How Assam CM Himanta Sarma is misreading RSS and PM Modi's politics
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 лют 2024
- #PoliticallyCorrect #HimantaBiswaSarma
Repeal of Muslim marriage legislation, criminalising 'magical healing', converting madarsas into general schools- Assam CM Himanta Sarma is building a hardliner image. ThePrint Political Editor DK Singh analyses Sarma's politics in this episode of #politicallycorrect
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read this week's Politically Correct here: theprint.in/opinion/himanta-s...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Sorry himanta is absolutely on right track......future home minister of India he will be
He was in Congress (1991-2015)
For politicians religion is a tool for their own gains. Wake up and you will know how slaved are we by these politicians.
Why only HM not PM
You are andhbhakt
yes that is minimum eligibility criteria to be hm in hindu mind
@@elborrador333cause the PM will be Yogi.
I think Child marriage registration removal is good move.
Political disagreement is different, but we can't allow women to suffer bcz of some religious beliefs or tradition or traditional values.
Ideally you are right but when it comes to religion, the age old traditions & परिपाटी always take precedence . Take example of many Hindu old traditions on सती प्रथा, untouchability etc. etc. Do you know how difficult it was for the reformist Ram Mohan Roy to banish सती प्रथा ? Since it was considered as barbaric by the then British rulers also so it was abolished legally . Had there been a political party at that time which counted on votes of Hindus, even this प्रथा would have persisted.
@@satishsharma9307I guess it's time for you to read Meenakshi Jain's book on Sati pratha before using it as an example to validate your point. I believe the book is named Sati, she has also given lot of talks on the subject, you will find them on UA-cam
@@satishsharma9307 There is a right time for leaving behind every bad practice. By hook or by crook. Now that sati is abolished, hindu community looks back on that practice as evil. If Muslim community want to live equally with Hindus and others, they must abolish their 1400 yr old practices which are not valid in today's world.
@@satishsharma9307it was not difficult at all, read dr. Meenakshi Jain's book on sati, sati stopped overnight, once the legislation was passed, and no records were reported afterwards.. since it was a super localised practice...much of hue cry about sati iss disapportioate superposition nothing more
Joker can you give us any example of sati pratha in our society @@satishsharma9307
For 75 years all state governments have tax-funded Islamic religious education in Madarasa schools where Kafirphobia is tought. In the same 75 years, not one state government has funded Hindu religious schools. And we have been calling this TRUE secularism.
not Hindu say brahmanwadi. Brahmanwadi Hindu teachers were teaching Sanskrit in tolls for years even before Mughal time and continued for years. All Hindu Muslim Christian king's and rulers paid for that. I come from a Brahmin family and I know about that.
@ravi-it3vj - your reply is pointless here. Why are you dragging in Brahmanvad in this? He is simply talking about the disparity between appeasement for Muslims be what we did with vedic/hindu education denial. It has nothing to do brahmanvad.
@@varunsharma5468 only brahmanwadi. scheduled caste scheduled tribe people either don't or can't visit temple. check data how many of them worship. brahmanwadi manuwadi are the most dangerous in our society. They divide and rule.
@@ravi-it3vj Brahman is Hindu and Hindu is Brahman while people like you are totalitarian leftists/communists & terror/Pakistani supporters!!
@@ravi-it3vj 1) Why Jain/Shikh/Non-Brahim-Hindu-religious-schools are not state-sponsored? Why only Islamic Madrasas? Stick to this point 2) Your parents and their parents must be horrible people. Don't generalize others based on your parents and their parents' horrible behavior. 3) Dear Islam apologist Dhimmi, pl don't divert the subject. we assertive kuffars are very well aware of these tactics by you guys. It doesn't work anymore.
Regardless of religion or political affiliation, child marriage or marriage below the legal age must be halted. There should be no room for doubt about this.
This analysis was more like an imaginative extrapolation, making weird connections and patterns.
After Uttarakhand, Assam is moving towards a Uniform Civil code
Print has only one agenda Muslim appeasement as like congress
But some of the points he made makes sense. What has happened to people like Vinay Katiyar, Uma Bharti, Sadhvi Pragya or for that matter Pragin Togadia ? Where are all these guys ? Why are they sidelined ?
@@pranavnair2616yes, because they lost against Modi.
You only need a few politicians to run a country, you need more technocrats from the outside.
That's what Modi is doing and something his successor will aslo do.
@@pranavnair2616 Most competent reaches at the top. Many joined training with Sachin Tendulkar. They lost to Sachin. So? 10000 people pass out from IIT every year. How many become Sunder Pichai? So?
Vinay Katiyar, Uma Bharti, Sadhvi Pragya or for that matter Pragin Togadia.... all are sincere soldiers of Hindutva. But only THE MOST COMPETENT will reach at top. Thats the rule of life.
👍✨100% True !!
@@nv9991 I am not talking about reaching the top. I am talking about getting good positions. Vinay Katiyar could have been made CM or even defence minister for that matter. Why a Rajnath Singh ? Forget that, what explains why Sadhvi Pragya was not allowed to campaign in MP ? And not to forget, I did not see Pravin Togadia even in the Ram Temple inauguration. Why ??
Media Muslim appeasement. Himanta is a 5 time undefeated MLA. He was a vital trouble shooter even during the Congress era. I don't think "misread" might be the one that one can associate with Himanta.
Himanta will sort out Print's agenda. He is absolutely crisp and clear.
Bold CM shouldn't worry about paid media.
How Print misreading Bharat's growth..
Fun fact Himanta Biswa sharma or Bjp get vote in Assam because of development,peace,many schemes etc not because of Hindu Muslim. In Assam any party cannot get vote on behalf of Hindutva politics there is nothing Hindu Muslim in general Public
@@OwaisKumar-se8dmand you have? where from Assam are you?
muslims of assam vote for himanta they are assami indians not bangaldeshi invaders@@mrrajdeep007
I am the student's union president of b borooah college guwahati..whatever he said is correct..people here vote bjp for development
He talks to Modi himself, but political commentators who don’t know both personally will comment on how himanta is misreading Modi 😀
As if these guys know any better - the golden days of access journalism is long gone.
Also it's better to keep in mind that these guys despise Modi and BJP and rooting for their oust so that their heydays are back again.
Probably this comment would get deleted... given ThePrint's ethics.
@@ytsktgolden days of journalism? Like what? RNDTV, India Today bagpiping for congress and cursing Hinduism 24*7?
@@abc69. you seem to have dyslexia
Early marriage are not Rituals and what this SP politician says is rubbish. can he practice such sharia in western countries?
In this case, DK Singh misread Modi and RSS. Himanta' move of scrapping Muslim Marriage Act to prevent Muslim girls from marrying below the age of 18 would never make Modi unhappy. Modi's cabinet minister Smriti Irani wanted to bring a legislation to increase the marriagable age of girls to 21 which she couldn't pass. Himanta did the same thing in a different way.
Also it's better to keep in mind that these guys despise Modi and BJP and rooting for their oust so that their heydays are back again.
Probably this comment would get deleted... given ThePrint's ethics.
Hemata is doing goodwork for hindu muslim both for our country future❤
He is corrupt af
@@Abiram69…outch really? That’s old …think something new to defame himanta sharma.
@@user-eu5on6cv9f bro stop being andhbhakt. He is literally very corrupt
corrupt and develpment focused >> just corrupt@@Abiram69
@@Abiram69if you have the proof go and file petetion in court against HBS what's stopping you chaamcha?
I fully support Himanta. Even article 370 was also untouched for decades with the Congress government's appeasement politics. After abrogation of article 370, the nation see the effects. Similarly media like Press wil try to exaggerate and discourage the public. Himanta boldly sho6take forward the task of UCC. A day is far away, the whole India will have UCC
This kind of Pakistani type press needs to be in Pakistan, NOT India!!
Article 370 had already been diluted by earlier Governments to an extent that it was a mere Shadow of its original form.
Hemantha, one of the best Indian Heros among many others on date, is loved by one and all. Only Khangressies are crying. Khangress can polarise muslims directly telling that their's is a Muslim party and they work for their good. Whereas BJP working for one and all Indians is communal. Dekhte raho, is baar 400 paar, pakka. Jai Modiji. Bharatmata ki Jai. Vande Mataram.
But DK the difference between the other hardliners you mentioned and Sharma is he is equally competent in governance as well. Don't forget even Modi and advani were also hardliners and yet were successful
We support Himanta. One of the best CMs. Shame on biased reporting
Exactly. Himanta Sharma doesn’t need certificate from print to prove his achievement.
@thezoldics7648you are copying Same message everywhere 😂??Guess you get ₹5 for every message from IT Cell......
15-20 years from now, Hemant Sarma will be another highly popular PM of India.
Two religions have an army to convert native people. That should be illegal and needs overseeing.
Some history of Christianity
In short, no, it’s not just a sad part of history. We need to talk about it because most of us have no idea the church spearheaded the relocation, decimation of native culture, and genocide of entire communities.
Each time I mention that we should be actively pursuing reconciliation AND reparations on my Facebook page, people are absolutely dumbfounded by the suggestion. If we have any hope of healing the generational trauma carried by America’s indigenous people, we have to start by owning what we did.
The truth is that Christians murdered, abused, and tried to erase native people and then told them it was all God’s will.
Making unsubstantiated and wild allegations only betray an ignorant and prejudiced mind. Intellectual honesty seeks objectivity and is the hallmark of educated and unbiased persons.
KURIA - READ THE DOCTRINE OF "DISCOVERY" OF THE POPE _ WHO GAVE CHRISTIANS THE MORAL RIGHT TO CONVERT and the fatwa to kill those who dont - THE PORTUGUESE CAME TO INDIA UNDER THIS DOCTRINE AND killed or converted Pandits to christianity and then sent logs to the Pope@@kuriakosepalathinkal4598
dont tell me that I post untruths - YOU ARE SO UNEDUCATED
Europeans came to this country with a bible in one hand and a gun in the other. If they could not “save” Native Americans, they would kill them. The premise of discovering and claiming the land was done with greed. The Popes or VATICANS "Doctrine of Discovery" allowed for it. @@kuriakosepalathinkal4598
YOU betray an ignorant and prejudiced mind. Intellectual honesty seeks objectivity and is the hallmark of educated and unbiased persons. WHICH YOU ARE NOT @@kuriakosepalathinkal4598
I am disgusted to JUST NOW be learning this. In 1830, President Andrew Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act, which forced Native Americans out from their own land to make way for white settlers whom they thought were "standing in the way of progress".
This law was passed by a 100% Christian Congress and signed by a Christian President. In his address to Congress on December 6, 1830, Jackson said, "Is it supposed that the wandering savage has a stronger attachment to his home than the settled, civilized Christian? Is it more afflicting to him to leave the graves of his fathers than it is to our brothers and children? Rightly considered, the policy of the General Government toward the red man is not only liberal, but generous."
This forced removal ended up killing over 10,000+ Native Americans and these were Christians who had justified the policy.
Am I reading too much into this? I don't understand, why don't Christians acknowledge their brutal history? When acknowledged, why do Christians justify this? When acknowledged, why do Christians say those times were those times? But Christianity is STILL THE SAME and it was on the POPES direction this genocide was done.
.
NOT just native Americans... European/Christians are responsible for the genocide, looting, raping & exploitation of billions of natives across the globe and destruction of their culture!! Hindus of Indian sub continent were major victims of these fascists!! Hell!! These totalitarian Europeans didn't even spare nature!!
After listening to Nitin Gadkari, RSS sure do has a different philosophy. He might be true to an extent but not sure what the future holds for Himanta Sharma.
Gadkari is more humane and humble than most of the BJP leaders. He never makes a hate speech.
@@paulm.k.8740converted talk about hate speechs where there own community preaches nonsense and hate towards idol worshippers
@@paulm.k.8740hate speech ? You people are straight cancer for our society who thinks if muslim give hate speech then woh bhatka hua aadmi if a Hindu talks about his own religion you straight blame them that they are communal what a sook you are boomer
Your comparison is completely lop-sided. There are instances of hardliners working such as Modi himself, yogi and himanta too. What is more important than being hardliner is working hard, such as himanta himself
Deep down even print knows that himanta is right but "pet palne ke liye appeasement reporting toh karna hi hain"
Government Funded Schools should not be used as Madarsas.. I mean this is not the case in Oligarchic countries. 🤔
The main benefit for Himanta is that there is no opposition in Assam. They are all in his pockets.
I’d like to believe THE PRINT and most HUMANs, and in particular most Christians in America, find the genocide of Native Americans by Christians and Missionaries morally repugnant AND SPEAK OUT. I’d also like to believe that people who claim to follow Jesus look back with a sense of shame on the treatment inflicted on those we have called Indians, Africans, Aborigines, people of India and others. We wonder why there was no great outcry from a large number of church leaders, Media, Heads of State, Hague, United Nations over the barbarous abuse heaped upon those who lived in the “New World” for many centuries before the appearance of Europeans. Also why dont they bring up Missionary abuse of humanity to evangelize the other either by love, lies or violence.
BJP got 60 seats and congress seats are 30 and you say there is no opposition , how stupid can one be
No u r wrong last election in Assam,bjp got 75 seats and Congress got 29 only out of 125 seats
@@amalnath6477 stupid 75 seats are of alliance BJP only have 60 , dont talk rubbish , where you gather data from dhruv rathee , go study something dumb head
The opposition is fragmented in Assam. Assam's linguistic, geographical and ethnic divisions have been converted into polarising politics with religion at its core. This has benefited the BJP.
You said Modi politics changed post 2002, really he became CM in Oct 2001 and the event being referred is Feb 2002, really what kind of politics is being ascertained for the four months is there any kind documents, speeches or policies which can be used to say that modi had different in four months and after four months it changed. The majority of the time more 75% was spent by CM in handling buj earth quake rehab, infact he held only 2 rallies for his own election as MLA
How the population of Muslims became 90% in Dhubri and 82% in Barpeta of Assam?? Please make a detailed video on that too
If only you had expected the anti quackery team from the Indian Medical Association on these faith healings 😂
He doesn't need certificate from Print/DK, who previously obsessed with PK.
Good thing by him, ALL people of ANY religion should follow Constitution and 21st Century Law
Dk, star this message. Himanta is the future home minister.
Himanta the great and he is the one who is taking all together to the best way . Love you Himanta sir. ❤️❤️❤️
All those he mentioned Uma bharti, kalyan singh and many veterans who never left ideology, yes they left party that is different. That's why they are respected in all right wing ecosystems even though many diffrance.
How converting Government run madrasa to normal school is the wrong thing? Why do only some people like this move?
1. DK is of course, right in saying that Himanta need not get hyper in defending his decision to abolish Muslim Marriages Act. He is now sounding unnecessarily loud and hostile. However, his concluding statement about Savarkar's political Hindutva versus Aurobindo's spiritual Hindutva is not in order. 2. DK, coming from sickular gang ( though he is much balanced, one must say) is no doubt affected by the secularists view of Savarkar. But DK should read an article on Savarkar that appeared in the recent Swarajya Magazine about his essay on God of Human and God of Universe. DK would realize what kind of a deep thinker Savarkar was. It is also unlikely that DK knows about literary writings (poetry in particular) of Savarkar. DK would then notice that Modi incorporates both the forms of Hindutva but actively practices Savarkar''s!! 3. But DK's broader point is fine- no one should overdo so called Hindutva, as it does not pay in the long run. And Hindus do NOT any other religion or religious practices but no anti national can be tolerated.
DK is the milder form of SG. This is not a compliment
But DK sir, the scenario has changed at the time of Kalyan Singh, Uma Bharti BJP was led by Vajpayee and Advani but as Shekhar sir, describes Narendra Modi is the man you see is the man you get and also at the recent express adda Prashant Kishore has also said that "whosoever will come after Mr. Modi is going to be more hardliner".
We need more CMs like Hemanta Biswa Sarma. More power to him
Excellent observations DK. I liked the episode.
Thank you
I just love this ❤😊
It is great surprise that the British laws are still there in India after 1950 !!!!!
Excellent Analysis
your objective is spot on ..lets call it propaganda.
The works these CM done are good for Hindutva but RSS Modi like people who work on development economy along with it
Great example of Yogi who is changing his image ❤
Of course.. Mama is misreading Modi and RSS. He should learn from Print instead.
😅
We can see a significant boom in infrastructure projects and development works after Himanta Biswa Sarma became the CM. Unfortunately, the national media only shows his political side and the development side remains hidden to the rest of India.
😂😂😂in secular wat d use of sharia so hyprocacy by chamcha media
how naive to compare Hemata and Yogi with Kalyan Singh and uma bharati. Didn't expect this foolish analysis from DK Singh
Very nice analysis
Dont worry Print .. The Senapati does not make his moves unless his leader tells him to..
The swing of D K Singh from one episode to another is really intriguing. While in one episode he shows such nuanced and refined understanding of things, in the very next one he might show absolute failure and complete absurdity in his understandings.
Himanta can't be compared with any other BJP CM except Yogi, and that's because apart from Himanta, only Yogi doesn't come from an RSS background. Hence, their obligations towards RSS and it's ideology isn't a given. Then DK himself says that Yogi has toned down in his second term. Well, Himanta might also do so in his second term, but this is his first, and like Yogi did in his first term, Himanta too might want to set his house in order first before toning down in the second term.
Another thing is that Himanta can't afford to do superficial showmanship, with no real politics because Assam's geography and demography is a big challenge, probably unique in Bharat. And like Yogi, BJP needs Himanta more than Himanta needs BJP. The same isn't true for most other CMs of BJP.
What Himanta is doing in our state is wonderful. He has taken all these steps for the betterment of our society.
Only in India banning child marriage is considered hard line approach.
What is your point and problem? You just seem to be whining on his popularity rather than analysing his decisions
Being India's gateway to South east asia,Just what assam is missing since independence. Mama is providing the much needed sense of relevance to Assamese mass... Jai aai asom, jai hind
Difference about hemanta is he can leave bjp and still can win assam.
There is a reason we call him mama in Assam....
These changes are absolutely necessary for strong India. Hemantha Biswa Sarma is the right person in the right place at a right time.
Agree! Modi-Shah combo does not like a strong State leader. They tried to control U.P. CM Yogi but that move back fired. Yogi ji is more popular leader in U.P. than Modiji. But same cannot be said about Shri Hemant Shrma ji.
Good Analysis..👍
Semi conductor chips fab is opening in Assam and he also has to fight demographic change he knows what he is doing he is in right place now
Hemanta is doing exactly for which ppl of Assam voted him to power,He has to fight the islamist invasion of Assam,I wish WB had such a leader to fight this menace in WB
I'd argue on your statement ar 3:40 about no other leader being this popular. Times were different but P.A. Sangma was very popular outside NE. He surely wasnt a crowd puller like Sarma, but was very well known amongst the people across India I'd say.
But a lovely analysis overall! Focus needs to be development. Everything else will fall into place
The best part about leaders like HBS is they don't follow Media & Media narratives! 🎉
I think it is not misreading. It is stepping up. One cannot directly transition from Muslim centric policy to true secular policy (which BJP is trying to achieve). First you need politically stable platform which BJP and Modi has provided and then strong leaders like Yogi and Himanta can build upon it further.
Home Minister or Defence Minister one day
As a voter to BJP He is on right path
No child marriage for any one please . Magical healing may be possible if mind is free from all kinds of dumb clutters .
You did a great Job
Great episode! Hard liners only break community peace..
Hardliners are needed in some states
Correct judgement about hardliners. They are like “curry pattha”.
Himanta has not changed without consultations Madrassas were holding muslim kids behind. Polygamy is wrong at multi levels so it needed to be changed Child marriages are abhorrent and disgusting so whats wrong with changing it. Doing the right thing does not make you a hard liner jai hind
Unqualified, Unapologetic, Unabashed support to Shri Himanta Sarma from Tamilnadu.
When print, wire, quint, scroll et all start r@**! ron@ about a leader, that's an indication of him hitting where it hurts.
India needs a leader of the calibre of a Yogi a Himanta or an Annamalai in every state and UT of India.
It's up to society to create an environment where such leaders are incentivised to join polity, their talents identified, promoted and empowered .
Appreciate your understanding reading the BOOK 📚🫡
Praising the enemies. 😜 After 10 years, they will remember Modi ji as a liberal and moderate PM as they do with Atal Ji. 😃
"Sidelining of hardliners" --> Evolution + Horses for courses.
You have said it so right. Impressed with your right analysis about RSS and BJP. The seculars and leftist in India think the bjp is a hardliner party. It is not so, because they know that hardliner politics is not good for Hindus themselves. It is a dual edged sword which can harm the hindus in future. They will always do what is good for hindus unlike the hardliners in other minority communities who have destroyed their own community
These opposition fellows always throw spanner in the reforms.
How print is misreading Indian politics
Assam CM is doing a tremendous job.
Print and all the Left Wing media has properly understood RSS and Modi's politics 🤣
Excellent move.
Why print never talks about hardliners in other rekegoon
Very balanced take. I think, however, much Print journalists overread stuff, they also consistently get the political realm of India right, like no other.
Here's another way to possibly look at the new Assam proselytization laws and the apparent disconnect between duration switching religions and switching back -- _Religion and other birth derived variables like caste determine state-provided benefits. In-principle, a switch-out should trigger a check on Intent. A switch-back is reverting to default, lesser checks are warranted._ (This simple argument needs to be thought through more in case of multiple/successive switch-outs and other complicating scenarios))
There is injustice somewhere
During Kalyan Singh time was not suitable for RSS due to BJP's negligible political capital.
DK's this prediction will go wrong in history
But what did I predict?
Since Kalyan Singh days, the mood of the nation has taken a right turn.
He is talking truths about child marriage. No media focus.
I do not see what Hemanta did anything wrong. But you are giving him a warning to focus next on development too. Nice 👌
Good he is doing his job well.
You are saying Muslim girls should marry at age 12
If somewsnts to change it is hardliner
Very good argument by print
Please make a video why it us good for girls ti marry at 12 if not even earlier
Well, he is reading the mood of the Indian people pretty well. Whatever be the BJP and RSS's idea.
Only in india banning child marriage and trying to ban polygamy would be turned hardline . The overtone window was so extrimist left wing , it is ridiculous.
What law do Muslims follow??? Constitution or sharia?????? That's the main question.... Can so called secularists answer this truthfully
I don't see anything wrong.... Definately thank you for Amplifying the CMs .. full support 🙏✌️
Child marriage is not in the book of any religion. It's a societal issue. It's prevalent among all communities. It's a social and economic related issues.
what a crybaby... kitna dukh dard pain loose motion
the victim card is soooooooooooooooo apparent on 's Mr. D.K. Singh's face
anchor is the doppelganger of himanta biswa sarma.
🙂