good white player yet a pundit says the not so good one is better in an England shirt then we should all know what time it is...a shirt could never be a deciding factor as to a players abilities
Trent would move more into the midfield and play those long passes and lobs to the front, its a great idea by Jack! But Southgate will go with a very negative mindset I have no doubt about that because he just sucks tactically!!
“In a England shirt”. Not like saka won player of the year for England or anything.
I saw jacks and thought wtf, then he explained and I grew to like it more, Trent doing what zinchenko does for arsenal would be amazing!
Don’t give Klopp ideas 😅
Trent's already been playing midfield under Southgate with walker at RB.... it's nothing new. Heck he's been playing cm/cdm on the national level since the u16s.
Stones and Pickford in for White & Ramsdale and its realistic if Southgate adopted Wilsheres set up
But for real though, is it possible though to play that high level City/Barca/current Arsenal high line/high press style of play at the international level? I'm assuming the players on the pitch need a reeeeeally good understanding of relative positions (not to mention the highest level of trust) for it to be pulled off successfully.
🥰
Jack explained that pretty well tbf, even though those 2 clowns kept interrupting him
bro how annoying are they when he's trying to make a point
It's just silly that they're questioning his preference for Ramsdale even though Jack was trying to explain the basis of his selection which is driven by the system he prefers to play in.
For obvious reasons, they picked their team based on their preferred system with no playing out the back and back-3 to allow the wing-backs to contribute more in attack.
He was Arteta's teammate and Wenger was his coach.
From Pep to Arteta to Jack
Nah after Arteta wins the prem for us within the next two seasons and leaves us for Barca we bring in Viera who will win champs
@@skp8748 after that we bring in Wilshere to win the club world cup.
@@skp8748 who after Vieira? Mertesacker? Fabrega#?
@@772364327rhdhqwag then we bring in Granit Xhaka to win the fifa World Cup and Euros 💯
@@hamster4810 Fabregas can go to Chelsea
Jack's pick is a better pick to me than those other two. He's more pragmatic without prejudice. I am a City fan but would never start Walker because he has missed many games that I think it would be too early to start him.
He picked all arsenal players how is that not biased?
@@Drizzle8481
I thought he picked only 3 Arsenal players. And don't forget Arsenal is the most inform team in the Premier at the moment. Do you remember when Spain won World Cup most of their players were from Barcelona because they were the best inform team. Same to Germany when they won in Brazil most of their players were from Bayern Munich.
@@tomodul2619 well said
@@tomodul2619 arsenal fans make me sick 13 games you’ve played well and now you’re comparing yourselves to Bayern Madrid and Barca it’s acc madness
@@saab2906 lol he’s a city fan
Jack was schooled under wenger and taking points from arteta I would listen to him over any of these guys
He was a flop who retired at 30 years of age 👍
@@peterkirk123 not for arsenal he wasn’t maybe elsewhere
@Rocky He`s on the right radio station for failed footballers Cascarino , Agbonlahor , O`Hara and Cundy will make him feel welcome 👍
@@peterkirk123 you're obsessed with him, commented about him everywhere
@@AB-gb6zz Stating FACTS in the Summer he got told by a Danish pub team " grab your coat pack your bags and clear off " 👍
Ben White and Saka have a good understanding/ relationship playing RB/RW. No point taking white unless you are going to take advantage of that and start him.
White's not playing rb, he's there as a cb back up.
Unfortunately no number of Arsenal players are going to make England play good football. Trent and Walker are obviously more natural choices in their system.
@@772364327rhdhqwag saka will be the main man
@@张杰维-p9m if Southgate is competent he will be.
Damn serious Wilshere is force to behold
An England team without Saka don't make any sense.
will say as a spurs fan that Jack has shown more common sense in a short youtube video than Southgate has the whole year.
Andy's so anti arsenal it's so jokes, he knows Saka is the better choice but he can't say it!
Jack knows 😂. You have to start Saka and white against Iran. The rapport that duo has. You don’t need to rely on the short training camp.
Jack's right but for whatever reason pundits love to underrate arsenal players. Saka is the best rw in the squad. Ramsdale is a better all around goalkeeper (watch the recent Ben Foster video with the GK coach if you don't believe me) with much better distribution. White is the best English defender on form. He's one of only 2 players to make over 20 tackles at over a 70% success ratio and is a fantastic reader of the game and England best progressive passing defender behind trent.
Honestly he's pretty much nailed the side, very similar to what I would do and would be such a dominant side with proper coaching.
Ben Foster is clueless. He thought the Wilson goal against Spurs was a foul.
@@andyh323so you know more about being a pro goalkeeper than a Premier league goalkeeper and a premier league goalkeeping coach? You sure you want to go with that?
Ramsdale is the worst out of the three. He was pathetic against PSV, Southampton, Man United etc etc. He's not better than Pickford at all.
Pickford has the 2nd best shot stopping stats in the league. If you don't know what PSxG +/-, educate yourself
I mean u ask his team, of course he pick his style and his favorite
Jacks team is so logical and probably the best 11 possible
These lot cannot even comprehend the most basic footballing concepts. It’s concerning for a professional media outlet
Andy doesn't even know what side Saka plays
I would have loved to see Harvey Barnes included. He’s a quality player, powerful with loads of pace, two good feet and can score and assist. If the media had been intelligent enough to pick up on it, and campaigned like they did for Maddison, I think the lad would have been a better choice than grealish or sterling.
He’s not as good as you think. Leicester fan, he’s good for us but he doesn’t offer anything different to rashford and sterling, and they both do it better than him so it wouldn’t make sense
Not good enough at all.
Who?
So Andy says Sterling due to form in an England shirt and then picks Foden over Saka when Phil Foden has done nothing for England
Saka also has done nothing for England
@@leviskhaemba5762 last competition against German saka is brilliant
@@leviskhaemba5762 pls do some research mate 🥰
@@rossog1980 i have
@@leviskhaemba5762 He’s done more than Foden
Once a gunner, always a gunner
Once a melt always one
Andy baffled by picking a team based on an actual plan and tactics all he knows is banter. And Bent too busy trying to fit in all the time.
You know the crazy thing is all three England 11 picks would work against any team in their group. But when they start getting into the later rounds with more technical oppositions is where it gets a bit crazy where one player has a slight edge over the other. Thank god I am not Southgate 😁
Sterling better than Saka with Walker at CB. Good god. Thanks, I needed that laugh.😂
Edit: Not to say Walker is a bad player. Very good, just not at CB in a 2 with an injury, even if he can start.
Exactly. Walker is quality but playing him in a 2 would be disastrous. He’s suited as a CB in a 3
Trent as a midfielder is what AMN used to do for Arsenal where he'd tuck into a midfield position as a RB
His idea is straight up the way Arsenal plays atm, Trent is Zinchenko's role except on the opposite side. The squad profile he picked is very similar to Arsenal's. The other 2 laughing about his team weird, Both are even putting Foden on the right when he doesn't even play there for the past 3 seasons, that space is occupied primarily by De Bruyne, Silva and Mahrez. Just check their heatmap. Why the hell would you not put Saka and Foden in their best spaces / position. And the last guy even omitted Saka, England's POTY from his squad, crazy.
Except Maitland Niles can't kick a ball straight
I know it's all playful but Goldstein's constant interrupting made this an impossible listen
Has Saka been better than sterling? “I just think in an England shirt”… lol bonkers
Saka has been miles better than sterling this season
Jack Wilshere for England manager?!
Am seeing Jack will be a very good tactical coach.
Im an Arsenal fans and I totally understand Jack's tactics but in a tournaments mode that will have only 1 week to train, Southgate will be playing the most basic style since it is the most efficient style. Like what England did last WC, putting all tall player and hoping to score from set pieces. Maguire will forever be Southgate no1 choice. Maybe a smaller country with less competitive fixture and thus more training time, Jack's style might work
Ramsdale, White RB Walker Stones CBs Trippier LB, Rice holding mid Bellingham and Maddison, Saka RW with good partnership with white on the right flank, Kane CF Rashford LW
Foden over rashford tho IMO
You can see being a coach has increased the way jack sees the game.
Wiltshire starting 11 is pretty good but only I don’t agree is Luke Shaw .. I would put tripper… Ben white is another I’m not sure quite frankly not much experience!
White has to go alongside Stones at CB. Saka has to start obviously. Despite Pickford's heroics for England, if England want to take the next step, Ramsdale must start as well
Wished people stopped talking over Jack, I actually feel like he goes a lot deeper than the others and sees the game differently. Is a bit wasted with people speaking over him when he is getting into tactical ideas.
Theres no way England should play without Trippier
Def both deserve to start..but Southgate will probably pick maguire over Ben White..which if he does would be scandalous !
Maguire doesn't play right back
@@peterkirk123 no but white is a better cb so rather he plays over maguire
I wouldnt start Ramsdale but id like him to. White and Saka have to start because White is probably the most composed player on that team. Never seen him panic.
Stones is England's best CB
@worldsforliving who's that?
Pickford just had a howler to prove Jacks point, Pope is doing better than him.
You were laughing at Jack when he say TAA from right back would go in midfield with Rice and others defenders form line of 3 center backs? What you laugh to? Some of the best teams doing that for years
Andy STOP INTERRUPTING AND LET HIM TALK!!!
Bent took a page out of Arteta's book. 2 RBs and 2 RCBs.
Ramsdale doesn't start - Pickford has had an outstanding season. Plus its like boxing you have to beat a champion, you can't remove Pickford unless you are head and shoulders better than him, and Ramsdale isn't.
You seen Everton?
Funny how none of the three teams included McGuire, but Southgate will probably play him. If McGuire plays and gets caught out of position and too slow to recover, I hope Southgate will finally realize what everyone else has been saying.
Jack wilshere is on smoke 😂😂😂
Trippier has to start. He’s can go left or right. He’s been the most consistent on both ends for the last year. Mainly because of health but that part of the game.
If was up-to-date Jack he would play Arsenal at the WC.
Ramsdale is englands best GK but Pickford always plays well
Isn't Jack copying Arteta's style?
No. Jack described a 3223 system with the ball but Arteta sets up with more of a 235 with the ball with the full backs either side of Partey and the 2 attacking mids between Jesus and the wide forwards.
Saka has to start but not White. Saka Kane and Foden should be the front 3… BUT Gareth Snoozegate will pick Sterling.
And still they put White and Saka on the left - wrong side. Wait for Saka to be in goal and Kane cent mid for Iran
Is jack on drugs? What a bizarre line up, didn't do himself justice with his analysis lol 😂
Sterling should not be starting
I can’t lie Goldstein has the deadest counter arguments 😂😂😂😂
nah these guys need to show jack more respect wtf
Wilshere onto something here
Against Iran, mine would be:
Pickford
Shaw, Maguire, Stones, White
Rice, Bellingham, Maddison
Foden, Kane, Saka
The only way maguire gets into the England team is if they play a back 3. This is because maguire has no pace whatsoever and that’s why Kyle walker plays as one of the 3 center backs to make up for pace. Another reason I think tomori should have gone. Maguire is awful and doesn’t know how to play in a back 2, as he shows for man utd.
Goldstein being incredulous that someone would pick Ramsdale over Pickford. Then picks Sterling over Saka
You can see tetball has influenced Jack
Completely agree with jack other than not choosing madison
Why are they mocking him before he explains his logic lol
Attacking formation of England XI :
1 - Ramsdale 🥊
4- White, Stones, Dier, Shaw 🛡
2- Rice, Bellingham ⚔
3- Saka, Maddison, Foden 🔥
1- Kane ⚽
🤣🤣he made sure he got all his arsenal lads on the pitch
You can't have Walker as a centre back. He can't read the game well enough to play centre back. His pace gets him out of trouble but he constantly let's players in behind him and a centre back you have to know when ease off and make sure the game is played in front of you not behind you. Awful awareness and positioning. Would play Stones and White as the centre backs, Walker or Trippier on the right and Shaw on the left.
Playing saka in lw is so stupid from bent. Saka is meant for the rw role. He came on against germany and changed the game alongside mount. Playing three at the back is just a negative approach against iran.
How can people really think that Walker is a better CB than White
Love the rice Jude and Madison Combo. Dont think it will happen in the first game but it would be interesting
the most enticing for sure. I completely trust Rice as a single pivot. He's super tidy on the ball. And watching Jude and Maddison, even though they have next to zero experience playing alongside each other, is very interesting as well.
Whenever there's a good black player and a not so good white player yet a pundit says the not so good one is better in an England shirt then we should all know what time it is...a shirt could never be a deciding factor as to a players abilities
not that anybody asked or cares
Ramsdale
Trippier White Tomori Shaw
Bellingham Rice
Saka Maddison Foden
Kane
U must b disabled or a child
@@saab2906 great response, insightful as ur average England fan
Trent would move more into the midfield and play those long passes and lobs to the front, its a great idea by Jack! But Southgate will go with a very negative mindset I have no doubt about that because he just sucks tactically!!
Ramsdale is easily the best british keeper at the moment...... plus, show me another english keeper who gives better long passes than most midfielders
He’s English mate not British
@@thf3038 He was also good against Italy and kept a clean sheet. I can name plenty of games where Pickford has been poor
@@dontworryaboutit7162 Do it then.
@@dontworryaboutit7162 I could name more where Ramsdale was poor.
Completely wrong.
Goldstein's midfield works, other than that it's an absolute shocker
Bents was the best
Well done and well said Jack wilcher
Finally Ben White has been noticed
Like the teams, Andy's team looks great
This is a waste of time. If you make up a starting XI without 7 players in defence you’ve already failed.
Ramsdale and saka yes.... Ben White should be nowhere near the England team.... shouldn't even be in the conversation...
Goldstein keeps interrupting, so annoying. Let him speak man
You can't drop Pickford until he makes a big error
Pickford is world class for England
Jack is through and through Arsenal, you can just see it ❤🤍
100% Ramsdale is no 1
Lmao move him here. That doesn't work on the radio 👌🤣
No bias at all none
Ramsdale? Oh Hungary not in it, should be O.K.
Super jack taking coaching seriously
Give ramsdale another chance to fail so everyone shuts up about him being englands best option
People seem to forget Iran are no mugs. Argentina 1 Iran 0 2018 World cup
Wilshere spot on except for the fact that Grealish should start over straight lines Sterling
Sterling carried us in the euros
No way andy said in a England shirt foden has been better than saka
Why should England play a one man striker team against Iran?
Trent, white and dier would be a disaster 😂
Back 4 should’ve been White Stones Tomori Trippier
Trippier is a right back. And Tomori is not going.
Stones over Dier every time.
thats hardly a surprise wants to start arsenal players....
Of corse he would
Jack Jack my all tym favorite player as an arsenal fan
Personally I like Andy’s team best.
I know English pundits love to talk about the keeper to generate views, but Pickford is the #1. Southgate isn't changing that