Cliffhanger! Gates was more about self glorification than in the safety of his men...a recipe for defeat...It stands that Washington should have been listened to as he was a great General...This demonstrates how close we were to losing the revolution...something that is not emphasized in history classes! Once again, great presentation, and I really liked the music...looking forward to the next video...
Please let me know if you have any feedback, comments or opinions! I am currently working on a mini-special on Benedict Arnold. Stay tuned for that, it seeks to explore Arnold's role in the war before his betrayal (including such feats as the Invasion of Quebec). I think you will all enjoy it :)
That's really cool of you. Thanks a lot, I appreciate it! I'm wishing the same for you. And, in case you're wondering, I have a few more videos on the way. I've slowed down a bit since I just began a new job, but they are still coming :)
@@GrimBattalia Thank you man! I did notice a slow down but figured you had a good reason. I'm going to slow down too because of uni so hopefully it's not an issue of either of us haha looking forward to your future videos.
As described in the UA-cam Video the Battle of 'Monmouth' (actually the Battle of Monmouth Courthouse) is described as a defeat. This is not historically accurate the Battle of Monmouth Courthouse was a draw, the Continental Army faltered at the beginning of the battle, when General Lee ordered a premature retreat. However, General Washington rode forward, rallied the army, cursed General Lee and dismissed him from the field. For the remainder of that hot summer day The Continental Army the British army fought to a draw and the British army withdrew from the battlefield and continued their march to New York.
Sorry to be a buzzkill :/ but its pronounced as Tar-el-ton not "Tar-els-ton" just want to correct you I recently found this series and became interested in it now that's why I write comments on the videos from 3 months ago
Not a problem my friend, I appreciate the feedback. I would rather know if there has been a mistake then proceed unawares. I'm glad you're enjoying the series!
Haha, classic line, classic movie. I think it gets way too much criticism for being historically inaccurate. I'm just glad to have a big budget revolution movie
I have to say - it's pretty widely accepted that the effect of Waxhaws was the revolutionary propaganda that spread afterwards, in reality the event itself was a messy misunderstanding that was easy to spin as a massacre in an age of simple and sparse communications.
Gate was a major douchebag. He took credit for winning the Battle of Saratoga when it was Benedict Arnold who made that victory possible. Benedict Arnold will still be synonymous with the word traitor, but I think I think Horatio Gates should be synonymous with the word weasel.
wasn't Mammoth Courthouse a technical draw in which at the end of the one day long fight the British disengaged and continued on there way to there bastion in New York? pretty sure only the initial contact was botched by the Americans. The American vanguard under the command of Gen Lee made a confused and indecisive probe against Howes rearguard. Washington rode up relieved Lee and began to consolidate his lines on the front slope of a hill. with the British now having there blood up decided to capitalize on the initial American confusion and sweep all before them instead all 3 of there assaults we're beaten back with heavy losses. the only thing I can think was in the context of your presentation it had to do with the weakened state of the main army under Washington. not trying to deride or ridicule your content at all I believe you have some skills and I'm a big fan of your work. I just disagreed with you calling Mammoth Courthouse a defeat. tactical draw in which the Americans where left in command of the field. our regulars showing off there new found skills after a winter getting great drill by that Prussian .
It was a defeat. The British planned to retreat, wich they did, the Americans hoped to inflict a decisive defeat on the brits, which they failed. Howes rearguard did engage the Americans, as is typical to buy more time.
I went back and forth about posting this response. But, I really wish that you would match your level of research with a level of care and accuracy in your mapping graphics. Your placement of Camden is way too far to the east, to the point that for someone with the slightest local familiarity with the region, it places the locale in a completely different context; closer to that of SC's Low Country than the southern Piedmont, where Camden actually lay. Camden is actually close to Columbia, but Columbia did not yet exist as a town. Your use of modern mapping is a bit distracting as well. Atlanta would not exist until midway through the following centuryThere were no large lakes present at the time. They came in the 20th Century. .
The same guy. Sigh. I wish they would get someone else to narrate. This guy just doesn't have it. His voice and style are very irritating. Is he a teenager?
Cliffhanger! Gates was more about self glorification than in the safety of his men...a recipe for defeat...It stands that Washington should have been listened to as he was a great General...This demonstrates how close we were to losing the revolution...something that is not emphasized in history classes! Once again, great presentation, and I really liked the music...looking forward to the next video...
At that point in time, Washington's greatness as a General was not yet proven. That knowledge was just beginning to grow.
Well done. Frank said thorough.
Please let me know if you have any feedback, comments or opinions! I am currently working on a mini-special on Benedict Arnold. Stay tuned for that, it seeks to explore Arnold's role in the war before his betrayal (including such feats as the Invasion of Quebec). I think you will all enjoy it :)
Grim Battalia do cowpens next
@@nordy4981 already done, I'm just working on some final editing since the battle terrain is particularly important for that battle
Can’t wait
Calvery - the place where Jesus was murdered - - Cavalry - Mounted troops.
Love all your videos, I know you haven't posted in a while, but if you read these, I just want to say thanks and appreciate your work.
Just dropping by to say I hope you had a great Christmas and I wish you a Happy New Year man!
That's really cool of you. Thanks a lot, I appreciate it! I'm wishing the same for you. And, in case you're wondering, I have a few more videos on the way. I've slowed down a bit since I just began a new job, but they are still coming :)
@@GrimBattalia Thank you man! I did notice a slow down but figured you had a good reason. I'm going to slow down too because of uni so hopefully it's not an issue of either of us haha looking forward to your future videos.
Nice video.. fact check.. Gates retreated to Charlotte, North Carolina NOT South Carolina
Good job, thanks for the work you put into this video and presenting the history.
wish i had you as my history teacher, your videos are amazing
As described in the UA-cam Video the Battle of 'Monmouth' (actually the Battle of Monmouth Courthouse) is described as a defeat. This is not historically accurate the Battle of Monmouth Courthouse was a draw, the Continental Army faltered at the beginning of the battle, when General Lee ordered a premature retreat. However, General Washington rode forward, rallied the army, cursed General Lee and dismissed him from the field. For the remainder of that hot summer day The Continental Army the British army fought to a draw and the British army withdrew from the battlefield and continued their march to New York.
Thank you for the content. My only recommendation is that Baron de Kalb should have been mentioned.
Battle of Bull Run in 1861 may be equal to this battle since how devastating of a defeat it was.
Sorry to be a buzzkill :/ but its pronounced as Tar-el-ton not "Tar-els-ton" just want to correct you I recently found this series and became interested in it now that's why I write comments on the videos from 3 months ago
Not a problem my friend, I appreciate the feedback. I would rather know if there has been a mistake then proceed unawares. I'm glad you're enjoying the series!
It's Tarelton
Not Tarelston
Washington did not lose Monmouth it was a draw just to correct you there at 1:33
Abraham Lincoln
That's what you call it.
lee nearly lost it for him
Monmouth was inconclusive, but definitely not a defeat for Washington. In fact, the British withdrew from the field first.
Wow, Gates really went and made a mess of things
"These rustics are so inept. It nearly takes the honor out of victory...Nearly.
Haha, classic line, classic movie. I think it gets way too much criticism for being historically inaccurate. I'm just glad to have a big budget revolution movie
And let's not mention Baron de Kalb, or the Maryland and Delaware continentals in their last ditch rear guard action.
Thanks for this! Better than anything I learned in US History class...smh
No High Schools named Gates.
Please Edit a video, before you post it.
I have to say - it's pretty widely accepted that the effect of Waxhaws was the revolutionary propaganda that spread afterwards, in reality the event itself was a messy misunderstanding that was easy to spin as a massacre in an age of simple and sparse communications.
Gate was a major douchebag. He took credit for winning the Battle of Saratoga when it was Benedict Arnold who made that victory possible. Benedict Arnold will still be synonymous with the word traitor, but I think I think Horatio Gates should be synonymous with the word weasel.
Another narrator is needed. I just don't want to hear this guy's voice through the entire video. How old is he, anyway?
wasn't Mammoth Courthouse a technical draw in which at the end of the one day long fight the British disengaged and continued on there way to there bastion in New York? pretty sure only the initial contact was botched by the Americans. The American vanguard under the command of Gen Lee made a confused and indecisive probe against Howes rearguard. Washington rode up relieved Lee and began to consolidate his lines on the front slope of a hill. with the British now having there blood up decided to capitalize on the initial American confusion and sweep all before them instead all 3 of there assaults we're beaten back with heavy losses. the only thing I can think was in the context of your presentation it had to do with the weakened state of the main army under Washington. not trying to deride or ridicule your content at all I believe you have some skills and I'm a big fan of your work. I just disagreed with you calling Mammoth Courthouse a defeat. tactical draw in which the Americans where left in command of the field. our regulars showing off there new found skills after a winter getting great drill by that Prussian .
It was a defeat. The British planned to retreat, wich they did, the Americans hoped to inflict a decisive defeat on the brits, which they failed. Howes rearguard did engage the Americans, as is typical to buy more time.
I went back and forth about posting this response. But, I really wish that you would match your level of research with a level of care and accuracy in your mapping graphics. Your placement of Camden is way too far to the east, to the point that for someone with the slightest local familiarity with the region, it places the locale in a completely different context; closer to that of SC's Low Country than the southern Piedmont, where Camden actually lay. Camden is actually close to Columbia, but Columbia did not yet exist as a town. Your use of modern mapping is a bit distracting as well. Atlanta would not exist until midway through the following centuryThere were no large lakes present at the time. They came in the 20th Century. .
Woohoo big mistake to underestimate us
The same guy. Sigh. I wish they would get someone else to narrate. This guy just doesn't have it. His voice and style are very irritating. Is he a teenager?